ASOIAF Theory Iceberg Explored
55:50
Пікірлер
@Karlonstark
@Karlonstark Күн бұрын
Don’t you just love when d list asoiaf KZbinrs include their political opinions in their videos 🙄
@embel1213
@embel1213 Күн бұрын
man she keeps reiterating “14 year old child bride” to defend dany but then constantly dogs on Sansa for being a child bride and hostage also while dany was victimized by Drogo i don’t think it makes a difference to Mirri who views dany as her oppressor just the same as drogo, dany as khalissi is definitely in a position of power over the slaves in the khalassar
@JG-oi5gg
@JG-oi5gg 2 күн бұрын
Okay Varys is not villain-monologuing. He is speaking for the benefit of the mice/birds he knows must be listening. Qyburn has taken control of them and he is, of course, Cersei's man. It is part of Varys's goal to have an off-balance Cersei back in control without Kevan or Jaime to supoort her, much less Tyrion oe Tywin. And Cersei may well move Qyburn into the position of Hand and Grand Maester, while returning the role of Spider -- it would be like her!
@tiaanpienaar3858
@tiaanpienaar3858 2 күн бұрын
Wow so funny people thinking it is terrible without knowing how much skill it takes to create something as great vfx like that Like all the old men judging the sport athletes on there skills
@bensonfang1868
@bensonfang1868 3 күн бұрын
If her and Laenor were having trouble conceiving, I feel like reaching out to daemon and asking him to father the children would even be a better idea, as through his marriage to Laena, daemon now also has a vested interest in the power of house velaryon
@rushnafwadud
@rushnafwadud 3 күн бұрын
I’m a little surprised you’re worried about bad audio on some other project when it seems like you’re using AI in parts of your narration. “Pi-kyu” (or whatever it was? “Petire” (rhymes with “satire / satyr”? I’d be a bit disappointed if it were so. I like your accumulation (in football KZbin, they’re called “aggregators”), but hardly, if any of it is fresh, and your monotone does it no service. I think you work quite hard at this, so I mean no offence. I’d rather hoped you’d grow the channel into something a little more original, and continue to do so. Best of luck!
@rushnafwadud
@rushnafwadud 3 күн бұрын
PS. Again, friendly advice (from a non creator and someone who doesn’t take it all that seriously, so you really mustn’t mind me), but maybe don’t use memes? It doesn’t suit your style of stoic narration, which is what initially drew me to your channel. Cheers!
@ErikBjornSmith
@ErikBjornSmith 4 күн бұрын
I don't think the Others take Craster's sons because there are no women, but because there are no men. In ASOIAF, it's the men that go off to war and die, leaving the women and children behind. The Others seem to be able to live for hundreds of years, if not outright immortal, and if that is the case, they'd probably have a similar reproduction cycle to the Children of the Forest who live for hundreds of years and probably have children spread out over decades. If that's the case, the Others were probably left with very few men and children, needing people like Night's King and Craster to give up their sons to help repopulate their ranks. We only refer to the Others as men, because one of Craster's daughter-wives said they were. Someone may not have necessarily seen the Others, but aware that Craster gives his sons to them. We're assuming that because of what she said, they're all magically turned into what the Others look like, therefore assuming that there are no female others. I could be wrong and there are no female Others and the transformation is entirely magical, it is a fantasy. But I don't think that's entirely the case.
@Volgotha
@Volgotha 6 күн бұрын
So she was becoming a stoneman. Would the same thing have happened to Jorah? 🤔
@movieloverfan18
@movieloverfan18 7 күн бұрын
He always supports the Lannisters. I think I remember that Pycelle used to belong to a House in the Westerlands, before he became a Maester and gave up his last name. There was another that was supposed to be Grand Maester, but he died suddenly and then Pycelle got it. He also gave Jon Arryn high amounts of Milk of the Poppy so that he would pass easily instead of trying to save him with purging. Maybe he knew that Arryn knew about Cersei and Jaime and didn’t try too hard to save him.
@viperswhip
@viperswhip 8 күн бұрын
I am pretty sure there was a peace treaty between the Children and the Starks/humanity. I think the treaty said the North was for the Children and older races, while the South belonged to humanity. Hardhome becoming a city breached the treaty. Thus they were nuked.
