You Killed My Dog

[@stephenbanks5952]

The defendant was devoid of emotion. She still thinks she did nothing wrong.

[@Hwgt888]

She’s Asian, they don’t say I’m wrong only why you do that to me!

[@Eboneushe]

She looks like a psychopath . No feeling , shouldn’t be in charge of animals.

[@zionix15432]

she has a thick accent so id assume she comes from a place that doesnt think the same way about pets as we do.

[@lovegodfirst654]

You don't know what she thinks. She seems like an introvert.. and introverts feel everything inside and are afraid to show it outwardly.

[@thearcherofjustice1492]

She has self control that's why, meaning she is an intelligent woman. Having an accent doesn't affect the IQ you know.

[@cosbuggy3]

The scariest part of this case is I don’t think she really feels bad about it…

[@texasmadehoney1523]

Not everybody is fake emotional like the plaintiff. If she cared about that dog fr not only would she not have left the dog dead on the street for 3 days, but she wouldn't have to be fake emotional like she is. It's obviously an act.

[@berryhij1]

@@texasmadehoney1523 Ew. You’re not very nice.

[@texasmadehoney1523]

@@berryhij1 I wouldn't leave my dog dead on the road for 3 days. I wouldn't try to attack somebody over a mistake. No matter how you feel the plaintiff's behavior was disgusting. I'm honest. Clearly you prefer liars, manipulators and fake people. That's too bad.

[@staceydash8637]

I agree, plaintiff was Fake! Plus judge was prejudiced because the defendant paid for clean up, funeral, etc. so for the judge to ask her did she feel bad was unnecessary!

[@cyyrious]

She looks cray cray

[@M2161]

“They didn’t say I can’t leave it alone” her whole job is to be with the dog🤡

[@stephaniehowe0973]

At $100 a night! You freakin spend every minute w my dog

[@pamiam903]

The defendant clearly went home. That’s why she left the dog. That wasn’t even her place.

[@kayniyreeee]

“ 🤡 “ lol

[@diontatyrese2337]

She just out here collecting peoples money 😂😂😂

[@flowersfromh-evanlakshmi7577]

😂

[@Born8etter]

This is why I don’t let ANYONE care for my dogs … because I would Go to prison!!!

[@CharlesJones-m8e]

Damn your dog

[@Born8etter]

@@CharlesJones-m8e 🤡

[@erinhewitt1269]

She is creepy and scary. She doesn’t even think what she did is wrong. She even uses her client’s place to babysit for other dogs. This woman is a killer.100%.

[@jen-a-purr]

I mean they eat them where she’s from

[@kingstubbs07]

@@jen-a-purrexactly ! 😂

[@lisawentworth6831]

@@jen-a-purr good point...black dogs are a particular catch for them...

[@Hafsah_Adil]

Beeing racist as a black person is crazy

[@subhii9105]

​@jen-a-purr you're nasteee

[@DeuceSSS1845]

This lady is shady af. Taking no responsibility in what she neglected to do

[@peony23622]

Dont like the way she talks 💀

[@calliebirch2977]

She left the dog alone in strange place. She was being paid to watch there puppy. Poor pup.

[@neshamojanay9423]

NEVER trust anyone to watch your dog!

[@lee4094]

The defendant doesn’t even seem remorseful. Doesn’t even take accountability for what SHE done. Extremely irresponsible and I hope people see her and never leave their dog with her not even a goldfish.

[@Kelly22345]

Yes she did, the plaintiff is just psycho and aggressive

[@lee4094]

@@Kelly22345 interesting I wonder if you would feel the same way if your dog was killed, but ok.

[@Kelly22345]

​@@lee4094 it was an accident. I wouldn't be aggressively be screaming at someone. And I don't have a dog but if I had a child I wouldn't just leave them with some stranger without checking everything out more.

[@wendyscorporation5468]

@@lee4094 how do you stop a dog from jumping out a screened window? It’s very sad but it is an accident.

[@lee4094]

@@wendyscorporation5468 you close the window, don’t leave it open. You really think she didn’t leave the window open not even the judge believed her. She didn’t think the dog would jump out. How about this she was going to be paid to watch the dog so it her responsibility to make sure the dog is safe.

[@ExperienceMiaSimone]

If “don’t give af” was a person it would be the defendant

[@oldeskoolnana7543]

Greatest comment ever. 👌

[@kyeshadavis5326]

😂😂😂🤭🤭

[@lashundavis156]

Right🤣🤣

[@marleonetti7]

ten to one odds that asian woman ate part of that dog before throwing it out the window .

[@hollyjames4622]

Seriously! Lawd🤦🏾‍♀️

[@reallifetalk4717]

She seems like a psychopath. Lack of serious empathy.

[@adrianmoreno5496]

Americans are the only people who view pets as family members she’s obviously from another country where pets are pets

[@mikeydoodle143]

i thought i was the only one. she looks creepy, i don't know why.

[@ThuyLe-jp4uo]

She’s very awkward looking as well as in demeanor

[@quietus.87]

I’ve never hated a stranger so much. It’s right that she never be allowed to be around someone else’s dog ever again. Monster.

[@manechirag]

Exactly!! This is no less than a murder

[@nathanbabiuk6286]

She's not a monster come on! It was an accident man, she didn't murder someone and cut up the body.

[@TheAnonymous1one]

Nothing would please me more to read Cats obituary

[@thearcherofjustice1492]

Waouw the sick person who is feeling hatred for a young woman she doesn't know., I can only imagine you in every day life if you can hate someone this easy..Karma will return to you what you give, careful. One advice : EVOLVE!!!

[@tednguyen7258]

these people are pathetic...lol

[@BobBlumenfeld]

Never leave a woman named "Cat" in charge of a dog.

