Who Sang The "Candy Store" Riff The Best? (G5)

Also known as "Who Pushed Heather Duke The Best? lmao
From the musical "Heathers" by Laurence O'Keefe and Kevin Murphy.
Watch the other videos of the original series "Who Sang It Best?" here: ► • Who Sang It The Best?
Follow me on my social media accounts!:
► Twitter: bit.ly/2Cy2QFJ
► Instagram: bit.ly/3zBx2v7
► TikTok: bit.ly/3A9BLWd
Timestamps
00:17 Jessica Keenan Wynn
00:35 Laura Field
00:52 Rachel Flynn
01:10 Temma Beaudreau
01:28 Zoey Johnson
01:45 Lucy Maunder
02:03 Sarah Halford
02:21 Paul Esswein
02:38 Illegal Heathers
02:55 Kerry Gibbons
03:13 Amy Ross
03:31 Jenna Leigh Green
03:45 Lauren Echausse
04:02 Brandis DeWilligen
04:20 Jessica Huch
04:38 Ian Allred
04:55 Hannah Cummings
05:12 Melanie Frewen
05:30 Charissa Hogeland
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
edited by me with the software Sony Vegas 18.0
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
#theatre #musical #singer

[@MisterGolightly]

Shut up, Heather!

[@saiyongdawn7756]

Laura Fields for sure💝

[@gracedoubleu]

Sorry, Heather...

[@laurenjames3812]

hello lord and saviour mister golightly xx

[@iAmMadeOfSoup]

Sorry Heather

[@MisterGolightly]

Greetings and salutations! xx

[@greenisnotacreativecolour1274]

Regina George: Who are you ? Heather: I'm you but stronger

[@jdjdfg431]

Midnight Moon Heather is stronger physically and has more “power” but Regina made an entire school collapse in like an hour

[@greenisnotacreativecolour1274]

@@jdjdfg431 Right

[@jdjdfg431]

So I mean I think they’re kinda the same

[@greenisnotacreativecolour1274]

Jdj Dfg I know

[@livindeadghoul]

Stolen

[@zykakatrinacabaccang7667]

Lemme fix the title "Which Heather Duke got pushed the hardest?"

[@jxss_xxx9690]

That’s so true

[@livziccardi1478]

Zyka Katrina Cabaccang abahahahah

[@Chipropractor]

1:46 She SLID

[@zykakatrinacabaccang7667]

@@Chipropractor she acted like she was on some slide i-

[@zykakatrinacabaccang7667]

@@candy5704 even better.

[@camillecrazed]

3:46 This is one of my favorites. It's probably because of Heather's offended face afterwards.

[@grecia83]

apart from the og ones this one is prob my favorite

[@ricardoortiz3174]

in the other hand, HC's face is kinda scared, totally out of character.

[@blinkywinky2431]

HC: SHUT UP HEATHER! HD: :O

[@user-js7zw2zk1c]

Ö

[@LuvSebbi]

She was like >:0

[@eryxfinn3141]

if they say “shut up heather” aggressively, you know it’s gonna be a good rif

[@TrashistPandaZ]

So true

[@walkadog1454]

Alternative title: Heather Duke getting bullied for 6 minutes straight

[@Ldrlvr500]

Dark Canary she deserves it

[@isabellarodriguez1874]

True true

[@WizGamingXD]

Denim Socks She honestly doesn't.

[@carmesan7965]

Dark Canary she deserves it.

[@Ldrlvr500]

I don’t know how I got that many likes it’s just me being salty

[@JulsFox]

“Shut up Heather” Dumbledore asked calmly.

[@chiaisannoying]

BAHAHA

[@kitagawhat]

LOL BAHAHAHHAHAHAH

[@munroak3911]

this is the most underrated comment on here

[@kitagawhat]

I can’t handle this lol

[@ghxsty_]

HEATHER DID YAH PUT YER NAME IN DA GOBLET OF FIYAH?

[@cherrieee]

We have to all agree that Charissa had the best “Shut up, Heather!” (5:30)

[@Th3RealH3nryEmily]

Yes

[@sophia_e123]

she’s my favorite heather chandler

[@kiv3745]

It was a aggressive and loud Literally fits her character

[@will0ww._.]

this cast is my favorite! they fit the characters so well.

