Top 25 Cigars of 2024

[@bransonjackson1609]

Great list. Its unique but actually makes sense! Congratulations!

[@JoseRamos-rb1cq]

Great List HalfWheel always in the cutting edge. Nice to see Viage making the list !

[@nydieselinfl]

Fantastic list! All are wonderful cigars. A bunch of friends of mine have a question about this list. 2024 was unofficially “the year of Kyle Gellis/ Warped”, and not one of his offerings were on here. Like the Sautner, Isla de Crocodrilo, and the 10th Anniversary La Colmena. Even some reviewers that I’ve watch and met in person have said that Kyle’s cigars this year were of ridiculous quality and value. I know everyone has a different palate, but at least one should have at least been here….

[@javiercavazos5449]

Spot on, Roma Craft makes some decent sticks, but Warped/Gellis Family really were the stand outs in 2024. Their cigars got no love on this list 🤷🏻‍♂️ 🤦🏻

[@mikefromtennessee5262]

And Gellis Family Reserve Piece Unique is a great cigar.

[@ManyMoonsLLC]

"This is why we practice." 😅

[@javiercavazos5449]

I didn’t get to watch you all live, but so far let’s just say I disagree with some of the cigars and some of the rankings. The good thing is cigars are subjective and individual palates vary, so your best cigar may turn out be my worst rated cigar. Such is life 🤷🏻‍♂️. Keep up the good work, thanks for always getting the latest in cigar news and information out for those of us in the cigar community.

[@johnadolph4407]

Love all the Roma Craft representation, but not one Black Label Trading Co stick in the top 25? 🤔

[@derekhernandez453]

I have a question about the top 25 Halfwheel. How do you decide which size cigar to review if the cigar is released in different vitola’s? Do you smoke the others and review the best one or do you pick randomly?

[@brookminx5837]

But where can I find them for sale? I can’t find them.

[@steveniceretros4359]

You guys are sleeping on the Patina Cigars…

[@ikemouser2580]

best value brands: plasencia, room101, cromagnon

[@Dash_Akol]

Definitely, this list and other lists are a form of advertising, so don’t take ‘em too seriously 😜

[@kevinneal8128]

Thank God MAGA season back and Charlie no longer looks like he is turning into Charlene and he has some life back into him!

[@ikemouser2580]

yup grateful for that

[@AutisticWimpyKid]

This is a very unimportant list. By pretty idiotic people... I just can't take them and their list seriously....

[@emmanuelfernandez9509]

You definitely don't know shit about cigars buddy. Keep it moving

[@AutisticWimpyKid]

Nice assumption there buddy. Keep being the stereotypical dumb American it suits you.

[@AutisticWimpyKid]

Nice assumption there buddy. Keep being the stereotypical dumb American it suits you.