Old Fashioned Coconut Custard Pie - Classic Buttermilk Recipe - How to Cook Tutorial

Are you craving a classic dessert that's sure to impress? Look no further than this Old Fashioned Coconut Custard Pie with a buttermilk twist. Follow along with our step-by-step cooking tutorial to learn how to make this mouth-watering dessert. Trust us, your taste buds will thank you.
Welcome to Collard Valley Cooks! Have you wished you could make your French Coconut Pie recipes taste like Mama made them? You can when you come sit at my table and watch my cooking videos. You will learn how to cook Southern-style dishes using my mama's techniques and recipes. You will become a great cook, so stick around and don't miss a post by clicking that subscribe button today! Please leave me a comment if you like this recipe!
We have 4 large print cookbooks for sale! Purchase Collard Valley Cooks Cookbooks through our website: www.collardvalleycooks.com/co...
We have over 700 Printable recipes on our website. Use our search bar on the home page of our website to find any recipe. You can go ahead and print it or save the pdf to print later. Go here to find this recipe under a food category here: www.collardvalleycooks.com/so...
To use our website search bar go to the top of the home page here: www.collardvalleycooks.com/
Subscribe to Collard Valley Cooks: / collardvalleycooks
Link to enter our current Giveaway: www.collardvalleycooks.com/gi...
See our Latest Video Tutorials: www.youtube.com/@CollardValle...
See our Most Watched Video Tutorials: www.youtube.com/@CollardValle...
Shop Tammy’s Amazon Favorites: amzn.to/3TSRbsx
Check out our website: www.collardvalleycooks.com/
Shop our Kitchen Best Sellers: www.collardvalleycooks.com/to...
We are Chris & Tammy Nichols and we are sharing our love for Southern cooking, passed down through generations and seasoned with a whole lot of love. Come sit at our table, where biscuits rise golden brown, collard greens simmer soulfully, and laughter and good times always bring back memories. We'll be showing you how to whip up classics like fried chicken and cornbread, explore hidden gems of Southern cuisine, and even throw in a few surprises along the way. So, grab your kitchen tools and get ready to cook up some memories with Collard Valley Cooks!
#frenchcoconut, #coconutcreampie, #coconutpie
Swaggerty Sausage Sponsor: www.swaggertys.com/
#collardvalleycooks, #collardvalleycooksrecipes, #southerncooking,

[@mrsm222]

Pet Ritz Pie Crust!! Ive been using that since 1980. It comes already lined in a foil pie pan package of two. You can get regular or deep dish. I like that the one you used seems to have enough dough that you can pull extra over the edge and crimp it. I will try to look for Pillsbury in the roll at Sam's or Costco's or BJ's. Thanks for that.

[@cherylmaddox2233]

Have you ever made a coconut pie that makes it own crust. Delicious!!!!

[@giovannibrito7]

l did it in the microwave, & came out better than the oven.

[@marthaholcomb8148]

Tammy and (Chris) Mr. Camera Man, I love your home. I think it is beautiful! I love coconut anything, your pie looked so tasty. Please pray for my daughter she is now taking chemo. Christal has colon cancer. My husband passed away with it 4 years ago. They say it can run in the family, well we know it for sure. I take her to Lubbock for staging Tuesday. Pray for her that they find it staying where it started. God bless your family, may they stay healthy.

[@CollardValleyCooks]

Yes praying now!

[@judycross8037]

Prayers for your daughter!!! 🙏🙏🙏

[@anitaselby7718]

I turned 72 last Wednesday. I finally found the best recipe for cornbread after all these years from you. Thank you Tammy fo teaching this old dog a new trick.

[@patc.318]

Hi Tammy & Chris! The kitchen looks great! Sound quality is good, too! Both my grandmothers and my mother called this French Coconut pie. To serve my crew this pie, we either make about 3 pies at a time or sometimes use a half-sheet pan and make a "slab pie'. Either way, we have enjoyed this recipe countless times! You know with my crew, there are never any leftovers! Thanks for the demo of another recipe, y'all!

[@janettesmith369]

You're right! I don't have... never had a rooster! and I have it too!

[@maryluyoung7073]

The kitchen remodel is just beautiful ❤ The lighting and sound is great quality

[@giovannibrito7]

l saw the video, going do it!