[@LunarL3xa]

​@@sophia_e123 Same she slayed

[@justforfunentertainment7076]

4:24 I love the little detail where Heather M. helps Heather D. up, it really shows her personality

[@Loopimay]

Eh, I don't. The whole point was that Heather McNamara didn't really give a shit about Heather Duke in act 1, which is part of the reason why she was so cruel towards her.

[@Thingumadoodle0518]

@@Loopimay I mean, she didn’t do much to help Duke when she should have, but saying she didn’t give a sh*t seems a bit unfair. She was the only one concerned about Duke’s bulimia, and suggested she see a doctor.

[@katlndry]

@@Thingumadoodle0518 Heather Mac really wasn’t the “cinnamon roll” everyone thinks she is 😭 She literally volunteered Veronica for date rape

[@Thingumadoodle0518]

@@katlndry I never said she was??? I was just making a point about her relationship with Duke lmao-

[@Ameneyuiki]

@@Thingumadoodle0518 In the movie that never happened McNamara and Chandler bullied Duke Veronica was the one to ask Duke to go see a doctor The musical showed a bad image of the characters :/ PLUS WHO TF MAKE A COMEDY SONG ABOUT R@PE

[@denlillepige7730]

1:49 Heather just YEETED Heather across the floor

[@corcor2222]

Oh god...

[@randomyeet8873]

It’s super heather

[@NorthofSophia]

The “shut up heather” could’ve been a been a bit stronger but that yeet was A+

[@hayleydoesthings]

This bitch empty

[@yuki_sushi3480]

Jade Chouinard og check aahahahha

[@librababyxo]

an appreciation comment for all the heather dukes shamelessly slammed to the floor throughout this video

[@herlocksupremacy9178]

needy for love sucks being a Heather Duke-

[@laskomoore]

On one of them it was Heather McNamara

[@sugarstudios5946]

but some of them were lowkey trash

[@cricketwastaken]

What if I dont want a name hh avocado

[@awilddon.8570]

F

[@goldfishbrain1419]

2:48 they were legit about to kiss before Veronica backed away, change my mind.

[@abigailw7146]

*kinda gay ngl*

[@zoe-vc4gn]

@@ratinclothes1605 IM HERE

[@zoe-vc4gn]

@@ratinclothes1605 please you didn’t have to come for my throat ✋😭

[@OneNerdyAce]

I said “oh yeah their gay. Definitely gay” and now I’m happy I’m not the only one who thought this

[@arcshuttle]

0:53 can we PLEASE talk about that death glare Chandler gave Duke the MOMENT she went off??? 😂😂

[@Alex-yv9vi]

The middle ones look 0:54

[@birthdaycake4611]

Why is nobody talking about the one when they had like fIVE heathers

[@cranberryjuice-kf5cc]

Which one?

[@aubrievanallen2744]

0:35

[@-jolin-3593]

True, I thought about that too!

[@vicenteisaaclopezvaldez2450]

What a nightmare.

[@derp4374]

I was like "wait what"

[@jarvis9054]

Heather being Yeeted for 6 minutes and 3 seconds straight

[@nongandrews8385]

U mean Heather, right.

[@jesm5698]

Oh sorry! I misread this! I thought it was Heather! But now I know it it’s heather

[@jotid8930]

Wait, I don't you mean heather not heather

[@parkerxd9422]

XD poor Heather Duke

[@franceslane3798]

2:21 everything about this is just perfection The background dancing, the slap, the singing *chefs kiss*

[@p0cket646]

wHooOoOOooOoOOOoo

[@queerparadox8328]

Honey that was a punch not a slap

[@TheBestSam42]

I love the harshness in his voice it’s so high and then he just punched her and barks SHUT UP HEATHER

[@Hannie-pf1ec]

a slap? honey that was a whole PUNCH

[@itsreaganlol]

5:12 i love how they used the use of lighting in the background for the effect of who is singing/talking, really cool!

[@bunkersketches1238]

2:22 Was the best SHUT UP HEATHER I have ever seen.

