Extracting Trillions of Dollars from Balochistan | Dil ki Baat 016

[@gulammurtaza3851]

Hope the wealth generate goes to public of pk.. Specially balochh... Not looted by politician and generals

[@nk6968]

Generals be like : Aye Ghadar e watan

[@Sidra-q5r]

Having some visuals like maps when you were talking about trades routes would have been a lot better for understanding

[@MysticSage-hg3jh]

Comments Kyun Hata Raha Hai Lala 😂 Kitna Paisa Diya Tujhay ISPR Waalon Ne 🤔🤭

[@UmarFarooq-ws1cn]

jitna tm 7 janaam mn bhi nai kama sakty

[@m.irfaniqbal9051]

May Allah give peace in Balochistan.

[@Dividerinchief]

No peace where Islam is there.

[@KaranBagga87]

You take their piece and how can you give them peace???

[@alimmuhammad9275]

According to US survey’s Afghanistan has over 100trillion dollars of mineral assets. There is hardly any investment by any country except China. We are joined at the hip with Afghanistan. Just think about it. It’s a very long and difficult process. When all you have is a hammer every problem appears as a nail.

[@StopandAct]

Chill dawg 100trillion 💀

[@ProGamer-wj3oj]

@@StopandActyep, bro pulled those numbers from his Ahh😂

[@amnahjayy]

Hi Muzamil, I've been following maharang baloch since a very long time & it would be great to see you both sit together to understand the current dichotomy in perspectives through the eyes of Balochi people and thought leaders like yourself from outside the region! (Also, loved listening to this - all eyes are definitely on balochsitan, and we must collectively ensure this transition to be a socially just and equitable one that honours the interests of the locals)

[@gulzaman556]

her missing person list is decreasing from last 4 months since BLA conducted many operations and failed . We know army is corrupt and so many innocents went missing just under suspicion, but the other reality is many are abducted or being trained by BLA n RAW and you wont see maharang speaking about other side .

[@chaudhry6769]

May she wake up to the reality of geo-political game and the stakeholders benifiting from local insurgency and may she try to resolve the actual issue of local grievance with wisdom and foresight without being manipulated by the narrative buildup for hindering Balochistan's progress & promoting instability. Ameen. Baloch people are simple many of them are uneducated but they are proud people and that pride is being used against them to hinder their own progress.

[@letslaugh8536]

@@gulzaman556 5000 baloch people abducted, you mean they all re in bla, total bla fighters are around 1500 to 2000. so ye jo logic dete ho iska koe tuk nhi, its better to leave narative of punjabi pakistani media and ispr jo ap ko hamesha bewakof banti a rhi hy

[@gulzaman556]

@@letslaugh8536no one said 5000 are BLA .but many are abducted by BLA or killed by BLA n many are taken by ISI too bcz of any suspicion. And punjab is not just for punjabis it host around 3 million balochi in south punjab who were kicked out bcz of internal tribal conflicts .Stop blaming other take accountability of your wadera system and tribalistic slave mind set.

[@letslaugh8536]

@@gulzaman556 we re already against wadera r sardar system. but who controlls them . army backed sardar wadera are rulling in balochistan . bla never kill someone if he is baloch from. balochistan . they target others . pehle kehte the RAW Marti hy . then afghani . and now you r blaming bla for abducions , stop cursing other. ISi and pak agencies have been failed from years.

[@ahmedch1698]

meanwhile Generals laughing in the corner while giving sandak on low price and owning mines in Balochistan

[@MrAhmed-dx5hw]

Kardi na fazool bat. Yeh lo Talia Baja dyta hun tumhary lia 👏👏.

[@ahmedch1698]

@@MrAhmed-dx5hw check news about Sandak and article which says Gen Bajwa & Faiz together owns mines in Balochistan

[@hamadbashir1174]

Source?

[@osama_facts]

Prosperity isn't just about the resources you have, but how wisely you use them and invest in your people's potential. In the tale of two oil-rich nations, Nigeria's plight reflects corruption and injustice, while the UAE's success in the Middle East showcases visionary leadership, sincerity and investment in its people.

