Caregiver says Alex Murdaugh made unusual visit on night of murders: full video

Mushell "Shelly" Smith, who works as a caregiver where Alex Murdaugh's mother lives, said Murdaugh made an unusual visit to the house on the night of the killings. She said it was unusual to see him at night. Days later, she said he tried to tell her that he'd stayed longer during the visit than she remembered.
#alexmurdaugh #murdaugh
CATCH UP ON THE CASE:
Alex Murdaugh murder trial: Timeline of events: www.wltx.com/article/news/loc...
Murdaugh murder trial: Who you need to know: www.wltx.com/article/news/loc...
Full coverage: www.wltx.com/alex-murdaugh
Subscribe for exclusive content: / @news19wltx
Follow News 19 WLTX on Social:
Facebook: / wltxnews19
Twitter: / wltx
Instagram: news19wltx...
Visit Site: www.wltx.com

[@Kklvr86]

This lady radiates tenderness, love, compassion

[@davewilliam1319]

Hello beautiful can I ask you a question?🙏🌹💐

[@jolenek283]

🙏🏼❤️🙏🏼

[@charlenestevens5457]

Tissue please! These men have no respect for women.

[@heatherpdavishasaids]

From where. She monochrome. Like Shaq in 1994..himynameisshaquattack.

[@jennifromtheblock216]

No!

[@aylen3322]

This woman is an example of good solid American backbone. These are the people we should be celebrating. Taking care of our children and elders and her own family. Angels among us.❤

[@joannalonie872]

Mary the Mother of JESUS is a great Example to follow as a Mother & A Human Being!

[@detroittokc6494]

@@joannalonie872 What is your point? Triggered because she isn't the right shade you prefer? She is a fine citizen of this great land.

[@dorothyfann4561]

@@detroittokc64940mhgfe

[@abigailcaraballo2623]

Amen

[@kccain4011]

@@joannalonie872 You just couldn't stand reading that comment, huh? Just couldn't allow someone to say something kind about this woman and you simply scroll on?? I'm sure you believe you're a Christian too?🤣🤣🤷🏿‍♀️ So many are going to be in for a heated suprise.👌🏿😏

[@odiliarivera-santos6657]

God bless this extraordinary woman. Taking care of children, the elderly, and raising her own kids. Compassion, commitment and integrity.

[@katmartin62]

The complete opposite of A. Murdaugh........

[@marymagdalene3004]

I love this lady, but she was working. She found jobs that could be done consecutively and that allowed her to maximize her earning potential. Good use of her time so just shows that she was a smart lady as well as a caring one, to be sure.

[@scooterallen1834]

Agreed. He manipulated

[@mes1220]

She's such a dear Sincere Mirculous sweet soul ☺️🌳🌞🌳🙏 God bless you yours sincerely million times 🌼🌳🌞🌳🙏

[@mes1220]

@@katmartin62 like they previously forewarn us how nrcissists forevermore attracted to the opposite of what they are 🌼🌳🌞🌳🙏

[@remedy9648]

It’s hard not to immediately like this woman. She’s like a ray of sunshine but looks so humble and is obviously a hard worker. God bless her.

[@richardlawson6787]

You must be a psychic...you concluded first off she is a nice person(of course anyone on the stand would be nice but let's continue)...then you conclude she's a hard worker...interesting ...tell me something about you to prove your powers because I'm intrigued!! Thanks

[@willoutlaw4971]

@@richardlawson6787 These sites make perfect asshole detectors based on comments

[@cathynewyork7918]

@@richardlawson6787 You don't have to be this cynical and this nasty. Remedy was just giving his impressions that this witness is a nice person and a hard worker, based on how she behaves in this court appearance with dignity and elegance. It is VERY possible that she is exactly what Remedy feels she is. Give her the benefit of the doubt. Don't be so nasty.

[@cathynewyork7918]

@@richardlawson6787 The Murdaugh witness is working two low-paid jobs -- clearly she IS hard-working. How nasty of you to make your sarcastic comment to Remedy.

[@tammyfrancis7856]

@@richardlawson6787 I’d hang out with that ray of sunshine, rather than an angry wet blanket like you, JUST based on what I’ve seen here. Lmao

[@CrackberryMe]

This is a whole mess. He tried to get this lady to lie. Thank god she has integrity and faith. He’s a monster.

[@Changeiscoming47]

Absolutely! This POS has no soul, no conscience, and ruined countless lives. He didn’t give a damn about anyone but himself. God bless this sweet and brave woman.

[@koridredd]

Well she did say conflicting things to investigators... i dont think she was being intentionally dishonest but everything you say is scrutinized at a trial.

[@roxyloveslucy]

He's going to prison , no matter what. And he knows that. Financial crimes.like his, carry a long sentence too. She's so brave. He's giving her intimidating looks. Frightening. I'm proud of her bravery.

[@jtaylor5405]

He is truly disgusting.

[@rollbamaroll6518]

No, no she didn’t.

[@dougl945]

This lady has more character than the entire family she cared for.

[@ecmcsorley2011]

For sure.

[@wendyhannan2454]

True

[@salliedavis0420]

Absolutely

[@mishawilliams4319]

FACTS 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾

[@HeloisaPait]

Incomparable.

[@madonnaclark4074]

I'm a black 62 year old woman.I been a hospice/dementia elder care giver in 90% white clients homes and in facilities.For over 30 years for some very rich people.I kept a personal journal. I wrote down date and time of every phone call visit meal diaper change when client was woke sleep their mood showeror bed bath. I watched all vistors like a hawk. I over heard some of the most inappropriate cell phone conversation business and personal.I never repeated one conversation. I respected all my clients privacy. If any of their family members had showed up at a unexpected hour.I would had wrote time before I open the door would had sent a family to let them know. I wasn't in the house alone .I would had wrote down what they had brought in the house and exactly what time they left.Alex was trying to bully his mothers care giver bullying her into saying .He was at has parents house for 30 or 40 minutes not 20 minutes. Trying to be fincicially manipulating by telling her he could help her pay for her wedding telling her he had connections at her job at the school to get her a higher position. Evil rich people can offer to do good self serving things to help people who work for them especially if they need a alibi for a double murder. It was very painful for this woman to talk about Alex visit that night she had so much respect for him and his family. As care givers we just want to go to work do our job mind our own business not be part of no damn family members murder investigation.This man hired someone to kill him.How the hell do she know if wouldn't try to kill her since she can prove he lying about his alibi of amount of time spent at his parents house.

[@intrepidtomato]

The greatest respect to you and your life's work. I wish this lady would not have been put in this position, she deserved far better than that. What a lowlife for using his mother and this kind nurse in that way.

[@cathynewyork7918]

From your comments, it looks like you did an excellent job in your lifetime work as a caregiver. Well done to you for such excellent and respectful care for your clients and patients.

[@madonnaclark4074]

@@cathynewyork7918 Thank you for the acknowledgement of my service. It is deeply appreciated. It is most times a thankless job by patient clients and their family members. Sometimes people feel like if they pay you .They don't have to verbally thank you it's included in your check. 😉

[@cathynewyork7918]

@@madonnaclark4074 Ms. Clark, I do understand you. I agree. People tend to take for granted some of their helpers. It is nice to have a smile and a kind word of thanks in addition to a paycheck, especially since your job requires not just your hard physical labor but you need to use your heart and soul as well. Tough job. You sound like a lovely person - your patients and clients are very lucky to have you.

[@mzuribeauty4287]

Hell no would I go to someone house to provide personal care

[@helenackerman305]

This lady deserves lots of hugs, support, and monetary gifts. Feel so sorry for this dear hardworking lady to have to go through this. 😢

[@ivannovotny4552]

Totally agree. 👍

[@mariacampana7764]

@@ivannovotny4552 100💯☝️%!

[@lynetteeaster2918]

I totally agree also! 😢🙏

[@LilySteph1949]

​@Repent and believe in Jesus Christ helping is setting ones mind on things above.

