The Case of Paige Birgfeld

When Paige Birgfeld disappeared, people were shocked. She was a hard working, humble mother of three, twice divorced. However, when Paige Brigfeld vanished off the face of the earth, an investigation would discover Paige Birgfeld had some secrets of her own.
Patreon► / thatchapter
Twitter► / that_chapter
Instagram► / that_chapter
Merch►teespring.com/stores/that-cha...
Sources►pastebin.com/C53a4PTx
Music►
• Music from That Chapter

[@drchanwong8547]

Came for the "hey you" stayed for the mudder off tree

[@afrojack5263]

Dang

[@morgangadbois2092]

Lol I love it then right in the beginning 197🌲. Lol

[@MassEffectGER]

Tree young children.

[@armpitfuzz]

DON'T FORGET THE WINK x

[@HeadNtheClouds]

I am the Lorax, I speak for the trees 🌲

[@mariamz4]

Walmart is out there solving crimes without even asking for credit

[@stopcheatingconsumers9779]

Really? Walfarts credit is ruining global communities.

[@MaddieFrankX]

Doing a better job than the cops it seems.

[@Chris_t0]

Most violent people and pedophiles shop at walmart, they fuel sex trafficking and other stuff, poor people are far too often just scum

[@rachm.]

and inadvertently helping people commit them lol

[@mobiusbelts3607]

@@Chris_t0 You must be very poor, then!

[@justjaek]

“It occurred to me I haven’t cried in a long time. I’ve learned to do that again.” Absolutely BROKE my heart. That poor man, I can’t imagine the pain he felt.

[@elavke5441]

I can

[@vacheriedevacherie1959]

Poor man, we can feel the pain in his voice :(

[@prettyybr0wn]

P

[@stormsssss]

That hit me hard

[@ms.annthropic6341]

Me too, sad dads break my heart 💔😭

[@heidikitchen]

I was a friends with Paige, our kids played together. I attended a dozen of her Pampered Chef Parties. I know everything about this case: I was at the candle light vigil, searched the desert (including Wells Gulch Road), sat through the entire trial, kept in touch with her parents. I was listening for inconsistencies, but the narrator pretty much nailed it. Bravo.

[@gazXspace]

How awful - god bless you Heidi.

[@blondebimbowannabe]

I'm sure Paige is glad to have such a loyal friend, you have a good heart Heidi. Rip Paige.

[@BoneCK15]

Do you believe that Lester did it?

[@007shinette]

I'm so sorry you had to go through this but also, Paige would be truly proud and thankful that you helped. Do you know how her family are, especially her kids ? Xx

[@taylorj6177]

I am sorry for the loss of your friend. :( May I ask: were you aware of her escort service occupation or was that super hush hush not even friends knew? I realize that's a personal question, I just wonder if it might have been related to the fact she just simply never let anyone know about her "other life" which can of course be very dangerous.

[@lily-joyheal9954]

"doesn't that bother you?" "No" "It should" I would literally shit my pants if a detective told me that

[@charmolettafranquestafiestayam]

her stupid little lean forward "it should" was so cringey. Jesus christ lady lay off the testosterone

[@lily-joyheal9954]

@@charmolettafranquestafiestayam lmao what? What part of testosterone makes you lean forward and speak softly exactly?

[@lily-joyheal9954]

@Lassi Kinnunen 81 how in the world are speaking softly while leaning in and fighting someone at McDonald's related? What mental gymnastics did you have to do to make that comparison and actually think it made sense

[@lily-joyheal9954]

@Lassi Kinnunen 81 yes but HOW is that the same part of testosterone. That's what I mean.

[@lily-joyheal9954]

@Lassi Kinnunen 81 ahh okay I see what you mean in that way. I just have a hard time connecting testosterone with her action in general.

[@langs089]

The arch nemesis of every murderer: hiker's

[@cigicook6996]

@sum body Damnit ! Beat me to it

[@AdamSmith-cc5mz]

You forgot mushroom pickers

[@Kazza_8240]

Dog walkers

[@cdd4248]

Dog Walkers PS - I walk my dogs every day hoping ...

[@Teobi1]

@@cdd4248 same!

[@bubbaguy4411]

* leans in* "It should"....damn, almost had ME wondering where I was that night. That investigator was awesome...need more like her.

[@CDubz12]

I am so here for that detective, her tone and manner with him were 👌🏼 even down to the fact he initially corrected her from Les to Lester and from that point on she called him Les every other sentence…

[@1stepcl0ser]

im always so surprised when the reason for divorce is something like one of them not wanting kids or wanting to live somewhere else. i mean these are basic things you HAVE to discuss before actually thinking of actually marrying someone

[@pulaski1]

You _would,_ and my wife and I _did,_ but *news flash* not everyone is as smart as you and us!

