Falsely Accused Feline Almost Neuters Complex Millionaire Murder Case | Peggy Nadell Case Analysis

[@amywc5309]

"Cat with a special set of skills.." Shouldn't have laughed aloud but I did.

[@basilodira4423]

Greed is a terrible thing

[@clqudy4750]

The root of all evil. That and the lust for power, of course.

[@You-Know-Youre-Right]

yup, the hubris of man

[@Koozomec]

It's the soul of USA.

[@GigiRulesTheRoost]

What cruel horrible people.

[@margaretr5701]

Very. I can't understand the thought patterns of a woman living a comfortable life,with generousity already flowing her way from a kind and generous mother in law, the grandmother to her children. A trip to Italy already in the future, which no doubt would be luxurious, given the description of her mother in law. From every description, she was treated with love and generousity. I hope the murderer dwells bitterly on what she gave up, comfort, family, even her children. What a twisted example of humanity. She should never be released on society again.

[@stephaniewinokur6383]

So sad that Diana would have done this to someone that was so kind and generous to both her and her children. Someone that loved and trusted her. She should never get out of prison.

[@codyco3199]

Sad she had kids.

[@margaretr5701]

Despicable woman. I can't understand it, she was not in need, and already treated with generosity. I hope she dwells on her immense losses, that she alone brought on herself.

[@JE4-1]

She was my next door neighbor growing up, I used to do yard work every single week for her and she gave me milk chocolate from her fridge. Such a fragile sweet lovely lady. I remember the exact day when 2 officers knocked on our door and told me and my siblings to go into another room, shortly after my mom came in the room crying and told us Peggy is dead. I was 9 and remember it like it was yesterday. She named her cat and security pass code which I now know from the Dateline episode after me..I’d say a lot of my problems have been because of the fear that day gave me. I would always hide if I saw a car in front of my house at night thinking we were next. It mentally changed me. Rest in peace Ms. Nadell

[@inahandbasket288]

Peace to you too Dear.

[@KaarinaKimdaly]

Sounds like PTSD. I am sorry you had to experience that. Best wishes.

[@pineywoodslawandcrime]

So sorry for your loss at such a tender age. Peace to you. 🙏

[@KamelaParis]

Oh God bless you and I am so sorry .

[@sarahjaye4117]

Aw 😢 I'm so sorry 💚

[@a.evelyn5498]

It’s incredible how she went from being a young wife & mother working as a homemaker (as domestic duties are still work, especially when involving children) & then became an executive with a net worth of $4 million after getting an MBA while a mother.

[@mangafq8]

Her husband owned a successful business.

[@kendra31]

Her family was wealthy. She likely had a trust and then inheritances.

[@Who-Dunnit]

.....the video literally starts with "her parents were wealthy and she lived a life of privilege". With dead wealthy parents and a dead wealthy husband, whats incredible here is that you thought she got 4mil from being an executive at xerox.

[@leahnadell]

My grandmother’s family was not wealthy and her estate was not 4 million dollars. This is a commonly repeated falsehood.

[@anneflynn9614]

I don't understand how people think that they can get away with murder.

[@CMD4WP]

In South Africa 78 people are murdered daily. 87-96% goes unsolved. Greed, Anger and Passion are some of the things that make people act in that way.

[@CankleCankle]

You only hear about the people who get caught. There’s no statistical data of those who have got away with it. I’m sure the number of people who got away with it is higher than most would think.

[@michaelcanty4940]

Murderer. Real tricky. Real tricky and complicated. I guess that's the way it is with murder? Perry Mason. No sir. Murder is usually very simple. It's the getting away with it that's real complicated and tricky. The case of the Phantom Flyer Perry Mason TV series

[@margaretr5701]

I can't understand the cruelty of murder, especially murdering someone who treats you well.

[@razzberry4756]

only like 50% of murders in the US are actually solved, it’s pretty scary to think about

[@EricDodsonLectures]

It's amazing how much detective work it must have taken to uncover that nest of vipers.

[@CountrysideCutie]

Only speculating on what my cats are up to when I'm asleep...😸😳😸

[@troy3456789]

Another set of extremely lenient sentences 😮

[@shameronstar7220]

I’m mean they’re women so of course lol

[@aurorincorporated]

That photo of Diana in a purple dress was an instant giveaway for me. I mean, if i wore something this nice, i'd probably attempt a smile, at least. But she... just didn't seem to have it in her.

