This has been my favorite season so far. I consider myself a Hope Valley fan, and there was wonderful moments with the townspeople. I'm sorry you were hurt in the last season. But I think you might enjoy it. Especially Lucas! They really went DEEP with his character. It was amazing. They brought Jeanette in and it shows how far he's come from and how much he has grown in grace, honestly, strength, and humility. My favorite was his understanding and forgiveness to a certain character. (I don't want to spoil it for you :) Have a great day! God Bless!❤

Amazing to listen to this April 2024.

❤

Amo ❤️ Lucas e Elizabeth...Deveriam continuar juntos.

Lucas Elizabeth são lindos ❤❤

Traduzir em português por favor

I won't watch Lucas with anyone else... if they force him into another relationship, it will look horrible. He is too proper for that.

😅😅😅😅😅😅 your review is just the best... I'm laughing sooo hard at how funny and ridiculous you have shown the show to be... I feel better now. The breakup was emotionally draining. But this video has made me feel better...

I can't get over the fact that Nathan has a connection to jacks death... its just so horrible.. Imagine ltlle Jack growing and asking how his father died... and knowing Nathans connection.. come on... looks too funny. Best she and Lucas both remain single.

Oi eu não consigo entender está série este escritores estão querendo mudar esse história mas não vai dá certo eles vão perder muito porque nós não vimos assistir sem Lucas não

❤

I was in disgusted disbelief at what I perceived as an unbelievable shift in storyline & quality of writing with season 10 under the direction of the new show runner. But, the dissatisfaction with WCTH had already begun with the addition of the young woman who was supposedly compiling historical research of past episodes of the show in season nine. I kept thinking that things were being said in interviews that were totally foreign to anything I had thought about episodes since season six, which is the season I became invested in the storyline because of Chris McNally. I’ve wondered if Chris’s magnetic portrayal of Lucas & resulting popularity was a problem for anyone, or the powerful online chemistry between he and Erin as Lucas and Elizabeth. The storyline & writing had been superb under JT’s leadership, & Chris & Erin’s portrayal of their characters as well. Their storyline was the main reason I watched the show. As to Lucas being the safe choice - how ridiculous!! There was nothing “safe” about the supercharged attraction between Lucas and Elizabeth. Nathan, the Mounty, would have been the safe choice! But, I’m not disappointed by now. I didn’t even watch season ten after the first three episodes. The writing was so poor that the acting even became superficial. I just wasn’t into it anymore. Frankly , I’m relieved. Even cancelled my paid subscription to my channel that carries Hallmark. I figure there will be changes in WCTH that will coincide with the direction Hallmark seems to be following in other shows. Done with following Hallmark, but I’ll catch Chris in whatever he does outside of WCTH, even if it’s Hallmark. He is a superb actor. He deserves good writing & good storylines. He has a loyal fan in me.😊 Gonna miss you girls!🥰

Many of the cast and crew, especially the writers and producers, trashed the show and then went on to trash their own reputations with their awful interviews and social media communications. They have been deceptive, manipulative and have shown absolutely no compassion for the fans who feel betrayed. I think of our lovely bridge scenes and realize the show runner, co-creator and writers truly burned that bridge - for all of us. You helped me work through the disappointment and anger I felt at the end of the beautiful romance previously written for us. Looking back, I wonder if Elizabeth was ever really deserving of Lucas and the unconditional love he offered her. Certainly S10 Elizabeth doesn’t deserve him and I don’t even want him in a relationship with that person. Thanks for helping me gain some perspective on the season. All my best to all of you and the other Lucabeth fans! ❤

One thing I just realized is how could E even consider being with Nathan knowing he was partly responsible for Jacks death? That’s how she honors Jack??? Hey Jack you died because this man was being disciplined & you took his place but I forgave him & will probably marry him !!!! Really ???does this feel right.

It wasn’t right. I think they had signs in eps 5-6 with Elizabeth complaining about not wanting a castle or leaving HV. Then, there’s a scene where Nathan is like, HV is where I belong is where my heart is, etc, I think to Elizabeth. His jumping from Faith to Elizabeth again is messy everywhere. 😓 Blaming Lucas for the breakup sounds like it having to be the man who is in the wrong instead of the woman, which is why she didn’t correct them. I think seasons 6-9 were great but 10 is total fanfiction for Nathan/Elizabeth. 🫣 She was running for him,seemingly heartbroken at the prospect of Lucas leaving town in season 8. That doesn’t sound safe choice. Then letting Lucas become close to Jack and even having the kiddo be a part of the proposal. My my my.🤦‍♀️😩

❤ love this because I feel same way about N is all about him he thinks

I will miss you all u ladies have been fantastic it truly been real listening to you all thanks for sharing ❤❤😢😂