[@LynnAgain83]

You would think so! 🤔🙄😞

[@karaleetrapp]

They were high school sweethearts, probably had more pressing things to discuss. But it is a lesson that should be taught in sex ed "If you can't agree on something as simple as children, your relationship will not work"

[@awright119021]

Feelings can change over the years. One of them may have changed their mind, leaving the other one with a dilemma.

[@pulaski1]

@@karaleetrapp "More pressing things to discuss" ROFL .... As teenagers they likely just wanted to hop in the sack, no discussion required! :)

[@sbeaber]

Jude: Evidence? Lawyer: His name is Lester, your Honor. Judge: I've seen enough. Guilty.

[@aladynamedSusan]

Lol that was my EXACT thought🤣🤣🤣

[@edyburkay]

that sums up this case :)

[@thundernegro]

Lawyer: I mean, c'mon... Look at em!

[@misfitbrit1989]

😂😂😂

[@zombies.in.space.]

there’s no way a guy named lester could be innocent 😭😭😭😩😂

[@ohthehorror6402]

Love it when the detective leans way over close to ol’ Les and says You should. Not once but twice. Badass.

[@winstonsmith3685]

“I need to dump this car that belonged to the woman I just murdered. That parking lot across the street from my shop looks good.”

[@reignman30]

To me, that would be evidence he didn't do it because who the hell is that stupid? If this guy killed her then he did everything else right and pulled off the perfect murder, but for some reason made the dumbest mistake of all? Maybe his ex wife framed him?

[@RillaGorilla420]

“I hear ya barkin big dog” has become easily one of my favorite lines from these videos 😂😂😂

[@tommymorgan4677]

I use it now and then, love it.

[@reignman30]

He got me, I was barking, and I still am. I'm sure he did it, but that's still some flimsy ass evidence. The only thing that changed after 5 years was they found her remains ... which still had nothing to tie him to it than what they already had, other than what an ex wife said years ago. Oh he'd dump her remains in a remote location? Where else would a murderer dump remains? Had he told his ex he'd suffocate her with a pink polka dot pillow case, wrap her body in orange nylon cord, encase her body in lucite, and sign his initials, and then they found Paige like that, then maybe he'd look guilty, or maybe his ex did it to frame him hmmmmmmmm.

[@pennylambley2536]

Totally agree. Mike has a way of telling the stories. No one does it like him. He keeps to the point and doesn’t drag it out and when he says “let’s give it a go” you are hooked!

[@dnap0lymerase171]

This is the perfect style to tell true crime stories for people who want to hear about them at night without being creeped out by sketchy music and robotic/monotone narration.

[@Brax1982]

But why do we deserve that? Should we not feel as morbid as we are?

[@2p4dr32]

Great eye.

[@3longatedMuskr4t]

Don’t disrespect Peter Thomas and Forensic Files like that 😭

[@sneak23heat]

I thought i was the only one who got creeped out at night lol

[@Exxtol1]

Honestly, I like this style because it's so unique. I like the "morbid" ones too, but this is refreshing. His sarcasm isn't focused on the victims, but on the gall and stupidity of the murderer.

[@roseandrews8523]

My condolences to Paige's children, her mother, father and friends. I'm so sorry for your loss and your pain.

[@jensenpete]

Agreed

[@mandarina4157]

Her father is so pure 😭 "How can one human being treat another human being so badly. I mean what an evil person." You tell them, sir…

[@TheNuckinFoob]

It's kinda shocking how pure the father is when his daughter was a literal prostitute.

[@jflo1532]

I still ask that all the time...

[@markmike7933]

Yeah I knew by 14 how badly humans could treat others. He must have led a nice life before that.

[@DrDemented9885]

He must of got all the purity in the family then. Because she wasn’t pure. She was a dirty women that met the usual ending of used garden tool

[@lordmysticlaw1991]

The dog: "I told you so. Five years ago. Led you right to his door."

[@dazza8551]

😂

[@ice9594]

Lord M, The dog: (shaking his head) "I have senses 50,000X better than yours yet you hoomans don't listen to me. I quit!"

[@lordmysticlaw1991]

OK seriously though, our labrador passed away of cancer last year and after she was diagnosed, we realised that our GSD had been insistently sniffing the lab exactly where the tumours were (by the time we found out, half her abdomen) for months. She probably knew something was wrong way before we did. I'm sorry girl, I'll listen to you sooner in future, thank you for trying to tell me.

[@ice9594]

Lord Mysticlaw What a sad sweet story. This is why dogs are such good service dogs. They can sense oncoming illness & mood swings too. About your Lab...Don’t “should” on yourself. You loved & cared for your pup the best you could & that’s what’s important - the happy 💕 memories.

[@unschuldshascherl]

@@ice9594 Yep, dogs are the best service dogs. I tried a guinea pig once as a service dog. It got the dog part pretty well though but had problems with the service part.

