These films need to be preserved at all costs because any future remakes will have countless bIacks shoehorned in
@jedrzejmoleda8051Күн бұрын
Omg, I have DVD extended edition and I didn't know about the changes until now... I completely support your opinion: It is really sad (but still not like Anakin in RofJ, this was outrageous).
@jasonminato6660Күн бұрын
House is what you would call, lightning in a bottle.
@JonasTisellКүн бұрын
I hate Jacksons AI use. It really ruined the Get Back documentary.
@adamroberts9159Күн бұрын
So which version should I buy? Just the HD theatrical?
@oooh19Күн бұрын
No remake! It’s amazing how it is!
@proprich5586Күн бұрын
I'd prefer the movie be remade properly. Probably better made as a series, if you could keep Hollywood tards from adding their stupidity.
@jacksquatt6082Күн бұрын
No, and it shouldn't. This is my answer to your title question. No, I didn't watch your video. I don't want to hear your argument. Go away.
@KlingonCaptainКүн бұрын
The only version I have is the Theatrical DVDs in the red blue and green boxes, and they hold up really well. But I'm glad to hear that it's safe to upgrade to the theatrical Blu-rays. It's similar with Jurassic Park. I have the steel book Blu-ray from before they messed up the film grain with the 3D re-release, and that's the only version I'll watch.
@g.aathoz1211Күн бұрын
Meh, why not bring up the obvious that House in the ending after the fire just is a hallucination, that really he is dead but only exists in Wilson's mind? I think that is what they went for but did not want to spell it out because they wanted to be deep and artistic...
@TheDavveponkenКүн бұрын
My God. I hadn't thought about this. But upon seeing the less graded original I remembered the original experience and the hunch that something what was off seeing later versions. I once had the noisy extended and they were alright colourwise if I remember correctly.
@PressA2DieКүн бұрын
I remember seeing The fellowship of the Ring in the cinema on the big screen and scoffing at the stupid PS1 characters running around in the zoomed out shots in the Balrog encounter. I recognised it looked awful originally. On VHS and DVD it holds up better so I gave the films a pass on my biggest original criticism of them. Funny its coming back now.
@o0oSolidSnakeo0oКүн бұрын
Dude, that was a fantastic video. Thank you.
@josuevassquez7522Күн бұрын
Baby intro got me mad so I clicked away
@c.f.3583Күн бұрын
now I´m frustrated...
@djtomoyКүн бұрын
They should just remake them with some more modern actors
@Dr.W.KruegerКүн бұрын
What are "Playstation Polygons"? Are they different from regular polygons?
@tlotpwist34172 күн бұрын
To sum up and if i followed you well, the best version is the standard theatrical BR?
@Hamachingo2 күн бұрын
You'll stream the ultra-compressed version with little edits to conform to your market and current politics and you'll like it!
@merivial86612 күн бұрын
A year and a half ago, I was ready to pursue my dreams as a musical theatre performer, dropping everything (I was graduating high school that year and preparing the tests to enter university) and going to college in the U.S. I auditioned in secret and got a scholarship for AMDA. By the time I was preparing to tell my parents about this, my niece died. It was a devastating blow for my entire family, myself included, and I gave up my dream school for my family. It was really hard, because in my country there isn't a stable musical theatre industry and I'm not interested in acting for camera. I'm now double majoring in History and Philosophy in my local university, working part-time, and auditioning for acting gigs in my free time. It's hard, but dreams come back to you one way or another. I want to become an actor because I'm a storyteller by heart. And that came back as writing, something I've done since ninth grade. I'm drafting my eighth novel. Giving up is part of the process.
@PeterEvansPeteTakesPictures2 күн бұрын
For a restoration done well see Martin Scorcese and BFI's restoration project on the films of Powell & Pressburger. Beautiful and faithfully true restorations of the original 35mm prints. Utterly gorgeous. (Search for Cinema Unbound: the Creative Worlds of Powell and Pressburger on KZbin) Regarding Peter Jackson's resotrations I think there's a good notion to slapping restraining orders on directors.
@serenityvalley94092 күн бұрын
I think it's a bit of a stretch to say that the original filmmakers don't know what makes it great, buy you do. Instead, it's more that what you think makes it great and what they think makes it great are different. There are things that you like about the original that they might not think about. There are probably many things that they specifically like about it that you don't pick up on. It's very subjective. Something that you really like about it might not be what others like about it. I don't think any of the "issues" you listed can really be judged according to an objective and agreed upon standard. On the other hand, if they started editing the story and the characters, then it would be objectively worse.
