Dear Greg, I hope you’re doing well. I’m reaching out because I’ve encountered some issues with HDR monitors while using my MacBook Air M3, and I was hoping to get your expert opinion. I started using an HDR1600 monitor from a Chinese company called Skyworth. It has a full-screen sustainable brightness of 1000 nits, a peak brightness of 1600 nits, and features 2,304 local dimming zones. Essentially, it’s a more affordable alternative to the ASUS ProArt Display PA32UCXR. When I enable HDR on both MacBook Air and monitor, the colors on the monitor appear very pale and washed out, except when I’m watching HDR videos-then the colors look normal. While editing in Lightroom with HDR enabled, I notice that some areas, like the sun, appear significantly brighter, which I really like, but overall the colors still seem desaturated. Is this normal behavior when using HDR monitors with Macs? Do you think I would experience the same issue if I were to use the ASUS ProArt Display PA32UCXR 32 instead? I’m trying to decide between getting a Mac Mini M4 Pro with a new monitor or purchasing a MacBook Pro 16-inch M4 Pro. I will mainly use it to edit HDR photos. Any advice you could offer would be greatly appreciated.
@marcburdenphotography2 күн бұрын
Really struggling with this. Not using apple, using pc, not sure that matters. I've created a smart layer, but i cant double press to open camera raw, I have to open it from the filter drop down in PS. None of these new features are there, even though I have ticked use the AI features. Any idea what Im doing wrong? also in camera raw I have no option to change colour profile, it only shows colour or monochrome in the dropdown list. ** UPDATE Think I've found a work around, I have to open the photo in LR first, open as a smart object in PS, then it all works. It will not work if you just open the file in PS or if you open in PS via LR without selecting open as a smart object in PS.
@gregbenzphotography2 күн бұрын
Not specific to anything but the version of PS / ACR. That’s not a raw smart object if you can’t double click into it. See gregbenzphotography.com/photography-tips/3-common-misconceptions-about-camera-raw-smart-objects/
@MrRicardoax013 күн бұрын
Thanks... 💯
@UpLighting4 күн бұрын
Are you using the HDR sRGB color space for IG?
@gregbenzphotography4 күн бұрын
That’s fine, so is P3. Key to successful HDR upload is the encoding, which I do by using my Web Sharp Pro plugin for PS. Details under the “tutorials” button in the panel.
@kobelrudolf17946 күн бұрын
I think there are too many pictures. Half would have been enough and the pano wouldn't have been half the resolution. Less is often more. Despite everything, well done.
@gregbenzphotography4 күн бұрын
I've tried and it fails. Truly need this much overlap. It's a very wide scene with significant lens distortion due to wide angle lens.
@charruaporelmundo8 күн бұрын
I'm jumping , finally to MAC, I only do Lr and Ps, no video. I have this two on my shopping cart, with a 1000 difference. the Apple M4 Pro Chip 14‑Core CPU, 20‑Core GPU, 16‑Core 48 RAM and the Apple M4 Max Chip mit 16‑Core CPU, 40‑Core GPU, 16‑Core 48 RAM. Do you think it is necessary the second one, or the 1st option (the cheaper) is more than enough, future proof (maybe 5 years). Thank you.
@gregbenzphotography8 күн бұрын
The first should be good for quite a while Be sure to check out that new HDR display when you get it. Game changer! gregbenzphotography.com/hdr/
@RG-vz8vh8 күн бұрын
Does anyone know how to RESTORE the way Adobe used to create ENHANCED versions of, say, the DENOISE feature? In the past, it created separate raw files with the enhancement applied, which while making furhter files, can actually be useful for many uses. It labelled them ENHANCED etc. The new version, applies the denoise (the AI Denoise) to the same file. But I've found it buggy and fails to apply the setting on every image, and having denoised raws separate, can be quite useful to pass on to other users, as the noise reduction is kind of baked in.
@gregbenzphotography8 күн бұрын
There is no value in a separate file. This is the same and can be undone. You can export as a DNG and your settings will be included. Or pass a sidecar file with the RAW if you’re setup to use them.
@JeanSolari-b6r9 күн бұрын
Is this problem avoided if you use Lightroom Classic to convert from ProPhoto editing to SRGB (for the web)? Is it still true with new masking features in LrC?
