Watch This Before Buying a Subaru or Mazda

Watch This Before Buying a Subaru or Mazda, DIY and car review with auto mechanic Scotty Kilmer. Subaru Forester car review. Mazda CX-5 car review. Who makes the worst Japanese car, Subaru or Mazda? Which Japanese car manufacturer makes the most reliable car, Mazda or Subaru? Are Subarus still reliable? Are Mazda cars any good? Which car is worth buying, Subaru or Mazda? Is Mazda a better bargain than Subaru? Car Advice. DIY car repair with Scotty Kilmer, an auto mechanic for the last 53 years.
⬇️Scotty’s Top DIY Tools:
1. Bluetooth Scan Tool: amzn.to/2nfvmaD
2. Mid-Grade Scan Tool: amzn.to/33dKI0k
3. My Fancy (Originally $5,000) Professional Scan Tool: amzn.to/31khBXC
4. Cheap Scan Tool: amzn.to/2D8Tvae
5. Dash Cam (Every Car Should Have One): amzn.to/2YQW36t
6. Basic Mechanic Tool Set: amzn.to/2tEr6Ce
7. Professional Socket Set: amzn.to/2Bzmccg
8. Ratcheting Wrench Set: amzn.to/2BQjj8A
9. No Charging Required Car Jump Starter: amzn.to/2CthnUU
10. Battery Pack Car Jump Starter: amzn.to/2nrc6qR
⬇️Scotty’s Top DIY Tools:
1. Bluetooth Scan Tool: amzn.to/2nfvmaD
2. Cheap Scan Tool: amzn.to/2D8Tvae
3. Professional Socket Set: amzn.to/2Bzmccg
4. Wrench Set: amzn.to/2kmBaOU
5. No Charging Required Car Jump Starter: amzn.to/2CthnUU
6. Battery Pack Car Jump Starter: amzn.to/2nrc6qR
🛠Check out the tools I use and highly recommend ► goo.gl/rwYt2y
🔥Scotty Shirts and Merch ► goo.gl/pTAeca
Subscribe and hit the notification bell! ► goo.gl/CFismN
Scotty on Social:
Facebook ► / scottymechanic
Instagram ► / scotty_the_mechanic
Twitter ► Scottymechanic?la...
This is the people's automotive channel! The most honest and funniest car channel on KZbin. Never any sponsored content, just the truth about everything! Learn how to fix your car and how it works. Get a chance to show off your own car on Sundays. Or show off your own car mod on Wednesdays. Tool giveaways every Monday to help you with your own car projects. We have a new video every day! I've been an auto mechanic for the past 50 years and I'm here to share my knowledge with you.
►Here's our weekly video schedule:
Monday: Tool giveaway
Tuesday: Auto repair video
Wednesday: Viewers car mod show off
Thursday: Viewer Car Question Video AND Live Car Q&A
Friday: Auto repair video
Saturday: Second Live Car Q&A
Sunday: Viewers car show off
►Second Daily Upload Every Afternoon of Live Car Q&A videos as well!
Scotty Kilmer is a participant in the Amazon Influencer Program.
#savagescotty

[@scottykilmer]

Doing This Will Make Your Engine Last Forever: kzbin.info/www/bejne/eZnFk4Vje6qLY5o Thanks for watching! Like and Subscribe for More Vids Daily ► kzbin.info/door/uxpxCCevIlF-k-K5YU8XPA ⬇️Scotty’s Top DIY Tools: 1. Bluetooth Scan Tool: amzn.to/2nfvmaD 2. Mid-Grade Scan Tool: amzn.to/33dKI0k 3. My Fancy (Originally $5,000) Professional Scan Tool: amzn.to/31khBXC 4. Cheap Scan Tool: amzn.to/2D8Tvae 5. Dash Cam (Every Car Should Have One): amzn.to/2YQW36t 6. Basic Mechanic Tool Set: amzn.to/2tEr6Ce 7. Professional Socket Set: amzn.to/2Bzmccg 8. Ratcheting Wrench Set: amzn.to/2BQjj8A 9. No Charging Required Car Jump Starter: amzn.to/3i7SH5D 10. Battery Pack Car Jump Starter: amzn.to/2nrc6qR ⬇️ Things used in this video: 1. Common Sense 2. 4k Camera: amzn.to/2HkjavH 3. Camera Microphone: amzn.to/2Evn167 4. Camera Tripod: amzn.to/2Jwog8S 5. My computer for editing / uploading: amzn.to/301tYt9 🛠Check out the tools I use and highly recommend ► goo.gl/rwYt2y Subscribe and hit the notification bell! ► goo.gl/CFismN

[@bebetovassell2814]

Cx5

[@savannahmatcham7633]

Your thoughts on the Impreza? I assume its a very similar platform

[@donotcare44]

Scotty, I need to know if this is worth getting - 2010 Mercury Milan, 4 cyl. 2.5 with 87,000 miles? Mercury went out of business in 2011 so, would there be an issue with getting parts for fixes?

[@MIT-zj8yx]

Hi Uncle Scotty~ Could you share with us of what do you think of European car brands in particular that are made in France? Like Peugeot, Renault, and Citroen. I'm hearing from friends that they are pretty good, affordable, and reliable for an European brand compared to the Germans. And most of the technical problems are mostly small trivial issues. I heard so far Renault and Peugeot are the best. In Africa, those old Peugeots cars, like as old as post colonial era, are almost as good as Toyotas. Reliable, its engine refuses to die even in the harsh African dusty roads. Hope to hear your thoughts on it.