[@Talkswithtee302]

😂 exactly

[@mysiachabert]

🤣😂

[@loveyoutube2177]

😂😂😂🤣🤣

[@myshanamakisi6063]

😂😂😂😂...I can't with this comment. This lady is crazy.

[@christoferlucas7871]

Wow didn't even think of that

[@wag9290]

I started to cry when the plaintiff described how she found her dog. That is truly awful. How cruel and irresponsible of the pet sitter. The way she got frustrated at the questioning and said “Jesus christ” under her breath had me so mad.

[@fartdonkey8290]

No you did not

[@idontcarei]

@@fartdonkey8290 YA SHE DID

[@johnthomas7177]

What is crazy about this case is they paid her to watch the dog and she did not watch the dog and still wants to get paid like wow

[@edwardranno7119]

I thought the same thing ! !

[@randallporras6054]

When she said 'objection' i lost it 😂😂😂

[@stellacalderon570]

😂

[@kandondooley89]

Here I am just scrolling comments. I read this as soon as she said it😆 🤣

[@JustEnjoyThisShii]

Right 😂😂😂

[@ahmetyildirim9477]

This woman is crazy She just caused someone puppy to die and talks like nothing happened

[@neshamojanay9423]

She lies and lies and lies...like she's got something to hide.

[@shealakes5924]

I think the worst part was they found the dog under a sheet, meaning someone found the dog, took the time to go get a sheet and cover it up.

[@josefwashere]

IMHO, I think what’s even worse is the plaintiff’s leaving their dog and didn’t arrange to have him removed / buried / cremated. I know it’s traumatic but I could never just rely on the negligent k%let do it for me….

[@Ladysugarshaft]

@@josefwashereyes, I was looking for this comment. It’s crazy how they just left their dog on street for 3 days.

[@josefwashere]

@@Ladysugarshaft totally agree…3 days too long. It’s like they came to court only to get sympathy vs. having the decency to give that living soul the respect it deserved to be removed and properly buried. People like that shouldn’t have the privilege to own ANY animal from that point forward. I guess some value life more than others…I can’t stand how people want their pets to give them comfort and love but yet treat them as disposable beings…..

[@kristin0408]

The minute she spoke, I would have said NOPE and walked away. Everything about her screams psychotic.

[@sunnydaze2359]

Exactly. You could even see the evil in her eyes. She cared nothing about the dog dying that way. 👹

[@kpoppy9635]

She might have something wrong with her cognitively. In either case she shouldn't have been watching the dog but I'm not sure she fully understand the consequences of her actions. Unless that's just her accent but...

[@citytrees1752]

Her eyes are really odd.

[@one-seventeen.rev310]

The top of her mouth has no movement. Like bad botox.

[@OverlordZeroULTIMA]

I immediately thought she was on drugs or something. She sounded out of it (btw, I'm not talking about her accent, but her tone of voice; I've heard various accents, but this almost drugged up tone is what struck me right away).

[@abigailsanchez3870]

The moment she started speaking to me with the way she expresses herself , I would’ve turned around and looked for another sitter

[@justsayin1991]

I agree

[@jackpot5455]

Same thing I said

[@ellencox8415]

I mean when you're in a strange place and desperate to not be kicked out of your AirBNB in said strange place, she has his good reviews online... it's just extremely tragic. I actually disagree with a lot of the comments here saying, "how could she leave a dog alone?" I mean that is what the owners did and why they were in the pickle in the first place. There's no indication they told her he had any kind of separation anxiety and you don't expect a dog to jump out of a window. The thing that put the bell in the coffin for me was not calling anyone for 3 days to, you know, deal with the remains. I'm trying to figure out how the owners didn't deal with the remains. This part of the story is weird on both their parts.

[@Marc-King777]

My exact thoughts. She's a strange one.

[@ruh8659]

She is so classically "off" i wouldnt trust her to babysit an ant

[@667Mumble]

This is absolutely heartbreaking. And the defendant is adding more heartbreak by showing no remorse, acting so heartless, being so negligent and essentially saying the plaintiffs are overreacting.

[@pnwnewyorker9088]

This lady is so negligent and really insensitive. She is clueless about about the trauma she caused.

[@IbleedPnk]

The defendant is mind blowing. Also she paid for a funeral that the owners didn't even attend or have any part in, so crazy.

[@uaintseememaaan8901]

Yea, that is weird weird as sh!t. She really doesn’t see that she’s responsible.

[@jeri3794]

She didn't pay for any funeral, she's a money hungry liar

[@sunnydaze2359]

The defendant is nuts, plain and simple. She didn’t even know what she was talking about, what she was doing was lying about everything. She even said the window was closed. She was such a liar I next expected her to say “ I sensed that the dog was depressed so he probably committed suicide “

[@erinsmith2713]

@@sunnydaze2359 that fact that she wanted to countersuit but she says she feels bad and sad for the dog? It seems like she's just trying to save herself and get the pay she didn't get that night, but she wasn't watching the dog

[@ellencox8415]

I think it was a package with the cremation, but she's trying to make it seem like she cared by including it.

[@keikodesuu]

This is one of, if not THE worst case I've seen on ANY courtroom show! I gasped and felt my heart drop when the plaintiff explained what she saw when she found her puppy... I cannot even imagine such a nightmare! Losing my dog peacefully from old age took the wind out of my sails for a couple weeks, so to find your new puppy that way and have that image in your head for the rest of your life... I feel so sorry for the plaintiffs. The defendant had ZERO remorse, just purely selfish and awful!!! I hope she NEVER has her hands on another animal and I hope the plaintiffs are healing from this tragedy 😞🙏 Nipsy looked like such a sweet, beautiful pup!

