Why did Jesus entrust Mary to the apostle John instead of to His brothers Jesus and Mary Mary an

[@Bread7654]

Excellent thanks for your ensights and God’s precious Word!

[@psalm--fh8lg]

How can someone tell you about God or Christ - but can't tell you who they of you are in scripture - it's ridiculous - would you like to know your biblical God given ethnicity George - I'll definitely show you

[@donhue4546]

@@psalm--fh8lg SHOW A VERSE WHERE JESUS CALLS MARY HIS MOTHER>???

[@kevinwynn6582]

Mary is the mother of Jesus... The Church is the body of Christ... Mary is our mother. Hail Mary full of Grace!

[@AnnetteMurphyger]

Blasphemy!

[@AnnetteMurphyger]

Mary is NOT our Mother.

[@sataystick3937]

@@AnnetteMurphyger Do you also say that Eve is not your mother...?

[@markymarkali]

@@AnnetteMurphyger We are brothers in Christ, ipso facto Mary is our blessed mother.

[@AnnetteMurphyger]

@@markymarkali she may be your Blessed Mother but to me she was Jesus Mother and his siblings.

[@harvelle1]

Wonderful explanation and teaching on this question. It blessed me!

[@stevehardwick1578]

John was referred to as "beloved" and also was the last apostle to die, these facts probably contributed as well.

[@Rydonittelo]

Peter, James and Paul were to busy bickering with each other to look after Mary. John whom Jesus loved was trusted and what a trust that was...... To look after the mother of God during her time on Earth. John was the best

[@fabriziocamera]

God has a mother? When was God born? Mary was before God and his creation? So Mary watched God create all things? Have you ever seen such text in the Bible? People perish for lack of knowledge, and for the lack of knowledge they blasfeme the name of God. Mary WAS the mother of Jesus MAN. Jesus was 100% man, 100% God. God does not have a mother, God was never born, he has always existed and always will be

[@sergioortiz1839]

@@fabriziocamerawhich Bible do you read? I had the Geneva but the print wasn’t legible due to poor print

[@donhue4546]

@@fabriziocamera HEY HEY HEY MY POINT BUT ALL THE FAKE XTIANS ARE MOCKING ME...,,JESUS SAID BEFORE ABRAHAM I AM...JESUS HAS ALWAYS EXISTED,,,, BLESS YOU BROTHER

[@danvankouwenberg7234]

Paul came around years later but the other Apostles were hiding.

[@roses993]

Mary was mother to only one of the trinity God the Son. Not God the Father nor God the Spirit.

[@jamespena4721]

That was some great commentary and scriptures that shed some light on why Jesus commanded John to care for Mary mother of Jesus. It makes perfect sense

[@sentjojo]

John refers to himself as the "beloved disciple" because his Gospel is not his story, it is our story. We are all the beloved disciple. He very intentionally wrote himself as a self-insert character. Mary being given to the beloved disciple as Mother is not an arbitrary detail to show how righteous Jesus is. We already know he is perfectly righteous, making that point from the cross would be unnecessary. These are the words of the dying savior in his last moments, each of them would be absolutely precious. If Jesus was just housekeeping, he could've told John to take care of Mary long before this moment. Jesus from the cross is talking directly to us.

[@c2s2942]

No, he wasn’t directly taking to us. He was directly taking to the beloved disciple. He didn’t place Mary into John’s care because sooner because he was still alive. Quit reading your own thoughts and presuppositions into the text.

[@sentjojo]

@@c2s2942 thanks for your thoughts. Do you consider yourself a beloved disciple of Jesus Christ?

[@syrailemaitre]

Thank you for the time stamps

[@ricknofzinger]

Thanks! I always wondered about this.

[@michaellns2860]

The early Church leaders, Where known as the apostolic fathers. These would be people that learn directly from the Apostles ...just for your info.

[@jerome4775]

The bible, as power and as true and holy as it is, isn’t all our christian faith is about. If you listen to churches that do not trace their lineage from the apostles, then you are lost and your interpretation of the holy scriptures is lamentable. If you are indeed in search of the true Christ, only two christian churches can make that claim: the Roman Catholic Church and the Eastern Orthodox Church. But if you want to be in fullness with the Christian faith, then it is only through the Roman Catholic Church where you can find it, the one headed by the only successor of Peter. Listening to churches other than the two that I mentioned is no different from listening to your barber or cab driver: they have an understanding but the education is pedestrian, at its best.