[@mayel5387]

*deep voice* SHUT UP HEATHER That’s literally my dad

[@feliz5919]

*that was hilariously good tbh*

[@angelaphsiao]

Just straight up decks him in the face

[@luzmoran9536]

*I agree* 😂😂

[@braylin5003]

While 2:45 is the gayer heather C. ever 😂😂😂

[@michelle9085]

1:50 “hUp HuP HeATheR”

[@general_logging3902]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@pezzimizt4603]

O h n o 😂

[@cherryjelly8494]

O h. L o r d

[@MissMommy0514]

I heard “shUP UP HEATHer”

[@talia9586]

i can’t i hear it lmao

[@jamie.lynn004]

2:55 She is the BEST Heather Duke I have ever seen. While the rest of that performance was choppy, you have to give them credit for all (yes, ALL three Heathers) being sick AND having mic troubles.

[@pandahtoemateo3321]

They were ALL sick AND all having mic probs?

[@jamie.lynn004]

@@pandahtoemateo3321 Yes! Crazy isn't it, and what a coincide that they all got sick on the same night.

[@Sammydodger45]

@@jamie.lynn004 probably gave each other the sickness

[@aesthetic_skxes9803]

In Shine a Light (Reprise) she is so FUCKING amazing

[@stateofgrace03]

ALL of them were sick? that’s so sad

[@b_mrkr1103]

Heather duke at 2:57 was honestly really satisfying to hear

[@quinnrose5017]

honestly the harsher the “shut up heather” is how good the riff is. I think first and last are best

[@BunzieCakes]

Oh good. The official ones are best by far. I agree

[@SimplyAngelic828]

AGREED.

[@-ejamezfictionalstudioz-4951]

These two are the og actresses at the first showing! How ironic!😂

[@luyi011]

Amy Ross had the harshest one 😂

[@bobsmith-ph6gu]

I think the gender swap one where he decks the guy is pretty good

[@caerrus1627]

2:25 *SHUT UP, HEATHER* their characters are super feminine, but when he yelled at duke, the deep voice made it 10x better

[@songbirdsystem1465]

royrae IS THAT MY BABY BOI KIRISHIMA?!

[@kaitlynrangel1998]

IM YELLINT

[@nongandrews8385]

*He was wearing girl shorts 0.o*

[@LTomlinson21JETS]

royrae

[@alysiaburrows2307]

The full version kzbin.info/www/bejne/eIi3eqOFj7Fjgbc

[@tvgirlyt]

0:18 jessica keenan wynn 0:35 laura field 0:54 rachel flynn 1:11 jemma beaudrean 1:29 zoe johnson 1:46 lucy maunder 2:03 sarah halford 2:23 paul esswein 2:39 illegal heathers 2:57 kerry gibbons 3:14 amy ross 3:31 jenna leigh green 3:47 lauren echausse 4:04 brandis de willigen 4:21 jessica huch 4:39 ian alfred 4:55 hannah cummings 5:13 melanie frewen 5:31 charissa hogeland

[@G4Spike]

5:30 is the best cause of the intensity of the "shut up Heather"

[@poi1]

3:01 STEP INTO MY CANDY STAAAAAAAAAAAAAWAAAAAAAAAAAWOOWAAAAAAAAAAA

[@rivertheenbybitch117]

In fairness, I think she was ill that day.

[@d.3781]

and she had mic problems,, i kind of likes her loud singing tho

[@vue945]

She was sick.

[@beefstroganoff8597]

Duke was good in my opinion.

[@ivyg1515]

They were all sick and they all had mic problems for that one. They had to scream

[@GieVoices]

I feel bad for Heather... No, not that heather. Not her, either. Yes her.

[@alexandriacanaan8165]

...McNamara?

[@vicentheguzman3349]

No other heather

[@Mac-43]

SchAißer poop I feel bad for that Heather over there

[@anahbella5438]

Lexi Cannan that’s what I was like I was like Is it.............sweet innocent little McNamara

[@randompromises1038]

yeah, heather and heather are so mean to heather.

[@sofiatrevisanfarret2157]

3:14 that "shut up heather" was the best for me

[@jpachu16]

I love how the girl flipped her hair up in audacity on the beat at 0:40

[@jaeedwards9548]

2:10 "CaNDy STooOOOooooO- YEA YEA YEA YEAYEAYEAYEAYEA

[@waterbottle1067]

My 1st impression when I watched this vid.

[@oskar3319]

Jared Edwards IKR THAT WAS SO EXTRA LMAO

[@szymongozdzikowski8457]

She did it perfectly!!!

