Why The Knuckles Show Was Disappointing

So, the Knuckles show released about a month ago and the reception has been very mixed. Some swear by it and state it is one of the best Sonic Shows and others are either mostly indifferent to it, or just hate it. As for me, well, I lean more negatively but I do want to give the show a proper critical eye and explain exactly why it didn't click for me. But, as always, I'm getting ahead of myself. Hopefully you all enjoy the video!
If you want to go above and beyond in supporting the channel, then why not check out my Patreon: / thepjshow
Timestamps:
00:00 Introduction
01:33 Episode 1
08:34 Episode 2
10:36 Episode 3
14:19 Episode 4
19:27 Episode 5
22:16 Episode 6
24:43 Final Thoughts (Focus, Budget, Music etc...)
30:26 Outro

[@thepjshow]

So, what are your thoughts on the Knuckles Show? Do you agree with me? Disagree? let me know in the comments below as I always try to read every comment!

[@marcusyates3044]

This Knuckles is my favorite movie portrayal, and I felt more for Wade now. So, I wanna see more of the SCU (Sonic Cinematic Universe), and still waiting for Shadow and/or Amy Rose

[@BrendynRobertson]

I thought it was a pretty good show.I just don't understand why it's hated because Knuckles has lest screentime, dispite being his show. It's about both Knuckles AND Wade. People don't understand that the miniseries balanced the two characters. Knuckles help Wade becomes a warrior in his own way while Wade help Knuckles in saying that Earth is his home. Anyway, I enjoyed all 8 episodes of the show. The characters are well-done, the story is brilliant and the action are cool. I give it a 10/10.

[@liamphibia]

You're late to the party, but we're *glad* you're here.

[@_NormalEditor]

Hard disagree imo

[@user-mq5fx9tu5r]

I honestly really liked the show. Knuckles character is kept consistent with the second movie and the jokes are actually pretty good here. Personally the first three were the best, they just had more action sequences and good cgi( not saying the rest is awful but in my opinion they had the best. I like Wade and to hear his backstory was relatable but they made it funny to some degree. Episode 4 in my opinion is the worst. Wade gets mannapped by his old friend who is a bounty hunter. Good start obviously Knuckles is going to come get him and take down Jack and Knuckles gets his hat in a cool way. Right? But no Wade is literally unconscious for 29 minutes and Pachacamac reappears. So I thought if they were going to train Wade into becoming a warrior and Knuckles would join him in this ancestral plane but No we get to listen to a cheap budget musical which is all right. Then Wade punches out of his cage and cuts Jacks hair off and drives his motorbike back to Wendy’s house and Knuckles says “ He’s ready”. Knuckles in the episode for a minute or less! Then episode five is decent. Then episode six is fine but the ending was cool but rushed and knuckles got beat up like a redheads stepchild. Then post credits and I thought they were gonna show a sneak peek for Sonic Movie 3 to get us all hyped but Nooo! I’d rate it a 7/10 pretty good but if Jeff Fowler directed the whole thing I would guarantee it would’ve been a 9.9/10.

[@bluemofo4920]

The most worrying thing about this show is that it did better than both sonic movies, which makes me concerned that they're going to do more stuff like this

[@thepjshow]

That thought terrifies me too

[@liamphibia]

They *cannot* repeat the same formula again. It'll be so tiring and irritating.

[@LegendaryExistence04]

If u mean better ratings, then it's because less people rated the show compared to the movies

[@Rediscool9]

Considering how critics ate it up too and how there are Sonic fans who are willing to defend it, yeah expect Paramount to do shit like this again because people aren’t willing to actually call them out when they do something wrong.

[@sboinkthelegday3892]

It was always going to be like this. If you want a "sonic movie" less hollywood than this pure distillation of hollywood, get Naughty Dog to do it and sell it on video game consoles for $80 like their other moveis posing as video games. Is it too late to ask Paramount feature Crash and Ratchet & Clank in Sonic movies, and make this series the Smash Bros of film? Western production on video game has had this irreverent attitude from the beginning, because games like Donkey Kong Country amd Crash bandicoot WERE jsut poorly understood fundamentals of gaming lampooning on Mario.

[@malikpierre-louis3343]

Honestly despite this series being THIS, I am not worried for sonic movie 3, because the director for the movies wasn't involved much with this show outside of episode 1.

[@liamphibia]

And the writers form Knuckles aren't the same writers from the movies. We're still good.

[@Abner-gu3ve]

Agreed

[@dakadadrew8017]

No wonder episode 1 was the best episode 🤣

[@manuelinacio4038]

Wade Wipple right now has more screen time in the cinematic universe than Eggman and Tails COMBINED. Let that sink in.

[@JosiahtheMessiah-11809]

What?

