Food Theory: YOU Solved the Grubhub Mystery!

[@bennettam.9330]

Sometimes I forget just how cool the theorist community is.

[@lfkkkfk862]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/d4rWeJ94hLF9eZY ...

[@aru5225]

Now we will never forget XD

[@thefolder3086]

I think Sunday is the one who steals jimmy tech and kills milkshake lady . She is not stupid so maybe enough to use the tech

[@MustardGuy161]

Fucking bots above me are annoying...

[@Thesis_Rose]

Ya i do too

[@blacknexus1852]

Can't believe how interactive grubhub is with the community to actually have deep lore. i love this

[@Jinxanator66]

Free publicity honestly

[@FayieElphis]

Personally I doubt they do. They just saw something fun and jumped on it, getting some good press in the process.-

[@Luixxxd1]

@@Jinxanator66 it's not free if they are putting the effort behind the lore

[@craftsummonner16]

Same its awsome

[@Ho_Lee_Fook]

They're just using matpat for easy advertising

[@th1sdud30nf1r3]

MatPat: * Makes a FNAF theory that makes sense * Scott Cawthon: Lol I'm gonna change it again MatPat: Makes a GrubHub theory as a joke GrubHub: Lol canon

[@deleted_exe]

Lmao so true doe

[@cyberseai9305]

Grubhub actually make a good marketing strategy by agreeing on a youtuber with insane popularity

[@ryacorn126]

It all adds up

[@deleted_exe]

Lmao

[@couththememer]

Hahahahhaha- *coughs coughs* haha- *cough coughs coughs* hahahha- *dies from coughing*

[@amandawoodley6476]

Am I the only one who wanted more of this amazing saga? I mean I know there were 3 videos… but I am just in awe.

[@lixmore7746]

Yeah me too 😭

[@SuperWiiBros08]

is so hilarious how accurate it is, but I still have a question unanswered, are any of the animation team that worked on the grubhub commercial related to jimmy neutron?

[@user-vo9he5ml6u]

Hi

[@Saadexe]

here before this randomly blows up

[@bytblox3366]

@@Saadexe same

[@intellectualidiot1719]

69 likes remind me to like when this gets more

[@pizzweak580]

People are like "here before this becomes popular" but you raise a good question. I want to know the answer as well

[@TheRealGuywithoutaMustache]

"You solved the Grubhub mystery" The legends who did absolutely nothing: "You're very welcome, MatPat"

[@OkKo-ii3ei]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/d4rWeJ94hLF9eZY ......

[@chelseamalveren3443]

Don't call me out like that bro 😭

[@technobladeneverdies7547]

You are a mistery like OwO my dude I see you everywhere

[@EngagingOverImmersive]

So... you gonna make an ARG?

[@azel7056]

Lol true but doesn’t mean we all don’t appreciate the community👌🏽

[@clementthangtinkhum7690]

Matpat: YOU solved the Grubhub mystery Me who hasn't lifted a finger: Ahh yes...all in a good day's work 🙂

[@Raymanlegacy]

@Krk Jk I DONT WANNA SEE THIS VIDEO STOP

[@ludllaver0079]

Can relate to that statement of yours @clement

[@Kalmia_1]

“Teacher Matpat’s proud”

[@ahmed4363]

Spy tf2: All in a day's work

[@Toastyboi32]

We’re the kids who do nothing on a school project but get full credit

[@paranormieprincess5788]

"Giant snake, birthday cake LARGE FRIES, CHOCOLATE SHAKE." The lyrics of the Fairly Oddparents theme song connects the missing woman to being Trixie by the receipt featuring LARGE FRIES, and a CHOCOLATE SHAKE!

[@littleone1349]

I caught that too!

[@nicolekosch4429]

Yep said it last time too and they had a cross episode too

[@thechaosofcaffeine]

yoooo that actually fits tho

[@purpleturtles3615]

And she acted like a snake.

[@gregh7432]

Omg

[@joshualifeheart3671]

The other angle of the grub hub bag is that Jimmy started showing interest in Trixie Tang while married to Cindy, and that Cindy hijacked some controls to take out Trixie, hoping to get Goddard, but not being experienced enough to accurately target it.

[@rubyrangitsch5248]

That was what I was thinking.

[@rubyrangitsch5248]

I feel like Jimmy might have found out and divorced her, which led to him turning his life around.

[@chillyswissmobile9695]

@@rubyrangitsch5248 smart

[@moondust2365]

Either that, or she knows that Jimmy started to show interest in Trixie and intentionally killed her to prevent that. A bit of a stretch, but eh.

[@hinzbx]

Possible.

[@historyhub5389]

Considering the fairly odd parent clip where trixie screams “feed me and tell me I’m pretty!” at Timmy, it may have Ben trixie that ended her relationship with neutron who she believed wasn’t tending to her needs properly. This would also explain the grub hub bag as potentially neutron still holding a grudge after the breakup and deciding to feed trixie... to death.

[@KrakenSea13]

Oh thats funnnnnn

[@cease842]

“YOU Solved the Grubhub Mystery!” Me who literally didn’t say or do a thing: Aw, gee, it was nothin ☺️

[@diakounknown1225]

literally nothing

[@kyatonic1]

Yes I swear I was sitting here like, yes I did solve this theory by sitting at home and whatching this video right now

[@mittuthefire]

It ain't much but it's honest work

[@beashemmad.sayson545]

Fr man

[@jinxneo]

Yes

[@WitherLord888]

It’s incredible how a Grubhub ad became a meme that then spiraled into a massive collaborative mystery ARG that involves Jimmy Neutron. Man the internet is funny!