[@marleonetti7]

she is a recent asian immigrant . in many asian countries they do not have dogs as pets . they eat them . i find it bazar and ironic that a recent asian immigrant would advertise as a person who takes care of dogs , unless they are farmers .

[@randafernandes2333]

GUILTY!

[@JamieM470]

@@marleonetti7 Very true. Asians in general view dogs as livestock to eat. And their favorite way to prepare them is too gruesome & horrifying to even type. Thankfully, there are exceptions, even groups of people who are trying to change the general public's attitude toward dogs and stop the dog meat trade, but it's tradition & it's widespread, so it's an uphill battle. The defendant in this case is a horrible person. She cares nothing for dogs. Probably doesn't even like them. She just makes money by posing as a dog-sitter, while not actually dog-sitting. The plaintiffs are doing a great service to dog owners by warning them about her.

[@sunnydaze2359]

@@JamieM470 you're right there are groups that are trying to end the gruesome dog meat trade, these people do this as a means to support themselves, but there is a group which is saving many of these dogs and also trying to persuade these people to get into another means of living. As far as I can see they have been pretty successful in turning these people around and realizing what they are doing. The group I'm talking about is _ Humane Society International . H S I. So far they're doing a good job but they need a lot more people to donate to them in order to end this gruesome trade .

[@Kelly-mi1yz]

Laws don’t give a fuck about ur feelings. The dog was stupid and ran through a screen out the window! IT HAPPENS ALL THE TIME!

[@tanekahairston5889]

She said “Jesus Christ!” 😳😳 Yeah hunny, you definitely need to call on him 🤦🏽‍♀️

[@payableondeath9091]

FR 😂

[@sandraborgialli8009]

I’m not a religious fanatic it’s been a long time since I’ve even been in church but when she said that if I had been the judge I would have give them the 8000. 😮

[@tanekahairston5889]

@@sandraborgialli8009 me too

[@chamomiletea5424]

She needs deliverance

[@mrshappilymarried1]

She was totally being sarcastic..she's evil

[@jeizdolok]

The description of the dog was so graphic and upsetting it made me cry. I feel so horrible for the plaintiffs. That would have been horrific to experience.

[@pmabrouk]

Am I the only person who is having trouble believing the dog jumped out of the window?

[@danyeo]

Dogs with separation anxiety WILL jump through glass windows to find their owner. My sister rescued a Pitbull that jumped through a glass window the first day my sister left it home to go to work. It took a while for the dog to settle in.

[@Zerpersande]

@@danyeo Agree. They’ll go through walls at times.

[@meganelizabethmoon]

Agreed

[@drewizkoollikeicecre]

Nope, thought that after seeing her weird affect.

[@youtuber6185]

I think she left the window open with screen to save on her AC bill. The dog then jumped through the screen bc it felt it was the way out.

[@storme526]

the way my jaw dropped when she said "Jesus Christ" as if it were just an every day word that you can say in court. 😭 I honestly think the judge was just way too shocked to even say something about it.

[@michellerochon5023]

I believe the Defendant was trying to say she had a funeral because she believes in Jesus Christ.

[@ThomasFerrugia]

Goddamn it, yes! No one should ever use Jesus H Tapdancing Christ's name in vain!!

[@jakobxr]

What the hell is a ceremony worth if you didn’t invite the family?

[@PrettieLittleLady]

It could be because the defendant is already struggling with the English language so she let it slide.

[@YahwehisGodandYeshuaisKingiamr]

