20 DARKEST Harry Potter Theories (MEGA COMPILATION)

[@leviosa5405]

Lily’s parents being killed would further explain Petunia’s hatred for Lily and the Wizarding world.

[@DjDoomtrain]

She was just Jelly in the belly

[@dunpik]

yeah she was jealous, she even wrote a letter to albus where she asked if she could also go to hogwarts, albus said no B)

[@johnramirez5996]

If her parents were muggles. How did they learn of Hogwarts? This school wouldn't have been known to them. So how could you be proud of Lily getting her Hogwarts letter if you weren't supposed to ever know it existed? They either knew magic or were squibs .

[@evapunk522]

​@@johnramirez5996 They don't have to know. Hermione's parents didn't know until Hermione got her letter. The Ministry & the school just know because their magic tells them who is muggle born.

[@Contessology]

Perfect timing, going to bed rn

[@HarryPotterTheory]

Enjoy!

[@enragedgoop]

Sleep tight. 😘

[@rjhenderson1541]

NGL lie; this guys voice is so soothing. Since I’ve seen all the videos he’s made, which are outstanding, so I usually put one of these on to help me sleep

[@BeefyPhill]

lol same

[@geoffstwitter]

Same

[@barbiquearea]

My hypothesis for what happened to Lily's parents was that they died in a car accident. Either the Death Eaters used magic to cause it to happen, or it was a unrelated tragedy. Either way, it still counts as a very "muggle" way to die. And I presume Petunia could have worked it into her lie about how James and Lily lost their lives, such as telling Harry that parents were in the car with his grandparents when it happened.

[@HeraldOfChaos76]

Oh crap and that would be the brilliant reason why petunia and Vernon said that James and Lily died in a car crash they already had the story planned out flawlessly through the death of their own parents 😳 not going to lie this seems pretty good I lost my books a long time ago but this seems like a pretty solid theory

[@barbiquearea]

I'm certain that if Dumbledore explained the necessity of keeping Harry with the Dursleys for his own protection, Sirius would have understood. In fact, it might have been better if Sirius was around because then he could be there to keep an eye on Harry and stop the Dursleys from abusing him. And having uncle Sirius checking up on little Harry from time to time and providing him with presents would have been good for his mental well being growing up. I think the reason Albus did not help Sirius is because he genuinely thought he was guilty. He had lost his mind and was in no capacity to explain himself, and even his memories would have looked like a scrambled egg and impossible even for a legiliman like Albus to decipher. This may have been the reason he did not stand trial because he was in no condition to do so. This and the fact that his last name was Black and most of his family were on Voldemort's side really didn't help his case.

[@teacookieYT]

I agree. I don’t think Dumbledore would do something so cruel as to torture an innocent man just to keep his plan in place. And I can also believe he didn’t take the effort to look into it further because Sirius never fought back against his sentence, as he’d stated, due to his guilt. If Sirius genuinely expressed that they had the wrong man, I very well imagine Dumbledore would’ve had a little chat with him.

[@SingingSealRiana]

Sirius is not a man of reason and no he wpuld not have allowed harry to be abused like he was. He also would have nwver raised harry as somwone devoid of self worth so he would gladly walk to hia own death to safe the only home he ever had..... Dumbledore knew of the abuse in detail, it made him angry but he allowed it cause it served the greater good. Sirius would have raised harry to be arrogant and selfimportent like himself

[@didreams969]

the owner of the ‘hair’ has to be from a live human..that’s why madeye was kept alive in the trunk

[@CaptainSherbertTheQuestionable]

My big thing with the love potion theory is that it is clear she didn't give him one but that it did affect harry in a way that pushed him towards the relationship. In the books during slughorns first lesson they cover a love potion that smells like things you are attracted to. Harry smells something familiar but can't place it. Since he wasn't outright attracted to ginny quite yet my best guess was that it was the smell of the burrow. Later on though ginny walked past him and he noticed the smell off of her. From that point on he essentially decided that it meant he loved her. Although he had been slowly starting to notice her more and more, it was that connection mase from the smell that really pushed it forward. So to me, he was affected by a love potion but not from drinking it.

[@lynmurray4331]

I don't think there was any love potion involved. He was friends with her and became more and more attracted to her very much the way my Dad ended up marrying the sister of his best friend.

[@CaptainSherbertTheQuestionable]

@@lynmurray4331 I am not saying she gave it to him it was moreso association to the smell. I am not saying that it wouldn't have happened otherwise but it was a definite nudge. He smelt the burrow and obviously she smells like it. So when he noticed she smells like the thing he loves most, it definitely had an impact.

