What is Jatitva?

[@Tarotaro23-k5r]

THANK you for this video, as a Hindu who grew up abroad i was shocked at how much Brahmins are vilified by radical leftists in india.

[@nehrumantri830]

Did you ever think why you got there in the first place? What can be said about the victims rallying around current opposition is equally applicable to the castes rallying round Hindutva.

[@pseudojournalist]

​@@nehrumantri830shhh he's a nri buddy

[@SarojSingh-nq5ql]

​@@nehrumantri830 So smart of u to know that he is the one behind all these things. Like seriously people who have never faced any discrimination wants to take revenge from those who have never done any.

[@sarthak3441]

So ur a low caste hindu??

[@sidhaunt]

Radical leftist? Buddy you have no idea how Indian politics works. This mere division of politics into right and left is a western thing. You need to learn history kid

[@itiha]

You started this video with a great example - I was raised in urban, cosmopolitan India, but I had no clue about my caste until I had to fill in an application for the 7th-grade board exam. In a way, the Government of India and politicians have institutionalized caste identities for their own political gain. I couldn't agree more with the idea that "jitni abadi utna haq" is a climax of caste identities that could break India politically. I think everyone needs to watch this video and consider where we, as Indians, want to take this nation. P.S : I love your Thumbnail 😎

[@TheEmissaryCo]

thanks a lot! Yes caste has calcified via politics and gone beyond societal elements

[@anshupandit4490]

The problem is these bimtas would sell their mother (india) for a few bucks. Out of 50 crore people max 50 lakhs people will get job and they are okay with it but it will destroy the country.

[@jayBharatiraanga6425]

​@@TheEmissaryCo Show all Veepasana Centers Symbiosis Society's Bharat Ratna Dr Babasaheb Ambedkar Museum Memorial Also of PMC Near Maal Dhakka Sasoon Hospital Pune Promote Distance Learning From Open University Show all Buddhist Ancient Caves Read Palee Bhasha Inscription For People Take a Palee Reader Expert U will Get More Like Share Subscribers Followers TRP Etc 😎📚💙🌹💦🤠

[@ritvik8773]

I am sure you do not belong to a disadvantaged caste, hence you had the privilege to not know your caste.

[@suneilsharma8617]

You should have put your caste as Sanatani Hindu..

[@nurag_s]

Caste is an identity, caste is everything. There's a saying that, one cannot escape: DEATH, TAXES & CASTE/JATI (Indian version). Also, I've tried my best to escape from my caste but It's impossible. It is the way it is.

[@TheEmissaryCo]

!!!

[@swapnil-nr3gt]

2-3 years ago, all channel that i thought would be big has gained lakhs of followers today because of there quality of content. i guess you could be one of them but yours is first channel that covers indian history and politics in english which is preety good to eduacted confused urban indians good luck

[@TheEmissaryCo]

❤❤

[@AkshayShukla.]

he'll make them more confused... comparing distribution of wealth to getting girls on tinder, 😂 then fear mongering of lebanonization of India😅 this guy

[@vorrdegard2176]

Wait 2 years seems suspicious

[@jataayu1]

Great video. Brilliantly explains the crux of the problem. Crisp and neat presentation. Keep it up.

[@TheEmissaryCo]

Glad you liked it!

[@cw9728]

I didn't know that the emissary had a youtube channel. Good call. This way more people will be able to reach your thoughts.

[@TheEmissaryCo]

Thanks a lot! Do share the video so it will reach :)

[@IndyRider]

I have always maintained that the best solution to the problem of 'caste differences' is urbanization and inter-caste marriages. This will help people see each others without the lens of caste both for the individual as well as the society.

[@Zzmaster_-mj2xv]

Icms won't solve anything.

[@ParthMansukhani]

​​@@Zzmaster_-mj2xv Rubbish, we need to stop being the thali and become a melting pot, or our nation will tear otself apart under jatitva

[@nikhil518]

I'm here before this blows up!!! You did an incredible job though I guess there are some nuances which I've witnessed being a general caste from UP. Anyways, One of the best videos on the topic on yt.

[@TheEmissaryCo]

Wow, thank you!

[@Employer101]

Thanks for the video. Not a brahmin but never seen a brahmin vilify any other caste or any other human like they do to brahmins.

[@cinefile0075]

😂😂😂😂 Brahmins made jati and varna. It's in rig veda. You don't anything about jati and varna then

[@arjyachatterjee6874]

​@@cinefile0075 Which verse ?

[@basantprasadsgarden8365]

This means you have seen nothing

[@Odysseus_of_ithica]

​@@cinefile0075 You lower castes have the audacity to take the name of our great vedas😂 Us Brahmins are the TRUE descendants of the Aryans.

[@rishavkumar1250]

​@@basantprasadsgarden8365 yeah don't lump all brahmins in the same basket

[@speedunc]

I learned about caste from schools, it's artificially alive in the urban areas just for political reasons. I see some moderate HIndutvawadis talk about reservation and unsurprisingly they also say Muslims are also hindu..and by that logic, Aurangjeb was a Hindu, Jinnah was a Hindu, Umar Khalid is a Hindu. This dilution of Hindu Identity along with politicization of caste are going to be very dangerous.

[@OmPaik-b8c]

Shut up there isn't even 0.1 hindutva people who says Muslims are also Hindu 😂... .but they say there ancestors were Hindus 😊

[@greatkaafir7478]

Lol RSS Calls Everyone Hindu In India Who Born Here Not Hindutvadi " ✌️

[@KingGodzilla-m2t]

Artificially alive in Urban areas? Dalits/Muslims/Adivasis faces more Rejection on Urban areas when they search room on rent for education/live/anything. Why? SC/STs are 25% of National population yet they are less than 13% in Urban areas. Because SC/STs are socially boycotted/Ignored by Society and Politicians. I do not have STDs, is that means STDs Don't exists? And it's artificially alive by H0es?