[@jmdionishow]

I wonder why Jesus didn't tell John "tell my brothers to take care of my mom"?

[@Michael-vj2ub]

Because he had no biological brothers.

[@anthonybrown5701]

Jesus knew that John would outlive all his disciples and that leaving her with John would be less stressful on Mary. All the disciples died tragically except for John who died of old age on the Isle of Patmos.

[@myfourhavanese7574]

So when James became a believer he should have gotten his mother back. Why did Mary stay with John till she died. When Jesus died she was only 15 + 33 =48 not an old woman as you describe. Also you as a child of your mother no matter what your belief is would you just let anyone take care and be responsible for your mother? And Jesus as God who is good will not even be ccnsiderate what his family would feel. He is God of Love. He is perfect and I dont think he will disregard the feeling of being abandoned by his children let alone his family. If Jesus, doesn't care about the feeling of his mother then you better think of the kind of God you are preaching.

[@Emsie76]

John (son of thunder) needed his hot headedness to be calmed by Mary mother’s love, let alone the fact that Jesus probably knew John would be the longest living apostle.

[@concrete3030]

The Bible absolutely says that we are the "seed" of Mary if we follow Gods commandments. Just another worldly MISINTERPRETATION

[@UserBR-v6l]

He didn't entrust Mary to John. He welcomed Mary into the church, where everyone who does the will of God is brother, sister, mother, father, son and daughter. Mary had never visited the disciples' homes, now she would. In her old age, Mary would still be taken care of by her own blood family, as God requires us to do.

[@arkrou]

Protestant hit piece against Christianity

[@geordiewishart1683]

Are you suggesting that papacy is Christian? Funny joke

[@robertcamaj4477]

Jesus did not have any blood brothers. "Brethren" is often loosely extended to all near, or even distant, relatives (Genesis 13:8, 14:14-16; Leviticus 10:4; 1 Chronicles 15:5-10, 23:21-22) The decisive proof is that the father and mother of at least two of these "brethren" are known to us. James and Joseph, or Joses, are, as we have seen, the sons of Alpheus, or Clopas, and of Mary, the sister of Mary the Mother of Jesus, and all agree that if these are not brothers of the Saviour, the others are not.

[@AlejandroRasmussen7]

The brothers couldnt even be there at least to accompany their mother even if they hated Jesus, they at least could be there for her. So if they coulndt even do that…

[@tarjan68]

Maybe they were afraid to be executed too (I've heard that the Roman authorities could be so cruel that they often executed family-member who publicly showed grief over their crusified kinsmen), maybe they just weren't there in time. Doubt that they hated Jesus. Most disciples weren't there either. Probably also afraid.

[@mechelledesigns]

I’ve wondered this as well.

[@homegrownson]

James and his brothers did not believe their brother Jesus was the Savior until after his resurrection and so he wanted his Mother entrusted in someone who Always believed in Him and Fr the reason you said, it was John and Mary were only 2 of very few who were there during his Crufixtion

[@sataystick3937]

are making assumption now? or you want to believe Jesus has no siblings(Mary has no other child).

[@danvankouwenberg7234]

James the Greater, son of Zebedee or James, son of Alpheos?

[@c2s2942]

@@sataystick3937Jesus had 4 brothers and at least two sisters. Get over it. She was a Jewish woman married to a Jewish man. It would have been dishonorable to her to not have as many children as possible.

[@c2s2942]

@@danvankouwenberg7234James the brother of Jesus, you know, the one Paul addressed as “James, the brother of Jesus.”

[@danvankouwenberg7234]

@@c2s2942 Does your Bible have Matthew 1 in it?

[@lyndavonkanel8603]

Mary did not have other sons.

[@rebeccachambers419]

Didn’t Mary and Joseph teach their other children who Jesus was?

[@dolladebruin]

We wont know, but I think it so, Jesus was not a quiet boy, eg talking in the Temple...