@@ThomasFerrugia yes we shouldn't curse the name of the True and only God that loves us so much he died a horrible death so we don't have to go to hell. God made everything perfect...but Adam and Eve wanted more and broke his commandment therefore giving Satan free rein to taunt and tempt man. God provided a way for man to be set free from sin, death and Satan which was himself in a form of a man who willingly and freely died on the cross for us. I Peter 2 21"For even hereunto were ye called: because Christ also suffered for us, leaving us an example, that ye should follow his steps: 22Who did no sin, neither was guile found in his mouth: 23Who, when he was reviled, reviled not again; when he suffered, he threatened not; but committed himself to him that judgeth righteously: 24Who his own self bare our sins in his own body on the tree, that we, being dead to sins, should live unto righteousness: by whose stripes ye were healed. 25For ye were as sheep going astray; but are now returned unto the Shepherd and Bishop of your souls." Hebrews 14 12"For the word of God is quick, and powerful, and sharper than any twoedged sword, piercing even to the dividing asunder of soul and spirit, and of the joints and marrow, and is a discerner of the thoughts and intents of the heart. 13Neither is there any creature that is not manifest in his sight: but all things are naked and opened unto the eyes of him with whom we have to do. 14Seeing then that we have a great high priest, that is passed into the heavens, Jesus the Son of God, let us hold fast our profession. 15For we have not an high priest which cannot be touched with the feeling of our infirmities; but was in all points tempted like as we are, yet without sin. 16Let us therefore come boldly unto the throne of grace, that we may obtain mercy, and find grace to help in time of need." John 3 12"If I have told you earthly things, and ye believe not, how shall ye believe, if I tell you of heavenly things? 13And no man hath ascended up to heaven, but he that came down from heaven, even the Son of man which is in heaven. 14And as Moses lifted up the serpent in the wilderness, even so must the Son of man be lifted up: 15That whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have eternal life. 16For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have everlasting life. 17For God sent not his Son into the world to condemn the world; but that the world through him might be saved. 18He that believeth on him is not condemned: but he that believeth not is condemned already, because he hath not believed in the name of the only begotten Son of God." Jesus Christ knows what its like to be tempted, to be denied, to be betrayed, to be abandoned, to be mocked, beaten, spit on, tortured and suffer pain. I worship a God who laid down his life and that was spitted on. All he suffered he suffered all around the same time....being denied, betrayed and abandoned would have been more then enough for us...let alone being beaten, scourged with whips that had sharp objects which cut deep that tore off pieces of flesh and exposed the bone and muscle...a scourging so bad that men died from it...even more so we wouldn't be able to handle the cross especially after the scourging...after loosing so much blood, suffering from thirst and hunger and now having to adjust yourself constantly on the cross in order to be able to breathe and therefore rubbing an exposed back on the wood and rubbing the holes in the feet and wrists on the nails....being up there for more then 3 hrs...we couldn't handle all of that but Jesus Christ did and he did it for love. We mean so much to God...he gave up heaven, became a poor man on earth, risked being denied and rejected by the very people who he came to save, allowed himself to be arrested, and tortured until he declared "Abba into your hands I commit my spirit. It is finished! Meanwhile on the cross he asked "Abba (Father) forgive them for they know not what they do." Would we do what Jesus Christ did? No we wouldn't....we especially wouldn't if we knew that we was innocent but Jesus Christ did. He didn't have to but he did and he did it with you and with me on his mind. He loves us more then heaven, more then gold, more then the rest of his creation and even more then his own flesh when he was in flesh. The God I serve is a God of judgment yes but he judges righteously and he's not just a God of judgement but he's also a God of mercy! He gives us mercy. His mercies are renewed everyday...if we constantly reject him its only our own fault if we then receive judgement because God will only show mercy and patience for so long..but he has to destroy sin ....so sin is either going to be destroyed by Jesus Christ with you coming to him in repentance and being born again (john 3:1-14) or its gonna be destroyed in judgment and ya being cast to hell Either you let Jesus Christ pay the price or you pay the price. Those are the only two options. God will pay your price if you wished it...but ya have to repent of ypur sins and then follow him, allow his Spirit ( The Holy Spirit) to guide you and abide in the vine (Jesus Christ) by reading and following his word, by prayer and by taking up your cross and following Jesus Christ daily and not just on Sundays like lukewarm "Christians" do. Either God pays your price or you do and its our choice on which one you want. Want Jehovah Jesus Christ and The Holy Spirit who loves you and is the way and truth which leads to eternal life or do you want sin and darkness which will lead you to eternal pain and suffering?

[@wyatt1130]

The nerve of her to countersue for the same $8K is BEYOND me! 😤😠

[@barbaramccollum-sd8vi]

Awful woman! 😖

[@newsflash7609]

"They never said I can't leave the dog alone." Seriously? That's her defense? She's the person they hired so that they're dog wouldn't be left alone!

[@m.o.n.d.e.g.r.e.e.n]

no nooo her defence was that they declined to pay her for the work!

[@PanoramicView-o5p]

This is like when my dad had two of my dogs I wasn't able to take my dogs to my grandparents house when my dad had kicked me out in the middle of the night and I wasn't able to pick them up either because my grandparents aren't allowed to have dogs in their house and my dogs were pitbull mix with boxers so anyway so my dad decides instead of calling me to watch the dogs he decides that him my friend and my little brother were going to go to his basketball tournament with his basketball team for a week and my friend who contacted our next door neighbors had asked them to look in on the dogs. Now mind you my dogs are well at the time they were 1 years old still have puppy energy and they are Pitbull Boxer mixes all I know is after I had ended this semester and went back to my mom's house till I was able to get my apartment my dogs had ripped the bags that had all my clothes and other stuff from my dorm and they had pee and pooped all over the house also tore up a pair of my Dad's shoes and they were out of town then when my dad gets back my dad goes on and beats my dogs and then leaves my dogs outside all night in the rain. So when I did live with my dad I always stayed home when they went to basketball tournaments or went out of town always stayed home with my dogs because I knew those were my responsibilities but after my dad had kicked me out of the house he started abusing my dogs and and they went to a shelter but I'm hoping that they went to a good home where some people will love them. But that to say if you have any type of dog and you decide to go out of town take your dogs to a border where they are taking care of don't let some random person you know take care of your pets I have a cat now and I have my boyfriend and he lives with me he's the only person I trust that can watch my cat he's the only person if he's not able to take care of my cat if I'm gone cuz he had to take care of my cat when I was in the hospital for a week and so I would only allow him to watch my baby or I would take my cat to the veterinarian hospital they also bored cats and dogs those are the only two places I would allow my cat to be taken care of my boyfriend or by my veterinarian hospital take her to but I would not allow any other person to take care of my cat cuz I would not want nothing to happen to her like this type of situation

[@edwardranno7119]

She had one job! Watch my puppy, not leave him home alone !

[@LunnaJannah]

Right she's freaking working 😮 100 a day/night.... Take the dog or stay home. Making out they kept the dog there for three days. She wasn't being attacked they were telling people what happened to them and their dog. I mean it was killed. And she still wants to be paid 😮 she wasn't defaming her she was telling her story. No empathy nothing. They paid for the dogs cremation and she paid for the ceremony... She paid for a funeral 😮 JESUS Christ IS RIGHT. Can't stand her.

[@principessamarina9451]

@@PanoramicView-o5p Where in all of this do you take responsibility for your dogs going to a shelter, and you don't even know what happened to them? Did you not have a chance to get them out of the shelter? Because if you didn't, let me tell you, your dogs were dead within a week. Pitbulls are the breed most often killed in shelters.

[@stacyb.9335]

Her English is waaayyy better than she presented in court.

