The Disturbing Murders at Keddie Cabin

Watch the new and 7th season of BuzzFeed Unsolved: True Crime! • BuzzFeed Unsolved - Tr...
We tackle a fresh case in the remote forests of Northern California
MERCH: We've got it! SHOP NOW: bzfd.it/2MDBk2d
Credits: www.buzzfeed.com/bfmp/videos/...
Check out more awesome videos at BuzzFeedBlue!
bit.ly/YTbuzzfeedvideo
bit.ly/YTbuzzfeedblue1
bit.ly/YTbuzzfeedviolet
GET MORE BUZZFEED:
www.buzzfeed.com
www.buzzfeed.com/videos
/ buzzfeedvideo
/ boldly
/ buzzfeedblue
/ buzzfeedviolet
/ perolike
/ ladylike
BuzzFeedBlue
Sports, video games, Unsolved & more epic daily videos!
MUSIC
Licensed via Audio Network
STILLS
Evidence Box
BlakeDavidTaylor/Getty Images
computer generated equalizer bars in waveform audio spectrum
vitanovski/Getty Images
Handwriting
CSA Plastock/Getty Images
Policeman in office, portrait
Darrin Klimek/Getty Images
Community
Plume Creative/Getty Images
Psychic/Palm Reading dwelling, home, business.
Pete Starman/Getty Images
Close-Up Of Hammer Against White Background
Hendrik Sulaiman / EyeEm/Getty Images
Confident woman smiling against wall
Portra/Getty Images
Studio Portrait of a middle aged women
Jamie Garbutt/Getty Images
1970s BOY PORTRAIT STRIPED...
H. Armstrong Roberts/ClassicStock/Getty Images
Red Phone Receiver on a Spiral Cord on White
artpartner-images/Getty Images
Steak Knife
LongHa2006/Getty Images
Bloodied metal hammer and knife
korionov/Getty Images
Chef's knife
Siri Stafford/Getty Images
Old fashioned police station
ChrisSteer/Getty Images
Mystery cases and evidence files
EXTREME-PHOTOGRAPHER/Getty Images
Folder & Paper (w/path)
PeteWil/Getty Images
Retro photo frame isolated on white background
ExpressIPhoto/Getty Images
Digital abstract background
OlgaGroza/Getty Images
Portrait of psychologist in examining room
Smith Collection/Getty Images
Retro Reel Audio Recorder
tridland/Getty Images
1930s MONTAGEF 37 HEADS
H. Armstrong Roberts/ClassicStock/Getty Images
Blank lined sheet of paper on white
stockcam/Getty Images
Brown envelope torn open
Andrew Paterson/Getty Images
files.
Utamaru Kido/Getty Images
Policeman
JDC/Getty Images
Male police officer with crossed arms
UpperCut Images/Getty Images
Rear View Of Silhouette Police Standing By Car
Frederic Genest / EyeEm/Getty Images
Writer
ClaudioStocco/Getty Images
Sherlock wannabe
EXTREME-PHOTOGRAPHER/Getty Images
Evil man hold shiny knife, killer in action
stevanovicigor/Getty Images
Police badge
Tetra Images/Getty Images
Selective focus blurred view of abusive boyfriend holding girlfriends head ready to strike in kitchen
Mark Andersen/Getty Images
Beautiful woman who is sad but strong
Paris Jefferson/Getty Images
Tough Serious Mature Man
drbimages/Getty Images
Portrait of middle aged man looking serious
Klaus Vedfelt/Getty Images
Human skull
Joe Clark/Getty Images
Unrecognizable woman running for her life
SimonSkafar/Getty Images
Wedding cake visual metaphor with figurine cake toppers
Mike Kemp/Getty Images
Witch in forest
Thegoodly/Getty Images
Bloody investigations
Yuri_Arcurs/Getty Images
Children's bedroom with a bunk bed nside a residential log home, Laurentians, Quebec, Canada. This image is property released. CUPR0211
Perry Mastrovito/Getty Images
USA, New York State, New York City, Crime scene barrier tape
Tetra Images/Getty Images
Abandoned log cabin with open window
Linka A Odom/Getty Images
Portrait of boy
Jordi Boixareu/Getty Images
Teenage boy (15-17) with bob haircut, hands in pockets, portrait
James Woodson/Getty Images
Group of boys smiling
Flashpop/Getty Images
Group portrait of people smiling
Flashpop/Getty Images
Ending it all
Yuri_Arcurs/Getty Images
Hand holding blood covered knife
Simon Winnall/Getty Images
Candle lights memories
by calajava (Peter Chan Shu-kei)/Getty Images
Number 28 Mounted On Textured Wall Outdoors
Klaus Fenzl / EyeEm/Getty Images
Cabin Door
buburuzaproductions/Getty Images
Spooky cabin in the woods
Sjo/Getty Images
VIDEO
Footage provided by VideoBlocks
(vblocks.com/x/BuzzFeedKZbin)
EXTERNAL CREDITS
Steve Mintz
+
Grant Henderson

[@mimoza7514]

Marty : i murdered 4 people Police : yall hear sumn ?

[@BeautifulbyDesign18]

mimoza 😂😂

[@tayloranderson7547]

Marty :I murdered 4 people

[@Emmmajaane96]

Taylor Anderson why do you do this

[@AJ-iy4fo]

🤣🤣🤣

[@davidmartinez2407]

;’[]

[@spacemarines1371]

Shane looks like the kind of person who while getting murdered would say "oh no I'm getting murdered" in a really sarcastic tone.

[@nonaorcawhale5415]

I can relate 😂

[@jude297]

* Has a knife in his chest * "soo, do i get to keep this,, or will you want it back?"

[@AJ-iy4fo]

@@jude297 🤣🤣🤣literally

[@GUROBOY..]

I would look like “Wow I’m dying... cool!” And my friend would say “Ah... AaAh.... AAAAH!!!”

[@katiefish7499]

True😐

[@patskindatired]

Homicidal man covered in blood in the woods: *Running as fast as he can* Shane: Monday's, am I right?

[@AmateurCreep]

I love shane bro

[@patskindatired]

@@AmateurCreep Bruh, sammmee.