@lisbette1731
@lisbette1731 8 күн бұрын
29:56 had me dead 💀 “they did die.”
@itsmia6521
@itsmia6521 9 күн бұрын
I have never seen anyone reach so goddamn hard. You are not pointing out the "terrible" cgi, you are nit picking. Hotd has still way better cgi than most high budget movies. Im also really dissapointed about your "in got the dragons have weight" argument. Have you even seen vhaggar taking of? Or her flying? Its by far the best cgi i have ever seen on a dragon. Please, start viewing other cgi the same way. You will notice that they ALL have similar issues. Because not every animator has the same level of talent. For example, in got, drogons face is very overanimated and it looks like hes out of jelly and uncanny. Something hotd fixed. But thats no reason to call the cgi terrible, because its a nitpick on a masterpiece.
@KevinHwoarang
@KevinHwoarang 9 күн бұрын
Varys getting startled by Shae when she sees through his glamour is such an important detail on who Shae ACTUALLY is.
@fuzonzord9301
@fuzonzord9301 10 күн бұрын
Fun fact: there's no chick a fil in Poland.
@Strangestthing1
@Strangestthing1 10 күн бұрын
I grew up in the 80s and 90s. Trust this CGI is not bad.
@fuzonzord9301
@fuzonzord9301 10 күн бұрын
Fascinating drama. Reminds me of the old case of Requires Hate.
@shara1979
@shara1979 11 күн бұрын
The jewels on his chain also show that he is bought
@fuzonzord9301
@fuzonzord9301 11 күн бұрын
The argument that Daenerys was only 14 is interesting taking into account that she ordered to slaughter any master who was over 12. So, somehow she was helpless but teenagers were guilty for system into which they were born into weren't?
@fuzonzord9301
@fuzonzord9301 11 күн бұрын
Whiteness is historically relevant in context of racist slavery and colonialism. Poland is a central-eastern European country with its own history. I generally avoid interacting with the locals during last decade or so because they want me dead for being disabled, but from what I remember, such a thing as "white identity" in Poland doesn't exist outside of actual neo-nazi groups. The larger ethnic identity of Poles is Slavic and it's mostly contrasted with Germanic. Poland was occupied by Russia, Prussia and Austria during whole XIXth century, starting in in 1772 with complete occupation starting in 1795 when it stopped existing as a state, was re-established in 1918 and then invaded and occupied for 6 years by Nazi Germany and Soviet Union in 1939 and then until 1989 by Soviet Union. Also, Poland had it's own internal system of slavery which was serfdom with its own racial theories where nobles were descendants of ancient Sarmatians and peasants were descendants of Ham. In fact the Curse of Ham which was originally considered to be justification for serfdom in Europe was later recycled in justifying keeping black people as slaves in America. So for Poland main relationship to slavery was serfdom which was abolished only in XIXth century and also Tatar raids which kidnapped locals and sold them into Ottoman slavery and use of slave labour by Nazi germany and Soviet Union.
@pearljammies
@pearljammies 12 күн бұрын
daenerys: -usurps ruling powers in slavers bay while despising the usurper & all who have worked with him/them -calls & considers the Freedmen her children, which is completely infantilizing them & refusing to see then as full autonomous human beings & adults, essentially considering them less than, which is the same type of worldview that enables enslavement -refuses to go back and fight for the freedmen once she’s in meereen, despite knowing they are being brutalized & reenslaved AND facing the white mare. Also, isn’t there irony in the face that the argument Dany fans make that she is powerless & enslaved is actually diminishing her and her power? Like…they’re reducing her to be less than / weaker than she is. That’s weird.