[@KingGodzilla-m2t]

Uppercastes are 15% of total population yet they makes up 45% of total population of Urban areas. Why Uppercastes are more Urbanized than SC/STs compare to National population? Coincidence? Systematic Dehumanisation/Social boycott/Unofficial Apartheid

[@rahulchakraborty8916]

You serious??? They think so??? 😳😳🤯🤯

[@blastoff2moon429]

I saw your website and it was superb ❤

[@TheEmissaryCo]

Thanks so much 😊

[@ShouryaRana-mh4ib]

This video is most honest video American video on jaati Verna 👍

[@TheEmissaryCo]

[@sricr]

This is a great channel. People, please spread this channel. Need of the century

[@TheEmissaryCo]

[@way_of_life77]

Love the video everyone talks about hindutva dividing india in 2 but no one talks about caste politics dividing india in 1000 if not million parts

[@nelsonlangford2181]

Another fascinating video. Nuanced and thoughtful. It was interesting to me that at the beginning you listed the potential self-identifications in India: clan, class, caste, even "Indian"... but the list ended there. In the West, we'd traditionally have had "human" in the list, and even "soul" or "spirit"/consciousness. Do you think many Indians self-identify as consciousness primarily? (Because that's what I'd have expected, as India is considered one of the most spiritual countries)

[@TheEmissaryCo]

Maybe the human thing is seen as redundant in India haha. Or perhaps because animals are also considered to have souls, it’s not as emphasized/special?

[@liveandletlive185]

The election results indicates a very dark future, u can see these caste divides being encouraged at every level and this regressive thinking of "jitni aabadi utna haq" is really dangerous.

[@basantprasadsgarden8365]

So, how do you think Caste can be eliminated?

[@rishavkumar1250]

​@@basantprasadsgarden8365 emphasizing class over caste

[@basantprasadsgarden8365]

@@rishavkumar1250 that won't change anything

[@raw726]

​@@basantprasadsgarden8365 well one idea is to industrialize or other is communist type government which should force indians to intermarry or die

[@millennialmind9507]

@@basantprasadsgarden8365qualitative industrialization and Urbanization, where do you think most inter caste marriages take place, certainly not in rural areas

[@afrozairin8438]

Hindutva should be against caste. But unfortunately I think it is not the reality because many Hindus support casteism.

[@TheEmissaryCo]

Unfortunately yah!

[@vidhibassi1214]

You’ve done a fantastic job! 🙏 Looking forward to the video on the Critical Caste theory!

[@TheEmissaryCo]

Thank you!

[@VinayakKumar-kq3ex]

INDIA'S wretched political system ensures that geniune social, political and economic reforms are always thwarted.

[@GOD...hey.]

08:49 Epic😂😂Judiciary Worldwide 😅

[@TheEmissaryCo]

Couldn’t resist

[@Moogli07]

Brilliant video

[@TheEmissaryCo]

Thanks!!!

[@sanehlata5326]

Excellent video

[@TheEmissaryCo]

Thank you very much! 😊😊

[@mayankpaneri1295]

8:50 the image for "judiciary"💀💀💀

[@TheEmissaryCo]

Had to do it 😂

[@cinefile0075]

I like how this guy shrewdly didn't even mention from where jati and varna came from lol. Its so pity that even NRI's mind is also filled with radical "Hinduism". How it happened?? Alienation or proper attention not given by parents that they're inclining towards this extremist identity. So worrisome situation

[@sarthak3441]

Don't worry.. White nationalist r taking good care of them

[@kaushikinazuma3053]

Jati mean community like manava jati mean human being community etc and India is diversity country different states has different cultures we don't have any rule book unlike other religions and we don't have caste we have Varna which means skill which is dead today we only have pujari or pundit and untouchability happened because person choose to not civilized themselves and today some adivasi tribe choose to become naxal terrorist because government not allowing them to live in forest.

[@cinefile0075]

@@kaushikinazuma3053 you are writing whatever comes in your mind without even thinking twice about it. Forest naxal....lol. Birth based Jati first mentioned in rigveda (1st mandala) and Varna (10th mandla). Biggest problems with Hindus is that they don't know anything about their own religion. Don't read Vedas shashtras upnishads and smriti stutis...

[@Zzmaster_-mj2xv]

They have just woken up to realise tht no matter how egalitarian they act they will still be hated for their so called "oppressive caste".why would anyone be "anti caste" when the "victims" are themselves guilty of casteism. 😊

[@DAIIIVA]

i want to give him money and have him say things i want ❤

[@TheEmissaryCo]

Will open a support page soon 😂

[@keshavfulbrook6698]

This is the most balanced and nuanced take on it I’ve seen. Amazing job. This is a subject that so often gets so polarized in one direction or the other that it’s hard to have a discussion. I am a “white Hindu” who’s had an upanayanam and I have had discussions many times on the issues of foreigners “place” in Hinduism. Discussions often get emotional and when people get hardline on the “a brahmin can only be born as one” stance I try to respect the nuance while also asserting my position and the position of my acaryas. Assumptions are always made though that I am a part of a political “other side” that is trying to invalidate hereditary practices entirely. My position is that non-hereditary practitioners don’t invalidate hereditary ones and visa-versa. That’s often not an easy understanding to convey or come to though and emotions on both sides flame up. And yes, mostly the people who are debating with me are anti-BJP “trads” who believe they are followers of Swami Nischalananda, etc. but even some who aren’t are still very deep into the “varna is by birth alone” rabbit hole, or rat hole as you say here, opinion.

[@nehrumantri830]

You don't become a Brahmin by calling yourself a Brahmin. If you were a Brahmin, how come you did not know this until emissary taught you? You should have known this and added to the discussion which you didn't. Unfortunately you're still learning. You got a long way to go before you realize that there is a whole world of people who can think the same as you. Who is a Brahmin? If you know the real meaning, it means knowing oneself or knowing God. When you're born in Brahmin, it means you already know everything. Then what is the purpose of the rest of your life? Is it to go about telling everybody that you're a Brahmin. The fact is you don't really know who that God is.

