Are they really hiding homeless people|Shanghai

Are they really hiding homeless people|Shanghai #chinavsusa
In this video i will search for homeless people on the streets of shanghai china, i want to see it with my own eyes that whatever the western media is telling about china is it true or not.
Homelessness and begging is quite a big problem in USA and many other major countries but in china from last almost five years i never saw any one begging on road,
whatever i am saying in this video is entirely my own analysis and my opinion, one can differ with what i think but we can't deny or hide the fact and truth.
Your searches:
china vs america
usa vs china
homeless people
is there no homeless people in china?
China architecture
Chapter:
00:00 - In this video
0:19 - Intro
01:57 - Bike Ride
02:59 - We vs Me culture
03:40 - Cost of living
04:17 - Drug problem
04:36 - no begging
06:30 - Shanghai subway
09:31 - Government help homeless
10:22 - inside park
10:39 - Outro
Social Media
/ junkiejourney
Thank you for watching. see ya in the next one.
China vs USA which is safer - • China or USA which cou...
$3000 per night- • Video
insane 800 year old village - • Video
Hit the like, subscribe and comment.
#chinavsusa #livinginchina #homeless #shanghai

[@sati87527]

are you joking no homeless what ever ccp gives you eat and come stupidhow much they pay you to talk shit

[@MrAlexCage]

that's a good idea, i do need to be paid.!!

[@AlbertAlize]

Every day tens of thousands of foreign bloggers go to China, how much money does China have to pay to cover up this fact?

[@kennedy6618]

@sati, Calm down CNN New's Boy... don't you remember? You felt into a pile of horse manure and got brainwashed with shit! Please go to China and snap some photos of the homeless people... We would love to see it on CNN NEWS!

[@dlcc012david]

Always remember rumours, lies n propaganda r carried by haters, spread by fools n accepted by idiots 😂

[@thungwalaen548]

You will receive your pay check from CIA in 2 days

[@jogana6909]

In China, if homeless people are found, the government has the obligation to help them. Homeless people are usually arranged by the civil affairs department to rescue station, and the next step is to be sent back to their hometown. When the homeless arrive in their hometown, the local government will continue to help him (house, food, etc.). Under this system, nobody will sleep on the street. - If a homeless person dies in the street (no matter where his hometown is), government officials in the place where he died will be held accountable. The last time I saw such news was about 30 years ago.

[@JAM661]

Were did you here that BS. I lived in China for 10 years and they will not even give you health care in a emergency unless you pay first. The government does nothing. Do you know what there SS equivalency is for retirement in China. It's $15 a month. In fact in China if you make more than $300 a year they consider you rich according to the CCP and yet housing is like 3 time more then the USA. Then you put you life long saving on a home and the building never get finished leaving you left to pay off the loan and you with a half built condo. You have no clue what you are talking about. China has all these polocies on paper but in reality all the CCP does is steal money from the people. Meanwhile China uses USA freedom of speech and press against use with propaganda and idiots fall for it. The government does not care for it people and they have no social program there either.

[@MADDENCN]

Because of the close off system, not much ppl are expose to the free system ( drugs are cool) 🤣

[@MADDENCN]

Us goverment telling americans you rather be homeless and free.. Than be under communism😂😂😂😂

[@byakuya3603]

They just have pathetic guaranteed housing and forced labor out of poverty, but the United States has the freedom of homeless people to live in the streets and a great food bank, and the United States wins！

[@MarkMiller304]

Lol free to pee and poo outside, that’s real freedom!

[@DK-ev9dg]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@aww7056]

Free to be locked inside after 6 pm bcs its too dangerous outside ... 😂

[@DK-ev9dg]

@@aww7056 😅well said

[@ITeachChinese]

About 10 years ago, you would encounter someone begging you for a dollar or something in the subway or in a restaurant, but now it is very rare to encounter such begging. If your income is low, you still have no problem eating, and you won’t have to beg. Elderly people without relatives can go to nursing homes, and disabled people without relatives can go to welfare institutions, both of which are completely free. In recent years, the overall mentality of society has been changing, and there is no need to beg.

[@jogana6909]

Professional beggars are not homeless, because in fact they rent houses to live in. Professional beggars always pretend to be poor, but they are probably richer than the average person.

