Did God Create Evil?

[@rohitshete145]

*Mental peace is the highest form of happiness. May all people reading this comment live a peaceful and happy life.*

[@lourdesangulo413]

Bless you too. ❤️🌟

[@topramennoodle21]

Yes peace of mind in everyday living is happiness to me. May you be well.

[@shashankhebbar1921]

No sir mental peace is the beginning of happy life

[@gsand07]

Rohit Shete blessings to you💖😘

[@idaloup6721]

To be Supramental is the key. It's a bit colder but at least It's peace. We are aware of our emotions and they don't control us anymore.

[@_HeARTSconnection]

Interesting. It seems like he's saying we create it by disconnecting from the source, which leads to unconsciousness, and evil being done during those delusional episodes of unconsciousness. Dang. 🤯 If we stay in the present, we will know how to let those thought forms which may consist of evil things, pass by. The stuff I'm learning from this man is way more valuable than anything I learned in school.

[@grunerfaden5223]

lets hope, they will teach his teachings more and more in schools all over the earth. Imagine what a difference this could make

[@vincentrobibero2077]

@@grunerfaden5223 It would develop a new generation that could be free of thoughtless beliefs and behavior by provoking the inner self to guide us instead.

[@mlg1279]

@@grunerfaden5223 It was indeed taught in schools of ancient India. However, the British replaced it with "modern" education

[@genobeano999]

you are very right school will not lead you to conscienceness.......its way deeper than that for me it was a war zone ...........it will wake you up but you still have to work at it but not as hard I believe ...........it could be a lost of a Son etc.....and other dramatic experience........... wish you all the Best my Friend

[@_HeARTSconnection]

​@@genobeano999 I understand. It is a struggle but it's so worth it. Thank you, I wish you all the best too. 💛

[@nedamandkarian4015]

I love it when he says "Let's see what is the intuitive answer" and then he keeps silent for some time before he gives the answer. He totally connects with his higher self to receive the answer.

[@themadgamer4571]

It's not just Eckhart that deserves the credit for changing human consciousness. You, and everyone else deserve just as much credit as him. Human consciousness is changing on it's own, Eckhart has just been one of the most aware and a profound voice for this evolution. But we are all a part of it. I appreciate Eckhart and I appreciate you reading this just as much. Have a wonderful day!

[@marlenelara9300]

❤ that’s right, he is just helping us to awake ❤

[@shevawnprather7162]

So are you saying that evil is used as a tool to guide us to conscienceness? I’m still not totally clear on this. 🙏

[@Giannhs_Kwnstantellos]

May we evolve to something beyond what we are now!

[@chrismccaffrey8256]

And it has been seeded and shifted by incarnations that became enlightened - Jesus, Buddha, Krishna, and all other ascended masters. They paved the way. The return of christ is now, through eckhart as one of the major western or even world spiritual teachers. And yes, us.

[@HMm-xi5se]

Exactly. Consciousness will be, and different containers will receive it differently but it always is ❤

[@whoopdeedoo876]

I wish everyone on earth could realize we are all one and that when we hurt another, we hurt ourselves.

[@alphaetomega]

We only align ourselves with the things we must experience in order to grow.

[@sirdushon]

Holder Of Hands !!!! 🌏✨

[@alphaetomega]

As the ancient saying goes "you can't con an honest man." Translate that as you wish

[@NenaLavonne]

♥️🙏

[@rubyquail]

Should we not hurt others to avoid pain for ourselves?

[@luisterrust]

To anyone: may all your biggest dreams come true this year, despite everything that happened. Love from Holland 🇳🇱❤️

[@spiritguided655]

Amen 🙏🙏🇨🇮

[@westcoast6314]

Ja bro laten wij onze best doen

[@carolinecollins8246]

Blessings and love always 🙏 to you to 🤗🌸🥰💞😊

[@janec.kowalczyk5824]

#Rightbackatcha ❤😊

[@cesarscreations5833]

Zelfde man🙏

[@usmc1875]

i love it when after putting forward the question he was asked, he just goes silent, and start to download all of it, to give us the wisdom:)

[@Zombied77]

I thought he was communicating in morse code for a minute.

[@karenjohnson5149]

Yes

[@ahmedwaly9073]

Exactly

[@SuperPinkblossom]

We are all love. We have to see our divinity. Go towards love. Choose love. See the god in us. Stay away from anything otherwise that has been created due to ego and fear and societal conditioning (evil) We have to choose our divinity. Choose oneness. The moment of power is our choice and that is in this present moment. ✨❤️✨

[@lifewithbeej]

Hi if you're reading this, I love you❤️

[@NBT2469]

Sending you my love, my friend.

[@SuperPinkblossom]

❤️

[@s.e.f8160]

Receiving your love and sending back my love to you 💜

[@NenaLavonne]

🙏🦋

[@hallohier3778]

Thank you ❤️ your comment makes me very happy 😊

[@SPRITIUAL]

so evil is the reflection of me, my fears,my judges, my painful thoughts... If I can transform my fears the evil will dissapear..

[@trutherone2140]

To experience joy, one must first experience sorrow. We are here to experience both in this place of duality.

[@ilovebeinggay6794]

Absolute RUBBISH! Any true God could create it so that you wouldn't need to experience the opposite. So are you now gonna say that God doesn't have the power or the intelligence or the love to do that? Can't wait to hear the insanity in your reply, that's IF you have GUTS enough to DEFEND what you posted.

[@eekay5710]

It was never the Father's heart that we should experience any sorrow, just as it never is any earthly father's heart for his kids. We also are not here to experience both in this place of duality as you have it. We are here to display the Christ life, to manifest Him and to be in a love relationship with the living Father and Son, as this is eternal life right here and now! John 17:3

[@ilovebeinggay6794]

@@eekay5710 hush 🤫

[@eekay5710]

@@ilovebeinggay6794 Give me one good reason why I must 'hush'.. only one good reason?

