What's China's 're-education camp' in Xinjiang really about?

[@JC-gt5vs]

I showed this video to a group of friends, but they still don't believe it and called it "biased by the Chinese government". But yeah, isn't Western media also biased or even more?

[@epiclamp44]

That doesnt negate the fact that the state controlled medial is bias to the state.

[@JC-gt5vs]

@@epiclamp44 I know, but there's actually no media that is completely unbiased in this world, not even CNN.

[@ohword9541]

@@JC-gt5vs Depending on the situation a third party could definitely be unbiased in this situation if they aren't being bought out by one is these countries.

[@彩虹小哥]

谢谢你的分享，但是其实中国人不太担心，我们只是勤奋的工作，直到我们的成绩无法被否认，没错，我们的目标是2030年之前GDP No1

[@carljohnson2194]

Both are

[@alecwk]

China viewed 2007 riot in Xinjiang caused by Islamic radicalization, which in turn linked to the social-economic issues faced by the people there. To overcome that, they brought in more development to the province and people were sent for re-education to better equip themselves. Today Xinjiang's GDP has grown from US$ 50 billion in 2007 to almost US$ 200 billion in 2019. That is the size of Greece and New Zealand GDPs. Also, its GDP is higher than 22 of the American states. The living standard of the Uighur are better off than many Americans.

[@g33k_Tech]

thank you

[@juantistic3855]

what liberal media won't tell us

[@gheese]

wumao moment indeed it is

[@CetribeaBurundibwiza-tz5le]

How are you expecting the USA and EUROPE to accept that the attacks are terrorists attack when they*USA and EUROPE are the ones who are Organizing these terrorists groups???. The only thing they were unhappy of, was because Chinese leaders are so smart and they acted quickly,

[@MidnightBloomDev]

Any source? Nice conspiracy...

[@candicem9344]

@MD Imran Arafin totally agree America is so evil it makes me sick to my stomach

[@RapeableDonkey]

@MD Imran Arafin Yeah the US is shit, alright, but still this is only a bloated, far-fetched, unfounded speculation regarding the given case.

[@linhaohoward]

I heard of Americans doing that. But I don’t think Europe is involved. Any proof?

[@dariuschong4574]

@@MidnightBloomDev Please enlighten me with some "leaked documents" or "leaked footage" of Uighur Muslims "organ harvesting activities" in Xianjiang. Nice conspiracy.

[@jackthompson3267]

' cgtn is funded in part or as whole by the Chinese government

[@ElZilchoYo]

And the media outlets reporting a genocide are CIA funded

[@蔡英文脸上张蛆]

I hope this video doesn't get deleted

[@ollie9849]

s Kumar I agree with what you said that the ccp should take less control of the media, but your assumption that China definitely does not have a terrorism issue is like me saying that India does not have a single rape case, ignorant and ridiculous. You guys with “free media” always thinks you know better, yet too lazy to just google some facts.

[@蔡英文脸上张蛆]

@s Kumar Can you find any errors in the CGTN program? You can use UN data. After watching too much fake news, you've learned to blame others without any evidence. You are a good student to them. Your brain can ignore all the evidence and make a conclusion. I don't want the CCP to open up so much fake news. There will be a lot of people like you who will lose their ability to think🙂

[@rocha115]

@s Kumar Attacking others with lies only makes you look ignorant. You have every right to believe what you believe, but try to find facts to back you up.

[@anonymintheworld9781]

@s Kumar Are you kidding? It is the United States that finances terrorism. Is China closely related to the United States?

[@番茄鸡蛋-q4d]

@s Kumar Do you know the difference between finish the problem and finish the people with problem

[@TheOraReport]

Very much appreciate another insight from that peddled in Western media

[@broerymarantika853]

Hello from Malaysia 🇲🇾, My Sister visited Xinjiang in 2019 before the pandemic, and I asked her if the Mosques are easily accessible? Any signs the muslims are being forced to denounce their religions and traditions. She said No, she had not seen any Clear Discriminations. She, as Tourists are free to enter some mosques, not all. She did see people entering and coming out from mosques.

[@Hoppensagen]

If she is entering a free to enter area obviously she won't see anything. Any reporter that has tried to actually visit the camps is denied so your story literally tells nothing.

[@claudec1843]

@@Hoppensagen how do you know who is lying and who is talking about truth?

[@claudec1843]

@@Hoppensagen don't tell me you really believe those reporters and US government.........

[@AndalusianPrince]

not what 99% of what ACTUAL tourists say, you lying bastard

[@lalala8462]

@@AndalusianPrince In fact, most tourists who have actually BEEN THERE know that is this true

[@duck1ente]

Look at all this happy Uighur! China and the CPP is the most benevolent regime, I trust CGTN on bringing real and unbiased news! We trust the People's Republic of China to keep the eternal happiness of Uighurs and even Tibetans!

[@JonathanExley]

The sarcasm is on point! Teach me, o' great one! 😄👌

[@cuteandfunnyearthlings2863]

Just look at the list, you see who are friends of china and who are not.

[@于于海兴]

很多国家必须跟着美国走，美国让他们干什么就干什么

[@vinnyboy1976]

Japan side with USA. None of this country want Muslims to live in there not just refugees

[@HenryHoe]

Not even one Muslim country criticised china

[@hexkobold9814]

@@于于海兴 Have fun being friends with Myanmar and North Korea. LOL

[@michaelz5497]

@@hexkobold9814 so whts wrong with being friends with them? Just becuz they didnt fit the western narrative should not justify tht they are not worthy any friendship. If anything, western countries, with their long colonial history and blood drenched modernization, process, should not be trusted

[@fanchuendennistsang4569]

The reasons for violent and terrorist activities in Xinjiang a couple of years ago are very complicated. Basically, it is the penetration of foreign extremist religious power. In addition, many Uyghurs cannot speak Mandarin and lack modern working skills. They are generally engaged in herding or agriculture. Uyghurs also want to live a good life, but when they come to the city they find that there are very few employment opportunities for them. The government has established an education and training center to train them garment sewing skills, electronic parts fabrication and textile production skills, as well as trade training, etc., with the aim to increase their employment opportunities and eradicate the soil of violence and terror. Xinjiang cotton is picked by workers hired from the densely populated provinces because no Uyghurs prefer cotton picking than herding. And now it's all machine-picked, and forced labor is nonsense. The purpose of the US banning Xinjiang products is to make Uyghurs unemployed and make Xinjiang chaotic.