[@madelineschultz4968]

I made this pie a month ago. It was a big hit! That's why Im making it for Thanksgiving tomorrow! Its so easy, too! Thanks!

[@CollardValleyCooks]

Glad you liked it!!

[@cherylthepearl827]

My grandma would make egg custard, chocolate custard and coconut custard. All were so good.

[@henrycooks1883]

Custards were my fathers favorite, my husband used to fix the equipment at an egg farm and would come home with 2 flats of eggs every time he went, some times a few times a week, I used to make a ton of custard pies. I miss those eggs, most were double yolkers.

[@DCo923]

Oh I love what you did in the house with your kitchen. You guys did such a great job, it looks great. Congrats and good luck with it.🤩

[@RavenNl403]

Oh yummy 😋 Reminds me of my Grandmother. Blessings 🙏❤️

[@katgirlsue]

I love this pie but I think I’ll try to make the “Impossible Pie" version. You should introduce your audience to "impossible pies" because there’s a whole generation out there that doesn’t know about the magic of these pies! They’re so easy, quick & delicious. The best part is being able to make a pie without a crust.

[@teachermarikitkat]

do you have a recipe to share for impossible custard/coconut custard pie baked in the glass pie dish? thanks

[@katgirlsue]

@teachermarikitkat - Google impossible coconut custard pie. It will come up. Betty Crocker website has lots of impossible pies. Maybe our girl Tammy will make some of them for us.

[@arlenefreeman9477]

Download try that that looked really really easy to make that coconut pie.

[@DebbyMorris14]

Chris, I hope your time with your dad /parents, was nice, & has a successful recovery! Prayers for them! And you & Tammy! 🙏🙏🙏🙏. Tammy, I’m so happy for you to have this new kitchen!! You look perfect in it! 😁. Hope y’all’s chickens do well as we approach cooler temps! Love you both! Deb. ❤

[@LifeisLoveLily]

Looks delicious! I love that you said you feed your sweet hens oyster shells and the good food ❤ shows how much you care for the little cluckers 🐓

[@rhondabutler4172]

I love all things coconut!

[@myVillage2323]

I despise all things coconut

[@rhondabutler4172]

@@myVillage2323 thanks for the info

[@carolspencer9396]

You make your pie crust look so much better than I can, although mine isn't a total crash and burn. And yes, it was Pet Ritz . Does anyone remember the frozen Ritz pies in the freezer section? They were great for a quick dessert.

[@joycehoward5193]

Good night sister tammy;Love your kitchen;Have a blessed Sunday with Jesus!

[@LishaTodayRecipes]

It looks so delicious and yummy pie dessert , thank you for this great recipe ♥♥♥

[@pamelasmith6130]

That seemed easy enough, I'm going to try it. Thank you ❤❤❤

[@Little_Mis_Abby_Rose]

Yummy! A must try cause my hubby loves coconut! Y’all did a wonderful job with your kitchen!

[@skipperry7360]

Wow, I've all but forgotten about this pie. Thank you for showing all the tricks to making Daddy's Pie.

[@roykemp6502]

Tammy & Chris, your production quality (new kitchen, remote microphone) is getting better all the time. Enjoyable rating is now 5 stars! Great recipes and a great couple! Thanks.

[@jamiwomack2129]

Your kitchen is so beautiful. Even the handles look perfect 🥰. Lol went downstairs to see if I had the 3rd cookbook. Put coconut on my shopping list 😊

[@debrareitan5305]

Looks so good 👍, I'm going to make one! Yum!

[@stevesmith4051]

That looks delicious, I could almost taste it through the screen. I'm wondering if you could add some chocolate chips to it and make a "Mounds" custard pie?

[@debrareitan5305]

Yes you can. Or just drizzle melted chocolate across the top in two directions!

[@mariedigioia5985]

Oh that sounds really good.....bc, sometimes you feel like a nut...sometimes you don't! 😊

[@barbaracotham2342]

Oh my goodness! This looks so yummy good delicious! Y'all are so great! Thanks Tammy and Chris.👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍

[@ReginaK2]

My mom had a recipe like that one but it made its own crust. It was delicious even cold…

[@diannasmith5695]

@YarnLoverRegina, that sounds like the Impossible Coconut Pie made with Bisquick except it uses regular milk not buttermilk. I'm sure if you Google it you'd find it. I don't know how to link it, sorry.