[@fahadghazanfar9733]

Check Nigeria population growth . they are making babies like rabbit

[@versaty65]

It doesn't matter how many mountains of Gold and Copper are there. It is naive of you to think anything good can come out of Baluchistan until its taken back from Army and comes under civilian rule, governed by locals who are elected by locals by fair election (not selected). Provincial and Federal civilian Govt (not military) should figure out solution for insurgencies and talk to neighboring countries to bring peace in province.

[@shykhabdull52]

Bindu teri q Jal rahi hay 😂

[@jaw0d]

​@@shykhabdull52is main jalnay wali kia baat hai. He gave a good solution.

[@versaty65]

@@shykhabdull52 do research on this topic, read some books, watch podcasts by all major stackholders on this topic, not recommending anyone and i hope you will be able to conclude the culprits of our countrys demise since 1947. if your deduction after all that research is opposite to mine, you are welcome to share your knowledgeable thoughts in comments. but not like this.. plz go do some homework 1st.

[@fahadghazanfar9733]

@@versaty65 Come out of PTI propaganda .

[@versaty65]

@@fahadghazanfar9733 yar pti kaha say aa gia isma

[@perseverance_5]

Pakistan is not lacking in resources; rather, it is a country plagued by mismanagement, where the military has exerted significant influence over civil institutions.

[@ismail4900]

that is a myth, pakistan is a resource scarce country in comparison to its population

[@waqarahmed9169]

Punjabi are the reasons behind it

[@Gujratiah]

​@@waqarahmed9169 corruption is across the board. Punjabis are the majority population group .... theres simply more of them. The so-called military establishment is an integral part of the so-called international establishment. Yes there is pull and push but ultimately the international establishment is dominant... as gen zia found out or the families of the those murdered by raymond Davis. Yes, balochistan militants have support from Washington, London and tel-Aviv and to a lesser extent New Delhi.

[@imtiazkhan9897]

@@waqarahmed9169 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@mustafaaa772]

Well said​@@Gujratiah

[@user-yc9ou3ei8p]

The best part is In how easy terms and like simple conversation you have taught such high knowledge

[@ihsanqadir8888]

Bkwas h ye sb paid PR compaign h establishment ki jo ap bi kr rhy ho 2010 mein sunty thy k Gawadar future ka Dubai bnney wla h 5 saal mein dudh ki nehrein hungi wahan Abhi 2 months pehly flood mein duba huwa tha pura Gawadar Lumber 1 ki PR Compaigns bnd kro

[@myselfisaliabbas]

Everything is Okay, but kindly use some pictures or clips... I hope it will be better for understanding

[@redpanther9380]

It feels like it's the last opportunity for Pakistan either we can cash it or we lose it forever

[@shadowwarrior8201]

True

[@verilyze]

Aisa kuch nahi hai tum log mei koi drive hi nahi hai khaali bak bak bak bak Kaam bhi kar liya Elon Musk Jeff Bezos itna Ameer aise hi nahi Bane the Tum log ko sirf Paisa chaiye Koi worker dream nahi hai Ki mai kuch Aisa banao Bhok na bahut aata hai Karne ka kuch nahi

[@waqarahmed9169]

Punjabis is very reason behind the behind the downfalls of Pakistan

[@s9ka972]

Punjab is one of the poorest state in India by Per capita basis . One of the very few Indian state that have barely invested in Service or Manufacturing sector .

[@kawan5851]

Learn from Congo and other African nations. They are exporting a lot of raw materials. But People are dying from hunger and elite is pocketing billions. So dont expect much from Pakistani elite. They will sell minerals and raw materials to foreigners and locals will suffer just like Africans.

[@zubairullahkhan1772]

یہ بہت افسوس کی بات ہے اگر 6 ٹریلین ڈالر کے دخائر بلوچستان میں موجود ہےتو حکومت پاکستان کو چاہیے کہ وہ خود ایک کا ایکسٹریکشن والی کارخانہ بنائےکیوں وہ دوسروں کو ٹکے دیتے ہیں جس سے وہ ایک بڑا پرسنٹیج لے کر چلے جاتے ہیں اب ان کمپنیوں میں ہمارے لوگ مزدوری کریں گےاور اپنے ہی معدنیات نکال کر ان کو تحفے میں دیں گے

[@DAANISH_KHAN_]

Who has watched the web series, "The Mohammad" released on the official youtube channel of Zafar Heretics...tell me. 🇵🇰🕋❤️🌹🍒🎉

[@mahtabhailian]

How musch the armed forces of Pakistan are the contributors of this workshop and how the participants will not fall into prey to any hidden agenda?

