The Forgotten Story of Regulus Arcturus Black - Harry Potter Explained

[@HarryPotterTheory]

Thanks for watching folks! MORE long format videos here: kzbin.info/aero/PLB5djWCQq2_e0UCOmVbhRP8HkxetpzXUV

[@spiderxand]

Reg was a good boy & a good son. I have a what if scenario for you. What if Harry was raised by the Weasley family?

[@michaelince7311]

Regulus Black was one of the un-sung heroes in the series... I'm sure if Sirius knew that he had switched sides... Their relationship would have been different

[@magicpyroninja]

I'm sure finding out his true fate after the fact would have filled him with great sadness and pride Sadness over the fact that he didn't try harder to try and bring his brother back to the side of good and great pride that is brother stood up against such a great evil and gave his life in the process

[@louisegogel7973]

Regulus died when he switched the lockets, so Sirius wouldn’t have had a chance for a changed relationship. In response to the above commenter, I think Sirius would’ve been sad at the lost potential relationship mostly, what it could have been like, and perhaps not so much what he could’ve done to change it, because that is a wild card.

[@Larka661]

​​@@louisegogel7973exactly, only Harry, Ron, Hermione and kreacher knew about what Regulus had done. Pretty sad, he had to die just to take a Horcrux that neither he nor kreacher could destroy. It's actually a good thing that the torture of his house elf showed him what Voldemort was really like. Obviously kreacher and Regulus were close. Most wizards saw house elves as nothing but servants. But Regulus obviously saw kreacher as a friend, just like Harry and Dobby. Kreacher warmed up to Harry and all his friends when Harry let kreacher keep the fake locket. Remember: "If you want to know what a man's like, take a good look at how he treats his inferiors, not his equals"

[@KeiraH-j1j]

@@magicpyroninja yep very sad too bad things couldn’t have been different🙂

[@Skippyy_plays]

When you go to the bad side and only switch when someone close to you gets hurt your a not a hero imo

[@VarjoPira]

Kreacher is such a well-written character. Initially reading the book as a kid, I hated him. In the end, he shares the same space in my heart Dobby does.

[@jayt9608]

I always liked Kreacher more than Dobby.

[@VarjoPira]

@@jayt9608 He had more of a character arc than Dobby.

[@jayt9608]

@@VarjoPira He was never cringing and servile, and actually loved and was devoted to the Black family, who actually, except for Sirius, treated him very well and even had their rather strange method of honoring their faithful house elves using their decapitated heads. Dobby always seemed to be cringy and servile, though he could and would stand up for what was most important. This always seemed to me make Dobby look weak, while Kreature did not care what you thought.

[@patriksalata6506]

All character in HP are top tier written characters. So I undersand if anyone have favourite any of characters.

[@KeiraH-j1j]

@@patriksalata6506 yep

[@96s40]

Sirius referred to his brother as “soft” and he was very kind to Kreacher even when he did not need to be (given house elf’s were considered servile and inferior beings). Hardly your typical death-eater, even from the start. Then he effectively sacrificed himself rather than forcing Kreacher to suffer the poisoned water again. I know it’s said he truly believed in pure-blood supremacy, but strange then he should risk his life in such a way. Every bit as brave as Snape but gets hardly any credit. Arguably the kinder of the two out of Sirius and Regulus, esp. given Sirius sent Snape to meet a werewolf Lupin knowing it would likely get him killed. That’s a pretty dark move.

[@Gabriel-bw2in]

I love how Kreacher leads the elves to fight in the final battle: "Fight for the master Regulus, everybody together against the dark lord!"

[@KeiraH-j1j]

Omg same

[@TheCS2Sasuke]

Should have been in the movie

[@Hoops_Fan]

I recall someone posted a fan art painting of Regulus and Kreacher standing before the basin filled with the drink of despair glowing green. It was pretty cool.