[@manuelinacio4038]

@@JosiahtheMessiah-11809 I'm not kidding. He is only behind Sonic and Knuckles.

[@CaptainCretaceous91]

I'm not complaining. He actually made me laugh.

[@manuelinacio4038]

@@CaptainCretaceous91 Glad you had a good time.

[@CaptainCretaceous91]

@@manuelinacio4038 That being said, watching Maddie ground Knuckles was pretty cringe. Then again, groundings are always cringe.

[@HarmonyBunny]

Missed opportunity to call it Wade & Knuckles.

[@Perolin.]

9:16 I think the best example of this is Better Call Saul. Better Call Saul's protagonist is the comedy relief in Breaking Bad and the writers manage to make him one of the most complex characters in not only the Breaking Bad franchise but in media. I'm not saying I expect this cinematic universe to reach the level of BCS but if you want to make the comedy relief character one of protagonists you have to do a better job than this show.

[@thelastcrow5660]

The show highlights the biggest problem these movies have: the human OCs (except Agent Stone) are unfunny and annoying. I really hope they learn from their mistakes and don't give Rachel, Wade and the others too much screentime in Sonic 3. Shadow's story needs to be done right. Poor boy is in desperate need of some good writing.

[@KgEclispe252]

Spoiler alert They will fuck it up

[@thelastcrow5660]

@@KgEclispe252 Don't be so sure. They did Knuckles and Robotnik justice.

[@liamphibia]

True. Though I'd say Tom and Maddie are good. They're actually a very supportive couple and have a very happy and healthy marriage. Which showcases why Sonic looks up to them the most in Green Hills, even becoming his adoptive parents. And best of all, they act like normal people.

[@thelastcrow5660]

@@liamphibia They're fine. I was refering more to the comic relief characters.

[@hihi-nm3uy]

I think this is reductive; bear in mind grand sweeping assessments are what created the 2010s era in the first place. I think there is an issue in the way the Knuckles Show handled the Human OCs, but removing them entirely is not the solution. A lot of the heart and soul of Sonic 2 came off of the back of the human chemistries that were built up. I get what you mean though.

[@liamphibia]

Oh my God. Everything you said about seeing Knuckles passing out in a desert and having a flashback showcasing his younger years and seeing Pachacamac being a hardass on him by making strength and combat as a main priority, only for his father encouraging him that fighting is only half the warrior. Just *wow.* And your pitch for Wade's backstory where we actually *see* him abandoned by Pistol Pete at TJ Maxx only for an officer to help him find his family, which shows why he wants to become an officer himself so he could help others, and his love for 80's music being his escapism. *PJ!* These ideas you presented for the main characters would have been *fantastic.* You should have been one of the writers! I'm even more sad this was never done here. PS. The Buyer was *Snively* the whole time underneath that big ol' beard.

[@MattSaysYes]

I would love is he was snively I need my girl Hope back

[@batman369able]

Lol, hes a pre reboot Archie Snively that made it out of prison and put work in.

[@nman551]

It’s disgusting that people attacked anyone who criticized the show, it hurt Sam procrastinates to the point that he broke down. The show is not good, and I’m never gonna let them live past making Iblis a joke.

[@malikpierre-louis3343]

Uh I didn't know about that, that is fucked Honestly I feel like people should chill when defending something, at the end of the day you shouldn't be this violent towards someone just for criticizing it.

[@nman551]

@@malikpierre-louis3343 I completely agree, I am not a fan of this show but I will not attack anyone who disagreed with me.

[@DaveMan1K]

Sam kinda brought that on himself from how he acted. He wasn't innocent either.

[@nman551]

@@DaveMan1K Excuse me? What so he deserves to get bullied cause you jerks can’t accept differing takes? What kind of monster says that?

[@nman551]

@@DaveMan1K You sound like you enjoy hurting people. Get off the internet.

[@ItzCisco101]

Jeff Fowler is the best, that’s why episode 1 is the best out of the 6

[@user-bz3yt8pi3n]

I think Pachacamac should've been the villain because he was a villain in the games, and the Knuckles clan killed Longclaw, they wanted power. This could've been about Knuckles learning about his tribe not being what he thought they were, and the ghost of pachacamac wanted knuckles to spread the tribe's philosophy, to continue HIS legacy, and the reason why he could'nt hug Knuckles, but could bang into things could be because he's being punished for his sins in life, like Jacob Marley.

[@lilstrawberry_lady]

I really wish the series could have been about knuckles learning more about the human world. That could’ve been way more interesting than this whole plot of knuckles trying to help wade fix his daddy issues💀 Edit: Wanda can die in hell.