[@jjervin91]

The Bible alludes to the notion that none of His family really grasped the reality of who He was/is until post resurrections.

[@rebeccachambers419]

@@jjervin91 yes. I just don’t understand that.

[@lyndavonkanel8603]

They didn't have "other children" together. Joseph was foster father to the only child Mary bore.

[@rebeccachambers419]

@@lyndavonkanel8603 yes they had other children.

[@jorgeabatocab]

Amen 🙏💖🎵

[@lamminlalvaiphei6269]

We are having a Bible study on 1 John 1 to 10 and will continue upto 3 letter's of John and the teacher was saying, this John is the brother of Jesus since John has a brother named, James and James is one of the step brother of Jesus rite , but I can't find any evidence that the John who wrote the Gospel, the 3 epistle and Revelation (are one) but, not the brother of Jesus rite, please notify me because wrong teachings in Church can be worst so please help me , how do I respond the right answer so please reply here or upload a video about John biography, when did he wrote the Book of Revelation etc🤗. Thanking you

[@joshn7825]

This video's explanation: 3 minute theory that John was a "better disciple" than any of Mary's other actual sons for being at the crucifixion. So her other son's God given responsibility to care for her was given to a non-relative. Simple explanation: She didn't have other children. Which one makes more sense?

[@AnnetteMurphyger]

Yes, she did have other children who didn't believe Jesus at the time.

[@wesleysimelane3423]

The bible makes sense...it mentions Jesus' brothers and sisters

[@fabriziocamera]

If it doesn’t make sense to you it’s because you need to read the Bible. The Bible is clear in many occasions about the brothers of Jesus, sons of Mary

[@ricardoamaya2500]

The word for brother that is used to show that Jesus had siblings had various meanings when used elsewhere in scripture.. so unless there's a more specific text than that this is just conjecture, ijs

[@bruhmingo]

Lol it’s only a “simple” explanation if you ignore the rest of the Bible. Try doing this with any other difficult passage and see how far you get, say, with Trinitarian passages.

[@novahall5748]

Lazarus was the disciple whom Jesus loved

[@c2s2942]

Verse for reference? Because it John was the beloved disciple. Lazarus was never titled as a disciple.

[@RickyDemetro]

Are you sure Jesus had brothers? The Catholic Church believes he was an only child.

[@rabbit4111]

Half brothers, since Jesus was conceived by the Holy Ghost, and they by Joseph.

[@geordiewishart1683]

I wouldn't put much stock into what the papacy teaches

[@lyndavonkanel8603]

@@geordiewishart1683 I don't put stock in Johnny-come-lately preachers in the 1500's and later say. The papacy teaches what has been passed down from the Apostles and Mary herself.

[@johannbach3180]

How old could Mary have been, though? In her 50s? That doesn't seem that old, unless you're talking about lifespans

[@c2s2942]

You have to view it in ancient Judaism, not modern western culture. Mary was likely a widow and Jesus was her primary caretaker by the law as the oldest among her children.

[@lyndavonkanel8603]

@@c2s2942 As her only son.

[@roses993]

Mary was only mother to one part of the trinity - God the Son. Not God the Father nor God the Spirit. Feel free to provide verses where Jesus or anyone in the Bible did or taught us to pray to dead people including Mary or do rosary, etc. That's not biblical. Timothy 2:5❤

[@dianelawrence1087]

John was with Mary and I don't see His brothers there. I believe James and Judas, His half brothers only believed after He came put of the tomb. Jesus was kicked out of His town because of their unbelief. They threw Him out of Hisown synagogue because they didn't like His teachings

[@tom6225]

Still just speculation, don’t act like it’s fact

[@3424English]

Leave Christianity and lead a happy life

[@donnahageman6289]

Jesus had half brothers and sisters, by Mary and Joseph . 4 brothers and 3 sisters. The oldest , one year younger than Jesus, was born in Egypt a😊nd went on to become an apostle and even wrote part of the Bible. Next was Daniel and David a year apart, then Elizabeth, named after Mary's cousin . Then Jacob, then Ruth and finally Mary Martha. Joseph of Arithema was Mary's uncle and he gave his grave to Jesus. After the incident when Jesus stayed at the temple they sent Jesus to school, lived with, the Essenes for two years, to keep him safe from Herod. Then He went with His Uncle Joseph, who was a trader, for two years where they traveled extensively. Even to Turkey and Egypt and other countries. This changes nothing about Mary's purity and virginal was probably a way to describe how full of Grace she was and always will be. Stop equating sex with denegration of a woman. Shame on you who think that. It's insulting to women and insulting to Jesus and His mother. Just say ever pure , not ever virgin. Also Jesus always emphasized that we all love each other as family. Mary lived with her son James after that.