@gregbenzphotography9 күн бұрын
It’s a big risk anytime you have more than one layer. Has nothing to do with external software or how you otherwise edit.
@Relentlessiam9 күн бұрын
Hi I noticed yesterday ( not sure if I’m doing something wrong ) when I opened a 5 image AEB / HDR as a smart object & tried to go back to work on it the features had gone even also as a non smart object I could not go back to camera raw & re adjust anything if I needed too ie denoise etc as the options was gone, am I doing something wrong ? Also & have reported this next scenario to Adobe ( I do drone photography ) same hassleblad lense as per your picture, when doing a wide ( 180 pano 21 image ) have you tried to apply denoise ? Camera raw must hate it the picture renders looks ok for about a couple of seconds then it goes to almost luminous RGB colours & you have to remove denoise anyone know a fix ? Right annoying …. Thank you 😊
@shamanbeartwo38199 күн бұрын
I'm so new to Adobe (five weeks) that when I have seen that message, I thought it meant Adobe wanted to update the software again. It seems like every time I turn around, Adobe Cloud wants to update so, I just ignored it altogether:)
@gregbenzphotography9 күн бұрын
I can see how that would be confusing!
@jacquesdemers199810 күн бұрын
Great information, thank you
@adriangidney713410 күн бұрын
Really useful video Greg.
@ericpecquerie486810 күн бұрын
Adobe like Apple are doing weird updates presently. Lightroom and ACR are no longer aligned for Adobe and IPHONE 15 is not able of Apple Intelligence. Weird times. Thank you for this post, it clarifies a lot and avoid a lot of frustration for the users.
@rgarlinyc10 күн бұрын
Fantastic explanation and your 'conversion demo" truly "dropped the scales of my eyes", Thanks a ton Greg! - and thanks for the link to your complete written tutorial too!
@khuzo445410 күн бұрын
i don’t understand 😭
@khuzo445410 күн бұрын
what should i do first? what to download first
@gregbenzphotography10 күн бұрын
This is the software: gregbenzphotography.com/lumenzia
@rgarlinyc10 күн бұрын
Wonderful insights Greg - you never cease to produce the goods. thanks a ton!
@vonkske5310 күн бұрын
Always useful video's but for non native english people you are really talking too fast :)
@newramesh10 күн бұрын
i am a non native as well, he's speaking with full clarity and slow...probably you should turn on the sub-titles for easier understandnig..
@rdbimages10 күн бұрын
For me ( even as a native English speaker) Greg is talking too fast, especially since he is teaching people. Don't forget that you can slow down the speech in KZbin by clicking on the gear icon and adjusting Playback speed. I set it to .75 in this case.
@jensvielmann766210 күн бұрын
Thank you for the video! But honestly, I’m getting annoyed with Adobe. Why the hell can’t they put those features in Lightroom beta or something? Makes life room, kind of useless if you actually wanna use new features. Not only the extra step of pushing every image to Photoshop, but also the fact that photo shops to look and save back DNG files. And even if it could, you definitely have to files then and double the space. Sorry I know I’m not the right place… but it really annoys me.
@gregbenzphotography10 күн бұрын
Implementing all that work twice when you expect to make changes is not efficient. It creates lots of rework, duplicate bug reports for the same problem, etc. I can appreciate how it may seem frustrating from the outside, but as a developer, I’d probably make the same choice if I were in their shoes.
@amiri739210 күн бұрын
@@gregbenzphotography Are ACR and Lightroom Develop not just the same thing but with a different UI?
@jensvielmann76629 күн бұрын
@ as a developer, I would think that all the functions are in separate classes or modules that I could call from ACR as well as from Lightroom ;) Maybe some Ui elements need to be added. But they need to do that anyways at some point. But the functions them selves would be stupid to implement them twice and not use the same
@gregbenzphotography9 күн бұрын
@jensvielmann7662 there is surely plenty of reusable code, but adding it to multiple pieces of software with the expectation of subsequent rework isn’t trivial either. LR includes Classic and Desktop on two operating systems, iOS, iPadOS, Android, and web. Getting it right in one place and then implementing elsewhere is much more efficient. I’m sure they’d love to give everyone everything they want if it was easy.
@J5388T11 күн бұрын
A verynhelpful summary, thanks Greg!