[@Abner-gu3ve]

That’s honestly a good idea. That plot wouldn’t be too much for a six episode miniseries and would give Knuckles more screen time

[@GumRobber]

I liked the show for what it was. I’ll admit it’s not perfect like I feel like knuckles could have had a little more screen time and I don’t hate Wade I just feel like some scenes could have been shortened a little and I personally don’t mind the bowling matches cause I like bowling but I think the thing that stings me the most is the ending cause it feels rushed it should have the final battle with knuckles go on a bit more and have the post credits be knuckles and wade arrive back in Green hills with Sonic, Tails, and Maddie greeting them. My rating for this show is a 6.5 or 7 out of 10.

[@thepjshow]

That is a pretty fair and reasoned take. I don't hate wade either, but it's more the characters and story surrounding his character that is the biggest issue. If they wanted to include Wade, they should have focused on his interactions with Knuckles and build them up as a unique duo. And, yeah, the ending is so anticlimactic. Even the post credits scene was nothing but wasted time.

[@genreproductions2706]

*When people start hating the Mario Movie* Me: It’s a great movie! *When people start hating the Five Nights at Freddy’s Movie* Me: It has its flaws but I had a good and scary time with it. *When people start hating the Knuckles series **_before_** I watched it* Me: I’m sure that they’re wrong about this series. *_After I watched the movie_* Me: This is a bad omen for video game adaptations.

[@lestatcanada]

Just because one video game adaption wasn’t on as great as other doesn’t mean all Vidoe game adaptions will fail I’m still excited for sonic 3

[@gamercentral2417]

1. It was only critics who hated the Mario movie. Almost no one else hated it 2. People only called it mediocre. No hate on it 3. That’s not an omen for all video games

[@DaveMan1K]

You want a bad omen, look at Uncharted.

[@lestatcanada]

@@DaveMan1K still don’t think one or 2 bad VG based movies is an omen of anything

[@shoebillstan8144]

Isn’t it weird how if LS Mark likes something everyone else despises it and vice versa

[@liamphibia]

He has really strange tastes.

[@Abner-gu3ve]

@@liamphibiayeah but imma have to agree with him on this show. I liked it 🤷🏾‍♂️

[@bartvshomer]

More weird to me how he complains about the very few human moments in Sonic 2, yet praises the Knuckles show despite Wade and his family being the focus over Knuckles himself?

[@Rediscool9]

Contrarian’s gonna contrarian

[@cherricake1796]

My god people like you live in an echo chamber ​@@Rediscool9

[@kostelakkkk]

If only they’ve named this show Wade & Knuckles…

[@gentikeri8236]

U know what i noticed,this is kinda like the sonic 4 of the movies let me explain: People say that sonic 4 wouldnt be so hated it its name was change And here we have this show wich evryone agrees that it should have been called Wade and Knuckels Who knew the sonic cycle still existed

[@eow4317]

Knuckles? More like… uh… fingers!

[@LegendryHeropon]

kid named knuckles

[@LegendryHeropon]

kid named knuckles

[@a_man_of_cultute]

Knuckles? more like... *FISTS*

[@shadow.1691]

Nah we got hands

[@Valroirr]

Wake up babe, the pjshow dropped a new vid! Jokes aside it's great to see you back with some very logical and solid arguments. It's a real shame because I initially heard great things about this sadly, I'm hoping they somewhat work on the rest of these episodes going forward but one can only hope

[@demonranger3097]

The Fucking Disrespect they threw at knuckles's backstory through its portrayal ALONE during the musical episode... was the nail on the coffin for me. Literally the ONLY character to have a Sadder, more Traumatic and Fucked up backstory than Shadow gets treated like a terrible and cringeful attempt at humor 🙃, that whole section STARKLY resembled the meta era, by having ZERO Mind, commen sense Brain-Que's, And ANY SEMBLANCE OF SOCIAL AWARENESS, for when and where to turn the 'cheeseball jokes' T H E Fuck O F F ! And still managing to not only fail at knowing when to be comedic, or serious for that manner... But 95% of both their heartfelt moments AND their comedic moments fall completely flat on their OWN. Not helped by their Stupid, and just Purely Un-Earned nature of things... I just pray 🙏 this dunce was due to the writer's strike and that Knuckles's will get HIS DESERVED show in all it's glory AND NOT with a season 2 just because of what that would entail, but With a NEW SHOW ENTIRELY just simply called (while truly EMPHASIZING our man)... Knuckles THE Echidna

[@chadgorosaurus4898]

And yet, people defended this abomination like it was their first born child

[@Abner-gu3ve]

Ima have to disagree. I loved the musical episode. That shit was fun 😂

[@spinolover124]

Geez, it's a show about a red anthropomorphic echidna and a deputy from a small town in Montana, chill out.

[@Abner-gu3ve]

@@spinolover124 ikr. Some of these Sonic fans are so dramatic. Good lord 😂

[@bigchungus2926]

@@Abner-gu3ve Just consoom more products goyim and never question there quality, that would be le evil NAZI thing to do.

