Bee Gees - I Started A Joke REACTION A SIDE OF THEM I'VE NEVER SEEN!!!!

[@lorrainemyers8515]

The Bee Gees have a 50 year career! Pick a decade, they have a song/ hit! This is one of my favorites with Robin singing lead. His version of Oh Darling is GOLD!!! Words, Run To Me, To Love Somebody, ( covered by Al Green , Michael Bolton ) Holiday, all gems...Mr. Natural, Songbird, Nights on Broadway, Love Me, Can't Keep A Good Man Down, omg I could go on forever! No, they started with ballads, some country tinged music, ( Come On Over covered by Olivia Newton John) and their sound changed over and over again! Disco is where they got the most attention , but they did, pop, adult contemporary, they wrote thousands of songs and fun fact wrote one of Barbra Streisand's MOST successful albums, Guilty.

[@patriciaewing8164]

Absolutely love ❤️ Robins voice, there will never be anyone that can sing like Robin. You have a lot of the Bee Gees music to listen and react to 😁🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

[@west_nebraska_dude4527]

Always loved this song. On Song Facts there is a heartbreaking story told by Robin-John Gibb (Robin's son): 'Robin Gibb's son played this song just after his father died from kidney failure on May 20, 2012. Robin-John Gibb told The Sun: "When he passed away we went out, they took the equipment away and we came back in. I picked up my phone and found 'I Started A Joke' on KZbin and played it. I put the phone on his chest and that was the first time I broke down. I knew that song and its lyrics were perfect for that moment. That song will always have new meaning to me now." '

[@catleonacatvino3561]

This is Robin's song. His voice was amazing.

[@kentclark6420]

I'll echo what everyone else said- their 60s style was totally different and more cerebral than the disco, and that didn't come in until the latter 70s. Their best songs were in the 60s, to me. They had so many great songs like this. 'Words', 'I've Gotta Get a Message to You', 'Massachusetts', 'To Love Somebody', are a few! The Bee Gees Wonderland!

[@peggykerbaugh8149]

I agree. Their best songs were pre-disco.

[@ednanelson1897]

Dude, you named some of their best 🥰

[@kentclark6420]

@@peggykerbaugh8149 Yeah, but I ended up getting to like the disco stuff they came up with. In a totally different way. It's amazing how diverse they were, and talented musicians.

[@kentclark6420]

@@ednanelson1897 Thanks! They are special songs, aren't they?

[@palmerdirector9169]

These are my favorites. Although "Jive Talking" is also.

[@56music64]

Robin wrote and is singing lead here, he said it was a very personal song also he said it was very spiritual. To me it sounds like someone who feels out of step with the rest of the world

[@jeannejorgensen1230]

This song showcased Robin’s beautiful voice. The BeeGees had hits well before their disco era.

[@jbrock917]

They put out a lot of songs before disco was a thing. The early 60s was when their first album came out. They formed their band in 1958.

[@jencooper3371]

My favourite is New York mining disaster 1941.

[@rhondahandley9595]

They first hit music as The Brothers Gibb-in the 70s they changed name to The Bee Gees.

[@jbrock917]

@@rhondahandley9595 no Ma'am, you are incorrect, they began using the name Bee Gees in 1959 after their first band, The Rattlesnakes, originated in1955, disbanded in 1957 and it did not originally stand for the brothers Gibb. They got their name from speedway promoter and race car driver Bill Goode and a disc jockey named Bill Gates, from a local Brisbane radio station, who hired them to entertain the audience at the track. Both mens initials were Bs and Gs. They called them the BGs at first but later changed it to Bee Gees. From 1966 - 1969 they released 6 albums and 12 singles as the Bee Gees. Google them and you will see that what I said is factual info.

[@JamesThomas-dn6ee]

@@rhondahandley9595 so wrong they have called themselves the beegees from pretty much the beginning in 1958

[@lcn325]

Wow the year I was born!

[@scarygazeplaysmsp1825]

You need to watch Fanny be tender with my love!!! Older song but awesome

[@DianaJG8]

This is a very beloved song and Robin's favorite before to sing before he died. Barry still played Robin singing it on video during his solo tour in 2014. 😪 Another great Bee Gee's song/video is "Alone".