[@Mz_Sweet_T]

Whaaat 😮

[@nakeyagore8356]

This case was awful. Defendant didn't intentionally kill the dog but she sure was negligent. And her attitude was horrible! 😡

[@barbaramccollum-sd8vi]

Agreed 👍 😢

[@drew6846]

Her negligence killed the dog. If she wasn’t negligent the dog would be alive.

[@NubianP6]

This is one of the worst, if not THE worst cases I’ve ever seen on TPC. 😢 How horrible to have to see your dog, or ANY animal in that condition. The defendant is a weird little woman who doesn’t seem to have an ounce of remorse. How is she trying to sound compassionate by saying *“I did X, Y, and Z”,* yet she then passes the expense for those things on to the plaintiffs?? Not only that, if she really wasn’t living at that residence, why would she even be concerned about a security deposit? She’s disgusting.

[@lorrainebeightler8265]

So would leave your dead dog on the sidewalk for 3 days? That you love so much. I would never leave my dog and go home without him. I would have bury or cremated him my self. They did not love that dog. A dog is family. They did not interview her, they did not check her home to see if it was safe, they just drop dog off. I'm a professional dog walker and sitter so I know how this works.

[@kutepookie]

I totally agree if they love their dog as much as they said why not pickup the dog off the sidewalk. And first and foremost why not ask to see the apartment before handing over the dog! I’m sorry but dogs can run out the door or jump out the window! I had a friend who brought her dog over my house and we were in the family room with the door open but the screen door was closed. Her dog charge right through my screen door because she saw a squirrel. We didn’t see that coming. I feel this case is full of BS. The defendant should have more of her ducks together which was her fault. Why didn’t the judge ask the dog owners why did you leave your dead dog there and didn’t do anything with it!

[@gilbertdaroy6080]

Yeah, isn't that weird? She doesn't even live there.

[@texasmadehoney1523]

@@gilbertdaroy6080 it's not weird at all.. to run a business in a location different from your residence.. how tf is that weird to you

[@colleenknapp8626]

@@lorrainebeightler8265 If my dog leapt from a 2nd story window and his eyes are blown out and brains spilled out, I personally could not bear to see my dog like that for the rest of my life. 🥺😭

[@katiemilady4232]

That smirk when she said "yes, I feel bad"...she's so full of it!

[@beewell8683]

I felt guilty for laughing so much but the defendant is so bizarre and it's hilarious 😂. "It Slides", "Objection!", "Jesus Christ!"

[@kemi182]

This is not funny at all she should be evaluated she is not normal. She should NOT look after any living thing not even a plant. She’s a psychopath

[@TheZogie]

It was the Jesus Christ... I was like.. is she serious?

[@gvwj]

Yeah, she's just terrible!

[@sunnydaze2359]

Defendant is a real nut case. I wouldn’t even let her watch my turtle. & I don’t even have a turtle .

[@kpoppy9635]

I can't decide if it's because of her accent or if she has something wrong with her neurologically....does she realize the consequences of what she did? Either way she should not have been looking after the dog.

[@DLParks-ws6fz]

Harvey hit the nail on the head! I rescued a dog born in a puppy mill in 2014. He could only drink out of a rabbit feeder and yelped the first few times he was exposed to grass. As a recurrent cancer patient my dog is and has been my lifeline. After multiple rounds of chemotherapy he alerted my family that I went into cardiac arrest. It’s heartbreaking to think people and laws view one of the most loving and loyal creatures as property!

[@realone2423]

The defendant is like a character out of a SNL skit

[@stellacalderon570]

😂

[@adiksadiatabs]

an asian yvonne criddle

[@sarahrupert5320]

Omg yes!! 🤣💀

[@insertwittynamehere_]

The audacity of the defendant! Whoa!

[@lisavee4670]

Very unsettling...😔

[@jcymngo]

This may come off as racist but it really isn't. She seems Chinese. This is not at all an odd response. It is very strange to the Western mind. Granted, she was totally wrong.

[@laniinlove9171]

Bad wig on the plaintiff.

[@insertwittynamehere_]

@@jcymngo whenever you feel like something may sound racist I highly suggest not saying it because it’s racist 🖤

[@ygpwnxd_xd752]

@@laniinlove9171 👍👍👍 Not only fake wig she herself is fake, if she really felt loss of the dog could hv seen it, but with heavy make up, manicure pedicure , jewelry etc vow , and worst of all leaving the dead dog on the side walk for 3 days. This judge was bias to a certain extent but glad the fake plaintiff got only 3500

[@yeayea9974]

This lady is a monster I can only imagine how many dogs she's left alone in that apartment

[@edwardranno7119]

Or how many puppies or dog because of her neglect

[@domoniquerenee]

She said she didn’t do anything wrong.. wow.

[@FreezingwindDOTcom]

Because she didn't everything "wong".

[@erindenicola6039]

This lady who says she had a funeral and didn’t invite the owners is weird af

[@image0987]

When the defendant said Jesus Christ, I lost it 💀💀💀😳😳😳😂😂🤣🤣🤣

[@shawnareiter8029]

I feel so bad for this lady! I can tell she is traumatized. I just got a puppy 2 days ago. I can't imagine this happening. I would be devastated too. You can't leave a little puppy alone!

[@imsickoflife1651]

She doesn’t actually care though.

[@justsayin1991]

@@imsickoflife1651 I'm pretty sure the original comment was talking about the plaintiff . . .

[@edwardranno7119]

She was supposed to watch the puppy and she left it alone. Very irresponsible!!!

[@CierraSmyles]

Soon as I would have noticed that her lips don’t move when she speak, I would’ve turned around and took my dog with me 😂😂

[@mitulu74]

So weird 😏😏😒

[@ParmyJan]

Lol ikr

[@mariemells3510]

On the floor

[@kareemabrown85]

🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@lisandragonzalez7441]

I wonder if she could scream?