[@SingingSealRiana]

Yeah it was kinda a factor

[@lynmurray4331]

When Fudge is talking to the muggle prime minister at the beginning of book 6, he mentions that the dementors are breeding and that is the cause of the cold weather and mist that summer.

[@MarchingArrow]

And I can never un-know it 🙂

[@zacharyscott6779]

Dumbledore didnt know Sirius was innocent and only found out once Lupin and everyone else discovered the truth. I wouldn't be surprised if he had an idea, but didnt know for certain. Peter was able to fool absolutely everyone.

[@SingingSealRiana]

But he cpuld have lnown, heknew siriis and he was one of thw nost powerful mindreaders, it wpuld have been easybit it did npt served him so why bother...

[@saphiramystique2086]

Here is my dark theory, and it's about something I never see anyone bring up. But, I think Sirius wasn't the only one imprisoned in Azkaban for a crime they didn't commit. Sirius tells Harry in GOF that he wasn't the only one sent to Azkaban without a trial, he also tells Harry that most people there gave up and died after a year. Barty Crouch Sr had become worthless when fighting against Death Eaters in the first war, he stopped giving most people trials and started having people (like he did with Sirius) taken straight to Azkaban, he even allowed Aurors to use the Unforgivable Curses (something Sirius also says in GOF). So, I believe there is a chance Azkaban had more innocent people than Sirius locked up in there, and I don't mean any of the Death Eaters that broke out in OOTP were innocent when locked up, I mean ones that didn't break out and were left in there because Voldemort or whoever broke the Death Eaters out aren't going to bother with prisoners who aren't Voldemort’s followers, or maybe some of the ones that's just gave up were innocent people.

[@gingerkays7362]

In “Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them” (the reference book, not the movie), Newt Scamander poses the theory that Dementors are mutated Lethifolds. Lethifolds resemble a cloak on the ground, they physically suffocate their prey (whereas Dementors emotionally suffocate), and the only known defence against one is the Patronus charm

[@daandekok3899]

29:17 isn’t it a way better explanation that Ron is a teenage boy with no experience with women. Who gets kissed by a girl and is like ‘oh that’s cool, let’s do that more often’. Ron never shows the effects of a love potion. He just shows the hormone driven actions you’d expect of a boy his age

[@winterrain1947]

exactly my thought.

[@lardman7667]

My version of the Dumbledore leaving Black in prison is that he wanted to have more control over Potter's upbringing in order to "optimize" him for fighting Riddle. Black would have probably tried to provide him with a normal childhood and might have kept him from some of the dangers in the books.

[@josecuestas7246]

@@lardman7667 Yeah, especially as Dumbledore had a lot influence in the Ministry, making strange that he didn't bother in gives Sirius Black a proper trial to proves his innocence. Implying that he did this intentionally, to kept more control over Harry's life, and to further uses him for his plans to defeat Voldemort, regardless the consequences for others.

[@mya1999]

Definitely it is made so incredible clear at least in the books that, Sirius Black was never easy to control and therefore expendable according to dumbledore

[@lexiibattwitch]

What if it isn't an expendability issue, but a liability issue? If Sirius raised Harry, Harry would've been spoiled and had an ego like Sirius. He wouldn't have had the necessary traits to defeat Voldemort in the first place.

[@josecuestas7246]

So, Dumbledore had other possible secret reason to makes that Harry was living with the Dursleys besides the Blood wards; to makes him more controllable and a better pawn, to turn Harry in a "cattle for slaughterhouse", "for the greater good." Well, this is still messed, because even if this served to defeated Voldemort, this proved that Dumbledore isn't a hero nor even a good man, he is actually an anti-villain, as he is capable to consider amoral and controversial choices, to stop a far more destructive evil.

[@lexiibattwitch]

@@josecuestas7246 oh no, he had dark triad traits out the ass. He was a sociopathic manipulator at all moments. It's a very interesting psychology to consider.

[@ericwhite1942]

As to the love potion theroys. I don't think any of them hold up. When Harry first becomes interested in Jenny, he doesn't act on it at first because of his concern with how Ron would react. Ron was 100% focused on winning the quidech game and only went to kiss whatshername when she approached him. However, when we see Ron fall under a love potion meant for Harry, he becomes totally obsessed with this girl he never meets and even attacks Harry, his best friend, when he suggests he's being foolish.