[@wowmyname4506]

That do be what its like in the woods

[@iamanitthanks4208]

I mean to Shane's point, the guy could have been hunting or something

[@WhisperingMoon83]

This made me laugh very loudly 😂

[@andrewb4742]

Marty could have filmed himself doing it and the police still wouldn’t care in the slightest

[@johanvajse8410]

this is a ridiculous statement. of course with that much evidence, the police would arrest and the courts would convict. But seeing as this didn't happen, and there wasn't really any evidence before Marty died, the police couldn't do anything. Also, there is the real possibility that Marty was innocent

[@andrewb4742]

@@johanvajse8410 1: sir have you never heard of a joke before 2: Are you Marty? Edit: also this is going straight to r/woosh

[@wowmyname4506]

@@johanvajse8410 you've never seen the police ive seen XD

[@serv3534]

@@andrewb4742 also this is a damn redditor

[@Alex-cw3rz]

I can imagine the next story being Marty was found with a bloody knife in his hand 13 witnesses had seen him do it, and he said to the police "I'm glad I ki lled the bas tard!". And the police still felt their wasn't enough evidence and ordered the victims family to pay to dry clean the blood off Marty's Jacket. This is a Blackadder reference but you could imagine it.

[@themac7915]

Marty: "I've come here to confess that I have committed the murders." Police: "What? I had my AirPods in."

[@edc4004]

Boo Rhyne ‘’no, they don’t fall out’

[@AlexGarcia-vg1iq]

Sorry I have my noice cancellation on

[@falconcorban4128]

More like head phones XD.

[@cookiejuice5886]

Alex Garcia noise*

[@potomato5693]

xD

[@mentally-ill-mary]

*Police in the 70's & 80's "Oh, you murdered someone... Ya got $40?*

[@nolovedasha1514]

Taylor Bright i died 😂😂😂😂

[@jeffjeff8935]

it just happens .... you know ....

[@jenniferloving9054]

Taylor Bright Something is rotten in Keddie, and I don't mean bodies!

[@maxlenhart7846]

Ecks deeeeeeee

[@kimberlyhaines107]

Bob Pickleson LA isn't a maybe. It's a definite "yes". Remember Rodney King and shit? Police officers committing felonies - I know of a few though I can't remember the guy's name.

[@bloodymetalangel287]

The fact that they tore down the house just further pisses me off. No one can convince me otherwise that that was intended to cover up any other evidence.

[@Scarecrow_Crane]

Yeah, it really seems suspicious.

[@johanvajse8410]

like Geogre Sodder bulldozed over their burnt house so no one could find any remains of the children they left behind when it was on fire? you can't think one is suspicious and not the other so if the keddie cabin was torn down to cover up any other evidence, then we know the Sodder Family's motive too

[@ovalhead1412]

Or it could be that the landowners didn’t want a cabin only know for a triple homicide standing abandoned

[@whynothanks2047]

Initially I was inclined to agree with you, but upon further thought I think maybe the owners of the cabins no longer wanted the campsite to be associated with a horrible event. Or, maybe too many people were going ghost hunting/loitering around the site in a way that was either unsavoury or unsafe. I think it really depends on who ordered/encouraged the cabin to be demolished, I wish the boys had looked into that! I think that’s where the answer lies. Tbh, if something like that happened on my property, I’d destroy every structure & start from scratch.

[@dw349]

The house was torn down 23 years after the murders... they sure took their time in "covering up" the evidence lol

[@linasayshush]

Shane: works on a show called "Unsolved" Also Shane: "So the killer was never caught?"

[@AssistanceAst]

2 years later still an underated comment

[@selene6170]

“ghost stories after sex” sounds like a band i’d listen to

[@fxckyouim2739]

You have good taste

[@emiliew5553]

sounds more like an album title but it really works either way

[@lilapuppu5961]

cigarettes after sex lol

[@omdoiphode5653]

@@emiliew5553 I mean Coldplay does have a an album called ghost stories

[@adambump5297]

I think I'd leave the bed if my partner started telling a ghost story or started going on about an unsolved murder.

[@rileywalton8276]

Ryan after sex: if you thought that made you scream, wait until you hear about the Axeman of new Orleans

[@izabella1129]

Asmr

[@kishenparekh9416]

loooooool

[@softclouds4025]

PLEAWASIM

[@samryder8496]

**W H E E Z E**

[@reidvillage]

WTH

[@shannonhiland4711]

My brother-in-laws grew up in Quincy (right by Keddie) and his mother went to school with the daughter who was murdered. He said that the whole town knew it was Marty Smart who killed them but the police were corrupt and didn't do anything. The police chief played football with Marty Smart in high school, and it was common knowledge in the entire town that Marty Smart was the murderer..

[@gabyoftherose]

Wow ..

[@Slockmen]

dayum

[@DenallieDNa]

Holy mother of God 😢😢😢

[@bdkplaysx]

one of the many reasons I don't trust the police.

[@pavitomexy]

In this way, what about Tina who has disappeared? Why did not Martin Smartt kill her in the cabin together with the others?

[@mattamuzzamil]

imagine being sheila and having to carry the burden that your family was brutally murdered and if u hadn’t decide to sleep w ur friend u would’ve been too. imagine the intensity of that survivors guilt

[@raniaminhas3406]

I can’t imagine going to sleep and the next day you find virtually all of your family murdered. I hope her and her 2 brothers are doing okay. I can’t imagine the pain of losing their loved ones and still not being brought to justice.

[@shadowprince4482]

I actually know Justin. Left him a little messed up but overall he's doing well. He doesn't like talking about it. I can't imagine though what it was like for her though.

[@emeraldgreen5985]

it makes me so mad that most of these unsolved murders could’ve been solved if the police wouldn’t have fucked up in some way or another

[@4loise]

Emma Jean Bean EXACTLY! Smh

[@lameloball3402]

True

[@Shwee113]

I just get mad about how people kill other people. Just don't though

[@emafojingaty447]

If the police weren’t racist with the zodiac killer. They would have saved so many lives.

[@krischimblo10]

emma j yeah that’s what they do though. The police are not known for being smart lol. They’re actually known for being the stupidest people you’ve ever met usually. I’ve had a few situations that would blow your mind.

