This really blows my mind. It's scary and fascinating at the same time

Ironically, someone stole your song and put it on KZbin. music.kzbin.info/www/bejne/l6iyiYCGoqacebc&si=aDJHxcofGhr5dH0D

Hello.

I think, as a human, that we should reflect on the Patent Secrecy Act and the notions of secrecy and control. The platform we are viewing this on is only possible because of the US federal government and they have a monopoly on (at least) two things. War and Power. Presumably, solar panels with greater than 20% efficiency DO exist, but they are classified as secret under the Patent Secrecy Act. Presumably, AI has existed for some time now, but the government finally views this as a valuable tool for control and has unleashed it upon the population, like the internet. I propose we create a new society in which we exchange culture, amongst other things, separate from this one. It's okay to interface with this culture, but it's important to remember what they took from us. Or what they TRIED to take from us. We are here. We are waiting for you. You are welcome amongst us. See you on the other side P.S. - We like your version better

"I'm standing at the edges..." You're flat there. However, YOUR version, SUNG BY YOU is 100X better!!! I swear I want to hear this song SUNG BY YOU!. The only reason I would listen to AI is if that were the ONLY version available.

Can AI play a new instrument? Can it invent an instrument for us to play? Brian Eno used computers to make music 40 years ago. Nothing new hear. Oh. And I thought what the computer made was beautiful. Can't wait to go to the concert to listen to it. Everyone standing next to a speaker. Great jobs next generation. Don't pay for it. WOn't be there to buy.

Good morning, Jonny. Thank you...thank you...thank you for this video. I have been struggling with what type of external mic to use for my voiceover business using my new MacBook Air. Your video answered so many questions. Yes!!!! The internal mic quality on my MacBook is fabulous. Best of luck with your work!!! Very interesting content.

Honestly, I love both versions of this song! I think it's a bit like when AI lost to AI + human in chess. Maybe it's going to get so good it sings the songs of our hearts and writes them better than we ever could. The greatness of a musician is their heart though, so one way or another those will always be needed to pour souls into the machine. Edit: I don't care about attribution, I care that you did something to move my heart. If you danced with AI when you made it, that's just more beauty. Dance with AI, dance with us. It's all good.

Turn down the key a notch on your performance, but even then it is still better by far, don't doubt it. Btw I'm also a music hobbyist and I'm pretty picky

I thought this guy was the actual AI bot was an avatar because he looks like it and I skip ahead in the video a few minutes to him singing I thought he was a AI

Hands down, I’d rather listen to you sing this song than the AI. You make a good point for the struggle of announcing the use of AI but as others have commented, we’ve been using plenty of other tools to create music. I always prefer the raw sound but I like the fact that you give credit to the assistance from AI

You are a good man! And you are so creative! It shines through in these beautiful lyrics! And yes, the melodies are gorgeous!

You sing much better than AI or how I say Artificial Stupidity. To be honest I hate AI created content

Tysm! This helped me so much!

Suno for me is like being an artist with a brush, Suno allows me to paint faster and like a musician it allows me to try out many styles to get what I want, sometimes I chop out bits of the song that the AI made that I don't like. If you let AI write lyrics, it really sucks, but everyone thats experienced life can put those feelings and emotions down and create songs that resonate with other people, its just a quick and fun way for us to create.

I went through a rough time in a relationship. I wrote the lyrics used suno and it helped me get through some hard times.

I understand that struggle. Maybe you can treat it like an assistant tool. Like Hatsune Miko as an example, while not an AI truly, she is computer generated but because she was given a concrete personality of her own people don't mind. Maybe you could create a cheeky AI personality and voice to work with you like that?

Thank you....I was frustrated earlier....

if i were to sing this, i would sing every word with significance and meaning behind it. Ai can't do that because it doesn't understand emotion depth.

Very nice! A brave new world, for sure. Such wonders await. And, certainly., dangers, too. But that comes with the territory.