[@HaseebKhan-pt9rm]

Technically Pakistan government will get only 25% profit

[@akbartanveer8245]

Thanks for the efforts and such an overview of balochistan. Need your research and overview of kpk and FATA former

[@MysticSage-hg3jh]

*If This Mine Is Sold, Then It's Worth Only $8-10 Billion*

[@muhammadathar626]

Realistic Analysis indeed. Waiting for upcoming episodes on Balochistan. Good Luck

[@dhillonsydney3644]

Invest nahi kar rahe saudi Pakistan ko buy kar rahe hai recodiq bech dia gya hai.3 airport bech diye pi bech diye...road train gwader china buy kr lenge agle saal loan vapis ho nahi payega

[@anonymoushunter6308]

how can you say that govt. of pakistan will give 15% of gold mining project share to Balochistan? Still local people of balochistan is suffering previous agreement of SUI project. There is no any priority of local people.

[@Mushwani____]

Sorry to say! Lakin Cpec aik Bhut Acha Moka ta Balochistan ko Develop karne ka through Chinese investment lakin Pakistan ne Sara Investment Punjab ma Kardia urr Balochistan ko apne hal per chor dia urr AJ Bi Balochistan ke log apne gar Smuggling kar k Chala rahe haan Agar Pakistan Balochistan minerals se faida uthana chata tu Sab se Pehle Balochistan k Awam ka Sochna Hogan nhi Ya Sui , Sandek Cpec k tara Fail Hogai ga

[@Hireharis]

Tumien Koie Paysey Deytha Hay ayes Jhot kou Peylaney k liye? Yeah free me logon ku Pudu Bana rahye ho

[@PoliticalSeer-ii3wh]

Paise Leta Hai Yeh ISPR Se

[@waqarahmed9169]

Punjabi are now going to invade Balochistan 😅

[@MuhammadAli-os1nq]

You missed the DHA and cantt announcements! 😂👍 But, as you mentioned, inshAllah good days are ahead for Pakistan and more job opportunities will be created to alleviate poverty across the country.

[@user-yc9ou3ei8p]

You have the great art of talking Muzamil bhai! One wants to listen and learn more, so many prayers for you and your family ❤

[@muhammadatiqueurrehman916]

❤

[@harshittiwari7424]

Such a nice analysis....looking forward to your next videos....love from India ❤️

[@ahelr2419]

Indian navy can easily choke gwadar....

[@AbidRKhan]

Muzzamil bhai you are a gem. The relevance and level of insights I get from your videos are not comparable to anything else. Thank you for doing what you do. God bless!

[@taufeeq8269]

I see no benefit in this for the common people of Balochistan who have been deprived of their rights. This is honestly just another cash cow opportunity for the generals, politicians and corrupt bureaucratese. That's my opinion.

[@noobslikeme6210]

Its a joke that you think Pakistan has so called "mineral potential". We are too malignant to progress now. If you don't believe me wait and watch HOW PIA will be prioritized. I assure you every pocket will get filled just not the national treasure. You think Pakistan is better than Nigeria? You think we are too patriotic to sell those minerals? lol we are already a failed state that ceases to exist.

[@rizwanyaqoob175]

Brother I think Balochistan should be divided into 3 to 4 regions for administrative purpose bcz this province has huge land and less administrative capacity.this will be also game changer for region prosperity. If you think this is right suggestion please suggest this idea to higher level and Balochistan government. If you agree to suggestion please give ❤ to my comment.