[@d_d_d_d_]

mike counting: 1, 2, 🌳, 4, 5...

[@3dlabs99]

... and first, second, 💩

[@rogerkandytorrez4515]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@vKxN]

wunce

[@cityzengirl]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@Gamer420life]

💩🌳= turdy tree

[@heartworkbykitty7933]

“…And Pages story was in the news less and less, her case becoming colder and colder while her bones remained under a colorodan sky.” I watch pretty much nothing but true crime now days and very few things get to me But every once in a while a creator is able to convey in very simple words the humanity that was lost and for some reason This was it, these words are what hit me. Not much can bring that out in me anymore, I’m honestly very desensitized when im watching these videos (not so much in real life because I compartmentalize) but that caught me off guard Ouch, my heartie

[@juliana.x0x0]

That Chapter has honestly become so familiar to me, that it's kind of a comfort, similar to what The Office was before it was taken off american Netflix. Ita like, you've seen most, but there are some gems you miss once in a while. And there are so many that you can just cycle through and kinda forget ones you havent seen in a while so it's almost like this brand new thing😂

[@markmike7933]

There's something SO WRONG that we find our respite in a Brutal crimes show :) But Mike is just funny as heck and enjoyable to watch and to be fair, it's the RARE show that really hits me hard. It's a detached view of people we don't know. No worse than reading crime in the newspapers. But when it involves kids or other defenseless groups, then it gets tough to just let it slide off. But for the most part, Mike is like a teddy bear you hold when you go to bed. And i'm a 54 year old guy :)

[@protonmonkey]

When her dad got choked up with tears and grief, that broke my heart. Parents should never have to bury their kids.

[@paulronco9709]

Agreed.

[@mliterature]

Ditto

[@AndyBonesSynthPro]

And yet it happens with such cruel regularity. My grandparents, my uncle, my friends, and the parents of so many of my late friends & acquaintances- they all had to attend their own children's funerals. It really seems unfair that I've survived. And I don't want to have children because they might be taken just as quickly & inexplicably. It's fucked up right?

[@haij16]

I did 2012 it is terrible it takes years and you don't get over it you just it just gets easier to deal with

[@wintercomesearly]

@@haij16 I know.

[@katc6880]

Before I give this ol video a goo, just want to say thank you for posting. You make miserable days better - appreciated

[@ThatChapter]

Well you watching means so much to me!

[@katc6880]

@@ThatChapter every post 🙂

[@laurab3876]

@@ThatChapter miserable days? What's going on!?

[@morgangadbois2092]

I feel ya on this!!! Omg!! It has to get better though!!! God bless!!

[@missolesoul]

I feel you Kat. Hugs from Seattle.

[@TheJayhawk79]

The detective who interviewed Les was awesome.

[@GregorySnipe]

💯. A total badass.

[@reignman30]

Your standards are pretty low. She got absolutely nothing out of him. He was free for 5 years after her "badassery".

[@renee5156]

Love that detective who interrogated Lester!! She should definitely have a raise for that one

[@reignman30]

For what lol? She got absolutely nothing out of him. The dude went home and lived his life for another 5 years. And then he was still convicted on pure shite.

[@michellemccreadie8028]

Mike : “no one wants to see my goblin body” Me : “Ah c’mon let’s have a goo”

[@s_a_r_a_jd2204]

🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂

[@fuzzyfreckle1341]

Nice one 😂

[@rebeccamosher9899]

It’ll be grand.

[@AD270479]

You just wanna see his tree legs...

[@TheOnlyElle.]

😂

[@frightfang5235]

“Doesn’t that bother you?” “Nope.” *Leans over*. “It should 😬.”

[@chloebowne7153]

Honestly, this had serious Olivia Benson vibes

[@FireRising86]

@Chris Kibodeaux Hate to say it, but it's almost impossible for a female officer to intimidate a man

[@chiarapaliotti9191]

@@FireRising86 he looked pretty scared to me 🤷🏼‍♀️

[@Becalavelle]

@@FireRising86 agreed

[@GoodestKitty]

FireRising86 When the man is innocent, not when the man is a perverse murderer

[@susansage1876]

That Chapter is so well narrated by none other than Mike, that I find myself rewatching episodes!!

[@toukie]

I hate it when they say "The seat was pulled back, indicating someone taller drove the car". I'm 5'6 and I always pull the seat all the way back before leaving my car.

[@fuddnugget5998]

Perhaps at her home but a burning vehicle in a random parking lot is worth noting.

[@reignman30]

Well it's a good tip for would-be murderers. I'm tall, so if I ever murder a short person, I'm going to move the seat up after I'm done. Then wait for my OJ moment. If the seat don't fit, you must acquit.

[@Amoreyna]

My mom does this and she's under 5'. Makes it easier for her to get out and in case someone else drives it next. In this case, obviously someone who meant her harm did drive it but other cases are not so clear cut. Hell, a criminal may even push the seat back to mislead investigators.