[@vivelarevolution9362]

then why does these so called training centers have watchtowers and heavily armed police if it's for everyone's good. And don't try to deny it because even China can't hide satellite data.

[@domsjuk]

Isn't it telling that despite its title this video actually gives no real information about the camps, and what they're about practically? Instead it presents all kinds of references to other events, topics, mosque statistics etc. (what's the source?), and just generally paints a picture that it's all fine, nothing to worry or ask questions about. But that wasn't the question, was it? People believe, what they want to, on every side.

[@matchlatte1233]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/pHykdIqif56Njrs

[@domsjuk]

@@matchlatte1233 Right, pretty much like this video having nothing to do with my comment...

[@matchlatte1233]

the same goes with the number in the west, what source are they refering

[@domsjuk]

@@matchlatte1233 Right. They note the other sources on top of the diagram, I only noticed that later. The French number is accurate according to this site www.trouvetamosquee.fr/category/mosquees-de-france/ don't know about the others, as neither really helps to find their possible references on the fly, but seems about reasonable.

[@lugebeatzz8747]

It's none of your business, every country is free, why are people trying to understand problems that are not theirs, don't play the sympathetic card when you have homeless people in your country start with that!!! Let Chinese people deal with their stuff....

[@AkamiChannel]

I see. So all those uighurs dancing in the bbc film were really just dancing because they wanted to dance. My eyes must be telling me lies.

[@phoebexie1891]

In fact, these performers are in the tourism industry，just like the matador you saw on your trip to Spain.

[@futureisredcomrades1902]

Yup. People in China dance all the time lol.

[@eyob8969]

Don’t know if your being sarcastic, but when did dancing become a bad thing? Ever walked down any s.American capital? 💃 🕺 it’s not rare to spot people dancing tanga in the street, same goes for Any ethnic diverse area with rich heritage, they like to show themselves off to tourists and camera, to invite them to come over and see their culture and spend money. You as an American probably have never left the comfort of your backyard but the world is a big place, and not everything is rehearsed Hollywood performance as shocking as it may be for you, there are people out there in the world with a different culture and norms

[@petertung1774]

I have been in Canada for 50 years. Just came back from a 18 days tour in Xinjiang. Here is my experience during the tour: I talked to couple of Taxi drivers. They said their business is getting better last 3 years because there is night market now. 3 years ago, no one walk on the street in the night because some bad guys fighting on the street with knife all the time. Now, policemen took these bad guys to re-educate them. Let them learn some skill, such as reading, writing, driving, plumping, electrician etc. So, after they get out of the education program, they can find a job. If they have job, have money, no one want to be a bad guy. This is a clime prevention program. I talked to a 24 years old waitress, she and her husband both are high school graduates. Last couple of years, they bought a house and now they are going to buy a car. I traveled around the world, I feel Xinjiang is the safest place in the world now. I would suggest you to visit Xinjiang to see it with your own eye. Don’t rely on news media.

[@CraigWinstanley1]

peter tung - excellent points ! I never trust a media source that does not actually visit the place that they are reporting on. Western media is a lying disgrace.

[@paulrenny5790]

I don't trust a single thing you wrote. I haven't been to Xinjiang but I've spent time in Tibet. It was a police state! And I gather Xinjiang is worse.

[@petertung1774]

@@paulrenny5790 I am a Canadian, no point to argue with you. Go have a look yourself. To see if the people in xinjian is happier or not.

[@chaofoodies]

paul renny What is a police state? It is common to see lots of police in China, few reasons: 1. Chinese population is high, so the police population is high too. 2. Police helps on all sorts of things, not only crimes, their daily job is like community service, e.g. a grandma locked out of door, police go check and help her fix the lock. 3. Unlike US, Chinese don’t fear police, they are nice to people, we always call them uncle police (even you are older than them lol)

[@chaofoodies]

MX3KY people have the freedom to choose where to live, and to become a second hometown. You don’t have to limit yourself to one system, you can watch and listen to everything and learn the best from all sides.

[@jwzjwz2003cn]

Let's be fair, majority of the students in those re-education are forced to be there to learn some skills even though they might get treated pretty well with great facilities. It is tough for anyone involved in this process. However if China don't do this, there will be a lot more bloodshed in the region with radical Islamic related terrorism. If people think it's better for radicalized Uyghur to run the region themselves, then just take Afghanistan as a reference.

[@grunt117]

Aye what's up Wu Mao, is it worth selling out to an authoritarian regime that suppresses human rights?

[@miquelmarti6537]

well, you invaded their country. They just don't want to be reeducated by the opressor that took its land. And you opress a lot, don't you?

[@SHADOW-nj3kv]

the people who have lived through those camps would disagree they are not treated well in any way shape or form it is genocide the only thing China is stopping is a culture all human should have the right to express

[@a.j.ltargaryen5995]

Throwing the extremists into re-education camp and feeding them vs Killing them. China choose the first. Note that those extremists were almost on the way to bomb a gods-know-which train station already.

[@zxz7338]

@@miquelmarti6537 fucking interesting, you implied xinjiang which is conquered by chinese ancesters at the exact time amercians conquered texas is not a chinese country .Great, why not you support those texas-independent ppl and see what you will get

[@jjc4232]

CGTN I LOVE YOU ❤️❤️❤️🔵🔵🔵🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳. Thanks for clearing the name of China!! Need more of these reports of the truth..

[@paulrenny5790]

This doesn't clear the name of China at all. This channel is bullsh*t. It's Chinese owned, and therefore CCP contolled. No Chinese media agency is critical of the CCP.