[@frankphillips5660]

The BeeGees had numerous hits before they went disco. I prefer all the pre disco stuff. Try Lonely days and How can you mend a broken heart. They were right there with the Beatles

[@Isleofskye]

THey were great b4 , during and after but when discussing the most influential Group and best selling singles and album band of all time we must ......... "Bet Without The Beatles"...lol

[@RalphMasielloArt]

Amen! Love the old Bee Gees.

[@Sissysuez]

I can't think of a bee gees song I didn't like but I absolutely agree with you I did like their music before the Disco more than their other songs but even their disco sounded good so they were just an awesome group and I for one absolutely loved Robins voice this is one of my favorite songs of all times

[@saflynn14]

Funny thing is they wrote those songs BEFORE the movie came out....they were asked if their music could be used for the movie.

[@breckrichardson390]

How about "Run to Me"?

[@matmagix3845]

I Started A Joke was written in 1968 and is considered Robin Gibb's signature song (note the vibrato vocal). Disco and funk appeared mid to late 1970s, so the Bee Gees had to change with the times if they wanted to keep an audience. The music the Bee Gees did before disco was often called Baroque pop, and a lot of those songs were tinged with hints of sadness and reflection. The Bee Gees during early days also tended to switch lead singing position of Barry Gibb and Robin Gibb. You can see this in "I've Gotta Get A Message to You", "How Can You Mend a Broken Heart" and "Run To Me" staple songs from their pre-disco days, which are great. The transition period towards disco is best noted in their 1975 album, with songs like "Fanny Be Tender With My Love", "Nights on Broadway" and "Jive Talking".

[@allanbluzdude]

This is what they sounded like before disco, this is the BeeGees I always liked

[@jeremyboynton6173]

Before 1970, Robin Gibb was the predominate singer in the group, and as time passed, it started having Barry become more the focal point. It's the main reason the group split up for close to two years. There was always an underlying sibling rivalry between Robin and Barry. Barry had the more marketable look, and better commercial sound. But Robin had the far more unique voice, which is why he was better suited for their earlier ballads. If you're looking for more songs to react to that are more Robin-focal, may I suggest "Bodyguard", "For Whom the Bell Tolls", or "This is Where I Came In" from their final album. His voice always is felt when listened to.

[@COD33]

This is what they did in their youngest days. Before disco was invented. Listen to "Massachusetts" "Words" "To Love Somebody", "Got To Get A Message To You".

[@heatherharmony5288]

I recently figured out what I got to get a message to you was about. Sad song.

[@pretzel_cat]

Heather Harmony I read an interview where Barry talked about how Robin brought the idea for “Message” into the studio. The others didn’t think it would work but Robin excitedly told them “It’s a love song.” He was right and it obviously worked for them. I love the way Robin’s mind worked; still trying to figure out many of his songs.

[@Sometimes-even-lyrical]

@@pretzel_cat Yes! I loved the way Robin Gibb's mind worked, too. Just another reason why I loved so many of The Bee Gees early songs. I love Robin so. He was such an important component among this trio of gifted brothers who made up The Bee Gees. A beautiful soul... a man sexily complex, cerebral, vulnerable, eccentric, sensitive, mysterious, insightful, creative, boyishly charming, expressive, spiritual, profound, and rare. He was a truly remarkable person and an artist with an utterly unique, heavenly, and irreplaceable voice! Rest in Peace.

[@DeepakIyerp]

This is Robin Gibb singing. Most of the other songs were sung by Barry. Thats why it sounds different.

[@DeepakIyerp]

@Diana Gero sory Barry👍

[@siouxzblu9790]

It's Robin singing, it's his song. Watch the video. Lovely voice.

[@siouxzblu9790]

@Diana, Oh okay. Lol

[@saflynn14]

Love Robin’s voice!!

[@susieq7401]

D SI - Robin wrote many songs including several solo albums. This was written by Robin and played at his funeral by his request. Voice of an angel.