[@garrethenderson7561]

I swear, 90% of missing bodies are found by hikers.

[@darkkiss7247]

Or hunters

[@dazza8551]

Thanks for the hikers!

[@Brax1982]

But what percentage of missing bodies ARE hikers?

[@joanwayne4036]

This is exactly why I don’t go hiking.

[@PatrickC139]

Pretty much.

[@rockinbobokkin7831]

I do believe all this success is getting to Mike's head. He bought a whole new shirt.

[@lonecapricorn9518]

And glasses lol

[@joymello1244]

🤣🤣🤣💀

[@NannupTiger]

I don't think that is new...

[@kimberleymclean6293]

that's not a new shirt..

[@catherinehpn3613]

@@lonecapricorn9518 are there lenses in the glasses? Lol

[@rockosantos13]

My girlfriend is worried about my addiction to this channel.. she doesn’t know I can stop whenever But I’m not lol

[@uMADden]

You look like you belong in these videos..

[@amylege3744]

Ha! So is my husband 🤣

[@debbyhutchinson6984]

Yeah "we can all stop any time we want " as we form our own little meetings while we watch just one more lol

[@mannyc4539]

@@uMADden 🤣😅😂🤣😅😂

[@uMADden]

@@mannyc4539 just speaking facts no 🧢

[@user-wi9iw8iw3s]

Mike is the best at narrating crime. Watch That Chapter as often as I can. Thanks Mike.

[@Friday_Night_Frights]

“Les? Is that your name?” “Lester” *proceeds to call him “Les” constantly*

[@didarden]

Lol. To get him agitated

[@Friday_Night_Frights]

@@didarden oh I know. Just thought it was funny lol

[@scaredygoat]

🤣 “whatever LES”

[@Alan-ej6wb]

Mo Lester

[@valentina1219]

I came to the comment just to say that LOL what a chad move

[@UnderTheTableGremlin]

When her dad said he realized he hadn’t cried in a long time. I WEPT.

[@joycampi7233]

That broke my heart 💔

[@karimb9157]

God bless his heart

[@war32mec]

Pulled at the ol heart strings.

[@DarkDreamsAndMoonlitNights]

Her poor Dad...

[@mikkayo]

So sad...

[@moxiemaxie3543]

Can you imagine finding out your partner doesn't want kids AFTER you marry them? Think that would be a conversation before signing a legal contract

[@Isabella-nh5dm]

It's funny because that's what I have always thought. I cannot believe the number of people I have known that have never discussed this before marriage! It is mind boggling. One of the most basic things. It's as if they gave no thought or talked about their hopes ands goals if life! (Cause for me that would have come up)

[@jayeckson]

Sometimes it doesn't matter even if you do. I was very clear with my spouse before marriage that while I think kids are great, I did not want any of my own. He told me he never wanted kids either. Months into the marriage he said he'd changed his mind because he loved me so much he wanted a family with me. But he's also hinted that he always wanted kids, and only said otherwise because he wanted to marry me and was hoping I'd change my mind.

[@reignman30]

Finally someone else mentions it. I was like, WTF? Makes you wonder what the divorce rate is with high school sweethearts. Can't be good lol. You're not even the same person you were in high school by the time you're 25.

[@Sylveon1002]

You should definitely discuss children before marriage,but they also married right after high school. It’s not uncommon for 18/19 year olds to feel very differently about wanting children in their mid 20s/30s then they did as teens.

[@SuziMcCrory]

What would be worse is finding out they don't want kids after you have kids. She did the right thing finding a different partner instead of taking it upon herself to bring a child/children into the first marriage. Definitely a conversation that needs to be had, ideally before getting married. BOTH partners should be on board BEFORE anyone gets pregnant. Birth control is so incredible now, it lends itself wonderfully to family planning.

[@jello12345]

Ugh. Her dad 💔 I can't imagine being murdered and just thinking about my kids the whole time until it's lights out. Terrible :( those babies.

[@xpkareem]

If a cop says they think you killed someone, your next line is "Am I under arrest? If so, I'd like a lawyer, if not I'll be on my way".

[@mliterature]

Yes! Exactly.

[@agirlisnoone5953]

I appreciate out police, we absolutely need them. They can detain you without arresting you so you can't really be on your way even if your not actually under arrest.

[@bethanyrash4118]

@Paul Hatz Cops don't have to read miranda rights anymore. They forgot so much and had to let so many people go over it that the govt passed a law about it.

[@Momsadventure7]

Exactly!!!!!!

[@wanderinghistorian]

@@agirlisnoone5953 not true, if you are not under arrest they cannot detain you, if they get pushy just keep demanding a lawyer, if they ignore that you're laughing because as soon as it gets to trial you can have it all thrown out for ignoring your Miranda Rights.