[@jasonz7594]

@@paulrenny5790 the truth makes you paranoid, make it dirty with ideology attacking, what a shameless Taiwan troll

[@jamilelandaloussi7126]

@paul renny, so? All western medias are oligarch owned & keep vomiting oligarch dogmas & mantras, while the truth is out there for all to see. The need to accomodate a dire reality to an optimistic narrative isn't as desperate for chinese medias (CCP controlled or not) in the 2010's, as it is indeed in a now bankrupt West going through a slow but durable decline, & yet currently at a crossroads where a brutal collapse could still be averted (let alone outright war), depending on how it manages the passing of the torch to the new world leading nation(s). Just sit back, relax & enjoy the show. Life goes on... 😴😇🤭

[@Mr.Jasaw13]

shows 3 random ppl who supposedly benefited from these camps (they don't say it themselves but the reported sure does 🤣 )... she had to abandon her identity and religion to become a cashier, bravo 👏 (nobody is arguing against china giving material benefit as long as you worship their government 😊 which means be a blindly obedient to some fat old farts at the top of this political hierarchy even in spiritual and private matters ) - then he shows some random "imam" (probably the only one who was afraid of chinese government and said what they wanted him to say.. and to be honest upon seeing that man I felt he was screaming for help inside 😢 ) and asks him some vague question about mosques being demolished and he gives an equally vague answer (and what now, an imam in one mosque has access to all of the information that china controls -consorships and filtering is a comon practice in this "liberated" country 🤦‍♂️ ..) And then he starts obfuscating the matter with a chat about a single case of terrorism which he uses to justify the lockdown of 2 million people ... 🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️ then he shows signatures of some economically blackmailed "muslim" countries or with a corrupt governments (popular for freedoms ? lol nahh I didn't think so ) signing in some papers for China ... are you serious ? the thing is that mistreatment of muslims in china is reported by every mainstream and independent media and non-media source ..besides china surprise, surprise... this is absolutely undeniable. It's actually so undeniable that you had to come up with this weak ass propaganda ... like it's really weak and only retarded people can fall for it ...✨

[@jjc4232]

@@Mr.Jasaw13 you wrote to much. Ain't no one is going to read that essay of hate lol

[@BillahaMdMasum]

I would like to believe your saying is true, Muslim population would prefer China to be their friend.

[@prometheanevent]

A reeducation center under a one party state that surveils its citizens, continues to try to wipe out Tibetan culture, and in modern history, caused millions to die from famine and persecution… What could go wrong - that a little “reeducation” can repair.

[@masterkoi29]

To all who doesn't know. Study the Tang dynasty era where xinjiang was the place of the Tang emperors relatives who married Muslims from the family of An Lushan. During the Han dynasty,Uyghurs doesn't still come to xinjiang as they are from other country. It was during the Turks invasions of the east that Uyghurs come to some parts of central china. During the Han dynasty, no single country has an attempt to invade china as their civilization will vanished if they attacked the powerful Han dynasty.

[@g33k_Tech]

history i like it

[@mothercoconuts3923]

You got a couple things wrong pal. Turks originated the east, not west. The original Uyghurs formed their Khaganate in what is today Xinjiang during the Tang dynasty and help the Tang crush the Turks. The current "Uyghurs" are by and large unrelated to those Uyghurs - it was but an ethnonym given by Soviet ethnologists, after the Uyghurs who occupied that geographical area centuries ago, to the Turks who migrated into Xinjiang after Emperor Qianlong massacred the Dzungars who lived in Xinjiang.

[@Hasan-qn4fh]

@@g33k_Tech except that the altai mountains in sinkiang is the ORIGINAL HOMELAND OF THE TURKIC PEOPLE there were nnever no sinites there till thousands of years later

[@Tsioboy]

If you don't mind me asking, if there's no religious oppression happening in Xinjiang why are the women on the video don't wear their hijab anymore? EDIT: If the Mosques are demolished due to disrepair, why some are changed into public restrooms?

[@dcli4584]

。。。i want to tell you something that although xinjiang is a Uygurs Autonomous Region，but actually most of people in xinjiang cities are Han. Based on the data in 2010, in Xinjiang's cities, %70 people are Han nationality people but not Uygurs

[@Tsioboy]

@Airgeddon1773 If they moved it, why are there no videos of newly constructed mosques tho?

[@strawberryswan555]

there is religious oppression, i’m an uyghur girl living in australia and my time there felt like i was in a room with cameras in every corner

[@Tsioboy]

@@strawberryswan555 Oh my…Chinese Government sure aren’t stopping anytime soon…

[@heian17]

​@@strawberryswan555 I think you don't wear hijab either.

[@menonalevi6984]

If Japan is so worried about ''concentration camps'' why they don't admit their war crimes first?

[@alxndrkorkmaz4711]

Can you give us a tour to the camp?

[@user-tt3xu2hf5b]

Bruh u think a state run media would show the insides of the camps. Pfft. It’s all smoke and mirrors when it comes to human rights abuses

[@SHADOW-nj3kv]

@@brandonsmith0369 preach brother these Communist Party stans have no idea that they're being played like a fiddle by a government who would happily let them die

[@xweifu4117]

It is the money, not any other things, actully bolcked your tour ! You should work hard and make money for xinjiang tour.

[@SHADOW-nj3kv]

@@xweifu4117 what

[@norincofan1949]

@@SHADOW-nj3kv you can easily book a trip to xinjiang, it is among the most popular tourism destinations for Chinese people

[@imrankabir6116]

1:33 I actually googled that, I was surprised to find that it's true.

[@emaadkhan3031]

@Xiao Long No, CGTN is biased towards China. Not that I disagree with the video. The difference is that you can be biased and still tell the truth

[@kannan-sar1758]

@Xiao Long everybody is biased, nobody is saint

[@mariaz6359]

@@Azrael1454 "Google" doesn't say anything dude, the graphs ON Google say something. And graphs can't be fake my friend, they're based on real data. May it be an American graph, Chinese graph or German graph. Please grow up.

[@mariaz6359]

@@Azrael1454 not being an apologist for anything, just telling you how graphs work.