[@mcpics4448]

Knuckle show? More like the Wade show

[@sophiaho2341]

i feel like i'm the only one neutral about the Knuckles series cuz i enjoyed watching it expect for the musical numbers and i'm fine with Wade getting some more characterization and his uncle-nephew relationship with Knuckles, i also liked Wade's mom she's a badass lady, the fight scene with her and Knuckles are spot on i know a few majority of the fanbase complain about the human characters in the scu(expect for like Agent Stone, Eggman or Maria) but i'm okay with humans being apart of the story thats my overall opinion

[@HealSpirit014]

I will say the intro to each ep went hard

[@harrisonjohnson4454]

I was worried I was going to miss out on the knuckles show since it was on paramount + but after I saw the reactions to it online I was suddenly OK with missing out

[@Bloobleeblu427]

It broke my heart when I sat down expecting to see further progression between knuckles and the characters, and instead was treated to this. That first episode was an unfair tease, btw. While I don’t mind Wade as a character, I do feel that they made a crucial mistake of giving him too much screen time and ignoring all the other characters. They could’ve made it to where we learn about his backstory in snippets, while giving enough screen time to the other underdeveloped characters so that we can grow to understand them better and not feel so overwhelmed. Great vid btw!

[@aaronimp4966]

So we learned a lesson; don't fire the director.

[@corruptedteka]

Did they really ? Why ?

[@ToyBonnie.Productions]

​@@corruptedtekaI don't think they fired him. He probably stopped directing the show so he can focus more on the third movie

[@Nagareboshee]

I hate the part when Knuckles went “Do u know da wae?”. Wasted potential.

[@nman551]

You do not know da wae

[@AgentWuT]

the riters do not know da wae

[@nman551]

@@AgentWuT they do not have Ebola

[@s-gamer2705]

I legit was left dissapointed cause Knux is my favorite. And i wouldn't mind having show like this...existing. BUT its literally promoted itself as KNUCKLES series. Where he's actually main hero of its story, but all i saw is...Knuckles is basically just...a guest character. I don't hate Wade, i don't care about him...But FFS, its literally clickbait for fans like me. If you liked the show, thats good. I'm glad you did. As for me....i just gonna pretend i never watched it.

[@KgEclispe252]

That's literally my issue too the show is fine but advertising as a Knuckles adventure was a freaking lie.

[@Abner-gu3ve]

Honestly that’s a very understandable complaint

[@imperfectmyst]

It was nice to see sonic and Tails but part of me wished we had more of them like sonic helping knuckles how to adapt life on earth and something happens to the emerald were they go on this side quest discover this world's version's of angel island

[@thepjshow]

That already sounded more interesting than the main story of the show before I even finished your sentence

[@imperfectmyst]

@@thepjshow lol like imagine???!

[@freezasama5802]

You have the best takes on the Sonic franchise I have ever seen love watching your videos was waiting a long time for this one but it's well worth the wait

[@XLR8wuzhere]

9:09-9:16 I wouldn't say it's extraordinarily difficult making a comic relief character a mc, there has been and still are plenty of shows, games (video games), even in mangas, manhwas, and comics that has done that, if either of three has more than one mc ofc. But, I wouldn't say it is easy either 🤔. If done right, the comic relief character can actually be a good mc, and it has been done before in many shows, video games, comics, mangas, and manwhas that has the comic relief character being a mc as either the deuteragonist or the tritagonist.

[@ablosch2452]

Well it certainly didn’t end up good with stuff like Planet Sheen, Cars 2, or the Minions.

[@jskywalker58]

i still really shocks me that people are defending this show...but i-i just fundamentally can't see the appeal people like dimiss criticism as "oh your expecting too much" or "sonic fans are never pleased". first of all yeah sure how dare i want the show to focus on who its named after, and second of all what am i as a sonic fan supposed to get out of this show, it contains none of the stuff that made fans love the franchises. just like you i don't even really hate wade i thought he was entertaining for the most part, if this show wasn't connected to the sonic franchise and was just its own thing, i think i would had a solid time with it, however it is a sonic product so i'm gonna judge it like that and as a sonic product, i personally think its kinda disgraceful. look i enjoyed the sonic movies but i feel like this show put the flaws of those movies up in the fore front, huge focus on human characters and the lack of elements from the games(though the sequel did improve on that), and good lord why are these sonic movies projects so against using music from the games they have access to some of the best music in gaming history and there just not interested in using it for some reason at this point i be shock if we hear music from the games.