@sit-insforsithis1568
@sit-insforsithis1568 13 күн бұрын
22:38 holy racism Batman 1:04:24 younABSOLUTELE bodied her bro
@ZachDift-kc4nk
@ZachDift-kc4nk 13 күн бұрын
If those worm creatures had human like faces and hands then my theory is that she went to Southoryos - and more specifically, she was taken to Gogossos. First, why would she go to Sothoryos? Bc there was a female dragon rider who is claimed to be the only person who flew over Sothoryos farther than anyone else - no doubt a girl like Aerea had heard tales of this adventurous female dragon rider and saw her as her idol and wanted to follow in the footsteps of her idol and hero. Second, why Gogossos? The dragonlords used it as a penal colony for the worst criminals of Valyria and the prisoners were tortured with in various ways including with blood magic where slave women were forced to mate with beasts to produce twisted, half-human offspring. So that’s why I’m curious to know whether those worms’ faces that killed Aerea could in any way be described as humanoid. It would also explain why these religious men treating her aka the Septons immediately eliminated all traces and evidence of this form of evil, sick and twisted blood magic by destroying all traces of those worms - they can’t allow anyone to get any kind of ideas (such as someone like Qyburn) Gogossos grew powerful through slavery and sorcery during the Century of Blood, with some calling it the "Tenth Free City" and its slave markets rivaled those of the cities in Slaver's Bay. However, after the Doom of Valyria, the Red Death emerged from the slave pens of Gogossos and 90% of people died from the plague. This red death disease is different from whatever happened to Aerea but it shows that there’s all kinds of messed up diseases that come out of Sothoryos and especially the region around Gogossos and was one of the reasons the enslaved criminals of Gogossos would rather stay and take their chances with torture, being worked to death and being experimented on with blood magic than risk going out into the wild where even a worse fate awaited them. I think that’s the wilderness that Aerea somehow ended up being dropped off by Balerion into or landing in and then she somehow got infected.
@leedleen9034
@leedleen9034 14 күн бұрын
Yea then he was driven back to Castle Black.. But maybe it will have a story afterwards in the books..
@ciano9535
@ciano9535 16 күн бұрын
Varys is maegor he was castrated as part of the ritual at summer hall
@robstewartstewart98
@robstewartstewart98 16 күн бұрын
As a Sansa fan….well I’m definitely for some version of an ending with Sansa doing well in a position of great power! (Queen in the North!) To use this flimsy excuse to Segway…… Regarding the show, while I have my own ideas of the could have dones (and fan fic to end ASOIAF) I think the following are some of my main in retrospect pointers: - early on, I’m not sure if it is unfair to expect the showrunners to figure out that the Bravvos arc might be something to cut out. Early enough to not bother having a Faceless man in season 2. But I’d definitely have Arya and the Hound teamup with Brieanne and Pod. - have lady Stoneheart - don’t bother with Robert Strong/return of Gregor at all. - bronn should not return to the story after season 4. - have the Tysha reveal, and Varys staying in Kings Landing - have the full valenqar prophecy - kill Varys and Baelish in season 5 - if you are going for a simplified Dorne arc, have Arys Oakenheart sneak into Dorne to get Myrcella, the Sand Snakes not planning revenge, but really, really angry, Ellaria gives a version of her book speech, and Arys accidentally kills Myrcella - be MUCH more willing to use, explore, and explain what magic is and how is works in this setting - don’t have Dany return to the Dothraki Sea - Have the reveal Tyrion is a secret Targaryen - Jorah should die in Essos - Bran should arrive at Winterfell at the end of season 6. R+L=J is revealed, Jon is proclaimed King, and takes the name Stark. - if you are going to use time travel, figure out ways to not have it make the choices of the characters who are not Bran meaningless. - However you wish, arrange for the destruction of Kings Landing before Dany returns to Westeros, and have her go to White Harbor. - Both battles of Winterfell should be meat grinders. Between the two of them, most of the important secondary characters should end up dead. - Brieanne should be one of those who die in the second Battle of Winterfell. Have Jaime learn of the prophecy, and make the rest of his arc struggling with it (however it ends up). - however you arrange it, have an ending where: . Jon is not King . Dany is not Queen . They are not married to each other, or Dany is pregnant with a dead Jon’s child. . Bran is “on top” (this doesn’t even have to mean he has the formal title of King)
@ciano9535
@ciano9535 16 күн бұрын
He could be maegor targaryen, son of aurion brightflame born in 232 making him 68 in the books
@YwY-ct5yq
@YwY-ct5yq 17 күн бұрын
Its probably some sort of Valyrian fire wyrm experiment that was melded with human genes... And given this, the whispers that were so horryfying to the septons were probably of how the creature impregnated her...