[@ilovebeinggay6794]

@@eekay5710 because you don't know what you're talking about. That's the only reason there is.

[@IntegralYogaPodcast]

And those who were seen dancing were thought to be insane by those who could not hear the music.

[@marialawal7449]

Love that

[@alizmusic0]

What about those who can hear the music and still consider those who dance insane?

[@Protector0ne]

The Fool on the Hill

[@justanotherfool7668]

@@Protector0ne sees the sun go down

[@caroleorr5461]

Just wanted to thank every one for your comments on this beautiful spiritual teacher. I know its virtual connections, but I feel it through out my being when I read everyone's comments. Blessed be we are all one...

[@macbeavers6938]

"I am the goodness without end, and the badness which makes the goodness good." --Conversations with God by Neale Donald Walsch

[@ethandaat7496]

Blessings from Syria we too watch you here, love and light to all

[@Wdominguez20111]

Why is it that these things he says absolutely resonate as true, within all of us to one degree or another, yet we still struggle to remember them when we most need to? Breaking our lifelong conditioning is such a challenge, but it’s probably the one challenge that’s most worth the difficult journey. I hope you all find whatever it is that you’re looking for. ❤️ ✌️

[@andrereloaded1425]

Well said. We all know yet many of us forget and need reminding.

[@freetibet1000]

Well said. The question why we still struggle and experience suffering after having heard an explanation that we really believe to be true is an important one. My way of thinking about it is that words acts as a form of a gate into a realm of knowing but is only a starting-point on a journey of transformation. Why are not words enough to change us? I believe not until this knowing have become part of our whole being wise words will still only hold superficial value for us. Not until every cell in our body knows it to be true we will still be torn between enlightenment and ignorance. The important thing is to enter into the gate of knowledge and wisdom and steadfastly walk the way of transformation through using the skillful means that many genuine spiritual traditions have given us throughout countless generations. This is the path we must all walk in order to return to the sun. By doing so we will be part of the process for the universe to become conscious and aware. This is the reason we are here now and our ultimate goal and meaning. Wisdom arise from within and points towards a non-dual reality. For this process of becoming awakened we first need to hear it from a perceived “outsider”, but in reality wisdom is a dormant reality that will arise from within ourselves. Wisdom is the transformation of ignorance and arise out of our own experiences. Only when we are able to transform our mistaken perception of reality will wisdom arise within us. That is the ultimate reason somebody else’s words are not enough to transform us, unless we happened to be on the brink of a final transformation anyway. Our own (mistaken) beliefs in duality, time and solid reality stands in the way of sudden insight and awakening.

[@andreahoyosl]

I love Eckhart. Through his teachings I have found my own inner peace

[@NenaLavonne]

He is a wonderful human ♥️

[@ProjectCarTV]

Have you never tried finding it yourself by not trying?

[@ReformedWhiteKnight]

Andrea Hoyos - what are his ‘teachings’? What is your own inner peace? How would you even know it is your own inner peace? Accord to what he says here he vaguely talks about that there is no separateness ... so maybe you are just assuming it’s your inner peace when you are just streaming a part of my inner peace at the same time? And what is inner peace? Is there an outer and an inner peace? Where is the separation if you are just a part of the whole? So many questions.... ? ;-)

[@geespar1]

TURBOCHARGER indeed, chasing inner peace is just another illusion you kid yourself with, if true peace ever comes it will be through an act of grace, not through trying or ‘learning’ (Eckhart has said this in his books), personally I’m still waiting’ for this act of grace, but maybe even that is a wanting/craving

[@Peter_Pepper_Love]

Lo💓e, that warm fuzzy when you eat a cheese burger 😏💞

[@amyhodges5464]

I am so thankful for you, Eckhart. The teachings that have come through you have changed my life for the better. This is a beautiful explanation of duality - thank you so much 🙏🏻

[@Fazlulkader]

"The Timeless God is already complete and perfect , but it seems that in the realm of time, God is becoming conscious through all these life forms ..." very profound understanding

[@siadawn]

I don't quite understand this... if God is complete, whole, and perfect - why would he need to become anymore "conscious" than he is presumed to be? Or am I missing something here? (I assume that to be the case lol). I love Eckhart and I "get" most everything he usually says; but I've lost the plot on this one here lol. It is indeed profound. Can you elaborate if possible?

[@keegisters]

@@siadawn I have felt some confusion with this too. All I can understand from it is maybe a piece of God is within us and through living through us He is learning how to be perfect in time. But once we pass away we understand that God is already perfect. Idk, I think the whole concept of living in a realm not dictated by time is also hard to comprehend at least for me

[@azilius5302]

@@siadawn i feel like Eckhart meant that God has all the knowledge there was is and ever will be. So, in a way God also knows how and what we see, hear, feel and experience. This means that God is already Perfect but in some Islamic philosophies it is said that God experiences His already Perfect Self by experiencing Himself through His creation. I think this is by the poet rumi God said "I was a Hidden Treasure; I loved to be known, so I created the creation in order to be known."

[@bahrieker1766]

@@azilius5302 And also having alll the knowledge does not make the god has the experience of them. Having the knowledge of holding a hammer and actually holding it have big differences. We're all reflected particles of god that belongs to the whole (as we are not just a particle but the whole himself) having experiences that he already knows. As in the earth, experiencing the material knowledge, and and in other realms other knowledge scope is being experienced. This much I know and able to understand. There was god... He wanted to know himself as there was nothing else rather than him to be a reference, and created his reflections experiencing themselves, and he got the knowledge of himself.