[@whatkingdom8244]

Silver: you got to be kidding me

[@fanofyoshi2238]

I think my favorite part is the irony in how the thumbnail's headline says "Just Plain Awful", while the video mentions redeeming qualities. I feel like a lot of your criticisms come from letting your personal biases cloud your judgement rather than an actual problem with the show (i.e. Episode 4), then again, i myself am one to let my personal biases cloud my judgement (i was also going to ask the issues with Chris's writing, but i haven't even watched Sonic X) But i think your video does have SOME good points.

[@gracecathrinelawrence1569]

Can i just defend the show, by saying the episodes were evenly split between knuckles and wade actually, knuckles got the majority of episodes 1 through three and wade got the majority of episodes four through six, both characters also appeared equally as frequent in the other episodes, i get that the show had more wade screentime than we expected BUT you have to remind yourself they had a lower budget than they did with the films and they had to pay idris elba allot of it to even voice act knuckles and the CGI mustve costed allot, i personally enjoyed the show very much, you dont have to focus on the bad things guys look at the good things too.

[@megawarrior_101]

I feel like we’ve gotten way too critical and pessimistic about stuff like this in general. I do think it would’ve been better had Jeff Fowler handled production of the show, but it’s not like the show itself was absolutely terrible. I think they did their best with the budget they had and made it overall pretty fun

[@dreamkiller1387]

Man this show had a lot of potential and i was hoping that it was better than it is now , also a great viedo

[@Mario_Sonic_Pro]

What sibling stabs their other sibling with a fork???? Watch the whole scene and look at Knuckles’s reaction, even HE was horrified.

[@kaxcommentssomethingREAL]

29:20 - 29:31 this. this is exactly how i feel after finally gathering my thoughts on this show

[@hopegalaxy]

We wanted da Wae. But instead we got the Wade.

[@matthewisguy7336]

13:23 That's a sentence that you -dont- hear everyday

[@AsAs-tu6vj]

You're like a goat I'm ngl You remind me of scrubz not like how you're like him but the way he made kid me feel Idk if anyones told you this but you're great at what you do and i hope you keep making content you enjoy and that we love

[@DanielKariuki-er5gi]

3:10 It's good thing James Marsden didn't return for the show because of all the backlash from Quit On Set about him supporting Brian Peck and all of that happened 1 month before the show came out.

[@Dragzilla66]

We really don’t need Wade in the Sonic Universe at all. We only needed Knuckles to be the focus, this show was torture! 👀

[@theedgyduo7091]

I sincerely hope the Sonic 3 movie isn’t as disappointing as this series

[@djdrizzy9139]

I just want a faithful animated adaptation of the Sonic universe, akin to the Mario movie. Why is that so difficult? Even just animating the comics would suffice! I think an anime episodic series would work best. (I really want to see my girl Blaze get animated)

[@KidGenesis-gd8ek]

Sonic needs a new anime. It'll be more rounded and diverse.

[@djdrizzy9139]

@@KidGenesis-gd8ek A new Sonic anime with characters like Blaze would be a dream come true.

[@KidGenesis-gd8ek]

@@djdrizzy9139 Hell yeah! Just imagine a Sonic anime that adapts Sonic Rush like an arc. Can you imagine seeing Blaze and Sonic together?

[@djdrizzy9139]

@@KidGenesis-gd8ek Yeah, a modern Sonic anime would go so hard. Instead, we get shows like Sonic Prime and Boom lol. Literally just animate the comics, and boom, there's a successful anime!

[@matthewisguy7336]

10:22 what?! Knuckles looks so cute there 😂

[@KrangtheMultion]

I rather the show be its own side story instead of introducing new characters like rogue and Amy that’ll be important in the movie if they were. The main problem with current mcu is how much shows you have to watch to know where the plot is right now or who are these characters

[@logankennedy4525]

There’s also the scene in episode 6 where Wanda tries to unlock the handcuffs with her thumb nail, and then her thumb gets dislocated. Fuck that scene.

[@StudioBionic1]

I feel like they should've just made a Knuckles Movie. That way they wouldn't have to stretch their budget so thin to account for a TV show, and actually make something we'd want to see. Maybe if Jeff Fowler directed the whole thing, not only would it feel more consistent, but he clearly understands the series better than anyone else at Paramount

[@hyperkl1219]

when can we get that sonic and the black knight review

[@YungDoesThings]

i'd like to think that Pachakamek was still power hungry and more like his game counterpart when he was alive. But once he died, he got all the negativity tooken out of him and he was much more relaxed. Still doesnt excuse this silly version of him but I think this is the only way to explain it.