[@andrewedward777]

Theory: MatPat is always high

[@darthwick7917]

hello there

[@2chill2bbored72]

@@darthwick7917 general kenobi.

[@theonewhoasked.444]

Yes

[@cupofmoss1007]

I’m almost 100% sure that they moved the chimney, since there’s actually a hole where the chimney used to be in the photo! You can actually see the hole in the side of the house, which we know exists on Jimmy’s house since we see it in the feature film.

[@tylerhayes4584]

Wow I didn’t even see that

[@jboy11123]

that could be it or it's part of the gutters i can't tell

[@NotMidnight._.]

I also noticed it, and it would align with the matpat’s concept of Cindy vortex’s house and the place of the bag from 11:50

[@PiercingSight]

That doesn't look like a hole. It looks like an illusion created by the lamppost in the image that lines up with that part of the house.

[@CD-Beats]

That is most definitely a lamp post

[@RedKetchum151]

Remember Jimmy has an evil clone in an AU. So it's possible that we're seeing how the evil AU in Jimmy Neutron turned out.

[@doozideer2045]

package: says “confidential” matpat: *shares the entirety on the internet to millions of people*

[@mistuniverse2018]

@Kflffk F silence

[@aquamarinerose5405]

They didn't want anyone opening it before Mat

[@ajvYT]

Lol ikr

[@Mr.Capitalism]

shhhhhhh only theorists know

[@youseineko]

They gave it to a KZbinr with millions of subscribers. They knew exactly what he’d do with it, and they wanted him to.

[@MoltenMonsters]

the fact that grubhub is quickly becoming the fnaf of food theory is really terrifying

[@andrewryan8267]

69 likes

[@Glory2Snowstar]

I mean, they’re both things that involve surreal 3D models with deceptively massive lore, so I suppose it was inevitable.

[@majamystic256]

personally I think Omega Mart might end up eventually being the FNAF of food theory

[@CoraCreates]

Even more terrifying than you, Nightmare Fredbear?

[@StephenDelRosario777]

Not to mention all the free exposure Grubhub is getting..

[@nozomiritter5048]

When you were talking about, it being Jimmy that killed milkshake lady something popped into my head. What if it wasn't Jimmy that killed her but Cindy! She could have been threatened by milkshake lady still being around! And being married to Jimmy at the time she would have had Direct access to his phone if he was asleep!

[@lalalove2530]

I WAS THINKING THE SAME.NNIICCEEE

[@charliecarter4828]

I also had the same thought

[@skelebonez1349]

YO EXACTLY!!! I mean I don’t really see any reason why jimmy would do that compared to cindy

[@KimukoDoesALot]

exact thought.

[@yeseniagutierrez9667]

She was also just as smart as Jimmy back in the show

[@Nintenoble]

It’s also worth mentioning that the dog reacts to the food appearing in front of taco guy, therefore being more real than the gems or stars the other characters experience

[@fucentauriel7202]

I’ll admit, when you mentioned that Jimmy might be responsible for the grub hub bag, my brain went to blaming Cindy for dropping it- possibly to get rid of a romantic rival.

[@disneytheorizer2721]

Same

[@SammyJay107]

Same!

[@arubikcubethatshouldnthave4440]

same chain o.0 (same)

[@sitoa3343]

same

[@cranberryjuice3469]

But if she hates the dog why keep him alive?

[@dagbs]

It's also possible that Jimmy went back to see Timmy and talked to the Fairies. Converting magic into science, he created an app. A dark twist is that he's using fairies as servants for his app.

[@andresv.8880]

Sounds absolutely like what a scientist would do. Oh magic you say? Nonsense, there must be some way to explain and replicate it

[@matthew9677]

Don't only kids get to fairies tho

[@retosius7962]

@@matthew9677 it's canon that timmy gets to keep his fairies for the rest of his life, so it's possible that they could meet again and jimmy does jimmy things.

[@matthew9677]

@@retosius7962 okay. Thx

[@t-sauce2497]

Fairies don't appear to anyone above the age of 12 if I'm not mistaken

[@Ohnay77]

The tan house that was circled also has the empty space where the chimney would be off it hasn’t been knocked over and moved. The windows are in perfect placement too. Two big windows in the middle of the y axis of the house on either side of the chimney area, the two smaller windows are most likely covered by the tree. I really hope you see this. My comments never get noticed.

[@Emanuele_Polisena]

That's right! I didn't notice it

[@taylormassey6196]

Good thought, but looking closer that's just a street lamp. You can see it extend out.

[@Emanuele_Polisena]

@@taylormassey6196 wait isn't it a telephone pole?

[@Ohnay77]

@@taylormassey6196 oh ye your right.

[@jennifergriel861]

The thing about the FOP connection is that the 2nd and third crossover specials make it very clear they’re set in separate universes. Like they can only get back and forth with dimensional portals.

[@KrakenSea13]

yes, however, another commenter pointed this out. the theme song of FOP says "Giant snake, birthday cake LARGE FRIES, CHOCOLATE SHAKE." and the reciept that GH sent MatPat has both a Lage Fries and a Chocolate Shake (bought by/for Taco Lady) which creates a connection between Taco Lady and Trixie

[@Yipper64]

6:10 this kind of theorizing is what I love about matpat theories. Its completely ridiculous, but it gets an explaination for the pre-determined answer.

[@BeanzAreGud]

Package: *Confidential* MatPat: "Hm TIME TO SHARE THIS WITH THE WORLD :D"

[@OkKo-ii3ei]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/d4rWeJ94hLF9eZY .....

[@BlahajWarrior]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/oXnJh3mBatiobdU ...