[@user-hp8fo9bz3x]

It’s not that there are no beggars, it’s just that all beggars have moved online.

[@quietlives]

@@user-hp8fo9bz3x Scammers more precisely

[@jogana6909]

"Professional beggars" usually rent houses to live in. They are not homeless.

[@user-ks8mo6zd7c]

10 years seriously? 20 sounds more resonable.

[@nmew6926]

Having a shelter is one of the most basic human rights. No wonder why US refuse to consider a redefinition of human rights. They refuse to consider food as another basic human rights because they use Food as a weapon. 500,000 Iraqi children starved by sanctions

[@GuyWets-zy5yt]

USA is so Christian...

[@robertlu2344]

And this is one of the reasons ppl support the government and appreciate the level of services the government provides. We, Chinese, never take any social progress as granted.

[@kennedy6618]

Hahaha, I brought a suitcase of clothes to China and thinking to donate to the poor people there. After weeks of searching for homeless... I end up leaving the clothes in the hotel because I couldn't find anyone sleeping on the street. Beijing 2017.

[@MrAlexCage]

it happened to me too when i was changing my apartment i wanted to give away stuff but couldn't find anyone.

[@JAM661]

That is because they are not allowed to hand out where there a lot of foreigners and in my cities. The police only let them sleep for a few hours at night and make them move on. Also people are not going to admit to a a foreigner.

[@y12avivo15]

Hi Kennedy, Thank you , you're so thoughtful, may i suggest that you donate them to your countrymen that needed the most with so many of them sleeping on the streets.

[@kennedy6618]

@@y12avivo15 , Yes indeed! I thought China was super poor and people couldn't afford to buy clothes but I was wrong because we were polluted with anti China propagandas. Next time I go to China...I will bring a suitcase of clothes to the homeless here in America. Good thinking!

[@y12avivo15]

@@kennedy6618 Don't worries about the Chinese, they are tough and know what hunger is. Last through all kind of weather.Worry about your own ppl.

[@hengongchua6250]

You should also find out how much Americans have to pay their income tax compared to the Chinese? The Chinese pay a very small amount of tax or not paying at all yet the country provides the people with such super infrastructures. As the Americans pay a huge amount of taxes but see the kinds of rundown infrastructures they are having?

[@MarkMiller304]

The result of state owned enterprises, the Chinese government generates its own income to invest into infrastructure for the country to increase productivity while the American government extorts the American people to pay its bills.

[@GuyWets-zy5yt]

USA looks like a new third country

[@Luming-di9rf]

Not something the average American thinks about. WMDs over people, that's how Americans think.

[@percytong5377]

Most of the tax money in the US go to sponsoring wars and the politicians instead of helping the people.

[@Super-Thomas-911]

Taxes paid by Americans go to the military-industrial complex, the military-industrial is used to maintain American hegemony, and American hegemony in turn is defending the interests of the rich Americans . So the taxes paid by the poor are protecting the interests of the rich.

[@logicviewer7759]

In Melbourne's Chinatown in 2018, I noticed a white homeless man because I rarely see homeless people. Because I was leaving Australia and returning to China, I gave all the food I had not eaten to this homeless man. When this homeless man found out that I was from China, he actually said that I lived in a sinful country. I felt offended. It’s hard for me to imagine a homeless person not criticizing his own government but criticizing a country far away from him.

[@meipakyu4688]

This is because CCP is portrayed as bad in the media! Homeless people in the city still go to the pub to watch the news😅😅

[@achtungbaby2009]

He is a fool. He belongs to the streets.

[@pbworld7858]

The NYC subway looks like a rat-infested war zone.

[@jogana6909]

NY subway is the worst in the world

[@aww7056]

Not to mention the mentals and addicts ...

[@GuyWets-zy5yt]

Maybe it s propaganda😂😂😂

[@edie930]

China is Very clean

[@Astrophageyep]

In the city I lived. Government built shelters of all sorts. It's considered political merits for the mayor which helped him climb the political ladder. I heard some homeless people were sent back to their hometowns. There are not so many homeless people in the streets mostly because basically every man has a house and some field distributed by local government in their hometown. Also, Chinese government doesn't offer so much welfare, so people tend to save and deposit money in banks. They do not lose their apartments just because they are unemployed for one year.