[@mzphillips53]

The Bee Gers became popular in the US in about 1967 when I was in the 8th grade. Man,oh man did I love them. The New York Mining Disaster of 1941 was their first song I heard. Then Words, Massachusetts, I Started a Joke, Holiday, I've Got to Get a Message to You and the list goes on and on. Robin did most of the leads in the beginning. Sometimes him and Barry would take turns. Later Barry discovered that he could sing falsetto and began singing lead on most songs when disco came along in the 70's. People like to say that the Bee Gees had 3 separate careers. Really. They had a long string of hits in the 60's. Then we didn't hear from them again until the movie Saturday Night Fever came out and the Bee Gees were back. Then we had a few more years without them and after a few years they came back again. 😁 Those early songs from the 60's were so stirring and moving. The disco years were fun but Robin could sure bring a tear to your eye back in the 60's. Robin's son Robin John played I Started a Joke after his dad's funeral. He said something like No dad, you didn't start the world crying. It was sad.

[@celiagorleski2716]

BeeGees recorded songs in 5 decades. This was from their first decade, the 60s. My all time favorite song.long before the disco and falsetto sound.

[@dianefiske-foy4717]

That’s Robin Gibb’s fantastic voice doing the singing, with his two brother’s doing backup. This song was from the late sixties. They’ve been singing since they were kids.

[@cosmicroadshow3288]

Smile an everlasting smile, that would bring a tear to me....some of the great lyrics

[@thewheel73]

Ahh a Robin led song. His voice is one of a kind. I miss him so. Disco might have been their monetary peak, but their pre and post disco songs are also amazing. This is one of the former. Case in point. This Is Where I Came In is both the name and the self-titled track from their final album. It's great. Hint Hint. ;) Thank you for the reaction. I could listen to Robin all day.

[@louisesmith4251]

He sang this 30 years later and still sounded incredible

[@BethHutter]

They started way back in the mid 60's. SOme really great songs which have already been mentioned. Robin's voice is just amazing. This song used to make me cry when I was younger.

[@Zlata1313]

Robin's voice still makes me cry.

[@NOLAgenX]

They were a big 60’s band. I recommend Massachusets and Lonely Days from that time period.

[@carolynnewcomb2153]

If you haven’t already seen it, I think you’d really enjoy their documentary “How do you mend a broken heart”. It starts back when they were three beautiful little boys singing three part harmony. It’s so good! Barry is now the last man standing, and he misses his brothers terribly but he’s doing really well... still singing their songs!

[@dagnelpaula1]

It's impossible to believe that next month, this song will be 52 years old! Incredible! During this era of their music, I especially love their songs "Words," "Massachusetts," and "Gotta Get a Message to You." Just be prepared...their 60's music was not as upbeat, and fast-paced as their later music. But it was ALL good! While I'm here, I want to wish you and the ones you love, and very happy Thanksgiving!

[@garfield122010]

I always loved Robin Gibbs voice the best ❤️

[@jessiemyrle4907]

The Bee Gees have gone through every genre of music that has existed since the 50s, and have succeeded at every one. Their true, true talent in writing, singing and their unique ability to harmonize meant nothing could keep them down. They are the BEST and ALWAYS will be. RIP MAURICE , my favorite RIP ROBIN and we will ALWSYS LOVE YOU BARRY💔💐💔💐❤️🌹🌹

[@sylviasegovia6467]

Thanks for the stroll thru the late 60's in middle school. Yes, there are others in this style from the Bee Gees. Try "I Gotta Get a Message to You", " How Can You Mend A Broken Heart" or "Words".

[@downhearted40]

Loved the reaction! James, you should look up these groups before your reaction to familiarize yourself with the history so you don't walk into something like this blindly. "The Brothers Gibb" has a fascinating history which also included a younger brother, Andy Gibb, a fabulous solo artist, who died at 30 due to drugs. The four brothers were so incredibly talented! Now the twins are gone as well, leaving only Barry. Check him out on barrygibb.com, he's got a new album coming out with his great old stuff collaborating with various country artists. ❤

[@Sometimes-even-lyrical]

@@downhearted40 Not necessarily. Being so surprised may really pique his curiosity and open him up to giving more room to experience definitely different and exquisite music. Believe me, he deserves more than disco from The Bee Gees

[@TheMike_I]

this song was from 1969, they had a lot of hits before disco was invented. more earlier classics by them To Love Somebody 1967, and How Can You Mend A Broken Heart 1971.

[@JamesThomas-dn6ee]

This song was from 1968

[@TheMike_I]

@@JamesThomas-dn6ee it was released in 1968 and it peaked at #6 in 1969.