[@Starlightnova111]

I really hope this series continues, it's actually the most entertaining series on all three channels if I'm going to be honest

[@OkKo-ii3ei]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/d4rWeJ94hLF9eZY .....

[@strange17]

All four right now

[@stormageddon248]

You always find a way to make wholesome things dark. And I’m so there for it lol keep it up

[@danielsahlberg4576]

This series just goes to show that MatPat can’t even make an April’s fools video without sounding convincing.

[@MGD07524]

Yep 🤣🤣

[@T3ki1a_]

@Gff G ta gueule non un peu? Dégage.

[@user-lz3mt5jf4w]

Самое глупое и худшее видео в игре: kzbin.info/www/bejne/qWnNn6CjrdStodM

[@amyamayzing5659]

true tho XD

[@Fat_chicken_is_everywhere]

Yeah

[@TimeBucks]

Good job so far theorist team

[@ranbo0]

agreed

[@yeetus_feetus8564]

Agreed

[@linkholder]

Agreed

[@brianalamo3487]

agreed

[@StarlitDraws]

Agreed

[@LoganWH8]

One small thing, throughout the Jimmy Neutron series, Jimmy messes with time travel more than once, and the future is far from certain. When Sheen accidentally gifts Libby a perfume spray that would make her evil for her birthday, Jimmy, Carl, and Sheen see a future where she’s taken over the world. The rest of the episode revolves around them actively changing that future. Jimmy seeing how miserable his 26 year old self was, he would definitely put effort into changing that future.

[@tanzanite.]

MatPat: At first I was like, "Mmm GrubHub lore" as a joke, right? MatPat: But bro MatPAt: *I don't think it's a joke anymore*

[@rustydino3611]

"Magically". Since Fairly OddParents is now on the table, what's to say Timmy didn't WISH for it? There are magic stars everywhere too.

[@graypetcoyle]

And we know through both the show and the live action movie that Timmy has both wished to never age so he doesn’t lose his fairies, but also due to special circumstances he is allowed them into his adulthood

[@christinaknapp1980]

@@graypetcoyle But those wishes as an adult have to be to help others. Though that doesn't rule out the Pixies or other antagonists from the show.

[@HailixOffical]

And thanks to the intro of farily odd parents, we now that Timmy can wish for food

[@S_Rendevouz]

What if Timmy wished for food to be more accesible to others but, like in some episode of the fairly odd parents, it backfired and accidentally killed Trixie. But hey, that is just a theory….

[@flameduel]

There was a fairy odd parents episode that has Timmy grow up temporarily, and show that his fairies were almost taken away. So at this part of time, I don’t think Timmy turner would HAVE the ability to wish anymore

[@ComicalRealm]

I swear Mat Pat is the only guy that can make a lore about a commercial series and connect it to Jimmy Neutron

[@willsmith3988]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/hWS1mJ2eg8qmpZo .........

[@mrgamemaster7761]

Nope. Someone high can also connect a commercial to Jimmy Neutron

[@pigwilber3688]

Yea

[@thelegendarybloxycola4727]

How many bots did this guy buy?

[@ashishthenayi3938]

Hey don't forget the loyal theorists. But it would not have happened without MatPat

[@Martezpan]

Just a reminder: MatPat made a theory about a food commercial related to a 20 year old kids show as a joke, and then the creators ACTUALLY RESPONDED THUS MAKING IT NOW HAVE POSSIBLE CANONICAL LORE

[@BlahajWarrior]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/oXnJh3mBatiobdU ...

[@sillyfegart5455]

"Fiction is reality now" - Sun Tzu

[@multiplemysteries5242]

I still find it kinda freaky. I remember watching the first theory and being like "Really? :/" and then the second one came out and my mind was completely blown.

[@erminpajazetovic9506]

You should really consider making a cospiracy theory chanel or something like detective stuff or whatever bc this is gold

[@knucklessammich3875]

I absolutely love it how this started out as a April fool's joke even he admitted it wasn't supposed to be this deep but since apparently people have been making connections to it he is now going with it if this becomes the fnaf of this channel I swear to God

[@analogueclockbop]

If that happened I swear😄😄😄🍊

[@leonardosomma4196]

The FNaF of food theory on terms of lore complexity?

[@tardislibrarian511]

You'll have them reading the source code of each ad, looking into where they printed the pictures, looking at episode numbers. Honestly, this is really interesting

[@shishanyu]

Grubhub marketing team must be like: “yeah… that’s tooootally what this is and how it happened… yes”

[@OkKo-ii3ei]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/d4rWeJ94hLF9eZY ....

[@texugo_branco]

Yep, They are just milking it!

[@CounteredSnow]

"free marketing!!!"

[@florindaancira9736]

The only time mat is right

[@liampbjray5562]

they're the exact opposite of every movie creator ever

[@GameJam230]

Let's take a second to imagine what would have happened if the creators of Earthbound or Undertale replied to MatPat after his Sans is Ness theory. *How many parts would he have made?*

[@OkKo-ii3ei]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/d4rWeJ94hLF9eZY .....

[@theperfectidio1]

@@OkKo-ii3ei THE SEVERAL BOTS IN THIS COMMENT IS TOO MUCH

[@marekadams6956]

3. The original, what the response means, and the SECRET MEANING behind the response.

[@adiksaff]

He might've suffered less from his Undertale theories... Oh if only...

[@shadycat_1935]

The creators of Undertale did, and they were super rude about it, so Matpat stopped building onto that one

[@donovancunningham4490]

7:02 Also, notice that the house has a noticeable line in the wall and the roof doesn’t make a full point.