[@mariaz6359]

@@Azrael1454 Once again, not Google my friend. Google is a means of gathering information, it doesn't create the actual information. And anyway, Google is an American company, not sponsored by the CCP, don't worry :). What other source of information do you suggest? Bing? Is that more reliable lmao. I see a graph, I see classified information, and I make my conclusions.

[@hongweiyu2352]

I saw this guy debating about South China Sea with US media a few years ago, he is very detail and facts oriented I that debate. Great talent he got.

[@hongweiyu2352]

@@huggybear441 try search"CCTV reporters debate on South China sea" on KZbin.

[@yjj7344]

Yeah its a bit inconvenient that the World court ruled that China was acting illegally.

[@SHADOW-nj3kv]

the South China Sea does not belong exclusively to China and Taiwan is an independent country

[@ixanaths]

@@SHADOW-nj3kv keep throwing shiiit on the ceiling and some are bound to stick, that s the tactics US and allies have been using for years to destroy China.

[@robihamdani5203]

If south china sea belong to china because culture in the past so thoose mongols can claim back entire land of asia 😂😂

[@pboi]

What in the Chinese propaganda is this

[@Doggiedodo]

China is changing better and better. Thank you all of the western world who are criticizing us.

[@lucianocartino5312]

You nerd ti be' true

[@Kulayyu]

Meanwhile at Guantanamo University...... Professor Pindo: this one looks like another Posthumous Graduate. Assistant: he failed the torture test, no retakes on that one.

[@jeffrey7737]

Meanwhile in XJ Univ ..... Today you will learn how to make a bed....for 3 months

[@wolfgang7812]

It's called shifiting focus away from one's own actions and behaviour onto someone else. It can also be called double standards. is that not what Narcs do??? Also China has major projects going on in Africa right now.

[@JonathanExley]

Aaah yes, deflection. The weakest response to an argument. So, so weak.

[@FortniteMoments8]

Hahahahahaha 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@bockscar1]

CGTN is a Chinese communist party state owned media who spread communist propaganda ! It was exposed when they refused to register as a foreign agent and tried to infiltrate in the U.S as one of the U.S news media ! After U.S justice department paid them a visit ! The CGTN founder " Ma jing " and over a dozen of its propagandist flee Washington DC in U.S after it was exposed ! Hmm too many CCP paid " "50 CENT army " TROLLs in these comments section .

[@jjc4232]

PLEASE SET ONE UP IN HONG KONG!! I M HONG KONG CHINESE 🇨🇳

[@jjc4232]

@Sharon Xavier the F you are talking about Biaa?

[@jjc4232]

@Sharon Xavier you call this shit democracy? Here is a video of rioters in hong kong beating up a women who disagreed with them blocking the roads. kzbin.info/www/bejne/f4DKfJmlfcmbh6M Well... I m not surprised that freedom, liberation and democracy stands for that shit!! Just look at the middle East!!

[@nikkie1724]

@@jjc4232 Are you not able to express yourself without the need for swearing. Very ignorant.

[@fluxmuldar]

If there's a place that needs a CGTN outlet, it's Hong Kong. Incredible amount of fake news coming out of that city nowadays.

[@pinkbubble79]

@Sharon Xavier go stay in China for at least 3 month before comment!

[@JDT01976]

Sure CGTN, we were all born yesterday.

[@nazhaassadi1361]

Not y’all deleting my comments. No wonder all the comments are so supportive

[@Robuxias]

This is not true, I have one friend who escaped from the Xijiang and she said that their people get raped, tortured, and killed by Local Chinese polices and guards. Also, according to her story, these are true and prevailed in this province. Which is very tragic :

[@oo-tb1bm]

我觉得您太高看汉族人了。作为一名汉族人，我不得不承认我们没有任何勇气杀人，就算被人拿枪指着我们也只敢讲讲道理的。过去数千年汉族人都是软弱害羞的。难以置信吧？但这是真的。在中国，数千年来都是少数民族欺负汉族人的。我们只是以理服人。难以置信啊，但事情就是这样哈哈哈。我自己也经历过好几次被新疆人欺负的情况。有一次我们一群朋友半夜听完演唱会去一家新疆面馆吃饭，上菜太慢，我一个朋友抱怨了一下，结果新疆人老板提着刀就出来了，把我们一群人吓得够呛，连忙道歉，乖乖吃完饭付完钱就走了。完了我们还觉得这几个新疆人很勇敢，从内心里佩服人家。艾玛。我们十几个年轻人被三个新疆人提刀威胁吓傻了。厉害吧？所以如果有人告诉你汉族人把新疆人杀了，不要信，汉族人压根儿没那本事。汉族人基因里就胆小怕事，不敢杀人的。

[@Robuxias]

@@oo-tb1bm Sorry I don't understand Chinese, and I have one question; how tf are u using KZbin WHEN CCP OFFICIALLY BLOCKED THE WESTERN MEDIAS? ARE U A MEMBER OF 50 CENTS PARTY OR SMTHN???

[@Robuxias]

@@oo-tb1bm Okay, u said that Han nations got invaded by other nations frequently back in old days, then what about Korea, Vietnam, Thailand, and other Southern&Northern Asia countries? you guys attempted to invade them (tho it became futile) and tried to made them as ur colony.

[@billyng8482]

@@oo-tb1bm 哈哈，让我在这个英文字的留言回了华文字。

[@grunt117]

@@Robuxias Chris Cappel from China Uncensored warned us about these dudes

[@trolllovindaddy]

I saw the vox report and they tear your report piece by piece

[@HomoCyborgZombie]

Can you link it? I'm trying to assemble a master post whenever I come across the Uyghur genocide deniers.

[@quintenschuppert7135]

Yes, please link it. Also, @oliasis please link the masterpost, looking forward to it!

[@mycodingchannel9690]

Ok wion subscriber

[@hke4369]

This is a joke right?

[@morpheyegeo8657]

Who is this aimed for? No American would believe this

[@christianteeples5650]

Spelling Bee Pronouncer: "Please spell 'propaganda' ." Me: "C-G-T-N"

[@juantistic3855]

cope lib

[@ChirpywaraTofu86]

nahh its the US creating propaganda here.