[@ReginaK2]

@@diannasmith5695 No worries Hun I will look it up thank you very much

[@lolaottinger3038]

I was late getting that recipe…only got it about 5 years ago and had made it once at my cousins house when she gave the recipe, a couple of months ago I made it again, then I started wondering if I could use well drained pineapple instead of coconut so I tried it and it worked. Next I’m going to use canned cherries.

[@ReginaK2]

@@lolaottinger3038 that’s sounds awesome and delicious

[@jobrinaworkman-thomas1551]

Impossible coconut custard pie. INGREDIENTS 4 eggs 1 ¼ cups sugar ½ cup flour ¼ cup butter melted 1 tablespoon vanilla ½ teaspoon salt 2 cups milk 1 ¼ cups shredded sweetened coconut INSTRUCTIONS Preheat oven to 350℉ and grease a 9-inch pie plate. Beat the eggs in a large bowl. Add the sugar, flour, melted butter, vanilla and salt. Whisk until combined. Add the milk and then the coconut. Stir until combined then pour into the prepared pie plate. Bake for 40-45 minutes or until a toothpick pressed into the center of the pie comes out clean. Let cool on a wire rack for at least an hour to set up. Serve warm with whipped topping, if desired.

[@patriciahartless2095]

😊 Hello Tammy And Chris . Your kitchen looks so beautiful . I know you're happy . That it's finished . Your custard pie . look so delicious . Have a great weekend .

[@lindamichael7903]

It looks very good and i know it tastes just as good

[@a_ya_la]

My Aunt made this pie for me all the time. So will be making it this Sunday and Congratulations 🎉 to your new Kitchen

[@CollardValleyCooks]

Hope you enjoy

[@marthav2772]

Hooray, its finished!😃🎉🎈👍 I know you're going to love it! Can't wait for another delicious something from your new, beautiful kitchen! 😉

[@user-dc9zx4zv7z]

Buttermilk and coconut? Sold! Love the new kitchen ❤

[@heidid5275]

Oh Tammy, that looks awesome!! Your kitchen is gorgeous.

[@MrsRassie]

Looks good. I love coconut. Hope you have a nice weekend you 2.

[@QIKWIA]

Beautiful and functional kitchen! Love everything about it!💯

[@crockerscrazyliving3619]

The kitchen looks beautiful

[@patriciamorrison5372]

Your Kitchen is Beautiful. I also went with White real wood cabinets in mine. My Husband & I Love it. The lighting also makes you look even more Beautiful ! Congratulations on your remodel.

[@marieagostinelli4085]

Hi Tammy I heard from Leslie (the far,I got pastor’s wife) that Chris has a channel to so I’d like to know the name of his channel too. Love you guys! ❤

[@CollardValleyCooks]

Nichols Retirement Empire

[@marieagostinelli4085]

Thanks @@CollardValleyCooks

[@pamelamontgomery6453]

Sounds delicious and easy to make! I have never made one, but will now.

[@juliebiever6693]

Tammy, please read your Oven Manual, and see is it is safe to line the bottom of your oven with foil. The last three ovens I have bought for remolding my kitchens have all said NO FOIL. If you look back at this video you will see your foils, trying to breath. I just don’t want you to ruin your Cadillac oven. Please take my ADVISE. READ THE MANUAL TO MAKE SURE IT IS OK.!

[@donnastratton8397]

Yeah my manuel says not to, so I just put a foil pan on the bottom rack.

[@RoseSharon7777]

If the heating element is under the metal base, the foil is a big NO NO. I argued with my mother about this for about 6 months until her oven started heating uneven then broke within a year.

[@jettabartholomew1118]

My oven is the same.

[@Daisy-or4pm]

Just wondering you put foil on the bottom of the oven. This reflects the heat.

[@Daisy-or4pm]

Why do you put foil on the bottom of your oven?

[@chicanorobert1]

I'm gonna call u my cooking buddy. Love Nana,u and ur husband take care

[@hisservantsconstruction]

Sound is good and clear and the pie looks great!