[@fromthebackofmymind]

@Samuel Jesse Jonah Are you just a tool, 24/7? Your jocularity is hokey.

[@dorothypollex1329]

Bought a CX5 in 2014 and had nearly zero problems in 8 years. Incredibly reliable after 111,000 miles.

[@mrchefcheck]

I got a 2014 mazda 3 2.5L. 125k miles now and no issues other than the usual brake job.

[@thomasward00]

We just bought my wife a new CX30 with NA 2.5L

[@sbalak]

Well said. Have a 2015 CX5 146,00 miles. Replaced 1 engine mount and belt tensioner. The car had 40 miles on it when purchased and most likely had been abused by testers.

[@prestozer]

wow, that's amazing

[@waterisgood2051]

how many miles do you have on it now? And is it still good? Had any problems? I have a model from 2013

[@Maiant]

As a 2016 cx-5 owner with nearly 100k miles on it. I highly recommend. The only problem we've had, is the latch for the middle console broke. Almost 6 years, and 100,000 miles, that's not too bad.

[@justinstorie7663]

That is exactly the same issue I had with my Mazda 3 only broke the latch on the center console with 109,000 miles I cannot complain.

[@craigsbuyer2270]

My 2016 cx5 has been problem free I bought it used and happy with it

[@polo08vw44]

Cannot complain very good cars no problems at all only went to mechanics for servicing, even my CX7.

[@tacuazinful]

My cousin has a 2015 2.5L awd CX5 with 190,000 miles and is running like new, Mine has 49K miles runs like new too

[@inodesnet]

The dealers can source parts very easily for that. Simple fix.

[@DenNEE]

My 2019 Mazda CX-5 is the best vehicle I have ever owned, and I have been driving for over 50 years.

[@badger3184]

I wish this guy was my neighbor. It would be entertaining watching him yell in his driveway. I really appreciate his honesty. Rare trait nowadays

[@hectorsantiago5350]

The 1st Gen Forester will always be a classic! Simple, yet effective!

[@___AWFUL___]

Thank god for cars because Scotty will never run out of content lol

[@terracotta6294]

Thank God for @ScottyMechanic cuz cars never run out of content.

[@sbs-0055]

Content is going to run out of Scotty instead.

[@cnunesoregon]

Last year I bought a 2020 Mazda CX-5. Couldn’t be happier. Easily the best car I have owned. Traded in my Honda Civic. No complaints about my Honda but the Mazda drives so much smoother. My only complaint about my Civic was the tire pressure monitor was so sensitive that every time the weather changed, the pressure monitor would go off. I will probably have my Mazda forever.

[@cdclinic]

I am impressed how Scotty organizes these videos. It's really informative and worth the watch.

[@FuryfistX]

he naturally has an editor.

[@jimwarniers1160]

I have owned Mazda's since buying a new 2006 Mazda 3. In 176,000 miles it never gave me any problems and all I had to do was keep up with oil changes, air filters and tires. In 2020 I bought a Mazda CX-5 and am thoroughly enjoying it as well. I believe that you get a lot for your money with a Mazda.

[@tripolitan]

Not to mention its sex appeal !

[@BrennanDG]

Glad to hear, just bought a 2018 cx5

[@edcipriani8873]

Jim Warniers - I wish I had your experience with my previously owned 2007 Mazda 3. I bought it brand new, and had 2 issues with it. First off, after the car was about 3-4 years old, I could not roll down the 2 front windows in the hot summer months here in Florida. I tried working through this issue, but continued to have this problem every summer, even after the 2 motors in both front windows were replaced. Thankfully I bought an extended warranty, because both of these repairs were covered using that EW. Even after the motors were replaced I had the same problems with the 2 front windows during the summer. 2nd issue with the Mazda 3 is once the car hit just over 80K, the AC kept breaking down. First repair was again covered under the Extended Warranty, but had continuous problems with AC up until I traded it in for a Hyundai in late 2015. BTW, I have owned 3 Hyundais since the mid 90's and the '07 Mazda 3 by far had the worst reliability of all of these cars. I know my experience is probably not typical, most other Mazda owners swear by their cars and keep buying them. I probably will continue to buy Hyundai, or go with Honda or Toyota in the future. Other than those 2 issues, I still loved that Mazda, it was the base engine with stick shift, and that car was fun as hell to drive. The current model Mazda 3 is probably the best looking compact car out on the road. I have seen that car in sort of a blue-gray color, and it's FN amazing looking.

[@liljess1982]

@@edcipriani8873 back then Mazda’s we’re practically built by Ford and that is probably why you had so many problems with that car. I believe it was 2010 or 2011 Mazda completely severed ties with Ford and they are their own entity now. Right now Mazda’s are being built in Japan rather than Mexico, better build quality . Mazda has made a lot of changes since 2007.