[@yeyeman6569]

propaganda according to people like you : "something that I don't want to be true and even if that thing is proven true I still deny it"

[@Andesu]

I mean as much as all media is biased, this video report is clearly a great example of propaganda. They interviewed token Uyghur individuals who are Mandarin-speaking and already established, but left out the ones about to go into these "vocational" centers.

[@OfficialCheesecake]

probably because they're required to learn mandarin to get better paying jobs in the future. han chinese in tibet are required to learn tibetan.

[@luckybolt2232]

the last one doesn't sound like mandarin to me

[@PChan-yt4uf]

Haha, some people comment when they can't even recognise mandarin. The gentleman explaining why mosques was pulled down was not speaking mandarin. Mandarin is the national language of China. All children in schools are required to learn it. Every citizen has to learn their own country's national language. What is so strange about an Chinese uygher speaking mandarin? I am Chinese and I was required to learn my own national language. Mandarin was not even taught to ethnic Chinese during my schooling days. So I am a Chinese, a minority race in my country and I can only do basic Mandarin.

[@galaxyguardian5883]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/pHmYh4eqmdaFjsU

[@shilanaisilang]

How many native Americans have ever got education? What's the point of "NO CHILD LEFT BEHILD ACT" for native American kids?

[@brandon9327]

Peace to your lady.

[@MrPurge11]

Yes, you go on and on and on about history, but this does not excuse what China is doing to uighur muslims. Its like your using one example of evil to cover up and ignore what China is doing to it's citizens.

[@rocappreciater5540]

@vial.of.photons Your American affirmative action plans aren't working well.

[@rocappreciater5540]

@vial.of.photons Ofc it's the minority fault

[@shilanaisilang]

@@MrPurge11 What did China do to Xinjiang Muslims? Their population is growing, and there're many mosques in Xinjiang. That so-called camp helped many of them find a decent job. Anyway, if you trusted BBC’s report, don't reply please.

[@00comm]

How do you say propaganda in Mandarin?

[@discoverchina1885]

ài guó, ài dãng, ài jiào

[@zoom8432]

Chinese propaganda tells you a fairytail

[@UrbanWarrior.]

*this channel is owned by the chinese government

[@adrianoippolito1999]

Its so creepy seeing the "love from x counrty" in the comments. As if anyone would actually comment that

[@hochongker8293]

"We think too good of you, Americans!" Of course, it's not too late to learn that.

[@thebelievers1326]

Mean ?

[@RobeonMew]

I, for one, welcome our great communist overlords.

[@aquilesca5tr0]

@@ge_ming_wu_zui at least they dont kills citizens

[@aquilesca5tr0]

@@ge_ming_wu_zui China is a dictatorship, the media is controlled, they are like in the myth of the cave without knowing anything real about the outside world and if someone questions the government he disappears

[@filipkachnic]

Hong Kong will be free, cpp has already fallen. 600,000 Chinese refugees since 2013.

[@exoels]

CCP ain't falling anytime soon 🤣 I am pretty sure India will fall sooner

[@filipkachnic]

​@@exoels Either you are lying or God: I pick you :)

[@wertvermehren7824]

Low key pro china propaganda

[@grunt117]

CGTN is directly owned by the CCP; this is straight up propaganda

[@Ducktility]

low key? this is high key!

[@johnseto3357]

I live in Canada. I can see the difference . nice to have more reports in English. Thank you.

[@nicoleholaday4083]

Just wanted to let everyone know that Canada's House of Commons has voted overwhelmingly (266 to 0) to declare China's treatment of its Uighur minority population a genocide.

[@VB-zj9cu]

@@Richard-gm8bd PM Trudue is a non competent known only for his looks, body, boxing shorts. How Canadians choose leaders is very questionable. No policy of his is in national or global interest. Canadians for long has supported and harboured separatists. In 1985 an Air India flight was blown mid-air killing hundreds by foreign radicals based in canada. Canada will one day pay a heavy price

[@戴先生-u4w]

@@Richard-gm8bd 但是 中国人民知道事实，你为什么不相信中国人，而相信这种假的离谱的东西呢？我懂了，因为你是加拿大人，白人的种族歧视重来都没有消失，还希望伪装成绅士！真是让人恶心

[@LostInRoads]

@waichhang mind ur business

[@Introvert_Honey]

Riche, you are absolutely correct.

[@TheAlexandar711]

The only way to fight narratives is speak freely, with arguments and asking for arguments for narrative. Truth must not be defeated. Truth is sacred.

[@apocalypsepow]

This is creepy af. 😬 Now show us Tibet.

[@grunt117]

propaganda is disgusting

[@MrFARUUQ]

As a Muslim and African I am deeply disappointed of China's treatment of Muslim citizens. Look at the imam in the video, It was said that China is forcing Muslim men to shave their beards and that imam not having one is a clear sign of the oppression. It is a sunnah or Islamic tradition for Muslim men to maintain their beards, more so if you are an imam, the religious lead.

[@goblinman3010]

@TheLatiosnlatias02 did you just call wahabi bad then shia too?? Would you explain to me why the shia ban?

[@goblinman3010]

@TheLatiosnlatias02 that's a lie I have many shia friends, did you actually meet or speak with any shia cause it sounds like you heard this stuff from isis or wahabi's side not them.

[@goblinman3010]

@TheLatiosnlatias02 who told you this hadith is saheh? Yeah man you definitely are getting this from wahabi, or are for sure biased against them 👎

[@SnekNOTSnake]

Just be happy that there's no western "intervention" in there.

[@adanphu4325]

You can't force others as well.

[@Ssm19494]

What about their religious freedom in these reeducation camps

[@fouadsamer648]

Well, what about the crackdown after 911. Don’t mix religious freedom with extremist terrorism

[@SaretGnasoh]

You are free to do your religious activities as long as not radical.