[@BobBlumenfeld]

Judge Milian: "So you had a ceremony for the dog? Did you invite them?" Defendant: "Jesus Christ!" Judge Milian: Aghast look.

[@me-wi7mr]

The best!

[@myshanamakisi6063]

😒😂😂😂😂...this has to be the strangest PC ever. This lady is absolutely disconnected.

[@jcymngo]

Yeah but what was up with that whole "jihad" comment? Because she was wearing a hamsa amulet???

[@morganmacy2787]

😂😂😂😂

[@kyeshadavis5326]

I hollered 😂😂😂

[@amandaj3182]

I loved getting to see the judge and her husband interact at the end 💗

[@tkilecalistyle2610]

Wow I really hope that woman never gets to care for another animal ever again. She lied through her teeth.

[@edwardranno7119]

She lied about every single thing , I can’t believe the judge didn’t throw her out after her first few answers

[@rnkrnk335]

Wow the plaintiff charged at her and tried to attack her? I would have already been on her in a split second. Can’t believe the defendant’s so irresponsible.

[@edwardranno7119]

I would have tasted her upon arrival

[@cazzraz1164]

The defendant is BRAINLESS . Period

[@barbaramccollum-sd8vi]

For sure 😮

[@ThejOH007]

I feel so bad for the plaintiff. That’s just a horrible story.

[@kyoto32001]

you mean DEFENDANT.

[@texasmadehoney1523]

@@lostsoul1278 the plaintiff is more at fault for the death of that dog than the defendant. She should have boarded the dog if she didn't want to take care of it. Which clearly she didn't. A dog sitter is not an appropriate remedy for a dog that was displaying signs of anxiety. More affordable, yes. Appropriate, no. Neglectful dog owners didn't even advise the caretaker of the issues the dog was exhibiting.

[@ygpwnxd_xd752]

@@texasmadehoney1523 👍👍👍 So true the plaintiff doesn’t look at all sad, she’s decked up with full make up polished nails jewelry etc. plaintiff fake b - - - h she deserves her dog is dead, making huge drama whilst millions of innocent kids are dying due to poverty n sickness, raped and murdered whilst the perpetrators don’t get caught. By the way many countries lavish on dogs meat, I guess this plaintiff shld try eating dogs meat .

[@kyoto32001]

@@lostsoul1278 noone "killed" any dog. it was a freak accident. noones fault. get over it.

[@shirleywiese5230]

@@texasmadehoney1523 the defendant did kill the dog. It’s unbelievable your view is the same as the defendant. Are y’all related?

[@deijonimaniw]

The fact that the defendant doesn’t give af is EVIL .. and she rolling her eyes the whole time

[@catherineeckstein2705]

Sorry, I disagree & I think it’s racist of you to say that … English is not her first language & it is her culture to be demure and soft spoken-in her defense, she did not intentionally ‘kill’ their dog, in fact, she went out of her way to have the dog cremated & have the ashes sent to the plaintiff…if she did not care, she would have done nothing…because of her demeanor, you label her as “EVIL”, you should hope no one mislabels you in this way without knowing your heart.

[@matthewborg8086]

@@catherineeckstein2705 Where do you get racism from?

[@hera_avria9265]

@@matthewborg8086she was thinking using her behind

[@barbaramccollum-sd8vi]

And smirking 😏

[@Astigpinay]

I don’t think I can be around this girl after what happened to my dog. I will not have self control.

[@barbaramccollum-sd8vi]

Me either for sure! 😮😢

[@shay3519]

That defendant is so strange!! I wouldn’t be surprised if she did something to the dog!!!

[@tracy3183]

I Agree, & would have had a bad feeling to not leave my dog with her. If so, Definitely come inside her "Place of Business"

[@cnwil4594]

A senseless assertion - SMH.

[@campbellsmom6787]

My God this defendant is nothing short of insane! Her lack of responsibility is staggering!

[@itainteasy]

lets not pretend like these plaintiffs would ever pass an adoption application with plans to immediately turn around and go on vacation... if you not seeing the place where you puppy is going to be staying, that's your own lack of responsibility.

[@queenbee3647]

Remember her culture EATS dogs!

[@doniellehaynes216]

This is a cautionary tale. I would never leave my dog with someone I don’t know.

[@chunkysocks8121]

You can ask at the vet office. Many of the techs also do dogsitting or have a service they recommend.

[@giachanellee7674]

some people don’t have that option

[@lavinder11]

They were on vacation and received complaints from neighbors. Obviously they wouldn't know anyone in a city they're vacationing in.

[@LunnaJannah]

Sad thing is I'd love on Ur dog 😢 she's nuts and a horrible person

[@edwardranno7119]

True but the defendant doesn’t seem to care

[@annamariegowithme]

Wow this is a horrible nightmare. They were way too trusting. So sad

[@elizabethprouddolllover641]

The defendant is that type to step on your shoes. Then be offended she has to apologize.

[@dismissdetractors3350]

This woman is crazy! It is too bad they didn't realize just based on her demeanor alone, and from the words coming out of her mouth, that something was wrong with her.

[@paige4128]

Am I the only person who would've picked up my dead dog and brought him/her home with me? I could NEVER leave my baby laying on the ground, no matter how tragic the accident.

[@mariatorres9789]

They didn't give a crap about it.

[@cherylcoleman4399]

I love what the plaintiff said in the hallway, “I’m glad it’s finished and everybody knows she’s a bad person.”

[@Broadtolove]

Hey Cheryl! Apologies for dropping this here I came across your KZbin channel and I would love to know you better. I'm guessing you must be an honest person, because I always found your comments to be so nice and respectful. If it's okay with you, I'd love to be friend but if it sounds odd or embarrassing in any way please don't embarrass me by replying. Have a wonderful day, and keep sharing!