I want to thank all of you for your podcasts! I always looked forward to them and I thank you for all the videos you posted. I got involved by binge watching the first 5 seasons and then I was hooked. Season 10 has been the worst--poor writing and producing. There were no real storylines and key characters changed to simply walking into a scene. Elizabeth used to be a strong, independent, courageous woman who this season was depicted as a selfish, narcissistic, small minded woman who played second fiddle to Rosemary. All of the strong women-doctor, pharmacist, business woman, and teacher were reduced to blithering idiots trying to fix each other up on dates! I have no respect for producer Krackow who did not fight for her character-disgraceful. I can’t believe how WCTH has been reduced to a cheap soap opera-- they have destroyed the heart and soul of the original show. I believe that they are looking to take WCTH off of Hallmark. I too will no longer watch. Love all of you! Thanks!💕

I am so grateful for all of your beautiful LucaBeth stories you have woven together, so we can go back and watch them and enjoy! Thank you for replying to me on Instagram that you will not remove the account! I watched the "Heart to Hearties" latest, and when they would state some of the questions, I was surprised they were going to answer those! Until they did not really answer them, they skirted around or went off on a tangent. Or they justified with things like, "That story ran it's course" sort of thing. I commented there, I felt that they spent a few years on their beautiful love story, with Lucas' gifts and lovely dates, and his thoughtfulness in taking it slow. She did totally give him her heart in so many ways, like when she took off her wedding ring, and when she said yes to his proposal! For them to treat the breakup by her saying she couldn't give him her whole heart was unforgivable! They tell us that they gave us this wonderful love story, yet they took it away with writing it this way! They robbed us. They cheapened it. They took away the foundation. I think that possibly Chris McNally wants to move on to other projects, and/or spend more time with his family, and he will be phasing gradually out of being a regular. if that is the case, it is understandable of the writers to bring Elizabeth and Nathan together, guaranteeing a huge audience still, making a lot of fans happy, too (not me!). If they have her tell him it was him all along, he was her true love and future, I could not handle it. More robbing us of the Lucas love THEY wrote for us! There were so many stories they could have told with all the mutual interests between Elizabeth and Lucas! I am so done with this show.

I don’t care what the interviews & after shows say. Something is fishy 🐟 about this break up? Besides, when has a show needed interviews and pod casts to prove that two characters have broken up?? Shouldn’t it be evident from the actual show?? I don’t care what the interviews & after shows say. Something is fishy 🐟 about this break up? Besides, when has a show needed interviews and pod casts to prove that two characters have broken up?? Shouldn’t it be evident from the actual show??

Jillian what is really lazy the line “Lucas was a safe choice” came directly from Team Nathan/Kevin McGarry’s fans. The comments were posted on social media. Actually in 99% of their unacceptable nasty opinions about Lucas, his acting, attacking him personally, they commented negatively about his personal relationship. Not very christian like. This is what I just not comfortable giving them a second chance.

Jillian girl, I agree with you. I think the whole LucaBeth breakup is a ploy to protect Elizabeth and Little Jack. It was too public and ‘unemotional/anti-climatic’.

In season 8 no one was chosen until episode 11.

The Lucabeth Lounge was truly something special. I’m so glad you shared your insights and joy about our couple in the good times. It’s very sad what they did to Lucas and Elizabeth and to WCTH. Thanks for using your platform to say the things I’ve been thinking. Best of luck to all of you.

Elizabeth never deserved a man as good as Lucas. What did she ever do for him? A few muffins? :)

I think its been stated by BB that LS made the change after episode 5 (from the JLJ interview) .. which is why there’s a disconnect within the season. I think Erin was definitely complicit in the decisions. I have seen tweets on twitter of people thinking since becoming EP she has been propping up her close group of friends: Ben, Pascale, Kevin .. Kayla next season with he teased love story in s11 (probably with Lucas) and Lori if she comes back too. Not sure Chris falls under that category.

We Lucabeth fans have been totally insulted with the Retcon of season 10. From the eyerolling when Lucas bought her flowers, to the horrific breakup at the train station. Our intelligence has been insulted. The production team lied to us. Erin Krakow lied to us with all her giddy giggly promotional interviews. What a lark. I have absolutely no respect for any of them. I can't even watch any of the previous seasons now, because I know who Elizabeth becomes. I've fallen out of love with Rosemary too. They dumbed down Bill Lavery. I don't ever have to look at Elizabeth and her woebegone long faces. I'm leaving Hallmark behind and moving to GAC.

Thank you so much for all of the great insights and chats and clips..and for just providing a safe space for Lucabeth fans to hang out. It was a super fun season for all of us!!