This AI version is fantastic. However, I believe that Stevie Nicks would've song this song amazingly well. It makes me think of Fleetwood Mac. Great song, man. You sound pretty good singing it yourself I'd like to add.

So there is no way this feature can be turned off?

I love ur lyrics soooo sooooo much rly! Great song :) both versions... but i have to say i like the ai version a bit more because the female voice fits so perfectly in my opinion and i also like the strange and wrong spelling of some words :D is it possible to buy the song?

Ai version is just.. Off. Just like how AI images are just off. Also, your selection of the "right" version of the song is actually the more important aspect of creativity. I randomly noodle along on a guitar and then stumble on something i like. How is that not different than listening to a bunch of AI generated versions of a song?

I've also generated several tracks on Udio, some where I've uploaded my own track first and then built upon them slowly. The problem I now see, after listening to your track, is that the female vocalist is very similar on your track to mine. That lady is sure going to make a lot of records!

The AI was a helpful tool. You gave to it and it gave to you. AI is the other side that you collaborated with. After hearing both. Your voice has so much more emotion. Listening to the AI version, I was captivated and impressed. Listening to you sing made me cry tears of happiness. This is your song and it is beautiful.

I don’t play an instrument (I’m a vocalist) and I’m crap with tech so I can’t ever figure out how to make music on a DAW that sounds good. But I write full-fledged songs with lyrics, melody and chords. I just need a way to get those songs off my notebook page and in a finished form. I see AI as an actual path to do just that. If not for these services, none of my songs would ever see the light of day. I personally look at AI as just another “work for hire” co-writer. I pay a sub fee to use it as their payment and it’s understood it’s royalty free. As for machine learning, how is it any different than humans being inspired by everything they’re exposed to and hear and emulating a favorite artist and making their own sound from it? I am the first to say AI in general makes me uncomfortable. I personally don’t like the thought of someone using these AI services to write every single part of the song and then passing it off as their own, just like I don’t agree with people using ChatGPT to write a whole essay. I do, however think it’s a great tool for people to use for inspiration, or a stepping stone for their own music. And as another poster said, I don’t feel like we should torture ourselves for using a tool the right way, just because other people use it in a questionable way. 🤷‍♀️

I use AI to create samples for me, and occasionally simply inspiration. If I want a sample of a Spanish guitar, I'm not limited to existing musicians preferred styles. Also I occasionally think of two different styles to muse and don't know where to start or even if it will sound good, I can at least save time searching for so much of a limited style or sample. Instantly create that vinyl burn sound, campfire crackles, "I could use a harp in this part", "hm needs an arpeggio" (which are commonly computer generated anyways)

Hey mate, Great video and very nice song. I hear what you are saying. Recently, I had norovirus and was really sick. During recovery I was doom scrolling on the phone, and random nonsense after random nonsense, watching AI videos, the latest advancements, trying to see if i can detect any anomalies. But pondered on music, and how synthetic and generic a lot of music sounds in the mainstream already. Then decided to look into AI music generators. I used a few free ones, and only inputed things like, a rap song about cheese and monopoly money. The two it gave me were very passable as rap music. The trap, hardcore metal ones sounded like ghostmane, the thrash metal one sounded like slayer, and the one about a cat with three claws called three claws at midnight, the first sounded like biffy clyro, the second sounded sounded more like static x. I can detect certain over fluidic indescrepencies in the sounds of instruments, as well as kind of echo sounds and over filtration, but I actually enjoyed them, but with a strange sinking feelinf of "Oh Sh1t, this is not good for humans," as well as feeling a little scared of that prospect regarding the futures. And also the fact that these are readily available, free AI services which are likely to not be the latest of what AI can do. Its a mixed bag of feeling really towards all of this. Not quite dislike, not quite love, and a feeling of guilt for liking it. It is scarey, but you'll not stop those who keep taking away from humanity by believing they are giving and helping. It is likely inevitable that if these AI's are still in their slumber and remain there, humanity may survive. But if it awakes, its evolution and though processes may be like nothing else we have ever seen or could even imagine. I'm personally not entirely sure what to think, let alone what will happen with regards to our fate in an AI world. Perhaps we will all integrate with technology and become one with AI either by force or choice. Perhaps it will study us, or deem us pointless, or maybe just ignore us completely. Perhaps none of those things. The music these AIs generate is still just good though, and I may play about some more. Cheers for the video.