[@carlosbenjaminturner5123]

Can you imagine the rage and wrath that Voldemort could have displayed should he had discovered what Regulus did? And not only that! But if He actually did read the letter the latter left behind? This idea seems the wildest to me that I even get goosebumps every time I think of it. I reckon it would unleash the greatest and most violent wave of murder and destruction that Voldemort would've ever displayed!!! 😱😱😱

[@johnyoung5413]

I hope they include his story in the series if it ever comes out. They could make a whole episode or 2 about that

[@JordanWylde_]

When the Death Eaters first formed, it’s possible they weren’t seen as a dangerous organisation to the Wizarding World, given how eager Regulus was to join before he realised what kind of person Voldemort was.

[@MMD_16-95]

True, but also regulus was pure blood supremacy unlike his brother Sirius, he idealises his family blood supremacy

[@KeiraH-j1j]

Hmm both very good points

[@Some_guy_passing_by]

At first, they were seen as racist pricks with goth/emo aesthetics. Regulus thought Voldemort was some sort of celebrity, until he got caught up . Snape was recruited as a 'death eater' at 15 literally because his mates were and it was a trend in Slytherin. Only later did the people like them find out that it actually involves murdering and torturing. A lot of people grew out of the racist emo phase but couldn't get out ...some of them were disposed of . Poor Regulus . He was probably 14/15 when he joined the gang and 16/17 when he died .

[@JordanWylde_]

@@Some_guy_passing_by same with Draco. He was a pure blood supremacist which is sadly common in Wizarding World. It’s bad but it’s a leap from that to torture and murder.

[@MMD_16-95]

@@Some_guy_passing_by Regulus joined death eater because he thought he will protect the dark wizard family but it’s turned he only care about himself ( Voldemort) in other side, Snape joined to death eater because his friends joined them and was only looking for places to belong and have something like family

[@CHAREDot9]

A flashback scene to RAB and kreature on the island where he drinks the potion and instructs the elf would have been nice for RABs story in the movies

[@raingreen1103]

He knew the mission before anyone else. He nearly completed his mission and as a teenager knew he would die. He gave his life for a good cause. He should have 5-10 minutes in one of those movies. Showing his realization of voldemorts evil and his sacrifice.

[@TheWanderingFire]

Given that the filmmakers were intent on completely omitting Kreacher from the films (the final books having not been published when OotP was in production), it's not surprising that RAB was given so brief a treatment.

[@louisegogel7973]

that makes total sense to me

[@johannailes3712]

@Studio732JRLhe was very impactful

[@electricheartpony]

​@Studio732JRL Kreacher literally betrayed Harry to Voldemort. I'd say he was rather impact full

[@johannailes3712]

@Studio732JRL he prevented harry being able to find the locket which then took a huge chunk of his time trying to find to, it also means in Harry’s mind he died for nothing

[@electricheartpony]

@Studio732JRL If Kreacher didn't betray Harry, then he certainly didn't betray Sirius. You don't need to be owned by someone to betray them, just be in their confidence in general. Sirius barely got betrayed by Kreacher, just him sending Harry to the ministry. Let's deal with your first little part that you wrote. It's called auto correct and just waking up. And this post is indeed about Kreacher just as much as it has to deal with Regulas, just maybe not your response to it. Might want to actually know what you're talking about before you go on trying to correct others and point out their flaws.

[@magicpyroninja]

Poor guy was a hero character who was sacrificed too soon and got forgotten by history and unfortunately he joins the ranks of many of fine men and women who are also forgotten to history for their brave sacrifices that change the world

[@mrdr0161]

His death changed nothing. He only slowed Harry down, he didn't help him at all

[@Finderskeeper98763]

I think you also have to take the account of Regulas upbringing. Being born into a pure blooded family and being the youngest he had to live up to a family that take pride in their purity. Sirius may have defected from the idea of his family but while he had James and the Potters, Regulas, had nobody outside of house slytherin. He was more naive than stupid. And Sirius could have done more to help his brother and maybe try to understand his mindset. He did not have to approve of his brothers decisions, but he could have keep trying to persuade him away from the dark lord.