[@E.K.2424]

Good and evil are two brothers with different fathers warring over the right to the conscience .... Luk 17:34 I tell you, in that night there shall be two men in one bed; the one shall be taken, and the other shall be left. Here they are: Jacob unconverted.....Israel converted.... same man Gen 48:2 And one told Jacob, and said, Behold, thy son Joseph cometh unto thee: and Israel strengthened himself, and sat upon the > bed.

[@adelbri]

Dark is merely the absence of light.... We take it all too seriously people.... Have fun..turn the light on..💞

[@robertcorderchiang3947]

why is light so privileged?

[@adelbri]

@@robertcorderchiang3947 You tell me why not brother 💞

[@signelassie]

"The end of separateness is the end of evil." A beautiful realization and explanation of our search and desire for Oneness.

[@tiffanyburson2106]

Love, joy and laughter! We are here to spread them!❤️🙏

[@realshanedejongh8455]

I wish you all here everything of the best with your families and loved ones for the remainder of the year and beyond. Thank you Eckhart for providing us with guiding us with your knowledge, we are learning.

[@happydays3678]

All good wishes to you too, my dear friend.

[@chrismusix5669]

"Don’t let anyone capture you with empty philosophies and high-sounding nonsense that come from human thinking and from the spiritual powers of this world, rather than from Christ." ~Colossians 2:8 "For the time will come when people will not put up with sound doctrine. Instead, to suit their own desires, they will gather around them a great number of teachers to say what their itching ears want to hear. " ~2nd Timothy 4:3

[@chamicels]

Kind of like Joel Olsteen and the rest of the other naughty serpents,

[@pgmstudios29]

what about the gospels of Thomas, it shows Jesus speaking literally about what Eckhart is speaking about. It is not official canon but you have to understand that it was humans later on that decided which books are canon hundreds of years later

[@janize29]

Bingo you said it correctly woohoo ​@@pgmstudios29

[@karanfield4229]

When Eckhart pauses, I feel he is being given information from the divine source called God. ✨

[@mindsigh4]

yes, he has said that he is not thinking, when he listens to or reads a question, he feels the import behind the words of what the questioner is really asking, the crux of the matter, sorry, words are tricky, but yes i can feel him being a conduit, a conductor of the message, not just a person sitting in a chair but connected/rooted deeply within to way more than a separate little self. also, have u noticed that there's no fear here with Tolle? this way speaks to me of someone surrendered to God, divine will, thy(the one without a second)will not mine(ego)...🙏💜🕯️☀️🌱🐾👣🌿🌎🕊️🔔

[@andymillington4691]

God is consciousness and the human ego is an aspect of this consciousness. It is the ego which creates evil nothing more. The illusion of separation creates the egoic desire for enemies. It is ignorance of our true nature that is the driving force for all evil in this world. If humans fully realised their true nature then evil could not exist. There is no seperation, there is no other, there is only you and you are everything.

[@TheJooberjones]

Bingo

[@TheJooberjones]

MY_OWN_PRISON Reticle theres only one thing happening, consciousness/god/infinity/whatever fancy sounding word you prefer. Separation, the sense of self, is in fact a construct built and perpetuated by the default mode network in the brain moment by moment. It can be deconstructed “over time” via meditation, the rediscovery of oneness if you will.

[@smoovewitit]

Jeff Nirenberg So is he saying that our life purpose is to deconstruct that illusion and help others deconstruct it in themselves? That our purpose is to achieve purity? Is that not desire/aversion?

[@ReformedWhiteKnight]

Andy Millington - I am sorry but this is just word salad! And there is nothing you could actually do to show any even a small aspect of what you claim.

[@TheJooberjones]

smooth wit it i dont know if purpose needs to be brought into it, but sure, the desire for truth i suppose. Do you have an aversion to desire?

[@freedomsteel9688]

This is a beautiful explanation, especially about how evil is not actually real. I had an experience with what I feel is Christ Consciousness and I know we all get to the same Oneness in different ways. But it came to me how what he is saying is true in an experiential way. For him to articulate it is such a blessing.

[@peshang9329]

Hello. Can you elaborate what you mean by saying evil is not actually real?

[@freedomsteel9688]

@@peshang9329 truth is what's real. So love, peace, joy. Evil is a natural process of not knowing the light. So once awakened even the memory of evil is forgotten and it's just like a dream.

[@youngtevanced8818]

@@dexdeux There is no devil, there is only human psychological conditions. Devil is only personified idea to illustrate the evil inclinations in human psychological conditions . In psychology we call this "the shaddow". It is misunderstood. Devil is actually you a part of you that is imbalance. Take for example lust, it is both good and evil depend on the circumstance, your parents lusted to one another and then your were made. If you lust on which is not your wife not good according to your values. See that? Yet everything is neutral it is just how we interpret things.

[@truecynic1270]

I must disagree. Evil IS real. Get to know, really and truthfully know , a dog then you might be able to see that evil is real. Dogs are NEVER evil but they are sometimes treated SO evilly.

[@bluwng]

That is a a silly word Christ Consciousness, Christ means anointed one, metaphysical weirdos just made up this word. Grow up and use your head. Bet none of this helps you with career and relationships because you are to busy thinking you are close to God or universe or infinite wisdom.

[@mikeq5807]

So well put! Evil is but a brief stage of consciousness realizing itself. It is part of the continuum of source consciousness. It is full identification with ego. Brilliant insight! If I had to give an answer ... Evil is the product of the ego mind, as opposed to source mind. When we are one with source, we no longer create evil.

[@chrissonofpear1384]

So what of possession, channelling, or blud sacrifices, we've been told, of, then? Not all of that looks of human, origin, either, @Mike Q ...

[@G3022-f7v]

Excellent answer MIKE! But ego mind is also created by the source mind.

[@introspectivedetective]

"Evil" is our interpretation of circumstances we deem negative in nature. A truer framing would likely be found in the word "contrast." In this wonderfully crazy realm in which we find ourselves, contrast is utilized by the Big Guy Upstairs as a propellant of sorts in service of assisting with our spiritual growth and evolution. So, God created contrast. Humankind, through judgment (and conditioning) may perceive and label this as "evil."