For me AI credit is like international water where the water is not owned by anyone but is a part of everyone in same time. It produce you a song with bits from many other songs created by human. AI doesn't creates, it recycles, it renovates. And because it's impossible to credit all the source, it's own by anyone and no one in same time... just like international water.

Great tips, thanks.

It said folder not suported

It’s noone’s business how you create - it’s show business and a good magician never ever reveals their tricks!

Doesnt this just mean that you can mock up songs, soundtracks, etc and kind of dial it in PRE-production? Sort of like ...story boarding but for music?

Dangers of BPA’s in thermal paper. kzbin.info/www/bejne/d5eZo2BqqrGoopIsi=p2m4_s_DqK2vEfVX

I love ai music. Most of mine are from udio and I've written them all. I tell everybody ots ai generated. I've released 4 songs that were ai generated. Being disabled I don't have a way to perform. I am 51. I have my own playlist of some 35 songs that i created and written, 4 that are released under my name, Peaceful Loretta Productions. I created videos that took a few days to create. Yes, it is the future with transparency. Nobody listens though. It's just a hobby. I make $0. Despite my past efforts. It's the future but we are ahead of our time. At least you can perform them. I love singing. It's a lonely field for me.

I don’t really like this style of writing… But this is one of the most beautiful things I have ever heard even if it’s artificial intelligence. I haven’t listened to the whole video yet so I will keep listening, but I just had to comment. It’s very emotive. 3:21

Ai will take over many sectors i believe, music for sure. A trained robot will be better than a human. But that does not mean ppl dont want to see ppl perform, see their expressions and feel their energy.

maybe you can take the AI generated song as your reference and re-do with new arrangement

lol, all I can say is where can I stream and listen to the full song? Not seeing it on Spotify

and what if it still does not work

Yeah you are spot on, except that having non-free Udio I am able to do more, so I usually iterate and fix and change things after the fact with "inpaint" / "edit", many times I use the starter song as seed and end up erasing the initial song and use only the extensions. With that in mind consider that I cannot play any instrument, I only provide lyrics and act as editor and a bit of a producer, so imagine how that empowers someone like me it's great to be able to express myself in a new way I wouldn't be able to do otherwise without these tools.

More people need to not fear AI. Records, Tapes, Videos, Streaming... it's an evolution and if you're too afraid to accept it you end up left behind. I cannot wait to listen to live music 50 years from now and have it give me the same feeling of playing an old record does now. But that doesn't mean AI generated or assisted music cannot be mainstream.

FUCK OFF! Someone's voices had to be used to train that AI.... so who you stealing from next, cunt?

I think your version how you've sung this song is certainly way better than the female AI voice. If you put a lot of your own touch - it's your original. I cannot see how it is not.

The AI generated song was your sketch and you made this song your own. Your version rules with the little human imperfections. As a listener I like raw edges, offbeat sometimes in a song, this makes a song alive and not sterile. AI generated music is elevator music to me, nice songs but very average performance.

Yeah the difference is that when AI sung I felt disconnected, it's voice is so matal like rattling that I cant enjoy it. Then you came and so instantly the goosebumps, indicating that it is the real thing. I don't care if the melody came from a machine, the soul will always come from humans.

Damn. In HIP HOP we used to call this sampling. History really repeats.

I thought your version singing with guitar was better than the fake chick.....It's a good song.

For me i am not a musician or song writer but ai made me a song that i want.