@ZerkaDarra2 күн бұрын
Yes it can, but it needs more lesbians and hobbits of color.
@daniejarr59552 күн бұрын
This video was excellent. Now how the hell do i find this fan edited blue ray edition. Any tips or tricks please let me know!
@equusamans2 күн бұрын
20:14 "Everything is open to corruption and decay. Especially what you love most." Wise words.
@feefee10ish2 күн бұрын
No other actor could have played House, Hugh Laurie was born for this role.
@silverhawkscape26772 күн бұрын
In short. Watch the Theatrical Version than the extended version.
@r3ddytia2 күн бұрын
Man you kinda flunked this one :/
@RedwoodTheElf2 күн бұрын
So essentially, the 4K version looked like a leprechaun puked on the film.
@brocktechnology2 күн бұрын
You never give a searchable title for "the fan version". Rumpelstiltskin error.
@SkyShazad2 күн бұрын
THIS IS SUCH AN AWESOEM VIDEO, I was thinking the same thing about the Colors.... I hope more people see this and also Peter Jackson,,, seriously
@ryanwarren29702 күн бұрын
It's interesting to see how Peter Jackson's handling of Lord of the Rings mirrors George Lucas's handling of the original Star Wars trilogy.
@Jacob-de8qs2 күн бұрын
I knew something was off when i watched the 4k. This explains a lot
@ajzeg012 күн бұрын
I can’t believe Reddit still thinks the 4K discs are good.
@Pugnaxxx2 күн бұрын
Meh I agree that I would never want them to do a Star wars type remaster. But most of this video is for the 0.5% of people who either notice this shit or gives a shit about any of that stuff. Nearly every side by side comparison you gave either I liked the upgraded version or could care less which was they chose cuz they both looked good. On a side note I am one of the those people that would like Bilbo to be switched in the prologue. Because ever since the Hobbit films when I see that scene again I am actually distracted that it's Ian Holm.
@jiikor2 күн бұрын
just like Harry Potter movies
@ESF197911113 күн бұрын
VERY-GOOD EXPLANATION VIDEO :) THANK YOU FOR THE EFFORT :) THANK YOU FOR SHARING :) THANK YOU FROM ISRAEL :)
@RobertR37503 күн бұрын
Unfortunately, Peter Jackson adopted the same attitude that George Lucas has toward American Graffiti, who said "the HELL with maintaining the original Superscope film image. *I* want it to look like digital video." Jackson said "I want everything to look like The Hobbit". I hate Jackson's attitude almost as much as I hate Lucas'.
@blackhairverse63613 күн бұрын
This is such a great video. The way you break it all down is just amazing……… I should be studying🤡
@blackhairverse63613 күн бұрын
The sounds Oscar makes when Micheal kisses him is just hilarious🤣🤣
@Mattallica135263 күн бұрын
Boromir: LOTR has no remaster, LOTR needs no remaster
@Gpcas93 күн бұрын
20:27 Love the credits 😛
@AmitBabooa3 күн бұрын
20:29 Brillant
@thomaswolf66453 күн бұрын
Fantastic piece of work.
@meadanification3 күн бұрын
Jackson has explicitly said that he wanted the Green tint for the theatrical releases but was advised not to. He was so happy to finally be able to do it for the re-releases.
@TheUnknownVideographer3 күн бұрын
Film grain also assists with brains suspension of disbelief.
@tocodelray3 күн бұрын
Ah. These aren't mistakes, just choices. The films are still enjoyable to watch.
@balrog477923 сағат бұрын
But without the green tint and noise reduction, the films would look better.
@iamzod3 күн бұрын
16:30 or so I will also note than the HDR default color temp on most TVs is set to warmer, I went in and changed both 4K HDR and non HDR profiles to medium (neutral) and they’re WAY more similar than not. Trust me I agree with you about the lot of it but also it is interesting to see how many factors on the user end can muck up the comparison and make it seem more extreme. Having done extensive tests myself between all the versions on the same setup.
@Knightmessenger3 күн бұрын
It seems to me that the 4k bluray format is worse than ever at getting colors and contrast to be as it was. Why does stuff need all these digital filters and special algorithms to convert it to a special HDR mode? Why can't it just be scanned at 4k resolution but otherwise use the same settings and calibration as was done for the 1080p bluray or 480p dvd? It's not like there was anything technically wrong or bad with the older LOTR scans.
@OhshitPositive3 күн бұрын
I had no idea the extended versions had this tint and now I can't unsee it. Unforgivable.