[@privacyhelp]

Every country has its homeless. But only in America where homeless people are easy to find in every big city.

[@MrAlexCage]

that's the point, why it's easily visible in America, there must be reason for that right.?

[@polycadence8482]

Clearly, you've never traveled outside of the West!

[@pbworld7858]

Try India and UK!

[@jogana6909]

@@MrAlexCage The United States advocates freedom, and it is a right for the homeless to sleep on the streets.

[@jogana6909]

Fentanyl is used as a medicine in more than 100 countries, but only the United States has the problem of fentanyl abuse. So whose problem is it?

[@user-ez9rw5lm5w]

现在很少很少再见到流浪者了。我很欣赏中国政府教他们工作技能让他们能持续地工作养活自己，而不是给他们一笔钱花光了之后又变回贫穷。授人以鱼不如授人以渔。

[@ellocoparasiempre]

Homelessness is a truly terrible thing... if the policies implemented in China are working, hope other Nations can take note and help their own people from such a sad situation.

[@MrAlexCage]

every country should provide shelter to homeless people in their own country.

[@henrylee3379]

You will just hear, authoritarian regime, no human rights, they are not going to adopt any policies from China.

[@polycadence8482]

It's more important for USA to spend $300 Billion on the Ukraine and Gaza wars.

[@hengongchua6250]

In a country where the populations are divided into different castes, don't expect the lowest castes people will be helped by the government and politicians who are from the upper castes. These upper castes people treated the lowest castes like animals.

[@ellocoparasiempre]

@@hengongchua6250 That's inhumane...

[@TheTruth-88]

China is magnificent

[@user-pr5rl1nl6q]

there is no words to describe the sufferings across America ' What happened to this Neighborhood? ' ' I've never seen anything like it': Inside the center of the tranq drug crisis ' ' Streets of Philadelphia, Kensington Ave Documentary, October 25-26 2023 ' - youtube

[@MrAlexCage]

Philly streets are definitely depressing, it makes me really sad to see them living miserable life.!!

[@hengongchua6250]

​@@MrAlexCage,but to the government, that is freedom and human rights which the Chinese people don't have a chance to enjoy.

[@evato8746]

The key problems are drug,. abuse of freedom and ineffective and many senseless government policies. Too much attention, money spent on making wars than taking care of it's people, building up its country. US gov main concern is focused on the rich and the powerful. That's why. Otherwise, USA with its good potential could have remained a great country. Now its government is downright evil!

[@ALWH1314]

I live LA, the capital of homeless. Homeless is popular here because all kinds of perks on street. For example, property owners in downtown are not allowed to block their side walk with plants or divider, can’t evict homeless residents, there are city provided toilet (using them or not is at their discretion), weekly hose down the street and trash removal, in cold weather they will be nice people bring them blanket, portable heater and there is free food near by and convent drug dealers. We have nice weather and dry, it’s friendly place for homeless.

[@user-kq6ee9xv1s]

在中国，中国当地会组织无家可归的人 返回自己家乡 ，能领取社会最低保障，当地的社区会给他们找力所能及的工作，比如保洁，保安，打更，加上低保和工资 能比较尊严的活下去，而不是当社会蛀虫，每天想着领多少福利，不去干活，美国那样的福利制度才是最需要修改的。

[@X-H-Wu]

China has the system of "protection house". Recently the Shenzhen government announced that they will add 100 000 units of protection house in the city so that every youth can have their own house, which I think for the migrants from other provinces, as 90% of population in Shenzhen come from other provinces and they often have to live in rented shared houses.

[@MrAlexCage]

Quite impressive

[@BeijingBuzzz-China-Travel]

Interesting video. Subbed.

[@jzeng2022]

More than 20 years ago, you would encounter many homeless people in parks, bridges, and underground sidewalks in Chinese cities. Nowadays, whether in big cities, small cities or rural areas in China, it is indeed difficult to find homeless people and beggars, and you can only encounter them occasionally. No government can hide these homeless people and beggars. Taking drugs is not a crime in China. People who take drugs but do not sell them are often forced into rehab. However, if they sell drugs, they face very severe penalties.