[@garaines]

Note: Never place aluminum foil on the bottom of your oven to catch spills. The foil disrupts the oven's air flow and heat pattern, resulting in uneven cooking. Cleanup is so easy with the tips below that foil is completely unnecessary.

[@milliegriffin2294]

Love the kitchen, love the pie! What depth is your sink? I am getting ready to replace ours, and faucet.

[@CollardValleyCooks]

It is linked on collardvalleycooks.com

[@halfadime09]

Oven temp? Bake time? Please include this info in future videos, but this looks amazing anyway. Good looking pie and I just love coconut custard. Yummy!

[@CollardValleyCooks]

All videos have links to the written recipe for you and they are all printable from collardvalleycooks.com

[@pacospete4299]

In my opinion more people today are more likely to have yogurt in their frig than buttermilk ..... great substitute in a 1/1 ratio

[@dr.jacquelynminor4506]

This was my first time watching, and I loved it! This recipe is a family favorite on Thanksgiving, but I've never tried baking my own, so I'm definitely going to try your recipe a few times to get it ready for our Thanksgiving table! ❤😊

[@gloriafulghum1255]

Love anything coconut, especially pie! Can’t wait to cook! Love your beautiful kitchen!❤️

[@tonytherf-mb3dg]

Hey guy's, the pie looks good and the new kitchen looks great. 👌

[@griffin7146]

I made this for Christmas and it was a huge success! I whipped some cream for the top.

[@CollardValleyCooks]

Sounds great!

[@rosiebennett7808]

Mmm,Mmm Yum 😋 I really love coconut 🥥 custard pie so good ! 😊❤🥧

[@judithbullard6676]

Your kitchen is beautiful. Good luck and many happy hours of cooking. The pie is next on my list to try.

[@judyabernathy80]

You are such a darling person, Tammy. I love your personality!! ♥️🙏🏼♥️

[@jantaylor7079]

Hi Tammy, your kitchen looks beautiful!! Congratulations🙂

[@marthab255]

I was always told heat reflecting off foil causes more heat and if you want a liner in the oven you should use silicone. I put my pies on a bake sheet in case they run over. So much easier to get out of the oven too. I am such a clutz with small hit things😀I just read about foil no no in oven. I say no to foil too.

[@pathunterdohner9052]

My Daddy loved coconut cake. His favorite!

[@karensheart]

Thank you so much for sharing this! This is my favorite pie. Congradulations on your new kitchen! ❤

[@laureencortese8588]

Absolutely beautiful kitchen ❤❤❤ the pie looks sooooooo good ❤❤❤

[@cathyorseske2564]

Glad to see you cooking in your new kitchen. Good luck Tammy

[@bethmcgill5944]

Why not use vanilla extract?

[@CollardValleyCooks]

You can

[@DianeC.]

Hi Tammy!!! The pie really does look mighty delicious. I'll have to give it a try. Your new sink and counter looks very nice. Hope you enjoy your new kitchen...Great Video!!!...🦋

[@shirleyvincent131]

Love the kitchen and that pie looks so yummy 😋

[@danielledougherty4095]

That looks sooooo good! I'm definitely going to try this!

[@brianstephens8809]

After making a batch of butter, I have buttermilk and not the kind from the store which would be cultured. Would that change the taste of my pie or have you ever used real homemade buttermilk? Thank you for your time and happy holidays to you and Kritter.

[@CollardValleyCooks]

Not at all

[@penniecurrie2424]

Mrs Tammy if you don't have a rooster how r you getting eggs,I was raised on a farm we always had chickens and two roosters????

[@lildebra7941]

I love the black hardware that’s what I have on my white kitchen cabinets beautiful, love your new kitchen

[@suezq9155]

Tammy you looks so beautiful in this video, I haven’t seen you for awhile and I was thinking “she is looking cute”. Wonderful recipe thank you for your time teaching. I love cooking. Say hi to the hubby, kitchen looks lovely.

[@kathrynreed9724]

The pie looked delicious. That is my husband’s favorite pie. I could never find the recipe that his mom made but this I think may be the one. The other recipes that I tried just had to much sugar.