[@waterbottle1067]

@@szymongozdzikowski8457 Ik she played Chandler before Jessica Keenan Wynn took the role.

[@szymongozdzikowski8457]

@@waterbottle1067 She made it sound almost like in recording studio!!! Her technique is like OMG!!! Im going to look for some bootlegs with her (dont have any hope, but lets be positive :))

[@mrsweeetrussianchild1914]

1:50 That ain’t heather duke That’s superman

[@marie-vy4mc]

how did she glide across the stage HOW DID SHE GLIDE ACROSS THE STAGE

[@christinariba5099]

How did she said that far?

[@nicolecarroll4508]

omg i died

[@sleepybubble2656]

HOLY SHIT HOLY SHIT HOLY SHIT HOLY SHIT HOLY SHIT

[@minorisgirl]

The stage had to have like soap and water on the floor like how did she slide that far

[@hamiltonlover-uu1vd]

i love how 1:56 is exactly like the outfit from the movie

[@gummy5862]

Gotta give it to Charissa (last girl). She was the best at hitting all the notes, which is super important in a riff. Simply being able to belt the high note isn’t enough.

[@marzel4212]

3:50 this was the most true offended face i've ever seen. Edit: thanks for the likes :O

[@lee_fengli]

LMAO

[@callmecly9559]

It also synced with the beat which made it the best offended face so far

[@plusiegaming8962]

XD😂 also I’m the 666th like

[@szlendak1368]

Clysoxips23 LMAOOOO

[@theresegarcia2789]

Looking back at this comment and the part I still so freaking hard😂😂

[@eldagoodyear911]

Jessica Kennan Wynn. She is the first person to be cast as Heather Chandler in the musical. She is the first generation. And she is so darn good

[@gamoviestudios1388]

3:31 ngl i kinda love this one just cause it was a nice breath of fresh air after hearing the same harmonies over and over lol

[@boydfam4436]

I think we all know who did the best 2:22

[@Jayeponz]

YASSSSSSSS

[@yesterdayspopsicle1693]

No.

[@Jayeponz]

@@yesterdayspopsicle1693 there are two types of people In the world. What can I say? Lol😂

[@eliac]

*Definitely*

[@destinygrebstad8216]

Yaaaasssss

[@npat1289]

i liked 5:30 heather duke tho- her voice is so soothing

[@rachelrodriguez650]

Yup

[@-amberrr-3521]

Its the original

[@chloryfish3013]

She’s the original

[@piranhasz427]

It’s Alice Lee, the og HD

[@zarakamat1802]

She be da OG

[@camelia6507]

Best ones: 0:17 the best SHUT UP HEATHER 0:53 2:22 love that 3:46 4:39 love that pt2 5:30 the best SHUT UP HEATHER pt2 (ps it's my favorite one) Worst ones: 0:35 the cloning of Heathers (however the singing wasn't that bad) 1:28 i just can't stand their voices lol 2:03 me when I get a good grade 2:38 there was no acting or emotion into it 4:21 (Nobody asked but this was my opinion kiss kiss 😘😘)

[@dizzifulclown_]

ok but illegal chandler (2:38) KILLED IT in my opinion she has scoliosis from carrying that show

[@samuelhingley7066]

3:31 is what candy store was originally gonna sound like

[@chile7954]

the chandler at 1:28 was actually really good! her mic is rlly crappy, but she's hitting the notes

[@sayaisnotokey1151]

i think 1:46 is great :)

[@elainacaroline5072]

@@dizzifulclown_ sameee also her voice was good she just didn’t start singing early enough

[@keiraschmal7402]

The eyes that Rachel Flynn gives Heather before the “shut up heather” is just gold 🔥🔥🔥

[@Torycorn]

The better question is who did the best ‘shut up heather’?

[@lewiscunningham8379]

Amy Ross for sure

[@yulialopez3812]

^^

[@catherine5322]

I mean, Charissa’s tho...

[@destinyhoward8245]

paul esswein for sureee

[@hellokittyobsession420]

glorybox Right!?