[@xinyiquan666]

NS， even in 1950s, you would not see many hm lss in parks, or bridges, or anywhere in china, yes, there were some people asking for donation or penney 30 years ago, but never so many, also they are technically not hm lss, they have home and house back in their villages , they came to city to ask for penny, these are mostly old people, another type is migrant worker, they are not hm lss, they live under bridge just for saving cost for renting a place, they do have jobs in the cities, even today , you still can see one or two in south china some industry zones, such as dongguan city and shunde city, but again, they are not hm lss, they just want to save cost, because in that area, weather is warm, so they can live outside at night, third type is some people they have diability, some of them 30 years ago, they chose to ask for peneny on streets, but you do not see those any more, local govertment take good care of them

[@t4ac]

Great video. I submit that it boils down to the priority of the government. US is not a poor country but it did a poor job putting helping its people as priority for the last 2 decades. When it attempted to do so, it either poorly executed or so much more about putting politics first and things quickly backfired.

[@jogana6909]

When US invests money in wars all over the world, of course, there is no money to solve homelessness.

[@inkbold8511]

Doesn’t this mean democracy doesn’t work cause it gives you poor quality government even with all the wealth that USA has accumulated, its entire economy is poorly run with corruption and bribery

[@Aapig]

Hasn't the United States been helping Ukrainians and Afghans? It's just that it's not helping Americans

[@partyhu]

你得先搞清楚什么是资本主义社会

[@jogana6909]

Investing in Ukraine can feed back US military enterprises, and politicians are profitable. Investing in the homeless pays no dividends.

[@asiaone999]

the definition of 'FAMILY' different from the West and the East, people in the East help their own units in their family and even help the extended family and relatives, it is a norm . Its a 5,000 year old civilization that have not change.. bro, glad you saw with yr own eyes, and dont bother relying on yr newsmedia back home. Clean city , friendly and helpful people. That is the mindset of the people when the country didnt fire a single bullet at anyone for the last 40 years, peace is already embedded in their mind.

[@MrAlexCage]

i totally agree with you Mate. the china i have seen in media was totally different than the china which i saw with my own eyes.!!

[@Dancequeen-406]

Nice video！Thank you for your objective record.

[@GuyWets-zy5yt]

In a lot of countries, exists social helps ,USA called that socialism. They don t know the difference between social and socialism. Truman said that long ago

[@horaceleung8646]

Why are there homeless people? Why is there no homeless person in China? I think there are several aspects that need to be understood. 1. Drugs. Many people become homeless because they use drugs, which is the most common in Western countries. The Chinese government regards drug control as a very important policy. Because in modern history, China was devastated by drugs, and opium made China a weak country. Therefore, the Chinese government does not want to repeat the same mistake. A very simple example is that if you are found to have more than 50G of drugs on your body, you may be sentenced to death. 2. Poverty. Many homeless people around the world are homeless because of this reason. However, Chinese society is an agricultural civilization, and self-sufficiency is a clear characteristic of agricultural civilization. And Chinese people are one of the most obedient races, as long as they can eat enough, they will not do anything rebellious. At the beginning of China's development, many rural people would go to cities to seek opportunities, but cities could not accommodate everyone, so there were indeed homeless people at that time. However, when many people recognize reality, they will go back to their hometowns to continue farming or doing some small handicrafts to support themselves, after all, the cost of living in rural areas is much lower than in cities. 3. Laziness. Laziness is an important factor leading to poverty, but Chinese people are renowned worldwide for their diligence. If a beggar with sound limbs looks under 50 years old, then no one will give you a penny. Because in the eyes of Chinese people, when such a young person goes begging everywhere, it is caused by laziness, not for any other reason. Therefore, they will only look down upon and not help. 4. Family. Chinese family culture is deeply rooted, and this family is not just about your parents and children, but also includes your uncles, aunts, and so on. When a homeless person appears in a family, it is something that embarrasses the entire family. So, once such a thing happens, family members will find him, take him home, and provide some help. 5. Government. In Western countries, the government does not care if you are a homeless person because they believe you have the "right" to be a homeless person, so they will not provide any assistance to the homeless person. In China, because there is no drug problem, the only possibility of becoming a homeless person is poverty. The Chinese government has used many methods to help the poor, including providing job positions, providing all agricultural materials, and even helping them build houses. This is also a very important reason why there are no homeless people in China.