[@ivannovotny4552]

@@mariacampana7764 Thank you. 🇨🇦

[@shandajordan]

I hate the way she was treated by everyone during this. She handled this with great pose. I hope she is treated good by the community. Thank you for being brave enough to speak up.

[@sylviagonzalez7462]

There's POWER IN THE BLOOD OF JESUS CHRIST I REBUKE YOU SATAN GO BACK TO THE PIT WHERE COME AND DON'T COME BACK

[@lifesabeachnyc8568]

Yes!! It may seem a small thing, but I wish I could go back in time and hand her a tissue!! They did for others who were emotional. She was the bravest of them all. ❤️❤️

[@padmasalam5267]

@@lifesabeachnyc8568 True! The lawyer gave the Latino female witness Kleenex to dry her tears. He was cordial towards her. He sounded a bit annoyed with the African American witness. To be fair, I am not getting a good feel about him. He rubs me the wrong way. Sad state of affairs, really!🥂🥂🥂🥂🥂🥂🥂 Cheers mates.

[@shaquittahaynes5519]

So I said the same thing I felt like he was yelling at her and then states that he was sorry if it Sounded like he was yelling No! It’s not fair but hey that’s the world we live in

[@wj744]

She needs a body guard from these racist people

[@karenlamb2434]

Such a hard working woman being dragged into this mess, I feel so bad for her. Alex has ruined so many peoples peaceful lives. I have so much respect for her too. Working two very hard jobs, working with children and the elderly.

[@davewilliam1319]

Hello beautiful can I ask you a question?🙏🌹💐

[@heather3383]

Totally agreed.

[@roxyloveslucy]

It seems like, every mysterious death in that town, since 2014, is linked to the Murdaughs! And their name, even sounds like Murder! 🤦

[@davewilliam1319]

@@heather3383 Hi

[@heather3383]

And risking being ostracized by an entire community in league with this pile with continual power (“Alec/“Alex “Murdock/“Murdaugh). I hope this isn’t like the Darrel Brooks case where there is an assumption that mispronouncing (or rejecting a name) is imaginarily “grounds” for misidentifying an offender. 🙄

[@ShoutItFromTheHousetops]

That was so painful and uncomfortable to watch. I can’t begin to imagine what this caring, hardworking woman must have been feeling. She was loyal to the entire family yet forced into a corner by this selfish, self serving man.

[@nicolemoore3275]

That poor woman was so nervous. She is however a very brave and honourable human for not only her testimony but for her dedication to the elderly and sick. Bless her.❤

[@hb8162]

My heart goes out to this sweet, honest, and heart-broken woman. What a great lady she is!

[@mszepr]

I feel the same way. 😢

[@wolke1955]

Same 🙏

[@jimhogg216]

Poor woman. That old prosecutor is asking her the same questions over and over!

[@heatherclayton-callaghan4270]

@@jimhogg216 That being the case , why can't she give the same answer then to the same question ?? She's a nightmare of a witness for the prosecution AND the defence !!!! There's no reason for her to have been called hto the stand, she's done absolutely zero in cementing any viable evidence. It's grossly unfair of you to blame the Prosecution or Defense for her unintelligible answers and constant contradiction of her own answers and statements !!!! A woman of her age should be able to follow the Judge's instruction to speak up, speak clearly, and use YES / NO as answers. To continue in court to call a " tarp" (short for tarpaulin) a tart is inexcusable !! People need to stop with the emotion and deal with the facts of the case. Just cos she's uneducated and has to have 2 jobs , doesn't make her anything other than uneducated, which , in later years she could have rectified had she wanted to. Sounds like her brother did Okay for himself so no reason why she couldn't have followed suit. Stop with all the bleeding heart crap, many people hold down more than 1 job. And the overnight gig with the oldies was just diddle of a job, a matter of watching TV while the oldies slept, with the occasional clean up if a bed pan was missed, not highly demanding physically, or mentally !!!!

[@oliviaclaireokeefe8596]

@@heatherclayton-callaghan4270 Based on the thousands and thousands of people who have watched this video and come away with such love and positivity towards Shelley, it is evident that you lack both a soul and a heart. Her answers were not “unintelligible” nor “contradicting”. She was there to do a job and undeservingly got sucked into this completely distorted and warped family. To say “a woman of her age” is insulting. It was also not the judge that said to speak up or use yes/no answers, it was a lawyer on the prosecution that incessantly made her repeat herself when she spoke very audibly. The South Carolina accent is very think and often leads to mispronunciation of words. South Carolina senators have much harsher accents than she does. She is not uneducated, she is a hardworking woman who cares not only for her four children and six grandchildren, but other elderly citizens who need care and constant monitoring. I think you lack 1) a heart 2) empathy 3) a soul and 4) an education. You’re a moron.

[@lightandlovewarrior9552]

What a sweet, honest lady. I was upset to see her so scared up there. God bless her 🌸🕊️💖

[@vg6790]

Me too

[@LisaLisa-os8ws]

She’s scared because white folks always got something for us

[@rhenderson05]

Lovely lady she was so SAD for the family she was dragged into this horrible crime. One can tell she loved the family she worked for.

[@tinabridge6230]

To me after watching the whole trial almost, she was the best witness on that stand. She spoke with all her heart and was honest. Bless this woman for being who she is!❤

[@billd3060]

No way the CFO of law firm was fantastic.

[@aabdul1000]

​@@billd3060 she and Blanco brought humidity to it

[@travelseatsyellowlab]

@Bill D Jeanne Seckinger did well but her testimony was more about the financial crimes, nothing at all regarding the murders. Seckinger is also angry with Alex, and it showed during her testimony. This lady is getting to the heart of the murder.

[@tonib1997]

Agree!

[@cathycupcake6849]

The paralegal lady too

[@AleisterCrowleyMagus]

Miss Shelly is shaking and crying when she says that “he was saying he was at the house” - so incredibly sad. She knew it then. And she’s terrified of AM - such a monster.

[@AleisterCrowleyMagus]

AND HE OFFERED TO PAY FOR HER WEDDING AFTER THE MURDERS. WHAT A SLIMEBALL.

[@suzyq-zy216]

100%!!

[@Dillonmac96]

Authentic people make the world right. No matter what amount of money he basically bribed her with she knew something was wrong and was honest about everything because she knows

[@karleet]

This is the woman I’d want to care for my parents in their last days. A true love.

[@wisdomseeker3362]

Oh I so agree . She has light around her . A kind and compassionate spirit.

[@lindaallebach4285]

Amen! 🥰❤️‍🩹🌹

[@Jordannnnn419]

She truly is the salt of the earth! Such a kind, compassionate, and hard working woman who would do anything for anyone ♥️ It was sad to see her go through that pain and nobody was really compassionate towards her. When Maggie's sister took the stand, everyone was going the extra mile for her... but not for this absolute sweetheart 😔

[@jacquelynn2051]

@@Jordannnnn419 Yes I saw that and titled it: The Nuances of Being Biased. This woman is your basic hard working American....period. She has two jobs and is no young woman. I'm a younger generation of negro american and I'd be hella upset to be dragged into this mess and all I'm trying to do is WORK. I'd have to conjure up my sweet Mom and grandmothers and Aunts who never said a harsh word about ANYONE to calm myself down. A new breed indeed. She seems a bit nervous and rightfully so, but sincere and respectful even when surrounded by a presumed at least 25% demons....race notwithstanding tbc. What? I'm OF my ancestors but I'm not my ancestors...lol. I say a warranted harsh word at least once a day. Tell the truth and shame the devil.

[@jackiek412]

The worst witness box in the history of court rooms. Have a mic that can be adjusted to the height of the witness. They shouldn’t have to lean forward.

[@bpassion4fashion581]

I DONT appreciate how harsh the tone towards her. I’m sorry! She deserves better . God bless her for her patience .

