Oda Revealed in Interview that there are TWO SHANKS!! One Piece 1134

[@goldmemberpb]

Stabs is probably the one who assassinated the previous Elbaf King. Loki saw him and mistook him for Shanks which would explain why he thinks Shanks is a coward.

[@whatthecluck6874]

This is actually the way this might play out.. That's so logical to think. Wow. I'm ready for this comment to be 100%.

[@mattb6616]

"mosamosa" (もさもさ or モサモサ) is a term for a very hairy person/thickly bearded person. "kou" (公) is most commonly used casually today as a suffix to denote familiarity with someone (or an animal. they werent calling hachi "hachikou" because he was Prince Hachi they were calling him hachikou because he was a good dog everyone loved). by calling the person on the other end of the cold-weather den den mushi "mosa-kou", Loki is giving them a nickname like Luffy would. Mosa is not the person's name, it is Loki calling them "Beardy" (or even "Shaggy") like Luffy would call them Beard-Guy.

[@mokaljordan]

Yup, so Mosa could be anyone, oda is making it impossible to guess since hes not giving us a silhouette nor any snail features, reminds me of when stella vegapunk called stussy for help to handle lucci and kaku

[@reimdl]

i just realized that in the silhouette of the person with the sword that we assume is a twin, this person is holding the sword with his left hand, same hand shanks is missing so it cant be shanks

[@odysseusdadon1234]

the viz translation is calling the guy loki is speaking too as shaggy

[@nunnayorz5836]

That kind of sums up why I'm not a fan of the officials. They tend to 'Americanize' things and sometimes nuance can be lost that way.. They probably don't like the idea of translation notes but I'd rather get it as close as possible to how the author intended.

[@loelldebach8450]

Bro i lost my shit when i found that out 😂 ruh roh shaggy, i rhink i just ate the hito hito no mi

[@mattb6616]

thats an accurate translation.

[@boghag]

So where's Scoobie then?

[@danielriver6206]

Like, zoinks, man!

[@LocalPlagueDoc]

I have a feeling that the Summoning circles can be "pre-placed" as a sort of Quick-Travel point, but need a nearby 'beacon' (being Saint Saturn back on Egghead) otherwise. It is also possible there's someone bonded with Imu already at the castle.

[@sya8109]

It’s quite poetic that this chapter is released around Christmas time. Harald reminds me of the line in of the famous Christmas carols, “Hark the herald the angels sing, journey to the new born king”

[@jasondice6332]

I haven't heard ohara or BDA about the "we are eternal" on Frankys shoulder, I haven't watched hidden islands video yet but your the first to point that quote out. That quote hit really hard for a 25 year going fan

[@marcomarin1196]

Never thought of it that way, Luffy and Shanks are technically adopted / step brothers too via Roger and the Sake Cup Ritual

[@TheUnkow]

So Roger's dream of having his child become the Pirate King will come true ... :)

[@bananacrabman6646]

I reckon shank's brother isn't a brother but rather a clone, from a story telling perspective the whole introduction of clones in this world hasn't reached a climax. Sure we got the seraphim but they haven't really progressed the story, rather they've acted more like fodder. If shank's brother or hell if shank's himself turned out to be a clone this whole time it would really justify the introduction of cloning into the world.

[@JomboyTonesAgain]

I hate the clone angle so much. Making mindless Kuma clones is kinda fine but it’s already way overstayed its welcome

[@AchyParts]

That meme of Luffy fighting 5 Kaidos may soon be a reality

[@jhonviel7381]

oda is planning on his own" 4th great ninja war", but with out resurrection!

[@reinselfxi4405]

Maybe Shanks just a clone of Garling, and that's why baby Shanks end up as one of the rewards in God Valley.

[@lapanthanim]

Possible, but personally I'd rather they all be naturally born people with separate histories from birth. *To be clear, I say this because any family drama they have I'd prefer to be among blood relatives who aren't also modified like Sanji's siblings.

[@stefenk7336]

Shanks brothers name will ne shaw. The next arc will be the shaw-shanks redemption arc. 😂

[@theone4821]

Just imagine 😂

[@justindosser8148]

Lilith repairs Kumas body. Bonney via command chip orders kuma to extract his memories from her and absorb them. Kuma does so and regains his memories and personality and keeps his pacifista upgrades

[@NoName......]