[@lunhui911]

In China, drug use will not be sentenced to death, but will be sent to a compulsory drug rehabilitation center for detoxification. After the detoxification is completed, the community where the person's hukou is located will help take care of the supervision and help the person return to normal life.

[@AlbertAlize]

The simplest prerequisite for the formation of homeless people is that there is no house to live in, but in China, you can rent a very shabby house for a few tens of RMB, as long as people are willing to work, they can live a decent life. The government usually provides free assistance to those who are unable to work. In China, only the salary above 5,000 RMB is required to pay personal income tax. Besides, ordinary people can hardly touch any tax. Tax is quite strange to most people in China

[@JJr-ce3vv]

Seeing is believing, in my extensive travels across over 120 Chinese cities and towns, I've never encountered the presence of homeless individuals or makeshift tent cities. By the way, I want to clarify that I'm not being compensated for making this comment.

[@MrAlexCage]

By the way, I want to clarify that I'm also not being compensated for making these positive image videos of china 😉 JK

[@mahendirangopal3885]

Yes, China can such things

[@jonwick7635]

lol india even let their homeless sleep with cows in the streets

[@yongzeehow2045]

US culture is that they like outdoor camping .

[@Zerpentsa6598]

There is transient homelessness in some cities of China. People who are temporarily jobless or moved into the cities but cannot afford rents or can't find temporary accommodation might sleep on the streets. They do have homes to go to if they returned to theur villages. But they are not many.

[@MrAlexCage]

emm you might be right but as for as my experience so far i didn't see anyone sleeping in the streets.

[@xinyiquan666]

those are migrant workers, some of them just want to save cost for renting a place, they do have job, or some are recetnly lost job, they are in transit , so they live outside to save cost until they find another job , yes, technically no one in china is hm lss, becasue over 97% people in china owns properties, their home are back in their villages

[@cool_things_collection]

Since they have 1.4 bilillon population, it's almost like a miracle.

[@Liu-lf8xs]

@@MrAlexCage you can go to Shenzhen, and you can find them

[@flybc16]

客观的视频👍

[@ChinaSongsCollection]

@8:57. He said more than 10 years ago. It's actually more like 20 or close to 20 years ago I think.

[@picandvideo]

There are a few shanty areas in every big cities in (maybe not in Beijing) China. For homelessness will be tough to find. Back then like 10+ years ago there were legit and non legit beggars. Even that now not easy to find.

[@Kyuestma]

❤

[@guestonearth1274]

woo

[@mauricetamata4265]

CHINA HAS THE BEST SYSTEM THEN ANY COUNTRIES IN THE WORLD CHINA IS RISING THE WESTERN COUNTRIES ARE SINKING BRAVO❤LOVE CHINA BULA N CHEERS

[@sarahchan5604]

The reason why there is not many homeless in China is due to the affordability: Some areas where is fully nicely furnished 3 bedroom apartment with nice view and within 10 years old costs only 500 us dollars monthly rent plus utitlity,600 us dollars a month and all set

[@jasonyoung2787]

I lived in Shanghai back in 2011, and it was not uncommon to encounter beggars and "performers" inside metro trains. It has become increasingly rare these days.

[@thuptenrikey2720]

Looking for homeless? Go to US, you Will find them everywhere.

[@MrAlexCage]

Sadly, i've seen that all my life....!!

[@feifan9347]

I remeber China had a drug dealer who produce literally tons of meth, he got the death penalty. Because of his genius talent for producing meth now every lab using chemcial need approvement. But gov will not punish normal people who suffer from drugs, it's already a disaster for whole family.

[@user-ic3qk5qx2d]

In fact, there is no soil for homeless people in China, because if you are homeless and lie there every day in the city, you will not get free food, there will not be free meals from churches, and there will not be free money from the government. You will also You can't beg. If you don't make money, you will really starve to death and you won't get sympathy. There is an old Chinese saying: Helping people in times of need does not help the poor. Perhaps, this is the important reason why there is no homelessness in China - neither the government nor society condone the homeless. Human nature is inherently lazy. If you lie there doing nothing and still starve to death, you will definitely end up with an endless stream of homeless people.

[@user-si8ct1pk6q]

You can't be shy to ask a question. He looks like he is about 65.