[@edcipriani8873]

​@@liljess1982- Yeah I had known about Ford owning part of Mazda for many years as well. I have never owned a Ford, and probably never will. Back at the end of 2015 when I was looking at new cars and looking to get rid of the the Mazda3, I looked at the Focus, which did get great ratings as far as the car's agility and handling. At that time I just didn't want to consider another Mazda, and wanted to go back to an automatic after having the stick shift Mazda for almost 9 years. Don't get me wrong, that Mazda3 with the stick was a great driving experience, but driving a stick in constant heavy traffic is a PITA. Shortly after taking a Focus out for a test drive, I found out about the dual clutch automatic transmission problems. Looks like there's a class action lawsuit now with the Focus, including the 2015-2016 models which I was considering. And Ford just seemed to drag their feet about this issue, being that it started in 2012 with the Focus. Currently driving a Hyundai Elantra, the car is great, but I may have to look elsewhere next time instead of Hyundai. The redesigned 2021 Elantra is ugly as hell and that front end is a disaster. Hyundai's design philosophy is that each vehicle must stand out on its own visually. Yeah, it definitely stands out. I am not sure what Hyundai designers are smoking and snorting, but if they continue with these crappy designs, I will go elsewhere. With the exception of the 2nd gen Mazda 3, which had serious trout pout, the other Mazda 3's were and are fantastic looking cars. And the new 2022 Honda Civic is the best looking one so far. Other Mazda owners whom I know swear by their Mazdas, and buy them over and over again. I wish I had that same experience with my Mazda 3. If I have to eliminate Hyundai down the road for extreme fugliness then I might have to reconsider Mazda.

[@Nubber]

Just bought a 2021 Forester Touring (made in Japan) the end of May. Drove to Nashville two weeks later on vacation. I now have a little over 5000 miles on it. It drives and rides like a dream. Test drove the Honda CRV and the Toyota RAV 4. Love this Forester.

[@ofcbob6391]

Nubber, only thing held me back from buying a Forester was all that piano black around the infotainment and AC controls. How do you put up with all that surface acting as a dust magnet?

[@jeffstone28]

I'm now looking at the 21 Forester and 21 Outback and haven't decided yet. A possible deal breaker for the Outback is that the climate controls can only be accessed through multiple presses of the touchscreen. I much prefer the actual buttons and knobs in the Forester. Easier and much safer.

[@takuyatanaka5587]

Keep oil in your trunk. You’re going to need it.

[@richardpolcsak1158]

My 2020 CR-V has an edge on anything Subaru. Test drove the Forester before "running" to Honda.

[@Nubber]

@@richardpolcsak1158 I am glad you love your CR-V. I test drove the CR-V and liked it, but the Forester drove better for me. I am old and the Forester was more comfortable on my old bones. lol

[@BetoSmith89]

I had to make this choice 6 months ago, I got the CX-5 AWD and I’m extremely happy. This comes from a former subi owner.

[@johnedieter739]

I'm trying to decide between the CX-5 AWD and the Q3. I wasn't too pleased with the Q3 trim/price versus the CX-5...

[@BetoSmith89]

@@johnedieter739 I got the CX-5 AWD Grand Touring and I have everything I need and more on it, AppleCarPlay, Bose System, leather seats, Adaptive cruise control and radar, moving headlights, an other perks. My parents have the Q5 and I can’t tell you the difference is almost zero. Something important to keep in mind, the maintenance on it is cheaper than the Audi. I just changed the transmission fluid and it was quite cheap and simple, something you can’t see on an Audi. I’m extremely happy with my car and I feel I made the right decision. Something important to let you know is for what ever reason, the leather on my steering wheel started to peel off, some people said that is cover under warranty but I haven’t take it to the dealer. If you get one, babysit the steering wheel and always use a sun shade.

[@Sir.Black.]

What about handling or "off-roading'?

[@BetoSmith89]

@@Sir.Black. I took it to different places like Lake Tahoe, Grand Canyon and Joshua’s Tree and I have no complaints, the AWD kicks in as soon as I loose track on the back wheels.

[@johnedieter739]

@@BetoSmith89 I put a deposit on the CX-5 GT last week. it's a 2021 1/2, so it comes with a few things that the 2021 didn't have up here in Toronto, such as the improved size infotainment display. Looking forwards to it.

[@followufollowme]

Mazda has the most beautiful design of ALL.

[@drevil2783]

True...even though i love toyota

[@Yoonalayciangelo]

Yeah, and a beautiful price too.

[@adam145]

Yeah I can't understand why no other manufacturers can make cars that are simpler on the shapes with less creases and just more elegant lines. European cars are ridiculous. There's body lines everywhere, with creases and bezels running all around with no purpouse.

[@ltwig476]

Agree. Except their front seat comfort was the greatest deal breaker for me. The Cx5 is 10 cubes smaller than Forester with seats folded down. I drove a 2021 CX5 and it handled fine, but was no match for the handling of Subaru's unique AWD. I drive an 07 Tribeca with perfect maintenance and never been in the shop. I hate going to CVT. So I might order the 2022 Forester and trade it in for the new CX50 after just 3 years if Mazda fixes those extremely poor front seats.

[@allenrj1]

Sorry, but Leonardo Da Vinci would have to disagree

[@jerwinafable5840]

Mazda CX-5 no doubt. Have it and zero problem...

[@ostrichesarecool2635]

I got a CX5 recently and it is an amazing car, reliable, comfortable and also the ride is super quiet!

[@jd8mm738]

Love my 2013 Forester. I've owned many different makes of cars, and I am very impressed. 3rd generation has the improved head gaskets and oil consumption isn't really an issue. Never been a fan of CVTs, so the manual is definitely the way to go!