[@silviataylor936]

That’s the prosecutor

[@BeRightBack131]

Oh, they always do that. I've had several times I've had to testify, and man, those defense attorneys get brutal. Even when you're the victim. First time I ever had to testify was when I was kidnapped at gunpoint and raped, held hostage. The defense attorney came at me like I was scum of the earth, screaming I wanted it, I asked for it, criticizing what I had been wearing as provocative (blue jeans and a black t-shirt). Another time I witnessed a lady tried to kill an old man by running him down with a truck. They were so nasty, trying to make it seem like I was lying couldn't have possibly seen what I saw, etc. I literally HATE courtrooms now. It's very traumatic to testify.

[@Mikey10Cooks]

He’s grilling her with a high tempo to get this solved, and where it needs to be = him underneath a jail. It’s not pretty, but necessary. These things are brutal, but necessary. It has to be done. I am deeply sorry for her, but this is what strong prosecution looks like. She is a hero.

[@jlcollins7673]

@@silviataylor936 both the prosecutor and the defense atty did it.

[@anonymouslee8287]

@@Mikey10Cooks Go back and sit down he states that and she jumps...pleaszzz!!!..

[@snatr]

Kills me how every other time someone in that courtroom broke out in tears they were immediately offered tissue. But not this lady 😒

[@marymagdalene3004]

I think that the prosecutor was a bit of a clod - kind of the insensitive sort. Can't imagine what it is like being his wife!!

[@squakke]

Because they racist af

[@davinaowen9918]

I said the same thing

[@goldenniblings]

The judge was so rude to this woman, she did nothing to deserve that tone from him. Awful.

[@snatr]

@@goldenniblings And just think about how hard it was for her to come testify against the people she did 🫤

[@sybstaf3496]

They don’t even offer her a sip of water yet he turns around and takes a drink himself…disgusting. I don’t understand why the judge allowed them to identify her family in the court…WTF. I feel so sad for her. Love and hugs to you Mucelle Smith 🤗❤️

[@Mako-sz4qr]

Yeah not even a tissue when she was 😢 God please protect her and her family

[@whitneykaterina8107]

Right!!!!!!! WTH!

[@sundayk875]

Yeah what was the point of that?

[@cliffordjones7329]

Can I call your something else? “I don’t know what’s going to come out of my mouth.” The most disrespectful statement I’ve heard. Obviously an in titled white male that doesn’t recognize her as a loving, kind, and caring woman.

[@margieupchurch3645]

Exactly

[@allistairmitchell3845]

It’s terrifying to tell truth to power. Once you know you have no choice, you walk with God. Afterward, you have the knowledge you did the right thing. Letting Murdaugh force you to lie would haunt your soul forever. Such a strong, wonderful woman! Amazing grace❣️

[@LorJuT]

Agreed. She’s richer than any Murdauch bc she’s rich in character and morals

[@doug4585]

And how beautifully you state that.

[@elizabeths113]

Amen!

[@susanaspiegel7692]

No she wasn’t afraid of his power. She felt indebted to him and his family and wasn’t sure of his guilt. She didn’t want to say something that was gonna lead to him being found guilty if he really wasn’t. He was good to her.

[@blackberry_700]

❤

[@archygirl1750]

Mrs. Smith, you are an amazing, lovely, kind, compassionate woman. You did a great job and you should be proud. I'm so sorry you got dragged into this mess.

[@paularubin4711]

I hope people reach out to her there and offer her a real GOID paying job!!! She needs to distance herself from enture family. All of them. Want an honest employee Get her a great job!!!

[@ahnonemous8250]

So nice to see such a lovely comment of support. She must have been terrified to testify against him knowing his power and her love for his mom. Shes genuine and courageous ❤️

[@deniseganey6890]

Iam not watching the trail. Who is Miss Libby?

[@robirew5094]

She showed dignity, compassion and courage. Doing the right thing is sometimes the hardest party to walk.

[@joerudnik9290]

She also could be risking her life… just as the other witnesses. They are all incredible.

[@robinstapelfeld8599]

They treated her with such disrespect and don’t offer her a tissue or water!!🥵 She handled herself with Grace under fire. Sending blessings to her and her family! 🙏🏼

[@guywebster8018]

Thats nonsense. She was treated with dignity and respect. What are you talking about?

[@musicmane4146]

@@guywebster8018 someone like you would say that .

[@guywebster8018]

@@musicmane4146 someone like me. Now what is that supposed to mean? You think you know me now huh?

[@guywebster8018]

@@musicmane4146 go ahead. Who is someone like me? Please enlighten me. 😂

[@musicmane4146]

@@guywebster8018 you

[@angelalachappelle9680]

It’s heartbreaking to see Mrs Smith tell her story of how Alex said he was there 30-40 mins. It’s so shameful that he would put her in that position. She is clearly a hardworking and honorable person. She doesn’t deserve this. My prayers to her and her family.❤

[@justicedenyd]

What was interesting was how her story changed over time. In previous interviews and statements, she apparently said 30 minutes. And she always said it was a blue TARP! Not a damn raincoat!

[@aydenrussell5183]

Honestly, he doesn't care about anyone but himself! He murdered his wife and son!

[@sissy4506]

She is a woman of GOD and couldn't and wouldn't lie for anyone and I am so glad!!!GOD BLESS YOU AND YOUR FAMILY MA'AM ❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@dianeaustin2414]

People of God lie all the time. I believe her, though, not because of her religion.

[@deletarobinson8347]

She's doing the best she can under the circumstances. I hope she is paid for usurping this amount of time. Of course , I pray 🙏 for Alex's Soul as well.Prsyer is medicine.

[@leee646]

@@dianeaustin2414 Actions speak louder than words. Many who say they're people of God prove that they're not by being untruthful.

[@Hendrixtanell13]

@@leee646 yes 🙌🏾

[@starlingballet6082]

I DO NOT FOR ONE MINUTE BELIEVE THIS WOMAN IS LYING.I KNOW NOTHING OF BODY LANGUAGE AND SUCH BUT MY GUT ( FOR WHATEVER THATS WORTH), TELLS ME SHE'S ON THE STRAIGHT AND NARROW. WHAT I WANT TO KNOW IS WHY IN GODS SWEET NAME WOULD MR MURDAUGH MURDER IS LOVED ONES AND LEAVE ALL THESE PEOPLE TO MOP-UP AFTER HIS UNGODLY MESS!! CLEARLY MURDAUGH WAS HAVING AN ATTACK OF CONSCIENCE AND CAME THERE TO SOMEHOW ( CONFESS TO MAMA WHAT HE HAD DONE) . HE SHOULD HAVE GONE TO HIS MINISTER OR DROPPED DOWN ON HIS KNEES AND BEGGED OUR HEAVENLY FATHER'S FORGIVENESS FOR HIS MURDEROUS SINS!!! I HOPE THERE'S A PSYCH EVAL HAPPENING SOON OR ALREADY...FOR MURDAUGH

[@idontcare1481]

That poor sweet lady! She stood up for what was right and I truly admire her. She is a big reason justice hopefully will be had in this case.

[@heather3383]

@@a.f.365 Ohmigosh, I never heard the whole call!!! Good grief!!!

[@patcaillier3317]

Poor lady. They keep asking the same time over and over. Geez.

[@StonedBarbiee]

@@a.f.365 Paul said that not Alex.

[@LouiseNLotn]

@@heather3383 me either! That is crazy!

[@heather3383]

@@LouiseNLotn And she is a gramma!! You know, I didn’t know fear until I had my own family to protect, and there are horrible people in power that will do anything to keep their wealth and stature. I actually cried when Satterfield’s son took the stand and had to relive the exploitation of his mama’s “accidental” death. I’m sure Ms. Muchelle is afraid for her loved ones, too. This Murdaugh may he in lockdown, but he has an extensive family who isn’t, and she has to be able to work. I am heartsick and praying for this brave woman and her family.

