Empire strikes back se edits are the most justified overall. I know the additions to A New Hope aren’t usually like but that addition of Luke and Biggs reuniting is the difference for me as a kid feeling so bad for Luke when his friend died, it changed the tone from another pilot shot down, to Luke lost his close childhood friend.

Ιt's almost like the Disney Star Wars trilogy is a trainwreck and those involved had no clue what to do.

I actually went to see this in pictures (cinema) when it first came out, not even knowing Disney had bought Lucasfilm at the time. The thing I noticed was the Mary-Sue cast as the lead, it took a while of course to realise she was such, and the term 'Mary-Sue' was something I would not hear about until a long time later, but in my mind that is what she so obviously was. I thoroughly enjoyed the film, though, So much so that at the end of it I exclaimed "Now, that is a Star Wars film!" But it was a sign of things to come. Shortly afterwards I discovered KZbin on my Blu-Ray player and eventually Nerdrotic, G&G, Drinker and others. They saved me....because of them I never watched another so-called Star Wars film, series or anything else for the past 12 years - I kept all my memories and recollections of the destroyed franchises on the altar of DEI intact.

That all adds to the charme of the pre-sequel movies. Without Lucas, Star Wars doesn't feel like Star Wars anymore, because the passionate creator, who deeply cares about his work, is missing.

stop trying to consider diesneys failures as actual starwars movies. they will be decanonozied as soon as diesny thorw in the towel and sells the francise

Where the hell do you keep a sandcrawler prop for 20 years? That's insane

The moment that got me was the teaser trailer for The Rise of Skywalker. Not only do they use Leia's Theme in it, but then they show Leia hugging Rey with Luke's voice saying "We'll always be with you. No one's ever really gone." Bastards. 😭😭😭

I remember when I would have cared to hear this😢

Why did the black guy pickup a light sabre and be able to use it as soon as he grabbed it.. are they the tool of the jedi, or force users.. why dont they just make a million and give to storm troopers???

You call Jar Jar binks lovable? So you are the other person besides George Lucas and his son who likes Jar Jar. The rest of the world HATES Jar Jar!

I agree will all of these. But I don't have two things I wish didn't change. 1. Adding a beak to the Sarlac, in the original, it was just a hole with tentacles. 2. In the ROTJ, they changed the ending music.

I love how we finally get to see some disintegrations thanks to Din Jarin.

Lest we forget how, in The Rise Of Skywalker, there is somehow anything left of the second Death Star to fight in/on in the first place. Not to mention its inexplicable location.

at the end of Kenobi qui-gon teaches him

Disney: “so we need a mustafar without mustafar” an employee: “let’s use the 2nd deathstar ruins” Disney: “but isn’t the deathstar gone?” an employee:”MUSTAFAR DEATHSTAR SAMETHING”

The millennium falcon plot hole is a poor / weak one. We don’t know how fuel works in Star Wars. We just know what it is, that it is deadly when not refined , and that’s it. We don’t know if it’s capable of it just sitting there and being ok or if it it will “evaporate” it’s not like they used gas

A lot of these were created by rian jonson or what ever his name is. The bloke thought he was bigger than Star Wars

Click bait, nothing to do with the Darth Jar Jar theory. Questions… lovable buffoon? Since when was Jar Jar Binks ever loved?

As someone who grew up with the original trilogy, all of the movies since have been utter guff with episodes 1/2 being comically bad (bar a few good fights), and 7/8/9 just being bad period.

a plot hole in a science fantasy film? i'm shocked. shocked. well, not so shocked.

Yeah shit movies, why are you even care? There’s six Star Wars movies and three crappy money grabs

May the force be with you

It's not a sequel trilogy.

Sequel Trilogy Luke wasn't Luke, he was Luuke. Can't convince me otherwise.😂 What a waste of a great character.

There only 3 starwars movies.

A few “dodgy” holes in that list! The busted lightsabre…well couldn’t Leia have repaired that? She was training Rey wasn’t she? And fuel should’ve evaporated on the Falcon, seriously?? Palps coming back, well as hinted in Bad Batch, a plan B was in the works. Thing is movies are not books, they are not meant to give all the minute details. Some things can be “extrapolated” or just imagined. Isn’t that the point?