[@keshavfulbrook6698]

@@nehrumantri830 it is not me who is confused about the definition of brahma jānāti iti brāhmaṇaḥ…this has been stated over and over again in the shastras. It is those who claim that being a brāhmaṇaḥ is a birth category alone who are confused. Don’t mistake my criticism of the idea as me holding it myself.

[@krishnanunni9034]

This is the working plan of those who want India to be divided and weakened.

[@ChanakyanStudent7971]

Caste based segregation or jatiyva is akin to the ethnocentrist nationalism of europe. If you're not of my ethnicity, you're my enemy. This has led to so many wars over centuries in europe. It literally took the biggest war ever to make these people come to their senses. Why are we regressing into this brutal tribalistic tradition?

[@Nagvanshieus]

Caste segregation is not ethnocentrist, regionalism is ethnocentrist, there's no ethnic difference in caste system, a Marathi Brahmin and a Marathi Mahar speaks the same language, follows the same regional traditions, worships the same regional God. Regionalism on the other hand is ethnocentric, a Marathi thinks low of the Biharis working in his state, a Bihari thinks that someone from northeast is from Chinese stock and not an Indian.

[@millennialmind9507]

Can you explain why caste arithmetic simply doesn't work in highly cosmopolitan city like Mumbai? Can you make a video on it?

[@TheEmissaryCo]

Basically explain it here kzbin.info/www/bejne/eqCci6eAoNt9nsksi=CyoT9g0j8Sfd0IIr - it’s due to ideological voting vs identitarian

[@anshupandit4490]

Ohh man someone made video on this. Thanks

[@TheEmissaryCo]

Hope you enjoyed it!

[@anshupandit4490]

@@TheEmissaryCo yup 🫡

[@sarthak3441]

Alright now let's talk about caste system...

[@ArunSeshadri]

Nice explanation of the complex caste problem in India. While Hindutva does serve the purpose of uniting all castes under one single banner of a Hindu, it is to be noted that it excludes the religious minority in India. And further, the oldest ideologues of Hindutva have indeed said that caste is the basis of Hinduism. Right now, Hindutva is forgetting the fault lines within Hinduism, and gaining supporters by 'othering' religious minorities. This is not the way forward. So, the ideology needs to be revised from its current extremist form to a moderate one. This would mean redefining Hinduism itself, and accepting that religious minorities are indeed a part of India. A society can exist with various religions, and India should be the torchbearer for multiculturalism across the globe.

[@basantprasadsgarden8365]

@@ArunSeshadri "but then how would Hindutva will remain Hindutva? Acceptance, Reform and Multiculturalism are the Traits of those Librandus. The Essence of Hindutva is in Bigotry, Segregation and Subjugation. Come with your original I'd Abdul" I just Summarised the Response of a Staunched Hindutvawadi

[@rajkumarbargaje9793]

This is the most simple explanation I've ever seen on caste and all things related to it. Thank you, bhau

[@TheEmissaryCo]

So nice of you

[@amaanhusainrizvi5798]

There exists a word for this - Jativaad

[@millennialmind9507]

Thanks, now I understand why Gun ownership came up in the western countries 😊

[@Saiblo]

Remember after independence Ambedkar has a chance to remove caste system but he still choose reservation for his selish reasons 😂. Jai bheem jai chutki

[@fingers_crossed_3839]

Who would give him the guarantee that caste will be removed and there will be no caste discrimination in the future when he is no more....but reservation gives that guarantee.

[@swapnil-nr3gt]

i have some natural power to to guess nature of particular place for example i have have never been to any foreign country and still can guess culture there in every aspect like dubai is big city with lot of buildings but you hardly come across local people and culture so it feel like soulless city sometimes(which is changing now a days as they are building more projects around family entertainment) like noida and gurgaon are preety developed but i think they are forced on that part of the india because laws there are still like rural part of that state or area consider pune which is like noida and gurgaon but with far better laws and safety i think you have lived in america and you are also kind of like me who can understand cultuere other places deeply and thats why you are able to make these video not only based on historical knowledge but also based on whats going on in india or how is culture here in 21st century this is preety amaizng

[@TheEmissaryCo]

🫡

[@Ktamb]

This is nonsense

[@braindeadin]

Advaita is the answer. Sw Vivekanada has shown the way.

[@lalitasharma6687]

Even german and everyone use caste like Muller etc

[@TheEmissaryCo]

Intwrestjng

[@Employer101]

Videos deserves billion views.

[@TheEmissaryCo]

☺️☺️

[@LucidBhaskar]

Excellent take, this channel should grow and reach a larger audience.

[@TheEmissaryCo]

Hopefully! Do share :)

[@visesaj]

You summed up the elections results.

[@snehashispanda4808]

Caste discrimination is rooted not in religion but culture. Caste was an ancient system of occupational class delineated in Hindu texts that over the years developed into a rigid social hierarchy. The lowest castes, or untouchables, were marginalized and faced persecution. Caste-based discrimination is not intrinsic to Hinduism and should not be thought of as religiously sanctioned. the poorer workers involved in 'unclean' occupations such as sweeping or leather work were historically segregated and banished outside the city limits. Over time, personal cleanliness came to be identified with "purity", and the concept of untouchability eventually spread to the rural areas. Manusmriti text was never implemented as a law code in ancient India. The caste system as it exists today is the result of developments during the rise of the British colonial government in India. The British Raj furthered this development, making rigid caste organisation a central mechanism of administration. By 1860 the British formulated the caste system into their system of governance, granting administrative jobs and senior appointments only to Christians and people belonging to certain castes.

[@suketudanke9897]

FYI, Tukaram Maharaj spoke in favour of Varnashram in his abhangs :)

[@bv3144]

Amazing explanation! I’ve never seen someone explain Indian politics like this, let alone an Indian(?) American!