[@c2s2942]

Give an actual, legitimate, source for this claim. Yes he had siblings. None of this is in scripture.

[@EngelbertWaramin]

My brother, I feel sorry of you. You are confusing your self. Ask God for he knows the truth not anyone else.

[@anthonybonifer477]

Mary ghostwrote for John.

[@stevendrumm4957]

Mary wasn't elderly when Jesus died, she was around 50.

[@retrograd332]

That's elderly in that day and age. The average life expectancy was much lower than it is today.

[@dolladebruin]

Agree it was eldery in those days, besides even if she wasnt old, she was alone, and Jesus asked John to look after His mom

[@markymarkali]

Mary didn't die. Sin causes death, she was without sin. She was Assumed into heaven.

[@wesleysimelane3423]

@@markymarkali she was human like you and me. So yes, she was a sinner

[@donhue4546]

@@dolladebruin SHOWE ME THE VERSE WERE JESUS SAID THAT,HE NEVER CALLED MARY HIS MOTHER

[@MarquisFacade88]

Jesus didn’t have brothers. The mother of God did not have her womb polluted by the seed of man. Scripture shows several times when “brother” was used for cousins or other relations. His so-called “brothers,” per scripture, were the sons of “the other Mary” at the cross. How can you miss that? And you say there’s no proof of Mary being a mother to us all? read Revelation chapter 12.

[@geordiewishart1683]

The usual papist propaganda. Mary was a sinner. She was conceived in sin, lived in sin and died in sin. To say that Christ was born forth from someone unstained by sin is to deny that he came in the flesh. And of what or of whom is that an identifying sign? Anti Christ

[@AnnetteMurphyger]

please listen to this video again.

[@AilynDay1]

I agree. I don't believe Mary's so-called sons and daughters would forsake her because they didn't believe in Jesus. They must have been law-abiding Jews and would not go against the 5th Commandment.

[@AilynDay1]

@SheepOfChrist818 If Jesus had other siblings, why did Jesus asked John to take care of Mary? Where in scripture are those so-called brothers and sisters identified as Mary’s children? In the New Testament Mary is always called the mother of Jesus.

[@AilynDay1]

If they were devout Jews, they would not have forsaken their mother. Additionally, the alleged sibling frequently mocked Jesus, suggesting they were significantly older than him. In that society, the elder sibling was held in great esteem and respected. Frankly, the notion that they neglected their mother due to their lack of faith in Jesus is extremely weak.

[@alvinantony5870]

Sir you are not interpreting this in the right way. Very sorry to hear this

[@prashanthikota5924]

Didn’t Jesus had fore knowledge regarding his brothers? John’s mother was also present at the crucifixion. Mary ‘s sons may not be saved at the time but Bible does not say that she despised her other sons. I do not believe it is Jesus doing his earthly responsibility but fulfilling heavenly responsibility.

[@alephtav7344]

Psalm 62 Psalm 64 Psalm 63 New Living Translation Psalm 63 A psalm of David, regarding a time when David was in the wilderness of Judah. 1 O God, you are my God; I earnestly search for you. My soul thirsts for you; my whole body longs for you in this parched and weary land where there is no water. 2 I have seen you in your sanctuary and gazed upon your power and glory. 3 Your unfailing love is better than life itself; how I praise you! 4 I will praise you as long as I live, lifting up my hands to you in prayer. 5 You satisfy me more than the richest feast. I will praise you with songs of joy. 6 I lie awake thinking of you, meditating on you through the night. 7 Because you are my helper, I sing for joy in the shadow of your wings. 8 I cling to you; your strong right hand holds me securely. 9 But those plotting to destroy me will come to ruin. They will go down into the depths of the earth. 10 They will die by the sword and become the food of jackals. 11 But the king will rejoice in God. All who swear to tell the truth will praise him, while liars will be silenced.