[@MrAlexCage]

i didn't want to offend him by putting camera on his face and ask him age. didn't feel right thing to do.

[@light9581]

where the subway when flood

[@stayfree870]

Kirk of Gweilo 60 had shown a small homeless camp community before. It's not very big.

[@user-ic3qk5qx2d]

You may have misunderstood the definition of homelessness. Those from other places who come to big cities to find jobs and are unwilling to pay expensive accommodation costs and stay in 24-hour shops cannot be considered homeless. If they find a job that includes accommodation and leave, or find a job that does not include accommodation, maybe they will get used to coming back here to sleep in order to save money, but that is also to earn more money and a better future. The real homeless are people who have no hope for the future, who only think about living day by day, and who no longer have a home on earth. And if these outsiders really can't survive, they can go back to their hometown in the countryside. This urban experience is at least a memory for them.

[@user-ic3qk5qx2d]

In fact, there is no soil for homeless people in China, because if you are homeless and lie there every day in the city, you will not get free food, there will not be free meals from churches, and there will not be free money from the government. You will also You can't beg. If you don't make money, you will really starve to death and you won't get sympathy. There is an old Chinese saying: Helping people in times of need does not help the poor. Perhaps, this is the important reason why there is no homelessness in China - neither the government nor society condone the homeless. Human nature is inherently lazy. If you lie there doing nothing and still starve to death, you will definitely end up with an endless stream of homeless people.

[@KennyL0009]

The main cause of homelessness in China in past years were largely poverty/lock of work. The causes of homelessness in the west are largely the results of addictions or addiction led psychiatric illness. There are plenty of jobs available in western countries. Western governments are not willing to provide adequately the huge amounts of resources (medical, social services, temporary housing/welfare) needed to get them well to rejoin society.

[@user-qy9sz3lb2w]

How come there are no homeless in 1.6B population?

[@imperfectxennial3008]

Because the government actually cares about the people

[@X-H-Wu]

"Protection house" for those who can't buy a house.

[@MrAlexCage]

China government is actually taking care of their needy people with skills, jobs and shelter.

[@rocksiu]

The effective management government is called the Communist Party. What our people deeply love and deeply believe in CCP.

[@rocksiu]

The effective management government is called the Communist Party. What our people deeply love and deeply believe in CCP.

[@linqix3379]

Even people who collect recycle garbage and sell them to get money are not homeless. Many elders do that just because they are bored after retirement and what to find something to do. Some of them even live in nice big house they or their kids own. One of my uncle actually does this, he is retired and have income from insurance. He likes fishing and travel around the country. He collects cardboard boxes and sell them for some money when he travel to some place that is not easy to find a fishing spot. His son can't understand why his father does this as they are not short at money. Cardboard box are cheap and a lot of them only worth a couple cents.

[@davadh]

You want to see homeless people? Come to the USA, not just in the big cities like New York, LA, and Chicago, in a med size city, you will find homeless people. And this is the so-call most wealthy, best humanitarian hospitable place on earth where the government takes care of their people.

[@Monitor2023]

I must say that there are still homeless people in China, but very very few. So you are not easily to see them.

[@MrAlexCage]

might be but so far i haven't seen anyone begging or homeless.

[@polycadence8482]

Prove up or s.t.f.u.

[@jogana6909]

I have seen such news: After a homeless man was sent back (by goverment) to his hometown several times, he went to Shenzhen to sleep out again. Obviously, there are always some people who think differently, but this number is very small in China.

[@hengongchua6250]

Yes. There are. But these homeless people are mostly those with mental problems who just wander around aimlessly.

[@xinyiquan666]

technically they are not, because they have home back in their villages, another type is those migrant worker, they just want to save cost for renting, they sleep at night on street with a sleeping bag, during day, they go work

[@anonymintheworld9781]

There will be no homeless people in China, because in China no one will be abandoned by family or friends without any help, and the government will help, all kinds of help, not only to give you a place to live, but also to ensure that you have the skills to support yourself.

[@fockerroy5629]

To be honest, there are homeless people in Shanghai. Usually you can find them in 24h KFC, MC, ATM and some cinemas. However, they can get immediate help from the government if they want. But they all have reasons which we don't know so that they don't want to get help from the government.