[@TheEmissaryCo]

Yes 🇮🇳

[@CalmSoul.514]

This talk is really good... Well researched

[@TheEmissaryCo]

❤

[@nehrumantri830]

You are the most qualified Excretologist alive today. It must have taken a S...load of work to finally get the delicious cream off the top. Like Carlin says"Holy S...". That is some serious .... Young Man ! Wonder if anybody can thank you enough. Though it does seem like a lot to acquire this info , I guess your observations on a whole lot of other things Indian for quite some time, as you say, must have enabled you to distill this perfect .... Storm. (I just can't help it!). I have two or three books on caste including Dirks, and I read parts of Ambedkar and the Gita trying to connect dots only to find some other Hydra head show up and lead to a whole bunch of arguments that throw you off course. I guess in general you got it right that the Democratic system in a way is kind of perpetuating the tribal jatis. I had myself seen groups of villagers traveling by train once all hyped to meet their legislator in Chennai. Obviously all these people were of the same village and caste who were trying "democratically" to position their suckers for maximum suction, Of course legally. It works both ways between the corrupt leader and the people who put him there for a definite caste loyalty dividend. Thanks for the work.😢

[@Zzmaster_-mj2xv]

Tf are u babbling

[@vivekgangadhara8165]

Catholics vs protestants in Christians Sunni vs Shia in Muslims

[@afrozairin8438]

This is sect Not caste

[@ankit5820]

one raising voice against corruption is not a or from corruption grps , bringing women abuse/rape is not being rapists and so does bringing their experiences/injustices/history of being caste oppresed before and now by CASTIESM( on lower castes) by CASTIEST ((doer/upper caste, yes that is where the terminology come from it is for the oppresor grps U definitely belong to that family lineage so u have'nt been told to or lack the social/family/relative culture/knowledge by their deliberate/inconvenient background of being castiest/oppresor-heritage-culture-BG)) UC/savarna families and middle castes subsequently on further lower castes. The coolness and calmness that u have and the oblivious neutrality is becoz u haven't been closely sensitizes to understand and consider the ugliness of castiesm( act by doer on someone relatively lower in caste) by castiest(doer who does dicriminate or try to do so to gain relative social/economic or other upper hands and the grim depth of relative and physical diff that dwelves in ppl in ral but shades to reject that ultimately ppl feel/listen-by-them/decipher personally so don't vote for BJP and hindutva parties.

[@Sams_Uncle]

Good job Veeré

[@TheEmissaryCo]

Thx Veeré

[@Themushroom98]

Very well-explained!

[@TheEmissaryCo]

thanks!

[@vpstateofmind]

I'am simple man, I see someone justifying caste , I put it in my BullS bin, the amount of points I could just whip out to call this video BullS is so high I don't even want to waste my time typing 🤮

[@prasmitkumarpradhan1497]

You are the example of jatitva

[@vpstateofmind]

@@prasmitkumarpradhan1497 u are an example of ignorant illiteracy

[@greatkaafir7478]

[ Casteism Word Given By Christian Portuguese In Goa And Caste System Created By Christian British ] 1) = Jaati Comes From Islamic Word Jaaat And Caste Is A Hispanic Word Brought By European's 2) = Shri Manusamrity Has Mentioned About 4 Varn ( Duty By Choice ), 40 Caste's and Subcaste " ( Chnadal's Were Brahmna's From Father Side )! 3) = In 300 Bc Megasthenes Wrote That In India There Are Only 7 Fold Division ( Caste's ) Of Indian Society In His Book Indica ! 4) = Hawnsagn Arrived 7th Century In India Wrote There Is Only Four Varna ( Brahmna, Kshtriy, Weshy, Sudra ) ! 5) = Al-Biruni ( 1017 ) Have Written In Tārīkh al-Hind (History of India) That There Are Only 4 Varn ( Again It Was Varn Brahmna, Kshtriy, Weshy, Shudra ) ( Today's We Have 3000 Caste And 25 Thousands Subcaste's ) How Did It Happened, Let's See ! 6) = First Senses Of Inda Was Did By The British In 1891 Hurbet Trisle Senses India And Mentioned That 2378 Maen Caste's In India And Chamar ( चमार ) Have 1150 Subcaste's And He Also Search Out 43 Race's ( Modern Day Western Language ) ! 7 ) = Indian Constitution Devide People Of India In Caste's General, OBC, SC, ST, Minority And Microminiature !

[@jyotiradityachoudhury7987]

I didn't know you had a yt channel. Have been seeing your post's on Twitter for a long time ❤

[@TheEmissaryCo]

Thanks for watching 😊 Do share and sub!

[@pradhyudh]

This is our DEI

[@libshastra]

It is Proto-DEI

[@Wozzi7]

Nice to see Equality Labs mentioned here

[@TheEmissaryCo]

Had to do it!

[@bsky636]

Caste=hierarchy.

[@rubin6202]

Hindutva is anti caste, 🤣 LMAO

[@user-ju1fm8rn1g]

Ohyy adltry alla gay mmad 😂😂😂go search your ammi sleeping with maulvi 😂😂😂

[@basantprasadsgarden8365]

@@rubin6202 this guy is just some random Savarna with an American accent

[@AkshayShukla.]

​@@user-ju1fm8rn1g apni aukaat dikhadi 👍🏻

[@shahanshahpolonium]

Yes it is. any counter arguments or are you just being a troll?

[@basantprasadsgarden8365]

@@shahanshahpolonium and how are you sure that Hindutva is Anti Caste?