[@nlcrme]

This lovely woman is my hero. I am a full time caregiver for my elderly parents, dad is 92 with late stage Alzheimer's and my 84 year old mother is blind and both are in hospital beds at my home. I also work full-time from home, I'm a programmer. I feel like I am up around the clock with mom and dad and with work, 7 days week and I have to grab 2 hours naps whenever I can and I am to the point of exhaustion. This magnificent woman gives of herself in so many ways and she still finds time to give more of herself. I got very emotional when she was sharing everything she did and how tenderly she spoke of caregiving for Alex's mom. I love my mom and dad very much and consider it an honor to care for them. What strikes me as to the most beautiful way she speaks of caregiving is she speaks with all the love and tenderness a caregiver would give to a most beloved family member ❤ This woman is an absolute treasure 💖 I look up to her and hope tobe as good of a caregiver and person as she is.

[@leoren2685]

Please look into respite care if you can. That it way too much for anyone to deal with alone.

[@antoniojones8738]

Much love and prayers to you stay strong and live and make the best of things and let God guide you. Take care

[@RhondaBennettTeam]

God bless you!

[@shahrzad7026]

I cried once i read your comments… You are an Inspiration… I salute You … You are Admirable… I feel what you said and all what you are going through… i have dedicated so much my life to many people… caring is always get you so much unspoken pain … 😭

[@chezzie9646]

That poor woman was afraid for her life, on the stand. She has some guts to go against her boss and possibly the most powerful family in SC . Bless her and her family. 🙏

[@kjh6903]

She does look terrified!!! I would be too . Poor thing didn’t ask for any of this .

[@marthataylor3413]

It is disgusting that he tried to use her for an aliby.

[@chezzie9646]

@@marthataylor3413 he thought she would cave in and agree with him. She stood for the truth. Bless her for doing that.

[@crimegeek]

Can we all give her the recognition she deserves!? What a selfless woman to take care of so many people. Her four children, other kids at school, then at night Mrs. Libby. Give credit where credit is due. 🏆

[@maryredeagle1358]

I thought this was a murder trial. Why all the financial statements?

[@estherstrategicadvisor749]

@@maryredeagle1358 Money is always relevant to people's character and motive

[@tracyguess8120]

Absolutely Amen 🙏

[@tracyguess8120]

@@estherstrategicadvisor749 you got that right 🙏

[@quovadisroberts1773]

​m at

[@michaeldailey7103]

This is a women who deserves respect and praise !!! She's obviously afraid , but she didn't let fear stop her from doing the right thing !!!! God bless you miss Shelly !!!!

[@tombryan1]

You want god to bless her when god let the killings take place, makes a lot of sense

[@margoatkins9166]

He rather did it our had someone do it he's play a big part of his family being murdered.

[@margoatkins9166]

Or had a big part of it

[@cherylkedzior]

I feel bad for ever ever ever saying I am tired!

[@terrydonoho9153]

​@@tombryan1who are you?

[@13Nena13]

Dang I feel for her. I can tell she didn’t want to tell on Alex. This selfish monster put her in a terrible situation. Glad she got through it and hopefully she can put this behind her.

[@sherricason1548]

It was just wrong to put her in this situation.

[@daniele5493]

Amen to that!

[@mariacampana7764]

She is brave and gutsy for sure…her tone came across with honest emotional words during her testimony & her answers did not sound staged. I realize they do a run down of possible questions the defense might bring up & what she may be asked by either side 🤔it’s when she says and basically is telling the jury when he “Alec” offered her help with the upcoming wedding during that conversation that night the “night of the murders” 😳 then precedes to have her recount him being there 45 minutes when it was a complete 🤥 to cover his tracks must of been very scary to degree of threatening ☝️ for sure is highly commendable on her part. Bravo 🙌🏼 👏 👏

[@aydenrussell5183]

​@@mariacampana7764 I agree!

[@CC_Babblecock]

Agree. I think she was conflicted, & didn’t want to say too much initially bc she was either fearful of AM, her job, or just confused about what was going on & wanted to get her bro/cops’ opinion. This is a great example of not to ever lie - he was damned with Paul’s video alone, & she would be in prison too if she did what she knew he wanted. This whole thing was such a mess, prosecutor consistently repeating inaccurate answers witnesses just gave him, standing in front of the camera, didn’t offer a tissue or help her down the stairs, disorganised, difficult to tell what point he was trying to make, reiterated things so much just going in circles, I couldn’t even tell whose side she was a witness of! The defence attorney was WAY better, he just had no chance in this. AM should have taken a plea bargain, it’s absolutely insane to think he could get off as not guilty on any of it, but he dragged everyone thru a trial for nothing, including his only surviving family member, his SON Buster. Didn’t care he lost his mom & bro, (& grandfather in the same week), let’s stick him on the stand too. Atrocious. The witness is a stellar member of the community, I’m appalled at how she was treated. The judge was the only one (being black himself) with any consideration that they speak differently (colloquially).

[@CG-qo2os]

It's very telling to me that she knew something was wrong when she said she called her brother. I've worked as a nanny and when something happens at work and I've had to call my Mom or a sibling because it's that upsetting and you are literally afraid, it's a horrible feeling. I believe everything she says.

[@avrilallison8224]

She is the type of woman that is way above the majority of human beings today. I have no words for this lady. Wish I had a mother like this . She is just so humble , truly the world needs more people like this

[@gaylestephenson9847]

She is the perfect example of a fine Christian Lady. God Bless Her.

[@jimvacuum]

@@gaylestephenson9847 wait giving false testimony? Is being a good Christian?

[@DA-ji4tf]

I am a lady like her, no mess no chasers. I work diligently every day.

[@georgiacunningham6883]

I am thankful for her, she reminds me of my SWEET mother.

[@tammymoore3667]

Yesss Lord need more

[@sashagirl1987]

Alex Murdaugh was trying to use this dear lady as an alibi and he said to her in an unspoken way to agree with him and he would help pay for her wedding AND help get her a good job at the school by putting in a good word with his Principal “friend”. Just so happened this beautiful lady has morals values and God in her life and DIDNT take Alex’s bait! No telling how many people he and his family have used hurt and ruined in their lives. Evil.

[@carolynm9638]

Did she say she testified truthfully bc of God? I must’ve missed that.

[@athenavan2242]

@@carolynm9638 I think that is an assumed value, most people of faith ain't going to go against their religious belief for a sick twisted entitled ass that AM is! I am sure this poor woman is afraid for her job I am sure that asshole could pick up the phone and have her job ended with a drop of the dime

[@athenavan2242]

@@carolynm9638 and after this trial is over she still has to live in the community that had catered to this prick

[@roxyloveslucy]

Lots, apparently. Somebody dies mysteriously around there, the Murdaugh family seems to be close by.

[@colleenthompson4069]

too bad Alec didn't have some "God" in his life ---- if he had, there's a good chance NONE of this would have happened

[@lucyseal8061]

This is the only person telling the whole truth without fearing this family. Good for miss Shelly. A brave force among us

[@texan903]

She was scared as hell on the stand, understandably. Going against a powerful family like the Murdaughs can bring serious ramifications. That's why she keeps saying they're good people.

[@carolenelake688]

I can't even remember what happened last week let alone two years ago. Kudos to this strong,humble soul.

[@t.c.8212]

This had to be extremely hard to do because she lives in an area where everyone knows everyone! Let protect her at all cost💪

[@DramaMustRemainOnTheStage]

She's in no danger

[@anthonycaruso3688]

What does that even mean? Protect from what?

[@lc6636]

She will be okay. The killer is locked up and no one wants anything to do with him.

[@blackberry_700]

@@anthonycaruso3688 l guess she missed God there before protect… “Let God protect her at all cost.”

[@X3AmySarah]

@@lc6636 it’s not just Alex.. I mean Buster is possibly connected to a death in 2015, then there’s the brothers of Alex. She needs to be protected. I hope she has some lead and training on how to use it just in case. This family is filled with psychopaths so it seems.