[@cindyknudson2715]

They originally wrote To Love Somebody for Otis Redding. He passed away before he could record it and they decided to record it themselves.

[@pretzel_cat]

If you like the r&b, funk, and soul feel in The Bee Gees disco era hits, here are a few earlier songs that show how that sound developed. - Mr Natural (1974): has a smooth r&b chorus that has a bit of a Temptations feel the more you listen. Plus this song’s instrumentals give me a hint of country too, which actually works really well and makes for an interesting blend. - Nights on Broadway (1975): funk sneaks into the bass line and Barry’s falsetto makes an early appearance. A fantastic song that manages to blend their classic early sound with funk-infused r&b. One of my top 2 Bee Gees songs. - Fanny (Be Tender With My Love) 1975: The other of my top 2 faves (actually this is #1 based on how often I listen to it on repeat). From the opening, this is a smooth groove that builds with layered vocals and falsetto harmonies throughout. The production here is absolutely perfect. Such a satisfying listen.

[@nerdiboy5128]

Personally, my favorite song of theirs; it helped me through dark times.

[@bcleone]

The Brothers Gibb (BGs) were a trio from Australia. Very popular when they were teenagers. They went to England and became more popular. This is how they started. Barry Gibb, the elder brother is also a supreme songwriter and has written many songs for other artists. The Kenny Rogers Dolly Parton duet "Islands In The Stream" was written by Barry Gibb! There is at least 50 years of exceptional music from them.

[@susieq9801]

They were Manx, born on the Isle of Man, moved to Manchester and were English, not Australian. They moved to Australia and were there for less than a decade before returning to the UK..

[@HRConsultant_Jeff]

I'll add to the others. This was not Barry singing. That started much later. They also did not have the falsetto in every song back then. Their singing was great before the disco 70's. Robin had a really good voice for this song. This song got a lot of radio play especially at a time of the Viet Nam war and kids feeling they were alone. This one along with "Mr. Lonely" were a whole different world.

[@karenj3611]

Oh, I really do love Robin's voice, these earlier songs are beautiful. Check out, How can you mend a broken heart. Massachusetts. To love somebody I've gotta get a message to you. All from there popular era in the 60's. The disco stuff came out in the late 70s

[@pamelapasechnick6899]

The very first 45rpm record I bought (with money I had earned by babysitting --25cents an hour was top dollar in 1968) was the BeeGee's song "I've Gotta Get A Message To You". Their disco music was good, but I really love their pre-disco songs the best!

[@capeach2708]

My favorite Bee Gees song.

[@christinewaide5249]

This is one of the saddest most beautiful songs ever written. You need to react to more of their old songs. 💕

[@cynthiadaves1933]

The Beegees are the best band ever....nobody else compares to them or have lasted as long as them ... people still like their songs today. Would you please react to IT DOESN'T MATTER MUCH TO ME BY THE BEEGEES.

[@mygirls0301able]

Yes. This is their early music. Robin sang this one. He is the bee gee without the facial hair.

[@wendysilva8749]

You need to see more of their earlier stuff... you'll love it!

[@joelliebler5690]

You may want to react to Nights on Broadway a truly great and fun song to listen and dance to!

[@Sanity155]

every decade covered by their brilliance. love them dearly

[@mpkny]

Love your Bee Gees reactions ❤ I love all eras of Bee Gees music, but 'To Love Somebody' from 1967 is one of my favourites that's definitely worth a listen. Also 'Lonely Days' from 1970!

[@Cookies_crumbs]

I had totally forgotten about “Lonely Days!” Great song! 👍

[@lindehughes1773]

They did exceptional music 🎶 from their first to their last, love 💘 them ❤

[@LillyMarz777]

Robin! What a voice he had.

[@sheilagholston7145]

Try ' Gotta get a message to you' and ' How do you mend a broken heart '. Please 🙏

[@maryannswanson3832]

They did what was popular at the time They reinvented themselves with the changes. That is testimony to to their longevity.😘😘😘😁😁

[@veliasalazar8678]

Have you ever reacted to words by the Bee Gees it is a great song love your reactio. Keep up the great job.