[@Botsotikiku]

Marty: I murdered 4 people. The Police: must've been the wind...

[@johnleodiez4394]

@Paul Sansonetti what do you mean?

[@professorbaxtercarelessdre1075]

was Officer Barbrady in charge? lol (South Park reference)

[@mxveewz]

guys, im voting red, something about them feels sus

[@RunAwayNau]

There are 2 imposters in the town 🤔

[@flaco.antonio]

😂 Jesus

[@TheTrainmobile]

The guy moves out of state, writes a letter to his ex-wife confessing to the murders. Admits to a therapist that he murdered the 4 people and left his son and the people in the room with him alive. Gee, I wonder who it could be! Either his ex-wife was an elaborately skilled manipulator or he murdered the 4 people in the cabin. I'm gonna believe the later.

[@LP-ej7ez]

His wife doesn’t sit right with me. Whenever there is something that is possibly incriminating her (receiving Marty’s letter and counseling with the sheriff), she says she “doesn’t recall it”, which is a weird excuse to use twice. As well as one of the murder weapons being dumped while the rest were left at the crime scene. I’ve been rewatching the episode a few times and the more I think about it the less sense it makes. It seems like the three of them each have different stories, which leads me to believe that the sheriff was somehow connected to the Smart’s in terms of the murder. I don’t know tho, maybe I’m too obsessed.

[@baumer2504]

@@LP-ej7ez I think it's only natural to become obsessed. You want things to make sense and they clearly don't. It's difficult to live with something like this when there isn't any evidence to connect to a suspect. But when there's a lot of people with different accounts and evidence that points in every direction it's hard to get past it.

[@AutomaticDuck300]

@@LP-ej7ez she knew what happened. But she didn’t want to get the blame for causing the murders (or she didn’t want retaliation from Marty), so obviously she’s going to say “I don’t remember” when questioned about it.

[@jennsays3532]

Read the whole letter, not just the highlighted part. You will see that Marty was talking about him giving up his own four children to be with her. The highlighted area is said to be taken out of context by lazy reporters who didn’t research the full letter. The full letter is easily found online.

[@breaddemon2343]

@@LP-ej7ez i think its pretty understandable why the abused woman wouldnt wanna rat out her abusive husband (ex husband?) and his coverup guy especially after the abusive husband probably just killed a woman and nearly her entire family just for meddling in the marriage, yknow?

[@lunettasuziejewel2080]

The "I've paid the price for your love" part of the letter sounds like the delusions of a self-justifying abuser more than an indicator of Marilyn's feelings. It'd be totally in line for a spousal abuser for Marty to have convinced himself that Sue was poisoning Marilyn against him, and that killing Sue would have ~*magically*~ broken her influence over his wife, making her amenable to reconciliation again. Marilyn's memory loss and/or reluctance to give evidence against her husband, even after his death, read like symptoms of PTSD, which I would wager she has a massive case of 😔

[@Nyctophilia_And_Tea]

Dang this is a whole psycho analysis

[@slideshowgurl]

Typical gaslighter!

[@chrisboshneck1717]

Damn, for a minute I was about to complain about how nothing gets solved. Then I remembered the name of the show is unsolved.😂😂🤦🏾‍♂️

[@tommyjenga5976]

Nice neck

[@kieranlooksangry]

Smart lol 😂

[@paralinkincubusninja5100]

Chris Bosh Neck lmao😂😂😂

[@ashleyhayes1036]

They should really do some interesting solved ones in a different series!

[@Danceratdancebydesig]

Chris Bosh Neck i've never related to a comment more than this one before

[@astrologia9266]

Ryan: I feel we're being watched Me: *all hail the watcher*

[@tfordham13]

*Stubs toe* *quitly* all hail the watcher

[@limedashseven]

*all hail the watcher*

[@gabezwurld9615]

astrologia's sunchild. “Oh you took a poopie and you have no toilet paper?” *all hail the watcher, baby*

[@nikkiverhage9613]

*rains* all hail the watcher

[@pxinkillxr456]

Me:Loses chocolate bar The watcher:YEAH ! LETS GO! ALL ME BABY!!!

[@dodleboper]

if the house wasn't demolished every horror movie family would attempt to move in

[@classyhomo682]

I just wanted to say that you give off good vibes.

[@alyssa0411]

I’ve always felt really bad for what Tina went through. She most likely witnessed the murders of her family members and then was snatched away and eventually was murdered herself. What a horrible thing for a child to go through. I have a daughter who is just a few months younger than Tina was at the time of the murders….it just breaks my heart. I hope she wasn’t harmed too much before she died.

[@slideshowgurl]

And I’d assume she was probably assaulted in the meantime. why else would they have taken her? Horrible

[@rwori]

@@slideshowgurl her remains were found with a medical tape dispenser and her pants had been ripped :( she was taken for a reason

[@samsonsamuel9786]

This branch of buzzfeed: talks about real crimes and informs people like real educators Also buzzfeed: “I ate purple food for a week”

[@EarlMcFord]

Jesus?

[@clairedowell1667]

amen

[@janietyler2013]

Hahaha, true

[@Sylar-upd4t3]

Is watching murder mysterious very Christian? I got told to stop recommending investigation discover to people at church by a pastor

[@zankfrappe5145]

tastes like intolerance :/

[@AnaClarePlus]

OKAY BUT WHY ARE THESE ALWAYS ON GLOOMY RAINY DAYS? IT'S LIKE THE WEATHERS LIKE "OH SHANE AND RYAN ARE FILMING, LETS SET THE MOOD"

[@rawfitness9352]

AnaClare there was a huge flood! Haha I live 10 minutes away 😂

[@aloevera420]

Same thing for me. Dark clouds start appearing when I'm about to watch their videos. A thunderstorm just started as soon as I clicked this video lmao

[@starbittenpixieboy]

AnaClare same! It rains or shows whenever I watch their videos. Even in summer. JESUS CHRIST

[@archiehamerton5479]

Pathetic Fallacy

[@waitwat3515]

AnaClare or maybe it's cos there is a hurricane?