[@AbsolutelyNot86]

What a lovely and beautiful person this lady is. Bless her heart! She did such a great job.

[@abbiejordan7383]

💯

[@charlieballew2131]

She's a nervous nelly....but truly honest! GOD Please bless her and all who care as she obviously does.

[@michaelkline884]

She did indeed and the prosecutor did a nice job starting off with simple questions to calm her down even introducing her family! ❤

[@Ambigirl2011]

@@charlieballew2131 I would be nervous too. Remember this is the South, Murdaugh country, basically white. Black people don't feel very comfortable in a Southern courtroom, especially if they have to testify against their white employer. Get real. As a New Yorker and an African American, it's a little different. New Yorkers, are a little more assertive than southerners, which includes African Americans from New York.

[@aliceschmid9697]

The mumbling in a low tone is a bit annoying.

[@EBlueTX]

Knowing what the murdaughs did to Gloria their old nanny and housekeeper she was probably absolutely terrified to take the stand against evil Alex and his evil family her testimony was definitely the key to this case and was remarkable she handled it with class .

[@sandrabell3113]

This lady never thought caregiving would lead to being a key witness. Bless her heart and soul for her bravery. Praying for her calm and peace now and in the future. We all love you! ❤

[@GiftSparks]

@@annahale1187It’s like he went there to establish an alibi. This poor lady was being used to establish that for him. I just feel so sorry for her.

[@dollycarter8810]

I hated the way this woman was treated by both sides but I think she did her best under the circumstances. Also, while she was so upset that she was crying I got angry that NOBODY asked her if she needed a moment or even offered her a tissue! They just let her sit there being miserable. Even the judge should have interceded in my opinion. God Bless Her!

[@padmasalam5267]

Agreed 💯! Poor woman! She deserved better. They were cordial towards the Latino female witness though. I see the difference in treatment. Sad state of affairs, really! 🥂🥂🥂🥂🥂🥂🥂🥂Cheers mates!

[@wendyhannan2454]

Well said, I agree appalling really.

[@DaisyAnnabelle6]

I agree! The Lord is with her so he will protect her heart and mind! She is covered by his blood for her entire life! 🙏

[@ek2137]

I agree. Shameful!!!

[@eifiondavies1889]

None of them stepped in when she was in tears,is this skin colour again.

[@jillfarley520]

His cross exam was really irritating me, one would swear she was on trial and not a witness. Such a sweet woman.

[@rejai]

Okay, I'm not losing my mind. Was the same thing. Very uncomfortable to watch.

[@wendyhannan2454]

I felt the same thing, he was intimidating this lady.

[@ecclairmayo4153]

From the very start asking about her name. I didnt even finish. Very racist

[@VeronicaPerez-yz1ou]

Yes 😡🤬

[@Poshgardenherbs]

@@ecclairmayo4153 right

[@honeyqueen4619]

The lawyers are disrespectful of her. They are rude. Trying to trip her up. She such a wonderful person does not deserve this. They treat her as though she guilty

[@lillypad9960]

Her testimony was stellar. I applaud her for keeping herself together and her self control.

[@goldenniblings]

❤

[@nonyabiznus5416]

My heart breaks for her. Miss Shelly is a hard working woman. Caring for children and the infirmed elderly is both physically and mentally exhaustive. Having to endure the extra stress of the situation and subsequent trial has to be extra burdensome. I hope she will be okay.

[@shayalynn]

Yes 🙌 She’s always served in one way or another most of her life. It’s pretty inspiring. I pray she will be okay and be blessed.

[@rillyjo5810]

I'm glad Alex didn't kill her like he did the other lady

[@x1314700xx]

Exactly.

[@sallythomas1503]

She is very nervous almost too scared to talk

[@tammycooper1500]

She should never had to be put in this position. Mudaugh does not care who he hurts or how he does it. He only cares about himSELF . Scum of the earth. I hope SC finds him guilty and I hope SC has death penalty. If anybody ever deserves it is mam who kills his wife and son deliberately, methodically and violently. Looks like he chased them around murdered them

[@wildflowers6486]

I hope she sees all these amazing comments! She needs to know how well respected she is despite that piece of garbage showing her zero respect. She's, kind, compassionate, and worked her butt off for her family. All his money couldn't buy him an ounce of the class she has.

[@arlenesmith1708]

Amen! I am just watching some of these testimonies. My heart hurts, to my surprise, I am crying with her. He wanted her to lie. I am not surprised...shame on him! We have seen this behavior sooo many times.. My entire family is from SC...we still have homes there. What do we always heer..."this fine gentlemen", "up standing, pillar of our community/ society". (Makes me want to laugh.) We know better and should tell those TRUE STORIES. DON'T LIE FOR ANYONE!

[@amyperazzo6287]

Yes, true.

[@jackpack3506]

I just want to hug her and thank her❤

[@dianecandoflamtaps3688]

I agree! I’m thinking about your comment about all his money. It’s all the money…he stole from others!!

[@MegaHockeyman20]

She’s not gonna see these comments… why even comment this

[@kristigregory4017]

I feel SO bad for her.. you'd think SHE was on trial for murder. Kudos to her for remaining humble & truthful! We need more Shelly's in the world!

[@jerseygall]

I feel so bad for her, it's nerve wracking being on the witness stand-but she did the right thing, regardless of how hard it was. I once had to testify, and it shook me to the core. God Bless you Ms Smith. Your are very much appreciated ♥

[@sublimebeauty1840]

❤️

[@BATTLERAPSHADEROOM]

❤️❤️

[@candacetimphony4299]

This is the worst line of questioning I have ever seen. This lawyer is taking an hour to for what should have taken 10 minutes. Mrs. Smith you handled yourself so well

[@karmansanders8047]

Asking her over and over the same thing almost.. trying to confuse her.. he’s rude and the judge is too..

[@yrp237]

I agree. I'm 3/4 in and I'm confused as hell. She said the blue tarp incident was 3 days after Mr Murdaugh Srs funeral at 6:30am then the prosecutor later said Alex showed up "that night" with the blue tarp. So which was it? And if she'd only ever gone upstairs 2 times in 3 years, was one of the times that morning to see the blue tarp layed out? Why then did she decide to go upstairs that day?? And what exactly did she relay to her brother on the phone about Alex suggesting he was there 30-40 mins and where is the in-house Alameda video since they had a camera and who controlled that camera!!?? 🤔 Did sled not investigate these things?

[@klmmc]

This lawyer is annoying, he blocks the witness, and you can't see her, then is constantly moving back and forth.

[@diapricea4888]

A good old boy southern lawyer, I worked for some...in SC rude and crude

[@diapricea4888]

Rude crude arrogant good old boy attorney too proud to offer her a tissue. I hope Karma eats him, this is sad to see. His tone of voice is condescending. I wish someone would slap him. He's maddening.

[@diapricea4888]

This woman is a role model. Loving, caring, honest hard working lady. I honor her spirit and soul.

[@fasustinasmith5414]

What a Saint. ..truly. Remarkable woman.

[@thegoodthebadandtheugly9920]

This woman has minded her own business her whole life. Shame on every one of these individuals for dragging her through this. It's obvious she fears the repercussions she's going to receive from this. What has happened is beyond a tragedy, but this is just as bad, rich-ass entitled people messing with the truly innocent, this infuriates me. No one deserved to die, especially this way, but every one of them from the grandfather to the youngest son had their pinky involved in some form of a dirty deed one way or another.

[@PresleysMom504]

Thank god the defense didn’t treat her as poorly as he treated others. Still, you can tell how he’s subtly trying to discredit her (which, fine, whatever that’s his job) and twist her words. I feel for her, for sure, this isn’t fair. I was glad when she finally said “I don’t remember, it’s been so long.”

[@dolocapo5430]

these rich ass entitled pigs make me sick that they were gonna run some game on this poor woman.....

[@lisab7570]

You couldn’t of said this any better.