[@pesmerga4862]

holy hell that attorney is obsessed with viruses. she would be having a FIELD DAY right now

[@wanderinghistorian]

Attorney. "Infection your honor!" Judge. "For the last time, it's 'objection,' and you're overruled."

[@MontanaDior]

Lmaoooo... y’all are crazy 😂😂🤦🏾‍♀️

[@Leosmommy19]

She's probably a Karen that doesn't wear a mask😂😂hopefully not

[@nocthemedic2951]

@@Leosmommy19 imagine being piss scared of a flu just because you were told to be scared

[@amityislandchum]

She sounded ridiculous. What an awful public defender.

[@johnpaukstadt3994]

That interviewer is badass. “It should” ... that would scare me lol

[@willbedford8381]

"a flame just down the road" and "Lester, first name Mo" I hope people appreciate Mike's words

[@IxchelPerez]

"Nobody wants to see my goblin buddy." You, good sir, haven't been reading your KZbin thirst comments...

[@morgangadbois2092]

Lol I saw this comment as he said it hahaha I love this man!!!

[@zamoomaw]

As a Mike stan I can agree🙋‍♀️🙋‍♀️🙋‍♀️

[@guardian2598]

It’s time for Mike’s onlyfans

[@jennylovesjoe1224]

Love this comment! 😁 I am so here for him too! 🙋

[@shannonjackson9778]

I would absolutely leave him a turdytree dollar tip for that show

[@scoutz0rs]

When the interviewer leaned forward and said, "It should." lol damn girl

[@missgigip]

I was clapping for her like get him! 💪🏼

[@degrelleholt6314]

That's when he should have said. "I want a lawyer." And not answered another question.

[@lincroyableprocrastinateur5414]

Yeah I giggled pretty crazily at that line! Just went from the leaning back, asking questions fairly intensely, to the lean forward and almost threatening him:-)

[@lincroyableprocrastinateur5414]

@Cynthia Murphy Even if she can't get things out of him, which she totally did! His observed reactions to the female detective can give them a ton of info just by themselves

[@YEAREAPIRATE]

@@navajo237 there's only so much an interrogator can do

[@kimwagoner1147]

I Love this detective. Two words would scare me to death. And she got close to his face when she said, IT SHOULD. Thank you Mike. I've been binging your videos. Lots down Lots to go.

[@lildyl3463]

When she leaned in and said “ it should “ was awesome , like right out of a movie

[@theodorTugendreich]

Police work does not always attract the smartest people, more often those who need to wear the uniform.

[@reignman30]

Wait lol, "awesome" and "right out of a movie"? Were you being sarcastic? I mean, I was thinking the same thing, but not in a good way. I was thinking, holy shit, she's watched too many movies. In fact her lean in was so awesome the guy got to go live his life for 5 more years after it.

[@lildyl3463]

@@reignman30 ya I mean she set that up so dramatically like it was scripted , so the moment she did that was jist pretty cool

[@jewel9646]

*leans in* “it should.” LEGEND

[@GatoSanDad]

The people saying that it was "weak sauce" are dumb as hell lol.

[@vintage1950]

My brother in law (Irish) would also say ‘The turd turning on the left’ whilst giving directions. Always made me laugh, miss him dearly.

[@samanthawellbrock8917]

When the interrogator asks Lester if there is anything they need to know……crickets…….I thought maybe he fell asleep. 🤣

[@Malcolmblacc]

I love in the beginnings when you try to act like you don’t know it’s filming lol your sense of humor is exactly like mine , I love your wit

[@Hey_pookie_lol]

I instantly like that police lady. “Does that bother you? It SHOULD, ok?” 😂

[@hapichampagne5916]

Same

[@samanthawebb6494]

Came here to say this 🤣

[@maddy02_]

She asked if it makes him nervous. Then she said "it should"

[@crystalray1118]

"Her friends must have loved her for that one". Thank you for speaking on behalf of all of us with friends in multi level marketing, Mike. Love your channel!

[@joliekae]

Pampered Chef has top-notch quality products. Their lemon juicer is sub-LIME. 🍋🍋🍋

[@Sweet_Malou]

@J M whoa!! Dark. 🤣

[@bigdaddy4444]

I can not in my wildest imagination see why he should be convicted. I'm not saying it was not him, but they have no proof what so ever. How can one be judged without any hard evidence?

[@ssvensic]

It's scary you can end up in prison for life without any evidence, witnesses, weapon, body,...

[@rommy143]

I really appreciate that I never get an obnoxious number of ads when I’m watching TC! Thank you!!!

[@leighelliott3565]

She actually lived in Atlanta when she was young. My sister was friends with her when they were little. Very sad how her story unfolded. Her family loved her very much.

[@Christopher-Lenz]

Did Lester really do it?

[@anhedonianepiphany5588]

@BasedLeaf Games It was probably one of her 'regulars' who finally discovered what $1000 per hour prostitutes _actually_ look like. Nasty dangerous business!