[@SingingSealRiana]

Also qhen he smells the love portion he was not yet all that aware of ginny, so he associates it with thw burrow until she walks by and herecognises the lovepotions smell as hers. So a lovepotion i directly has him think of her as the ideal partner, withput him having drunk any. Tjat the romancw fwwls qeird and to fast tp many is cause jk sucks at writing romance

[@winterrain1947]

LOL what she wrote for Ron and Lavendar about summed up teen romance perfectly. No love potions were involved between those two.

[@rebekah4761]

A normal muggle death could have been the car crash that was rumored about Harry's parents. It just means non-magical.

[@JennyShull]

If the Harry Potter Books were all in Harry’s head: •are the people in his fantasy world real people? •Was Voldemort a real person? •Were Neville’s parents really tortured and driven mad? •did all of Harry’s grandparents die? •did Harry’s parents actually die in a car crash? Where was Harry when it happened? •Did Harry actually have friends? •Did Harry actually go to the school for mis behaving kids? •Why did the Dursleys take in Harry instead of dropping him off at an orphanage? •Did something happen to Hermiones parents? Did Hermione run away from home and live with Ron’s family? •Was the Knight bus just a normal double decker bus? •Did the Dursleys and Harry really go on a trip away from home to escape something to with Harry?

[@vanguardanon4979]

The bertha jorkins thing makes so much and how something so horrid would have be used for the body potion

[@ADHD_and_Crayons]

I've had a dark theory about Dumbledore since the beginning..... here's the short/long of it: Dumbledore knew how horrid the Dursleys are, which is why he placed Harry there. You see, Dumbledore knew that if Harry was raised in the wizarding world (even by the Weasley's) that Harry had the potential to grow a bit of an ego, from being popular & wealthy...... an ego that could match Voldemort's. Dumbledore knew that if Harry was raised in a way that made him never view the Dursley's home as "his home" then Harry would unequivocally fight for Hogwarts & the wizarding world. I believe if Harry was raised in the wizarding world that he would have ended up accepting a Slytherin placement, instead of running from it....... Draco became the new Dudley, so of course Harry would want no part of him, including the Hogwarts House he was placed into..... Harry would have definitely met Draco if he was raised in the wizarding world, so it probably would not have been enough of a deterrent to deny Slytherin. TL;DR -- Dumbledore specifically placed Harry in a home that would mentally abuse him his entire life, in order for Harry to become the exact opposite of Voldemort (which would ultimately become the key to end Voldemort).

[@codered3009]

That’s such a great theory x

[@Reckoning2943]

I agree with Dumbledore’s need to keep Harry alive but I don’t agree with the mental abuse. It is even stated in the books that Dumbledore chose to leave him there as best option because of his aunt. The blood wards, or the magic that Lily used to protect Harry would continue as long he lived with a blood relative. With death eaters and the exact whereabouts of Voldemort unknown, it was Dumbledore’s best option to shelter him from the wizarding world so that word would about Harry’s whereabouts would not get around. It was a kill two birds with one stone situation. Also, it doesn’t make much sense to say he did it for mental “abuse”. Prior to Harry’s arrival, there were no signs of them being anywhere near hateful or abusive, they were just incredibly bland, unpleasant people who loved their son Dudley. There were no indications of their later mistreatment. It can be presumed that Dumbledore knew that they weren’t the greatest people but he was mostly unaware of the extend of their abuse, as seen in their way of contacting Harry about his enrollment in Hogwarts. The man, in his ignorance, had most likely no idea.

[@agnieszkabatyra4332]

Makes sense!

[@Slimreaper3000]

What is interesting is Voldemort grew up similarly away from the wizarding world

[@Mukation]

This is exactly what he says to McGonnagal in the first book/movie. There were hundreds of wizard families that gladly would have adopted Harry and raised him with love (including Weasleys) but there was also the fact that Petunia was Lilly's sister: Lilly's love protected Harry as long as he lived with Petunia, which even Petunia knew (at one point were Harry was about to be thrown out by Vernon, Petunia gets a letter from Dumbledore and she simply tells Vernon that the boy stays.).

[@RobertLydonReviews]

I stand by point I’ve made before that Petunia is one of the worst characters in HP as she abused a small boy for years. However didn’t Petunia’s jealousy and hatred towards lily start because she was a witch? If lily wasn’t a witch their relationship wouldn’t have been ruined by jealousy.

[@pimpdobby2675]

the love potion theory is bogus, he watches ginny at hogwarts while hiding in the horcrux hunt, at which point the love potion would be well out of his system

[@jcarver69]

Also, if he was given a love potion, he would never have left to hunt the horcruxes anyway they simply wouldn't have mattered to him. Look at how Ron reacted when he accidently ate some nothing mattered, but the girl.