[@jeanfarmer3495]

What a heartless jerk no different than the man he represents. Ms. Shelly you are the epitome of beauty, grace and honesty may God continue to bless you ❤

[@Shadeed33]

Give her her flowers! She deserves to be treated with dignity and respect!!!!

[@minimalist2036]

I love this comment!

[@louettesommers8594]

AMEN.

[@therealz360z7]

Considering the reputation powerful men in the south have it is obviously extremely difficult for this woman to come forward and I'd like to tell her thank you .He can't hurt you and your strength will help to get justice for his victims.

[@Barb417]

You mean privileged white Liberal men.

[@leximarie3808]

I don't get it. Murdaugh played her like a fiddle but she's not outraged. Getting information/testimony from her is like pulling teeth and she called him a wonderful man several times. I don't find her testimony anything other than hostile. "A good person". Right, tell that to the kids of his former housekeeper. Honestly, I don't find her credible.

[@DramaMustRemainOnTheStage]

@@leximarie3808 hostile meaning she's not there by choice for those that don't understand what hostile witness needs

[@DramaMustRemainOnTheStage]

Why do you think only powerful men are in the south? We thank you for that btw.

[@Barb417]

@lexi marie I think she was trusting of the family. When the shootings occurred, she witnessed more than she wanted to. She's probably had a million people coming at her for information since that fatal night. Most importantly, you can see how fearful she is to say what she really wants to say. That's why she keeps saying "he's a good man". She is a victim also. Wrong place at the wrong time. I feel sorry for her.

[@_aje]

This is what an honest witness looks like. We applaud you! May God bless you with many prosperous years to come.

[@cliffordjones7329]

That’s exactly what an honest witness looks like. Those who have nothing to hide, hide nothing!

[@audreydiane7499]

If everyone worked a fraction of how hard this lady does the world would definitely be a way better place! She seems like the sweetest person.♡

[@MOEWETTA23]

I agree with you💯 You're a cutie by the way lol

[@martharoark4059]

She has been placed in a horrible position where she was asked to lie. The long line of a dynasties unraveling because of lying and greed. This woman is amazing.

[@susiethompson5123]

And her allegiance was still to the family. Precious soul.

[@ivory8581]

I am confused because at first she testified specifically that he didn't tell her to say anything to anyone about how long he was there He just stated how long he was there. Then the next time the prosecutor says he told you to tell someone. And she said something to the effect of if law enforcement asks, I was here 30-40 min.

[@kathypearl5108]

I couldn't help but notice the lawyer who asked Ms. Smith questions first did not offer her a tissue when she was crying but he offered the lawyer a tissue. Also he rudely said to her "Get back up there" when saying to Ms. Smith to go back to the stand. Kindness isn't difficult.

[@josn1053]

Lawyers seemed not happy with what she said and the lawyer acted rude telling her to go back and sit down.

[@kathypearl5108]

@josn1053 how professional!!! NOT!!

[@aylen3322]

The whole time I’m thinking get this woman a freakin tissue already. Geez. She deserves it.

[@anonymouslee8287]

@@josn1053 The south and they let them talk to them any type of way...Ancestors traits!...

[@annebalderston2520]

Some lawyers will do anything for money.

[@davidsnyder4801]

This woman is the ONLY person i feel bad for in this entire situation....

[@esthergarciamelgoza4805]

.. and Blanca, the housekeeper.

[@trishmckenzie8810]

Awwww... she looks so scared heartbreaking 💔 😢 How incredibly brave she is. She put her fear aside to speak the truth inspite of Murdoughs' intimidation and bribery. Angel 😇 on earth. ❤️ her

[@lachick74]

Those tears are because she knows he’s guilty, but on the other hand, she also loves them! She’s so nervous, and uncomfortable! She’s trying her best to articulate her words but her nerves are making it hard!! She’s justa simple, God fearing woman who wants to tell her truth!

[@lauragosnell2481]

I feel so bad for her! It is so difficult to speak when you are nervous but throw wanting to cry in the mix and it’s over! She is doing fantastic for the situation and bless her heart for speaking up!!

[@kathleensueoka3599]

She has fear in those tears. He killed and could again had to have been on her mind.

[@ShebrewQueen]

Who wants to tell “the” truth.

[@gaylestephenson9847]

Why do they keep saying they can't understand her? She speaks perfectly well and is very clear in her thoughts and words. This is pure intimidation- I hate it, but it is exactly what powerful MEN do to those they believe are beneath them.

[@gabesmom29]

I don’t understand why he is acting almost hostile. She is his witness isn’t she? Doesn’t sound like he did a good preparation with her prior to this testimony. That’s part of his job. It’s like he’s enjoying badgering her at times.

[@cyama8679]

Honesty is one of the best attributes of a person. May God bless this amazing and courageous woman.

[@melodieperkins7080]

Yes, if you tell the truth you don't have to look behind you. Speaking the truth gives you peace.

[@greeneyedsoutherngirl6468]

You have to look behind you when you work for a Murdaugh. Look how many “accidents” have happened to the people around them! But yes, God will protect her and so will the people of Hampton.

[@jessicaoxendine1691]

God Bless Her♥️ You can tell she is a loving, caring, hardworking, beautiful lady! The way they treated her is pure sickening!!! Pisses me off that they not once offered her a tissue or any water! I’m from NC just a few hours away from where this took place. We are Southerners and we have an accent. The way they treated her period was just WRONG! Sending Ms Shelly lots of love, hugs & prayers from NC♥️ I hate that someone with such a beautiful soul was made to be put in this position. Watching this has been heartbreaking ❤️‍🩹 Ms Shelly I pray for peace & comfort and that you may live a prosperous life!!

[@lekiahall2702]

She is traumatized yet she is strong. Stared directly in his direction, as she identified him. Then paid him dust. He chose the wrong person he thought he could manipulate or intimidate. Her God and conscience is mightier than any fear he could evoke. Best wishes for Ms. Muchelle 👑❤️

[@kes78]

He did the same with the lovely housekeeper. He totally misjudged the fact that these are honest, kind hard working people. Everything he's not.

[@Ole.miss.Georgiawoman]

This woman is the epitome of outstanding character. The lawyers did not treat her respectfully, that repulsed me. Good bless you madam.

[@paulinemuthena6545]

The way they are questioning her you would think she commited the murder..They are all guzzling their water but never offered her any.

[@boundariessetinstone5893]

Lawyers are L’s

[@karmakat7710]

They're in nauth cahlina-- I wouldn't live in the south of it was FREE!

[@Ole.miss.Georgiawoman]

@@karmakat7710 I live in the south, and wouldn’t live anywhere else. I grew up in Wisconsin, and never thought I’d be a southern, now I’m glad I am. There are evil people everywhere, don’t judge the south by the Murdaugh trial.

[@christasumner4020]

I so agree. I love the South. Good and bad folks everywhere. I don't judge all of the North based on that comment

[@tonisodano5472]

This woman deserves our respect, honor & grace !

[@jonaydogan2275]

Amen !

[@lillyanp4]

💯💯💯👍🏻

[@YcatsMartinez]

Love her. Hard working salt of the earth. Pure gold. Absolutely believable. You can tell that the truth of this situation is painful for her. I’m sorry her life was tainted by this horrible situation, but I’m grateful for her honesty. I’m currently caring for my father with dementia. It’s a hard job and it’s my only job, though unpaid, and yet this amazing woman not only is a caregiver, but works full time for the school district. Amazing human being.