Wouldn't that make Bonney brain dead?

[@blazer1218]

​@NoName...... no Kuma took his memories out for Vegapunk and didn't turn into a vegetable so the paw paw fruit can definitely target certain memories/emotions or whatever

[@zero1188]

If you look closely at shanks side face you can see his scars. If you look closely at twin shanks you cannot

[@Stachelbeeerchen]

Let's go!!! Another upload from my most favorite OP KZbinr.

[@Yamael]

Pretty sure Saturn had to perform a summoning to get the other Elders to Egghead, so the question for me would be who of the many mysterious figures we've seen in Elbaph has summoned the two new arrivals. Pretty sure we have 3 antagonists here. Also, here's to hoping that Loki will turn out to be an ally and the whole "killing the King" thing will be a huge misunderstanding or done to actually save Elbaph.

[@hasnaindude]

saturn also teleported himself into egghead when he was close enough to the island so could just be that the gods knights just went close enough to teleport in

[@mokaljordan]

Loki could be talking to Colon's father, 2 chapters ago Colon's dad and Ripley was brought up by Colon's Mom and its only right that after we are got introduced to ripley that we will meet Colon's dad next This Shanks twin/imposter might be Imu's right hand man whom Imu sent personally/he volunteered to eliminate luffy as if Imu only sent 2 god knights then the god knights must be more threatening or powerful than the gorosei

[@lapanthanim]

I've thought for a long time (since fights tend to scale up and we're not even actively fighting the WG in a final war or whatever yet) that the Gorousei may have incredibly high defense but the heaviest _hitters_ (at the WG anyway) are probably God's Knights. It'll be scary if this guy who is almost certainly the next leader of the God's Knights has comparable haki to Emperor Shanks.

[@mokaljordan]

@lapanthanim yea it seems to me like oda was showcasing the WGs best defense feats on egghead, with the seraphims, sentomaru,kizaru to some extent(since he taught sentomaru) and then the gorosei regeneration ability, i think its only right that we see some offensive feats from the god/holy knights that will rival the Yonkous or a unleashed admiral, it might be controversial to powerscalers but its odas story he can do what he wants

[@seafreak2237]

Out of all the fake out take outs, vegapunk having a clone backup is so logical I genuinely don’t care. I frankly expected it

[@theanalyser8456]

0:03 Not the rat noises😂

[@steviekeanee]

People calling shanks a rat these last 6 years are on suicide watch after this chapter

[@BenD_Bass]

Im curious to see what evil thing Lilith is plotting. It's interesting that Shanks and evil twin can fast travel. Evil Shanks uses summoning circles and Shanks seems to sail on rainbows with the Sun Stone. I like the theory that Shanks travels using the under water currents, but he ran into Kaido and King on the way to Marineford and they were most likely flying

[@1TakoyakiStore]

I don't know why my brain went this direction, but when I heard the conversation between Loki and Mosa it sounded as if Mosa was Imu who had fallen for Loki. Especially when Mosa said they were terrified/scared of something recently, that made me feel like they were referring to Joyboy's haki terrifying them during the Egghead Incident. Of course this would present far more problems than it solves, but I still think it's worth mentioning in case a part of it in some small way ends up panning out. Of course it's more likely that Mosa is simply the female companion of imposter Shanks (Frank if you're going with what Liam decided on 😂) or that they're just a random female nobleman on Elbaph.

[@dfile7598]

My thoughts & opinions of the chapter: 1. When reading the way Luffy was talking to Saul, I now wonder if the Elbaph arc will mostly involve how Luffy will handle the other side of being an Emperor, which doesn't involve brute force as he displayed during Egghead. 2. Judging by the conversation that Loki had with this Mosa person, could it be possible that he/she is somehow involved in what Loki did to his father, and why he was imprisoned in the 1st place? 3. If the hooded man is somehow Shanks's "twin brother", then wouldn't this lead Luffy into learning a less pleasant side of his fellow Emperor?!

