We RANKED Rocks & Roger At 100 On Our Top 30 Tier List ALL-TIME!

For episode 32, we decided to take advantage of Break Week by creating a top 20-30 list. For this list, we went with the number system 100-1. 100 being the absolute BEST and 1 being the absolute WORST.
We failed miserably at completing it because we spent almost over 25 minutes deciding who should be number 1. We ultimately came to a decision. Enjoy the debate! Let us know your thoughts.
Leave a LIKE, COMMENT your thoughts, SHARE with a friend, and don't forget to SUBSCRIBE to the channel for more content. Much love and happiness to all of you!
Support Us: mee6.gg/m/thatonepiecetalk
Listen On Spotify: open.spotify.com/show/7BpFZtr...
Discord: / discord
Our Second Channel (Clips Only): rb.gy/y4e1ze
Twitch: / thatonepiecetalk
TikTok: / thatonepiecetalk
Instagram: / thatonepiecetalk
Patreon: / thatonepiecetalk
Video Production: KZbin | / braverystudios
Instagram | / braverystudios

[@empiricalpurity]

I disagree with Seb’s comment that the in-fighting on Rocks crew shows that Rocks is unable to control them. It could very well be the opposite and Rocks actively encouraged the in-fighting for them to demonstrate their strength.

[@BigEL23]

Larrys head cannon is out of control when it comes to Rocks

[@onionbby5017]

Y'all were getting into it on the live I was lit

[@billzbez6019]

And Lawrence just change my mind with the black beard analogy lmao

[@billzbez6019]

But whats to say Roger wouldn't have white beard big ,mom and kaido on a submissive attitude either? We have to look at it both ways I believe rocks and Roger are equals in strength

[@empiricalpurity]

I disagree. I think their recruitment styles, choice in crewmates, and interpersonal relationship within the crew are completely different. I think Roger is like Luffy in that he earns his crew’s trust, loyalty, and devotion and the crew is like a family that looks after one another. Rocks is like Blackbeard where your position on the crew is determined by your strength and you are constantly striving to usurp the position from the people above you while defending your position from the below you.

[@billzbez6019]

@@empiricalpurity yeah but my point would be hypothetical, if Roger we're to join that crew in replacement of rocks would he rain as caption ? We're speaking of great wills and strength here, not based on what they would have done lol

[@empiricalpurity]

@@billzbez6019 I understand what you’re implying but I think your oversimplifying wills. The type of will matters in what a person is capable of doing. I think we can all agree that Luffy’s will is very impressive, right? I personally don’t think Luffy is capable of dominating anyone because that’s not his nature. Creating a hypothetical situation like that and forcing Roger into Rock’s position is, in a way, a betrayal of Roger’s character. I think if Roger woke up and found himself on Rock’s crew (with it without Rocks) he would try to find a way to get out of there as soon as possible. I wonder if this makes it clearer. Blackbeard has a very strong crew. Do you think Luffy can dominate all those people and force them to follow him just like Blackbeard did?

[@billzbez6019]

@@empiricalpurity so then the conversation wasn't about who was stronger then who ? Because I was under the assumption that this conversation was strength based

[@empiricalpurity]

@@billzbez6019 Luffy v Doffy = The will to protect v the will to dominate. Agreed? Luffy’s will to protect > Doffy’s will to dominate. The person’s values determine what their will can achieve. It doesn’t matter how strong a person’s will is if the objective goes against their values.

[@gottagofast1548]

Okay so i got a theory, the rocks pirates on god valley betrayed rocks, big mom and kaido talk about rocks as a like problem and they got rid of him, every rock pirate survived except the captain? No one of them got any scars besides white beard on his chest, also the gorosei was on the island not that it means a lot but there was like, holy knights plus marines plus roger qnd his crew plus garp vs rocks and his pirates dude, the fact that they teemed up speaks for itself

[@11quinlin]

Its ya new fan yonko

[@ThatOnePieceTalk]

Nothing but positive energy from us to you. Thank you for watching! 💪🏼

[@legitdee2113]

Don’t worry about the views this is great content !

[@ThatOnePieceTalk]

Thank you and I assure we aren’t. We happy with what we got and are content. Thank you for saying such a great thing about us. 💪🏼

[@empiricalpurity]

They’re getting more views. In the past each episode was getting 100-200 views. Episode 31 has more than 600 views as of right now. They will definitely continue to grow as a channel. The best thing is they’re genuinely passionate about One Piece and doing this out of love. We just need the community to be more active in the comments section.

[@jackingram9599]

i think rocks and roger would be an insane 1v1 but i can’t scale 1 above the other, based off of feats, statements, and reputation Roger is the strongest . Rocks only has reputation and some statements like he was Rogers greatest advisory, idk i can’t believe that if Rocks was THAT much stronger than someone like Roger, Whitebeard, Garp he’d die . cause there’s no way anyone on rocks crew is getting jumped UNLESS their were 2 or 3 heavy hitters w Roger, Garp, Reyligh

[@HubrisPhilantrope]

"It just makes sense that Roger" the Goal of Luffy, and evry pirates in the world sure is second😂😂! Luffy always won 1v1 but ye his ideal, the man who had the same dream he has, the man who is as eager as ace but with the power to always back it up, this guy sure😂 fought his biggest fight 2v1 and was weaker than his biggest rival. Plus Kaido and Big Mom said Roger was something else not Xebec.

[@user-gq2jy3vt4r]

What if it was the Marines that asked Roger for help?

[@ThatOnePieceTalk]

Also, possible. That’s the thing. Nothing about God Valley really makes sense.

[@empiricalpurity]

@@ThatOnePieceTalk I’ve always just interrupted it as two opposing forces recognising a greater threat to both sides and putting their pride aside to work together to achieve a common goal. Imagine what would happen if Whitebeard and Shanks agreed that Blackbeard represented a threat to both their futures and decided to team up against him and worked together to save Ace at Marineford.

[@DJLEO23100]

actually garp said that roger pirates helped the marines vs rocks pirates

[@KingsJustice1]

@@DJLEO23100 Either way they needed to team up which is key. Neither of them by themselves could be Rocks so I don't understand how one can say Roger > Rocks just because Rocks lost. Its completely ignoring the handicap.

[@sethsherr2793]

How’s Shiki gonna take out Roger make him Float or throw big rocks at him no what’s to say Roger won’t just use conquers rokoshiki

[@sethsherr2793]

Imu is the strongest done

[@user-nh3ox9vw7m]

Oden was a conqueror

[@everettstang2662]

I like to think rocks is equivalent to buggy where he failed upwards and ended up with these powerful pirates underneath him from a happy accident. And the crew convinced themselves he was so powerful none of them would challenge him

[@pebalii6184]

Lets be REAL! HOME BOY IS SPEAKIN FACTTTSS

[@salaarsheikh5089]

I disagree with guy saying rock was number one, even his argument is so stupid and incoherent, you're saying we can assume that roger had help and the in fighting, but says WE DONT KNOW THAT when they state Factually correct info. Roger doesn't have a lost uptill now in the story. Rocks lost, roger i am assuming roger kicka everyone Solo😂😂, garp was having a steak.

[@Yallaredumb]

Rocks D. Xebec is on fraud watch. Y’all were hating on people for attaching themselves to characters who have minimal screen time. Yet Rocks has had basically zero screen time, and Larry has the audacity to put him above Roger THE KING OF THE PIRATES??? The panel where they clash and Roger wins the 1v1 is going to taste so sweet. One Love 🏴‍☠️