[@OksanaKrasnova]

neo - fascism

[@SaretGnasoh]

@@OksanaKrasnova please explain

[@OksanaKrasnova]

@@SaretGnasoh what is there to explain, a neo-fascist regime is developing in China, which devalues a person's personality

[@moulion]

Remember to Tweet & share this video guys

[@DialecticalMaterialismRocks]

check out my coming videos. They are in German about uiguren

[@Amaling]

Hmm I wonder if this outlet has any incentives or pressures to portray this positively

[@wanshimain]

THIS IS A DISGRACE! THATS WHAT THIS IS. SPREADING FALSE INFORMATION INSTEAD OF ACTUALLY HELPING THE INNOCENT PEOPLE

[@serpentzachary1340]

Both Chinese and western media can't be trusted remember that and stop being a social justice "white knight".

[@strawberryswan555]

as an uyghur this is most definitely not false information

[@g33k_Tech]

@@strawberryswan555 tq uyghur ..dilireba dilmurat sister

[@clutch1477]

Adult people in school??? School cannot go home for years? Why muslim women cannot wear hijab? Where the mosque?

[@lunix3259]

"Funded by the CCP" enough said, especially your journalist here is dodging important questions that the rest of the world is asking. This is what you tell the Chinese mainlanders.

[@peacefullights]

China has very good relationship with islamic nations, I personally don't think so to be correct as it is shown in media about torturing muslims in china.

[@strawberryswan555]

um they are torturing muslims. just cuz they have better relationships with other islamic countries doesn’t meant they won’t do harm

[@jennyhart6057]

If this re-education camp is too good true to be true, then why won’t they let foreign reporters visit? Also why won’t the camps give info about those who are MISSING? Why be so SECRETIVE?! 🧐 There was also no in-depth reporting about how these ppl were re-educated...

[@exynos8557]

Of course they did visit, otherwise how those BBC's idiots reported it as concentration camp? Will you admit that they made it up? Obviously, you won't admit it. If you willing to seek out the truth, no one can stop you! Welcome to Xinjiang!

[@금강산-c9t]

How come noone mentioned in the video cannot be found in any of the internet searches? If Abulizikari Aobuli does exist and is an artist, his works should be showing up, right? Please don't be delusional from all the propaganda and censorships from China.

[@realphysiotherapy606]

maybe try chinese searching engine and use chinese character?

[@liambassitt5919]

Exactly

[@irritatedanglosaxon1705]

Well... Look at last night NY festive, 5 people stabbing innocent men and rapidly we called them TERRORISTS

[@Wintry_Jasmine]

US-Zionist Axis It was today in UK, a 21-years male arrested on suspicions on terrorist.

[@DADFENG]

respect CGTN tell us the truth❤

[@Jonathan-ib8gq]

What this video failed to cover was how a re education camp deters terrorism. The four examples given of people who were considered better off for these camps, were they terrorists, or targets of extremism before? And were they given the choice to enlist in these camps?

[@americancommunist6076]

basically if your chill, you don't blow shit up

[@grunt117]

Answer: No, they don’t This is state owned propaganda. The Chinese communist party owns CTGN

[@americancommunist6076]

@@grunt117 so china can't talk about china? and the power of the CPC over this channel is pathetic, I wish they had as much control as you think they do.

[@altruistforlife7958]

The re-education centers basically educates them on what Chinese citizenship and being a member of Chinese society means in terms of responsibility in and to the public. Even though they are ethnically and religiously Uighur, they are Chinese citizens by birthright. Culturally and societally, promoting nationalism of a specific group is destabilizing because it harms the society as a whole. Uighur extremism resulted in the death of hundreds of people so it's a pretty legit stance.

[@Si_nengatcha]

Simple Poverty leads to despair leads to crime No poverty leads to happier and quality life leads to no crime. When you have things to do and earn money and able to make a good living, you tend to avoid crimes

[@Ossian-dr1vr]

Nice propaganda video! "all people have by now left the re-education camp" so why are people still in "re-education" camps? You say "the re-education camp like there is just one when there is really between 500 and 1000. hmmm... why does this strange phrasing exist I do wonder.

[@scottsleo]

I believe the Chinese government lie, there are 25 million such re education centres in Xinjiang, where one centre house only one human. Is that enough to satisfy your wish that China is torturing the minorities?

[@Ossian-dr1vr]

@@scottsleo I don't wish that they are, I wish that they don't. I think it's horrible.

[@firerice5650]

The truth is somewhere in between. For a fact the Western world and specifically the US has been writing emphasized sometimes biased news about China for political reasons. And letting people know that China is bad. While in Chinese papers it said that the US is doing that to 'attack' China. This become so far that the people in Western countries and Eastern (Japan, South Korea India) had started to not only hate the CCP but also the people from China. This is why Chinese people started to not like the Western people and is the reason why when visiting as a white person, locals will look at you which then we again think it is racism. Theres Something in between the US and China that's unexplained. But I do understand that the US wants to keep it's place in the world so they will do their best to get China down. The true truth we'll probably know when there happens to be a war.

[@YellowFat]

I want to know more about the 're-education camp'. Looking for the next video!

[@tnorge3584]

Yamcha Gaming totally agree with you. This is just a lie.

[@patrickd4358]

@@tnorge3584 yeh right our americans just fucking god!MEGA!

[@thanhvinhnguyento7069]

@ with a country that big you'd expect travel to be equal

[@hke4369]

@@yamcha8309 same. United States torture races they don't like. I thought all countries are like that

[@terry1708]

How the Superpower anti-terrorism: Invade their countries, kill the leaders and soldiers together with civilians, destroy their cities, towns, and villages. Done! BBC: Heros! How China anti-terrorism: Re-educate extremists, teach laws and skills so that they can work and reduce poverty. Done! BBC: Genocide!

[@thekoreanjesus6202]

fake news, there were youtubers in xinjiang saying its normal while at the back undercover cops were following him all around.

[@xmz70]

Is there is free internet and free access to the region, then we can know the truth.

[@polarstar3001]

Why would you assume anywhere on earth to be 'free'? Though we appreciate sincerity, so please come to Xinjiang and watch by yourself.

[@Sarah-sd7kk]

There is no freedom on youtube lol. Videos that speak the truth about China have their views significantly lowered by youtube bots

[@小明-f8u]

@@Sarah-sd7kk but videos can be forged,so we hope you can have a try to know1 what is the true

[@Sarah-sd7kk]

​@@小明-f8u Not sure what point you are trying to make. But yes, CNN and BCC indeed forge a lot of fake videos about China.