[@introspectivedetective]

@Damian Lopez Took me a long time to reach this realization, brother.

[@susanhowell1673]

@Troll Mctrollerson amen.

[@Maria-tt9by]

This is true only in part.... because something that is pure Evil....is pure Evil, there is no interpretation on this. We do interpreted every experience in different ways, because we are different, and also because we have different backgrounds and cultures, and evolution too. But there are extremes that cannot be interpreted, they are what they are, and from my prospective we must find a common sense of view on this if we want to create a new peaceful world.

[@dianaboughner7977]

@Damian Lopez If we wish to evole into a kinder and more peaceful civilization we must shine a bright light on evil and not allow immunity to wealthy, titled, religious, or any other person/s involved in crimes against others through a justice system that is ineffective in deterrence or that can be paid to overlook certain violations. I realize the value and beauty in meditation, presence in the now, choosing to detach from the thinking mind, examining and not living in stories, but I also cannot turn a blind eye to the suffering caused by evildoers whether they are categorized as with premeditated intent, unconscious of their deeds, or mentally ill, these perpetrators cannot continue to wreck suffering and havoc on others without serious consequence.

[@ALI_RAWAL]

It's true GOD created evil and good both....in order to test human beings which of them choose good and which of them choose evil

[@arameofudieci3937]

A great topic indeed, and a big thanks to Eckhart! While our minds struggle dealing with a non existing time and our strong perception of it, our souls (photons in the metaphor) keep being one with Him (Sun), not to achieve consciousness through form, but to create through choice. No form no choice, choice creates, getting back to Him is the goal. Without the duality evil is part of, there could be no choice. Once we remember we can always, instantly choose, we learn that choosing for love creates love and get us back to the source, choosing for form keeps us here and creates experiences we define as evil. Simple, yet obfuscated by our lack of faith.

[@saiharsha2736]

The whole secret of the universe is in the Now

[@dreamlandsociety5842]

At least its all there Really is.

[@ReformedWhiteKnight]

sai harsha You understand that this is incredibly hollow? Just sounds good without saying anything? What exactly is ‘the whole secret’? Why do you assume there is even a ‘secret’? What is the universe? And how would you know that the secret (which you clearly don’t know or it wouldn’t even be a secret) of anything is just in the now? The whole spiritual movement is full of just absurd claims trying to sound like they could mean something. Most of the wisdom I read here in the comment section could literally be created by and AI Programm mixing up those ‘spiritual insights’ at random and and rephrase them in ever new combinations - but void of any real meaning or full of deep wisdoms... whatever angle one might be looking at them. The archetypical wisdom one can find in the Bibel are way more tangible and applicable than these types of random ‘insights’

[@saiharsha2736]

@@ReformedWhiteKnight You'll know what the secret is if u are completely in the now

[@ReformedWhiteKnight]

​@@saiharsha2736 We are always in the now. When I am writing this I can't be doing this in the past, and I am still waiting for the next hour to arrive. We are in the 'now' by default! There is no secret! I could argue that by trying to make this into a secret you are trying to take away the power for others to realise this simple truth ;-) Btw I would argue that time itself is not linear so that past, future and the now are part of an everlasting trinity, a circle and hence what you do right now has already had it's consequence on you ... you just don't know it yet. So the saying of (instant) karma has some truth in it, although I tend to understand it more from a christian perspective.

[@saiharsha2736]

@@ReformedWhiteKnight the portal into the unmanifested is in the now. That's the secret . U can't find it elsewhere

[@mildredagary-spiritualguide]

This is an answer similar to my previous comment, coming from Eckhart Tolle himself. An excerpt from Power of Now: "It seems that most people need to experience a great deal of suffering before they will relinquish resistance and accept - before they will forgive. As soon as they do, one of the greatest miracles happens: the awakening of Being consciousness through what appears as evil, the transmutation of suffering into inner peace. The ultimate effect of all the evil and suffering in the world is that it will force humans into realizing who they are beyond name and form. Thus, what we perceive as evil from our limited perspective is actually part of the higher good that has no opposite. This, however, does not become true for you except through forgiveness. Until that happens, evil has not been redeemed and therefore remains evil." Boom!

[@SPDRmagick818]

"I form the light, and create darkness: I make peace, and create evil: I the Lord do all these things." Isaiah 45:7 (KJV)

[@dixieandkurt]

Perhaps evil is simply resistance to Divine intention, which is allowed because of the possibility of transforming evil into something life-giving and beneficial. For example, the energy of my anger towards another can be transformed into compassion through understanding. The elements of the earth…soil, seed, manure, etc...,can be transformed into a beautiful rose. Instead of just looking at the manure, awakening may be the ability to see the possibilities included in the bigger picture. 🧐 It’s hard.

[@sisko3893]

@@dixieandkurt Sin to God is disobedience to His will. So yes, resistance to divine intention and creation.

[@robertcorderchiang3947]

@@sisko3893 obeying God is resistance. it's impossible to not have resistance. otherwise, you'd be God

[@sexobscura]

@@dixieandkurt for your rose to flower it needs to 'not be the manure' but itself. They are separate things. Your analogy is fuzzy but its logic is flawed

[@lindakoch9524]

How could God create evil if God is all good?

[@dodosnoopy]

A perfectly explained answer, once we realized WHAT we truly are, then every human perception and definition falls away....we are pure consciousness experiencing itself in dreams ( illusions )......

[@jennybouffard5971]

"When people see things as beautiful, ugliness is created."

[@vinayshivhare2494]

Absolutely

[@vinayshivhare2494]

Nothing is bad untill identification started..