[@threethirteen]

best heather duke: 5:31 best "shut up heather" : 2:24 best heather chandler: 4:09

[@brooke2601]

pluto honestly 👌

[@sunnysideofthings]

pluto I so agree

[@Pixiehollowfairy777]

pluto i

[@kelseyann4445]

Yeah

[@katiek2615]

pluto agree

[@RainbowEssence-c3w]

They all clearly put a lot of heart into it, but I suppose I will always be partial to the original since that's the one I heard first. That being said, the death glare at 0:54 and the shove at 1:31 were both hilarious lol. The punch out at 2:25 and the "oh no you didn't!" look Heather D. gave to Heather C. at 3:51 was hysterical too. 😂 In terms of voice (at least Heather Duke's voice) I am in love with Alice Lee's depiction of her and her version of Shine a Light (Reprise). She has such an amazing singing voice and really nails that jealous, drunk-on-newfound-power alpha bitch role (in a good way lol).

[@queerparadox8328]

The coldness in Heather's voice at 3:31 though... Not even to mention how beautiful her singing was

[@violetriley5692]

3:02 wasn’t singing...it was just straight up screaming

[@holly-marieknight359]

Violet Riley xD

[@keiji_fiji9954]

Exactly lol. But she tried her best and she had fun so I'm not complaining

[@ElinorMahoney]

Lol she was ill, piss off

[@PlaystationSimmer]

I believe she was sick when they performed, so I think she deserves some slack lol

[@josephphotiboi4681]

Well,your supposed too slightly scream and belt it

[@arianabig4702]

Everyone is talking about how heather duke got slammed to the floor BUT WHAT ABOUT 1:45!?

[@rykerwashere608]

Ive seen this so many times its unbelievable

[@kayden6048]

5:30 Duke was best. She sounds beautiful.

[@malloryjade1760]

•Itz Kit!• :3 she is the original heather on broadway so it makes sense lol

[@sunnyrecs]

mallory jade heathers never made it to broadway, it was actually off-broadway

[@_jelyfish07_49]

She was also in the first one

[@oliviapinero296]

@@sunnyrecs no they made it on Broadway back in 2010 but they went off Broadway in 2014

[@sunnyrecs]

LimeyLivi i just searched it up right now, and it wasn’t broadway, in 2010, they made it into a 2-day concert and then in 2014 they decided to go off broadway

[@queendiscombra]

2:23 has the best “Shut up Heather 4:47 has the best Riff

[@ghxstyboo691]

QueenDiscombra fully agreed

[@Crazymeh18]

Girl: shut up heather! Guy: S H U T U P H E A T H E R .

[@-amberrr-3521]

Yup

[@user-oq6ri8be2o]

YEEEES! XD

[@abbysoto7643]

@@zoenic_ole fACTS XD

[@amandarachel2108]

They all slayed it

[@coolbae1998]

0:57 is the best, along with Jessica's. 🖤

[@armysorass2329]

Shoutouts to all the Heather Duke's that had to be thrown onto the floor by Heather Chandler XD

[@livmacmillan415]

Thank you for the shoutout lol

[@zipzapzop6519]

Plus that one McNamara for some reason, lol

[@sketchycat6223]

Aria Akihiko Heather could throw me to the floor anyway tbh

[@drakebell5649]

Heather could push me and I'd thank her

[@florencegregory2019]

Aria Akihiko smack

[@Doctor_Drama_Mama]

2:24 why is no one talking about how Chandler just assaulted duke

[@ilovebats449]

Oof it do be like dat doe

[@overripeschnitzel]

✨ *b i t c h p u n c h* ✨

[@brogle22]

If you play it in slow motion you’ll see that chandler’s hand never made contact with Duke’s face Just pointing it out and how real it looked

[@HeatherChandlerBQ]

But she deserved it...

[@quacksterlol8370]

Smack

[@andrewjosephbowen]

No bad vibes, but Sarah Halford and Charissa Hogeland were my favorites! I love the chest quality they give throughout even entering their mix! Great video! ❤️

[@waterbottle1067]

and the A5 Sarah did hit different

[@tayishahissey691]

That first one is amazing and the actresses are so good

[@reaper2003]

“who sang candy store the best?” me: _heather_ my friend: but aren’t they all named- me: *_HEATHER_*

[@phroggymai]

Nah, Heather is the best, and I definitely think heather was the worst one. Overall, Heather is in the middle. They almost got it, but I didnt like it as much as Heather!!

[@ruricarris4770]

@@phroggymai wait.... Omg are you serious right now? How could you forget Heather! Obviously she did the best.