[@crazeyjoe]

My preference of the two is the CX-5.

[@ralphchristianson]

I have had my CX5 since January 2017, and it is still running just fine.

[@brianhill4995]

Same here we brought new in 2017 CX5 77k never been back to the dealer I do my own oil changes.

[@vidar8117]

@@ralphchristianson you got probably the golden year for the cx5, 2019 have infotainment/electrical issues and 2020 have egr’s in the exhaust for emissions

[@mela6046]

@@ralphchristianson 2017 CX 3 Touring awd automatic in NYC change oil at 5K miles...runs like butter....

[@JosueLopez-te1ek]

@@ralphchristianson it's been only 3 years should be running good I have my 96 Toyota with 279k and still not check engine light on that a champion

[@melkorvast]

Thank you Scotty for constantly upping your game.

[@scotchbudmeister9018]

I chose the 2020 Mazda CX-5. I sprung for the Grand Touring Reserve turbo. It's a blast to drive 👍

[@davesuddreth3749]

I love my 2014 Mazda 3. 150,000 miles and still going strong. Regular oil changes and transmission fluid changes

[@TrueGold88]

Mazda is a great underrated company, I really like the Mazda 6, It's a reliable good looking car!

[@bookooc5605]

I have a 2010 Mazda 3GT. Love it. bought it new.

[@thundergato84]

The new Mazda6 will be even better. I'll be RWD with a inline 6.

[@davidy80]

@TrueGold88 I have a 2014 Mazda 6, it looks great, has never put a foot wrong and I average 42mpg, so yeah, I agree entirely.

[@insideoutsideupsidedown2218]

Since they got out from under the Ford Motor Co. umbrella they really have been able to shine.

[@kendallsmith1458]

Own my 4th Mazda - 20 CX30. I'm convinced

[@thinkmore2975]

Just bought a 2021 cx-5 and i am so happy. Mazda for life now

[@poncho828]

I think they look the best compared to the competition

[@JetEarlewood]

Mazda Jigoku. Mazda Hell. That’s commonly said in Japan due to the weak resale value.

[@MAli-os2yj]

@@JetEarlewood its second after subaru. Subaru resales at 60%. Mazda and Toyota tied at 58%.

[@mlinton3007]

Very happy to say we have one of each for our two vehicles Subaru 2018 Forester and Mazda 2021 CX5. Love both

[@randyhinderman4768]

We bought a Forester in May of 2020. People ask me if I like it. I tell them no, I love it. It handles great on the road and the auto vehicle hold feature makes driving in town a lot less stressful because the car does not require you to hold the brake down at stop lights. On the highway the auto lane assist keeps you centered in your lane. All that is required is a slight stroking of the steering wheel. Our mileage may not be as much as some but we are happy so far.

[@Chillehhhh]

Which trim did you buy?

[@AmboyChamblis]

😂😂😂✨👍

[@bradhaines3142]

my highlander hybrid has all that, and gets 35mpg, i love that car more than anything i've ever owned.

[@lehbeltman]

Bought a 2016 CX-5 new, 110k mikes now and absolutely no maintenance issues. Probably the most reliable car I’ve ever own.

[@seanthompson8071]

@@devenmellor Some Mazdas are made in Mexico. I know my 2015 Mazda 3 was ... and it's been great, but I have low miles on it.

[@af.7992]

Same here! 🙂

[@fahmidnd2]

@@seanthompson8071 Yeah some are made in mexico, it just depends on the region you buy from i think. over here in canada we got the japanese ones, i think?!?

[@brucemorris3830]

I also bought a 2016 CX5 right off the lot and it clearly (for those questioning country of origin) says right inside the driver’s door “MADE IN HIROSHIMA JAPAN”. Yes Mazda does make cars in Mexico or Malaysia or wherever labor is cheap. But they’re absolutely labeled in big capital letters when they’re made at THE REAL Mazda factory in Hiroshima. (I think the background radiation gives Mazdas superpowers when they’re built there, swear to god)

[@colbyg37]

Daily drive a 2020 Forester Limited. Love it!

[@bioheart09]

I beleive they forged the pistons and thickened the heads. Perfected design now makes me want to bank alot of money on newer subarus.

[@concernedcitizen4031]

The only problem is we cant see scotty waving his arms.

[@1337ofDiscreet1]

the subtitles are not reliable and I'm deaf so I need to watch with sign language 🤷🏻

[@Natasha831_1]

2019 Forester owner here! I love it soooooo much. I bought because it had the best visibility compared to other vehicles in its class.

[@SupaStah01]

I have a 2010 Mazda 3 with 240,000+ miles and she still runs strong. Frequent oil changes, changed tranny fluid twice, and struts is all the ole girl has needed after 11 years of solid service. Great little car 👍

[@robbflynn4325]

We bought a 2019 Forester new in November 2018. Now has 52,000 miles. No issues. Very good in the snow. Nice all round SUV. Great gas mileage, low to mid 30’s mpg. Would recommend.