@jonsnow943
@jonsnow943 17 күн бұрын
Sansa is Queen of the North and Riverlands until Robs will comes out then she marries Harry the Heir and brings in the Vale. Harry also could have a claim on the North
@Wolf-bz6kq
@Wolf-bz6kq 18 күн бұрын
I believe that who the community call Faegon is indeed Aegon. The mummer part in Mummer's Dragon is reference to Varys. Prophecies and visions are vague and Vary's machinations are more in favor of Aegon than Daenarys.
@porneliushubertsthaicuisin1316
@porneliushubertsthaicuisin1316 19 күн бұрын
Burnt bones prove nothing
@luvprue1
@luvprue1 20 күн бұрын
I believe that Tyrion is Tywin true born son. His only son, and Tywin knows that, which is why Tyrion got Ty in his name.
@ErinMcIntyre-cw2qc
@ErinMcIntyre-cw2qc 20 күн бұрын
@SikhiJedi
@SikhiJedi 21 күн бұрын
They are harassing you, just block and move on. They are harassing you online, well the digital space allows you ignore someone. It’s yourself who looks for conflict online, ignore and move on
@KevinPendragon
@KevinPendragon 21 күн бұрын
I did ignore and block them
@SikhiJedi
@SikhiJedi 21 күн бұрын
I think you are blowing things out of proportion and you are becoming her. Just leave things alone move on with life, stops starting drama bro
@rainyleefa1984
@rainyleefa1984 22 күн бұрын
I disagree with most of your theories and observations but I give you props for the work you put into this video all the same.
@MarijaJevtic-qg9fv
@MarijaJevtic-qg9fv 22 күн бұрын
Dune sandwoms
@eoghanclark165
@eoghanclark165 22 күн бұрын
Balerion likely died due to becoming weakened by the same red worm parasites that Princess Aerea became infested with, not old age. I daresay Cannibal could very much still be alive.
@user-luciddream
@user-luciddream 23 күн бұрын
My issue with the ways they apply feminist analysis to asoiaf is its very shallow. They do not care about the material circumstances of women and how that might drive their behaviour. They have no understanding or sympathy for what the common experience of a woman in that world would be like, in fact they don't even believe lowborn lives have any value period. Their feminist analysis includes no intersectionality. Women can infact inflict harm on others in regards to race, class etc which is something that you can criticise every single character on, including Daenerys. You can argue "well its just a fictional story so who cares" but if they can insult others and assume their politics then why can't I reverse it and throw it back at them? In fact I think the reason their takes are so bad is because they are incapable of viewing these characters as solely fictional.
@robstewartstewart98
@robstewartstewart98 23 күн бұрын
8:04-9:13 YES! YES! I KEEP SAYING THIS ONLINE! I....kinda get pushback when I try to interpret Jon's role this way.
@user-luciddream
@user-luciddream 23 күн бұрын
don't agree with some of your points (i believe her “love” for drogo is a trauma response to cope with her circumstances and i dont want to argue about it) but dany/targ super fans are all so annoying with major victim complexes. you would think these characters were real with how personally attacked they feel by these discussions. "how dare you say my fav fictional character has flaws! if you don't think dany is perfect then youre stupid and illiterate and wrong!" YAWN.
@RayOpp1
@RayOpp1 23 күн бұрын
Varys is the many faced gods assassin if they had a sleeper cell
@seastar4194
@seastar4194 24 күн бұрын
Come or the theories, stay for the kick ass beat downs! Keep up the good work Kevin!
@fabriziomeschini4337
@fabriziomeschini4337 24 күн бұрын
lmao that's not what is meant by 'gardener writer'. Get out.
@jessjess23brooks89
@jessjess23brooks89 25 күн бұрын
Man, Cersei so crazy and extra. "I think we should use a Baratheon cloak at the wedding, for appearances and luck." Cersei: I can't wait to kill you.
@xavier84623
@xavier84623 25 күн бұрын
Weirwood arrows might actually counter dragons in some way similar to dragon glass and others.
@xavier84623
@xavier84623 25 күн бұрын
I thought this video was going to be about a new theory of how the curse of harrenhall is due to magical radiation build up from all the dragon flame.
@jewels6944
@jewels6944 26 күн бұрын
It's olyver frey Squire of robb
@KevinPendragon
@KevinPendragon 26 күн бұрын
Isnt he at the Rosby castle?