[@EMusicT]

The Bible never mentions that Mary had other children other than Jesus! It never mentions that Jesus's Brothers were mary's sons,never.

[@EMusicT]

@@robmarshall956 look I said it doesn't matter how you understand it. Fact matters whether it ever metions they were his siblings through Mary? Just be honest and try to reason with this

[@psalm--fh8lg]

@@robmarshall956 So you can tell us all about people in the bible except YOU - tell the folks about your people Esaw

[@psalm--fh8lg]

@@robmarshall956 The spirit of God is also the spirit of "truth" let's see if you are capable of speaking an iota of truth - Does God say he hates your entire ethnicity FOREVER YES or NO (Malachi 1:2-4) yet I loved Jacob, And I hated E. S. A. U and they shall call THEM, The border of "WICKEDNESS" and, THE PEOPLE against whom the Lord hath indignation FOREVER

[@dionoram]

Only reason some people especially Catholics deny the fact Mary had other children is because they believe Mary was so Holy that Joseph wasn’t allowed to be intimate with her. To them it would be sacrilege.

[@EMusicT]

@@robmarshall956 I want to be careful and I am not catholic to make it clear. Here they are saying is he not the carpenter's son and his mother mary and continue to mention his brothers. But how are they his brothers, through Joseph or through mary? Since they are also saying his Father was Joseph you need to be fair either all is true or none is true. If Joseph is Seen as his Father then the likes of James could also be his brothers through Joseph the common Father. You will not find anywhere Mary being mentioned as Mother of anybody else other than of Jesus. And Jesus is taking the Blood line of David just like his siblings through Joseph even though he is not connected to him at all but is seen as if he was his earthy Father. So you can not deny that Josoph's children will be Jesus's brothers. It is either take it or leave it. This is the best and resonable explanation

[@StellaLunora]

In Islam mary is sinless and had only Jesus. No mention of saint Joseph. Makes me think Islam might just be what Christianity is looking for. God is one In Jesus Name (:

[@bruhmingo]

Islam is obviously false

[@dsanchez9703]

I love when people are interested in these type of questions. If anyone wants to know more interesting things, check out books by a group called the Jesus Seminar and their founder Robert Funk.

[@factsoverfear9771]

False images on your thumbnail . Revelations 1. 14 15 kjv says Jesus’s skin was black and hair like wool. Daniel 7 . 9 kjv says hair like wool also 💡 Judges 16.19 kjv says Sampson had his hair in ( Locks ) 💡 An Ethiopian named Simon carried Jesus’s cross up the hill 💡 Moses married an Ethiopian lady named Zipporah 💡. Amos 9 verse 7 kjv literally compares his chosen Israelites he saved from Egypt as Ethiopian 💡. Genesis 2. 9 through 13 kjv says the Garden of Eden was in Africa 💡💡💡

[@juri8723]

imagine making a big deal out of your skin color. You are prideful and to be rebuked.

[@ellisjarvis7498]

You literally come here just to post this nonsense in pride? Well done

[@factsoverfear9771]

@@juri8723 If it’s not a big deal then why white wash it ? If a Bible character was let’s say Mexican … is ok to portray him as white ? If you have no problem with color it should be ok that the scriptures I gave show the real looks of the ppl 💡

[@factsoverfear9771]

@@ellisjarvis7498 Is the Bible nonsense. I simply gave scriptures 💡. It’s non sense to white wash what Jesus and the Israelites looked like. That’s why the Bible itself gave references to the race of his ppl and even what Jesus looked like . Is the Bible prideful then ? I say I am correct in saying do not put up FALSE IMAGES 💡

[@chavezpower6727]

@@juri8723 Facts is correct. The bible does many times describe Jesus and his ppl as a black race . I'm mexican and say this. TRUTH IS TRUTH

[@hesavedawretchlikeme6902]

Methinks and believes that at that very moment his brothers and sisters were estranged from Jesus. They did not "yet" believe on Him as the Messiah. Later on, they did.

[@knyghtkrawlr]

Literally said this in the video