[@anonymoushunter6308]

according to yours opnion give more money or distribute more loutera groups

[@rizwanyaqoob175]

@@anonymoushunter6308 no brother this is only fiction if this is right as u say but I think it will not happen in every region some region will grow and prospers

[@hussaisa]

میرا گوادر کے کیے سوال ھے کہ ھم گوادر کو ٹیکس فری اور ایک نیا صوبہ بنا کر دبئی کے انداز میں فری ٹریڈ کے کیے کیوں نہیں نکیں کھول دیتے۔ جہاں چائینا ، سعودیہ ، امارات قطر، امریکہ جو چاھے انویسٹ کرے اور فائیدہ اٹھاے۔ میرے خیال میں گوادر کا ایک بڑا علاقہ ایک کنسورشیم بنا کر تیس چالیس فیصد کے حساب سے اس کنسورشیم کے حوالے کر دینا چاھیے جو ڈیفینس کے علاوہ ھر شعبہ اپنی ضروریات کے حوالے سے خود چلانے کے لیے با اختیار ھو۔ ڈیفنس یا اسکے خود مختاری کے کیے آرمی اور حکومت پاکستان کے پاس تمام اختییارات ھوں ۔۔ صوبہ جو بھی کماے اس کا مخصوص حصہ اسکی خودمختاری اور حفاظت پر خرچ کریں کسی بھی بڑے بین القوامی شہر کے اصول و ضوابط کو اختیار کرتے ھوے ۔

[@tilakmahto8179]

US got snooping based in Pakistan, that how it killed Aiman al Zawahiri in Afg. In lieu of that, IMF approved fresh loans to Pak and USAF approved Bajwa's request of MLU upgrade of PAF's F -16s

[@fk1one]

When we think of Balochistan, we remember their warm hospitality, rich culture. And also the brutal atrocities inflicted upon them by'Na maloom Afraad', the brutality of fascist state agencies, and corrupt forces. We recall the kidnapping and murder of innocent students. We acknowledge the grave injustices faced by the people of Balochistan. They hold a special place in our hearts, and we pray that they will soon be free from this evil occupation and oppression, Insha Allah.

[@areebahmedshariff2842]

Hi, so I watched your video and I had a few things to say about it, First I don't think the gold and copper mine will be using energy from the national grid, since half of balochistan even nowadays gets it's electricity from Iran, Secondly while China is a very big economy if you see the data post covid China isn't growing that much and with a very aging population consumerism won't really last long in China. Thirdly yes America is looking inwards and will eventually move away from this region and then there will be tug of war between different powers (Iran Saudis even Us) to control this area. And lastly if you have traveled to Northern Pakistan specially to Hunza you will see that from Nov-March there can't really be any cross border trade due to weather conditions there

[@muzamilkhan6250]

25 din main paisa double 😁

[@mrsbilal593]

IN SHA ALLAH AAMEEN

[@solitairesilverjewel]

Better use graphics too,

[@saniyaafzaal]

Jab roti sasti hogi, aur mehngi hogi jaan. Wo din b aye ga jab aisa hoga Pakistan!

[@abeehanadeem288]

Also give your views on the issue of grievances of locals in Balochistan especially in Gwadar.

[@piranha3037]

PAKISTAN’S public debt - both domestic and foreign - has soared like anything in recent years to Rs67.5 trillion on government borrowing needs to finance its surging budget deficit.

[@MrPrabhatRastogi]

China GDP growth rate has stalled. They are facing an existential real estate debt crisis. They have -ve inflation for first time in 49 years (just for context, negative inflation is worse than high inflation) When will Pakistani KZbinrs actually become rational and not brain washed by “self inflicted” propoganda

[@umerghaffar4686]

I'm wondering how the mining of Rare-Earth Metals (REMs) will affect our relationship with China seen as China is currently the largest producer of REMs. Will our REM reserves be valuable enough to the market so that customers can turn to Pakistan for REMs instead of China. You talked about migration to Balochistan in the coming years and, as a keen language-lover, that raises Qs for me regarding the preservation of Balochi language. It is already a very small language in Pakistan by numbers and migrants from other provinces might dilute the presence of Balochi language. Establishing trade corridors also allows us to project our soft power to people involved in trade transiting from Pakistan. We are very proximal to Central Asia with only the Wakhan corridor in the way. While we also have great cultural ties to Afghanistan and Iran.