[@cherryvoid5238]

@@anhedonianepiphany5588 why so mad?

[@thereisnopandemic]

Hookers have bad lives. What you expect

[@thereisnopandemic]

@@cherryvoid5238 he is saying the truth that is not anger. Why you project

[@Guro-Blue-kun]

13:32 That was pure gold. That investigator was golden. *"...it should"* 🤡

[@luluhussain7592]

“Or she wouldn’t call him again, full stop.” So sad 🥺

[@marstirelt]

"Lester Joe, first name Mo" I came for the true crime, stayed for the sneaky jokes like that

[@denesechavez5581]

Ha! I just got that! Took me awhile lol

[@jedaaa]

I noticed that but I don't get it...

[@evoluna3056]

@@jedaaa Mo Lester: Molester

[@victoriamoreno498]

I heard the mailman listening to Mike the other day

[@scottmatznick6461]

Went to pick up weed at the neighbor's the other day and she had Mike on. And luckily not a mic on

[@michaeldailey7103]

Scott Matznick That's awesome !!

[@unterdessen8822]

Impeccable taste for a mailman.

[@jenniferwebster405]

That’s so funny

[@kathykelleyskillercontent1795]

That's awesome.

[@Rbattam]

When she asked him for one reason why he should be ruled out as a suspect, that was the longest pause I've ever witnessed in my life.

[@afcaton1]

The nod says it all "Did you do it" " No I did not" all the while nodding his head up and down. You gotta love Psychology. 💘

[@Llama_lolz]

It’s crazy how people are literally finding their calling here. I prefer his videos more than any true crime show on cable

[@Findpepperbridge]

Agreed

[@garyjohnson4657]

Boring!!!!

[@w.kfontaine7084]

Mike?

[@SewWithLyza]

Yes I love how he tells the stories,especially the humor and the goofiness 😆

[@andrewstephens3440]

Cable 😂🤣

[@cmpsep]

"...and pampered chef." "Her friends must have loved her for that one!" Keep speaking that sarcastic truth, bro!

[@tomasviane3844]

So true!

[@___LC___]

When that friend you haven’t heard from since high school or university sends you a message on Facebook or email....

[@annacostello5181]

I unfriend anyone approaching me for that crap

[@CreativeCreatorCreates]

@@annacostello5181 beware the hun bots!

[@rexyray222]

That Lady Interrogating Him was a BOSS!

[@AviViljoen]

How so?

[@bailey2913]

“Goblin body” pmsl, brilliant. You’re a funny guy Mike 👍🏼

[@jerelnaito5975]

Wal-Mart surveillance has solved so many murders... Note to self: don't shop at walmart for murder supplies

[@jerelnaito5975]

@Alessia Sivieri Vivian these amateurs are buying brand new shovels and keeping the receipt

[@Emiliapocalypse]

But if you’re planning on _getting murdered,_ showing up on Walmart surveillance is ok 👍

[@koolaid117]

The police will look at your bank transactions and if you used your debit card to pay for these things, that's how they get you. My advice, use cash.

[@jerelnaito5975]

@@koolaid117 lol... us watching all these murder documentaries could probably be used as evidence too

[@Muralikrishna99]

😂😂😂😂

[@rustystewart1950]

Thanks for putting subtitles when the interrogations are goin on.

[@PinkyJapan]

“That doesn’t scare you?........It should.” That detective is my hero! What a bad ass!!!

[@deezelkane]

What an absolute B... she had no proof, there still is no proof.. imagine if he is actually innocent. Scary times to be an American. That could be you, being falsely convicted, and you seem over the moon about this case 🤦‍♂️

[@PinkyJapan]

@@deezelkane I'm American too sir. What she did is a common interrogation tactic. Have you watched many police interrogations before?

[@PinkyJapan]

@@deezelkane Also, if you think it's scary to be an American, google Japanese police interrogations. They can hold you for as long as they want and pepper you with questions for DAYS on end until the suspects finally crack and confess to crimes they didn't commit just to end the torture.

[@deezelkane]

@@PinkyJapan yes it’s borderline coercion. It’s disgusting. I’ve seen many cases of a degenerate detectives doing this, and making innocent men be found guilty. America is disgusting

[@deezelkane]

@@PinkyJapan I don’t care what them asians do, they have their own laws. I expect better from westernised places. This man got convicted with very little to go on. You should be very scared mate. Pray it doesn’t happen to you

[@larryroyovitz7829]

I'm shocked at how many (hint: most of them) don't get attorney's when they talk to cops.

[@susannabear]

When the detective leaned forward and said ‘it should’ it was so badass!

[@rengsn4655]

SusieItaliano a normal innocent person would be scared

[@BalboaBaggins]

not really

[@Dizzyswoops]

Her interrogation skills were pretty blah

[@PlatosPunk]

Kids a "dealbreaker?" Wouldnt....you learn that before marrying ?