[@MaddyN999]

Early Bee Gees are deep and their best

[@kenb897]

One of their best songs is "This is where I came in". The official version is the best

[@juliefox1743]

Absolutely! One of my favorites!

[@lisac7965]

Watch Robin, do this song in 89 from Melbourne Australia, fantastic performance.

[@lisac7965]

This song is definitely Robin song, Barry does his own solo on words try it out

[@bettyartis3648]

They've been singing together since the late 50s. Late 60s was the first time they hit it big. This is one of those songs. Robin featured prominently with hospital style. They broke up early 70s only to reunite with the funky and disco reinvention which took over the mid to late 70s. They ruled r and b and disco only to face backlash because they were too successful.

[@rabeksmom]

LOVE their old stuff! "How Can You Mend A Broken Heart" is one of my favorites - also "Massachusetts" and "Got to Get a Message to You"

[@mmanilaboy]

i got all the bee gees album including their solo albums, for me the best BEE GEES are their 60's and early 70's, specially when robin gibb sings the lead just like I started a joke, a very unique voice

[@ronneranthonylutasemais8923]

Very good!! React For whom the bell tolls live Bee Gees

[@beverlychristian4959]

I was fortunate enough to listen to the Bee Gees before disco. Their best music was in my opinion before disco. Massachusetts, To Love Somebody, Gotta Get a Message To You, Too Much Heave, How Do You Mend A Broken Heart. Anything before disco they would have multiple titles in the top five regularly.

[@randy8297]

They were child stars in Australia. There are videos of them as kids on Australian TV.

[@christineparker7534]

What a beautiful memory of your Grandma ♥️

[@wilmerquesada8323]

Now you starting to realize why the Bee Gees are the best group.

[@sunshinerain4ever]

Robin's voice was so beautiful

[@kerrypapworth1526]

The early Bee Gees music is wonderful 💕

[@sylvialopez5928]

That was a great song for them it was a number 1 I believe they had 19 number one hits

[@maryannprzybycien2013]

Have you done "How Can You Mend a Broken Heart" yet?

[@sabinerobinson3198]

Best music. Played them out. Also HALL and OATES. Both groups had hit after hit. Great Song thanks.

[@downhearted40]

Hall and Oates are more 80s but fantastic choice! Your Kiss is a good one.

[@mykuklaki]

Please, please Andy Gibb - I Just Want to Be Your Everything or Shadow Dancing. He is The Bee Gees younger brother. You will love it!! It’s disco joy.

[@dp3396]

Yes!! Listen for Barry’s vocals.

[@ConnieKWONG-lw4zl]

This great song sung by Robin in the year 1967. very long time ago before their golden disco era 😊🎉❤ but still unique great soulful song ..😊❤

[@TexasMagnolia]

A must hear pre-disco song is “Fanny”!

[@pretzel_cat]

Second this! Easily my absolute favorite of theirs; can never listen to it just one time. And Nights on Broadway if he hasn’t heard that one yet. I see He liked Jive Talkin’ so Nights, with it’s funky bass, would be right up his alley too.

[@TexasMagnolia]

@@pretzel_cat Nights is my all-time favorite!!!

[@kayjohnson8377]

This song came out in 1967. They had a lot of music in the 10 years before disco. A lot of ballads and romantic songs.

[@marciamaria7796]

Linda voz! Linda canção!👍👍👏👏👏👏👏❤❤❤🇧🇷

[@jeannejorgensen1230]

You should listen to their pre disco songs. So beautiful and emotional.

[@delenelewis9024]

They started with slower ballads like this one. As they matured they stretched out into other types of music. Disco was after they'd been performing for 20 years! And after disco was also just great music! Have fun listening to it all. It will take a lifetime! :)

[@JeansDolls]

This was sang by Robin, he had a lovely voice.

[@beatlesgirl2782]

This is my favourite Bee Gees song and Robin has always been my favourite Bee Gee

[@kaynewsom6780]

Thank you for this one. I love Robins voice.