@Relentlessiam11 күн бұрын
I see your using ACR 17.0 there is now 17.01 do you know if it has any benefits ? Many thanks & nice drone shot ( hassleblad ) 😅
@gregbenzphotography11 күн бұрын
Any double dot release is just bug fixes
@photonsonpixels11 күн бұрын
Great advice, Greg. Thank you.
@jackpinoh11 күн бұрын
Very helpful. Clearly explained. Thanks!
@sjkahn12 күн бұрын
Greg, thanks for explaining a host of frustrations I was experiencing, but NOT understanding--now I do! And, importantly, know how to minimize them...
@robertstonephoto12 күн бұрын
I would think about moving the Denoise panel to the top...
@davecurtis883315 күн бұрын
Great video. This is the first video that explains SDR/HDR display limitations and tools vs the actual image data dynamic range and clipping.
@Ancaja12321 күн бұрын
I cannot figure out how to get this beta feature. Opening an image in camera raw and I don’t see adaptive profile. Photoshop is up to date too
@gregbenzphotography21 күн бұрын
Did you enable the tech preview? Click the link in the description to the full written tutorial on my site for details.
@Uisci8124 күн бұрын
This was SO helpful! I thought it was my Ram. I have a 2015 MBP with 16gb ram and thought the reason opening raw photos took forever was my ram was all used up. I watched your video, brought up the cpu graph and just changing a few settings on my Lightroom edits shot my cpu to 600% while my ram never moved. It’s an old quad core so I’m guessing the new 14-core M4 backboom pro shouldn’t have any issue with it! That’s the one I’m looking at. Thank you so much for the video, I’m. Much more confident that what I’m buying will more than fix the issues I’m having with beyond slow Lightroom issues
@gregbenzphotography24 күн бұрын
That’s great! You’re m in for an amazing upgrade (not just speed, the HDR display is a game changer for photography).
@Uisci8124 күн бұрын
@@gregbenzphotography I’m not tech savvy so I keep asking myself and the internet “is going from my quad core i7 (what my laptop says I have) to these M4 14 core cpu 16 core gpu REALLY going to speed it up that much or is it just hype! People keep saying it’s WAY faster so I guess I’ll give it a shot. Just trying to make sure I “future proof” my computer as I don’t want to buy another one 2-3 years later, but once cry once.
@gregbenzphotography24 күн бұрын
Anything Intel in the Mac world has a short life. I won’t be surprised if support is eliminated in next year’s MacOS update (there is little MacIntel support in Sequoia). The M1 has good life left in it, and the M3 should be great for many years to come. So plenty of options for closeout sales or used if the M4 pricing is a concern. I am excited about the brighter SDR and nano-texture on the M4 to use it for productivity work in the field, should help make it easier to see in bright light. I bought it and will review in a couple weeks.
@Uisci8124 күн бұрын
@@gregbenzphotography thank you! I looked at the nano texture and it looks “flat” so as to reduce glare, I do t use it in the field so not a concern to me! I will be getting the M4 pro 16” with 48gb ram so I should be more than good for a number of years. I’m an amateur photography who does it as a hobby so nothing to graphically intensive besides the stacking of some photos and maybe small video edits if I get into in surf photography/video with my surf gear. All of which I’m assuming the m4 pro should handle with ease. Thank you for taking the time to respond. You’ve been more than helpful
@gregbenzphotography24 күн бұрын
@Uisci81 yeah, you’ll be screaming fast with that setup
@kentfaithwendyzeng26 күн бұрын
Awesome video! The tips are practical and really helpful. I can’t wait to try them out! Keep up the great work!
@GTti79Ай бұрын
Nice, but, no copyright? :/ and also if I open those with a iphone doesn't show the picture in hdr....
@gregbenzphotographyАй бұрын
Not sure what you mean
@GTti7924 күн бұрын
@@gregbenzphotography if I had to share a hdr gallery, I would like to have my watermark on it, I can export pictures with watermark, but I cannot create a gallery with the option to have a specific watermark as a default on those. Also I notice that the gallery show HDR when i see the pictures with a desktop, MBP 16", but they are sdr rendered when I try to see those with one iphone 14
@gregbenzphotography24 күн бұрын
@GTti79 iPhone browser does not support HDR as WebKit does not yet support the hardware. Adobe knows this and is serving the best thing a browser supports there. Instagram (app) on the iPhone works well. My Web Sharp Pro plugin supports HDR on Instagram as well as watermarks (and many other HDR enhancements - such as full control of the base SDR image). Click the tutorials button in the panel and see the HDR sections for more details.
