I wonder if, for a 4 player game if you just house ruled that all egg spots get refilled instead of just some, if that would speed up the game. Some complain that it’s about 20% too long at 4 players. Would this help with that and offer an accelerated game pace for 4 players? Playing this on Saturday. Also, what about the expansion packs for this game? Any opinions?
@johnneeve67762 күн бұрын
Theme 2? Go watch some birds.
@bethezebra3 күн бұрын
I actually appreciate you pointing out the flaws you see or rules you don't enjoy - understanding demotivating play factors or weak spots could influence future designers and designs to not make similar mistakes. I love seeing how and why people want to house rule a game; I'm into the psychology of fun. Don't apologize about that. Also, looks like a really cool little game. 🔥
@theperfectboardgame2 күн бұрын
I totally agree with you! A negative review is my favorite kind of review. I don’t do them often because I spend my energy finding games that I’ll enjoy playing, but for all the reasons you listed, they’re a fun intellectual exercise. Of course, I also have a great deal of respect for the art and the designers who make these games. And I want to be fair and respectful of them.
@HaragothNAR4 күн бұрын
Yeah no, 10 for theme
@greginfla_15 күн бұрын
Another successful board game channel that I never heard of until today. Good job. Good commentary All your comments are relativent and fair.
@CyclonicJay6 күн бұрын
Too much luck sadly. Not enough strategy. But what a great idea to upgrade a dice!
@Ryan_Schlutz6 күн бұрын
Awesome video. Thank you!
@theperfectboardgame5 күн бұрын
Glad you liked it!
@匙曲げ神9 күн бұрын
I checked your website and saw terraforming mars as high on skill and interaction and went like nahhhh xdd
@amjuga19 күн бұрын
Have you ever tried the game megaland? It’s one of our family favorites. It’s kind of like a video game! I enjoy playing it as much as our 6,8 and 10 yo!
@toranar554510 күн бұрын
Are the animal/captain meeples in the retail edition of the game?
@theperfectboardgame9 күн бұрын
Yes!
@homerchristo10 күн бұрын
Funny. It's my birthday soon. My daughter asked me what I wanted : Planet unknown ! I answered. And I have Fit to print just unboxed to try ! Planet unknown is easy to find second hand at half prize .
@Waterh2L11 күн бұрын
Great list!! New York zoo is great!!
@theperfectboardgame10 күн бұрын
It really is!
@alonsocortes234111 күн бұрын
Hi!! I really liked your analysis methodology!! nice video!
@theperfectboardgame10 күн бұрын
Thanks for the feedback!
@pm7124111 күн бұрын
Yeah... I hate Terraforming Mars.
@jasonexperience897011 күн бұрын
what would a theme 10/10 look like?
@theperfectboardgame11 күн бұрын
A war simulation or role playing game. A 10/10 describes a different genre of game. Euro games always have a lean toward mechanics.
@theperfectboardgame11 күн бұрын
I’m glad you asked!
@reksilog14 күн бұрын
Where do you get your storage boxes? I can't understand the audio.
@theperfectboardgame13 күн бұрын
Dollar stores. Sometimes from Michael’s art supply stores.
@thesphyrth16 күн бұрын
Looks like I'm getting myself Swordcrafters. It looks like Dice Forge without being a table-hog. Swordcrafters will be joining Rhino Hero Super Battles for my fave party games.
@theperfectboardgame10 күн бұрын
Made up your mind already, huh? Glad this video helped.
@penguinmanor807617 күн бұрын
Where did you find those token organisers.
@theperfectboardgame13 күн бұрын
Those were from The Container Store but I bought them years ago. Might not be sold anymore.
@MistyCozyGaming18 күн бұрын
Aww, I'm sad I missed the giveaway. I've been dying to get my hands on this game for a while. Great video!
@theperfectboardgame17 күн бұрын
Thanks for telling me! That’s a huge confirmation that I should do more giveaways in the future!
@MistyCozyGaming13 күн бұрын
@theperfectboardgame no one would be sad about that!
@LesPetitsChefs18 күн бұрын
Great review! Thank you for this video!
@theperfectboardgame10 күн бұрын
Hey, thanks!
@gilgalad623118 күн бұрын
Listen, if you like Catan… cool. But me, Catan is by far the most overhyped game out there. I have played maybe a half dozen games. And, I am super ok with never touching the game again. Not my cup of tea at all. Not sure what people see in the game that it is as popular as it is. I’d move the meter a bit more into the luck side.