[@cam-yf3ix]

ikr they are going off films not books :/

[@Slimreaper3000]

@@jcarver69Ron had expired love potion though

[@talia8493]

@@Slimreaper3000not expired. The book said it grows more potent overtime so it was stronger, not expired

[@julianivanov1139]

also thematically it’s bogus! the whole idea about why voldemort is evil’s because his mom used a love potion to ensnare tom riddle - so he was conceived without love. although now that i write that maybe it would be poetic if one of harry’s kids with ginny is the new voldemort because they also were conceived in a loveless marriage lol

[@manuelbartoli9394]

I think the creepiest above all these dark theories is the one which evaluates Dumbledore’s hypothetical plan to turn Harry into an obscurial to use him as a weapon against Voldemort, as his beloved Grindelwald has done with his grandson Credence against him.

[@untitled6391]

Holy jeebus

[@TheFreelancer131]

There's ALWAYS a Theory About Oh it's a dream oh it's all not real oh there actually dead. These types of "theory's" are Extremely low hanging fruit and should be dismissed instantly any story that would ever Employ such a stupid Stunt is no story worth Reading/Watching. It's Low Brow in the extreame.

[@rodneyquinn2528]

Dumbledore couldn't read peoples minds, snape himself said the muggle view of leginimancy is the ability to read people's minds, and that's a poor description. It's the ability to see into ones minds and memories thought of at that current moment. And occlumency is the ability to shield it. Snape was the most powerful occlument. Tom riddle as a youth was a powerful occlumence. And the fact is even Lupin thought Sirius did it. Dumbledore didn't know and wouldn't have been able to

[@andrzejzborowski4920]

Sirius never wanted to defend himself, so why anyone wanted to reveal the truth? After Pettigrew killed those muggels the day after Voldemort had vanished Sirius was standing by the hole in the ground and laughed like a mental person. He never asked to meet Dumbledore to tell him the truth. But the weird thing is that some Death Eaters in Azkaban knew that Pettigrew was on Voldemort's side but they never told this to anyone. Perhaps they were treated like mental as well.

[@Didymus20X6]

Edinburgh. I've been there a few times. Say hello to that crazy drunken movie critic, and tell him I said "GO AWAY NAUOW!!"

[@Dayth_]

13:23 I always thought Dementors were a tool for Dark wizards with a horcrux. What if they lacked a foe or a willing servant? The Dementor's Kiss could provide a souless vessel for them to inhabit.

[@hiddentruth1982]

theory polyjuice potion doesn't require hair to complete. You can use any part of a person but the hair is the easiest to get but yields the weakest results with organs yielding the strongest results. Only the version with hair is taught because you could actually replace a person with stronger, longer lasting versions.

[@barbiquearea]

True. Its basically the same principle of extracting a DNA sample from someone from virtually any body part. But hair is just the easiest way.

[@psychxticrose]

This isn't a theory. You can literally use anything. Hair is just the most common because it's the easiest to get

[@josecuestas7246]

In my opinion, as theory, Dumbledore was the true antagonist of the franchise, because if you analyzes, he was involved in many shady aspects, starting with the creation of the Dark lords, Grindelwald and Voldemort. - Grindelwald. Because he encouraged the ambitions of his old pal, leading to that Grindelwald started his plans for his Revolutions. - Voldemort. Dumbledore was aware from the darkness within Tom, yet, he was passive to gives him support and avoid that Tom was walking in the dark path, leading him to become lord Voldemort. Without count that Dumbledore was manipulating and controlling the life of Harry since the beginning, starting to forces him to lives with the Dursleys, a very abusive family and bigots toward the magic, only for the blood wards, despite to has a cruel childhood. Adding that Dumbledore was always keeping secrets from Harry, leading him to get exposed to dangers in Hogwarts, only to accomplishes his personal plans, even if this ended implying put in jeopardize others, and that occured casualties, like Cedric Diggory and Sirius Black. And even if his strategy allowed stop Voldemort in the end, Dumbledore isn't a good man either, as he clearly applies the logic, "The end justifies the means", showing that he isn't a hero as the people and the story itself tried to portrays him, but he is simply a pragmatic man capable to consider morally questionable choices, only to acomplishes his objectives, even if this implies some consequences for innocent people, thus making him like a hidden antagonist in the franchise.