[@umecoalpaw7573]

This is still easily my most favorite food theory series. Part 1: Haha, funny grubhub meme theory. Part 2: Oh... Oh dear. Part 3: MY CHILDHOOD NOOOOO XD

[@SMG9000.]

part 4: kzbin.info/www/bejne/q56no2Ojhdqsh8U

[@NervousBoiReck]

@@SMG9000. when are they gonna make a part 4 it's been a year

[@SMG9000.]

@@NervousBoiReck idk but I hope for one

[@NervousBoiReck]

@@SMG9000. make a prediction

[@SMG9000.]

@@NervousBoiReck later this year

[@TheMafiaPanda334]

This is one of the most elaborate sponsorship/advertisement schemes I've ever scene. I applaud you all for a very tactifully planned co-op.

[@Cyberlong]

I see this as an aboslute win!

[@alexp.7068]

@Molly Sigler is that... a homestuck reference??

[@alexp.7068]

@Molly Sigler I hope it's just some bullshit and not a homestuck reference

[@thenameisalie6]

@@alexp.7068 well, what a coincidence that would be.... :D

[@casseymancl400]

Just remember MatPat, if we’re wrong, this will be the most elaborate April fools prank ever....

[@OkKo-ii3ei]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/d4rWeJ94hLF9eZY .....

[@hey_this_is_a_handle]

well, this is probably an elaborate april fools prank that lasted 4-5 months.

[@jamscotty5707]

@@OkKo-ii3ei *go away*

[@TimmyTimmyton]

This is wrong, in the ad, Salad Lady's door is rectangular, but the house we see has an arched doorframe.

[@grumpyoldman3458]

April, May, June, July AND August fool!" - Holly, Red Dwarf

[@ShursGarden]

There's a problem with this: The 15 Year Future Jimmy/Cindy relationship only happened like that because Libby became an evil dance-crazy dictator. Their actual relationship wouldn't be like that at all.

[@QuietChaos1996]

That's exactly my thoughts. Cindy and Jimmy were growing and evolving by the time the show ended. Like, THEY KISSED IN AN ALLEYWAY WHEN THEIR FRIENDS COULD HAVE TURNED AROUND!!! X'DDD I think that they didn't have the toxic relationship before they got married. (I also think that Jimmy might have been cheating on Trixie with Cindy because of how deep and far Jimmy and Cindy's feelings were.)

[@QuietChaos1996]

@Kflffk F I don't think many people speak French...

[@theoutsiderjess1869]

True by the end of the show Cindy was way nicer to Jimmy

[@emralddan672]

Who knows could be an alternate dimension.

[@metazoxan2]

Not to mention I"m not completely convinced this whole Lore theory is meant to include Trixy Tang's demise via giant Grub hub bag. Not only would that mean killing off a significant main character but it would be doing so for Timmy's universe and not the Jimmy one. I mean as far as crazy theories go it's possible but that feels a bit much. Sure "realistic goddard" is near the bad but a lot of stuff is placed oddly for the sake of hints so it's exact placement is questionable. IF we assume this video is right and Milk Shake Lady is really TRixy maybe she just ended up breaking up with Sheen and moving back to her own universe. Or maybe there was a problem with living in a 3D world for so long when she was born in a 2D one.

[@Evie0h]

This is so bizarre, I remember now every single clip of the show that’s brought up/shown. I forgot how much of a fan I was of that show as a little kid, I even remember making my family watch the movie for it for movie nights, and made my older brother fall in love with the Sheen Show thingy

[@TheAdvertisement]

Matpat: I need your help for evidence. The thousands of theorists too bored to do anything else: _YES SIR_

[@mickaellapalmer]

Yep

[@shiningskies47]

The best part about this is that GrubHub definitely just put a bunch of random stuff together to see if he would somehow connect it all

[@Mark_Agamotto1313_Smith]

My theory is, Grubhub didn't actually have any continuity, but WANTED them. So they send Mat the info hoping that he would come up with a fleshed out backstory for them... FOR FREE!

[@ClownHoundII]

I don't think they chose random stuff. I believe that Grubhub animators probably looked over what they had for what could have be related to the show. (Ad animators tend to be young adults so them remembering the show is possible.) They picked out details and sent it to Mat for get free advertising. A lot of it is actually is related to Jimmy Newtron too. The blonde lady wearing green, a huge neighborhood that has a similar house to Jimmy's and references to a robot dog.

[@bwingbwinggwiyomi]

free marketing for them lool

[@cromwell4029]

Half of me thinks that grubhub wasn’t expecting their adverts to get this much lore and just went along with it

[@ClownHoundII]

@cak01vej Parodies are of free use and allowed to make money. Similar character designs can't be sued unless the characters are unable to be distinguished from each other or clearly a rip-off. An example would be the redhead man with glasses. While he looks like an older Carl, he isn't an official character in the JNU or one that looks extremely close to any official character, thus is fair use. As for the atom symbol, the symbol for atoms can not be copy righted the same way the image of a hamburger can't be copyrighted. Edit: They can use an own character for a parody as long as credit is given and isn't just a reposting of official private episodes/clips. (No leaks) This is why references to other characters shows, well as rule 34 are legally allowed.

[@seawarrior3323]

Ok MatPat, hear me out. What if Taco guy is secretly one of Jimmy’s clones! Whenever he eats a taco in the clip you showed his eyes lit up and looked almost mechanical. What if he dropped the bag on Milkshake Lady because he was evil! What if he has Jimmy locked up somewhere and now holds on to the controls over the Grubhub town…?

[@catelynh1020]

I watched that part a few times at .25 speed. Looks to me like reflection of tv since he's moving his head forward and to the side to take a bite

[@veeicake]

Like the evil clone from the evil earth?