[@AgentWuT]

I think why the main focus on wade is he's gonna be important in a sonic movie/show someday but i highly doubt that

[@featherguardian6023]

I just finished watching the Knuckles Series and honestly it would have been better as a Movie but I Enjoyed it for the Most Part, sure Wade was the Main Focus but I knew that it would have been expensive to make a CGI Character the Main Focus in a Series but I have Fun, I will admit that in the Future of this Cinematic Universe there how to limit the Human Cast and focus on the Real Stars but because this is a Start I give it a Pass for Now and who knows maybe putting humor is to balance out the Sonic 3 Movie to be Serious, I have to say that this show isn’t the worst thing to ever happen to the Sonic Franchise, that would be Forces, and I will admit that one thing I will admit with Everyone is Wanda(although that Finger Scene made me Laugh so Hard like in Episode 2 Knuckles imagining to do a MK2 Jax Fatality), I enjoy the Series that it’s a 7 out of 10, the only way this Knuckles Project would have worked was if it was a Movie or a Animated Series with Angel Island, Rouge, and the Chaotix but I had Fun and I loved the References from past Game like Tails Bed being Purple like the Tornado 2, the Beginning being a Homage to the Games, Shadow being hinted at a Event of 1974, The Buyer maybe being connected to either Ivo or Gerald, the Rogue Agents interesting Motivations to Neutralize the Morbians as Humanity Fears what they don’t understand, Knuckles getting his Hat and Love for Music, and that Musical being Fun to watch with 2 amazing references to 06 with Iblis and the Flames of Disaster, 7 out of 10.

[@Sean-qg3gg]

I hope Wade gets one small contribution to the action in Sonic 3, with his training from episode 4. In the other movies, the only thing he actually did was distract Eggman from killing Sonic too soon. He took Stone hostage, but that didn’t actually do anything. Since Tom seems to be reaching obscurity in plot relevance, maybe he can properly be accompanied by Wade as a competent partner for the human interventions.

[@Bendytube72]

Man I don't know what people are talking about, I fucking love this series!!

[@benluka1811]

I thought it was fine but could've been a lot better

[@DanielKariuki-er5gi]

3:47 Yeah I don't really like Christopher Lloyd's casting in this show especially when they made the ghost joke "I'm a ghost" we've heard that joke millions of times come up with something new!

[@CreativeGeoff]

My biggest worry is Shadow being a "bowling fan" like they hinted at the end. If they nerfed Knuckles and his tribe, I could only imagine what they'll do to Shadow.

[@DaveMan1K]

From the sheer unbridled vitriol I saw from Sam, Johnny and Nick, I expected FAR worse. But after being burned by Marvel and Star Wars countless times, I don't look the gift horse in the mouth when something less egregious is released. Having just come off of the utter nothing burger that was Sonic Prime, this was a breath of fresh air. On the count that all my time and investment wasn't for naught. Unlike the shows from Disney+ that are named after the titular character but sideline him for someone new and better (normally a self-insert) as well as insult and demean him, here at least I can look at Knuckles and know he's still cool. And I'm sorry but if people are gonna apologise for Sonic X sidelining the main cast, then they're gonna have to do the same thing here. And at least with Knuckles it's one Sonic character vs several human characters, not one human character against several Sonic characters. Could this have been better, absolutely. Could it have been worse; don't count your blessings. They could've given Knuckles the same treatment as Loki, or Boba Fett, or Obi-Wan, or Moon Knight, or Picard, or Mando. But they didn't. Yet people still bark and clap like seals for those shit shows.

[@antonissa8345]

Will you ever do a video about movie eggman?

[@gentikeri8236]

Thank u for reviewing episode 4,now my life can move on

[@imba9105]

I still agree with what Fadel said, watch episodes 1,2, and 6, but for some reason I’d also watch episode 3 but only the parts Knuckles is in

[@DarkRingKnux]

my personal thoughts on the knuckles show after watching it as soon as it came out: I quite literally loved that knuckles was snatching people from left and right, but I liked that they made sonic adventure references, yet there was so much potential with the show like make it so knuckles goes out and protects the master emerald like said, but even so I still think knuckles should've tried to find more secrets of his tribe, overall I hated what they did making wade literally protagonist cause paramount knew that if it was named wade, nobody would watch it.

[@bennygro8484]

Could you do a Character Analysis on Tikal?

[@omegaproductions6660]

I may strongly disagree but I respect your opinion

[@NolanSmashing-zz5oq]

When is that gamma character analysis coming out

[@supersonicstyle5177]

People really hate this show for some certain reasons, but i think that the entire sjow was nice and yeah, it wasted hell alot of potential to tell more about MOVIE knuckles and what he used to do in other planets, how did he manage to figure things out as a kid after he realised that his entire tribe is gone. But for me, i think that the show is FINE, it doesn't need to have all of that shit to be a good show, remember that this is sega and paramount not some bigger companies like sony or nintendo. There is specific budget and they have to work with it. I don't hate wade or anything about him (except his family) and i loved how he had this character development. And how he actually have some REAL battle experience not like what he used to be in the 2nd movie. The proplems with the show (atleast for me) is the wasted potential to introduce more characters or more places to the cinematic universe, the goofyness of chief pachamakamac (i can't spell his name) and the ending of the show. I felt they could've made a little teaser of the 3rd movie or show us how wade is actually being like a real professional cop and hang out with knuckles and shit like that.