[@Kart546]

1:20 In dalits we have different practices which make us like different from hindus Hindus worship idols we don't I never seen any hindu god picture in any dalit houses In my community we have long history of practicing shamanic rituals . For a fact our marriages don't include any pandits or anyone like hindus do We don't have haldi or any other hindu tradition which can be found in muslim marriages in india . We invite entities with some hyms and smoke then our marriage happens . We also don't have rigid caste marriage We can marry whomever . Even indian muslims has gotra system but dalits has no gotra marriages We have different form of not marrying in same village . Our culture , customs , language, etc is different Dalits only asking to stop killing dalits, stop hatecrimes . Stop the hate against us ! Hindus had 0 interaction with other indians like dalits . Hindu apartheid is far more complex then South african apartheid . No dalit enter temple we have dignity of our own . They make fake blasphemy that dalit enter their temple . For a fact no dalit worship their god . When they make such fake case so they kill that person on spot thats what they do most of the time . Hindu identity is of very recent forced onto our community . Also we have localised gods which are different from hindus you are right !

[@anshupandit4490]

Are but what are you trying to say. You know right there are 18% dalits if you ask for seperate religion and not count as hindu then who will control the things example yadavs are 21% of india and they were never discriminated and are hindus. Plus dalits have 1000s of caste. Go ahead proof yourself to be different from hinduism and get alienated by your fellow dalits. Ps: i would be the happiest if you guys hust became buddhism dont want sh*t in my backyard.

[@anshupandit4490]

So what?

[@anshupandit4490]

Bhimta spotted

[@anshupandit4490]

Bhimta spotted

[@Kart546]

​@@anshupandit4490 so what he was right about that . We follow different traditions from hindus in india . The problem with india that it's constitution doesn't recognise into a separate groups . It directly put us under hindu religion . Which is why our religion become endangered

[@ManishSharma-ku7ij]

You either divide India into Hindu and Muslim or Hindu Castes. We're buggered as a nation.

[@TheEmissaryCo]

Essentially how Indian politics works yah

[@darshanpatil7777]

Why did you not mention the venomous manusmriti? Also the conflation of hinduism and hindutva is misleading. Your right wing biasedness has handicapped your own critical attempt in this video. I hope you try to introspect or else it's a clear case of building an audience base based on populist sentiments.

[@prasmitkumarpradhan1497]

You are the typical jatitva manusmriti is dharma grants not religious scriptures you just want to find reasons to bad mouth Hinduism

[@greatkaafir7478]

Lol Have You Seen Indian Constitution Don't Punish Rich Indian And Only Apply On Polr Indian's What Could Be Worst "! 😂

[@IsirAkini]

Manusmriti is only one smriti out of hundreds of others. And many smritis criticize the manusmriti. It is anyway a book on law, not religion.

[@bikashnayak9311]

Manusmriti defines 4 Varna - not caste - not reservations. Gita mentioned Varna

[@user-ju1fm8rn1g]

Your mind is venomous when don't have knowledge even about Ambedkar 😂😂😂

[@_natureisgod]

Whole india Same DNA but based on work caste divided😂

[@Aarashi99]

I direct competition to dhruv rathee Keep going brother

[@mrayushtiwari]

This was brilliant! Well articulated

[@TheEmissaryCo]

Thanks a lot ☺️

[@mathis6578]

haha.."hindutva wants to eliminate caste"... you are making me laugh! pls stop!!

[@swapnil-nr3gt]

Hindutva by defination is against cast. If you don't know this then learn.

[@anshupandit4490]

Yes they want so that they can get hindu vote and win elections go read something

[@arjyachatterjee6874]

Ignorance is bliss for people like you especially when from that so called Brshmannical party, Ramnath Kovind and Draupadi Murmu became presidents.

[@BeE_AriyaN]

Tell me you know about Hindutva only through leftist sources without telling me. Go watch Kushal Mehra's video on what is Hindutva where he explains all his claims with proper proofs, of course only if you're interested to know the truth about it.

[@greatkaafir7478]

[ Casteism Word Given By Christian Hispanic In Goa And Caste System Created By Christian British ] 1) = Jaati Comes From Islamic Word Jaaat And Caste Is A Hispanic Word Brought By European's 2) = Shri Manusamrity Has Mentioned About 4 Varn ( Duty By Choice ), 40 Caste's and Subcaste " ( Chnadal's Were Brahmna's From Father Side )! 3) = In 300 Bc Megasthenes Wrote That In India There Are Only 7 Fold Division ( Caste's ) Of Indian Society In His Book Indica ! 4) = Hawnsagn Arrived 7th Century In India Wrote There Is Only Four Varna ( Brahmna, Kshtriy, Weshy, Sudra ) ! 5) = Al-Biruni ( 1017 ) Have Written In Tārīkh al-Hind (History of India) That There Are Only 4 Varn ( Again It Was Varn Brahmna, Kshtriy, Weshy, Shudra ) ( Today's We Have 3000 Caste And 25 Thousands Subcaste's ) How Did It Happened, Let's See ! 6) = First Senses Of Inda Was Did By The British In 1891 Hurbet Trisle Senses India And Mentioned That 2378 Maen Caste's In India And Chamar ( चमार ) Have 1150 Subcaste's And He Also Search Out 43 Race's ( Modern Day Western Language ) ! 7 ) = Indian Constitution Devide People Of India In Caste's General, OBC, SC, ST, Minority And Microminiature !

[@ankit5820]

U seems to be family friends of rajeev malhotra the two faced guy, modern savior of brahminism.

[@Zzmaster_-mj2xv]

Cope

[@death-jy1ph]

Nice explanation. Just adding one of the most ugliest crime for caste, that is, killing of own daughter when she marries other caste. This called honour killing.

[@kumarashura6621]

It's predominantly seen in rural areas. I don't know about other states but it's less important in migrants area of many states. Maybe because they are all migrants from other states but then once a certain community got a large number then you can still see traces of it again. Bihar and UP seems to major breeding ground for this kinda thing in northern India.

[@vamsikrishna3855]

You should have more views. Period.

[@TheEmissaryCo]

Please do share in friend groups so I get them 😁

[@cokedupnormies2651]

Make a video on the Gautam Desiraju map of the country!!!