[@Hazara26]

Atleast Bangladeshis are more brave people than Baloch and Pushtoons because how they sacrificed and kick the army out from there and got independence. If Baloch and Pushtoons are brave people then they should kick army ass instead of complaining😂😂😂

[@aminajaved8199]

It's good that we now know what's the reason behind Balochistan upheaval. A factor which was hiding wearing long boots has come to light. It's time to work together to push back military boots and have civilian supremacy in our country. Pakistan Zindabad. ❤

[@nadirameen9677]

Superb work and information. Just a fact check, there is a common belief that the indigenous gas will cease to exist in 3-5 years time. However as someone from the petroleum extraction and forecasting industry I can assure you this is not how it is. Market analysts make rather simple calculations while stating this in their reports however in reality the percentage share of the local gas towards the total mix will shrink but it won’t be the end. This would have been true, had there not been a single molecule of gas being imported. Anyways thanks for the information in there!

[@nabilkhan4527]

Can you make video on Mexican economy, it has seen tremendous growth in last 3-4 years....what's going on there?

[@AK47-y9w]

22:40 kalbution yadhve spotted Allah Baluchistan ko kulbution jesi nazron sy bachaye ameen

[@AK89.]

salam muzzamil bhai. i highly respect your thorough discussion about opportunities in balochistan. but in my opinion, even if there are opportunities in balochistan, i dont think anything good will happen because you know how the so-called govt works in pakistan. they are all enemies of our country. nothing good can happen in this country. sadly, this is the reality.

[@withmkk]

Although your videos are interesting enough, but I would suggest use graphical images , maps , charts etc during your videos , ta k its look more interesting , otherwise its look like a boring university leture... Peace.

[@AsadVideoEditor-zq7bp]

Iran is only surviving on their gas and fuel. My pov is, Balochistan shares the same terrain as of Iran then why don't we invest in drilling in Balochistan for gas and fuel as it would be a free source of energy if we find some reserves and Pakistan shouldn't even fear of any international sanctions. Sui gas was also discovered in Balochistan. I think Balochistan is more important for Pakistan than Kashmir from economic point of view.

[@farahsalahuddin]

Great podcast. Any development will offset the chronic underdevelopment in balochistan. And Karachi always grows from bolchistan investments too. So truly hope what you say comes true. Pakistani people are finally dropping hate and embracing foreigners. Saudi , American , Chinese , afghans. All are welcome. Be smart.

[@anwaymandal9767]

20 se 25 saal lagegi, 7 8saal mey development kuch nai ho payega as per current situation in the country.. Churan mat khilao... Plus 10billion investment 1 2sal k nai, yeh 10-15 saal ka investment hai

[@Shandairyfarm5]

Bahi sab map b dikhya kro Sath Sath Jo by krty ho

[@areebahmedshariff2842]

Also when you go to balochistan keep these things in your mind 1) level of education in the general public 2) Rampant smuggling (Iranian oil is being sold literally everywhere) 3) The sentiments and hopes of the local population.

[@zayn4263]

Love from tandoadam sindh 🇵🇰🫂

[@Alizaiblashari-w8h]

Insecurity in Sindh hurts investment, displacement of natives especially Hindus are migrating from Pakistan to India

[@9Rehankhan19]

That’s good. Let them migrate

[@Muzamalhussain155]

No doubt it's all same in my city

[@Alizaiblashari-w8h]

@@Muzamalhussain155 sir but in Sindh it is more or zero insecurity because Sindh gvt seems powerless to countering Kacha decoit who are supported by waderas and politicians. Primes concern nowadays for people in kashmore is how long will they survive more days from attack

[@Alizaiblashari-w8h]

@@Cjahaga yes of course brother these problems are reality but In sha Allah soon we are optimistic our country will move out of these turbulences. And Muslims are one there is no difference in muhajjar or Sindhi Muslims.

[@muhammadbinarshad5142]

Further, I'd love if you add the resource of your research in the video details. For us to read those articles and be more informed. Thank you

[@49894989498949894989]

Saudi Arabia will install a refinery in Pakistan to serve the oil needs of China. Why not directly inside China?

[@osamamehmood1229]

But asked government for good security it's an improvement suggesting 😊

[@dastagirsiddiqui8477]

KOSA acting as an actor of establishing forces to protect its interests against the genuine agendas of people of Pakistan

[@bharathfsf3686]

I know your intentions are good but still don't use 'extracting' in this sense. It sounds like exploitation.