[@L3131L]

Regulus has been my favorite character since I reread the series as an adult. I only read Deathly Hallows twice when it came out because I didn't (and still don't) like the book... but when I read it again 4 or 5 years ago, I had a total emotional breakdown over Kreacher's Tale. I love Regulus so much it hurts!

[@ashlazdanovich8396]

Regulus Black is one of my favorite characters from the books. Sad they didn’t add him in the movies despite how understandable it is.. 😔

[@ulrikerm3832]

This is the video I once asked you to do and it is, as always, wonderful. You draw the picture of the caracter with the emphasis and solemnity he deserves, as he, just like Harry, accepted to die to stop Voldemort. Thank you so much. ❤ Redemption is always possible.😊 Such a pity Sirius didn't get to know it! Both brothers died prematurely fighting the Dark Lord.😢

[@captainmorgana8842]

I'm soooo happy you are still making these vids❤ can't even begin to tell you how much your channel helped me through, always return when in a bound of stress...had been a while, binging tonight 🎉

[@trolletuva]

This gave a really interesting angle to Regulus and Kreacher too.

[@grec.]

Came here to say how beautifully well written this script is.

[@occheermommy]

This is something I feel like they could explore more in the upcoming series. It is stories like these that I hope they use an episode of flashbacks to really explore side characters. Also I feel like during chamber of secrets they could use something like the story of the founders would make a great jumping off point for a spin-off series about the founders.

[@rickmcarthur67]

Well, fans keep going on & on about the reboot series, for good or bad, however has someone actually revealed if like the films, it'll be completely made in the UK with a full UK cast, is that even a concrete condition by JK Rowling too, or is it just for the US by Disney +, or what? The main reason I ask, is that no doubt however many episodes the series is eventually given altogether per season, there will be more than one missing character from the films, besides Regulus up for consideration, obviously? But for him, they'd be looking for possibly a child version & a teenage version if he was born in 1962 & died in 1979? Wonder who could play him by the time he's needed?🤨🤔

[@occheermommy]

@@rickmcarthur67 well is MAX previously HBO MAX but I get your point. Idk if that is a condition. I haven’t heard any specifics about the series other than there is one coming and it will be one season per book. It will be interesting to see what happens

[@KieranDarrall]

The moment u realise that Harry, Sirius, Draco, Ron, Tonks, and Bellatrix are technically related

[@lucythecool_pug7565]

7:05 unintended pun there lol

[@louisegogel7973]

20:10 “ We’ve all got both light and dark inside us. what matters is the part we choose to act on. That’s who we really are” A wise man once told me: we all have, within us, a complete zoo of all the types of animals, and it is the ones we feed with our thoughts and actions, our attention and our focus, which grow strong. Thus we have the potential to be anything in the world. We always get to choose.

[@davekilby4515]

I love the.very thing Regulus Black did when he discovered Voldemort's secret to immortality and I admire his actions and him(RAB) wanting to make or try to make Voldemort immortal again. What would RAB say to Harry Potter if he found out that Harry Potter killed Voldemort for good? I love you Regulus Black, you are perhaps the best former deatheater there is! You ROCK Regulus Arcturus Black. By the way,Ron Weasley finally finished the task you started to do so he and you both ROCK!

[@rudebodega]

Do the books ever explain how the Potion of Despair was refilled when the locket was swapped out? Regulus had to have drunk all of it to get the locket right? So did he or Kreacher create more potion? Or did the bowl have some kind of enchantment and would refill itself after you placed something inside it? Or did Voldemort come back and think “Huh, that’s weird, I could’ve sworn this was full…oh well, quick fix!”?

[@Some_guy_passing_by]

It was probably self filling.

[@louisegogel7973]

@@Some_guy_passing_byI agree that it is most consistent with Voldemort that it would be self filling.

[@emankcin1701]

Probably self filling since it was full of potion when he checked if the locket was still there.