[@user-ic3qk5qx2d]

You may have misunderstood the definition of homelessness. Those from other places who come to big cities to find jobs and are unwilling to pay expensive accommodation costs and stay in 24-hour shops cannot be considered homeless. If they find a job that includes accommodation and leave, or find a job that does not include accommodation, maybe they will get used to coming back here to sleep in order to save money, but that is also to earn more money and a better future. The real homeless are people who have no hope for the future, who only think about living day by day, and who no longer have a home on earth. And if these outsiders really can't survive, they can go back to their hometown in the countryside. This urban experience is at least a memory for them.

[@byakuya3603]

China has a population of 1.4 billion. How can there be no bankrupt and homeless people? But people in China like to buy houses and live with a family. In addition, even homeless people who live alone will live in abandoned buildings and bridge opening, because those places are safe and sheltered from the wind and rain. It is unimaginable to sleep on the road at will in China, which is neither elegant nor safe.

[@0animalproductworld558]

I think there are homeless people in china but incredibly rare.

[@user-gc9yh2ic4q]

The "mang liu"盲流 mentioned by Steve is not exactly homeless. The literal meaning is aimless warnderers. It's a unique phenomenon in early 2000s. During fast industrialization many farmers came into cities thinking good opportunities and life awaiting them there. Often they did it without good planning (no good internet access back then). A tiny part of them failed to get a job and therefore not able to afford accommodation. The authority first saw these people as potential threats to social order and attemped to arrest them and send them back. Then a couple famous incidents happened. Some university student was mistaken as mang liu and thrown into jail where he unfortunately died. Also another man was physically harmed by police, which caused him to go on a rampage of vengeance in the police station and took quite a few lives. After those the government reflected and changed the detention centers into aiding centers, where the mang liu are given food, accommodation and vocational training and help. But generally these years with growth of economy and smartphone in every hand you can hardly find people in those aid centers.

[@MrAlexCage]

🙂thank you for information 👍

[@syncmaster915n]

7:00 the dancing people are Tibetans

[@MrAlexCage]

ah i see,

[@charliemac5154]

Western propaganda! I am Scottish and lived in China many years I NEVER ever saw homeless people. The Chinese state looks after its own. Unlike in the UK. China is a wonderful place. I met my wife in Shanghai and cannot fault it Wo Ai China 🇨🇳❤️🇨🇳❤️🇨🇳❤️🇨🇳❤️🇨🇳❤️

[@0animalproductworld558]

The police in the US are fully armed. The police aren’t enough so they need the FBI as well. The police in china do not really need to be armed.

[@user-si8ct1pk6q]

I believe there should be some homeless people if not a whole lot in China.

[@ErniJuliaKok]

Maybe they're underground?! Funny!

[@xinyiquan666]

there is nothing underground in china, he showed you the subway, subway is ungerground

[@MrAlexCage]

lol we all will be underground one day eventually?! Funny 😉

[@jeorge1153]

Liu mang (hudlums, trouble makers or undesirables)

[@mauricetamata4265]

IN. AMERICA EVRY YEAR WILL. HAVE MORE HOMELLESS PEOPLE LIVING IN STREET BECAUSE EVERYTHING IS EXPENSIVE IN THE U.S. IT WILL GET WORSE NOT EVERY BODY CAN 'T AFFORD TO RENT AN APPARTMENT FOOD WISE IN CHINA IS 75 PERCENT CHEAPER THEN THE U.S. THANKS FOR THE VIDEO CHEERS N HULALUIA

[@theoracle9873]

Finding homeless in China? You will be surprised to have more success finding many of them in the world's most expensive country , Singapore, rather than in China. They will come out at night, so the park , void deck benches and street benches are designed to prevent sleeping in the open. Why? It would be an eyesore to the tourists and expats. You got to dig below the gleaming facade and seemingly smooth veneer to understand the world' s most expensive city state by a long shot.