[@小明-f8u]

@@Sarah-sd7kk Yes,thank you.That's just what I want to express.

[@koolbeanz7902]

Lol and I'm supposed to believe this 😆

[@dariang4725]

Lmao and look at all the Wumao trash in the comments. Can't even construct a coherent sentence in English. Sure I totally believe this. Especially since it's funded by the CCP.

[@andersonanderson1525]

Serpentza,laowhy, china uncensored are not happy with this

[@selisdega5642]

i watch them,. they are funny,.

[@Ritzrfx]

you can't justified genocide with terrorist attacks

[@yantingting2219]

信的人自然会用眼睛耳朵发现真相，不愿意听的人看到听到也不会承认的

[@michealsmith54]

你怎么知道他说的是真相，维吾尔自己说得谎话?

[@retong385]

@@michealsmith54 如果你不信他说的就自己新疆去看看，或者像我这样有几个维族的同学！

[@voyuss910]

@@michealsmith54 我周围不少新疆同学，有的甚至入了党，他们都不知道自己原来生活在水深火热之中，瞎揣测啥呢∠( ᐛ 」∠)＿

[@Leyee-l9y]

@@yubowei872 在看西方新闻的时候你怎么不这样想想？每到西方说到中国你们不是就信吗？说白了你就已经信了他们说的什么集中营，你有什么资格评论我们？

[@Leyee-l9y]

@@yubowei872 他分了几个视频做关于新疆的好吗？你看完再说？

[@sidsun4500]

Freedom for the Uyghur!!!!!

[@schmelzikasefaust8193]

@TheLatiosnlatias02 Hard to handle the truth, right? You should be ashamed to support this regime and the way it treats people. Grow up, dude...

[@ObiJohnKenobi67]

"We hear accounts about Auschewitz being this place where Jews are gassed, but actually they were learning skills to improve their place in German society. Look at Jacob here, he learned to cook strudle"

[@ddegn]

As long as Jocob learned to cook strudel there must not be anything wrong. BTW, Mao kill way more people than Hitler. I think Xi is trying to be like Mao.

[@momojafar9385]

Guy please don't fall for this blatant propaganda.

[@Ducktility]

-10000 social credits

[@Jason7k.]

and believe western propaganda?

[@garden6195]

in camps, people are being killed, raped, and you say it's a lie. Of course, the truth will come out, and on that day you will be accountable.

[@qoo1723]

support and respect from Taiwan.

[@RandomGuy9]

I sure trust the Chinese state-run media when they tell me their Gulags aren't that bad.

[@homewatcherhousewatcher9482]

Why not? China is better than the Us in all forms

[@RandomGuy9]

@@homewatcherhousewatcher9482 Not at all. It's much more terrible especially when you have to live there and are not in the priviledged group. Public executions for non-violent crimes, no freedom, long prison sentences for minor crimes, massive human rights violations and an aggressive foreign politic. It's also the most capitalistic country I have ever seen.

[@ZRHTrainspotter]

This is propaganda

[@user-tp2ff9wn1g]

The tongue can conceal the truth, but the eyes never !!!!

[@cristianomessi8497]

These "re-education camps" are so beautiful that Uygurs try to escape from China not to get into them.

[@jackabbott2170]

escape? you mean with their passports if there was a genocide going on there would be a refugee crisis

[@alebaobao]

Is that re-education center just for uyghur people? Why do they need to learning that education seperately? Can they just learn it in school with other etnicities? I'm genuinely asking and just curious why there is re-education camp in the first place?

[@royhsieh4307]

the same way i wished there is a special education for the poorly educated, or dummified by some western medias

[@johnwang3120]

The people were previously either from heavily religious families that had strict customs so needed special treatment for rehabilitation in modern society, Or were part of terrorist training groups

[@TheMandom88]

CGTN SHOULD GO TO US/MEXICO BORDERS AND REPORT ON CAGED CHILDREN DENIED WATER TO BATH OR BRUSH TEETH AND SLEEP ON CEMENT FLOOR WITH NO BLANKET.

[@digitalnomad5643]

Xinjiang serves for the OBOR initiative as a conduit to the Central Asia. It must not be allowed to prosper if the OBOR initiative in Eurasian continent is to be stymied.

[@Infamous41]

Sounds like u said let them do whatever they wish without complaint for a happy asia

[@samowen2286]

And here's the answer to why all of a sudden China is responsible for "genocide".

[@bengkellia3660]

Hahaha, yes of course, very beautiful and perfect, rose petal and colorfull. Everything looks good and OK.

[@Avicados]

Yeah they all want to be there, leave their families and cultures while never going back. It’s the best time ever!

[@SaheelHussan]

Uyghur Muslims women used to wear burqa.. why none of them wearing it now?

[@SaheelHussan]

@Detective Conan It's uyghur identity. Burqa and Niqab two different thing. Burqa only cover hair not the face.

[@SaheelHussan]

@Detective Conan I shouldn't. I know what it is.

[@SaheelHussan]

@Detective Conan I'm from 100% Muslim country Maldives. We call burqa to headscarf it can be in any length, but it doesn't cover full face like Niqab. So meaning can differ from you to us.

[@jasonshen7600]

A family relative actually did a failed "theft" and got sent to prison, he begged the judge to sentence him longer cuz he wanted to finish the sewing class there.

[@阿眠-i3h]

@Keanu Reeves 真有这回事，几年的

[@tommywong1997]

cgtn is owned and funded by the ccp

[@ittastelikekool-aid7483]

That means it's not corrupted and controlled by the cia like cnn, fox, bbc and other mainstream media outlets.

[@tommywong1997]

@@ittastelikekool-aid7483 But controlled by CCPPD...Right?

[@ittastelikekool-aid7483]

​@@tommywong1997 You're not getting it. What makes CGTN honest and authentic is because it's controlled by the government, unlike businesses in the US where corruption and profit means more than broadcasting the truth. It make sure it's not corrupt like other news sources that sensationalizes the news for the sake of profit.