[@An-Idiotlol]

36 seconds ago goes crazy

[@sml2withhuggy230]

I’m gonna make like a stop motion of the knuckles series but it’s gonna be different but in one scene it will make that knuckles remembered his tribe and what they would have done , and that’s how he would end the villan, I’m gonna release it on June 8

[@carolineneh2791]

Love your content man just subscribed Quick question Back in your video where you rate all the mainline Sonic games you said you'll do a special 50k subs video on how Sonic Heroes is your favourite game of all time And back in your Amy character analysis video you said you'll a character analysis video of E-102 Gamma Where are those videos and by the way I think Sega should hire you as a writer for the mainline Sonic games , Spinoff Games , And Comics

[@thepjshow]

Thank you so much for the kind words. I have been taking notes and trying to put together a script for my Sonic Heroes Video For a while now but I just want that video to be my best one. So I keep going over my thoughts, deleting stuff constantly and just going around in circles. But rest assured, it will be here as soon as possible. As for the E-102 Gamma video, I have yet to start planning out a script but I can't imagine that the video would be too long. I've got a lot of university work on my plate up until early august so unfortunately, I think content is going to still be a little slow. But I am definitely going to be working on them (sorry if that wasn't the answer you expected).

[@carolineneh2791]

@@thepjshow it's fine it was a bit scared maybe you cancelled them

[@ablosch2452]

Do you find it better or worse than Sonic Prime and Sonic Boom?

[@Peasham]

On the one hand, I'm loving people criticizing the movies by criticizing this show. On the other, I'm sad that no one's figured out how every complaint one might have about this show is something also present in the movies.

[@Deathwaddles]

Good video but your forgetting that the knuckles TV show was created during the Hollywood writers strike soo that's why we got what we got, but it still would've been cool if we got a knuckles TV show that goes more into his past and deeper into his tribe. guess we can't always get good things

[@KidGenesis-gd8ek]

Might be because of Ken Penders, so they tried to avoid a lot of things.

[@julianhinck5455]

chris was fine in the first season of sonic X.

[@theheroofreviews6630]

Hi The PJShow I did a review on the Knuckles show to, but yours is pretty good can your tell me what you think

[@Abner-gu3ve]

Seeing all the fans hating on this show while I honestly enjoyed is something I find hilarious 😂

[@Right_Bumper]

I really hope this doesn’t foreshadow the future of Knuckles as a marketing tool

[@WispyKelp]

I’m glad to hear that someone else is actually criticising it fairly. Me and my brothers were so excited for this show and when we watched it all together we were just disappointed. Yes there’s definitely things about the show I enjoyed, but honestly I didn’t like most of it, which sucks cause I wanted to love this show. After watching it, it made me nervous for Sonic 3 which is something I was super excited about

[@bukkyfabunmi-oshinor3263]

i think you weren't paying attention to Agent Willoughby's reason for capturing knuckles she warned Walters on the possibilities of what sonic tails and knuckles power might cause on Earth and thinks gun is being soft on them and i agree that the buyer was underutilized and wished he got more screentime and character

[@Kywriter475]

Another question, why is it a show?I feel like with some tweaking, it could’ve been a two hour film. Now if each episode was an hour long, that would make sense, but nope.

[@erikwillis2181]

I don't think those where bounty hunters in episode three I'm pretty sure they where the buyers henchmen. Also glad I like bowling so much.

[@garageislander4165]

Bowling the series & Knuckles.

[@donathan2933]

I liked the show ngl. I thought it was good silly fun and it didn’t seem like a series meant to be taken seriously. Yeah I wished Knuckles had more screen time but I still enjoyed what I saw

[@toraregisfurry]

you should do a team chaotix analysis lol

[@KoLJayDubb]

when u gonna become a sonic writer?

[@DanielKariuki-er5gi]

Imagine if they made a show about the movie versions of Tails or Shadow and it was 2d instead of live-action so the budget wouldn't be a problem because I don't think 2d cartoons are that expensive.

[@Pan-cackes]

The series is mediocre because of the bad writing. If you look closely, the first episode is very entertaining and shows Sonic's characters (and Knux himself) more than the rest. The reason? Different writer for each episode. Yes, each writer seemed to have an idea of ​​how the show was supposed to take place, which led to this weird thing. The series should have been written by Fowler, he worked for Shadow the Hedghehog and knows enough about Sonic to have made the first 2 films with his team. Even though the first one wasn't perfect, it presented Sonic and Eggman well and the second one was simply a big improvement over the first one. This is the reason why I think that nothing is lost, the team that makes the films is aware of the criticism and tries to improve.