[@vinivicious2822]

I bet $100 that Mosa is Mother Carmel.

[@dominik8782]

Luffy meets NotShanks before Shanks.

[@sk8rboi66]

The will of Kuma, brain of Lilith, and the body of clone Vegapunk is something that I can see happening.

[@v-nus7718]

I believe the throne room being the place where the two spawned is important. Imu and the World Government have links to seats of power across the globe.

[@animefan77]

I was also guilty of this in my fanfics. I deeply apologize to Shanks

[@Ibrahim-Al-bazzaz]

I like the mice sounds at the end hahaha bless you

[@cantor4554]

I love that you call it a graduation.

[@NoName......]

Lowkey, the One Piece community has a reading compression problem. The Egghead Stella IS DEAD! This is the Stella from when he visited Elbaph 20 YEARS AGO! This is clearly not the same Stella. Also if Stella couldn't find a way to restore Kuma, why do people think 1/6th of him could? I think Kuma will be brought back but at a price. His memories

[@sirrogerjalbert]

Bonny has his memories and pudding has the ability to transfer them

[@the1344show]

I think that the shanks twin is actually the first ever clone in one piece world made by an unknown force, maybe by Imu themselves. But for one reason or the other they can't make another clones hence the seraphim project.

[@rubencp93]

They were the ones coercing (or manipulating) the king to stop waging war and start trading. Elbaf has always been an unachievable land for the WG because of their immense power, but if they stop focusing on being warriors and become scholars and traders instead, then invading them would become much easier. Them having a summoning circle in (what looks like) the throne room means that either Harald was working with them and willingly let them put the circle there, or there's a Kanjuro among the inhabitants of Elbaf. Another possibility is that they infiltrated the castle, killed the king, somehow replaced him with a puppet, and started 'weakening' the giants. That was the king Loki killed, not the actual Harald. Shanks being a coward could be because of this. He saw this Shanks kill his father.

[@xxSLAV33xx]

I got Jarul vibes from Mosa after reading the official chapter where Loki calls them Shaggy. After watching this though I have no idea lol.

[@tayman9011]

My first thought was that Loki was talking to Mars or Figarland with the former being more likely to me because he seems to talk about the terrifying haki from Joyboy

[@nunnayorz5836]

Hard to see Marcus talking appreciating anyone's kindness.

[@tayman9011]

@@nunnayorz5836 I understand your point but Loki is actively talking about killing the insects which the caller ignores and calls him kind for his counsel. Sounds right up the alley of such a higher up. So that 'kindness" he refers to is just Loki's want to protect a "friend"

[@tayman9011]

@@nunnayorz5836 Now I must add if you were one of the 6 most important people in the world and putin came up to you and said 'I've got your back" would you really be so inclined to deny his offer and spoil the relationship? Or would you be smart and feed into it to keep such an ally?

[@zero1188]

A better twist would be that is the real shanks.

[@JomboyTonesAgain]

Yep!

[@nunnayorz5836]

That would mess up Luffy if his mentor and idol who he based his whole pirate life on turned out to be a lie. It would be a betrayal to Roger and Rayleigh too. If it's a sibling of Shanks, that's fair because Oda foreshadowed it. No need for a cheap WWE heel turn.

[@mokaljordan]

Yup that would be a better twist at this point since the twin theory hit critical mass but man does oda has to explain alot for it to work

[@blahblahgdp]

Its crazy that the chapter isnt officially out and im being spoiled all over youtube. jesus christ

[@Pixachuu]

It's officially out since 11 hours ago. I'm agree that people on youtube spoil everything before the chapter is out, but Library of Ohara is one of the few which doesn't do it

[@xxxxxx89xxxx30]

Wild take: Mosa is the bandaged figure and Evil Shanks is there as the leader on a secret mission to release Loki and manipulate him into something.

[@jon3s3n94]

even if the twin theory turns out true shanks will always remain a rat in our hearts

[@gatofan5920]

Just finished reading the new One Piece chapter and Artur posted perfect timing 😼

[@New3DSLuigi364]

Well DUH. . . Of Course that "Shanks" Lookalike we saw talking to the gorosei wasn't ACTUALLY Shanks; He doesn't have the REAL Shanks' Actual Scar; There's a REASON We weren't shown the other side of his face; TO HIDE The Big Twist to save towards closer to the endgame!!