[@JNY42]

The fact that Marty Smartt apparently had a boiling hatred for Johnny Sharp, and that he left his son alive in another room, as well as Justin Smartt claiming to have seen the suspects means that it seems like they intentionally ignored them. The wife also claimed to have seen her husband and friend burning a hammer at 2 am. All the murder weapons were left in the house because they belonged to the Sharp’s except the one Marty Smartt owned, his own hammer. I mean case closed if you ask me

[@thepriorstone4064]

It’s amazing how the former sheriff acts all high and mighty about everyone apparently solving the case and called him out on corruption, all while knowing he and his department actively made it impossible to solve the case

[@alexanderossevorth2790]

I just- Whoever names their child "Bo Boubede" must *really* hate their child.

[@fentanyl5690]

HAHAHAHAHAHAHA

[@12-dimethylpropaneneopenta80]

I choked on my saliva when I came across this comment and it made me sound like a dying dog 😂

[@samtoffolo]

Unfortunately, his name is John ‘Bo’ Boubede.

[@dirgewordsmithe]

I was half sleep listening to this and thought Bobo Betty was the STUPIDEST nickname for a murder weapon I had ever heard!!!

[@ScorpV1]

"boobede" lol

[@sth2969]

The unsolved mystery of the camera man of buzzfeed

[@sth2969]

Scorce sorry im new

[@preita]

Scorce who is it?

[@brndn206]

Adam from Worth It?

[@xaninite8247]

Preita tamang poor Adam... goes through so much

[@saftytorch4435]

He's the Goatman.

[@teirdalin]

"will remain, unsolved." I mean, it kinda is solved. He clearly did it.

[@yanxinlu6101]

Right? Like it’s so obvious??

[@hashimahmed9409]

Even tho there is so much evidence he has not been convicted. Btw I’m not trying to defend him because he did do it. I just think the police and law are just so corrupt and not make a conviction

[@perishonimpact]

i feel so bad for sheila. the amount of survivor's guilt she must have felt :(

[@wickednikki1303]

“Oh you murdered someone?...You got 40 bucks?” Lmao I love that part...

[@kevinkenny871]

......And I love wickedness 😉

[@xPhantomxify]

Wicked answer, wanna get a wicked cup of coffee?

[@tayloranderson7547]

Oh you murdered someone? You got 40 bucks?

[@kaitsymone]

i read this as he said it lol

[@prod.medusa9724]

evidence: he did it wife: he did it shane: he did it ryan: he did it village: he did it police: ...did he tho?

[@greenllama2856]

The letter: yes I did it.

[@thatweirdgirlnextdoor4339]

Common sense: he did it

[@twistedfoot6808]

Marty: I did it

[@oliverblack9876]

Mmm

[@francescofulghieri9608]

him: I did it

[@Mishieftress]

Marty has seemingly passed away from cancer in 2000, but I really hope the case will find closure, seems like the new Sheriff actually wants to do his job.

[@jellybeanboy]

I hope he suffered every single day

[@BRIDGETTWC]

Not really because it's 2024 and still isn't solved 😢

[@UktHrll]

@@BRIDGETTWC they have 2 confessions that Marty did it and boxes of evidence leading back to Marty do they want a power point presentation that he did it

[@arushafarheen4509]

everytime Ryan says "and the case remains UNSOLVED" i feel restless as they dont have closures but the fact that there is a hope this case may be officially SOLVED is so heart soothing

[@mellowhamster]

You guys should do a series called 'Buzzfeed Solved' Where you talk about real gruesome crimes that are solved, but Ryan puts forward all of the suspects and Shane has to guess/deduce who the culprit is. Then Ryan reveals the true culprit.

[@logansmith2703]

Mellow Nite I'd love that.

[@sophianuijens]

yes please @buzzfeed get on that :)

[@jordanshell5472]

YASS, that should happen, look at all the episodes they can do.

[@brittsilva]

Oh yes. Yes.

[@caseymo7416]

YES!! I'd be totally addicted to a "Buzzfeed solved"!

[@vidasultani757]

I love how they go from the topic of stabbing to scooping ice cream

[@theitalianstallion973]

Toori Baba you need help…more help than me 🤣😂🤣 where did that come out of “I’d scoop on your asscream”

[@richardoakley6560]

Vida Sultani “Smart”

[@daniellemaroney2931]

IDK, but that Asian guy is funny.

[@stargatherer5926]

Vida Sultani you just summed up the whole show my friend

[@tayloranderson7547]

I love how they go from. The topic of to scooping ice cream

[@kayleeg1019]

No telling what Tina went through it rips my heart out… 💔 prayers for their surviving siblings.

[@strangeavocado9279]

I’m really glad that the sheriff who reopened the case has a personal connection to the case. It’s more likely that he’s solve it and I hope he eventually does.

[@751savik]

No one: Marty: I killed 4 people. Police: Will we ever solve this case?

[@SweeterGull]

Totally not Zokix11_MC dude he had to confessed twice

[@bipedleek241]

Avi K Henry lee Lucas exists, not all confessions are true

[@tayloranderson7547]

No one: Marty: killed 4 people police :👮 will we ever solve this case?

[@bipedleek241]

Taylor Anderson bruh

[@virgomoons]

Ikr like wow cops great job 🤦‍♀️

[@youmatterbanana8965]

**scary man running through a forest covered in blood** Shane: as u should

[@judesliggoo]

to each their own

[@madduckz]

Swred farmor man

[@wowmyname4506]

That is indeed how it is in the woods, they dont bother you and you don't bother them

[@tairneanaich]

I mean I would assume they were probably out hunting maybe?

[@pubeline1]

But did you teach yourself how to dougie yet?

[@Hannah-rg8nk]

wife: he did it... sue: he did it tina: he did it shane: he did it ryan: he did it. literally everyone else: he did it therapist: he did it Marty: i did it Police: LiEs

[@nathaliemillerr]

“and now u tell me that were through? great! oh IM the psycho because I murdered four people.” -JD from Heather’s at some point probably

[@nathaliemillerr]

he only murdered 3 but u get the point

[@beachvibez4214]

@@nathaliemillerr lmao

[@lydiar1883]

@@nathaliemillerr I mean if you count himself, you’re not wrong haha.

[@Matylda11Ireth]

It's pretty sad to think about the fact that Sue Sharp escaped an abusive husband just to be murdered by another deranged man.