[@PennelopeWhitmore]

I take care of my mom too. She doesn't have dementia but the symptoms she has is very similar to it. Would it be easier for you and her if you did get paid? I had a savings but it didn't last very long and my mom doesn't get a whole lot so I looked into getting paid from the state. It doesn't come out of her pocket and I can help her with bills and groceries. It depends what state you live in and it keeps her home and not in one. God bless.😊

[@user-eu2me4bp7j]

Eh we shouldn’t celebrate people only for sacrificing and working like a dog. It’s not sustainable. I hope she takes care of herself ❤

[@YcatsMartinez]

@@PennelopeWhitmore fortunately, my father was very prepared financially. I’m also married and my husband was very supportive. My employer also gave me my position back after my Dad passed. I shouldn’t have sounded like I was complaining. I only mentioned payment because undoubtedly the Murdaughs paid this woman for her work. I hope you are doing alright. Caring for my Dad was the worst but most rewarding thing I’ve ever done. I had help though as there a professional caregiver usually on hand. Again, I hope you and your mother are doing alright. I know it’s hard. I’m sorry.

[@YcatsMartinez]

@@user-eu2me4bp7j I don’t know anything about this woman other than what I took from this video. Honesty and determination are what I saw. She’ll live her life as she sees fit. I hope everyone takes care of themselves, but you can’t make them. Some people are just wired selflessly. ❤️

[@PennelopeWhitmore]

@@YcatsMartinez that's wonderful . God bless you dear. I'm sure your dad is so thankful for you. If we had more people like you this planet would be a better place.

[@804smiles]

It's very refreshing to finally be able to see there are some good people left walking amongst us! I 🙏🏽 she is well & feels some comfort in knowing she did the right thing couldn't have been easy to do this in front of the world. ❤️ Here's to u Miss Shelly!!! 👏🏽

[@WC188_1]

Can't go wrong in telling the truth.!

[@brendacolinger6450]

What a wonderful person Muchelle is. Great work ethic and a go-getter. God bless her.

[@magdaline6383]

Thanks to technology, his SUV was at that house for about 20 minutes.

[@beckyf569]

Her pain was palpable when she had to repeat what Alex said to her. You can just tell that she doesn’t want anything to do with this but she knows she must because it’s the right thing to do. Bless her heart 🙏🏻♥️🙏🏻

[@porschialauren]

You can literally feel her energy thru whatever ur using to watch this on. Such a sweet kind loving soul. I hope you see all these comments and see how hundreds of thousands of people support you and admire the woman you are. PROTECT THIS WOMAN AT ALLLLL COST !!!!!

[@bluecollarlit]

Yes, she's compelling.

[@kayrhoads8938]

I totally agree, Murdaughs lawyer was not very nice!

[@1misscole]

@PorschiaLauren I'm Feeling The Same Way BC With ALL The 🦬💩 Going On In The World Right Now It Dose Make A Difference Knowing We Still Have Good People In This World😇

[@allthejuice8236]

I wish someone will make her a GoFundMe

[@daniele5493]

Absolutely!!! From this family!!! This Brave Lady Shelly!!!🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽

[@hattiesallie2622]

From 2019 to 2021 she work two jobs, one being overnight care. 🙌🏾 I applaud her so much!

[@remedy9648]

Agreed! She seems like the most humble, loving, hard working lady and from the second she took that stand I thought wow! I’d love to be surrounded by people like her.

[@louettesommers8594]

@@remedy9648 I agree 100% . The world needs more people like Ms.Smith. God bless her.

[@seneseduhart8412]

@@louettesommers8594 she is a queen

[@texan903]

@@seneseduhart8412 she's not a queen but she is a nice, honorable, upstanding lady.

[@SuperKlaipeda]

Not one pr1ck offered her tissues or water, like wtf 🤬 And are they all bloody deaf 😡........ Sweetheart you have done amazing job ❤️ So much love and respect goes out to you and your family ❤️🙏

[@patiencebossert5523]

Why did no one give this beautiful soul a tissue and water. and even a break to catch her breath.

[@histerp51]

I feel sooo badly for Shelly…She loved these people and did her best and he expected this good lady to lie…Abused everyone including her…just wicked and very sad for her.

[@tennesseestephani1353]

She didn’t love them she feared them.

[@davewilliam1319]

Hello beautiful can I ask you a question?🙏🌹💐

[@justkiddin84]

@@davewilliam1319not a pick up spot, dude.

[@Sunn777]

@@justkiddin84glad you straighten him out. Ridiculous.

[@justkiddin84]

@@Sunn777 I mean, you can’t walk outside your house without some creep getting in your space. At least leave us alone on a news site!

[@hannahhuntermimi]

Wow! I am in disbelief about how poorly both sides treated this sweet, kind, honest, hardworking African American woman. The way the judge ridiculed her when he said “we cannot understand you so just speak up because I guess you cannot change your voice!” Everyone in there has a heavy southern accent. Obviously, she is soft spoken, and she was nervous and had been thrown into a messy situation that she never should have been burdened with. They didn’t even offer her a tissue or give her a minute to compose herself when she started to cry. Despicable!

[@anaalarcon11]

It’s a court not tv court show

[@mikaylaevans8749]

Right!!! I wish i had a few minutes with the guy with the glasses on 🤬

[@thecrazypinkcatlady]

The judge himself is a person of color who grew up in this same Southern culture so I’m mindboggled at the way he treated her.

[@lilactuliee6953]

​@@anaalarcon11 They give people tissue in court. These lawyers showed no manners or humanity towards her.

[@gssm4289]

Tells you much about how they think of certain ppl. No tissue because they don't care. They think she feels no pain. So she doesn't deserve to he treated with dignity. Smh

[@lavernejackson1958]

This woman is an angel. She’s salt of the earth. Hardworking

[@GiovanniSpruzzatinia]

Can we celebrate this hard working, beautiful, God fearing/loving and absolute exemplary woman that has a heart full of love & compassion to care for others...She deserves so many blessings from God...she will forever be in my heart & prayers...

[@marinafrancesoldman1819]

You don't have to be God fearing ( what an awful expression by the way) to be a good person. People shouldn't be good because they are afraid of a god punishment! It should be conscience and morality!

[@GiovanniSpruzzatinia]

@@marinafrancesoldman1819 And he said to man, ‘Behold, the fear of the Lord, that is wisdom, and to turn away from evil is understanding.’” (Proverbs 1:7) Let all the earth fear the Lord; let all the inhabitants of the world stand in awe of him! (Psalm 33:8) Is your problem the mere mention of God? Because when raising a child ,some parents threaten to ground them or take away video games etc...and it's the FEAR of losing something the child likes that keeps them on the straight and narrow...and we are ALL God's children & in living by God's word, teaches us morality & what is right & wrong & how we should love & treat others...or it can simply be the fear of letting God down or striving to live a life of service to others the way that Jesus did...and living on this earth in a way that will hopefully get us to the kingdom of Heaven with our Lord and savior for eternity when our life on this earth is done....fear/ respect can go hand in hand often...So learn where morality is born from before talking down or insulting another person you don't know or never met ...that isn't being morally conciences🤷‍♀️ but regardless, I don't have to know you to tell you that I love you as my brother/sister in Christ,and will be praying for you ...Have a blessed day 😉🙏🙌

[@jayb2491]

This lady has genuine hurt and emotions for this family. My mother was a nursing aid for over 30 years and she was same way with her patients giving more genuine love than their own families did.

[@rhonda-oy9er]

He mad bcuz she would not lie for him

[@teotaylor4]

It took courage for her to deliver this testimony. May God bless this lady.

[@angelag6223]

She's nervous, she's scared, with reason. When he mentioned her job at the school, when he mentioned her upcoming marriage. He was letting her know he has "the means" to ..... intimidation was his main goal. I felt bad for her while watching this .

[@gaiabeleza]

I hope this woman feels all the love, compassion and respect thousands of us feel for her!!! ❤

[@jeffreyzeiss1326]

I feel so bad this honest humble sweetheart of a woman had to go through this. What a hard-working person and what a beautiful soul she has. Wish there were more people in the world like her.

[@daver1787]

Unbelievable woman. Wonderful.

[@windywednesday4166]

Yes! Actually, there are more people in the world like her they're just not the loud screaming ones we hear about. This woman is a gem. 💎

[@jaggirl]

It's a racist area. In my opinion.