[@Muffy-b1g]

I noticed the unsmiling face, too.

[@RJ.87]

Maybe Schrödinger’s cat came back from the dead and used its ninja-like knife throwing skills to commit the murder, assuming Schrödinger’s cat is dead, that is 🙃

[@bthomson]

Occam's razor anyone?

[@traildoggy]

You won't know until you look...

[@Lucy-ym8ch]

Maybe, maybe not 😺

[@jkjives1786]

​@@Lucy-ym8ch😂😂

[@paulryan2128]

That's just silly.

[@dissidentfairy4264]

Diana is so incredibly evil. There are no words! She absolutely needs prison for life!

[@Rebecca-hc5ju]

Agree!! I can't believe she's going to be eligible for parole in less than 20 years from now!!

[@troy3456789]

​@@Rebecca-hc5ju Probably fewer years than that.

[@tripledair]

Those dreaded knife welding cats!

[@nhmooytis7058]

The ones with concealed carry permits are even scarier. 😼

[@dlppl3407]

It hurt my heart. Why. Why inflict pain like this. Savages. They should never ever be allowed to leave their hole. RIP lady

[@leahnadell]

It should also hurt your heart that people listen to the story of my family tragedy for entertainment. Please do not support content like this. My grandma, whom I was very close to, would not support this.

[@drswaqqinscheckingin7210]

@@leahnadell Does it also hurt your heart that people read your family tragedy in the newspaper for entertainment? Or watched it on the news for entertainment? Or heard it on the radio while they were searching for entertainment?

[@whosaidthat9265]

This is a great lesson in not assuming guilt based on behavior. The daughter was super suspicious and quirky, I saw this case on a show where the daughter spoke, and she definitely gave ‘vibes’ of guilt but was definitely not guilty

[@two_tier_gary_rumain]

The story she concocted was completely bizarre. The level of detail is something liars do. Was there ever a cat? Why did she make all that up rather than saying she found her mother at the foot of the stairs with a knife in her?

[@Koozomec]

​@@two_tier_gary_rumainattention seeking ?

[@whosaidthat9265]

@@two_tier_gary_rumain she didn’t make it up and yes her mother owned a cat. Her mother had a routine which included taking a knife, plate and fruit to eat to her bedroom to eat. The daughter made a lot of assumptions but they were based on factual information. Like I said, her being bizarre is not the equivalent of her being guilty

[@two_tier_gary_rumain]

@@whosaidthat9265 I see.

[@gabrielleandrew542]

This was shown in another way in an Australian case of Azaria Chamberlain . The child was finally after years proved to have been taken by a dingo . Initially the mother Lindy Chamberlain did not appear to be giving appropriate responses for a grieving mother . Many thought she was guilty of harming the baby and she was found guilty at trial . It was likely she was found guilty in major part due to her public performance after the child’s disappearance. She was later found to be not guilty and exonerated .

[@lc2962]

A greedy & dirty daughter in-law. Awful! I hope Diana never sees parole.

[@margaretr5701]

Hard to comprehend. The daughter in law was living in comfort, received generously from her mother in law, was even included in a trip to Italy, yet her twisted mind had no problem eliminating the life of her mother in law, family member to her husband and children.. She lived a life that most would appreciate and can only wish for. I hope her days are spent in bitter regret at what she did, now she's lost everything, what a callous,, cruel fool. I feel so sorry for the deceased, who obviously trusted her daughter in law.

[@dicedrice7216]

Damn! I need a Scandal Scorecard to keep track of all the characters and locations!

[@Swansong321]

I sometimes wonder if my cats are speculating about ME

[@haydeecolon7868]

😺😸😹

[@rocroc]

They are!!

[@TiffWaffles]

Most definitely. They are also plotting world domination, but don't tell them that we know about their aims. Who knows what they would do to us humans if they found out we knew the truth. I love my cats, though. They are the best companions.

[@margaretr5701]

Maybe!! But I trust them over 99% of the human species.