[@Advaitamanta]

Bro that WU refrence got me LMAO

[@TheEmissaryCo]

🤣🤣

[@mishraji1721]

❤❤

[@TheEmissaryCo]

💙💙

[@atanumandal3586]

There is a popular *narrative peddled by “sanatan intellectuals”* that in ancient Vedic times it used to have a *“fluid social hierarchy” under the Varna system,* which became rigid and oppressive later on particularly during the British Raj. They quote some sections of their religious texts - indicating that a Shudra child may also be inducted into the upper caste category, if he wishes to pursue the duties associated with these varnas. This is a carefully constructed *myth to justify the existence of varna system in sanatan dharma.* The so-called “fluid social hierarchy” under the Varna system has been a proverbial “carrot” for the people of backward castes… According to *Bhagvad Gita* - Varna system is not hereditary but is based on karma (deeds). That is the Hindu doctrine of *"Karma & the cycle of Rebirth".* This so-called Mobility across Varnas actually NEVER existed in the Hindu society... Just see the *sheer cunning of this "Karma & the cycle of Rebirth" argument:-* (1) If you are born to Upper Caste parents in THIS LIFE - it is justified by your "Good Karma" in your PREVIOUS LIFE! (2) If you are born to Shudra/Dalit parents in THIS LIFE - it is justified by your "Bad Karma" in your PREVIOUS LIFE! *Absolutely Machiavellian narrative* to forever protect Upper Caste bloodline for all generations to come and to maintain their hegemony in the society! In practice, Varna System is a *generational curse or boon* that is passed down from one generation to the next... because your Karma in THIS LIFE is rewarded/ punished only in your NEXT LIFE... which nobody can VERIFY.

[@rishavkumar1250]

A son of a farmer or a laborer could become a soldier ... There were shudra landowners and shudra kings as well ... Yes ,there was no mobility for SC and dalits but that's because they were never a part of hindu society. Until the Brits classified them as hindus .

[@basantprasadsgarden8365]

@@rishavkumar1250 you forgot to mention how those Sudra kings had to hide their identity for the sake of gaining Legitimacy by some probably Illiterate Priest.

[@Zzmaster_-mj2xv]

Religious scriptures saying this doesn't make this concrete. The scriptures were as it is fluid with interpolations and deletion depending on the political climate. Most scholars do agree tht rigvedic times showed greater fluidity in caste then later periods. Sanskritisation and rajputisation were very common. Also bhagvad geeta also says an enlightened person is to treat an untouchable the same as a Brahmin. Ig we should ignore tht right?

[@fingers_crossed_3839]

YEAH you are absolutely right , I fed up with these people denying this facts and putting everything wrong in our society on british. and washing their hands of it saves them from the criticism and guilt.

[@KingGodzilla-m2t]

0:26 Do you have proofs that it's written by Ambedkarites and Dalits? You gonna blame random Dalit kid, even if some Uppercastes got Erectile dysfunction? There are Higher chances that Uppercastes write it by themselves just to play Victimcard and frame Dalits. Police didn't arrested any culprits yet but you assumed that they will be Dalits and Ambedkarites?

[@user-ju1fm8rn1g]

No it's opposite, blame bhramhin if Dalith women give birth to female child 😂😂😂😂

[@KingGodzilla-m2t]

@@user-ju1fm8rn1g likhna seekh le pahle. Samajh nhi aata kya kehra

[@KingGodzilla-m2t]

@@user-ju1fm8rn1g blame Dalits if Brahmins get Erectile dysfunction.

[@rishavkumar1250]

​@@KingGodzilla-m2t it's ambedkarites who do it ... saar brahmins took our women saar

[@KingGodzilla-m2t]

@@rishavkumar1250 any proof? Blaming Ambedkarite for your mistaken birth too.

[@shubhamchoudhary5467]

Came here after @gabbar shared it on twitter. Good video

[@TRBhoopathy]

Hindutva vs Jatitva is an interesting analysis. Unfortunately the presentation does not clarify why VERNAS /JATIS originated in India? This fundamental background on the Indian civilsational/Hindu origins of caste and its sustained perpetuation over thousands of years, in water tight compartments is NOT seen in any other religious in the world.. The damning of humans into segregated CASTES by birth with no scope to change, is the genesis of this south Asian crisis. It is not a interreligious conflict? It is the INHUMAN treatment and suppression of the DALITS and other backward castes by the self ordained upper castes is gut wrenching. CASTE is the CANCER of Hindus. There is NO miracle drug or surgery to eradicate this CASTE CANCER. How to remedy this malice. ENDOGAMY has SHACKLED and bonded all Indians into these RATHOLES. It is self sustaining and has been perpetuated over millennia. HINDUTVA is NOT AN ANTIDOTE to this caste cancer. INDIANS are least bothered about this mammoth elephant trampling the nation.? CASTE can never be demolished by quotas? Individuals should liberate themselves from these caste bondages? UNLESS Indians shun the pernicious AND diabolic practice of arranged marriages (95%), which is invariably are confined to the same caste groups, this CASTE CANCER can NEVER be abolished.

[@TheEmissaryCo]

Interesting POV!

[@fzz6716]

The government could have eradicated caste id they wanted to.

[@89RAkesh]

What a crap. Judging India from urban India and from US is hilarious. Leave your comfort and visit rural India , which is the most of India and understand why India votes for caste and not cast vote. It's sad but but a sad reality for a reason.

[@rishavkumar1250]

Rural India's power over the politics needs to be decreased

[@basantprasadsgarden8365]

@@rishavkumar1250 How are you going to do that?

[@greatkaafir7478]

Caste Drive From Casta Portuguese Word Not Even Indian Jaati Is Islamic Word Not Eevn Indian There Are Varna System According To Your Will " ✌️

[@KingGodzilla-m2t]

Water and food is English word, There was no Water and food in India before Britishers. We were starving before Britishers

[@arjyachatterjee6874]

​@@KingGodzilla-m2t So what is your context here ?