[@shahmudassirahmed5913]

Excellent but graphics, maps and images are what missing in this video

[@naveendokka8026]

Bro sapne kitne ache dkethey hey aaplog chinese ko safety nhi hey wahapr aur forghner ayengey 😂 gwadarn pura fencing lagrahey aur bolrahey 😂

[@ali.z.a5139]

Bhaijaaan South mai Agriculture bhht ziada ho skta hai.....

[@dastagirsiddiqui8477]

Excellent presentation please advise and invite foreign investors through proper channels

[@nasreenkausar2945]

Hope for the best if practically start doing It's great awareness

[@PoliticalSeer-ii3wh]

Tu Comments Hataayega Toh Takleef Ho Sakti Hai Tujhay Kabhi ...

[@kuldeuec]

Pizza hi Pizza chains khulengi 😂, Generalon ko toh fayda hoga hi hoga 🎉

[@ahmarjatt2242]

Pakistan, a 'Nation-State' ❌❎ Pakistan, a 'State-Nation' ✔️✅

[@owaisaziz8537]

Rulaogy kia Bhai nice dream for back in 2000~2010

[@rahmatullahnasir]

Sir welcome to Balochistan

[@aktarzaman4205]

Boycott pak army goods( fmcg) business

[@muhammadnomankhan3521]

Video achi hay lekin at the end wo sab paisa jayega kis k jaib main, apko bhi pata hay hamay bhi pata hay.. is liye ghalib dill behlanay k liye khayal acha hay..

[@AnberImran]

Oh my God!!!! So much FUN listening to this topic, the way you explain and Thiss is my first time I am trying to understand geopolitics. Looking forward to more videos❤❤

[@aliso5987]

First 2 minutes of video you said things that I always says but no one is ready to accept the reality. Population density and large terrains are major reason for less development in this area. I say this as an engineer. But people will always say their bullsh*t without any understanding of development.

[@raaskoh4346]

Jab ap aye nahi ho Balochistan jab kuch pata nahi pir vlog kiun karty ho.

[@alamicrodev6526]

Please make a podcast and sit together with mahrang baloch and maybe even manzoor pashteen.

[@ksoftseo9386]

Aik Ur Important Cost ap Skip kr rhy hen brother,,,,

[@sohailakhter9697]

For Gas pipelines,India should be involved

[@BaariSoft]

video unliked, too long ads you are showing.

[@raaskoh4346]

Bs minerals hai Balochistan ma aur tumko kuch nazar nahi ata...

[@HAssanrixvi]

Phr b development Punjab ke hogi

[@deathshadow5316]

can you also do a video on where did our imf loans get used up?

[@hadirehman1010]

loved this video, looking forward towards more parts of these geopolitics series

[@tobateksingh4933]

Road structure Clean water Security

[@HappyKafir]

Balochistan is not Pakistan.

[@HappyKafir]

@@wahmad8211 sure, by convoluted Pakistan history book. True history is very very rare in your country. The Khan of Kalat was forced by the army to accede. Kashmir did it willingly to India when your country sent mujahideen into J&K. Your Kashmir Kashmir song / rap is a main reason for the army to rule over you.

[@HappyKafir]

@@singsll5641 I believe there was an offer of Kashmir in lieu of leaving Hyderabad "alone". It was wrongly ASSUMED by MAJ that Kashmir would be no problem and that he should concentrate on his "maiming, butchering and cutting apart" India for which he was ok with getting 20,000,000 Muslims "smashed" (who would have been in Hindu majority states.)

[@user-yc9ou3ei8p]

So good to see how you have showed us true picture and hope and possibilities ❤

[@mustafaaa772]

This gave me hope for Pakistan 😂

[@Rinusk69]

Vigo vigo wali feeling arahi

[@chHssn]

So sad that no one is speaking about palestine

[@hamzashaykh9780]

These Trillions will be used for DHA

[@bhuraj7654]

This is good for pakistan and India

[@MushafMehdi1]

I thought this dil ki baat thing would be boring as my paradigms are always reckless towards someones personal opinions and ideas; mainly talked over a controversial issue yet this whole series turned out to be fabulous, the statistics, the story telling, the impact literally wholesome!

[@user-yc9ou3ei8p]

Wow great that Balochistan govt is actually doing this workshop! Also you are the best choice to call in this workshop