[@lillyanp4]

💯💯💯

[@lisagerman5593]

Living in racist Walterboro, SC this woman is a true SHERO!! Being a true hard worker and to endure what she had to being on trail is a true example of a good, kind spirited person and it is a shame we don’t have more people like her. She is an example of love and not hate and racism like the people she cared and worked for!!!

[@Changeiscoming47]

Having followed this case and trial from the beginning, this sweet and loving woman broke my heart more than anything so far. She was clearly distraught, trembling, and crying. Alex stared her down during her entire testimony. He’s a monster and sociopath who used and abused everyone who had the misfortune of crossing his path.

[@sashaann9679]

Very well said 👏

[@LizzaJo]

He drips arrogance 😞

[@ritag7306]

Somebody give her tissues! I hope this arrogant pos gets harshest sentence possible

[@oliviaclaireokeefe8596]

Couldn’t have said It better myself. Retweet. 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻

[@jewelsbug84]

Buster looks like a sociopath. No emotion

[@annettepolvere9981]

I feel so sorry for her being put through this. She seems like a wonderful person.

[@nancyhuber9479]

AM made so many people suffer. This lawyer was so rude and condescending. It’s just despicable. God Bless you, Muchell. I wish you all the best and lots of love ❤️

[@mariannescalise6658]

Such a hard working woman 2 jobs raised 4 kids and 8 grandchildren she is an amazing woman ! I hope God blesses this hard working woman and eases things in her life she is a wonderful women who is caught in a horrible trial shes honest and its hard when you were involved with the family and him telling her about her school job and he knows the principal thats scary the things he said to her and even the amount of time he said he was there it seems like hes trying to intimidate her and he would help her with her wedding thats scary!! No wonder shes crying and shes telling the truth!! Its not easy when your testimony can cause problems for the family you were working for!! Hugs sweet lady! You did good! MY OPINION

[@jaqilevi3563]

It's almost shocking that she worked that many hours. When did she see her own family. That's sad.

[@duststorm2699]

He is diabolical & knew how to scare her.

[@LO-en6is]

Yes she is a strong beautiful honest lady. God bless her!

[@donna5499]

What a Beautiful Lady, you can see how hard for her because she has loved this family. I wouldn’t want to be in her shoes.The truth will set her free. Keeping you in my prayers Sweet Lady, you are a very Strong Lady. Hugs my heart 💜 goes out to you💜🙏🫂

[@lindadavis3728]

She is still employed by Alec's mom. I can understand how hard this must be for her. She is a very honest, brave person.

[@saardfetner8620]

The lawyer is excellent doing his job and so is the witness. Life goes on. No mercy in this case. It is the way things are. Sometimes you are at the wrong place. Be aware of wolves in sheep clothing. Satan is working hard during our last days.

[@adinalewis7118]

Is she really....

[@lindadavis3728]

@@adinalewis7118 Maybe I wrong about that. Thanks.

[@brandimyhren6317]

I respect this woman so much. The murderer could have harmed her just as easily. She must of always felt so awkward when he came around because he is evil.

[@MyHome7_Carla]

She has an abundance of strength and patience. I love the way she did not allow the Def counsel to intimate her. She stood her ground! God bless her!

[@nene1964]

This woman must be scared for her life. Her statement is so damning. She’s so brave for doing this.

[@angiepattillo3599]

I feel like that's the reason she was crying.

[@Luke-pb4pc]

What if it really wasn't him but he k kws who it was or what if he really was out scoring drugs

[@nolie021]

Exactly! She knows how influential they are or…were. Incredible bravery to speak the truth. She could have easily accepted the bribes. A woman of strong ethics❤

[@karinklaustermeier4009]

The lawyer having her brother and daughter stand up seems like intimation. We know who your people are.

[@joyl3321]

@@karinklaustermeier4009 Exactly - what the hell was the purpose of that???

[@cynsmi]

My heart breaks for this lovely lady. To be working two jobs and then have this low life putting pressure her like this when she cared so much for his family. There are no words to describe what a beast he is.

[@annebalderston2520]

Why doesn’t this stupid lawyer get a box of Kleenex? Poor lady.

[@journeytoabetteru]

Exactly and I don’t think for one minute that he didn’t threaten her, I don’t believe he just said I been here 30-40 minutes, he said more than that! She is very aware of how connected he is/was. I pray that God protects her from any hurt harm or danger in Jesus Name 🙏🏾 Amen

[@pepsiyummie1]

Reading the comments brought tears to my eyes. We all feel the same way😘. Wonderful people commenting on a wonderful person. Love that so much!😊

[@chrisnewburg4839]

Ugh I want to give this incredibly strong woman a hug. I could feel her angst thru my screen. God bless you, Shelley.

[@krj55575]

She has such a humble spirit about her. You can tell that it broke her heart when he told her that he was there for 30 or 40 minutes. She loved them, and they were good to her. She wants to believe he’s a good person. Such a beautiful soul!

[@jaymaeberhard1590]

Any family would be blessed to have such a loving and caring lady providing care to their loved ones.

[@gaylestephenson9847]

@@jaymaeberhard1590 I want her to take care of me!! Such a precious soul.

[@myrnasherman4351]

This witness is absolutely amazing. She in my eyes is the epitome of the American backbone. I applaud her courage. GOD BLESS YOU MAM

[@elizabethhayes4505]

She did not deserve that. HAVE SOME RESPECT for the witness

[@frelnc]

This disgusting lawyer asked her the same questions over and over and over. And she tried to answer everything he asked. I'm really amazed that nobody objected "asked and answered". He wants to act like he's being kind and considerate, but he's not. He wanted her to lie for him and tell the jury he'd been there 30 or 40 minutes. But no matter how he tried to confuse here or distract her, she told the truth.

[@kathismith7441]

I agree

[@patsypruitt8927]

I did! I'm yelling, asked, and answered jeez.

[@colleenthompson4069]

trying to get her to misstate her answers by badgering or intimidating her. Typical tactic to try to find a hole to create an illusion of doubt. The defense knows they have an uphill battle trying to get jury empathy or jury to acquit. All of the finance stuff has nailed his coffin shut so they need to break witnesses to deflect the obvious appearance of guilt

[@kathismith7441]

@@colleenthompson4069 agree

[@dogsbestfriend9]

The lawyers having her repeat her words for effect to the jury. We'll see how she's cross examined. AM is a monster to try and make this woman an accomplice by lying

[@lisasenn86]

Makes me want to cry listening to her. Wondering why this attorney isn’t getting her a tissue. The tears are streaming down her cheeks. Can only imagine how she feels. She’s a good woman.

[@RoyalFlush7096]

Because he’s clueless.

[@marvalousmarva6190]

I was just reading the comments and I came across yours, I made a comment in regards to why nobody offered her any tissue as well. It was rude not to, I felt so bad for her.

[@ritag7306]

Same!!!! Where were the tissues!!!

[@justsan1477]

He offered tissue to a male witness who started to sob, and happened to be a lawyer friend of the defendant.

[@CAJUNBEE]

Some people have no compassion! I feel for this women also. She needs to be very proud of herself for telling the truth!

[@annerose1925]

This woman was remarkable. She endured an exhausting troubling experience and was able to keep her sense about her. A smart diligent hardworking individual and a terrific role model. I hope she finds peace and a pleasant satisfying and hsppy future.

[@marinafrancesoldman1819]

No, she is not testifying clearly

[@KM-bu8ec]

Yeah, I think it's inappropriate that the attorney asked her family to stand up to be identified for the very reason that the defendant may want to get revenge for her testimony. This makes me furious!!! Does anyone else agree?

[@MomWentBackpacking]

Yes!!!! That was my immediate thought! Sort of a way to intimidate her before her testimony!

[@LR-ux4fh]

I did overnight caregiving shifts for patients with dementia when I was in nursing school in college. It's very taxing and exhausting. God bless this woman, for doing the right thing.