[@Turtle-k4x]

A well thought out video. Thank you for sharing it. Why didn't RAB have Kreacher take them both back home instead of staying in the cave and dying? I think he is one of the bravest characters in HP. And not spoken about enough. Thank you

[@owencarter6440]

I think Regulus knew that he had to die. If he had left the cave and Voldemort found out he had tried to make him mortal, Voldemort would've killed him himself. Regulus probably thought his death was worth the cause. Though, I'm not sure, there's much to think about there.

[@Turtle-k4x]

You are probably right. But RAB did leave a signed note so he wanted Voldemort to know it was him. You are right about another point. There IS a lot to think about here. Thank you for replying to my message.

[@melekcan3214]

I've always wondered if there was any way for Regulus to be saved. Kreaceher had told him about the cave. He must have known what to expect. Couldn't he come up with a plan to escape? Simply put, he could teleport with Kreacher. Why did he choose not to escape? Letting yourself die sounds like suicide. He realized that the ideologies he believed in throughout his life were nonsense, he felt remorse for the bad things he did and wanted to punish himself, or he was so afraid of Voldemort that he preferred to die rather than stay alive and face him. Or, more likely, Rowling didn't think it through that thoroughly. Regulus' story is full of holes. How he discovered the horcruxes, his psychology on the way to his betrayal. so it's pretty fun to think about it.

[@PumpkinJack31]

@19:09 REAL Harry Potter Fans recognize that Regulus WAS in the movies. He was the inferi that dragged Harry into the lake after Dumbledore had been incapacitated in movie 6 HP & the HBP.

[@dydydymond]

Well, let's see how the TV show does it, with a book per season it goes from 2h(movie) to 6-10 h (TV Show) I hope we get to see everything from the books, I mean... They have more than enough time.

[@queenbrightwingthe3890]

Always wondered how he found the locket and replaced it in the water with a fake.

[@darkmage9252]

Kreacher

[@salmanawan980]

Movie flame channel covered that if you look for it

[@louisegogel7973]

@@darkmage9252Kreacher went with V. and saw all V. did.

[@TheWanderingFire]

The un-notorious R.A.B.

[@braindominguez7938]

Nice reference regulus with draco malfoy Both of them i can see are the same Both were once bad and became good Its really sad when regulus died. I would like to see regulus and sirius team to beat voldomort. This biography is awesome ❤❤❤❤

[@a.d.clarke4990]

"I knew a boy once who made all the wrong choices. Please let me help you." 😥

[@Obsidius]

I wonder what could have been if Merope chose her traditional family name and called her son Thomas Gaunt instead

[@leto-nl]

I think it would have made no difference as he later on ignored hes birth name and choose the name Voldemort. I think that he would have done the same things in hes life allthough finding hes father side would have been harder he still would in the end call himself Voldemort and become the dark lord

[@Obsidius]

@@leto-nl I think was butthurt because he didn't find any trace of the name Riddle in any records of wizards. He'd probably turn out the same yea, but the nuance of having an actual famous pureblood name, would've made some changes imo

[@stefrondi1339]

His name wouldn't be Voldemort. The anagram wouldn't work the same

[@leto-nl]

@@stefrondi1339 Unless he found out hes heritige befor he came up with the name Voldemort

[@stefrondi1339]

@marcelsgroot even if he found out his dad's last name was Riddle, I doubt that he would use that name since his dad was a muggle and, in this version, Riddle wasn't part of his name.

[@elya13]

finally some reggie recognition.

[@D34671]

judging from the thumbnail, Regulus lives on playing golf under the guise of Grant Horvat

[@thierrymorales9797]

A very good video

[@vivianp5962]

Awesome

[@patrickfahy9207]

Even in the books, I don't feel like we find out enough about the character. I'd say that's part of the reason he's not in the movies. How do you include an unseen character? He's intriguing as the only character (at least that I'm aware of) that turned on Voldemort before he lost his powers. How he found out about horcruxes and how to find the locket would be interesting. Also, what did the family and other Death Eaters think had happened to him? They obviously knew he'd died but only Kreacher knew how

[@molassio1989]

In my opinion, whether it is in fiction, such as this, or real life, those that become spies and embed themselves with the enemy, for what they believe is right, is one of the most courageous and risky things that one can do.