[@VikingPadre]

I have had a 2009 Forester since 2012. Almost all the service was done at/by the dealer. Love the feel, the handling, the visibility, the spaciousness. I had no issues with it until it got to around 100k miles, then everything needed to be replaced, starting with the suspension, wheel bearings, a new transmission at 123k, and recently a new engine (!) at 137k. Now shopping for a new SUV, and the only reason a Forester is in consideration is 'cause I love the feel, the handling, the visibility, and the spaciousness. But a CR-V hybrid is giving it a run for the money, for the fuel efficiency of a hybrid and, frankly, for Honda's reputation for reliability. Or I'll buy another Forester and get rid of it around 90k miles.

[@robbflynn4325]

@@VikingPadre if you want reliability go for a RAV4.

[@VikingPadre]

@@robbflynn4325 Yeah, I know. On paper, it's the winner. I just didn't like the driving experience of the RAV4.

[@robbflynn4325]

@@VikingPadre yeah my wife and I both drove the RAV4 and the CRV and preferred the Forester. Either one would be a pretty good choice. The CX5 is another good SUV.

[@VikingPadre]

@@robbflynn4325 Yeah, for the highly-subjective driving experience, I'd put the CX-5 above the RAV4 and below the CR-V. But the Forester tops them all.

[@Jruth68]

Thank you for this Scotty, it was Perfect. I'm in the process of buying 2020 CX-5 right now. You have given me some piece of mind on my choice of vehicles.

[@tkogene]

I own a 2017 Mazda CX-9 with 100k miles on it and it's been amazing! Beautiful to drive and zero issues. It's quick, quiet, handles great, and quality is top notch.

[@prophetewelsamueljones8923]

I am leaning towards the CX-5,Amen!!!

[@10XGems]

CX 5 suck!

[@RobSteinhauer]

I have always owned American made cars in 2020 bought a Mazda CX-5 Love it best vehicle I have ever owned

[@mattevans1643]

I used to exclusively buy American, now i wouldn't touch them with a 10 ft pole. They're junk.

[@ericclaeyborn3600]

Before I bought my 2021 CX-5 CE Turbo w/AWD, I was seriously looking for an American-made car to buy. It seemed like every one of them had either Engine Stop/Start or a CVT in them. Whatever a union or government touches eventually turns to garbage.

[@goddess_posh]

My Subaru Forester 2.0i-S Eyesight just turned 1 year and its so great! Super reliable, easy to use and comfortable especially with the new Eyesight feature! Plus its forever AWD! Love my Subie!

[@braddahmike8974]

It was because of Scotty we bought the Mazda CX-5. 2021 model and love it. All built in Japan! Big factor and NO CVT Trans! Best decision we made! Thank you Scotty for you honesty and education you give us.

[@stephendove5747]

Cvt has been excellent since 2019 models.

[@casimoran]

Turbo or non?

[@stephendove5747]

@@casimoran turbo still great milage and ride

[@kimberlya9591]

@braddahmike8974 - I get confused with Scotty's recommendation on CVT and Turbo and manual vs automatic. Does he not recommend the CVT and/or turbo? Or only if it's with manual? Or no automatic period? Lol! I watch so many of his videos, I get confused on what he's recommending and what year, make, model, etc..

[@joseolaguera7785]

Love my 2019 CX-5 Touring. Fantastic blend of affordability and features. Best feature is the cockpit - so clean and sleek. Its competitor’s cockpits are overcluttered but the Mazda’s is so easy to navigate. The exterior design is simple and classic and reminds me of the profile of high-end luxury crossovers. Get it in machine gray metallic - the look will never get old!

[@DaBudaa1]

I have a 2013 Forester with 103,000 miles. I change the engine oil & filter every 5000 miles, instead of 7500 miles. I also kept up with the transmission and differential service intervals. Recently, I took it to the dealer to have the thermostat replace and coolant flush; the thermostat was not broken, it was more of a precaution, since I've replaced multitudes of engines due to a faulty thermostat.

[@imbrudedsoul]

My 09 base model forester is still running like a boss. Just did a 1k mile trip from CLE to the outer banks, not a single problem!

[@kosmic8204]

This is a great one scotty. Thank you. Please do one on a 2017 forester limited. Thank you.

[@g5alive795]

I owned a 99' forrester, great car. Picked up a 97' outback in 05' w/ 85k & today w/ over 210k, it's still chuggin' along. GREAT CAR!

[@LIFETEEN48]

So so glad about this report. Thank you so much!!!

[@RobertBeedle]

If you’re looking for one. The Mazda CX-5 is the better way to go

[@eskieman3948]

@@RobertBeedle I imagine you sell them....

[@theillegitking1304]

Scotty your videos made me get rid of my crappy jetta and get a 2014 honda accord exl, with the 3.5L naturally aspirated V6. Couldn't be happier!

[@Shadobanned4life]

Scotty I appreciate your good,solid advice. Thank You Sir!

[@declansdad]

I've owned 1 Mazda and 4 Subarus. Sadly, the Mazda was a troubled vehicle (MPV) that I spent entirely too much money to keep it running. Traded that in on an Outback for the wife and she was thrilled....now many years later, the Outback has become the daughter's car and my wife is the proud owner of an new Ascent. My first Subaru was a model year 2000 Forester S with a manual 5 speed--great car and I never had an issue with it. 5 years later, I traded that Forester in for a 2005 Forester XT with a 5 speed manual--modded that car and kept it for 7 years--again, never an issue, even with the modifications. To this day, the FXT is the car I miss driving the most--wish I had never sold it!