[@smittykins]

If they ever develop opposable thumbs, we’ll be in *serious* trouble. 😹

[@sharonhoyt2133]

I've been very familiar with this case for many years and was appalled that they wanted to allow either woman a chance to get out of prison. Dr. Grande did a great job of laying out the details of this case.

[@lynnettez]

Crazy story... what I find even crazier is watching your view total go from 900 to 2k within 15 minutes. Way to go! 🤩

[@deboracopeland4795]

Yes but we need more likes!

[@susanross1651]

The fear that poor woman must have gone through in her last few minutes of life. Heartbreaking 😢

[@margaretr5701]

Giving up so much for years now spent in prison. I'd like to know what's in her mind. Hopefully. It's soul crushing, bitter regret. She had everything, but wanted more. ... Did nothing matter to her? Family, comfort? husband, children?

[@margaretr5701]

Yes, it is heartbreaking, a lovely, kind woman's life was taken by someone she trusted. Incomprehensible, poor lady.

[@lucymb00]

I love dr. Grande! He is the best at this!!! Through, concise, accurate, funny, and clean to watch. Formidable!!!

[@KaarinaKimdaly]

Yes, he is very cerebrally acute and hard working. I can almost hear Aznavour singing, "Formidable". . .

[@Koozomec]

It's the anti climatic and anti dramatic presentation i like the most. The dry humour is the cherry on the cake.

[@TheAverageGuy12]

Purr...fectly pernicious predicament. 🙀

[@jasmincampbell8105]

😢 Peggy must have been so heartbroken

[@KaarinaKimdaly]

Yes, that is how her kindness was repaid. How horrible.

[@margaretr5701]

Many can only dream of the life she had, a kind and generous mother in law. She gave up family, comfort, her children, even a luxurious trip to Italy.... I hope her days are spent in soul crushing regret.

[@traildoggy]

Alright, so THIS time the cat didn't do it. But if you think the cat wouldn't kill a complete stranger you are completely deluded.

[@statusdisarray9598]

😂❤😂exactly

[@Bebecat477]

Poor woman. Thanks, Doc.

[@americatruecrime]

Their plan was a *catastrophe*

[@nhmooytis7058]

Going a little FURther with the puns would require I PAWS the vid.

[@americatruecrime]

@nhmooytis7058 that would be purrfect.

[@VirtualVirtue23]

Have you ever gone live and/or thought of having a call-in show? You could merely speculate on people and their situations, we wouldn’t expect a diagnosis. Maybe call it: “Speculation Station with Dr. Grande” 😂 Or Todd-Talk Perhaps Alliteration Alley Whatever the name, we’d tune-in Anyway doc, great as always. Thanks!

[@DavidDeeble]

What do you have to do to be charged with first degree murder in New York?

[@markiangooley]

Also make an enemy of a major politician? I don’t know.

[@DavidDeeble]

You got that right.

[@everydaywithsandra]

Apparently more than just one murder

[@edenstanding8676]

This is my FAVORITE title so far. It's VERY eye-catching.

[@danielintheantipodes6741]

I suppose the police have to investigate the inheritors. Poor murdered woman. Rotten way to end, just to satisfy someone else's greed. Horrible. Thank you for the video.

[@terywetherlow7970]

@daniel: ikr. Women now committing such heinous crimes like it is just another day!!! Hard to believe for me.

[@margaretr5701]

I hope her daughter in law lives her years in prison in soul crushing, bitter regret. She gave up everything, comfort, family, for what? Poor lady, her last minutes on earth, spent in pain and betrayal.

[@Thisismetman]

Why were their sentences so low!! What is wrong with our justice system.

[@LowKeyTired-q7d]

The murder conspiracy with a stranger thing is ludicrous !!!

[@margaretr5701]

Terrifying.

[@aussiejewels]

Diana must have thought involving a stranger never having met or being personally involved with the victim was very clever....Like hiring a hit man...Diana was wrong!..And what kind of depraved stranger instantly agrees to kill an elderly innocent individual for money?...The love of money truly is the root of A L L evil!..Poor Peggy!...Her final moments of life must have been beyond horrific and terrifying!

[@PamelaH_HappyVibes]

I agree, keep her in Prison for life!