[@markkim1356]

> Dumbledore was aware from the darkness within Tom, yet, he was passive to gives him support and avoid that Tom was walking in the dark path, leading him to become lord Voldemort. the whole slughorn's memory arc basically confirms that dumbledore had very little clue about tom venturing into dark magic and/or dumbledore could've given him some leeway due to his troubled childhood. i'd imagine a pragmatic person like dumbledore would've kept eyes on young tom if he realised he was going off.

[@josecuestas7246]

@@markkim1356 As comparison of Dumbledore with Voldemort, is just like Obi Wan with Darth Vader, in the sense of a mentors that failed in guided their students for the right path, leading to that Tom Riddle and Anakin Skywalker ended walking in the dark path, turning them in Voldemort and Darth Vader. And even if their falling to Dark side was caused by several reasons, since their childhoods, Dumbledore and Obi Wan can be also blamed for this outcome, for failed in understand better the inner issues of their studends, and help them properly to faces their inner demons, causing the creation of a monsters that threated the Wizarding world and the Galaxy.

[@blake7587]

The whole “It was all a dream” theories are the dumbest and laziest theories because you can say it about anything.

[@aglez-vj9dg]

He used to read Word Up magazine

[@shuehall4996]

Theory about Ginny and Harry, she used love potions. I don’t agree with that.

[@ufuksogut6960]

Yeah very poor theroy

[@vivianp5962]

Cool & your theory on the possibility of poly juice potion is TRUE :)

[@travisvanalst4698]

The “imagination” theory for Harry doesn’t pan out. If his parents died in a car crash he would have been with them. Not many parents leave a baby that age with people. Especially knowing that the grand parents were dead so there really would be no one to leave him with as we know the Dursleys don’t want him. I have two kids and with our first child my wife didn’t want her sleeping at someone else’s house or staying there like at all in my daughter’s first year. It seems like someone just wants to make a psychological reason for a fictional story. When 9/10 times psychological issues are blown way out of proportion and blamed for things happening, instead of just enjoying a fake story.

[@stacijezewski6367]

i love harry potter but the theorys don't stop

[@newhybrid101]

Lets go guys

[@demonscarecrow91]

Avada kedavra roughly translates to: I destroy as I speak. Abra kedabra roughly translates to: I create as I speak. The two are more like opposites rather than one being a bastardisation of the other.

[@tysongrey5823]

There's one problem with the voldamort polly Juice potion theory. Doesn't that potion take 6months to brew. Or something like that.

[@lj1210]

One month. Also, Polyjuice Potion can only be made from a living person. That's why Barty Crouch Jr. kept Mad Eye Moody alive in a trunk for the entire school year instead of killing him.

[@eamonlyons8069]

Everyone talks about lily's parents but James'? I think they were both murdered.

[@rebeccatekahika4931]

I thought it was dragon pox

[@Didymus20X6]

27:33 - "BLOSSOMED!" I see what you did there.

[@JCardo2502]

I disagree on the love potion, the writers of the movies just didn´t know how to write any other female that wasn´t Hermione or they just simply didn´t want to, they loved their Mary Sue Hermione

[@bobbyrayvictory6905]

A Mary Sue is someone who hasn't earned their skill. I'm not sure that applies to even the film Hermione. If anything I feel like she was nerfed in the movies. If anything, she's a maguffin. She just always has the special spell or book that's needed just at the right moment

[@retsaMinnavoiG]

Hermione was not a Mary Sue... I'm not sure if you understand what a Mary Sue is. It's a young female that's good at everything for no reason, masculine traits rather than feminine traits and has no real flaws or moments of weakness. Hermione has to sacrifice a lot to learn what she knows (for instance she is rundown and tired in the third movie because of the time turner) and we see her reading and studying constantly - she earns her knowledge. She changes immensely throughout the movies and starts as obnoxious and annoying but after being made fun of and ostracised she changes the way she acts and becomes self-aware that she needs to change. She never does much fighting and does need to be rescued or isn't strong enough at times. She mothers Harry and Ron and has many moments of weakness and 'traditional' female emotions. Her active roll is usually relegated to her knowledge that is well explained and took realistic effort from her part. There are a handful of moments in the movies where she does something that would usually be given to Harry or Ron but they also occasionally do something that would be given to Hermione. A Mary Sue is not any girl that can beat a boy.

[@WillieKitty-ig8gl]

The dumbledore and Sirius theory is not correct. In the books dumbledore didn’t know Sirius was innocent, the only people who knew was Sirius himself, Peter Pettigrew and the dead Lily and James Potter. Have you even read the books? Please do.