[@mauricetamata4265]

U.S. NEEDS A GOOD LEADER LIKE XIJIPING THE PRESIDENT OF CHONA

[@mauricetamata4265]

THESE PEOPLE IN THE PARK WITH THEIR TENTS THEY ONLY HOMELESS FOR ONE DAY THEN THEY GO BACK HOME CHEERS N BULA

[@wongyoonchark5050]

HOPELESSNESS & NO SOLUTION FOR THE 11 MOST HOMELESSNESS CITIES IN US, live in makeshifted camps are out of control： New York City, Califonia, Los Angeles, San Francisco, San Diego, San Jose, Las Vegas, Boston ,6. Washington D

[@meipakyu4688]

I have been to China! homeless people in the city are force by the local government to move to rural areas where they can easily find farming job and a home (there are few homeless in the city who just move from place to place to evade the police)! In other Asian countries (like Phil, Thailand, etc), people only become homeless because they want to stay in the city rather than live in the rural country area. However, the government do not force them to go back that is why you see slums in these country! In the Us and the west, homelessness is caused by drug addiction, broken family, and joblessness.

[@cool_things_collection]

In China they actually never compel you to relocate to rural areas; instead, they send you to the city of your birth (sometimes can be a rural area, it also can be a big city, depend on where you were born), as indicated on your ID, to see if you can find your family to surpport you. The local government in your birthplace is obligated to assist you in acquiring skills that could help you find employment, so they will send you there. If you are currently unemployed, they will provide you with a stipend.

[@zhiyu1778]

@@cool_things_collection👍👍👍

[@zhiyuanhu3377]

You got it wrong.In fact, the China government will help those who are homeless in big cities.Send them home.Provide them with food and tickets to go home.Instead of forcibly sending them back to his hometown.If a person loses the ability to live independently and has no fixed place in a big city, then perhaps it is a better choice for him to return to his hometown.

[@clintonfong1958]

There are still some poor old people who are searching for empty bottles or cans through garbage cans. Not sure if they are homeless. However, they are rarely seen on the street.

[@MrAlexCage]

yes i have seen some too but never saw them begging or sleeping in the streets, those poor old people are still working at this age but not begging, huge respect..!!

[@partyhu]

他们可能比你有钱...老年人闲的没事干，打发时间呢

[@clintonfong1958]

穿的破破爛爛的有錢人撿垃圾,不是心理有病,就是家人有問題.要正視社會現象,有問題就要面對.

[@cool_things_collection]

These old people actually often richer than you think, they just feel too boring to stay at home

[@clintonfong1958]

LOL

[@mohdsharkawiluabdullah2256]

so annoying random people simply cut in the video....and blah blah blah...

[@wongyoonchark5050]

famillies camping

[@yingxu7908]

US spenp too much fun（$）on this none sence topic and the other one（house has no one live in）the ghost town

[@user-jm8qm8dn5w]

Are you from the USA? Why are you trying to find homeless people for a vidro? Why do you not help some people for free. Be a spiritual loving person. Why do you hatdcghe poor?

[@yanzhigang4]

green and yellow bicycles are better to ride

[@thungwalaen548]

Come on, guys! Why are you guys always talking about China? We India is so much richer, cleaner and more advanced than China. India is even the only superpower on this planet! Nobody can beat India! 😂

[@ongbookok9320]

Well done India, keep it up! Not easy for a country that hold the largest population in the world.

[@avil8686]

Agree

[@MrAlexCage]

LOL 😂

[@user-tk4ux1bi2d]

The Chinese government has an evaluation for creating a hygienic and civilized city. One of the indicators is that there should be no homeless people. As long as there are homeless people in the city, they will be arrested by the Chinese police or urban management and either sent to a detention center or driven to other areas.

[@banarama4144]

They are sent back to their ancestral homes and put under social services

[@user-tk4ux1bi2d]

@@banarama4144 No, they were sent to labor reform or had their organs harvested

[@xinyiquan666]

you talk about Guantanamo bay

[@cool_things_collection]

They won't arrest you. Instead, they send you to the city of your birth, as indicated on your ID, to see if you can find your family. The local government in your birthplace is obligated to assist you in acquiring skills that could help you find employment. If you are currently unemployed, they will provide you with a stipend.

[@phoebusapollo1644]

You must have been paid by the CCP to tell a lie to help them. Everyone knew that the CCP killed more than 1 billion people at 1960~1970. Today, only 0.1 billion people live in China, and they all live in mountains and eat just grassroots and mud. So China doesn't even have a normal city, it doesn't need police or detention centers.