[@EmKH-mi4eb]

... or by the same man ...? We don’t really know tho, people will agree to what they want to believe

[@alastorbutwithagun]

@@EmKH-mi4eb are you the police on this case?

[@EmKH-mi4eb]

@@alastorbutwithagun haha def not, just an amateur (not even) who’s addicted to crime case and investigation

[@alastorbutwithagun]

@@gamerslatestnews819 say what?

[@bella-zt7oz]

@@EmKH-mi4eb I was thinking that

[@idreary7590]

What I learned: How to get a nice scoop of ice cream.

[@tedsava1800]

We interrupt this tale of unspeakable horror and gore to give you some handy tips on how to get a nice scoop of ice cream!

[@strangewayfaringstranger]

From someone's skull?

[@strangewayfaringstranger]

Ha yeah. In this show called The Pacific, Rami Malek's character throws pebbles into this guy's open skull. Makes me think of that really.

[@caragrace6167]

BNHA/WEEB BTS/ARMY well if you put a spoon in warm water it will melt the hard ice cream, but it better to dry the spoon so it does t mix

[@marieisme03]

Ikr same legit never thought of dipping the spoon in warm water.

[@kaelanniblett2460]

With the letter from Marty Smartt, I think it could've been him telling his wife (even tho she never got the letter) that he killed for her. So it wasn't his wife who wanted it, but the way he saw it was that they needed to be killed. And it helped his marriage in his mind. But in her mind their marriage wasn't fixed so he was asking what else he has to do for her (like to win her back).

[@wireman4029]

I drove through that resort last summer (2019) after learning about these murders. Although the cabin that the murders occurred in had been bulldozed, the neighborhood itself still had an eerie feel to it. I wanted to try sample gold panning the creek that surrounds the cabin site, but felt really uneasy and only wanted to leave.

[@havi8-0-9]

the brain is a crazy thing

[@michellespann5675]

Shane: *constantly asks demons and ghosts to kill him* Ryan: I’m starting to think you wanna die

[@elisesimone613]

Press X to doubt wanting to live

[@melissalawrence2124]

The sad thing is, I can't recall Shane ever denying Ryan's claim. #Pray4Shane

[@hannahjoy333.]

“They told me “get out of your head” but I can’t, it’s a prison.” *~ Shane Madej*

[@Natalie-mo9ye]

Shane Dawson and Ryland are exactly like that

[@idr1s00.3]

Ryan: a knife into a body Shane: a spoon into ice cream

[@cianhayden9630]

Shows just how childish he is

[@minez5628]

@@cianhayden9630 How disrespectful and idiotic he is, actually

[@cum1918]

Mikael Inez Wait Cian or Shane?

[@kimmyseon46]

@@minez5628 bro chill

[@minez5628]

@@cum1918 Shane, don't even know Cian and I agree with him

[@urmumgae4245]

Marty: hey Marilyn I murderd our sons best freind's family *Marilyn doesn't recall this meeting*

[@robertmyles9124]

If my parents named me Bo Bo Betty I'd probably go on a murderous rampage too.

[@chargedcoyote8119]

What’s actually really scary is they probably showed one of the houses the murderer lived in

[@cerysgibson3947]

Michael Gilhooley gilhooley? Or Gilholy?

[@McCheazyy]

or he still lives there

[@UniverseGamerLumi]

Shane doesn’t bleed blood he bleeds *oily* *sheen* with a *fruity* *garlicky* *smell*

[@abbywolffe4114]

**laughs nervously** W h a t t h e f u c k

[@UniverseGamerLumi]

Abby Wolffe don’t you remember that episode

[@abbywolffe4114]

@@UniverseGamerLumi yeah that's Shane's reaction

[@UniverseGamerLumi]

Abby Wolffe oh frick i forgot, sorry

[@braceface1514]

🤣🤣🤣

[@rainiagacha1556]

Pardon me but, WHAT EVIDENCE DO YOU NEED TO SOLVE THIS YOU HAVE 2 CONFESSIONS, THE HAMMER, THE FACT HIS CHILD LIVED, AND A MOTIVE?!

[@52wbending52]

They didn't really bring up Marilyn's inconsistent behaviour or why she acted in the way she did. Honestly, I think it was the safest way for her to try and get the truth out while being terrified of her murdering ex-husband, i.e. saying she doesn't 'recall' certain events or letters, but confirms his handwriting. I get the feeling she tried to have the evidence speak for itself without putting the bullseye on her own back. Too bad the police just hosed down the facts. I don't think she's involved in the coverup.

[@ankitakuvalekar5977]

"You gotta do your job, 10% of your population was just murdered" 😂😂 *had me in splits*

[@slylover123]

im so glad shane is in this series ryan is not funny at all

[@oof-rr5nf]

slylover123 I wholeheartedly disagree :D

[@aditi9097]

@@slylover123 I believe both Ryan and Shane are awesome:))

[@gwynleah204]

Also Shane is twice as funny because he's got Ryan to bounce off of, and Ryan's more of a documentary guy than a funnyman.

[@maxcaulfield50]

@@slylover123 It would be boring if there is no ryan.Leaving the demon alone on the show.

[@crieverytim]

those boys that stayed in the room during the murder. ... smartt boys. real sharp.

[@turquoiseocean6092]

Lmao

[@tylersharp4769]

ice la honk my last name is sharp

[@strongfork]

Tyler Sharp i was gonna ask if you were smart cuz. sharp means smart but i saw you were a pewdiepie fan 🤢🤮

[@mindyober7146]

As in “Marty Smartt” boys?🤔🤭

[@amycorbett4664]

I shouldn’t find this funny 😂

[@rifflechipz.furrrr]

It baffles me that Marty was never arrested

[@KennyMcCormick99]

I KNOW WHAT ITS LIKE TO LOSE A PARENT AT A FAIRLY YOUNG AGE... HOWEVER, to lose a parent & 2 siblings in a truly horrific fashion, is just unfathomable! And I feel SO BAD for the survivors having to live w/ this EVERY DAY OF THEIR LIVES!! I PRAY THEY GET JUSTICE & HAVE FOUND PEACE. 🙏

[@eddixon2015]

I wonder how many cold cases could be solved by a thorough re-examination of evidence already in police possession.