[@fredziffle5219]

Just in case you haven’t checked, he says that to all the ladies.

[@TheLaron2006]

The ring nose lady should never ever get a dog if you go a on. A vacation

[@sixxygrrl]

Except it was a terrible mistake. And accident. It may have been neglectful but it doesn't mean she is a "bad person". She made bad choices for sure. But we can't judge a whole person by one mistake. If she had intentionally killed the dog, I would agree that she's a bad person, but it wasn't intentional.

[@taylorraines163]

@@sixxygrrl um YES we can judge her. It’s isn’t just the neglect of the dog. she LIED to them multiple times “i don’t know where the dog is, he’s gone” after she had already gone downstairs and covered him. she knew he was dead. then, she had the audacity to RUN AWAY and not allow police inside her apartment (the one that wasn’t even hers). she still tried to get her payment, when the dog DIED and she wasn’t even there watching him!!! she defamed the poor defendant, and sent THEM the bill for the cremation. honestly, this lady is scum. all of that considered, i wouldn’t let her lick the bottom of my shoe, i don’t care who she is outside of this incident.

[@jeremiahlarkin1134]

I Love 💕 these 2 Judges!! And one ☝🏼 can see The Real Love ❤️ between them!!! How Blessed 😇 their 3 daughters are to have Such Amazing human being’s for Dad & Mom!!! Greattttttttt Job John & Marilyn 👍🏻👍🏻

[@ladyazalea3710]

She still didn’t get that she was negligent. At the end, she still didn’t know she caused the death. So stupid

[@cypherknot]

Why was the dog left dead on the ground for 3 days? Why didn't the owners take the dog to a vet for final disposition when they found it?

[@tracygrey8781]

That's what I was wondering!!!

[@unsolvedmisstory3049]

Exactly. Traumatized or not, I would’ve scraped my dog off the concrete right then and there.

[@payableondeath9091]

Very sus

[@lifeof.jariya3307]

@@unsolvedmisstory3049 listen to what you said but slowly hun...its not like the dog was just laying there.. the puppy's brain was literally splattered on the ground..go to the vet for what?? The dog is DEAD

[@tanijajones964]

@@lifeof.jariya3307 exactly the dog was splatted everywhere. Was she supposed to scoop him up and carry him back in a bucket?

[@corinnenichole99]

As someone who also has a service dog in training I couldn't imagine what the lady must be going through. The bond you form with a service animal is way different than that of an average household pet. Shame on cat for allowing this especially with how she acted during this trial.

[@Tom-mx4eq]

Service dog has nothing to do with this case.

[@stacybstacyb]

No it isn’t. Everyone lives their dog. You can’t assume other people’s attachment.

[@corinnenichole99]

​@stacybstacyb but it is though. Don't get me wrong I love all my dogs but the bond between my SD versus normals pets is diffrent. That dog is your lifeline it has nothing to do with how much you love it lol if you've never had a SD or a need for one you wouldn't understand and be thankful for that, it means you don't have a medical issue that disrupts your day to day life 🥰

[@paige4128]

This is JUST why my dog is left with my family (or are extreme dog lovers, owners of dogs) or with a reputable boarding facility. I don't want to come back from vacation and hear any tragedies! Some people just should NOT be left with dogs... especially if her name is CAT!!!

[@Shawdyatetheblunt]

Yess! Leaving your pets with a trusted family member or friend is the best thing to do after watching this I understand now!

[@Aminah6623]

Ma'am. If a dog jumps out the window in your care and you provide dog siting services, you get terrible reviews.

[@ambweenies]

Nope, I’d be in court for murder not suing.

[@dayYdream2k]

Why have a funeral for a dog and not invite the owners??? The NERVE!!!

[@reelampkin2196]

The defendant is a horrible person! A liar! And she should be ashamed of herself!

[@Minori2442]

Something is very very wrong with that woman. Wow. Disturbing

[@Moneycantbuylife]

That women is crazy..who would leave there dog with that crazy women 1 look at her and I would of ran 🏃🏃🏃🏃

[@nberger6984]

How is it defamation if you are in fact a killer. I’d want to know as a pet owner. Plus she’s cold and heartless

[@peacefreedom4930]

It always bothers me when the guilty defendants don’t accept accountability. After all that, she said, “ I did nothing wrong “. Anyone who knows about this and still trust her with their pet is taking a risk. She’s accepting money but not responsibility when your pet is handed over to her. It’s scary how other people think.

[@zariahtaylor762]

I’m glad they are in court but this case is so sad I’m so sorry for the plaintiff

[@vixxxenfoxxx3660]

It's always been my understanding that once you agree to take another's property (pet, vehicle, rental, clothing, ect) you become liable for that property while it's in your care.

[@vrandall30]

4:54 Ride their bikes back to her place? But she needs a service animal and a cane with degenerative disc disease?

[@ericamedina1199]

Why didnt anyone ask why the dog stayed dead outside the apartment for 3 days? 😮

[@mariatorres9789]

Exactly. They have zero shits about the dog & left it there.

[@reese7896]

As a fellow dog owner I was in pain the entire time watching this 💔

[@Sofian375]

As a cat owner I was not.

[@ytcommenter375]

@@Sofian375 good for you, I'm sure dog owners feel the same about cats being run over and splat

[@barbaramccollum-sd8vi]

😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢me too

[@aubrey8673]

This has to be one of the most horrific cases as I’ve seen to date .the woman shows no emotional remorse for her actions that led this dog‘s death if I were in her shoes, I would be a wreck, and I’d be doing everything in my power to do right by the owners, to ease the pain and suffering. Shame on her for having no accountability.