[@user-nj9ll6em8k]

Nope

[@user-lz3mt5jf4w]

Самое глупое и худшее видео в игре: kzbin.info/www/bejne/qWnNn6CjrdStodM

[@firdanharbima6997]

Possible since his head is upside down instead having big Uper head

[@pgj1997]

13:30 Isn't Dimmsdale in California, though? In the episode "Fairy Idol", they show exactly where Dimmsdale is, which is California IIRC.

[@Pup_Star]

This all started as a April Fools joke that was, in and of itself, an April Foods joke. Round of applause. 👏👏

[@lfkkkfk862]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/d4rWeJ94hLF9eZY ...

[@FriendlyNeighborhoodNoob]

Oh ma god stop the video links

[@nicknackattack1618]

@@lfkkkfk862 how many of these are there bruh

[@Sir.Craze-]

@@nicknackattack1618 it's a bit. Don't talk to it just report for spam

[@LukasSheshene1]

@@Sir.Craze- I reported for spam!

[@nikinidefonseka4716]

At this point, Mat should throw out his ‘certified false’ stamp

[@Universal_Box]

Hello [Insert name here], we’ve been trying to reach you about your car’s extended warranty.

[@littlechi7738]

@@Universal_Box ahhhhh run hide scatter

[@thedaisygirl207]

This feels like a never ending fever dream.

[@atchaaa]

@@Universal_Box I don’t have a car

[@BiggestPhangirl]

1. Glad you included JT Power Hour because that expands the GCU even more. 2. I still think the JT Power Hour contributed to the idea of GrubHub because Jimmy saw Timmy’s fairies and assumed they were computer programs that could do exactly what his personal GrubHub app can do…except Cosmo and Wanda were Timmy’s personal apps. So I honestly think the entire concept of GrubHub (Jimmy’s special version) was directly influenced by Timmy’s fairies. 3. I highly doubt Jimmy killed Trixie, but I wouldn’t put it past Cindy. Her character was always the possessive, demanding, jealous type and generally toxic. 4. Cindy may not have known the brown dog was Goddard. Jimmy certainly had the capacity back in the day to make Goddard more lifelike, but seemed to admire the mechanical appearance more. I think he disguised Goddard to appease Cindy, OR he pretended to get rid of Goddard and “adopted/bought” a new “real” dog. I suspect Cindy wasn’t ready for that, or still rejected Goddard, and forced Jimmy to give him up. 5. The reason we don’t see Cindy and Jimmy together as a couple may be because their marriage failed, and not just due to Cindy’s sub-par personality. Cindy would have every reason to be angry if Jimmy just played video games all day, as that leaves her with the burden of housework AND breadwinning. She may now live in the blue house to avoid her husband/ex-husband(?). 6. If 3 and 5 are true, Cindy’s motive for killing Trixie could be a step beyond jealousy. If Cindy thought Jimmy was distracted by Trixie or that Jimmy still secretly loved Trixie and was distracting himself from Trixie via games, the best way to both get her husband off the couch AND remove a threat to their relationship would be to eliminate the most probable source-in this case, Trixie.

[@samworkbench]

Number 7: it was likely that during a divorce that Cindy got ti pick the property she gets to keep, what better way to spite Jimmy then also taking the lab which she stays many times she wants, which also could show she only did things with Jimmy for the lab and money that Jimmy provided. Number 8 is Number 7 is true, maybe Jimmy didn't give up the dog and just used the dog as am excuse to talk to Sheen and his wife and let them take his dog out on a walk, but Sheen having a Job was constantly unavailable leaving Trixie to talk the dog on a walk, and they way Cindy saw it was a pregnant lady that Jimmy was interested in whi had a child who Jimmy was probably talking about teaching the kid or giving a high tech gift to seems might susz and Cindy has drawn outlandish conclusions before she killed Trixie and divorced Jimmy. Number 9; college could also be community service that Jimmy has to do due to manslaughter and then after he makes it and helps run it he is put under house arrest a but which is why he never leaves his room and makes food instantly teleport to him so he doesn't accidently set of the alarm, and Cindy gets away Scott free.

[@SolstaceWinters]

Knowing Cindy, I'd blame her for some fairly odd murder. We know how vindictive she can be.

[@somuchtocook9159]

I actually made a post that says that she would be put in prison after jimmy gets wrongly accused for murder

[@xxlovetohate534xx]

Haha "fairly odd murder." Thumbs up for you, sir.

[@dustydave961]

You have a good point here. You may have solved the mystery.

[@joshc5613]

that's exactly what I was thinking. it wasn't about Goddard at all, Cindy killed Trixie as a final revenge for taking Jimmy for herself for so long

[@arieltallen5732]

That's exactly what I thought!

[@hottopic3622]

"feed me and tell me im pretty!" such a mood trixie, such a mood

[@JENNATHEZOMBIEE]

Lol

[@rayneozier]

I’m still not 100% sold on this theory, but it makes more and more sense with each new video.

[@leonardosomma4196]

I thought that last episode grubhub made this canon?

[@kurukavatar5089]

@@leonardosomma4196 not completely

[@leonardosomma4196]

Gotta say, I'm not completely sold on the house theory

[@leonardosomma4196]

@@kurukavatar5089 thx

[@kurukavatar5089]

@@leonardosomma4196 you're welcome

[@mica4977]

While I can't remember much of the show I still love Cindy's sassy confidence XD

[@codenate02]

The Trixie thing still bothers me, since the Power Hours confirmed canonically that the two are in the same UNIVERSE, but quite literally different dimensions. Even their art styles are canonical and noticed by the characters who cross over. Of course, Jimmy has consructed a portal between the two before, so anything is possible I suppose.