[@marissathebooknerd]

Amazing video ❤ Thank you ❤

[@rebeccaperrydoosan7456]

I believe number 4 my heart hurts for sirius

[@untitled6391]

Harry was thinking of Ginny even when he, Hermione and Ron were away on the hunt for horcruxes. So a better (but still not plausible) theory would be that Hermione was in on it.

[@untitled6391]

You can't trust mind reading completely. False memories can be formed and presented by skilled wizards like Snape does with Voldemort. So there was no way for Dumbledore to know for sure. Also, veritaserum would have worked but maybe the thought that Sirius was innocent didn't even occur to Dumbledore since the evidence added up, with the 13 muggle dead and Peter's thumb found at the crime scene. So there was no reason for Dumbledore to suspect anything. On top of that, while Sirius was unruly, he was still a part of the Order, a sensible man and would've listened to Dumbledore when explained why Harry needs to stay with his aunt for his own safety.

[@kitsunekodomo]

29:50 it would explain why Ron was in a zombie like state after taking an antidote in Slughorn's office. Being double dosed by love potion from two different people. Luckily it was solved before it could cause any chaos.

[@AndrewThePotterKidYT]

Yes new vid

[@LouisGaufridiSorcerer]

Abracadabra is actually an ancient name of a demon and the spelling depleting one letter each line, creating a triangle, is used to destroy the power and energy of the demon. Typically this demon is a sickness demon. So it being close to Avada Kadaver, let it be destroyed, is the relationship me

[@melbell700]

Omg the Ginny love potion theory is crazy!! What if she did and the kids turn out the same was as Voldemort. Without the feeling of love. Don’t play with my emotions like this!! 😂

[@gwynnelovas7702]

I think that the mughals would have had no problem taking care of Voldemort and all of his Death Eater followers if he just had a few good machine guns

[@jessejohnson8365]

4:11 I always thought they died in a car crash! They would have to know that Harry when grown up would research it! If he found Grandma and Grandpa died in a car crash, it's an easy lie to say, his parents were also in the car. They could even say that Harry was in the car. That would make for a convincing lie to add two additional people in an event that you knew about.

[@kyles3334]

Wouldn't Serious Black being attached to Harry more from raising him also be a problem since they knew what Harry was and what they had to do, to get rid of the dark lord in the end.

[@Inkaddiction906]

Sirius stayed locked up because he never fought the claim. He accepted his fate so why would anybody question it? He felt he deserved it.

[@tyrannosauruswrex123]

I LOVE THESE VIDEOS 😊😊😊😊

[@lexiibattwitch]

What if the 'normal muggle death ' was the car crash that Petunia told Harry actually killed James and Lily?

[@isthepizzaforyouandme]

enjoy the trip!

[@HarryPotterTheory]

Cheers!

[@jaehaspels9607]

All of the theories were quite interesting. When you brought out the fact that Harry should've had grandparents, I said, "Oh yeah." I had never really thought about that. It's fun to hear theories because it's a fictional world after all. I find it really hilarious that the Death Eaters who are so gung ho about purebloods are led by a guy who's a half blood. They sound hypocritical and stupid.

[@Noorsassi8]

The Harry's imagination theory is really flawed because the Dursleys have a reason to hate him whereas in this universe there is no explanation as to why they would hate him

[@kitsunekodomo]

26:00 didn't Hermione read how to made them? Of course she wouldn't make one herself, but just exactly was in those books she took for Dumbledore's office?

[@Marias.Icerunner]

Bertha might have the saddest death ever. Didnt get the chance to meet her child and got her unborn child stolen like that is just unthinkable. Curse Peter, so coward the only thing he manage to kill is 12 people and an unborn child.

[@saraanic9436]

Her name is Bertha.

[@Marias.Icerunner]

@@saraanic9436 Thx

[@hsuehhs1]

Next video should be how many years in Azkaban Prison would the Grand Witch from the 1990’s film The Witches would face for crimes against Muggle Children?

[@trendloe]

37:33 in DnD, a corpse is considered an object...

[@johnramirez5996]

If polyjuice potion work on everything from person to gender how did Hermione turn to a cat?

[@JennyShull]

If a corpse becomes a horcrux will the horcrux be destroyed if the corpse decays?

[@90sHouseBoy]

The dementors remind me of people that have dementia and Parkinson’s disease when they lose their memories and happiness and joy. I’m sure JK Rowling made the dementors on the effects of Dementia and Parkinson’s Disease

[@dylanelizabeth7712]

Depression

[@kaylajones7558]

What's wrong with the Twilight series?????? I've read both the Harry Potter and Twilight series and seen all the Harry Potter and Twilight films. I'm a fan of both franchises. So why diss Twilight?????? I'm confused.