[@ludwigbeethoven3119]

sounds like something Lao Tzu said in The Tao Te Ching? Fingers pointing at the moon...word pointers

[@ms7HD]

So if I see you as beautiful with your ugliness , then does ugliness even matter ? Like if we see that we are Human trough eyes of being does being imperfect human matters ? It's all good , or its all bad . But there is no in between , no opposition - no sides , no polarities to be defended .😌

[@VCRider]

We consciously or unconsciously see beauty as a manifestacion / expression of god consciousness. In form we recognize balance/ proportion and symmetry as beauty a manifestation of love. In absence of these qualities we see "ugliness". However through God consciousness we do not judge but strive to perfect /improve perception of form to higher manifestation of beauty in form as altready given by nature.

[@ManuelaChristina1]

There is one human that can explaining such things. Eckhart thank you.

[@alex_maveric]

I agree to some degree…. We only label “bad” and “good” due to our innate selfishness as humans. From god perspective, there is no such thing as “evil”. This is the truth that emerges if you have a non dual experience . And is disturbing for the average human being

[@chickadeeacres3864]

The best explanation I once read was that God was like a full glass of water. In order to “see” what He was, He made the glass half full so He could compare existence to non existence. In other words Form or a relative universe of opposites. When we’ve forgotten that this relative universe is an illusion, we judge everything and give it a degree of meaning of either good or evil. I like to think of us all playing a video game and forgetting we are the one holding the game controller and not the character on the screen. We didn’t die, nothing is right or wrong it just is.

[@nnamdi095]

"Or may be just watching a video game ..." given that we do not consciously instigate the ego-based impulses that we identify with

[@carlawelch4647]

I wish you all happiness and consciousness. We already are one so, I wish you all joyfulness in our oneness! Peace, love and light to all!

[@NenaLavonne]

Eckhart never disappoints ♥️ Such a treasure 😊✨

[@Canadian_Eh_I]

Came for the answer to the question...stayed for the relaxing voice, lol

[@hugooliveira4440]

So are you, sweetheart

[@jokevermeer3828]

I am he as you are he as you are me And we are all together ♫♪

[@heartofhawaii8232]

Be YOU tea Full teaching Eckhart! THANK you. May the integration of COMPASSION/LOVE.. of the Christ Consciousness within, and the Awakened mind of the Buddha.. UNITE, and connect us all together again in Wisdom, Peace and Awareness. Namaste and Warm Aloha from Hawaii.

[@jonathanschotten1410]

God is sooo wonderful and incredible and so naturally enjoys nothing more than hearing people argue the toss about who he is and what he does.

[@deliayoga2490]

Thank you Eckhart. That is a 5 star explanation. Big hug to you and to everyone listening this video .

[@tiuticcarefreelife974]

"The more an entity is identified with form, the more seemingly evil the entity creates and the more suffering is created." "Why are we here? We are here. Here is the arising of the answer. The answer is not just the answer; is also the end of the illusion of separateness and the end of so-called evil." Thank you.

[@Coachingdevie]

this is only the first part of the answer, intuitively I will add that after the illusion of being separated from oneness evil it is also the illusion of the believe to be superior to others, superior to nature, stronger than God (this my experience as a former Buddhist forest monk) 🙏🏼

[@johnambrosio19]

Love is the answer. It’s sustainable for the whole entire universe. Consciousness is the Source of light and love because it eternally works. But energy from consciousness is likely in infinite frequencies from being very high of such love to very low of opposing love which we interpret as evil, to fear, hate, not care, and lust which is false love. But true love is allowing every being of source free will to choose love or go against it. But our world must collectively choose love in order to be a wonderful world instead of what it now is. I send light and love to the world! 🌟❤️

[@lynnhall9957]

Yes. This resonates with what I believe. Love is the highest frequency and maybe same as Grace. Which entails mercy and concepts like compassion for those who are victims of darkness. God is not indifferent. We are created to reflect the image and on a journey to recover it fully. For me, it is the image of Jesus, who role-played it for humanity and culminated it all thru resurrection from death itself which beat the effects of time and this dream for all eternity.

[@hydelockjan]

Come you lost atoms to your center draw And be the eternal mirror that you saw Rays that have wandered into Darkness wide Return, and back into your Sun, subside.

[@atashakgem]

Whose is this? So true 👌🙏

[@deej20007]

You’re nice with words

[@lynnhall9957]

Lovely

[@jennyrook]

In fact, if evil exists at all it is because we are separate, that we have forgotten our true nature. It is our separation which is so very painful that it engenders us to flail out against each other, to try to control other, to hurt other in our unbearable sorrow. As a child psychoanalyst, I realised that ALL bad behaviour has its root in emotional pain. There is only pain, and the only answer is compassion.

[@robertcorderchiang3947]

what is our true nature?

[@marvincudjoe]

In the beginning when time did not exist there was one infinite consciousness or spirit, then a part of that consciousness had a thought, that thought was, what would it be like to be separated from God, that part of God that had that thought was us humans and some others, but no one can be truly separate from God so we are experiencing the illusion of separateness and of course to be separate from light you experience darkness and that what is call evil.

[@LoveLove-ov7xv]

👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼

[@Denise0752]

marvkojo kojo ......Sounds like A Course In Miracles.

[@jessicagagliardi2747]

If a part of consciousness had a thought creating separateness and therefore creating evil, then the answer is Infinite Consciousness created Evil?

[@sexobscura]

only *Divine* knows the path to Pure Beauty

[@wilma8326]

In infinite conciousness there are no parts that have an idea separate from the whole. All that is known is known by all. Either the whole supports the idea or it didn't happen. Both is true

[@serpent4s]

God / source is unconditional love, evil is the absence of love. One cannot create the absence of itself. Evil is the consequence of free will and free choice not direct creation . So the short answer is no, source did not create evil, for there is no evil inside god

[@samanthamorrison333]

All is in god but god himself is empty

[@May-zl8bf]

Well said!!!