[@ramonadooley2628]

No other coconut like Bakers . Wish they still had the Bakers canned coconut 🥥

[@user-wk4nt2ef6z]

You make things looks so simple to make and delicious to want to eat. Thank you for alwayz veibg you. Love your new kitchen remodel. So happy for y’all.

[@chicanorobert1]

I watch u all the time, I think ur really good at making cakes,this dessert 🍰 looks great. U cook realistically. There may be mishaps in the kitchen, but that's real cooking.luv ya sister Tammy, God bless u and ur family. Amen

[@nedrawatson4022]

That pie looks 👌 so good OMG I can just imagine how it tastes. I got to make one. Take care my friends ❤️ 😊

[@CountrySweet]

I never seen the actual recipe of how much vanilla or how long to bake this pie

[@CollardValleyCooks]

It is linked to collardvalleycooks.com and free to print

[@sherrybaird570]

That looks delicious but I'm afraid I would eat the whole pie by myself. Yet I'm going to chance it maybe tomorrow. My Aunt makes this for my Daddy and she puts pineapple in it instead of coconut. Either way I know it will be so good.

[@carolspencer9396]

That pie looks delectable! I keep telling you, I shouldn't watch you at 2:30 in the morning. Yum!

[@williamcleland]

Beautiful pie. I'd try hot fudge sauce on a piece. Heavenly.

[@dianegraham2546]

Love your new kitchen and Love that coconut custard pie.

[@alcorn1959]

HI Mrs tammy...love your new kitchen... oh btw hi Mr chris

[@macman3175]

Hey! the audio sounds great,- and the production value is a lot better too, I knew you could do it ! God bless

[@shirleywine714]

I love coconut your pie looks so good your channel is great

[@titasmom678]

Looks yummy. I've seen other recipes that use coconut milk or sweetened condensed coconut milk instead of regular milk, so maybe Ill try a combo of buttermilk and coconut milk.

[@janetbuckley3724]

I love her recipes! Your kitchen is beautiful and I’m sure it has all your needed amenities.

[@Lgm4375]

Pie looks yummy good and pretty! Love the finished kitchen and love, love seeing the puppy dogs walking around.😊

[@sarahsmith5998]

Tammy, made this pie by your recipe and it was a hit. So Lucious and good. Thanks!

[@CollardValleyCooks]

So glad!

[@joshuahawley2264]

Tammy my Mamaw loves this pie she's been making it for years! I think I'm going to make this one or your buttermilk to take to a friend's house tomorrow. They've been in and out of hospitals here lately. I feel I need to do something and food is always a good idea!

[@kathysantos2594]

Just love the new kitchen! That pie looks incredible!! Can't wait to try to make it! Bless you both.

[@QIKWIA]

👀🏆🔥👍🏾👊🏾 🫢OMGGGG!!!! What a pie!!!😋 Looks toooo good!

[@elaineblack-fh9sd]

you're not telling how high I'm supposed to cook the pie when I put it in the oven is it $375 degrees or how much

[@CollardValleyCooks]

The written recipe is linked in the description for you

[@Lindasromperroom]

Where do you buy your pie crusts please? Beautiful kitchen Tammy!

[@CollardValleyCooks]

Believe it or not Walmart

[@anthonydolio8118]

Thanks Tammy. We had coconut custard pie for all the big holidays.

[@lindashockley2840]

Girl, you are making my favorite pie !

[@rubytaylor4566]

Yummy , I put coconut in some of my sweet potato pies, coconut pie and coconut cake are my Favorite. Thanks for going back and sharing recipes from your first cookbook!!!!❤😊🙏🏻 Ms Ruby

[@StephenMarks-yn1js]

I just made two and they turned out 👍👍 two thumbs

[@CollardValleyCooks]

Awesome!

[@mjwatt17]

What temperature did you cook it at, and for how long?

[@CollardValleyCooks]

The written recipe is linked in the description for you

[@kymdisney11]

You know I'm a faithful viewer..., I don't care for coconut, but I watched this video to see your latest kitchen update! Lol! It sure looks beautiful! You must be so happy!!! 😁😁😁

[@ragathnor326]

I cant get coconut custard pie down here in South Florida which is so sad for me. Its been 30+ years since I have had any. Am gonna try your recipe!