[@professorbaxtercarelessdre1075]

indeed

[@silvercheetah92]

Probably more than we think

[@tonyspark245]

I don't know about the handling in the US but in Germany there is a thorough re-examination. Mostly when they want to test new gadgets. They're still nowhere closer to solving most of the cases which 3just baffling at this point

[@user-gs1xi8go8v]

right. at this point im convinced they just burn all the evidence every time they close a case. especially since so many older cases could probably be solved literally just using the technology we have today on the preserved evidence but for some reason they just don't?

[@tamarkb6833]

FBI has a cold case unit that works with local authorities

[@quietplace8455]

Ryan: “let me throw you a bone-“ Shane and Ryan: *”LITERALLY.”* Shane and Ryan: *”Oh.”*

[@Cardo2Suave04]

As soon as I saw this comment Shane and Ryan said exactly what you commented

[@xavierf.8173]

Clout chaser

[@ournzway1434]

Quiet Place An ad popped up and I saw this comment, then when the ad had finished this exact phrase was said 😂

[@kylahriddell6042]

@@Cardo2Suave04 no because same here

[@peetagreefin7762]

I feel so bad for them. The mother didn’t have much money and just wanted to give her kids and their friends a fun vacation even if it was just where they lived. May they all rest in peace, wherever they are, and hopefully the bastard(s) responsible will rot in hell

[@camerondavis3247]

this was my great aunt and cousins... its amazing to me to see so many people curious about this.. to me our family doesnt talk about it.. especially my grandpa.. i do hope they solve it but the prime suspects died.. god bless everyone making this still active update: they are making a Netflix documentary about this and currently in the works just for those who are curious

[@sogosakas]

sending love

[@michaeijackson1353]

Is your grandpa Don Davis?

[@camerondavis3247]

@@michaeijackson1353 yes

[@nickmuckerman607]

They need to make a "(wheeze)" shirt

[@jurajohnson3479]

id wear that all the time

[@littlediamondggaming6919]

nick muckerman they have a wheeze shirt they have merch

[@tea-rex6254]

I want one of those Buzzfeed Unsolved hats that Ryan wears all the time

[@dARTHvADERGirl7]

I would buy 200 of those shirts

[@LYO999]

nick muckerman you can find a lot of (wheeze) and 'hey there demons, it's me, ya boy' on redbubble ;)

[@macayla9004]

petition to move the scary mannequin behind shane off screen

[@artistriey2071]

Macayla Newey na fr....

[@daniellelawman9724]

It'd be more freaky if you noticed next time that the mannequin moved...closer

[@christinash2235]

Ikr

[@meltedcrayons7670]

That thing scared me. I was watching this one night and I yelped after seeing it.

[@dreguedes2388]

i was watching at night and I think that thing move. I didn't sleep that night

[@myettechase]

This is basically Buzzfeed Solved at this point. It was *clearly* Marty.

[@tjkaiser8029]

Who’s here after the news 😢

[@havi8-0-9]

rip

[@bloodyneptune]

✋

[@cutc2k764]

what happened?

[@midnitest0rm]

Plot twist: The Deer was the murderer all along.

[@szaylahskye]

When I say this gave me chills... i-

[@dirtydeeds576]

Like that episode of Adventure time

[@thedg7590]

I KNEW IT

[@special_ed128]

case closed

[@BHPaperstacks]

Skinwalker

[@prinwrld]

“Oh you murdered someone??....well you got $40 bucks?” Shane always has me in tears 😭

[@clayysi]

Happy tears or sad tears

[@prinwrld]

BridgetWithATablet a good mix of both

[@user-xb4tg2xs6n]

I'm the #1 shane stan gtfo lmao

[@leoooooooo7673]

YAGURLPRIN ? 40 dallors bucks?

[@Andrew-bb7ci]

YAGURLPRIN the video kind of just glances over him saying that, I didn’t glance it over, I fucking started dieing.

[@rorygiambalvo2955]

I love when they go to the locations as well, adds a really great visual element. This terrifies me because I can see that it's a real place, not just pictures.

[@alyssa0411]

I just drove through Keddie when I was traveling from Quincy to Lake Almanor. I looked over at the building along the road that says Keddie Resort and thought of this case. One week later in mid July 2021, the Dixie Fire broke out and the fire went right through the neighborhood where Cabin 28 once stood. According to the burn map the flames are showing they were right across the street from where the Sharp’s used to live. I hope some of the area managed to survive. It’s a beautiful area, lots of pine trees and the Spanish Creek runs nearby. As of right now (Aug 2021) the fire is still burning and has claimed 250k acres.

[@jellybeanboy]

My cousin took me to Keddie after the fires and all of the remains of the house have been destroyed

[@straw83rry.m1lk]

Guy: Confesses Police: Not enough evidence edit: ik that when someone confesses it doesn’t always mean it they are guilty but i feel like there was some evidence against the guy at least enough to convict him or at least put him on trail

[@Bloxsor]

😂🤣

[@White_Recluse]

Anyone can say they did something, that doesn’t make it true.

[@christinash2235]

The whole town was afraid of Murderin Marty. I imagine him being some scary abusive man who held them all at gunpoint in a bar. Including the police. Plus Bo or Bubba or whatever the hell had organized crime connections. He confesses, these small town ppl in 1981 no internet scared to death like "yeah ...uh ...that's nice dear, will you please pass the Country Crock?"

[@christinash2235]

@@White_Recluse there were 60 people living in the village. I stayed in one of those places for three months, nearest supermarket was 45 minutes away, I had to walk to the family corner market over a narrow scary bridge, one of my coworkers died in a ravine, drove right into it. Similar set up , they were living in the California wilderness. It's not like the Zodiac in San Francisco. California is enormous like three or four states big. It's not all a city. People disappear and die of exposure here too. Still.

[@christinash2235]

@@White_Recluse to put this in perspective the place was so isolated a car from the early 1970s was parked and rotting in the middle of the forest, Im guessing where someone died forty or fifty years ago, saw it on a hike. This is the kind of place they were in. They fuck hell know who did it. Their combined elementary and high school probably had 17 total children.