Thank you so much ladies!!! Loved every minute! Lucabeth will always my favorite. They will never, never replicate that with E & N!!! Unforgivable and the explanations have been even worse! You are all in my hearts! 💖

This has been fun, informative and very entertaining, so please don't go. Come back as 'The Lucas Lounge' 🙂

So many great points! Loved this. #chrismcnallyfangroup wish I could have vented with you girls.

I don’t agree with most of what you said, but it was hilarious and entertaining! Best wishes 😀

Thank you Ladies for everything you made me laugh and cry. I needed this. They ruined a good show. Made Elizabeth unrecognisable. I adore Chris and will watch other programs he is in but not the (as it is now called) the fire dumpster show. I can not believe after 10 years I am walking away from a show but I can never watch again. You ladies have been so helpful in helping me get through this terrible ending. I quit watching at episode 10.

I run the Chris McNally fan group and I truly agree with you guys. Great Podcast. I'm still very emotional about it all.

You will be missed. Thank you for all you did to support LucaBeth.

Thank you for sharing our journey of love and romance. It was good as long as it lasted. Very sad for that unfortunate end of story.

Jillian should be the showrunner! She has better ideias then the whole time of WCTH.

Can't thank you all enough for all your podcasts and the love and laughter that has always shined through. Although the writing made no sense and the characters were unrecognizable what really "Calloused my heart" was the awful gaslighting they did to the fans who sincerely believed they had moved on from teams and the disastrous triangle, they knew exactly how this all would go over yet chose to stir the pot and instead of being honest about it are being exactly the opposite of what they constantly profess to be a community of family! They have now made it a completely disfunctional family that I have no desire to be apart of after the unbelievable explanations in all their recent interviews! Wish you girls all the best and thanks again for all your opinions and laughs I will truly miss all of you and a show that once brought people together instead of purposefully tearing them apart once again! ❤

I read a comment on FB..Nathan, the “Barney Fife” of romance😂😂😂😂

The spinoff started at the beginning of season 10. They weren't our characters this season at all. Certainly by episode 3 the worm began to turn and the retcon became a whole new story with the same actors playing characters of the same name but with different histories, ambitions, mindsets, and characters. Elizabeth is a despicable character now. Terrible. Lucas isn't our Lucas. He's a recon version of Lucas from a Team Nathan fanfiction. The whole new direction is a bad Team Nathan Fanfic gone live. Hopefully they don't turn Lucas into a predator like their fics do. But this truly isn't our story and they aren't our characters so I'm very comfortable in saying canon ends at 9.12 And they lived happily ever after. I will not watch this show again.

Thank you ladies not only for this insight of season 10 but for all of your thoughts on the Lucabeth storyline. I agree with everything you’ve stated in this podcast and will miss these conversations as well as the When Calls the Heart show 😢

Thank you ladies, I am going to miss you all. I also feeling betrayed. I stop watching episode 11 because I felt like the show was not making sense! The show runner Lindsey is a horrible writer. Brian is a liar! Thanks ! ❤😢

Div, I watch almost 200 shows kkkkkkkkkkkkkk and even so I was very disappointed, because I didn't think that like the other series I watch, the couple that I thought was endgame would end. Because WCTH does not have the ability to write creative stories. For example, I watched Grey's Anatomy for years and the couples are changed all the time and we managed to overcome it, because the stories are convincing, the traumas are convincing. WCTH is a sad joke about a protagonist who no longer convinces and is not really the values she preaches.

Thank you for this! I have enjoyed listening to your podcasts. It's been so hurtful what they did to Lucas and Elizabeth and listening to you guys makes me feel better. Thank you so much! You gals are a blessing!

You talked about the HFR. I was there. One thing that bothered me was their was a young girl who brought these dolls. She had them dressed up as Lucas and Elizabeth. The entire room cheered. The panel thought they were adorable and took photos with her. She now feels like she was used and wonders if they feel any guilt whatsoever. In retrospect, they knew what was coming and they didn’t care.

Ladies, you will be missed most of all. Question: would you all consider a podcast for the HM series The Way Home, or any other series you all like? I would love to subscribe to anything you do. You’re engaging, dedicated, funny, and the best sleuths!❤😊

As a former devoted, loyal fan of WCTH it wasn’t only that the writing for season 10 was lazy and boring, and they assassinated the characters of the main couple, but that the real life producers, writers and actors of the show intentionally misled their own fan base. It was a complete deception of what they told us to expect. They have lost all integrity and credibility and can no longer be trusted, so I will not be watching.

Maybe its time to end the show

Lucas sacrificed everything for the town and not even one person from HV went to support him in capital city. He had to Celebrate his victory alone. And then they excluded him from Goldie 's christening. They treated him horribly. He is too good for the entire Town

Just cancelled my subscription with Super Channel and When call the Heart. I didn't had any pleasure this season watching the show. Thank you for the Postcast I always enjoyed it. Merci et au revoir!