[@tommywong1997]

@@ittastelikekool-aid7483 Why is control by the government sincere and true? Did you know that the responsibility of the media Fourth Estate lies in monitoring the government? Your thoughts shocked me. Are you America?

[@ittastelikekool-aid7483]

@@tommywong1997 Do you actually think the Chinese Govt is the same as the government here in the US? You need to do a serious investigation and know how the Chinese Govt works. It's THE best government in the world today. And yes I'm America living here in California the past 51 years.

[@Verbal_Kint416]

propaganda at its best #freeuyghurs

[@simonyap6422]

America and some EU countries don't want to know and don't want to listen.

[@ZYBIGBOIII]

So do u wanna know about 64?

[@user-ic7mv6bj4w]

Amazing. You are one of very few REAL Journalists left on this planet.

[@anandyadav8144]

So your channel is funded by chinese gov.

[@alexish8789]

IF YOU DONT BELIEVE THIS CHANNEL,THEN BUY A TICKET TO XINJIANG AFTER COVID

[@Pikachuloong]

太棒了，中国就需要这样英文超赞的媒体人，向世界传达“中国声音”

[@Marsbati]

可惜在白人世界他们就喜欢看白人播的新闻 就算中国会讲流利英文 白人不在乎 纯粹种族主义

[@啦啦啦玩魔兽的妹纸]

kjajk6366 你看看有多少踩 提到中国他们都没有好印象 吃狗吃虫子商品质量差 他们只相信媒体报道的中国罢了 管他们干啥 一群虚伪的恶心的人

[@ButcherOfBeek]

"There is no war in Ba Sing Se"

[@LMB222]

Those are concentration camps, not "education camps"

[@ashtoash2213]

The concentration camp eliminating unemployment and terrorism.

[@aaaaabbbbb2830]

education camps that are teaching enemies of the state how to survive the gas chamber

[@strawberryswan555]

@@ashtoash2213 you think 10 year olds are terrorists? you think 80 year olds can do anything you dummy

[@blose4793]

China should share their re-education activities in countering terrorisms. If not, the western media will continue say China has something to hide. Some countries also identify and re-educate radicals, they don't get whacked like China.

[@gyin9098]

China has invited Western organizations many times, but they refused to go to Xinjiang, cause they know it will break their fake news propaganda

[@lyndonbennett2746]

This all well and good, but do the Uygur's actually have a choice whether they attend the camps or not? Every Chinese person I've talked to who lives outside of China says that the western assessment of the camps being more like a "concentration camp" is accurate. Obviously I'm not saying I'm an expert with overwhelming proof, I just find it interesting how there seems to be a difference of opinions between Chinese people living in China, which does have government censorship, and Chinese nationals living in other countries with access to multiple news and journalism sources.

[@lyndonbennett2746]

@TheLatiosnlatias02 I completely agree with you on most of what you're saying. I absolutely believe that how the United States has treated Muslims around the world has been horrible. I also agree with you that China's approach is far better, and more peaceful. I have nothing against China; in fact my girlfriend, and my aunt are both from China. The real question I was asking is why there is a different account of the activities going on in these schools, or what ever you want to call them. And also, why is the Chinese government so strict on what journalist's and tourists can and can't film. I realize that the western media is almost certainly making the situation seem worse than it is, but if things are so great, why can't foreigners and journalist come see it for themselves? That was my main concern.

[@lyndonbennett2746]

@TheLatiosnlatias02 I guess it can be true that journalist spin things and have agendas, but journalism is also important as it can uncover the truth, and it's an expression of freedom of speech and thought; don't you think freedom of speech and opinion are important?

[@user-ev4lq5fr1o]

He did not show what these camps were about😑 man, show us the inside footage?

[@veryiran1567]

Love china from iran 🇨🇳❤🇮🇷

[@hathimeldar9482]

Thank you ❤ From your Muslim brothers and sisters that are being tortured in Xinjiang

[@hathimeldar9482]

@Karan Jeet Singh when ur Iq is equal to your age I don't really give to fucks about ur assumptions

[@xiuxinlyu9271]

Instead of believing in stupid news, try to hear voice from people who live in the truth.

[@Music-qm4pw]

You are completely right!! This is not XINJIANG instead it is East Turkistan!!!

[@apep7188]

"De-radicalizing" an entire population is basically "exterminating their culture" in different words.

[@dex4836]

True

[@yuusera5957]

Then what would you call the wars that Western countries started in Iraq, Afghanistan etc?

[@apep7188]

@@yuusera5957 That's all about the petrodollar. Not about wiping out an entire ethnicity.

[@yuusera5957]

@@apep7188 Sure but what are the results?

[@mycodingchannel9690]

Yep, child marriage and stoning are great cultures

[@troutstalker7855]

What is the name of this reporter?

[@developertips2607]

When a man in Xinjiang sees a western reporter on a train and waits for everyone to go to sleep so he can talk to them, you know how bad they are treated.

[@g33k_Tech]

have u gone to xinjiang

[@snarktube]

Well, do chinese are shown same news as we are? I can't find a particular video showing how uighar books that were taught after 2002, got a uighar official death sentence while the content of the book were far less extremist as a normal story.

[@MitsukiHashiba]

Dont belive anything what CGTN said. I have some Uyghurs in my Village (Germany) who came as refugees to Germany. Everybody told me what they have been through etc.. all of them say the exact same thing what the CCP has done to them. I love those people, they' re so nice and still standing strong after all!

[@theredbar-cross8515]

Let's see how long before KZbin deletes this video.

[@Oksendal5]

It won't and shouldn't

[@meplenn]

At least I have downloaded this video

[@YouOnUsPath]

If Chinese against muslim, its same like they against their own ancestors ming dynasty poems about prophets Muhammad saw

[@vincentzs5306]

I like how every Chinese government funded channel is labeled on KZbin. But the channels funded by the US government aren’t. LOL. BIAS BEFORE U EVEN STARTED WATCHING THE VIDEO TO DOUBT THE CONTENT.

[@inspiringer6418]

I'm pretty sure companies choose their own title