[@6sixtysix]

3:32 kinda did…. Loo

[@alexburt1323]

It's videos like this and others that should make the people who want to bring back Potter and friends for a multiple season run rethink their idea! Instead of Harry and company, they should do a multiple season run involving the time when Lily, Bellatrix, Regulus, and etc were going to Hogwarts! Countless storylines involving lots of characters! And a huge money maker as well!!!

[@ultimativerHexer]

Well, a successful Harry Potter TV show would possibly be a good basis for a lot of great spin off shows.

[@comicsanslover]

regulus black is so bbg

[@mrdr0161]

Hes a pure blood supremacist who slowed Harry down

[@mrdr0161]

@patrycja3220 you people are insane

[@GiftOfDaGab_91]

Does anyone not notice the shear contradiction of Serious's moral compass??.... Or is it just me??.... Let me explain.... On one hand Serious wanted his younger brother Regulus to free himself from his parents pure blood supremist ideologies, he wished he made better decisions but yet when Serious was a young man he contributed to the bullying of Severus Snape along with his friends; James, Remus and Peter.... Make it make sense. I mean, if he could show a moral compass for his family why couldn't he humble himself when it came to Severus Snape?. Another thing that's largly contradicting as well is the relationship between Regulus and Kreacher the house elf; you all know that house elves can become FREE elves if given clothes (as portrayed in the movies via the encounter between Harry and Doby "though I'm not sure about the books never read the books as i have adhd/autism i don't have a strong enough attention span for book reading") so why if the relationship between Regulas and Kreacher was such a close bond, then didn't Regulas free Kreacher from being a house elf like Harry did with Doby?

[@KeiraH-j1j]

Hmm…

[@Some_guy_passing_by]

None of the Marauders' had much of a moral compass ( except Lupin maybe). What they did to Snape is glossed over as bullying, but it was actually sexual harassment . They cared for people whom they liked and completely disregarded others' feelings and safety while making up excuses to justify that. Even Draco , who made Harry's life a nightmare, never descended to strip him in public or push him towards inevitable death ( like Sirius did to Snape ). I don't understand how James became the head boy , Hogwarts rules were messed up . So , Sirius' attitude towards Regulus doesn't surprise me . And why didn't Regulus free Kreacher you say ? It never occurred to him ( if a Death Eater's elf runs free to leak the information, that's bad news). And a lot of elves don't want freedom because of generational brainwashing , they thought a free elf is a disgrace! After the Voldemort issue , he couldn't free him because if Kreacher ran out or something and if that reached Voldemort's ears ( that his victim of Horcrux cave actually came back alive to tell the tale) , Kreacher, Regulus, His mom would all be killed .

[@pianofry1138]

Kreacher wouldn't have wanted to be free. Most elves are like Winky and not Dobby. Freeing him would have made him miserable.

[@KeiraH-j1j]

Yeah not that I can blame Dobby

[@KeiraH-j1j]

I just wish lupine had told the other marauders to stop bullying people. Otherwise I think the rest of them were not the nicest when they were younger and at school

[@lauramiller4939]

Always loved Regulus' story and wished Sirius could have known and it had been included in the film. One thing I can't reconcile though-who refilled the basin potion AFTER Regulus drank it? After Kreacher was forced to drink it he said Voldemort refilled it, but Kreacher didn't know how to make it, and he never said he refilled it, either. And since he was very detailed telling the story (and was suffering from intense thirst at this point), he just wanted to get water from the lake. A refilling spell wasn't used because Regulus drank it dry. Voldemort never went back to the cave again until the year after Dumbledore and Harry were there. I have no choice but to call this one a genuine plot hole.