[@Mooncrab4269]

What vampire in history myth or not, become glitter in the light? 9/10 times its dust 1/10 EXPLODE so they made a joke out of a entire belief, the director and book writer was actually a disgrace on the sypy category

[@HarryPotterTheory]

It's just not for me- personal preference! But I'm not stopping you from watching it.

[@RiaKitty]

Azkaban is a prison. Can’t bail someone out. Omg.

[@arinerm1331]

The theory that the Wizarding World is a product of Harry's imagination is bolstered by Platform 9 and three quarters itself. Harry was born on July 31, 1980. James and Lily were killed October 31, 1981, exactly 15 months after Harry's birth. Harry learned he is a wizard on July 31, 1991, his 11th birthday. He had lived exactly 9 3/4 years with the Dursleys at that time.

[@dublinairportplanes]

Love posts like these.

[@themasqueradingcow91]

His parents had a rough 21 years

[@MonographicSingleheadedM-sp2wk]

Most dark theories seem to revolve around Apbus being a dick 😂😂😂

[@treatb09]

nah its all to find an heir to the deathly hollows so death can regain his power. I suspected dumbledore was actually death, because of his hand you see when claiming to try to destroy a horecrux, but death needed a wizard to touch the shell to drink the water...and a set of circumstances vast. he was pretending to be dumbledore at a certain point. Potentially when he got the philosopher stone..another anti death device. But voldemort was able to escape death and death hated that as much as the philosopher stone. Just as much as the invisibility cloak afforded in the tail. So he give harry the cloak knowing it wont matter since he will age, then the stone to give him courage and help harry appreciate death by an illusion of an after life and then the wand to maintain a magical world, since harry wont abuse magic to escape death.... So death can finally capture tom riddle, who would have been the heir to anti death. Which means each house had a potential method... tom was trying to basically destroy death’s power over life. Where death would basically be the first dementor... but as tom riddle makes horcruxes. He loses himself piece by piece, like other immortals. Since death is too. Immortal... Where then death was able to manipulate the wizarding world and control it again. To feed, and prevent a cycle of power... voldemort was actually a hero but corrupted by his own naivety. Why else use the house’s most valued possessions.. Same with destroying the philosopher stone. All the movies have that repetition against longevity. Next time you watch harry potter. Imagine it being death instead of dumbledore after the philosopher stone is destroyed... pay attention to how the power hierarchy of magical form degrades. The only plothole being that the elderwand should have be a wand that cast every spell and when destroyed. All magic was gone too. N harry becomes a vagrant.

[@dream10994]

I think if u read the books the love potion theory does not make sense

[@HeraldOfChaos76]

That whole orphan car crash theory was absolutely unholy I'm glad that's wrong😂 I've had to deal with certain aspects of losing family that will actually do that if you're not careful luckily I was able to root myself in reality through fantasy and stuff like that and because of me connecting certain characters I like to certain kinds of people I wish I had I decided to make the certain kinds of people as realistic as possible and thank God for avatar The last Airbender Harry Potter and dragon Ball z because Harry aang zuko and Vegeta we're very very helpful tools in my healing when I lost certain people and I'm definitely not comparing myself to any of these particular people I'm just saying that I exhibit a lot of their traits that we're rooted in grief I just think it's pretty interesting how I'm ecstatic that the car crash theory is debunked for a plethora of reasons I can actually see why that was a thing for a little bit and also that Twilight jab was the best thing I ever heard 😎

[@thelegendarybigfoot6760]

Can we get one on how the elves became slaves ?

[@dishman4694]

I absolutely abhor the fact that the most interesting aspects of EVERY book/novel/poem-song are never confirmed by its author.

[@xodicnz2161]

Only one that's wrong I feel like is Harry's and Ginnys In the Movies they have little to no chemistry but for the books I'm currently only on prisoner of askaban and they've got a chemistry might not be a lot but it isn't little that's for sure In chamber of secrets harry even asked her to be his valentine I feel the love potion theory is only for those that watched the movies

[@kidoo2009]

The theory on how to create Horcruxes is wrong, because Voldemort didn’t do that to Harry and he was a Horcrux he didn’t mean to create

[@MJoker569]

Harry Potter and whatnot.

[@MrSlider57]

Dumbledore was the Henry Kissinger of wizards 😂

[@maryholder3795]

Ugh fetus theory no wonder her editors did dislike it. Grandparent murdered was always my thoughts. Molly gave her husband a love potion so it was said. Daughter like mother. Sirius definitely left in prison by Albus, he'd lose control of Harry if Sirius was free. Harry imagination, creation of the wizarding world, as a defence against being with Dursleys.