[@bryanwilliams4620]

My wife had a new 2010 Forester. We liked the car and the AWD but it started burning oil after about two years. Traded it for a new 2013 Accord Sport 6speed. We still have the Accord...

[@noventay4]

Well if you start changing the oil on jiffy lube or Firestone that's what you're asking for

[@ansv3340]

burning oil and Subaru were together for live)) many jokes out there, that owners never have to change their oil, because they always keep adding fresh oil.

[@sammyjammy6647]

Have any of you had paint issues with your Honda? There’s literally a Facebook group with thousands of members who have had chipping paint and faded paint issues with their Hondas even recent ones like a 2019 model

[@MrQuickscopes34]

2017 Accord V6 here, she purrs and will continue to purr for the next 25 years.

[@Xyb3rTeCh]

You can't compare an SUV to a Sedan you nitwit

[@HossamElramy3]

I have both a 17 forester limited and a 2014 cx-5 my heart goes to the forester but my brain screams cx-5 they’re both great options as long as you take care of them they are both very reliable. I personally saw both cars on the market for sale with over 250K miles on them and they’re still running!! Either way I’d say I prefer the Subaru just because of the amazing All Wheel Drive system it has!

[@Hdlc27]

Brain over heart. Logic over feelings yet you went with feelings smh good luck

[@ploughable]

Nice video, I had to choose 1 month ago and I got an used Mazda CX-5 with full options AWD 2.2 diesel 175 HP from 2016. I'm very happy with the choice from both engine and the Safety/ADAS technologies after doing already 3.000 km

[@hmcmullian4842]

We have both. 2010 Forester with 220k miles and a 2015 CX5. Honestly, I love them both. The Mazda is more zippy, but the Subaru is more responsive and solid on the road.

[@ayubmukabi3820]

Subaru is unique is a dependable car if use the right mechanic and genuine parts

[@markzimmermann3982]

Hey Scotty, I did listen and I did watch A lot of your videos, are used to drive Volkswagens, and now I am a proud owner of a 2017 Mazda CX-5 and I’m so glad I made the switch just like you said in your video it’s a very quiet ride there’s even times when my passengers asked me if my car is still running, no engine noise or road noise I am very happy with the quality of this vehicle and I will definitely be a Mazda owner for life😎

[@divak9026]

Have a 2016 CX-5. Never had a problem. Really pleased!

[@Moshishak1]

Thank you for your dedicated and impressive presentations.

[@techngizmosINC]

I have a daily 2014 cx5 that I have owned since new I have only ever changed oil , brakes and tires at the dealer , and once replaced coil 1and 3 and two rear shocks . It now has 310,000 miles and still drives likes it’s brand new . I will always buy a Mazda from this experience .

[@dashdfklasjd]

Is it still running to this day if so how many miles on it

[@shimonbiton2163]

i was driving automatics all my life and with the subaru B3 i noticed i enjoyed using the tiptronic, after 12 years of wonderful experience i sold the B3 and 5 months back i decided to get a manual transmission car 16 years after the last time i drove one. BEST DECISION IVE MADE. i enjoy driving so much more now, makes me feel excited to go out on a drive like when i was in high school.

[@brucemorris3830]

You can’t actually DRIVE until you can drive a stick shift. Welcome to the club 😂😂😂

[@oleksandrglachshyn2363]

I love my 2017 cx5 looks aggressive and beautiful, gas response unbelievable, inside beautiful, great drive!!!

[@ScottXiong]

Great video Scotty! So happy I managed to get an off-lease, low-km, 2018 CX-5 with Manual Transmission (the last year they offered it), after another driver ran a stop sign and totaled my 2014 CX-5 with MT. Spent many weeks searching, waiting, and hoping. Unfortunately, the MT's only came with the 156 HP 2.0 L engine instead of the 187 HP 2.5 L. No deactivation cylinder tech thankfully, but they did get rid of the manual e-brake for the electronic parking brake which I'm not a fan of. Came with some bonus i-activsense tech too which was not standard. Not a lot of power, but drives and handles like a dream (or overweight and oversized MX-5/miata). Also made in Japan, and you can tell the difference.

[@tammysimons4916]

If I had a choice between these two models I'd go with the Mazda.

[@mela6046]

I have Mazda all the time = ZERO problems....2002 Mazda Protege Lx automatic 4 door ... 214K miles...RUNS LIKE BUTTER...CT/NYC area

[@mela6046]

I have 2017 Mazda CX 3 Touring 18 " wheels automatic = ZERO problems....

[@highjinx6519]

Yep we have a ‘12 mazda 3 & it’s been the best car I’ve ever had until we got our ‘15 cx9. Cx9 only has a little over 50k and we’re in love with it but the 3 has almost 300k & have only done basic maintenance. Serpentine belt went once but that’s something we should have been checking or replacing before it got to 200k. My significant other and his dad Suck at maintaining cars and that thing has taken a beating and still going.

[@dragospahontu]

@@mela6046 Subaru is cool

[@mela6046]

@@dragospahontu I know that was a TOP car 4 me....the older ones made long ago....in the 80's...they went 120 mph no problem.. steering wheel shaking but aok, NO front issues = nothing....I miss that car...If I were to buy a second car I'd look 4 my old car...lol...