[@HarryPotterTheory]

I’m pretty sure the potion is just self replenishing. By Voldemort filling it maybe he just meant that Voldemorts magic refilled it.

[@occheermommy]

Yeah I figured as long as something remains in the bowl, the fake locket, it refills. When voldemort gets there and it’s empty it’s because there is no locket in place. That’s what I figured anyway.

[@emankcin1701]

@@occheermommy It was full of potion but Voldemort turned it clear as water to see if the locket was still there.

[@occheermommy]

@@emankcin1701 just checked the book. It is a bit more ambiguous than that. You are right it wasn’t empty but it also doesn’t specifically say Voldemort turns it clear. It says “for a second he looked down upon a basin whose potion had turned clear, and saw that no golden locket lay safe beneath the surface -“ I’m not sure if this is what was intended but I would read that as the bowl self refills but since it was empty it was clear liquid not green as before. I see it could be up for interpretation though.

[@dietdrpepper15]

Anyone else feel bad for Regulus, he left a big middle finger 🖕🏻 to Voldemort…and Voldemort never got it. 😢 like that was one of his last acts of his life, and Dumbledore and Harry screwed it all up! Justice for Regulus’ fu to Voldemort!

[@occheermommy]

His really final wish was that voldemort lose his immortality when he faced death. Yes the note was intended to show voldemort it was him but I don’t think that was his final goal. What he couldn’t have known was that there were more horcruxes. That made it so much more important that Harry find the horcrux. So in the end he got his dying wish.

[@dietdrpepper15]

@@occheermommy I know, but I wish the note could have stayed for him to rub that salt in Voldemort's wounds.

[@Some_guy_passing_by]

It feels so bad I wished Voldemort knew how his own Death Eater literally gifted his Horcrux to outsiders, not just Snape . Why , Harry could have said it to him during the final showdown, but NOPE !! It would have given Voldemort a sense of futility " I was never going to succeed in the first place?!"

[@louisegogel7973]

I think it’s better that he didn’t know. It might have shaken his faith in the absolute obedience of all his deatheaters and followers, perhaps endangering Narcissus’ crucial moment in the graveyard.

[@louisegogel7973]

@@dietdrpepper15They didn’t have time to open the locket there… they were in deep trouble to get out alive.

[@ralfhtg1056]

When I think of the brothers Sirius and Regulus Black I always picture guys like the drummer of Arch Enemy, Daniel Erlandsson.

[@raiderjohnthemadbomber8666]

Wouldn't that mean that Regules" character was in fsct, stronger than Dumbledors? Regules didn't have anyone to force him to drink the potion. The only creature there was one that was sworn on its life to protect him from harm, whereas Dumbledore had Harry to help him.

[@HarryPotterTheory]

Maybe mentally, yeah

[@CarrotCakeMake]

Dumbledore had the regret of killing of helping kill his own sister. Regulus likely had nothing that bad in his young past. At worst he probably observed the other death eaters doing some bad stuff.

[@occheermommy]

Kreature was ordered to force him to drink it. So he had someone there to force him. Remember he told him to show him how to work the protection, make sure he drank it then take the locket and destroy it leaving him to his fate.

[@louisegogel7973]

@@occheermommyexactly

[@louisegogel7973]

@@HarryPotterTheoryremember, as the above commenter said, Regulus ordered Kreacher to make him drink the liquid so the locket could be replaced successfully.

[@kool4209]

I thought Volde used Kreacher to create his trap which is why he was able to get back into the cave. Tho it appears Elfs can apparate anywhere so he shouldve been able to get R.A.B out but ya know

[@grievous444]

Does Kreacher or RAB create a new potion of despair after replacing it? Or does it automatic returns after a while? Always wonder that

[@joshuahecht6866]

Automatic probably. It’s Voldemort His power last as long as he lives.