[@majamystic256]

I think Dimmsdale is in California

[@bittybaby22]

I can’t really remember the episode, so I don’t know if this would be possible, but maybe they used the crossover magic/science/however it works to see each other and eventually Trixie stayed in the JN universe. Maybe that’s how they were long distance?

[@official-obama]

He predicted marrying trixie

[@violetrose674]

If that's the case, then this might not be the Trixie from our Timmy's dimension. Dimmsdsle could still be a place in Jimmy's dimension with all our favorite characters (barring the fairies), but not the version that we see in Timmy's dimension. Similarly, Retroville could still exist in Timmy's dimension, just not the version in Jimmy's dimension

[@ceaslug9791]

Does anyone else notice how Jimmy’s eyes flash when he bites any grub hub food? I can’t make it out. it might just be reflection from the tv, but it ONLY happens when he eats grub hub food.

[@vrabb9030]

His eyes shine a few frames before the burger is bitten

[@ceaslug9791]

@@Playmaker48 I’m glad; I don’t have the ability to go and dig stuff up right now so I’m glad someone’s on it!!

[@KCThatOneDreamer]

YES! Those theory brains are working hard down here in the comments!

[@frankhaugen]

The chimney being moved has an even better explanation: energy-loss. The chimney is a good distributor of the heat from the fire, so it's relocation to a more efficient location would make economic sense and it'd be reasonable for a local government to require that only fireplaces that's not wasting heat would be allowed to be used

[@deleted_exe]

Yea

[@frankhaugen]

@DaBomb8493 that makes even MORE sense, and is seriously plausible. "Government changed local codes, chimney is toppled, chimney is rebuilt to new code". That's a scenario that would fix the continuity instantly, and be realistic, (if it's bad weather that toppled it and not a rocket-flying teenager, it's probably something that actually have happened in real life)🤔

[@about6penguins10]

I don’t know if you have ever thought about starting an official game theory discord server but it would make it super easy to talk with and get theorist to communicate together

[@garygrim9235]

Fun fact: A Jimmy Neutron reboot apparently has been confirmed for paramount +. So we might see if any of our theories are right in the near future. I think it's slated for fall 2021, so see you all then.

[@ninjapumpkin0127]

Synchronize your death watches.

[@dicetrip1357]

@@ninjapumpkin0127 yessir.

[@TheShardsFamily]

Till they decide to make up their own lore

[@Dougherty-h8i]

It must have already happened because it's 2023

[@garygrim9235]

@@Dougherty-h8i and this post is 2 years old, what's your point?

[@return3168]

Flashbacks to MatPat saying that he had “solved” FNaF by the third video, anyone?

[@sekoseko2291]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/hWS1mJ2eg8qmpZo ...........

[@beanbaguette8185]

What's with the links in the comments lol

[@nuclear4569]

@@beanbaguette8185 usually just spam I think

[@joshuaarchbold3741]

lol that is true

[@TwoCagedBirds]

@@beanbaguette8185 Just report them when you see any. That's all you can do really. Hopefully, KZbin knows and is trying to fix it.

[@flame5769]

"How many times do you want to say GrubHub?" Matpat: yes

[@lfkkkfk862]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/d4rWeJ94hLF9eZY .

[@Anti_OT2763]

Double yes

[@endk.3500]

I mean he’s talking about it I don’t get why he wouldn’t say it

[@Mrbruh6000]

@Kiaran Reddy rick roll

[@OncelerKidsAreCringe]

Why so many links?

[@cat_casserole117]

I spotted another hint that it’s Jimmy’s old house if you look at 11:41 you can see that his neighbors house is blue with a red roof and when you go back to see the picture of the house being circle you can see that next to that house it’s a blue house with a red roof.

[@Mr_Kiwi]

In regards to the house: It doesn’t look right. In Jimmy’s house, the roof and top floor appear to be intersected. But in Grubhubs house, there is space between the second floor and the roof. Although, it’s probably likely that they simply added an extension to the attic 🤷‍♂️

[@givemoney5970]

Chur

[@BlahajWarrior]

@@givemoney5970 kzbin.info/www/bejne/oXnJh3mBatiobdU ...

[@luyucyycyccuycuy]

New idea for a food theory: what is the perfect meal? or rather the perfect meals for a day, meaning the foods that according to the nutrition facts will come the closest to meeting the daily recommended amounts of everything for a 2000 calorie diet

[@OkKo-ii3ei]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/d4rWeJ94hLF9eZY ...

[@rachelstephens3820]

Yess, amazing idea

[@haroldinho9930]

And give you all the vitamins??

[@gigaseb]

And all the macro nutrients

[@homerman76]

I mean there are some theoretical ideas for something, but any results would be more like "the perfect meal" because of how it isn't nearly as clear cut as "one perfect meal that satisfies the nutritional needs of everyone" with how differently each body handles food within even the same family (my brother and I are only a year apart and yet one needs more calories daily than the other because of how their metabolism runs.) It would still be interesting to go over the topic and why such a meal doesn't exist though.

[@bennyboiart7781]

7:00 Not to nitpick, but for the tan house to be Jimmy's childhood home, you'd also have to find a plausible reason for why they added another full story to it; just by looking at the two photos, you can see the tan house is two full stories, whereas Jimmy's is more like one and a half stories, what with the second level being built in beneath the roof itself. Edit: People have pointed out that one fairly plausible explanation for the two houses looking different is that they may not actually be the same house at all, but rather that the tan house is a rebuilt/heavily re-modeled version of Jimmy's childhood home, but that it is still located on the same property as the original.