@libertyprime930718 күн бұрын
IIRC, the thematic reason given by Roxley for the cheap pottery and manufactured goods tiles, is that they are small artisan shops, they did not pay a significant direct role in the economy, however some of the innovations that were made did in fact lead to changes in the larger industry and changes in consumer demand. Thematically, it's a nod to the tiny-scale, but very creative and impactful businesses. This was originally supposed to be conveyed in manufactured goods by having different items shown on the different level tiles, and explained in the rulebook, but it was ultimately scrapped to keep the design streamlined.
@jadehandy20 күн бұрын
Do you have any rating videos or shorts on ‘set a watch: swords of the coin.’
@DWatkins-d9c21 күн бұрын
Just found this channel and I love your website you’ve built. I can’t believe you did it all on your own. It’s super cohesive and easy to navigate!
@theperfectboardgame17 күн бұрын
Thanks so much! It’s taken four years to build what I have so far, but this is just the beginning!
@chasey406922 күн бұрын
This vs Food Chain Magnate, which one would you recommend I pick up?
@theperfectboardgame22 күн бұрын
Brass. But only because FCM is too aggressive and not fun to play with players of different ability levels, so I play it less often. Given players with the same level of experience, FCM.
@TsuziQMadeinTaiwan22 күн бұрын
Will you review this game, now is out?
@theperfectboardgame21 күн бұрын
It is currently sitting on my shelf of “to-dos” ☺️
@rewind_kitsune22 күн бұрын
I played with my fam first time today. They know what's up - I didn't. I like board games, but not really good at strategy. This is NOT beginner or amateur friendly. Complexity is 7-8 at least. Be so for real.
@eddydelrio130322 күн бұрын
SpaceCorp 2025-2300AD by John Butterfield, pub by GMT.
@zacharygritz454022 күн бұрын
Man that shirt is awesome, I want one!
@bocabub23 күн бұрын
so cute !! 😂
@seanmolloy463623 күн бұрын
A few games I would suggest are very family friendly that I have not seen you cover are Dorfromantik and Diced Veggies. Forgive me if you have, but I certainly do not see diced veggies on your website as of yet. It is a great family game as you can change the mechanics of the game depending on who is playing with you. So if playing with a table full of adults you can play the heavier more strategic rules, and if playing with some kids you simply play the generic rules. The kids love "cutting" veggies from the dice pile and building and developing their own recipes and meals. Love the videos and the site, keep it up!
@danielconsta24 күн бұрын
Omg I love planet unknown!
@StephenMatthews-s7o24 күн бұрын
Ben, I love Planet Unknown and that was most concise & thorough yet exciting & enticing description of it I have ever heard. Thank you for using your uniquely powerful perspective in the board game industry to promote such a wonderful (and unique) game. Bravo!
@theperfectboardgame17 күн бұрын
What high praise! Thank YOU!!
@bestatstartrek217925 күн бұрын
Have you tried mystic market
@fiatlux80526 күн бұрын
Great content! My oldest son is almost 7 so I love to see this genre of kid friendly (or non-gamer friendly) games.
@jameskirk469227 күн бұрын
Thanks for the video
@jameskirk469227 күн бұрын
Thank you for the review. I do find it useful.
@jameskirk469227 күн бұрын
Thank you for great video and great list of family games. Very useful.
@chillionaire711428 күн бұрын
Im shocked swordcrafters missed my radar. Might be a complete delight, or total disaster with my two boys (4 and 7) just wanting to battle! Paused watching this video to get a copy. Middle Ages i also want to look into more: i have family members that like Kingdomino, but they have moved past it complexity wise.
@theperfectboardgame28 күн бұрын
I’m so happy to share it with you!
@GabrielFerreiraDOP28 күн бұрын
I've stopped as soon as you said (in between the lines) that you hate Wingspan
@TouyaKII28 күн бұрын
How can the theme can only get two? It has endless character with difference variation.
@theperfectboardgame28 күн бұрын
I could explain what I was thinking, about how my rating system has evolved over the years, but in this case, I’ll just say I was wrong. Theme should be between 7 and maybe a 10.
@purplemicrodot5828 күн бұрын
My nephew's family of 5 kids is pretty unstructured (nothing wrong with that) and chaotic. He says the problem with games is that the pieces get lost. All these games seem to have tons of small pieces. Can anyone recommend a family game, ages 6-12, that is a little easier to keep up with?
@theperfectboardgame28 күн бұрын
That’s tough. On this list, Werewords is your best option. It has a lot of pieces, but they aren’t very important so if a few get lost it isn’t a problem. Also, each player gets dealt only one card. Another thing to look at are flip-and-write or roll-and-write games. For a 5 year old, I recommend Scribbly Gum. These games come with a pad of paper that players write on. After the game, their papers are scored and then thrown away! Scribbly Gum also has a few cardboard cards. Railroad Ink has some dice. But in both cases, only one player (say, the adult in the family) needs to access the cards/dice.