[@dabbsie100]

sad. Rest easy, Peggy

[@nhmooytis7058]

If I did crime vids I’d avoid a sponsor called DELETE ME. Just sayin 😂

[@MegaLivingIt]

Such a sad thing for Peggy that her son married that kind of person. Her daughter is understandable as a person who can't deal with bad situations like I believe she could not bear to see her mom with the murder weapon like that. Also, just blurts out things but doesn't mean it.

[@nhmooytis7058]

At one point I made my cats my life insurance beneficiaries but after some strange ‘accidents’ I changed it. 🙄

[@demonflowerchild]

WHAT KIND OF "ACCIDENTS "?

[@nhmooytis7058]

@@demonflowerchild cat conspiracy to get the payout faster 🙀

[@BigZebraCom]

Just a reminder, I'm not diagnosing anybody in this video; only speculating if a homicide is possible when luring someone to use the 'delete me' app like this

[@MrBillcale]

wow that was really dark, dark and evil

[@troy3456789]

I wonder if you have to give all your personal information and SSN to *Delete Me* for them to be able to delete all your personal information at different data collection businesses. Anybody?

[@topgamer8289]

Can you imagine how fire Dateline would be if Dr. Grande hosted it?

[@aliciagriggs8531]

They drag the story out a ridiculously long time, going over the same things many times.

[@Meela234]

@@aliciagriggs8531 No lies told in this comment! I watch the first 15 minutes, then turn back to watch the last 15 minutes. The middle is all the repeated info. If Dr. Grande hosted it, we could get 3 or 4 stories in an hour!

[@topgamer8289]

@@aliciagriggs8531 yes, my point being that Dr Grande would be an amazing host.

[@quester09]

don't f with cats

[@eadweard.]

I once saw a documentary called that. It was garbage.

[@nhmooytis7058]

FAFO. Seriously 😾

[@jenanne31]

Frisky felines are seldom guilty of felonies! Thanks for another entertaining video, Dr. Grande.

[@eadweard.]

Frisky means horny, doesn't it?

[@nuthinbutluv4u142]

Felonious Felines!

[@nhmooytis7058]

Frisky felines are frequently fearsome felons. 🙀 Don’t FAFO.

[@maciekillebrew2614]

Excellent, Dr. Grande. I look forward each evening to your story-telling skills. Your alliteration is wildly entertaining!

[@GGiblet]

oh i remember this one! love to hear your take on everything

[@mistrjt9213]

This is how vengeful sprits are made 👻

[@julieyoung3315]

Good Day, Dr. Grande. 👌

[@aheimdahl5201]

Why would she pull the knife out of her chest?! Her fingerprints would be on the knife. Never, _ever_ touch any weapon used in a crime.

[@margaretr5701]

A shock reaction? Perhaps thought it'd save her mother's life in the moment. I can't imagine thinking clearly under such traumatic circumstances.

[@aheimdahl5201]

@@margaretr5701 I agree, it had to be sheer shock.

[@nottooherbal]

Never remove a knife before the medics come .

[@margaretr5701]

Agreed, but shock and trauma might do otherwise. I can't imagine seeing a parent in such awful circumstances, it's possible she felt removing the knife might save her mother's life.

[@birdworldist]

Yes king go off

[@FLepKup]

Dr. Todd Grande posts his well researched, informed, video and I always watch.Been following and watching since he began. I'm not at the position to contribute directly but I certainly well when I get employed. I thoroughly enjoy all your videos Dr. Grande and have shared them. Wish you well Dr. Grande. Thanks for you hard work and great videos.

[@zenawarrior7442]

Yeah a new upload. Some of my YT comments are disappearing so thought would reply asap lol. Sure it will be interesting & informative. Thanks Dr G😊💌💌

[@breathnstop]

Complicated case. Good job doc.

[@JugglingG]

When phoning emergency services and whilst in immediate shock, people commonly do try to make sense of a traumaric scene by applying an innocent backstory and in the process minimise it ...eg in the case of a body they may say something like 'it could actually be a manakin/hoax' etc because it is so far from the realities of normal daily life

[@tiagomontenegro5932]

Estate pf New York is murder's paradise, 20 years was a killing deal, it was like she won't be eligible for parole until next week 😂😂😂😂

[@barbieblue3336]

I think you're supposed to call 911 first. Don't remove knives 😥

[@margaretr5701]

Shock reaction, I couldn't stand seeing a knife in my parent. I doubt I could remove it either. But I don't judge. Poor woman.