[@MrEscape314]

So this video paints RAB as an unsung hero, but did he accomplish anything? It reminds me of Amy Farrah Fowler pointing out that Raiders of the Lost Ark would have turned out the same if Indiana hadn't been there. RAB gave his life to get the locket out and that would have frustrated Voldemort, if he'd known. It is a well intended sacrifice, but seems kind of pointless. Instead of disrupting Voldemort's plans, it frustrates Harry who then spent months looking for the locket a second time. If not for RAB's good intentions, Harry would have had the locket months sooner.. Maybe he could have destroyed it over the summer instead of wondering who RAB was and what he did with the locket. Am I missing something?

[@occheermommy]

While it doesn’t change the eventual outcome it allows for the redemption of RAB and Kreacher. So it doesn’t effect the hero obtaining the McGuffin but it makes a big difference in character development and that’s why I think it was there

[@occheermommy]

And I love the Big Bang Theory reference!

[@MrEscape314]

@@occheermommy yea, kinda like how Indiana added to the value of the movie, but not the end result. Raiders would have been a very different movie if Jones hadn't shown up.

[@mrdr0161]

​@@occheermommy it changed a lot actually. If he hadn't done this, then Harry, Ron and Hermione wouldn't have needed tk break into the Ministry to get the real one, they wouldn't have had tk go camping for months, Ron wouldn't have left them, they wouldn't have been caught by snatchers and Dobby would still be alive

[@occheermommy]

@@mrdr0161 but those were all things that just happened to take place. They were indirectly responsible for those events. The point was that the end result that Harry got the locket and destroyed it wouldn’t have changed. It would have been easier but didn’t prevent it. But we got to see RAB redeemed this way

[@CesarSanchez-e2v]

i like to think that when the dark lord returned and only after he did is when the basin replenished

[@three-moons6036]

I love him

[@spiderxand]

Reg was a good boy & a good son. I have a what if scenario for you. What if Harry was raised by the Weasley family?

[@LyleFrancisDelp]

Regarding your merch….what is “Haggord”?

[@lidiabinger1520]

Regulus told kreacher to return home and the "plan" was all regulus idea

[@tonyamcinvale-brown5950]

How did the potion get refilled after regulus drank it?

[@ginismoja2459]

I was thinking the same

[@d.jjameson9302]

What doesn't make sense to me is that to create a horcrux u have to kill someone in cold blood n then preform the dark ritual right? Well then how did Voldemort turn harry into one accidentally if he didn't preform the ritual cause he couldn't have without knowing that he was making him into right? Can someone please explain that

[@dawnkindnesscountsmost5991]

It's thought that by the time Voldemort attempted to kill Harry that night in Godric's Hollow, V's soul was so maimed, mutilated, and unstable from all of the murders he'd committed and the horcruxes he'd created, that he had very little, if any, control over what happened to his soul on 31 October 1991. V's soul was also up against the protection of Lily's tremendous amount of love for Harry, and her sacrifice; V's soul just didn't stand a chance of holding together whatever was left of it, against the mighty power of a mother's unconditional love for her child.

[@jaysenwayne3142]

Regulus... The Itachi in potterverse

[@erikiversen1828]

How is the basin filled with potion when Regulus had drank it?

[@dawnkindnesscountsmost5991]

The basin was enchanted to automatically refill.

[@MdTriki]

It seems like a fight against a corrupt system, getting to that horcrux, symbol of power

[@paulyb7267]

Who was more of a brother to Sirius: Regulus or James?

[@elunaxalt]

Most definetly James. First of all, Sirius literally reffered to him as his brother by anything but blood. James' parents, Fleamont and Euphemia took Sirius in when he ran away at 16, so he and James from that point on lived together like brothers.

[@alsimmonshellspawn6021]

How powerful was he?

[@YellowBear-kx1ff]

Does the Tooth Fairy exist in the Harry Potter universe?

[@albinokanickel4492]

No, but in supernatural.

[@ladycplum]

Couldn't Regulus have saved himself by grabbing onto Kreacher before Kreacher disapparated? And when you think about it, although it was a noble sacrifice, it kind of made things a bit harder for the Trio on their quest to find the Horcruxes.