@theperfectboardgame28 күн бұрын
Whoops. I read that incorrectly. 5 kids, not a five-year-old. Nevertheless, those recommendations are very suitable.
@dddmmm2128 күн бұрын
My recommendation is Little Alchemists. My 9yr son plays anything but my 7yr daughter is super picky and not a big BG fan. The fact she is asking for that game makes it a win here. And the game is made in chapters so it is quite easy to introduce to true beginners. Additionally, I would say "Escape the Island" and "Wrath of the Fire Mountain".
@theperfectboardgame28 күн бұрын
Thanks. You are clearly someone who knows their games.
@dddmmm2128 күн бұрын
Tough thing with the "family game" concept is the fact it wildly varies based on the kids age... 5, 7, 9, 11, 13, etc... these are age brackets with vastly different abilities.
@theperfectboardgame28 күн бұрын
I have endeavored to choose games that will hit all of those ages except a 5-year-old. However, if you watch my older top ten list, in 2021 my daughter was 5 and none of the games required reading and all of them were even simpler.
@Exozik28 күн бұрын
Nice video. Now could you do Top 10 friends week evening board games? Seems no one does that kind of video.
@theperfectboardgame28 күн бұрын
Can you clarify what you mean? Like, games you can play on a weeknight with friends? Deep strategy games that you can learn and play in less than two hours?
@Exozik28 күн бұрын
@theperfectboardgame Yes, best games to play on weeknight with friends!
@theperfectboardgame28 күн бұрын
I have a video called 5 Gateway Games that are Better Than Catan. That’s about the same idea. For a new game, I think Explorers of Navoria is excellent. But I will see about making a new video. “Top 10 Weeknight Games”
@gabechase991228 күн бұрын
These lists are so creative! I love how the mechanics are compared to other games and how you show kids playing the games! Great video!
@theperfectboardgame27 күн бұрын
Thanks for the feedback! (And for teaching me Werewords!) I looked at this list again: you haven’t played any of the other nine games with us! Wow. We have work to do!
@gabechase991226 күн бұрын
I noticed that too and am super excited to play more games with you.
@chetil28 күн бұрын
So many great games on this list. And we're very honored to see our game Gardlings in this company. I'm very happy that you liked it 😍
@theperfectboardgame28 күн бұрын
Our family really enjoyed Sparks, too. But the brilliance of Gardlings is the simplicity of the rules with simultaneous play. The tiles are also extremely intuitive. It’s wonderful!
@davidgarza973129 күн бұрын
I love Middle Ages! I want to eventually buy it but I’ve enjoyed playing it a lot on BGA. It’s so smooth but it has a nice decision space that makes it a good evolution for Kingdomino
@theperfectboardgame28 күн бұрын
“Smooth” is a good description. Maybe it’s because while other games might have a turn order phase and action phase, in Middle Ages, they are combined into one, adding expedience to gameplay.
@davidgarza973128 күн бұрын
@ and everything is visually tracked by the position of the player pieces too so turn order is very hard to lose too
@Flip5ide29 күн бұрын
Great list! I have Foundations of Metropolis but haven't got it to the table just yet, I also backed the reprint of Planet Unknown so even more hyped to get that now. Plenty for me to check out from this list thank you. We had Illiterati but for some reason it just didn't click with my family unfortunately, they seem to prefer Wordcraft, the theme is bolted on and the components are terrible quality but a great word game worth checking out. Hope you and the family are well and don't get hit hard with the Typhoon heading your way, stay safe.
@theperfectboardgame28 күн бұрын
Thanks. We are heading off island for two weeks so family can meet the twins. We’ll be in the Portland, OR area, where I was raised.
@theperfectboardgame28 күн бұрын
I haven’t heard of Wordcraft, I’ll have to take a look. I alluded to high expectations for a new game from Adam’s Apple Games. The game is Defenders of the Dictionary and it’s probably going to be our new favorite word game. Had a chance to play it at Essen; it was fantastic.
@Flip5ide28 күн бұрын
@@theperfectboardgame oh thanks, I'll check it out.
@hmmmstvethebaffled772029 күн бұрын
Love planet unknown. Super creative and fun, so much configuration and replay ability. Love the mechanic with the neighboring goals, and the simple fact that that there’s no “turns” where you have to wait for others first. Love it!
@theperfectboardgame28 күн бұрын
Yeah. I’m a bit predictable. Every time I play a family game with simultaneous play, it’s pretty much always going to be a favorite. It is just so much easier to keep kids engaged when they never have to wait long.