[@ritamartin8153]

Absolutely right !

[@wikipunt]

Thank you great explanation ☯️💚

[@konberner170]

And the longer answer is yes. In manifesting free will, the potential for evil is also manifested. If that potential did not exist, then evil would also not exist. So while there is no intention for evil from the source (in a timeless sense), the desire to manifest free will is stronger than the desire to manifest no evil. Thus is seen the connect between love and free will, that to love is to allow for the possibility of evil.

[@lronshawcross2248]

No one: Eckhart:

[@thatboythaylon369]

This made my day 😂🤣😂🤣

[@disherovd]

Good joke 😅

[@Johnny_0704]

Blinks*😂

[@lauradurbin4653]

This made me actually laugh out loud

[@patriciastewart2537]

@@disherovd errr....I don't get it.

[@WornOnlyOnce]

🙏🏽 Namaste & 🖤 to all you Creators 🖤 when one becomes conscious no evil can exist 🧘🏾‍♀️let that ego go & evil cannot be created

[@BlondeManNoName]

God created free will and that allows both good and evil. God is love though.

[@yaasmiynbrown7095]

Oh so true. I agree wholeheartedly

[@cathyronywright978]

Yes right in the GARDEN OF EDEN..there stood the tree of GOOD AND EVIL BLESSING AND PEACEFULNESS

[@wilma8326]

I like the metaphor of the movie and the TV screen. Any movie we choose to watch is shown to us through the technicality of the screen. The screen is completely neutral about what movie plays. Could be a love story, an action story, a horror story,. Whatever you want to experience. It is not the screen that chooses what movie will play. You choose that. The screen lovingly shows you what you choose. It is always the same screen. The horror doesn't change the screen even one bit. It only adds to your experience. You might be addicted to watching horror. Don't blame it on the screen. Remember that you chose it and choose again, my friend 💞 PS for advanced seekers 😊 The ultimate and final choice is to identify with the screen. Then the question why evil exists falls away.

[@zawepygler1223]

Evil is not created, it is a consequence of having gained free will. We choose evil sometimes over good.

[@mikey6214]

Define evil.

[@zawepygler1223]

@@mikey6214 There will be a definition per each of few civilisations that exist on the planet now. A better question would be: which definition is true?

[@clinkzenn]

Can you Explain free will and also explain what tolle says i couldn't grasp one thing

[@antediluvianarchitect8483]

Stay on your path! You don't need the thoughts, they are not your true self anyway. You are. You are the pure consciousness. There are many of us that are pure expressions of consciousness, no thought required. It can be done. Let the guiding path of intuition guide your actions, not the thoughts. Staying balanced and aware overcoming the hurdles will lead to ever greater enlightenment. The hurdles (ego backlash) exist to lead you to greater enlightenment and resilience, everything has a purpose.

[@lordbyron3603]

What a wonderful analogy - what a beautiful answer ! As I listened, I didn’t know where he was going with this - I didn’t know where I was going with this either - and so my mind was quiet and still . But as soon as he mentioned the sun , I immediately felt this inspired feeling in me and I smiled. And as I continued to listened, I began to feel more joy in me ! And as he spoke about the photons seeing themselves as individuals ,, I was amazed and in awe and wonderment at how he came up with an answer to the question that brought me full of joy!

[@OfficialJBlair]

I love you Eckhart. Thank you for your time and energy. Your words and being have allowed me to see my own. Thank you.

[@karenjohnson5149]

I love you too Evan heart🌹

[@thevoidisshining]

We are creating God while God is creating us 🤩🤩🤩🤯🤯🤯😘😘😘

[@karlamariagamboacarrillo3794]

What a beautiful, wonderful and great explanation! Your are great, Eckhart Tolle! Thank you for sharing all the time. Blessings.

[@karenjohnson5149]

🌹

[@shakilahmad2152]

Straight answer vividly is" No"

[@samanthamorrison333]

More like yes

[@shakilahmad2152]

@@samanthamorrison333 plz listen last few sentences carefully. Even cumulative effect of whole talk suggests the answer as no.

[@samanthamorrison333]

@@shakilahmad2152 evil can be defined as complete identification with form = Illusion. Entity creates Evil and suffering. But the entity is the complete identification with form. Form is created by awareness or by mind which is created by awareness. So is evil directly created from awareness? No. Is it indirectly created through an illusionairy entity which is made out of thoughts and emotions which the mind creates which awareness created. Yes

[@ssoma151]

@@samanthamorrison333 God is not good or evil just like the sun shines on all, God is love and in all, good and evil is man-made not God, its what separates us from God thinking things are good and evil.

[@samanthamorrison333]

@@ssoma151 thinking things are good and evil but actually good and evil does not exist. And humans do not exists either. And nothing else really exists. It is all awarenesses creation. But awareness or god is in all of its creation.

[@bcvc3365]

Yes, the source created everything, light and dark, yin and yang, etc. There cannot be light without the dark.

[@achildofthelight4725]

Sun and moon are given as signs in the bible.... Sun has no darkside, no shadow of turning. For us to be one with God, we must give up our rock 😉

[@othervideos4002]

Yin and yang, light and dark are all part of the ego illusion. So that is a true statement when viewed only from the limited perspective of this physical earth plane, because you are not seeing the whole picture. In reality, there is only light. There is no good and evil.

[@DrBeeSpeaks]

This I innerstand. ❤️

[@wiseforce7045]

@@othervideos4002 if anyone kills your family out of spite how does that feel to you? Neither this nor that? Like..., Eh! Ok then.

[@sheilakirwan9462]

Other Videos not even light

[@ChadKarl]

Evil is the absence of God just as darkness is the absence of light.