[@billtheone3467]

they were high school sweethearts

[@Philmore.]

Code word, he didn’t have enough money

[@dre3k78]

Yeah and why would you try to get back with her after she had 3 kids by someone else?

[@sandrafaith]

You'd think.

[@musandlala7991]

@@dre3k78 I mean, Where is the self respect?

[@kmdewhurst]

That detective is a master negotiator. Very impressive.

[@AviViljoen]

What? She's nothing but a bully. And she got nothing out of him. In what universe does that make her good?

[@juliaszybowicz7709]

He did it. Lester. You can see it. He is such a sociopath. Another heartbreaking story💔😢...RIP, Paige. Yes, your secret life is out, yet, your murderer now sits in jail. I hope and pray your family and friends have some sense of peace and justice now. ♎⚖️🕊️☮️

[@Nothinggirl]

Geeze when her father mentioned him not crying that was sad af 😢🥺

[@LovenEverythingNails]

Right? It was heartbreaking hearing his voice crack like it did. Seemed like a very nice man.

[@Tracymmo]

@@LovenEverythingNails He really did!

[@mattkaustickomments]

Could you imagine that detective being your mom? You couldn’t get away with ANYTHING. You should just go straight to the timeout chair.

[@borderlinerecluse]

"Does it bother you that when I looked in your room after midnight and didn't see you in there? It doesn't bother you. *leans in* It should."

[@adzreenaziz6255]

Detective ：Did u make that mess in the kitchen? Me ：no Detective：thats incorrect...yes u did

[@truth4004]

I agree it reminds me of my mom. LOL

[@danadecker4855]

Moms are half detectives already

[@reignman30]

I gotta be honest, I'm surprised Lester didn't start laughing. That was pure cringe. She made it too obvious that she was bluffing. And he already knew she didn't have anything because even at trial they still had nothing. Because there was nothing lol. A public defender won the first case and got a mistrial lol. A public defender!! That's barely better than representing yourself.

[@aniaikoza7506]

The fact that she met up with her first husband after years and something sparked between them once again, only for her to get killed right after the picnic made this story even more tragic than it already is 😭

[@danajohnson6273]

“Nobody wants to see my goblin buddy.” Best line of This Chapter.

[@SneakingMOUSE]

I love your content, Mike. Every other channel that reviews cases solved or cold, will always have this obnoxious "scary ambience" playing in the background. Personally, the choice to have things more serious, less scary, and sometimes oddly upbeat makes your videos stand out as something truly special. I respect you.

[@Hugh-Glass]

I feel real bad for Paige's father. This was pain no father deserves. God bless those mourning their kids.

[@LePreuxBuisson]

When he talked about how he hadn't cried in a long time, it was so painful to watch..

[@Hugh-Glass]

@@LePreuxBuisson yeah. As a dad that was a gut punch.

[@Hugh-Glass]

@@LePreuxBuisson yeah brother. Sometimes it's hard to fight the fight to simply function or have the energy to take a shower. I found that forcing strenuous activity and exercise helps a great deal if you can find the gumption to begin.

[@FR4M3Sharma]

@@Hugh-Glass You're a Wonderful Human being. Thank you for your words.

[@Hugh-Glass]

@@FR4M3Sharma

[@sarahshelton1729]

I LOVE how Mike’s so grossed out about the MLM scams she’s shilling *cringe*

[@DesertVox]

With that kind of investigation and railroading by the prosecution, no one who ever crossed paths with a murder victim is safe from being found 'guilty' by the flimsiest of non-evidence.

[@SnoobaWookie]

"I did not kill her, I did not. Oh hi Mark."

[@usandthem2523]

Classic.

[@yourshadowself]

"shut the door!"

[@sognsogn-jo9qb]

lol

[@LilKingler]

Thought the same thing lmfaoo

[@Jayleepeartree]

LOL

[@KontraV]

I loooove how the interrogator kept calling him Les even after he tried to correct her 🤣🤣🤣

[@GregorySnipe]

She is awesome!! A badass.

[@Misunao23]

Probably an interrogation tactic. Gotta get them reaaaal uncomfortable.

[@skandababy]

She's ignoring jurisprudence... why not ignore his right to respect in the court. The court ignored professionalism, social customs, unbiased fight for justice, and oath of office. It's typical behavior of a DA when they have no real evidence, and therefore need to manipulate the jury's perception of the defendants guilt. When evidence is scarce, dramatics and misrepresentation of the truth will suffice. Another disrespectful, self-entitled, self-righteous, authority figure shamelessly exhibiting abuse of power. Another agent of the gov't with a power trip.

[@skandababy]

And I'm not implying that the guy is innocent, I'm unequivocally stating that the charges against him were not proven... at all... and certainly not beyond a reasonable doubt.