@Antferguson_PhotographyАй бұрын
Super helpful!
@BIGplanetLifeАй бұрын
Another great video!! You always explain and demonstrate the features in a very informative and helpful way..Thanks!!!
@gregbenzphotographyАй бұрын
Thank you!
@stigfloberghagenphotographyАй бұрын
Great stuff 👍
@melissam731Ай бұрын
Hi Greg! Amazing difference in the original and color corrected image. Very helpful tutorial! 😀
@watchlover8297Ай бұрын
I tried this and my dark image opens in PS with weird colours, blues, ambers, just looks horrendous. Not sure what Ive done, am using Lumenzia 11.8.0.
@gregbenzphotographyАй бұрын
Lumenzia can’t change native PS behaviors, if the image opens in a funny way, it’s something about RAW settings or something like that.
@watchlover8297Ай бұрын
@@gregbenzphotography Thank you for answering. I unchecked the Check alignment (difference) box and it seems to have corrected the issue. I just did the pre blend again with it unchecked and worked again with no colouration. Just did the prebend with check difference (alignment) checked and the colour issue is back. Just thought I'd mention it. Thanks again.
@gregbenzphotographyАй бұрын
@watchlover8297 that alignment option is meant to be used only monetarist to align edges manually, it definitely won’t look pretty.
@LarryRogers-c3sАй бұрын
I meant Crop and Expand
@LarryRogers-c3sАй бұрын
I’m like you video however I still get “Crop” not “Crop 7 Fill”. And regenerative fill is NOT there. I am running ACR 17.0 as per the title of the video. Any ideas?
@gregbenzphotographyАй бұрын
Make sure you enable the tech preview, restart, and have true raw data (if reconsider can go negative, it is not raw).
@shamanbeartwo3819Ай бұрын
I am entirely new to LR (like, 2 weeks new) so I gave it a real test. I tried some images I took in a very dark bar with multiple colored light sources at ISO 25,600. I tried everything I know how to do in Darktable and got something I could live with but it took several modules and a lot of tinkering. A single click on AI denoise left me saying, "Wow!" Yeah, still lots of noise but I could get something I liked enough for social media without leaving my model looking like a cartoon character.
@gregbenzphotographyАй бұрын
That’s amazing! I have not pushed the tool that hard as I don’t have images above ISO 10k. Thank you for sharing your experience.
@ZhivoderovaАй бұрын
Thanks for this review! I see that Adobe Adaptive is more suitable for landscape photography. I applied this effect to an interior photograph, which is my area of focus, and I wasn't satisfied with the result.
@gregbenzphotographyАй бұрын
Definitely worth ongoing testing, results vary by scenario. Be sure to use the option to report any bad results to help them improve, very important in this preview phase.
@danielanderson5983Ай бұрын
I have downloaded and installed PS 2025, LR Classic 14 and ACR 17. BUT, I cannot seem to access any of these new Ai features, especially Adobe Adaptive Profile. It just doesn't show in the profile dropdown menu. What am I missing?
@gregbenzphotographyАй бұрын
Enable the tech preview in settings, restart, and make sure your image data is truly raw (if temp slider can go negative, it is not raw).
@mikephillipsphotographyАй бұрын
Thanks for the video Greg. I had a play with the non-destructive denoise feature and notice that if I apply it, come out of Camera Raw back to PS, then go back to Camera Raw the denoise is no longer applied, and I have to go through the rigmarole of waiting a few minutes for it to apply again. I think I prefer to stick with the denoised DNG output and work from that.
@gregbenzphotographyАй бұрын
It should stick if you click OK to keep the changes. If you see something else, that is a bug which should be reported to Adobe.
@behrfeetАй бұрын
Hi Greg ... when I open a RAW image as a Smart Object in PS and then double click to open ACR I get the message that Denoise is not currently available for Smart Objects. I'm using ACR V17 and have tried to figure out what I may be doing differently than you are but nothing seems to give me the option you have shown
@gregbenzphotographyАй бұрын
Make sure you turn on the tech preview in ACR settings and restart. Also make sure temp cannot go negative, which would indicate the data you are using is not raw.