[@basantprasadsgarden8365]

@@greatkaafir7478 Jati is an Islamic word. I guess the Slok "Ya Devi Sarvabhuteshu Jati rupen sanshita, namastastsay namastastsay namastastsay namo namah " has been written by some Maulana then

[@vardhamanam]

👏

[@arsalanmirza3411]

CASTE IS EVIL 👿

[@Cybernaut-z2x]

why are you, an NRI, talking about things you don't know ? For an Indian, Hindu identity is non-existent, only caste is what is real.

[@Tarotaro23-k5r]

Lol stfu he has every right to his opinions, and he does incredible and thorough work. As long as an NRI tries to view india through a decolonized lens I’m okay with then sharing their opinions.

[@nehrumantri830]

You maybe nearer the truth if you concede that caste is not based on birth and 85 to 90 % are Sudras. Reading all puranas and fancy nonsense does not make you a Brahmin nor is being born in a Brahmin family. To begin with it how can one certify the parents are Brahmin They maybe dumb doornails for all you know.

[@user-ju1fm8rn1g]

Rahul gyandi and druv tattie 😂😂😂

[@drjagritisingh6569]

You don't know anything, as a uc ofcourse catering to uc thoughts.

[@rishavkumar1250]

Stop using an upper caste surname then. . Use your surname like chamar, jatav or Paswan or whatever the hell it is .

[@vineetjiran5759]

Nice, if you could do in Hindi that would be accessible to wider audiences

[@TheEmissaryCo]

It has Hindi subtitles!

[@binskee677]

Nice video and i agree, division is the last thing india needs. But we have to acknowledge two things: 1. the current BJP and the RSS is almost solely ruled by the upper cast, usually wealthy and well educated. As long as this superiority thinking exists, there cannot be any unity in india let alone between Hindus. It is highly questionable that the upper cast "BJP rulers" have the best interest in mind for the lower cast. I don't agree with quotas, i think quotas are a bad thing, but equal representation is extremely important if we want a society with equal opportunity at some point. I'll be honest, i don't know how this can be achieved, equal good quality education for all would be a start. 2. This is a delicate topic and there might be many different perspectives on this. Although cast was not really created by the British, the so called concept of a "Hindu" which combines all the casts, were indeed "created" by the British. Before that people would not identify themselves as "Hindus" but they would identify themselves based on their cast as this concept of a Hindu didn't exist before that (at least not in the current form). But as such a diverse country is very difficult to rule, the britsh had to come up with a solution to unite all the casts. This was done based on the upper cast interpretation of the old sanskrit vedas which obviously supressed the lower casts (the whole history is a bit more complicated than this but you get the idea). The word Hindu actually only exists because the british were not able to pronounce the word "Sindu". Again i'm totally against dive or quotas, but if we neglect history and that our nation is indeed very diverse with many different cultures, it will create way more issues and divide in the long term. We have to live with the fact that we are all different and have our differences but we i strongly believe we can still come together and stand united, irrelevant of what any political party says or does.

[@Zzmaster_-mj2xv]

1st point is plain wrong. BJP is now ruled by OBCs even their top brass has obcs more than general castes. 2) There was a concept of Dharma always, not necessarily as hindu. 😊

[@binskee677]

@@Zzmaster_-mj2xv thats just how they want to be seen, it's really been steered and ruled by the top casts!

[@booksquotes948]

Vertical oppression exists ?? Nope

[@pisasupayani]

There is nothing wrong with jatitva. So long as government has power to destroy merit and kill businesses, people will always want to have their caste have their share of that power.

[@TheEmissaryCo]

Eventually it leads to too much zero-sumism and stifling of innovation

[@basantprasadsgarden8365]

This Channels sounds like the thought process of a Savarna but with an American accent. Looking at the audiences of this account, it isn't surprising. Regarding the Title of the Video "When Caste becomes a cancer" , A question arises in my mind, Was there even a Time when it was not a Cancer? Yes, it only got recognition of Cancer when it knocked on the doorsteps of it's Creaters , Nourishers and Defenders.......

[@arjyachatterjee6874]

Your comment seems like that of an idiotic Neo-buddhist who cannot argue with facts but rather than throwing tantrums. Already you have embarrassed yourself twice, wanna more once again ?

[@vamsikrishna3855]

8:50 20% of the judiciary lol 😂

[@TheEmissaryCo]

😁😁

[@Kart546]

19:46 i think thats how an average upper caste hindu thinks . Hindutva is divided the country like this and will divide it even more . I don't support any party or i don't have power to vote . But my parents voted for non bjp party We oppose the idea of hate . Thanks for giving your 20:49 Segragation line . Development is same as civilized india used by British to justify their colonial rule of india . 1.Development with exploitation - modiraj2024 2. Civilized indians with exploiting indians -britishraj1954 I don't care about politics but i love your pov its all over indian internet .

[@anshupandit4490]

Ja exam pass kar ja balak

[@Kart546]

​@@anshupandit4490tum logo ko hum logo k hone se hi problem ?

[@BeE_AriyaN]

​@@Kart546 ever wondered what is Hindutva? Go read about it or watch videos on it. For starters you can watch Kushal Mehra's video on what is Hindutva. They don't hate our existence, rather they feel pity on our uneducated assumptions & blind hatred towards them

[@Kart546]

​​@@BeE_AriyaN follow your hindutva we have no problem with it but please respect other people aswell who have different views . Hindu American guy have that view because he from upper caste and his caste identity never tell him the other perspective . He's giving example of Jamaican American but why he's not telling about reserved land for indigenous people native Americans . Each state has its own constitution and laws will India can have it ? White Americans atleast acknowledge about slavery you people try to hide it and it's not us it's British it's not caste it's jati . It's not jati it's Varna etc atleast acknowledge the past then compare India and US . Slavery was something of past . But caste system is not of past it exists everywhere in India

[@BeE_AriyaN]