[@earlallnutt]

I bought the new (2018/2019) CX-5 2.2 Diesel All Wheel Drive (140 kW or 188 hp and 450 Nm or 331.903 ft lbf of torque) . Very happy. Definetly beter than the Subaru in my opinion.

[@joshcarlson9352]

I passed on the DEF fluid and took the gasoline turbo. Still a hefty 310 LB-Ft and more horses. Climbs hills like a boss.

[@drevil2783]

Agreed

[@darrensmith8673]

I have a 2015 Outback that I've owned since late 2018, 85,000 miles and no issues with regular maintenance including a cvt fluid change, which I would highly recommend if you want your cvt to last. Vehicle is amazing in snow, with better ground clearance than the CX5 and can haul more stuff... Was put off by the CX5's tiny cargo area.

[@simple7ev]

Bought my first car this month cx-5 2018 touring and love it

[@dannyven18]

I got a CX-5 Touring 2020. I love how quiet it is and love the smooth ride. Also love the sport mode.

[@73av8r5]

I agree. We traded our 2012 Mazda 5 for a 2018 CX5. What a difference….much quieter! The 5 was so loud on the road we had to yell to hear each other. We loved it other than the road/wind noise though.

[@hfdewees]

Totally, the Mazda CX-5. We have a 2013 with the 6 spd manual. It has been a great car.

[@my240sx2]

My 2019 Forester Sport is so awesome. Zero problems with ~40k. I love the torque vectoring 4 wheel drive, so fun to drive in the mountains.

[@PacificAirwave144]

I have 2014 CX-5 FWD. Nearing 58,000 miles, and I've done all my own oil changes, 33-38mpg highway and many times with 2-3 passengers, their hiking stuff, and the AC running. Maybe 29mpg average when not on long trips. Its been a gem so far.

[@rogerbamatutz1927]

I have a 2014 Touring CX5. It's been a great and reliable car for me. In fact, its been the best car I've ever owned including the way it handles.

[@gretaberry4983]

I’ve recently purchased the Maza CX5 2021 , and very satisfied with it’s performance. The drive is smooth the seats are comfortable, the motor is quiet, it’s good on gas ⛽️. I love it .👍🏽👍🏽

[@MAli-os2yj]

Just curious. Is there enough room in the back seats for 3 people to comfortably sit?

[@Xyz-gf5op]

I have a 2010 Mazda CX-9 ( my 4th Mazda) with 110k miles. It runs perfect no issues at all apart from typical maintenance. Love it ; drove from Houston to Toronto, Appalachian mountains, etc. I love the naturally aspirated V6 but not sure about buying the current 2.5 Turbo.

[@DavidMosby]

I have watched hundreds of hours of Scotty. Thanks! Looking for a 2017 CX 5.

[@dschmitt3373]

Forester has been my choice for many years. Entry into the Forester is amazingly easy for a taller or larger person. I enjoy the ride. Go Subaru!

[@haroldbeauchamp3770]

Hard pass. Oil consumption, head gaskets, failing cvt’s, axle issues. I’ll keep my Toyota’s.

[@takuyatanaka5587]

@@haroldbeauchamp3770 preach it! 🤲

[@rogersmoot6194]

@@takuyatanaka5587 He is correct about CVT problems on the Subarus. Many excellent mechanics have strongly suggested that I avoid any vehicle with a CVT.

[@sam_mce_99]

I bought a 2013 Mazda CX-5 brand new and have put 185,000 miles on it. The engine still runs like a brand new car plus there are no squeaks or rattles in the interior. The only knock I can give it is that I wish it had a more sporty transmission. This car has been so reliable that I'm sure it will get 285,000 miles no problems.

[@noventay4]

Don't think so, get rid of that ASAP

[@robertsaladino]

great to hear, just purchased a 2018 cx-5 ...

[@raulcruzquintanilla9834]

Scotty you make my days with these videos man!

[@user-oc5pe4yb3c]

I just found a new channel. Thank you I like your concept No wild rides or walk around

[@MrMattDat]

Scotty, with 3 Mazda CX-5s in my family (2013, 2015, and a 2019), and having grown up in a car family, I've got to say that the CX-5 is exceptionally well built and is standing the test of time (and that is hard time here in MA). Those underbody splash panels are priceless to reduce salt intrusion!

[@cymatic83]

I love my 2nd gen (2008) Forester. It's a perfect car IMO, if only a little loud on the road, and the seats could be softer, but can't beat the outstanding utility and handling. Unstoppable little tanks.

[@colechapman3382]

Nice. My sister has a red 2008 Forester which is surprisingly fast for a small tin can. It really is like driving in a fishbowl. I have a 2012 Outback and it’s not nearly as fast because of it’s size but the seats are more comfortable and the cabin is quieter to make up for that. We’ve been very pleased with both of our Subarus and my sister and I are probably gonna get new Subarus in the future

[@cymatic83]

@@colechapman3382 it really is like driving a greenhouse down the road. I sold my 2008 and upgraded to a 2011 Premium. Much quieter and now comfortable. Doesn't handle quite as sporty as the WRX frame Foresters but I love it.

[@andiemerri]

Have owned 2 of these 2002-2008 Foresters. My favorite car! One reached 270,000 miles. Now, I have a 2015 Forester XT.