[@shannonhensley2942]

Technically the second story was already there the roof was smaller. We actually see the second story from the jutted windows. But in all honesty jimmy very easily could have cause major earthquakes, fire, floods, or tornados to make the houses get rebuilt. I honestly believe his parents kicked him out but didn't actually want him to be homeless so they reconfigured the yard to allow jimmy a place to live outside of their home but close enough to still love him.

[@eldoctoroso]

Also remember, Jimmy destroys the house on a regular basis and sometimes other properties so that would also be an answer to the urban development

[@midnightrambler8866]

I noticed that too!

[@QuietChaos1996]

In the show, its actually shown to have 2 full stories.

[@QuietChaos1996]

@Kflffk F Can you NOT share a video in FRENCH please?!

[@The_annoying1]

I litterally cannot get over the intro. So well done!

[@oompylover312]

MatPat must’ve been like: “Confidential? Ha, shouldn’t have trusted me with THIS!”

[@leonardosomma4196]

😂🤣

[@brentambrielcabigas1086]

Comedy at it's peak *Or is it*

[@canineatnight6026]

He just acting..... *Or is he?*

[@rachelrasmussen1101]

I'd investigate Cindy as the murderer. She had access to Jimmy's tech.

[@DivineChaos204]

And maybe Jimmy and Trixie might be in a relationship

[@shai2902]

Because cindy probably thought he was cheating on her with trixie !!!

[@jakemicallefellul2462]

Same

[@multiplemysteries5242]

Yeah. Plus, murdering Trixie in that way (or murdering someone at all) seem like a lot more of a Cindy thing to do

[@beebunch9380]

Definetly

[@Ms.SouthernSweetT]

Ok so I have two theories about Milkshake Lady's/ Trixie's death: 1 it could have been an accident on Taco Guy's/ Jimmy's part because we know he is prone to not have his inventions always go as planned, and in an attempt to refine the Grubhub app he created to deliver the entire towns order at once hence the giant bag something malfunctioned, thus crushing Milkshake Lady while on a walk with Goddard. Causing Jimmy to spiral into depression not leaving his couch, playing video games and ordering food all day. Or 2 : After marrying Salad Lady/Cindy out of convenience because Trixie was in Dimsdale or away at college and not wanting to alter the future's timeline. But Jimmy sometime later reconnects with Trixie but she has moved on as well, Cindy finds out about the reconnecting and not wating to be outdone hijacked his invention causing the bag to crush Trixie but making Jimmy believe it was his fault. #BUTITSJUSTATHEORY Love this mystery/saga🧐💜

[@kevflon]

But he keeps describing the Grubhub bag falling as magic, and we all know Jimmy only uses science! But there is someone that does use magic and also had a thing for both of the girls!!! Timmy Turner!!! He killed her to frame Jimmy!!! lol what a twist!

[@remyratatouille634]

@@kevflon WAIT NO THATS A GOOD THEORY

[@theeefybeeefy4200]

Maybe

[@yeonkimin1437]

@@kevflon Timmy killed Trixie to frame Jimmy so he would live a sad life :O

[@Jemims_luvs_u]

AYO WE EED MATPAT TO SEE THIS BECAUE BOTH THEIRIES R GOOD

[@gabee_is_silly]

I’m confused,shocked, and loving this series

[@tiagotiagot]

And there's a vertical line where the chimney would've been, which could be an indication that part of the wall was created later resulting in a seam where the two sides met because they weren't originally built with fitting together in mind.

[@zyrahorihara8419]

Yes!

[@mageytodd659]

I noticed that too

[@marcusanark2541]

Up!

[@NighttimeDaydreams]

I pretty much commented the exact same thing, but with far worse wording, before scrolling down to see this perfectly articulated masterpiece. XD

[@tamagonbagel6569]

To quote Dan Avidan, “This is absurd” That’s a good thing

[@tsucube4377]

@Sp0s3 kzbin.info/www/bejne/gKjRlHSHqtefp80

[@aetheralmeowstic2392]

Man,.Trixie Tang yelling "FEED ME AND TELL ME I'M PRETTY!!!" never gets old!

[@ggjk8419]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/d4rWeJ94hLF9eZY .....

[@BlahajWarrior]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/oXnJh3mBatiobdU ...

[@jadamalfoy4135]

this theory is like hearing a summary of a soap opera

[@bubbadoo1267]

You DO realize that "The Fairly Oddparents" is ALSO connected to both "Bunsen is a Beast" and possibly "Danny Phantom", don't you?

[@Ash_Wynn]

this could make things more complicated

[@tr4sh1]

Oh god please this is so complicated why-

[@KimukoDoesALot]

I'm starting to think grubhub ads are crossovers from nickelodeon-

[@user-dz4eb5rb3g]

And Danny phantom is connected to t.u.f.f puppy and Bunsen is a beast is connected to super brawl

[@karenruble4989]

These comments are making me learn about shows I didn't even know existed.

[@andrewroller3214]

After watching MatPat complement us all I feel like that one guy in a group project who did nothing but still got credit

[@OkKo-ii3ei]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/d4rWeJ94hLF9eZY ....

[@neonzplayz5060]

Okay I don’t know why I said that

[@dancingowl2443]

Same

[@leonardosomma4196]

Theory: after Jimmy saw how poorly Cindy treated him in their marriage he decided NOT to marry her altering the future so he could hook up with Betty

[@existentialrookie5432]

Oh god. Things are gon get even more complicated by adding a time machine in the equation. This would throw off our timeline

[@leonardosomma4196]

@@existentialrookie5432 I'm just saying. But hey, that's just a head canon, A FOOD HEAD CANON!