@@Kart546 you'll never find me denying jaativaad, I mean why should I, I'm an OBC myself. I'm just saying if you're openly critical about Hindutva then at the least you should know about it, that's all what I'm saying. You think jaatis living in silos will anyway solve the segregation we still have? No. Then why not explore an idea, through the lense of its originators, if it really is what it claims i.e. an ideology actively against jaativaad or casteism to unite us all Hindus & even non-hindus under a single umbrella. In your own words, is the idea worth exploring? If yes, do watch Kushal's recent video in which he explains with proof what Hindutva is, & then let me know if you still believe if it's an ideology of segregation & discrimination or contrary to your believes, an ideology of unity & anti-casteism You're welcome in advance

[@xyzabc-li2ty]

Another nri showing his unawareness on the history of caste based discrimination which is still deeply rooted in Indians , I have many examples like in corporate jobs promotion were given based on caste not on their word, expect for big Cities, you can see caste based discrimination in india , most important in marriage even both of them love each other and are from same culture still society will not accept them , very bad take , also politics are done on the issues of society, so if you are seeing politics done on caste , it is because the society care for it , from caste you will remove the politics around it

[@TheEmissaryCo]

I’m not an NRI. I’m a PIO 😊

[@xyzabc-li2ty]

Come to india bro, u will see the reality yourself

[@Aarashi99]

If you want to popular in india speak in hindi that how dhruv rather gain massive following in india

[@kaushikinazuma3053]

Jati mean community like manava jati mean human being community etc and India is diversity country different states has different cultures we don't have any rule book unlike other religions and we don't have caste we have Varna which means skill which is dead today we only have pujari or pundit and untouchability happened because person choose to not civilized themselves and today some adivasi tribe choose to become naxal terrorist because government not allowing them to live in forest.

[@fingers_crossed_3839]

so will you also defend british they also thought of us to be non civilized?

[@kaushikinazuma3053]

@@fingers_crossed_3839 by your logic you are from british 🤡.

[@lalchandlohana3479]

Thanks but if this video would in hindi it would reached more people would be educated and knew the rahul pappu to divide people into different caste and come to power 😡😡😡😡😡

[@TheEmissaryCo]

It has Hindi subtitles!!

[@vikky4209]

Privileged exploiter teaching us

[@TheEmissaryCo]

Sir, I am a Bahujan

[@udhayakumarMN]

😂😂😂😂

[@upcomingtech1091]

😂😂 judiciary

[@ankit5820]

u r just a cunning from the grp of brahminism for saving it for caste sustainability for their future by either using ambedkar either for or agaisnt their motif of crushing this movement and creating us as a grp for fututre service and inundating/usurping ambedkar like Buddha in future.

[@kaushikinazuma3053]

Jati mean community like manava jati mean human being community etc and India is diversity country different states has different cultures we don't have any rule book unlike other religions and we don't have caste we have Varna which means skill which is dead today we only have pujari or pundit and untouchability happened because person choose to not civilized themselves and today some adivasi tribe choose to become naxal terrorist because government not allowing them to live in forest.

[@ankit5820]

@@kaushikinazuma3053 posh ilako m pala bada aajse 30-40 saal pehle k practically castiest families k previlege se posh ilako or oblivious n misinformed by those who wanna get it faked and then blame it on britishers or muslims. Read Dalit literature soecifically which are based on experiences of dalits of castiesm and discriminations. eg JHOOTHAN by omprakash valmiki. MURDAHIYA, poem: CHAMARO KI GALI, story : THAKUR LA KUAN, etc etc. Read lives n thoughts/ideas in examples n stories by Sant Gadge Baba , Ayankali, Periyar, Jyotiba Phule , Sant Ravidas from theie very own personal perspective only and not Savarna/Upper-Castes one's who'll share and eat up ugly reality of castiesm to appropriate it for their non identification and continuation of caste for future( saving socio economic resource capital disguised in one or other form majorly in hinduism. ) by their Cultural/Savarn/Informational Appropriation so that in future some person like you after Previlege or by intention come to say cunningly/unknowngly, from reality of present to a few decades, to hundreds of century old Sant Ravidas experiences of casteism why he said no one is impure from working with flesh to those who have purity concept in terms of diet, leather, and untouchability ((( clearly letting u know justified by scriptures by pujaris/brahmins followed by all as god's law))) every human is same every one has flesh in body to tell they r also humans and deserve respect(( (it was 1500s))). tulsidas writer of ramcharitmanas in 1500s has also written castiest derogatory and by birth trait and abusive language in sanskrit verses duly flowing in common language n culture in ppl since always so it was not anything what u say it was timely dictated by pioneers of religion/hinduism who were als by birth brahmins who made sure difference remains there becuz the ugly disrespective view was in thier informal verbal traiditon/culture and beliefs duly confirmed and assisted using scriptures and god's name etc etc. u probably are am NRI reached ther from previlege capital and deletion of reality by heavily or almost wholly savarn dominated mediamen editors n academia, markets who control manipulate marginalise the thoughts time to time they don't want to be known, or be removed/added/ or thoughts of mainstream n elite masses. u may also be a person from india's posh areas or one with many a people in ur contact of bjp/upper castes in india.

[@ankit5820]

at @17min they are not castiest who raise the issue of caste inpublic. You are surely/definitely from an indian Upper caste/savarn lineage in US who has told u that they r castiest and not told u anything about the local level injustices becoz they simply wanted who whitewash their image and imaginations and to their chldren speaking this.. no boy you r castiest. word started in use to bring the phenomena of discriinating or creating a visible/hidden acts of castiesm/discrimination/crime(physical/social/economic/political etc) . Bringing the voice against raoe doesn't make someone rapist/crime so does raising and feling the ugliness of caste and bringing it in public doesn't make someone castiest but is agaisnt it the deprived and marginalisation.

[@Secular_Saddam_Hussein]

judiciary 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@lalitasharma6687]

Even german and everyone use caste like Muller etc

[@TheEmissaryCo]

Hmmmmm