[@phroggymai]

@@ruricarris4770 Ah, Dammit, I guess I did forget Heather. But Heather still comes out second!

[@ruricarris4770]

@@phroggymai well.. If there's one thing I definitely do agree with you is that Heather did the worst...

[@xoxbbygirl1012]

Ruri Carris no, heather did the worst. The riff wasn’t very clean. I

[@veronicasawyer5050]

2:22 "hAnNy wAcHa wAy-TiN-fHoR"

[@tranlenamphuong6192]

Bitch slap 😂

[@Caezine]

It's my favorite

[@camillecrazed]

Oh hey Veronica.

[@gaypeoples]

*sTEP INTO MY CANDYYY STOREEEEEE.* *oOoOo tIm fOr yA tO pRoV yOur nAt a lAmASs aNyMaR.*

[@Royoyo]

ՏᕼᑌT ᑌᑭ ᕼᗴᗩTᕼᗴᖇ!

[@kaitlinmills6412]

I LOVE Charissa Hogeland as H. Chandler, Iconic!!!

[@cabin.13.runaway]

They were all so good!!! I personally favored Paul Esswein a lot lmao

[@keiji_fiji9954]

1:13..I've never heard a Heather Chandler sound so much like the original oml

[@sharonr.8840]

LARGE BAGUETTE LAFAYETTE :3 omg that heather Mac was LIVING

[@m0thtearzz.]

LARGE BAGUETTE LAFAYETTE :3 voice is too high I think but other than that it’s pretty much spot on

[@julietc89]

Ikr

[@arianagrandeedits7995]

The first one too, But i agree

[@cocaronpa3381]

Ariana Grande Edits cause the first one is literally the original lol

[@toxicmarshmallows6920]

4:38 - riff is bomb AF 2:22 - best harassment of duke 3:46 - best duke surprise face 2:55 - best honey watchu waitin for

[@sonialeung1439]

3:46 was also the best delivery of 'shut up heather'

[@noelle3780]

2:39 The gayest lol

[@makennapatton3680]

2:22 the aggression 😂😂😂

[@nongandrews8385]

3:46 Duke was like "excuse me!?!?!?!"

[@superstar2446]

Yuds

[@amb2487]

the way jodie steele did a mixed D6 as a part of her 2021 riffs is forever iconic

[@joceyyy_]

It's amazing how some high school productions are amazing and some are horrible.

[@Cauti0nSeaman]

@ 2:04 when heather got pushed and she let out a little “OOW!” it had me DEAD

[@holly-marieknight359]

Slick Nick Asmr thatt so cute

[@lovekiki1879]

I can't unhear that now

[@sophiehuml4225]

i’m wheezing 😂

[@llie841]

Why is nobody talking about the one with like 6 different Heathers?

[@no-eq2jf]

one is martha so 5 heathers

[@lillianhull3811]

One is Veronica to

[@abbys.7124]

Right? And half of them weren’t even wearing a Heather color...

[@rosecruzan1187]

Ah yes, the heathers. Heather chandler, heather duke, Heather macmara, uhh... pink heather... uh... jean jacket heather...

[@jay-xx5ei]

Shut up heather-

[@daniela4850]

jessica keenan wynn will forever be my favorite. i love her as heather chandler and i am just in love with her voice

[@brooke____]

2:22 and 4:39 …what is happening here. Top notch comedy and I’m here for it

[@mlpsoda1175]

5:31 best Heather Duke 2:24 best 'shut up Heather' 4:09 best Heather Chandler

[@user-nh8ot4hh7r]

Mlp Soda Alice Lee (The Heather duke ur talking about) is amazing. She’s the original Heather d.

[@ottercos]

best shut up is true

[@weirdshazz3535]

I agree with you

[@anne-gabriellareyes6662]

AGREED (but what about the others)

[@Omni77120]

agreed, got to say XD

[@xo_sunnypixels_ox6862]

2:22 WHOOOOA heather abuse department that punch WAS OUT OF SCRIPT

[@u_adore_me_but_I_adore_twice]

Random Reader lol

[@lilredstrawberriez]

Idk if I should be kinda happy or sad it was fake

[@Azeriiall]

joking jokester yes

[@rainybopz]

Oh go-

[@rainybopz]

The suspenders...