@behrfeetАй бұрын
@@gregbenzphotography Thanks Greg ... the program restart now gives me that option to use Denoise within PS. You lost me on "make sure temp cannot go negative" though
@karlkirkman30017 күн бұрын
Hi Greg! I had the same problem on my Windows laptop. I finally solved this by going into the Preferences panel for Camera Raw and changing the gpu settings to custom and checking both options.
@gregbenzphotography17 күн бұрын
@karlkirkman300 good to know, thanks!
@moderntimes4814Ай бұрын
Is there any possibility to run camera raw as a standalone application?
@gregbenzphotographyАй бұрын
Technically, it always is. Closest thing to it is when you open a supported file directly into it in PS.
@pafredricksАй бұрын
Hi! I installed this today and the Adaptive Profile feature is missing. I did check the technology preview box and restarted PS Beta and even my computer. I have every other new feature but that one. The only options in the Profiles drop down are Adobe Color, Monochrome and Browse. What am I missing?
@gregbenzphotographyАй бұрын
That indicates you are not working with raw data
@pafredricksАй бұрын
@@gregbenzphotography I’m using a raw cr3 file and I see the profiles in the correct folder on my Mac. It works in Photoshop now but not PS Beta. Weird but that will do lol Thanks for your help!
@gregbenzphotographyАй бұрын
@pafredricks make sure the temp slider cannot go negative. If it does, you don’t have raw data (any use of ACR as a filter is always faster data, not raw).
@pafredricksАй бұрын
@@gregbenzphotography got it! Appreciate it very much:)
@kc6715Ай бұрын
Thank you! This was very helpful - and there just aren't enough ACR tutorials out there.
@markmetternich7629Ай бұрын
As far as the Denoise I still think I will bring that in as a separate raw “smart object” layer file into Photoshop so that I have more flexibility to localize it into the original raw file.
@gregbenzphotographyАй бұрын
Even that is easier, as you can duplicate the layer in PS (new smart object via copy) without adding an extra file on disk. Your workflow is great for many images, I do that for local control too.
@markmetternich7629Ай бұрын
It is finally so great to see someone else working in (and teaching) raw layers in Photoshop! I’ve been preaching this from the mountaintops for about six years with stupid amounts of negative flack (which is normative when you’re a pioneer.). But YAY, people are finally starting to catch on! Your videos are always great! 👍🏼
@gregbenzphotographyАй бұрын
Yeah, RAW layers are amazing. I wish ACR was a native part of PS to work even faster and see the blended results live. Such an incredible tool.
@tamashaaszАй бұрын
Many Thanks for sharing this valuable info on the new features, much appreciated! The adaptive profile seems to me a very promising feature. Obviously it depends on the image at hand, but at least it offers an alternative over the traditional manual approach. I would love to see a feature addressing the WB in similar manner. Non destructive noise reduction with the possibility to tweak the slider at later point is a killer function and a huge time and storage saver. Hope these will be ported over to LRC soon. (I know ACR is the same, however still prefer LRC as starting point from workflow prospective). Also I like the perspective correction with generative fill and seeing the potential once it will push out full resolution fills.
@karstengieselmann5569Ай бұрын
Many thanks for this excellent video! As a LrC user and consumer of the "What's new in Lightroom" videos it seems I have missed some exciting features currently only available in ACR.
@gregbenzphotographyАй бұрын
The cutting edge stuff tends to show up in ACR first, then move into LR as it matures.
@DavidZeiler6969Ай бұрын
interesting my new copy of adobe 25 however still generates a dng from the denoise so not non destructive not shure of the difference
@gregbenzphotographyАй бұрын
Enable the ACR tech preview and restart to make sure you have support.
@andreasliedmann4482Ай бұрын
THX a ton for the informative video Greg ... nicely done and well explained the new features !!!! I do have the same issue like another guy further down the pipe ... I have updated to PSCC 2025 and have enabled the settings in ACR to make use of the non destructive AI feature , but it does not work as shown in your video . I am always ending up in the window where it is does produce a DNG file ... ??!! OS is Mac Sonoma . Do ihave to change settings in PS itself ??? Kind regards Andreas
@andreasliedmann4482Ай бұрын
Solved ... I had to restart the machine and not only restarting PS . Now it does work !!!😍