[@jayt9608]

Kreacher could not keep Regulus from the pool, and he commanded him to flee in his last mo.ement before death. I wonder if Harry went and summoned his corpse, or what remained, for a proper burial.

[@louisegogel7973]

@rms5993It’s a good thought! It could have worked too!

[@mrdr0161]

​@rms5993true. But regulus gave him that order... not voldemort

[@Tho66]

Chose him as the IGN in league

[@RahulSehgal5521]

how regulus arcturus black know about what is horcruxes

[@magicpyroninja]

I think his legacy lives on in Harry continued through the bloodline

[@elunaxalt]

How

[@magicpyroninja]

@@elunaxalt Harry, having picked up where regulus left off, finishing what he originally started out to do and raising his family in the same manner keeps the legacy alive. You think Harry's not going to tell his children as grandchildren about these heroic members of the black family?

[@KeiraH-j1j]

Oof… this is why you don’t join the death eaters… and yes, there were a lot of scenes that were left out of the movies

[@chrismeloy5560]

Harry Potter is 43 today and happy birthday to J.K. Rowling

[@Boom_Boom-1976]

RAB is not a major character you are clearly not familiar with the books that well. RAB is a story told by Kreacher in one chapter.

[@dwhitemarquebillones8235]

We could've gotten this backstory scene during DH part 1 but they instead made that absolute pointless dance scene

[@Skippyy_plays]

So basicly regulus is stupid, he joined the “death eaters “ thinking what they were a bunch of stand up guys who went around and did good ? I wouldn’t see someone who did wrong untill it affected someone close to him a hero of any kind 🤷🏼‍♂️ ya he tried to do good at the end but still a meh person over all

[@eliasthienpont6330]

🦁🦁🦁🦁🦁🦁LION c LIKE No. 223

[@melanievetter6211]

🏞🏝🏜😊

[@-RegulusBlack-]

👁️

[@aspenschroeder6117]

😘

[@007akshays]

first

[@hughsahlstrom951]

Controversial opinions ahead perhaps: People need to stop trying to give depth to evil characters like Draco, Regulas and Narcissa, and stretching goodness to characters like Andromeda that show Slytherin is good. No. Slytherin is evil. Cartoonishly evil. Regulas and Andromeda don't even appear in the books. Draco is a spineless bully who fans redeemed in the heads but no redemption happens in the books or movies. JK doesn't likr Draco. No Slytherins ae petrified in the COS suggesting there are no mugglebprns in Slytherin. Only Slytherins join Umbridge and none join DA. And no Slytherins return to fight during the Battle of Hogwarts. Its only Slughorn. And is it a coincidence that Old Reggie is always depict as handsome and attractive, instead gross and offputting. Yes he described has handsome but the pictures people use to depict him are always very strikingly handsome and upbeat, not capturing the evil person he was. That's part of fans redeeming him in their heads. And only in their heads. We get a small unreliable account of its exploits, and by all accounts, he was basically evil. Before Harry Potter youtube channels who remembered Regulas was a character? I didn't. Always forgot he existed. It works like this: Gryffindor is good, Slytherin is evil, Ravenclaw is smart, and Hufflepuff is other. Simple as that. I love Harry Potter, love it but let's not suggest that Harry Potter has any moral depth. Snape is grey at best and even then he is relentless bully to everyone and Slughorn is the only viable Slytherin yet he is still kinda racist. There are no good Slytherins. Period. At all. All the villains are from Slytherin and the ones that aren't are Voldemorts spineless lackeys. All evil in Harry Potter Universe comes from Slytherin. It would better if Slytherin was a more well rounded and the other three had more darker qualities. But they don't. That's just how it is. I strongly suspect the love of Slytherin has to do with the current trend of loving and rehabilitating villains and evill characters, and tearing down good characters and making them much worse than they actually. These are just my opinions as strong as they, I'm always open to have my mind changed. I love Harry Potter so let's all enjoy it. Love you channel man. Keep it up. ⚡️