[@skandababy]

@@GregorySnipe How?

[@NotAGovernmentAgent]

"Prove to me you didn't kill her" - Umm, that's not how burden of proof works detective.

[@GhostDrummer]

The way she leaned forward when she said, “It should” was chilling...I’d be a little concerned at that point.

[@reignman30]

I'm disturbed by the sheer volume of people who thought her tactic was badass or chilling when the better description is cringe.

[@alexabandala1952]

“And they even went on a date on Thursday, June 28, 2007.” OK SIR, your tone is deceptively casual and conversational, but when ya start dropping exact dates and times I know some shit’s about to go down.

[@drebk]

100% Was all like.... uh oh.

[@aladinsane9785]

UwU....*notices you’re a girl* K-konichiwa! *twiddles thumbs and sweats profusely as you stare at me in disbelief* B-baka!

[@bobbymenon4057]

👍☺️

[@deannad3077]

@@aladinsane9785 You just made me think of the movie "Fried Green Tomatoes" lol ... thank you :)

[@gs4309]

“The mother of tree young saplings...

[@Gardner0871public]

Chazz Nasty underrated comment 🥇

[@Dangerkraft]

This is good content

[@geraltsjaskier]

*UNDERRATED COMMENT*

[@astrialindah2773]

😂😂😂👍

[@annwithaplan9766]

G S - And on the turd of April.

[@khover4242]

"No one wants to see my... goblin buddy." Rofl! How do you manage to make us laugh in the midst of tragedy? Crying for two reasons now.

[@marylineftn5007]

"It should." Perfect!

[@parapsychotic]

That interrogation was more like being calling into the principal’s office.

[@esparka]

Lady Dick pointed hard right at his face. She warned him that he should be concerned. Please note the final outcome.

[@Rorschach00Testing]

...or the 👻 ghost of Christmas past.

[@rjritch9196]

She was so cringeworthy. Women shouldn't be given that job ever

[@sosmooth13]

@@rjritch9196 I’m gonna sound like a white knight right now, but I’ve seen PLENTY of cringey interrogations from men in her position as well.

[@rjritch9196]

@@sosmooth13 I completely agree with that, but there's a certain dynamic between genders where the woman feels she has to act way more extra just to validate herself as the authority in the interrogation

[@dovebar76]

Tuesday’s and Friday’s are my favorite days because of “That Chapter!”🥳💯💙

[@mrs.dr.spencerreid3992]

I concur ‼️‼️‼️😁

[@LynnAgain83]

Agreed 👍

[@20FreeWill]

Lames

[@lisamariejg641]

Oh my gosh that detective - I love her! That’s like a line out of a movie :O “Does it make you nervous that we may think you did something?” "No" "It should"

[@nilz9397]

That lady interrogator was brilliant when she looked at him and said 'it should'.

[@AviViljoen]

She wasn't. She got nothing.

[@rosepatterson9374]

Hearing her Dad choke up... 😭 So, so sad.

[@buzbuz6221]

Everybody gangsta until the investigator lady says: “Does that bother you? Well it SHOULD”

[@kyladio93]

He got told

[@user-gj1me4mf5c]

She is the worst investigator I've ever seen. It is cringe inducing. And an embarrassment to that department.

[@just-trust-in-your-own-way]

That investigator lady was the real g. She was awesome!

[@eriksimca9409]

nah it was better when she asked what happend *hmmm incorrect, ok?*

[@darkndeed6311]

It may have been the wrong time for that statement. She then tried to be friendly while offering lesser possibilities of an accident.

[@zombies.in.space.]

mike, your puns and commentary on some of the insanity of these cases is the only thing keeping me slightly sane in this life, so thank you

[@cynthiam3943]

Oh dear she didn’t want to leave a house that cost her 6,000 dollars a month, what a shame!

[@sarahelaine8]

I'm so glad you didn't play the voicemail from her kids. It's beyond heartbreaking!

[@Tracymmo]

Oh good God! I don't like when those kinds of things are made public.

[@hopefullyinnocuouscontent4290]

I was anxious for over half of this video before I realized he wasn't going to include it. Definitely one of the saddest things I've ever heard, and irrelevant to the case honestly. Of course they missed her, and wanted her home. She was a good mom. Mike is a better man in my eyes for leaving it out.

[@missemeortiz]

That detective lady was amazing - I felt the pressure through the screen lol

[@AviViljoen]

Amazingly incompetent. She got nothing.

[@timothywideman6837]

I’m gonna have to finish watching this later. I have to be somewhere by four, and it’s already tree-tirdy-tree.

[@Traeseare]

I'm not even a person who likes watching crime dramas, but I can't stop watching this channel LOL. Thanks for your vids, they're helping me stay sane (somehow) through the covid isolation. You're a great story teller and I love how you lean into your quirks hahaha