Remember 99 😢😞😞

They did plan the sequels out. It’s just that no one agreed with each other. So they just winged it and prepared for the last one to be bad.

Really does Doseney (Sic) give a shit it all sells toys to gullible fans and fills coffers

Kylo used a Tie-fighter from the death star. You can see it parked next to Luke's X-wing

3:29 Good job that comic is Legends as it would create a plot hole in the Empire Strikes Back as Chewie goes to search for C-3PO... He would not need to search for him if Vader ordered him returned... Though it might explain why teh Ugnaughts had not yet melted him down.. Though they almost do! I prefer the more simple and logical explanation... C-3PO is just one of THOUSANDS of Protocol Droids... And he is never referred to be Name in front of Vader... So, It was just another droid!

Myself I was always a fan of Freedon Naad sith story

Thanks for changing the wording of these kinds of video's to something less insulting.

Major Plot Hole #1: The entire story line of movies 7, 8 & 9. Major Plot Hole #2: Rey Major Plot Hole #3: Everything Rey says Major Plot Hole #4: Everything Rey does

If the emperor was a clone, why did the clone have the scars that "the original" got fighting Windu?

Disney undoing cannon is trash.

The force voices thing was actually explained in the Star Wars: The Clone Wars series. Yoda goes to Dagobah in S6 E11 - S6 E13. It logically follows that he taught the other Jedi how to do this. The writers on this youtube channel clearly didn't watch those episodes. Probably looked up the Sparknotes or something. And the quote is "The definition of insanity is repeating the same actions and expecting different results." That's a quote from Albert Einstein. That isn't even niche knowledge. The quote has been used so many times. A famous example is Far Cry 3. A game which I know WhatCulture has at least one video about. These writers are pathetic.

I dont get why people were so confused about Obi Wan calling Vader Darth was such a big thing. Its not weird to call someone by just there title. My ad has a friend that everyone just calls Colonel cause he was a colonel in the army.

The disappearance of the clones was already explained long before the Bad Batch series, a little over 20 years ago, in fact. However, that is now Legends content. Although not canon anymore, it isn't like the fans had waited too long for an answer back then. As for the lightsabers, the real answer is that George went with green for ROTJ because the blue lightsaber wouldn't show up very well against the big blue skies on Tatooine. (Most fans know why Mace Windu's lightsaber chosen to be purple, but iydk, it's just because Sam asked George.)

Garbage... Do your research before you go and post some dumb ass shit like this

One plot hole is why Disney spent $14 billion on the IP without a clue about what to do with it.

I get that these movies weren't exactly incredible, but were they really THAT awful? People hate them more than they hate child molesters.

The Sequel Trilogy isn't canon to me. Asoka and the Mandalorian are the only real sequel so far.

24:57 What the frag is that thing made out of??????? Beskar???

18:57 Insane how they brought Saw back. For those of you who don’t know or didn’t get it, Saw Gerrera was a rebel fighter in one of the arcs in the Clone Wars animated series. He fought alongside his sister for the freedom of his planet from Separatist rule. At the very end of the struggle, however, when the battle wall over, she was dangling from the side of a cliff. As Asoka Tano used the force to list his sister up, a partially-active gun from a crashed droid ship locked on to Asoka and shot her in the shoulder, making her lose focus and drop Saw’s sister, killing her. Can’t remember the arc or planet name but it was a very good arc in my opinion. When I saw rogue one from the comfort of my home, I shot up once I heard Saw’s name and just started saying stuff like “holy crap!” And “that’s that guy from the clone wars arc!”

It’s probably been said before, but what I think should have happened is that when Palps is telling Ani about Darth Plagus the Wise, it shoulda have slowly zoomed to the performance which would shift into a recreation of eventa

Ok introducing Bleeding a Kybar Crystal was the only good thing that happened in Star Wars since Disney happened

Ray being a palatine is just as bad as that one person in the Cursed Child being the Daughter of Voldemort Both Palpatine and Voldemort are completely evil characters who would never have children Voldemort wanted to live forever so there would be no point in thinking about the future and Palpatine was doing the same thing every sith did when he trained Vader to take over but tried to switch to luke

7:46 that must be one of the most hilarious moments of my whole childhood, the concept of 35 stormtroopers chasing Han

Maybe it’s just Disney wanted to milk the series for more money?