[@Bee-2-the-Dee]

Dirty Diana

[@shellyharry8189]

Stupid crime by ignorant criminals

[@eadweard.]

Thick tossers.

[@terywetherlow7970]

What in the World!?😮

[@see-rious-ley]

The daughter-in-law did all the work for the daughter to inherit everything. 😐😐😐

[@tanyaedwards4574]

The daughter-in-law was also due to inherit money.

[@margaretr5701]

@@tanyaedwards4574 Not anymore! What a callous, cruel fool. She gave up an enviable life, murdering a generous, kind family member. Her poor mother in law, trusted her, was grandmother to her children.... I hope she lives in soul crushing, bitter regret.

[@TastySlowCooker]

Two syllables: Justareminderi’mnotspeculatingaboutanyoneinthisvideo OnlyspeculatingaboutwhatcouldbehappeninginasituationLikethis

[@discospiders]

Raise your hand if you think Dr G has cats!

[@elizabethwarman9028]

Hi Dr Grande, Excellent analysis. As always I learn something new from your videos.

[@oleopathic]

Dr Grande, please do a video about the murder of a Russian opposition leader Navalniy, who was murdered in prison this week. This is massive news as it comes during Russian elections and a successful Ukrainian destruction of a large Russian battleship. Might this have been a revenge-murder of a political opponent ? Certainly an expected tactic used by Putin, as described by Guriev in his book "Spin Dictators". PS: 1 year ago, you reviewed president Putin. Today, he caused Navalny's end. It would be poetic justice to discuss the life and mission and end of Navalny.

[@captainamerica6525]

I think that all the info regarding Nalvanys death has not yet made public.

[@oleopathic]

@captainamerica6525 There are conspiracy theories floating around and for good reason. Grande could do a review now and an update later. This is a historic moment which needs to be discussed.

[@tanyaedwards4574]

If you listen to people who know so much more about the man, the date he was killed, etc... it all points to it not being Putin who killed him. Navalny's Dr visited a few days before, and the reason why the US and the UK's mking so much noise about it should raise your suspicions.

[@oleopathic]

@tanyaedwards4574 this is why we need to keep talking about to hash out the truth.

[@wiseauserious8750]

Why did they not both get life in prison?

[@blk5124]

Such greed.

[@margaretr5701]

Callous and cold. Imagine this woman living comfortably in your family, treated generously, mother to your grandchildren, wife to your son, all the while with such dark thoughts on how to eliminate you for money. She already had a comfortable life, upcoming trip to Italy with her generous mother in law.... a home,family, children. Hopefully she's living in mind destroying, soul crushing, bitter regret, at what she did, and lost.

[@albertafarmer8638]

My goodness...

[@jaysonwhiteford4531]

I had an interesting possible idea for Dr Grande to cover. With an increase in exposure to very graphic videos (I cant seem to make it through a month or even week without a graphic video popping up on X or Tic Toc), would Dr Grande be interssted/capable of doing a video on the possible effects that may come from youth and even adults being exposed to this media? I recently saw the video of the mother and daughter being hit by a car after leaving a Drake concert in St Louis and it has ruined my day.

[@pineywoodslawandcrime]

I saw that and have yet to recover. 😢

[@llrx4858]

Dr. Grande, could you do an analysis on Shamima Begum? I believe it would make a wonderful debate. Thanks

[@LibraInSeattle]

If something happens to me, definitely investigate my cat. She’s pretty cantankerous. If she doesn’t get her treats by 4:30 pm I will get a love nip on my ankle while I am working at my computer. She also snuggles with me when I’m not feeling well. She has everyone convinced she’s sweet and quirky. It could be a ruse. 🐾🐈‍⬛ This case was pretty wild. Some people can be so cruel. I love animals so much. They are not mean unless they’ve been trained to be that way by a human (or if they’re feral but that’s more fear and survival instinct). I’m thinking of specific dog breeds that have “bad reputations” but it has more to do with the owner / trainer than the dog. I grew up with a Rottweiler and he was the sweetest dog. He was a rescue dog. He’d been abused and starved and that’s how we ended up with him. We had to earn his trust and eventually he was a happy, healthy member of our family. He was protective of us, but not aggressive towards strangers. If I screamed for help I have no doubt he’d have been there ready to protect me.