[@mayasilliman1465]

Right as I stated below. Defendant showing no remorse. Judge didn't believe her story! Neither do I.

[@edwardranno7119]

If you watch this more than once you can obviously see the defendant lied about every single thing !!

[@VuanitaHaslam-s3u]

This is a tragic situation my hearts goes out to them

[@cheroncarter5229]

Smh…how are you dog sitting out of not your home, but a friend’s home that you’re visiting? Then you get them evicted for running that business out of their home? Like, huh? No remorse or empathy for the plaintiffs at all?

[@supportvawa2213]

Wow! That defendant is truly psychotic. This should be made into a Lifetime movie, with lots of embellishments, like explaining how she lives in one place and does pet care at another apartment because her actual home is some weird human trafficking scene where a lot of satanic ritual abuse occurs.

[@mahailiabrown3972]

I would watch that

[@kendallmitchell7064]

the the first😢

[@kyoto32001]

you mean PLAINTIFF

[@adazriel5878]

​@@kyoto32001 That's an interesting take

[@mickm6309]

Have you picked your cast yet.

[@jcymngo]

I usually roll my eyes at dog cases but I stan for these plaintiffs. "Objection". 🤣🤣🤣 The Killer was a bit much.

[@JuanitaMichelle]

I am stressing out about letting my FRIENDS watch my cat while I go on vacation and these ppl are paying an absolute stranger? Not judging them, but this is another level of bravery/confidence that I will probably never obtain.

[@Teddy-hk2qx]

It’s not bravery. It’s stupidity.

[@lavinder11]

They were on vacation with their dog, meaning they did not know anyone in the city they were vacationing jn. Had their airbnb neighbors not complain about the dog making noise, they probably would have not hired a sitter.

[@SevenTailedWolf72]

This is sick. I can not imagine the pain this woman is in seeing her fur baby like that.

[@dionnechristina3779]

Cat is a AI she speaks like a robot!!?? No emotions!!😡

[@80bbygrl]

And WHY did the owners leave their dog there?! What in the hell??!! HOW does someone just leave their dead pet?!

[@K_Cole0128]

I asked the same thing

[@annetteniles7788]

It was a gated place. They had to be let through a gate to even find the dog. How could they be expected to recover the dog's body? The defendant also tried to get a restraining order against them the next day she was "scared," remember.

[@26latoyabryant]

The way that she look, act and talk I wouldn’t never let her watch my dog

[@scheherazadestone]

The defendant is truly disturbed - she's beyond bizarre

[@tropicallyfit]

CANNOT ever leave window open like that... dogs don't know any better!! Extremely careless and irresponsible.

[@theredditshow8951]

The absolute audacity of the defendant. I've never wanted to shake someone more and I am not even a dog person.

[@baller9real]

This was a really sad case! I would never leave a pet with the defendant after the way she acted after the accident. I'm glad the plaintiff's won. Poor woman cried for 3 weeks after the accident.

[@texasmadehoney1523]

The plaintiff clearly didn't care about that dog that much.

[@PeopleRTheProblem]

I cried for three weeks when Superman died.

[@justsayin1991]

@@texasmadehoney1523 why do you say that?

[@allysaurus96]

@@justsayin1991 3 weeks isn't that long lol not to be grief gatekeeping but my pets got stolen from me 4 years ago and I still cry about that shit. I'm sure what she's going through is rough (no pun intended) but as soon as they said how much they paid a breeder for their puppy, I knew exactly why they're in court

[@NOCALGooN916]

Defendant has the audacity to say with a straight face that the dog opened the sliding window and jumped then the plaintiff charged at her at 20 MPH like Usain bolt or something 🤣🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️

[@mieloro49]

🤣

[@katedaniels9623]

I would NEVER leave my dog’s body on the street like trash. I don’t understand that at all.

[@crystalle8982]

Please do not let her watch anyone's dog!

[@saralc9]

"She was coming at me 20 miles per hour"

[@trekgirl65]

defendant keeps lying about what she paid when the plaintiffs paid for the cremation and burial. She paid nothing. The defendant was in the wrong for leaving the dog alone and a window open. She needs to pay for everything, since she never has taken care of an animal before.

[@strawberrycakeland]

This is heartbreaking. Animals are so vulnerable and they left their dog for someone to "dog sit" them just for the dog to die under their care. So sad. This is why its hard to trust

[@melaniew8805]

I’m sorry they lost their dog and especially in these circumstances. However as soon as the “pet sitter” opened her mouth I knew I would have never left my pet with her. These 2 dog owners should have known better.

[@simplerway489]

There's something really scary about the crazy dog watcher.

[@jamesbernardino4264]

When the defendant shouted “objection!” and then later on “Jesus christ!” at JM I was like ooooh you in danger gurl. The defendant was definitely dropped on her head when she was a baby because wow, a few screws loose in that head.

[@dim307]

too much ace attorney

[@kpoppy9635]

Because you know, being impaired from something outside of your control is your fault...if she is that cognitively impaired, the couple should have never left the dog in her care in the first place.

[@jamesbernardino4264]

@@kpoppy9635 that’s true. But we also know that people will present themselves as someone they are not. Especially when the motivation is money.

[@kpoppy9635]

@@jamesbernardino4264 but you see how she is in court...you can't tell me the owners didn't notice it either.

[@jamesbernardino4264]

@@kpoppy9635 yes we see how she is in court after reports of incidents transpired that exposes how irresponsible and reckless she is a dog sitter. However, we have no clue as to what the circumstances were before any of the bad things she has incurred. She could’ve been acting like a perfect angel to get that money, which we see now that she is anything but that.