[@ummmmyeaaaaaaaaaaaaa]

The fact that they're still working on this case gives me hope idk

[@ummmmyeaaaaaaaaaaaaa]

adj0992 uhh I was. Tune into the parts where they explain this is an active case 👍🏼

[@galaxysuniverse4638]

I was the 666 path like,Should I be scared

[@hereforjhs7026]

i agree with you, ummmmyeaaaaaaaaaaaaa

[@alienusterrafirma]

? You understand that if a murder case is unsolved they frequent the case over the years, forever, until they find the perpetrator.

[@ummmmyeaaaaaaaaaaaaa]

Tyler Laughlin yeah but it's nice to hear that this case is being revisited atm idk

[@user-jg6bu3hc8f]

It's so eerie to think that even i felt like they were being watched the entire time. Pretty sure someone was peaking through those windows.

[@chasedavisson56]

Shane’s Ryan impression is IMMACULATE

[@fungus791]

Ryan: "I can't put my mind into the mind of a criminal, but like-" Shane: "I can." *Wait a sec...*

[@fungus791]

@@thearchitect8135 ikr

[@scotteishalucas9624]

It's not hard though it's kinda just psychology lol I mean I sit and think "if they did this or this they wouldn't have gotten caught" but I also think "the police had this and this and still couldn't find who did it and this and this"

[@cateIeya]

TheArchitect813 Lol. Shane’s just putting himself in someone’s shoes. It’s easy to think about why many killers would call. It’s mostly to taunt the victims. Many times, they want that feeling of “living in the edge”, and if they succeed in calling and not getting caught, it’s their greatest feelings. But then again, this is just my theory.

[@highschoolpimp]

I think we are onto something Chief.

[@__rainbow_2.0__49]

Honestly,i can

[@ericsabourin7033]

“Just spark up a cigarette, “Let me tell you, about the Keddie Cabin murder”. Ryan laughing hard

[@kingbee2537]

Eric Sabourin his impersonation was good too

[@aspen-rose]

(wheeze)

[@no-lw9qf]

I'm (wheezing) probably because I did just that.

[@mrdumpsterfire5458]

Me though

[@stevensardinta93]

In a taped interview of Marty Smartt by a DOJ officer, The DOJ officer questions Marty if he thinks his stepson Justin, who was sleeping over in cabin 28 that night could have seen or heard anything, and Marty answers talking about Justine, "He is quiet. He could have noticed something without me detecting him.". Then Marty quickly changes the subject. In my opinion, Marty just placed himself inside cabin 28 during the murders, and Marty himself realizes it too. kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z5-uXpd_jpeWZ9U

[@CrestfallenLizard]

"Police in the 70s and 80s were like, 'oh you murdered someone? you got forty bucks?'" police nowadays are like "oh, you murdered someone? so have i, and i got a paid vacation out of it!"

[@namename1379]

Great! Just saying not all cops are like that but I'm not gonna say that their all good people. There are some fucked up cops out there.

[@talon_xi165]

@@namename1379 hey, let's be honest, there's fucked up people in all jobs and throughout society. Don't let the bad apples ruin it though!

[@mosscoveredfrog155]

I genuinely love this comment lol

[@3am_mom]

😐

[@pluto1906]

@@talon_xi165 i mean given that the origin of the bad apples phrase is that in a barrel, a couple of bad apples will rot them all, bad apples will by definition ruin the rest

[@jaycierileymandrell]

Marty Smartt: *literally confesses and tells his wife he murdered four people*. The police: ope, this case is unsolved

[@dx1450]

Therapist: Yeah, this guy just confessed to me that he murdered some people. Police: OK, thanks for your information, have a nice day.

[@birb125]

Marty's hammer found near the crime scene in a lake with (possible) blood stains The Police: darn, could have been the murder

[@Seanfrenchh]

Anybody who says ope has got to be from Ohio.

[@crvshout]

@@Seanfrenchh Ohio does not exist

[@Seanfrenchh]

@@crvshout you know, I can’t say I dispute this lol. Parallel universe seems like a more accurate description. 😂😂

[@itzkirml]

Police: gosh, if only we could solve this case Marty: I did it- Police: if only there was enough evidence Marty: but- Police: *if OnLy-*

[@DOHmination]

lol

[@user-hn9up1ol8n]

This was so funny yet frustrating to read at the same time:’)

[@user-xl1eg1xw2g]

I legit see this conversation happening 😂😂😂😭

[@Zero-dead-]

New evidence showed that the son maybe have actually seen his father in the house that night

[@eileenzm0911]

Hello aghase

[@spectre6892]

2:33 Buzzfeed unsolved in a nutshell

[@marsmurderer9868]

Ok but that forest is absolutely beautiful, some might say it look creepy, and it does, but it also looks gorgeous

[@stupidbroad]

with their big black SUV, Shane and Ryan look like some kind of government official searching the area

[@dgcatanisiri]

Right up until you hear them talking, and you realize it’s just a couple of chuckleheads being idiots.

[@xxsohalalmodexx]

This needs more likes 😂😂😂

[@sudharanichippada1841]

@@dgcatanisiri lmaooool

[@jellybeanboy]

Maybe thats why that one guy in his truck just stopped and stared at them (they talk about it in the post-mortem)

[@kolteel]

"Do you tell ghost stories after sex?" IM LAUGHING SO HARD HELP

[@zenodotus-xxiv785]

and he was like "that's for me and my girlfriend to know" like first off I didn't know he HAD a girlfriend, and second, I'm pretty sure he does.

[@mopetmaddie]

Kas8605 oh my god i literally could not stop laughing for like five minutes when he said that 😂

[@xanderrokovich8119]

Well, my girl and I discussed the whole plot of Leś Miserables during sex so...

[@whatever9097]

Kas8605 What you don’t?

[@hashly8521]

Xander Rokovich During?

[@veggiesaremurder]

Shane and Ryan don't seem to know just how hard little kids crash, and the stuff they can sleep through.

[@cprow0997]

Yeah but people screaming for their lives in the next room?

[@veggiesaremurder]

@@cprow0997 yep. It really doesn't matter. Kids have slept through murders many, many times. They sleep through massive fights, even natural disasters like earthquakes.