[@ZenithLegend]

This story sounds like the plot from Taylor Swift's "Anti Hero" bridge. "I had a dream my daughter in law killed me for the money // she thinks I left her in the will."

[@gazoo7411]

Or, "Tale of the Cats Meow." Meow

[@palletwizard]

Thank you king for going off

[@kellimoorer9032]

New Cactus 🦎😊

[@noextrafood]

Why do people always want someone to help with the murder?

[@Joe-Przybranowski]

I think less alliteration would legitimize these long legal lessons.

[@KaarinaKimdaly]

HaHa.

[@Flamsterette]

Thanks for the upload, Dr. Grande! Your true fans love your humor and sarcasm. February 27 is National Protein Day, International Polar Bear Day, Insipid Day (according to Jonathan Swift), National Kahlúa Day, National Strawberry Day (gotta have a Leclerc Go Pure strawberry oatmeal bar later!), Pokémon Day, No Brainer Day, Read Five Pages in the Dictionary Day, and National Retro Day.

[@KaarinaKimdaly]

I am embracing No- Brainer day by spacing out into another Grande video.

[@Flamsterette]

@@KaarinaKimdaly That's a good one!

[@mathieuleader8601]

the lady in the sunhat looks like Rose the Hat from Dr. Sleep

[@Meela234]

The daughter talked to dog-on much. Never give your thoughts on how you think a suspicious death happened. Tripped over a cat and stabbed herself?! No wonder she was the initial suspect.

[@marquese1960]

Yes keep her locked up for ever.

[@micheleanello2953]

Dr. Grande’s photo was on the wall in Peggy’s house is the photo of the stairway if you look bottom right!! 😅

[@susie1370]

I am from Rockland county NY , New City, NY ! ❤

[@inflatablepeas6649]

Tbh I expect more alliteration in the ad reads

[@kaycampbell29]

We love your hard excellent!

[@leahnadell]

Thank you for making my PTSD worse. You have disrespected the memory of my grandma and harmed some of her only survivors. What ever happened to “do no harm,” Dr Todd Grande?

[@drswaqqinscheckingin7210]

how did it make your ptsd worse? What was disrespectful?

[@christiandulaney1638]

6:08 "Karen Ham-Samuels" More like Karen Ham Sandwich

[@hhp2932]

Just wow.....

[@beautifulsunset4071]

Imagine what the husband must have thought and felt when finding out his wife betrayed him in such a heinous way and murdered his mother for his inheritance.

[@StrayCatHomestead]

Suggesting again that you cover the murderer Talon Barton from laytonville California several years ago.

[@dj-te5yj]

The video thumbnail looks like Carmen San Diego

[@franciscoramirez9867]

Ariana Grande's dad back at it again!

[@eadweard.]

Who's Arianna Grande?

[@christopherbako]

That's supposed to be a secret. 🤫

[@KaarinaKimdaly]

​@@eadweard. She is a doughnut-licking 'singer' celebrity.

[@Meela234]

😂

[@LaniLanilei]

@@eadweard. I think the singer. She is not his daughter.

[@pauguste6559]

Goes to show you never truly know someone. Wow!!!

[@margaretr5701]

Terrifying. Yes, living in your family, taking of your generousity, mother to your grandchildren, wife to your son. Treated like a daughter... Yet harbouring such dark thoughts on eliminating you. I just can't understand. Hopefully the murderer lives in bitter, soul destroying regret, at all she did, and all she lost.

[@kathypappas6867]

I remember seeing this on Snapped. How awful this was . Peggy was supposed to be a nice woman. I'll never understand how greed makes you do things like this.

[@hjlydia]

The feline community should have sued for defamation.

[@kristenhanks8669]

You neglected an opportunity to make a New Jersey comment.

[@treavorwhitlock5606]

I do not think that people found guilty of murder for money should ever be eligible for parole. With that action you are really demonstrating that you do not value human life, and your character is so low that you cannot be trusted in a free society

[@barbieblue3336]

Please don't blame cats first.

[@scowil456]

“I have a special set of skills… meow!”