[@brokenThinker]

man those boys pulled out on top of my list cuz it was just great

[@evilymusic]

personally loved Amy Ross’ the best. perfect balance of technique & passion + an extra nasty SHUT UP HEATHER lol Charissa Hogeland was also very good and had a lot of power!

[@kale278]

2:22 Is completely the best, change my mind.

[@changingchannel5532]

I completely agree

[@legustalokinkynasty659]

Agree

[@dangodangoytb]

Yes indeed

[@taliacraig927]

Agreed

[@riverstyx8126]

And the way he went 😃 🤜😙🩸

[@queenofrandomthings4920]

Let’s fix the title: “Which Heather Duke got abused the hardest?”

[@aidensimpsalot3577]

2:22 duke got pummelled

[@HeatherChandlerBQ]

@@aidensimpsalot3577 deservedly so

[@riverstyx8126]

2:22 and 1:46 are currently deceased 💀

[@ArixCupio]

2:22

[@aichastrakdjedou6132]

2:22

[@carla-gw7yu]

i’m just happy you included illegal heathers

[@kikyo1267]

The first and last heather are my favorite!!!

[@neenie_lelka5387]

5:31 is the best, but the boys were great too

[@kaylees5627]

Yea

[@exkmam733]

Lu-lu-chan its de original

[@alchris8041]

@@exkmam733 Jessica Wynn is, but I like Charissa's more.

[@micahadamson4309]

@@exkmam733 The first one is the actual original, she's just the understudy.

[@jasminep8930]

Very true

[@missrarity.6277]

I rate the deliver of shut up heather and the violence of the push 😂

[@parkchimmin7913]

kateh x 2:25 Is the best one!

[@uwkhj9836]

Park ChimMin I agree 100%

[@erosversace2510]

Omg me too

[@muda552]

PAUL ESSWEIN FOR THE WIN!!

[@rielletambaoan_]

Emma Talton sings hey pham

[@artbycallie6816]

I love the first one but they all did a great job! Rip Heather D.

[@RaidenShogun-oj8ez]

I can’t choose! They were all so good! I could possibly sing that…

[@DerangedDoodler]

4:47 higher than my grades, and those are pretty good tbh

[@kailaflowers3288]

Dani Art Boi the pit stain adds a lot to it too

[@imjustdaniela4664]

@@kailaflowers3288 LMAOOO

[@overripeschnitzel]

*it’s beautiful.*

[@overripeschnitzel]

@@kailaflowers3288 also that avengers shirt mmm 👌🏻

[@miraculoustalesofobliviousness]

@@kailaflowers3288 BWAHAHA I CANT UNSEE THAT NOW 😂

[@hay_byte1885]

*No heathers were hurt in the making of this video* Heather Duke: I'm I a joke to you?

[@Cry_Ry]

And that one McNamara.

[@_unicycle701]

You mean am I a joke to you

[@hay_byte1885]

@@_unicycle701 oh well

[@shadowman21282]

Shut up Heather

[@hay_byte1885]

@@shadowman21282 Sorry heather

[@jellycoolreader9796]

The second one was really good

[@yee-raplantar-maximoff4318]

Lol, I came here for 100 different ‘Shut Up Heather!’s and this vid did not disappoint

[@waterlillygacha454]

am i the only one who really likes the original heather dukes voice??

[@lwazizi]

It's amazing

[@heathersmc]

Is that the last one?

[@nmbrrr77]

@@heathersmc first and last one :)

[@m0thtearzz.]

Hyunieee :3 not first ?

[@nmbrrr77]

@@m0thtearzz. the first duke is the original and the last also

[@puzzled-head3493]

0:54 she looks like she WANTS to push her, even tho it's just singing and not acting. Like, homegirl about to scream and fckin yeet her mic into Heather C

[@ArtAche-vp6sz]

Bonnie chan The savage and salty boi! Heather D. Got the death stare instead

[@fireworkcookie1002]

Lucky for her qwq

[@puzzled-head3493]

@Ronnie Irazes Oh My God

[@trixie7759]

F in the chat for the Heather Duke who literally slid across the ground when she was pushed and had to sprint back to her spot

[@fif.eats.fishs444]

1:48 heather c flinging heather d was so smooth witt

[@Ashley-ej3gz]

The best part is We seeing heather duke getting harassed for straight up 6 mins and 3 seconds XD