[@Omni0404]

Who is this Harry fellow I keep hearing about?

[@hiddentruth1982]

Dumbledore set up the whole thing. The Potters dying and all of it. When he met Tom he realized that to let Tom run loose would have been far worse. While there were things beyond his control he set things back on the path he wanted. He knew about scampers and all. He even sacrificed the Potters to end Tom. That's why he know Harry had to die and where all the horcrux were located. Dumbledore knew that Harry had to kill him or at least that someone with part of Tom's soul would. So he planned waiting for the one to come along to do it, even setting up Harry as a conduit with his parents dying in front of him.

[@josecuestas7246]

Basically, Dumbledore was the true master planner of the events of Harry Potter.

[@hiddentruth1982]

@@josecuestas7246 yep

[@neutralGuy777]

Basically Dumbledore is the aizen of harry Potter 💀

[@owenevans3703]

British theory sounds so classy

[@sspaceforce]

could you as a drinker of polly potion... use a part of your (polly) hair into the brew to keep your polly shape as you are now technicly that person...?

[@saraanic9436]

Obviously not. Otherwise Barty Crouch Jr. would have killed Moody. He kept him alive so that he could continue making polyjuice potion.

[@dawndylyon]

Odd question:I just rewatched chamber of secret but if the journal took giny's life and revived tom while the body got restored in goblet of fire. Would we have had a double voldemort situation?

[@mswildstraw]

The scene with Aunt Petunia wasn’t deleted, at least it wasn’t here in the states.

[@evapunk522]

Tbh, I don't even know anymore because I end up seeing a lot of directors cuts & they have a tendency to put a lot back in so I don't even know what was in the original theatrical cut anymore lol

[@danielgodfrey4415]

Dumbledore moved on as a ghost

[@bailatwerski2951]

Actually all these theories make sense and possible. None of them seem absurd to me. Thank you for making this series and compiling it

[@psychxticrose]

You obviously haven't read the books then

[@nathanlynch9634]

I’m part of that 25% that’s subscribed.

[@JennyShull]

A theory: Lilly and James dated, got engaged, married and had a baby to spite Snape. They could have dated, got engaged, married and had a baby with anyone they knew but they dated, got engaged, married and had a baby with each other. Snape hated that. Lily had a falling out with Snape but still liked him. James and Snape never got along. Lilly might not have had feelings for James. James might have had feelings for Lily because Snape had feelings for Lilly. (To me there is no love between Lilly and James just spite for Snape and a mutual tolerance of each other.)

[@talia8493]

Then where does that leave the explanation of why Harry is capable of love. Remember in Half Blood Prince, Dumbledore tells Harry that Riddle is not capable of love because there was no genuine love between his parents. Remember Merope gave Tom Jr love potions throughout their marriage and only stopped because she thought enough time had passed that he could love her for her.

[@RobloxFilmsAndAnimations]

I liked Albus until book 6, Then after finishing thee series and watching you I hate him now

[@julianivanov1139]

this is not a criticism of you! but a lot of these theories seem to wholly derive from plot holes and gaps in jk rowling world

[@dawidsz5474]

This material is super dumb and makes only if somebody have not read the books

[@eelkemulder7329]

Nightie night peeps

[@melanievetter6211]

🎉🦁

[@MsAuburnluv]

Could have been a car crash that they died in.

[@danielgodfrey4415]

10:37 actually I think muggles can see dementors. They see them as blue hair people. Lol.

[@flobbertdobson1598]

Idk why they didn't give veritaserum at all trials

[@younghokim1994]

If Neville was there to see his parent's tortures, why wouldn't they have tortured him too? These theories are bad.

[@guinevererodriguez3807]

He was same age as harry so he was also a 1year old baby

[@julieeeee778]

671. Points. Julie. 😊🎉❤gryffindor. Hogwarts house 🏡

[@sharksl1064]

I don't think the Harry's imagination one makes sense as hp theory explains harry supposedly makes the wizarding world up because he is depressed and abused to the point of near starvation so he makes up the world however the dursleys would not have been so abusive because harry was never magic they hated harry and Lily James and the whole wizarding world petunia did because she was jealous Vernon because petunia did and it was abnormal so they wouldn't hate him they would love him it even states in the book before Lily got her Hogwarts letter her and petunias had a strong relationship so they hated harry because of magic so if magic didn't exist then the dursleys would still be bad people on the outside but the y certainly wouldn't be so abusive