[@Schwoomy]

we have to be real here, this show was very dishonestly marketed, look at any trailer and most of it was focused on Knuckles and the main bowling plot was nowhere to be seen, Paramount knew what the fans of the previous 2 movies would’ve wanted with a show titled “Knuckles”, so that’s all that they showed in the trailers, the only thing accurate about the show from the trailers was that it would be a show about Knuckles training Wade, but they knowingly made it look way more action oriented than it really was I really didn’t feel like the people who wrote this shows were Sonic fans in the way that I got the feeling that the writers of the movies were, at least there stuff like the pop culture references and amount of human scenes felt more like they were something the writers had to begrudgingly go along with because of some corporate mandate for mass appeal or for budget reasons, here it just didn’t feel like the people who wrote this even cared about the series (and they were different writers just to be clear, so I’m still not too worried about movie 3, but we’ll just have to see)

[@francespacheco8129]

I don't wanna be rude but... "The Shabbat Dinner" is my fave episode... Now the episode that wants to make me shoot myself is the "Flames of Disaster"... I still hate wanda with every fiber of my body tho. Also I would love a scene when knuckles gets back home and Maddie is pissed, that would actually bring some funny comedy... Or is that just me?

[@dragondelsur5156]

The very state of this show convinced me that this was only greenlit after Paramount saw how popular this version of Knuckles was, if anyone had a story they wanted to tell with this character, it was botched by this, the budget limits and fucking bowling. To me, the most infuriating part of it all is that it destroyed any chance at making Tikal the spirit guide. Thank you Pachacamac, you ruined your daughter yet again.

[@aha2384]

god the sheer and utter disappointment i felt knowing that such a bad show about knuckles, my all time favorite sonic character. turned out to be, like this, just some bowling featured comedy that should've focused on knuckles' grim past and his serious character arc, but no. everything in this show was horrible ASIDE, from knuckles himself. and we barely get to see him, it breaks my heart. my beloved echidna warrior deserves better than this, knuckles has been treated as a joke for over 15 years and the time when he's actually portrayed well, he ends up being featured in a show that's nothing but comedy filled with trash jokes and horrible writing, ugh.

[@DanielKariuki-er5gi]

6:14 KID CUDI!!! 😮😆

[@ignikatv1589]

Yeah, it's painful. I'll just pray, the next Movie will be better

[@walklytekel5713]

Here we were thinking we were gonna get rouge & got a fucking tv sitcom by episode 3

[@dragondelsur5156]

I was expecting Amy so I understand the disappointment.

[@NymphieJP]

I think the music scene had some Julian Barret influence. Check out the mighty boosh if you want to see more of that style of music/story telling lol I'd be really interested in seeing if it was his choice. It just feels like him.

[@skuffy4930]

I'm someone who has always preferred practical sets and effects to CGI, and how the opera scene is done honestly felt like Hollywood decided to rudely insult them and act like they're worse than making everything a computer generated blob. Way to go...

[@achilles1651]

The anime footage was from sonic x right, just so I have my references straight?

[@thepjshow]

Yeah, it's from Sonic X Episode 32

[@hopeshines632]

We wanted to know the way, but instead we got the wade.

[@justapotato1176]

didnt have high expectations but having most of the plot of a show about knuckles (literally the last echidna and guardian to the bloody master emerald) being about *bowling* is wild to me

[@DarkHeroesForever]

12:54 So you were okay with Rachel in the first movie? I mean you are entitled to your own opinion, but I always considered her the worst for pretty much the same reason why we all hate the Wanda. I know the second movie had that infamous wedding scene that in some ways redeem, but it comes at the cost of wishing it had it's own movie rather than feeling integral to the movie 2's plot, especially when she and the Randall character don't even interact with any of the Sonic characters.

[@thepjshow]

I think Rachel is a pretty meh character. I will admit she overstayed her welcome in the 2nd film, but at least, in some cases, her existence could lead to decent comedic moments. Like how in the first film, she was annoying, but it lead to funny interactions between Tom and Maddie. I cannot think of a single positive to Wanda no matter how hard I try.

[@DarkHeroesForever]

​​@@thepjshowFair enough I guess, but I feel like the biggest problem I had with Rachel which I feel the sequel amplifies is that she feels like a character that belongs in an entirely different genre of film. It's like when someone was writing the script for the first movie, they take a scene from a script of some random romcom and have it be copied and pasted to the first movie's script.

[@edikanessien8602]

Don't tell me they are gonna take Shadow large screentime in Sonic movie 3 and give it to some random human character we don't like including his own spinoff series, I want Shadow to be the main focus in the movie including his tv show like a John wick movie