[@saintmig1101]

Separation leads to indifference to other's feelings. Compassion leads to consideration. If people lived by the golden rule:" treat others the way you would like to be treated" then obviously that would result in utopia. So why do some people separate from acknowledging other's feelings? Lack of self love that prevents them from loving others which results in indifference? They say, "hurt people, hurt people". Any thoughts out there? I would love some opinions/insights....

[@mikeq5807]

Hello! One can be kind to others before one is able to love because kindness is the result of a disposition. Love is kind but is the result of a conscious connection to source. There are souls who have no disposition for kindness because they strongly or completely identify with ego. Kindnesses may be the result of a certain level of awareness of the other. However, for many they are the actions of the ego mind. Love, compassion, empathy, forgiveness are virtues that effortlessly manifest only when the soul is one with source. Your experiential dynamic, your spiritual ecosystem, is a reflection of you. The outward will transform as the inward transforms. Tend to the root, and the fruit will manifest on its own.

[@deej20007]

FYI a utopia doesn’t exist by definition

[@conniesmith4108]

Thank you so much...your books, teaching always resonate with my heart and your beautiful podcasts continue to inspire...Namaste ❤❤❤

[@Tori_4]

my mind is blown. this makes perfect sense

[@donaldexcell6697]

" the end of the illusion and the end of so called evil! ' those that have ears to hear let them hear!

[@peterwatchorn411]

A perfect explanation of this simple, yet complex question

[@lightloveandawake3114]

Everyone and everything is ONE. The good and the bad, we choose. We are all equal. Follow the golden rule; “Do unto others, as you would like others to do unto you. Let’s all be more tolerant regardless of our differences. God is having a different experience in all and everyone of us. 💗

[@highlegend1655]

God is the King of all Kings🙏👑🙏

[@SEB78765]

We are all God

[@highlegend1655]

If we are God, why are we all to face him on the day of judgement? Why did the Lord give us laws to live by? Wouldn't we all be holy and free of sin if this were the case?

[@SEB78765]

Brisco Crisco Who told you you had to face God and have a judgment day?

[@highlegend1655]

@@SEB78765 Yahweh

[@SEB78765]

Brisco Crisco Sorry to be ignorant but what’s that?

[@lenhindle1108]

Brilliant insights...theologians have been wrestler to the ground by such questions for centuries...your few minutes of insights gives a more satisfactory answer than hundreds of thousands of pages of left brain analysis...thank you E.T....you are a blessing.

[@steliosgourdoubas4189]

Evil is created by us!

[@marlenelara9300]

You better believe it, all day every day

[@sh0ber]

Isaiah 45:7 -- "I form the light, and create darkness: I make peace, and create evil: I the LORD do all these things"

[@itsmia5902]

What happens when all things become fully conscious and there is the overall awakening?

[@samanthamorrison333]

Heaven on earth

[@itsmia5902]

Kassiani Douka ♥️ but there has to be other beings besides on this earth...and if we’re not individual separate consciousness, then how is consciousness limited to just earth? I’m confused. Also, if humans on earth become awakened then what is our next step in eternity? 🤔

[@samanthamorrison333]

@@itsmia5902 if there is life on other planets in this universe, which is very possible, and if there are other universes with other living forms in them or other dimensions with living forms in them, which is also very possible then their awakening is also neccesary for all the creation created by awareness to remember that they are awareness which created them. Then all will fall back into only being. The collapse of all creation back into itself which is only being and being aware of being aware. But in being aware the quality of creating resides therefore awareness can rise anytime soon to create again. The uncreated awareness is the only thing that is real. Everything that arises from it is awarenesses creation. The creation can never exists seperate from the creator but the creator can abide in its own being not needing to create only if it wants to because it can. So awareness can be by itself not needing its own creation to be. But all creation is made out of awareness by awareness through awareness, is ultimately awareness disguised as the world.

[@itsmia5902]

Kassiani Douka Thank you for this amazing reply! I’m going to read it about four more times. Then I may have some more questions for you. 🤗💛

[@boyblue80]

I have a feeling we are the cells of a body yet to be born, and that body will be the next you. Your next incarnation. Kind of like the whole universe is collaborating and becoming conscious in order for you to be born in your next life. Planets and galaxies the cells of that body forming.

[@gazzam3172]

So many people misunderstand what he is saying, Its very enlightening. I wish some would just listen a little harder.

[@varshamuzik2149]

Whoever is reading this May all your dreams come true 🤗

[@Dvox_]

Thank you :)

[@rosifischer1363]

I would prefer that all my wishes come true.

[@gav25x]

@@rosifischer1363 same thing

[@rosifischer1363]

@@gav25x No, not the same. That´s a linguistic negligence. Dreams are fantasy, wishes come from the heart.

[@Maria-tt9by]

Thank you 🙏

[@zindigo9465]

Look within to change and do not look to others for their change.

[@yogib4468]

Your teachings are so thoroughly spoken, 🌻

[@maryschultz7195]

To wrap my mind around the scheme of things, I look at it like this: “God” did not create “evil”, that which is called “God” is evil... turned down. Pure Consciousness is the “God” in It’s highest form of energy. As the energy filtered down, it became energy at the lower end of the vibration creating an illusion of separateness and all the emotions and human habits connected with emotions. To accept the Now would not create opposites (or emotions). ... Blessed Be everyone- my Love goes out to you.

[@robfalgiano]

That’s quite an interesting way of looking at it. It resonates with me even though the full ramifications of what that means for us on Earth at this vibration are hard to grasp.

[@darkroom8942]

I love his pace. At first it seemed too slow but after a moment I felt I meshed with his pace. He brings you in if you let him.

[@tonoornottono]

yes, he speaks with the heart. even his silence has a sort of meaning because his words are so secondary to the message.

[@JoyfulUniter]

Yes, God is playing every role.

[@cindyj.8560]

Thank you Eckart! I want to tell you that my dream said evil is the way to awaken the earth.