[@katrinaoliver4167]

I hate it when I can’t stop fighting with my husband and we have to go see the town Sheriff

[@key9306]

My dad asked if Shane was Mark Zuckerberg.

[@dominiquepowell-saidykhan2916]

KZL 😂😂😂😂😂😩😩😩😩 Poor guy...lol

[@alpharumble5012]

Lol. Zuckerberg wishes he chould be Shane. People still listen to Shane.

[@bearsbeetsbattlestargalactica6]

Yes

[@teanashookson3638]

KZL say he's Mark's underrated cousin

[@jaylynbrielle3807]

This comment is gold 😂

[@checkman]

*7:13* psychologists believe that part of the reason why serial killers stay "close" after committing their murders, i.e. call and leave anonymous tips, return to the crime scene, write taunting letters to police, keep "souvenirs" etc. is because they are trying to re-live the adrenaline and excitement they experienced while they were committing the murders. Once it's all over, they lose that feeling, and desperately want to get it back.

[@promousey]

Me when I watched criminal minds once: jkjk-- I'm pretty sure that's all true

[@Idk5kitty]

Criminal minds?

[@catty7457]

Melody So yeah it’s a show about fbi profilers

[@Fienchen08]

U okay ?

[@checkman]

[ M•a•r•i•a S ] LOL yes

[@donaldvonglitchenberger4108]

One of my favorite episodes. Love when they visited the sites. The last few years it seemed buzzfeed didn’t want to spend the money for travel and lodging

[@elizabethlovett4318]

I've heard some killers get close to law enforcement and seem to act like they want to be caught, not because they want to be CAUGHT but it's more a flex on their part in showing how much smarter they are then authorities and also increase the fear of the public.

[@jellybeanboy]

Hannibal from Hannibal

[@h4nn.h]

it’s not BuzzFeed Unsolved without (wheeze)

[@panicatthetwentynermanticc6217]

hannah it's Buzz(wheeze) Unsolved

[@potatoechan1422]

He choked

[@emmapierce2807]

panic at the twenty øne rømantic crybaby bean discø YOU ARE MY IDOL THAT WAS PERFECT

[@aubreynan]

hannah I'm so confused

[@skylow3245]

Hey Hannah!

[@lenamurphy3613]

Terrifying that only 66 people live here, that's my junior and senior year classes combined. You'd know everyone really well. Someone there knows who did it. I'm telling you.

[@EmKH-mi4eb]

Lena Murphy 🤔🤔🤔🤔 hmmm...

[@UIAL570]

Or at least a good few people know something small details and combined could create a realistic timeline for who was where or doing what that night

[@corridefazio4704]

Good point

[@deluxeedition4639]

those are some small classes omfg

[@shes_lovely4006]

Martin Smartt most definitely did it.

[@gallaghergirl1234]

“Police in the 70s and 80s were like ‘oh you murdered someone? Do you have 40 bucks”😂😂

[@ilkerbasan]

2022 update: Gamberg and Hagwood say they are closer now to solving this case than ever before. Martin Smartt died in 2006. John Boubede died in 1988. But this family still deserve answers.

[@keddietruth716]

Actually thats a 2016 update. Gamberg was let go and Hagwood left pcso to join the board of supervisors.

[@sid.s.kamath]

Well it seems to me that almost every crime that remains unsolved is a result of bad/faulty investigation on the part of the police where in they either lose evidence, ignore evidence, not inspect the crime scene properly, not interrogate the suspects and witnesses properly and such. Just pointing out an observation. It's not that the perpetrators of the crime are super geniuses to cover their tracks; it's just that the people trying to nab them didn't do their job right.

[@ellamurphy6588]

Siddharth Kamath so tru though

[@tillidiesoon7815]

Siddharth Kamath I AGREE ON A SPIRITUAL LEVEL.

[@shristikumar610]

Siddharth Kamath That's so true!

[@stepmothercity]

Fun fact: a much higher percentage of murders were solved in than 50s than today, despite the advancement in technology.

[@aleksandravukotic655]

Siddharth Kamath the only exception I think is the pills murders

[@falisha6615]

Why am I watching this before I go to bed

[@kaitlynerwin4571]

AllThingsFalisha haha same

[@jaybaybee94]

AllThingsFalisha cause f#ck sleep that a why

[@kaeirose618]

AllThingsFalisha Right? Same.

[@jellamariz2921]

AllThingsFalisha internet: why are you going to bed? Just watch more of this amazing vidsss *whispers

[@iviano1149]

because shane

[@deltasweetashoney8880]

Whenever I go camping this story is always the one I remember. Gives me trouble sleeping especially when the cabin you’re in doesn’t even have lockable doors…

[@yangcortes3920]

I keep rewatching this episode. By far, this is truly the scariest one. The music and atmosphere is so unsettling.

[@loveandlucky3]

An 'unsolved' mystery apart from the fact that Martin Smartt almost definitely did it.

[@therealboomhauer69]

Plot twist the keddie cabin killer is watching and saw this comment and thinking damn she knows it was me.

[@therealboomhauer69]

@Luke Brown well then that means no one can tell.him to it then i c Mean how can u not hear two people getting murded in the same house as they were in.

[@tayloranderson7547]

An unsolved mystery apart from the fact that Martin smartt almost definitely did it.

[@maryaguilera2494]

@@tayloranderson7547 no

[@rhysfuchs9430]

@@tayloranderson7547 Who are you, you're so damn annoying.

[@Baconator-pf9oi]

These people have the best names, Jonny Sharp, Justin Smart and the greatest Bo Boubede.

[@rosemarybailey8364]

Baconator 7682 Bo Bo

[@BVani-ov9px]

😂😂

[@CRUSH40RULES]

@@Djd840 soapdick?! Oh my goodness what an unfortunate family name!

[@General12th]

@@CRUSH40RULES "Soptic". Pronounce it however you want.

[@mian8422]

J.J. Shank No,definetly Soapdick 😂

[@bradwillis7415]

"In April 2018, Gamberg stated that DNA evidence recovered from a piece of tape at the crime scene matched that of a known living suspect.[18]" its the most updated info

[@zydrat3.anat0my]

Oh my god I laughed so hard at the pillow talk moment where Shane is like "do you tell ghost stories after sex?" 😂