[@nightmarezero6888]

How can his brother be a rat when he was on the Celestial Dragon's side from the beginning ? This meme is so lame, I can't.

[@tayman9011]

TBH no matter how Oda plays this extra clone of Vegapunk it's still just that a clone. We still in a very real sense lost Stella however his mind and memories remain intact.

[@SirEvilestDeath]

You don’t become a step in a family if you are raised by a different family…

[@LagoonKnight]

I bet those swords Left and Right are meant to be used together. Each ending up in the twin's hands. There will be confusion at first but am sure Luffy will notice the differences, and be aware that it's not Shanks. Especially if the impostor attempts to attack Luffy and crew.

[@thyvevusion218]

I was actually waiting for this videos the second I saw someone else's chapter review

[@solflake]

Who’s the someone else

[@rooplostkosmos6276]

What’s the music that starts at 12:52 ?

[@nikpad5822]

Hmmm not a bad clash of ideals going on with elbaph would be cool if they find a middle ground. Instead of going the full pacifist route, liking the arc so far I can't wait to read more. Also always nice to see these breakdown videos especially on the Japanese language etc

[@xxtortellini1016]

7:11 quite the Viking design

[@TheChillKrill]

if your only source is Assassins Creed: Valhalla and the Vikings TV show.

[@xMrMayhemx]

i really hope this is a double fake out and he's actually evil. you can feel the menacing energy of his in every panel his part of when he's not fake grinning about something funny.

[@anebawkroinuj4017]

Yooo ive never been this early Lets gooo

[@a11irv33]

now wait to see if mihawk will beat the “painter” allegation 😂

[@kingfishproductions3476]

I hope Kabuki's health gets better 😥

[@duskstorm1]

Finally, the real Rato Rato no mii

[@O.Reagano]

“The Rat Descends” hahahah

[@Cloudhead0]

Maybe the shanks Loki knows is actually the evil twin, that's why he hates him????

[@MarceloB]

Luffy will meet shanks twin brother but will notice because his Haki is different

[@cnervip]

stabs is real! or hanks if you wish, and maybe the female is also sister of shanks, shankira

[@JomboyTonesAgain]

Did he……? Or are we still making massive jumps and guesses here? I really hope there’s no friggin evil twin or anything. That would be so lame.

[@gonzalomn4047]

It's not Shanks twin, but Shanks clone. Or maybe the mysterious knight is the OG and Shanks is the clone, but that's my bet.

[@GavinHintz]

Nothing has been definite, but yes I think the possibilities of the other person that looks like shanks could either be twin or clone.

[@tahiri3463]

Does no such thing click bait lets go

[@Santoryou90]

There is a chance of Shanks being Bi-polar

[@Eventzz0]

no he didnt, stop clickbaiting.

[@SeveralGhost]

Im weirdly sure that Eustass Kid is going to step out as the new Stella

[@M3plusYOU]

Nice to see you finally come to terms with what we all knew 6 years ago

[@micahlallison4691]

He's a yonko-za

[@Zoro.d.uchihaa]

We here

[@danielriver6206]

Shank's brother is also Bonney's biological father. That's NOT something that's been revealed, I just believe that's what's been hinted at. Until Oda confirms or disproves this theory, that will be what I'm going with.

[@pr6800]

How was this hinted at?

[@JomboyTonesAgain]

@@pr6800the existence of shank’s brother has barely even been hinted at. The fandom making these wishful jump to conclusions is bizarre

[@danielriver6206]

@@pr6800 It has been noted by people that when Oda drew the Worst Generation as the opposite gender, Bonney looked somewhat similar to Shanks. That made me wonder if the Celestial Dragon that took Ginny as his wife might have been potentially Shank's brother Also when he was meeting with the Gorosei and wanted to talk about a "specific pirate" people theorized that it might have been the most obvious choices, but I think this might have been Bonney, but that's just my speculation. Not a lot to go at, I know. I'm probably wrong, but again, this is what I'm going with unless Oda's reveal ends up completely disproving my theory.