[@amymarckel420]

I love disco era Bee Gees, but their early stuff is what I still listen to the most. Robin’s ethereal voice always moved me so I have a deep connection to the songs in which he sings lead. If you want to check out their early stuff I would start with these: To Love Somebody, Massachusetts, Lonely Days, and How Can You Mend A Broken Heart, the latter two being written on the same day when they reunited after a short break up. Happy listening. ✌🏼❤️

[@gracemichelli.2am124]

Pre disco era. Lot of great songs. lol

[@SS-rk2me]

Check out their documentary on HBO Max "How Do You Mend A Broken Heart". It's so sad and heartfelt.

[@jimalden9376]

Yeah, this is the 60s, pre-disco era. Great stuff too

[@cosmicroadshow3288]

The Bee Gees had originated many new sounds and genres

[@mikeaudette2823]

The Bee Gees made their 1st recordings in Australia in 1963 (the same year the Beatles released their first album). Their brilliance spans decades.

[@valeries9290]

They always evolved throughout the last fifty years.

[@beeseewill2407]

There is a KZbin video of Robins son R.J.Gibb singing "I started a joke", he sounds great so much like his father.This one was Robin's song with his nice vibratto. "I started a Joke" was from their early days around the 60's.along with "To love somebody",also" How can you mend a Broken heart". R.I.P. Robin Maurice and little brother Andy.

[@maryannswanson3832]

I was 17 years old when this came out on the radio a lot, always loved the vabrato in Robin's voice. I will be 70 in 2 weeks. Their music changed with the times, which makes them timeless!!!😎😎😎😎💛🧡💜💙❤️💚💙❤️

[@RomeLifeReactions]

Happy early bday 🎂🥳

[@maryannswanson3832]

@@RomeLifeReactions my first happy birthday wish for my 70th birthday. Music has been my life, first concert was the Beatles at 12 , 2nd was Led Zeppelin! Grew grew up in Detroit. If you ever get a chance I love the song by 3 dog night, Eli's Coming. The stage version where they are singing on stage. I bet that you would enjoy it.😍🤩💥😁💚💜

[@nikkiharris6091]

Robin has a beautiful voice, they mixed it up in the 70s. 💞💞💞

[@davidvanriper60]

if you want to check out their later songs; try ALONE (from 1997)....Man in the Middle (Maurice, the 3rd BeeGee, leads)...and For Whom the Bell Tolls. The breadth of the group's talent is on display!!

[@patty9728]

I love this song...

[@richardnelson2895]

Early BEE GEES 60s 70s pre disco

[@roboh27]

The Bee Gees has many many great songs before they went disco. In my opinion their early stuff was the best and had the best lyrics and vocals.

[@robbiec1018]

Love Robin’s voice

[@loriwishman1866]

This was played at Robin's funeral. RIP so talented.

[@lindehughes1773]

TO LOVE SOMEBODY would be a good one to react to

[@bettyblakley4157]

Robin Gibb personified! Complex song! I love this song!

[@davidkadingojr.6941]

How Do You Mend A Broken Heart?? Incredible song,,,,

[@SilentHunter245]

The Bee Gees made music from the late 1950s to early 2000s. Their disco music is just a small portion of their catalog although probably their most well known music. Definitely check out some of the later stuff from the 1980s to 2000s. Some good stuff there like Alone, You Win Again, This is Where I Came In, and the list goes on and on.

[@lharrill7229]

It's an older song. These guys started out in the 60s I believe. That's Robin Gibbs singing lead.

[@lillyf973]

I totally fell in love with Robin's voice after listening to this song😃 try Run to Me; ths harmonies are AMAZING

[@dougbarton4668]

The Bee Gees started performing in ‘58 or ‘59. Barry didn’t even discover his falsetto until he was much older.

[@3ScotsInk]

"To Love Somebody." One of the best songs ever, and beautifully sung by Barry, Robin, and Maurice. Pre-disco Bee Gees are the best!

[@djyanno]

Try "Run to Me", it's one of my favorites from the Bee Gees

[@carolinagallegos3926]

I think the Bee Gees were better before disco!! I was never a fan of disco....great reaction young man!! Please keep exploring their before disco music, you won't be disappointed!!💖💖💖💖

[@stevenmurano7863]

put me in the group who would take their body of work from the 60s over the disco era ANY DAY of the week. this is fantastic stuff. check out 'to love somebody'...a perfect song that they had hoped Otis Redding would record....but it was not to be. fantastic.... also 'i gotta get a message to you'.....'words'