[@mackybell14]

*That makes so much sense* Matt got it wrong. The pregnant lady wasn't Trixie, it was Betty, Cindy was becoming increasingly jealous of Jimmy and Betty's relationship... So she uses some of her knowledge on Jimmy's tech to make the Grubhub bag crush her rival. Jimmy is devestated and in pieces, then comes along Cindy to "put him back together", sweeping Jimmy of his feet and eventually getting married to him. TLDR: Cindy went complete yandre and killed Betty so she could be with Jimmy.

[@ainultasneem7536]

@@mackybell14 Didn't MatPat cross off Betty as a suspect because Milkshake Lady didn't have a mole and they had different eye colors? I mean he explained it in the video

[@leonardosomma4196]

@@ainultasneem7536 yes

[@samanthaslagel8138]

this is literally the most insane level of niche detail and thinking of EVERYTHING , proud of the theorist team, those who made this video and fans alike!

[@Hamster07]

I think at this point franchises create lore based on what matpat theorizes

[@sevasti6583]

Ikr

[@user-lz3mt5jf4w]

Самое глупое и худшее видео в игре: kzbin.info/www/bejne/qWnNn6CjrdStodM

[@internetperson8638]

I strongly believe that Grubhub had no intention to make a hidden story, but MatPat discovered something, and they are just going with it now.

[@regiman222]

So Fnaf 2.0?

[@ducktaledudette]

@Krk Jk Quit that pls

[@aiemanhadjidatu8183]

Less likely. The evidences are quite convincing, especially when they mailed MatPat.

[@babydinosaurr]

Lmao totally 🤣

[@internetperson8638]

@@aiemanhadjidatu8183 Again, they could just be going with it

[@florallise385]

this is why i love theorists so much. instead of just thinking its a normal add with a few references, they look so deep into it. i think that is such a cool ability

[@saraygortizgalvan2837]

This is one of my favorite theories on the channel

[@itsthatonechickagaincallth7843]

Love it when big companies reach out to creators on different platforms to make shared content. Beautiful.

[@goldeneagle8740]

"Grubhub taco guy looks like jimmy neutron" -the day MatPat went insane, and justified it

[@BlahajWarrior]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/oXnJh3mBatiobdU ...

[@ggjk8419]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/d4rWeJ94hLF9eZY ...

[@gogauze]

Tbf, I think it actually started with spotting the jackets with the atom logo first. Then it all came unwound from there.

[@artisplatters]

I can’t believe GrubHub actually got involved with our shenanigans 🤣 it’s legendary

[@papervbox]

the way the editors make these concerning scenes with the characters is just amazing

[@rjohmerjohx]

Cindy found Jimmy’s grub hub tech and in a fit arguing dropped the device/pressed a button releasing the bag on Trixie. Out of guilt she let Jimmy keep the dog

[@generalcorgi698]

"Jimmy Neutron is a murderer via grubhub" is not the hot take I was expecting

[@harryxyz2982]

@Kflffk F no one likes your content

[@Tartarsauce.]

The fact that there’s such intricate lore around GRUBHUB never ceases to amaze me.

[@galcide1927]

14:33 loving how she gave birth with a milkshake in her hand 😂

[@Isaac28649]

I didn’t even know it was a joke cause everyone of his theory’s are so crazy

[@NervousBoiReck]

69 likes 😏

[@dr.braxygilkeycruises1460]

It is hilarious how invested in this theory I've become when you consider I have never seen even ONE episode of Jimmy Neutron.

[@thesymbiotenation.4552]

Same the closest we got was the Powerhour special

[@leonardosomma4196]

Never seen an episode myself

[@idontknow-fl4id]

Same

[@aspiring.creative.person6092]

SAME

[@AllHailKingKurt]

You want to watch it, don’t ya lol

[@goldenjakey49]

These theory’s are getting so insane that I wont even be surprised if we see Purple Guys car or the house from the FNaF 6 8 bit car secret.

[@OkKo-ii3ei]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/d4rWeJ94hLF9eZY .....

[@jamscotty5707]

@@OkKo-ii3ei *shut up*

[@tgbluewolf]

6:38 so Jimmy made diamonds--which later feature in the grubhub commercials...?

[@sunnex474]

Matpat: the average car ownership length is 6 years BitLife characters: hold my beer

[@LP-ir3op]

poor people in their used toaster: hold my pocket lint

[@leonardosomma4196]

Who in the US made this rule!?

[@christopherchadwick4677]

@@leonardosomma4196 it’s not a rule

[@LP-ir3op]

@@leonardosomma4196 the people who produce stuff need to make more money so they make everything last less time then it used to so people have to replace it which makes the producers like 10x richer

[@leonardosomma4196]

@@LP-ir3op here in the UK my family has had their car for 10 years

[@bethgraviss8922]

Another way to prove the house theory: on the cover of the special episode, I saw that there was a blue house next to a tan house and they were very similar shaped and similar in placement.

[@Bricz6176]

Good point.

[@darkamora5123]

On the chimney being moved, the picture shown in the video looks like it has that same groove where the chimney would be . Every time Jimmy knocked it over we saw the groove, and if they finally chose to never rebuild that groove would be present, and it is.

[@Beyondthe5thPanel]

Daggone!

[@lindsey9958]

Ye, it looks like they replaced it with a gutter drain

[@andreytop1gg]

In one of Taco Guy's ads, you can see the dog ordering tacos from Taco Shack for a brief moment.

[@noahziegler3679]

Any character: *exists* MatPat: “At some point this person murdered someone.”

[@ggjk8419]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/d4rWeJ94hLF9eZY ...

[@wafity]

As someone who has watched Jimmy neutron as a kid, I really enjoy these theories