[@confetti_kisses427]

No that's the worst part

[@holly-marieknight359]

Stephanie Greer she never said they didn’t harass each other

[@confetti_kisses427]

She's not, really, but I don't feel like explaining why

[@wyatthagenbeck8055]

2:22 Heather Chandler just punched Heather Duke and didn’t even bother singing it and I live for it

[@alcor3372]

Geralynn Conley Heath

[@penguinnii]

No seriously doe this part got me crying 😂😂😂

[@ivyloops]

lmao I sorta love how everyone thinks he was actually punched, stage fighting is fun

[@marianazawadski8250]

Is my favorite Heather from Syosset of shut up Heather.

[@Youraveragecreepypastafan]

I love this part, thanks for time stamping it

[@kuramacabre]

My favorite Heather Chandler is Ian Allred, the second dude with the Avengers shirt. His performance is the best. 🤣

[@OH_jiwon]

I've seen the first and the last one already and I honestly thought that that were the same actors :0

[@Harmony-wj8ji]

I just realised Heathers and the schuyler sisters wear the same colour scheme Holy shit

[@mychaeltorres2436]

Dr BlackCoffee don’t do that. Why would you do that? Uggghhhhhh 😂😂

[@dreamerforever1002]

Dr BlackCoffee this was confidential information!!!!! How dare you say this to the public!!!!!!

[@shiinakohz]

Dr BlackCoffee Ya only realised it? I realised it the last 3 months ago.

[@junodean9532]

They are also stoplights.

[@isabelle2072]

Blue yellow and Red are the colours of the Schuyler Sisters. Blue Green and Red are the colours of Heather Heather and of coarse, Heather

[@lilylou2615]

I like how all the other ones have the their name and illegal Heather is just called illegal Heather.

[@escotiyaotl8869]

The cast wasn't really announced, so that's the best he could do.

[@koji6745]

Anonimity is the best we can give that poor girl

[@angeliqueriou2660]

Here's her channel if you're genuinely interested. She continues to sing and makes incredible covers such as this one: kzbin.info/www/bejne/mp-qi3Z4jsqeY7s

[@megaygirl1804]

Arissa

[@dreamersball1003]

PLS I CANT STOP REPLAYING 2:22

[@gerbilfantastic]

I *love* the group choreography at 1:45!

[@agh1815]

5:03 why are they on a farm LMAO

[@JG-cf2lz]

lmfao

[@ky1204]

lol

[@xoxodgaf]

LOOOOL

[@mynameisasecret5320]

A very sad representation of school doors

[@rainybopz]

Lmbo

[@cavejohnsonstanaccount4635]

2:40 “So honey what you waiting for-“ “shut up heather.....dy stORE OOOOOOAH”

[@sabrinaalbert9119]

Illegal heathers be like that

[@pinkiedies]

Lol

[@saishuu1261]

If they said 'Candy' they would of got copyrighted (I'm joking)

[@valta2760]

That made me cringe a lot 😂

[@anthonysmith3462]

There school is an embarrassment

[@midnightdoodles]

0:39 was honestly my favourite, also the first one but you have to pay at least a tiny bit of respect to Heather C at 2:39 . I mean she literally carried the whole show on her back and made it pretty fetch-

[@TrashistPandaZ]

STOP TRYING TO MAKE 'fEtCh' A THING ITS NEVER GONNA HAPPEN

[@midnightdoodles]

@@TrashistPandaZ No! I won’t until you make a dead girl walking! That would not be big fun.

[@vennamal2166]

the first one definitely rocked it

[@lifeofdesssss]

Who did it better: Riverdale or Illegal Heathers Like=Illegal Heathers Comment=Riverdale

[@lolkayak]

i’m commenting but not about riverdale. they actress who played Heather C in illegal heathers want actually bad and she’s acc a really good singer now. she has a yt but i actin remember the name of it ☹️. u will probably all know this tho just saying for anyone who might not

[@dallia5085]

I love how there’s 109 likes for illegal heathers and basically none for Riverdale. They really screwed up, didn’t they?

[@lolkayak]

Blumelody they really did screw up

[@morgrugyn]

Ok I know it says comment= riverdale but holy heck illegal chandler could be on Broadway, riverdale can go fuck itself

[@Toxxicslime]

OwO