[@jhonviel7381]

@@danielriver6206 wow thats a freaking stretch, but i hope you understand that bonneys story line finished at egghead, i dont think she will have a bigger role than any strawhat, her ability to stop the pacifista is her main mechanic now.

[@Sebbe1993]

Stabs is real!

[@yesmansam6686]

Rat rat no more

[@mattb6616]

its just regular shanks

[@e2st869]

Shanks and Stabs

[@thewillofdreams6921]

❤

[@KeisersozayHTTC]

Shanks cried Because Gold D Rodger told him I AM YOUR UNCLE ,, Rodgers sister was Shanks Mom , shanks has a twin Danks and a sister , His sister is Luffys mom with Dragon Shanks is Luffys uncle Luffy is related to Rodger , The sister wears a Bandage on her face because she smiles like Luffy .

[@AstorThalis]

So the theory is that Figarland Shanks got lost during the God Valley incident and either Imu or later Vegapunk created a copy/clone of Shanks to cover the loss. Whatever reason they might had, but that seems just the obvious thing because a twin sounds not very logical when Dragon/the RA knows about the God Knights they would have mentioned the powerhouse threat in form of a twin brother of an Emperor, right? tl:dr 2nd Shanks is a Seraphim

[@charles9618]

Im starting to not give a shit about one piece

[@TheChillKrill]

I'm here for one piece updates. Not made up facts about Norse, English and Viking people. Also 14:09 a pentacle isn't demonic. Google is free.

[@1sneeze]

Holy click bait

[@isaacblau_]

mosa - imu - mu did i took to many drugs or could there be something?

[@thanyou]

sh'aintks

[@animefan77]

I think that it’s likely that Dorry and Broggy are definitely not gonna be ok with the changes of Elbaf

[@zero1188]

Loki have king conquer

[@shahnulislam9897]

chu

[@gwen6622]

i kinda hate the evil twin theory. it does seem like its turning out to be true, but i wish it wasnt. i think its kind of lazy writing, idk, and also lazy character design. if shanks has a twin, yes his face would look identical to shanks's, just without the scar. but why would his hair look the same? why would he have a similar sword? surely even though they were born identical, they may have never even met each other. or at the very least, their childhoods would have been SUPER different, and it would be very weird for celestial dragon shanks to style his hair the same way that pirate shanks does. but, if it's what oda is deciding to go with, then there's really nothing i can do but roll my eyes at it, like i do with all the death fakeouts that i wish didnt happen

[@HeraclesN-fp1bw]

I predicted Shank’s twin coming to Elbaph & maybe going to be the major antagonist of the arc where they are here to eliminate everyone that escaped from the Gorosei like Luffy & Bonney, but I did have an interesting thought but what if Shank’s twin is maybe even Bonney’s biological father 😨

[@jhonviel7381]

its not your theory, obviously you heard/read it from some one piece tuber or some one piece forum. that being said its a rather baseless theory.

[@HeraclesN-fp1bw]

@ No I came up with my self in fact I thought if this at the near end of Egghead that Shank’s evil twin would be the major antagonist of Elaph

[@Evil__Morty]

Mosa = Imu

[@init_yeah]

Do acollab with man on the internet😊

[@I.Bslayin]

First

[@Ro321chile]

Please Oda, i beg you, don't be an evil Shanks twin plot twist. It literally would come out of nowhere

[@marcomarin1196]

It's not out of nowhere, It's been set up with him appearing in the Goresei's room and Shanks hinted backstory as a Figarland

[@Cryosxify]

I mean it could be built around cloning like with stussy. garling loses first son, can't have that, replaced with clone

[@Yamael]

@@Cryosxify With how Celestial Dragons and nobles in the One Piece world work, I wouldn't even be surprised if this "brother" was the one that put Shanks in the chest that Roger stole to get rid of him and not have to share the eventual inheritance or something like that.

[@Idonthavealias]

@@Yamael or after loosing his child he produces a second child which looks like shanks

[@NoName......]

What if the Shanks we know is the clone and this is the REAL Shanks?