[@aiyappachottera727]

Today I got something new and wonderful. The idea duality is painful and unity is peaceful.

[@nicholasmitchell8749]

Evil or unloving acts that sharpen the illusion of separation in order to harvest energy without equal regard to the seeming other. Consent is given through naivete or fear, thus ones own personal power is given away by believing in the illusion that the doer is attempting to sharpen. No evil can exist when there is no fear.

[@Newkicks85]

Yes! I love the way you broke it down.💜

[@omtatsatification]

He who still sees good and evil is not resting in himself.

[@doc2590]

I like Eckhart, and his teachings. I like just watching the thoughts and feelings and getting present. But I don't like this answer much. There has to be another answer for this question. "All the evil in the world is due to God getting to know himself" just not sure about that.

[@bmwvintageprincess]

he was looking for the answèr as if from somewhere so may be he was not fully in the space of Now that is y

[@moony77]

He struggled with that answer.

[@doc2590]

The question, "did God create evil". Is a great question. But first, is there one consciousness which has created everything? And if the answer is yes, then yes "God did create evil" sounds simple enough to me. Then we can ask why. And there are oh! so many theories, as to why.

[@moony77]

bruce feeney Sounds simple but intuitively we know better, right? We label evil as evil and good as good. Is it all ONE in the same to the Master creator?

[@doc2590]

@@moony77 I'm not sure what your saying. Are you saying good and evil are the same to God. Because, to humans good is way preferable over evil. And if your saying we need evil e.g., wars, famine, painful diseases etc to enjoy the good things in life. Well I gotta say, that plan/design sucks. In my humble opinion.

[@javieraarcoslafferte9770]

i dont know what would have done without all his teaching, im so grateful

[@consciouslifestyle9018]

Evil is just an illusion, especially in identification with the form, which results in separation - a reality of unconscious people. When you become conscious, you sense unity, you identify with soul energy and connect to God. Unconscious to conscious is the key. Thank you Eckhart!!!

[@LoveLove-ov7xv]

👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼

[@rosifischer1363]

If evil is just an illusion the opposite is it, too.

[@Peter_Pepper_Love]

😏👍🏻💞

[@LoveLove-ov7xv]

rosi fischer yes!

[@robertcorderchiang3947]

if you think you are becoming conscious and connected with God. It is only because unconsciousness is working in you. if you can go from unconscious to conscious, that's because you are even more unconscious because then you have to identify yourself with unconsciousness living within you, or you have to create unconsciousness as outside of you. that's even more unconsciousness

[@enia6373]

Thank you Eckhart, your lectures and books have been changing my life! I'm so grateful! 🙏🏼

[@EmpressLilith222]

Absolutely. Source creates all. What we call “evil” is created by source also. This Truth makes people uncomfortable. Instead of railing against what makes you uncomfortable, go search why this is True and you’ll discover why “evil” has a purpose.

[@Hallands.]

Isn't that's what satanists say? By doing evil with abandon, they inevitably promote consciousness coming into the world?

[@rstsport9874]

Creators Sun, the light of the world, our daily risen Saviour. 🌞

[@MichaelJonesC-4-7]

Father Sun & Mother Earth. ¯\_( ͡❛ ͜ʖ ͡❛)_/¯

[@fibson9775]

'Give evil nothing to oppose, and it will disappear by itself' -Lao Tzu

[@atashakgem]

The evil in vast aspect of world is really not this simple ,

[@fibson9775]

@@atashakgem Explain further

[@arunurmi594]

According to Tolle, God is "complete" and "perfect" outside of time. How did God not know what kind of damage it would do itself if it ever came to time to take on forms? Did it not know it would lose its awareness of itself and cause great suffering to itself? And why did it ever come to time to take form in the first place if it existed in "completeness" and "perfection" outside of it?

[@danielboomers]

why cant he just say: i do not know the answer to that!!!

[@shaneross7428]

Those people who didn't search for answers for the miraculous reality of life have always been the happiest. Those who heart commanded them to " know the truth" were assisinated by "God" those ignorant have always had bliss.

[@rb5325]

Everything has purpose. The purpose of 'evil', suffering or darkness is to take us back to ONE.

[@eekay5710]

'Evil, suffering or darkness' .. we can never connect any of this with our Creator, as all of this got its offspring the very moment Adam ate of the Tree God warned him nót to eat! His (Adam) sences were switched on and from thát moment on the human race lives from the darkness of his soul, his own thoughts. And this was what Jesus has come to save.. our souls, our wrong thinking! Matt 18:11 'For the Son of Man has come to save that which was lost'. - which, not whó!

[@flord7240]

To anyone: in order to understand about God, reading the Bible is needed, from Genesis to Revealation or from "Old Testament" to "New Testament". Because without reading the Bible, you cannot understand it. Before, since i hadn't yet read the Bible, i know i believe there is God but when i started reading the Bible, i felt illuminated inside or enlightened and my faith become even more stronger. I didn't even expected to shed tears while reading it and felt so connected to the devine spirit. My burdened or the weight i carried has been lifted, the pain, anger/ hate vanished and wounds become healed. There is something inside of me that's been awakened spiritually and my negative thinking/anxiety was gone.

[@janetwithers7427]

Yes, I have found that evil does not exist but in our perception of things, as is -- good. Is-ness is... Neither good, bad nor other. On a humorous note, God is having quite a dream, playing all the parts, ...and do we not reflect that when we dream? Somewhere in all this seriousness is a great laugh. 😇

[@robertcorderchiang3947]

how does God know it's in a dream, being roles and playful or it's in the real state of God?

[@now591]

"evil does not exist" - ? Those Norwegian girls that got beheaded in Morocco believed that also, and look what happened as a result!

[@nothingbutthetruth3227]

We are created with an inner knowing of good vs evil or a two year old would never tell a lie! Children know the difference.