@Lord_Taron_Texas
@Lord_Taron_Texas 27 күн бұрын
@KevinPendragon how's it going today Ser? Take me a minute to find this video but I have a theory about this myself first I want you to make sure you tell your cousin Arthur Pendragon that I said "what's up My Round Table Homie?"... I do not believe for a second that the third Queen is the queen of thorns herself... I believe it is some foreshadowing that has already been kind of coming towards the light and it may be the last step in some other foreshadowing that is crashing into the previous foreshadowing to activate the theory that I'm fixing to lay out on you and that is that's a third Queen is....... Princess Arrienne Martell!! Because she obviously kept bringing up in that sample chapter she was in for the Winds of Winter she kept asking about Viserys, and knowing he did she was curious about that then she saw the master whispers for the golden company and thought he was like a Targaryen and thought he was ugly and then obviously she's going to see young Chris AKA aegon .. I say I say...blackfyre I believe him to actually be she sees him and sees he's a come with youth that's tall and motley intelligent who happens to be related to her somewhat closely but not really but also she's had the itch to marry a Targaryen ever since she heard about the beggar King and her wedding alliance so she goes ahead and does something without consulting her father and then I'm sure aegon blackfyre is going to do something crazy also even after talking to John connington and having John tell him know you need to save your marriage for Daenerys ...he's going to end up doing it anyway because it's not coming to westeros fast enough for him, and we just so happen to have a princess Martell there who desperately wanted to be married to a King and wants to have more power than she's already going to receive because obviously she has a power-hungry vacuum inside of her stomach LOL so it would make perfect sense for her to become The unwanted third queen that John connington tries to talk aegon out of doing but he does anyway because he's young and stupid like all of us was at one point and then Arienne lol we all know she has bad decision making issues and also impulse control problems lol so even if she talked to her dad or not she's still going to do it whether he approved or not I'm sure so cuz there's been too much talking about and foreshadowing over weddings and marriages and alliances to conquer the kingdom and how they need dorne and all that shit Plus on top of all of that ignore every bit of those reasons and here's the main reason this would make cersei extra paranoid and extra crazy and make her go further off the edge because now she doesn't know which beautiful queen is actually supposed to replace her.... Lol instead of thinking she has it all figured out and maybe solving the problem with Margorie now all of a sudden a second Queen comes out of the woodworks who's more beautiful than cersei and she doesn't know which one is actually the one that's supposed to replace her and bring this chain reaction of hers to life that Maggie the frog head you know spun out for her so yeah if anything that's enough reason alone for it to be another young beautiful queen lol Sorry I know that's long and I know I made a lot of jokes in there and cracked a lot of jokes but same time I'm pretty sure my theory solid. Let me know what you think
@KevinPendragon
@KevinPendragon 26 күн бұрын
I considered Arianne as well. I think Arianne is the younger more beautiful queen from Cersei's prophecy. But I don't think she's the 3rd qeen. LF would have to know about Young Griff to make the connection and I don't think he knows about Young Griff. I do think Arianne will be queen but it will be a shock to her and LF as well
@Lord_Taron_Texas
@Lord_Taron_Texas 26 күн бұрын
@@KevinPendragon I don't know man I feel like a little finger knows a little bit more than most people would ever even think I mean I feel like he's got some overreaching people out there telling him s***.... Plus I feel like you may be getting info from the queen of thorns or hell even Willas Tyrell.... I would go so far is the even say that if let's say darkstar fleas dorne either before or even after they come to find him there at the beginning of Winds of Winter whether he just leaves before they find him or there's a battle and he wins and fleas I wouldn't be surprised at single bit if Dark Star showed up at the bloody gate asking the knight of the bloody gate if he can pass because he has come to see little finger lol I mean I wouldn't be surprised one bit if Little fingers talks to Prince Doran or DarkStar on the Reg. Is I mean they all all of them specially The Prince and Littlefinger they all have a lot of double-dealing back door dealing and secret dealing going on more than a spider web of that connected together then it's even probably known in the books yet it's just surprises waiting to come out
@defAngel
@defAngel 28 күн бұрын
Hahaha you spent as much time on the Quentyn theory as it deserved. I’ve always hated that theory. lol
@KevinPendragon
@KevinPendragon 27 күн бұрын
I despise it so much lol