[@tony9207]

Mazda 2020 CX-5 Owner... and appreciate the great content on the channel. Never gave Mazda a chance in prior years... glad I did. Usually a Honda / Acura buyer. But something about the Mazda CX5 - not quite a car... but not a bulky SUV.

[@blaze_it94]

Got a Cx-5 AWD and I have not regretted it fun to drive and the interior is just amazing

[@M9_Prime]

Only issue I have with my 2016 Mazda CX-5 with 155,000km is the rear brakes wear too fast. But also I should be servicing them more often but the wife says i take too long (30-45 mins a wheel). For a 2016 it still feels like a new car to me. Very solid on the inside and solid suspension.

[@brucemorris3830]

It’s funny because my 2016 eats front brake rotors at a similar distance (I’m in the US so mine is only at 83K miles lol) But I also drive on a very dangerous highway daily for work and have to make panic stops OFTEN. So I’m on my 3rd lifetime pair of front rotors but only my second pair out back. I also took Scotty’s advice and went Akebono pads on the front this time and so far they’re doing GREAT.

[@tizzy6376]

Sit back, eat your popcorn, and watch some Scotty

[@jackbrown1813]

Had a 2014 Forester. Lots of problems--both rear axle bearings, right front axle replaced, oil consumption ( 1/2 litre in 6000 killmetres-Subaru's threshold 1 litter in 11000k so ours not deemed "excessive). All this before 100k (60000 miles). Many other problems so traded on 2020 CX-5. So far very happy with CX-5.

[@jakenuno9900]

2018 CX-5 GT, zero complaints. This marks my third Mazda. 👍

[@Jaredcouture12676]

I traded my Outback in for a 2018 CX-5 and couldn’t be happier. My oil actually stays where it’s supposed to be now. Weird!

[@vidar8117]

Wait until your water pump fails in the CX5 and report any infotainment issues right away if it’s under warranty, I do recommend getting the MAP or extended warranty your dealership offers

[@Jaredcouture12676]

@@vidar8117 The dealership I bought it from gives a lifetime power train warranty on their CPO cars. Not too worried about it. I’ve heard the cylinder deactivation can cause some issues. Something goes wrong with the transition and you get a lifter tick. Had a Cadillac with cylinder deactivation years ago and it didn’t go well. We shall see 🤣

[@noventay4]

@@Jaredcouture12676 never heard of a dealership honoring those warranties they just find a way to put it on you.

[@ansv3340]

@@Jaredcouture12676 water pump is not power train! and knowing dealers they will deny any repairs under warranty just get some buckaroony from you

[@fahmidnd2]

@@noventay4 i just got a mazda 3 with unlimited power train warranty for 5 years, but ive never heard of life time

[@edwardanthony7283]

Never owned either but did drive a Mazda in the mid 80's & it was impressive.

[@markanderson350]

I bought a Mazda 5, a mini van type car new. I am quite satisfied overall. I see huge improvements in the new cars and being a former Toyota person, would recommend them. I like your style. You stick to educating us, not selling.

[@Mong0thepawn]

I am still waiting to see how well the CVT holds up. I have a 2009 Forester with the 4EAT and it has been rock solid. I bought a 2015 Forester last year when the 2009 was "totaled" by an issurance company after it was rear ended by large truck being driven by a distracted driver. Oil changes on the 2015 is easier than the 2009 because of the oil filter location. The differential oil is a lot easier to change on the 2009.

[@mihavodnik1146]

We’ve had 3 legacy in our family…all with no issues, 1st one have 500.000 km and still going strong💪👍

[@francisdereimer7953]

My wife and I bought a 2016 CX-5 and it is easily one of the BEST vehicles I have ever owned, and at 62 I've owned and driven plenty of cars. It is an extremely smooth riding car with awesome pick up and everything works and has worked perfectly. I don't known what the nay-sayers had to complain about but I thankfully have experienced none of that. At this point I plan to keep it well into the 100,000 mile range or until the wheels fall off!

[@douglashaught8773]

bought a cx-9 recently. Love it. A little bigger than the cx-5, and 3rd row if necessary. I am new to the Mazda company. I have had Chevrolets, Toyotas, and Nissans. The one Chrysler product I had the paint came off, and it only lasted 125,000 even with good maintenance. I also had trouble with both of my Nissans. Looking forward to having a long life vehicle that looks great!

[@michaelwelsh9957]

My wife has a 2016 CX 5 and it’s been great so far. There was an issue with the infotainment system, nothing with the lights. I am changing the transmission fluid at 80,000 miles.

[@thomkruise]

I had a 2018 RAV4 and liked it, but traded it in for a 2021 CX5 and absolutely love it! It has more get up and go by far. My only complaint is that the back seat has very little leg room. Everything else about it is fantastic! It’s a great car for road trips, too! Very comfy!

[@raycpronto]

yes very big let down on the cx5 is the leg room especially with two kids in car seats.

[@indotube8125]

Aybe better lexus RX 5 years old.. More comfy i guess 🙂

[@kevinintheusa8984]

I bought a new Subaru Outback in 2017 with the boxer 6 engine and loved it so much. It is still going strong today. About a year later we got our son a Mazda CX-5 and he loves it and it has a lot of the same features as my Outback but was about 10K cheaper overall. Both cars are running great today and my wife is still driving her Toyota Tundra from 2007 with over 200K miles on it.

[@MtryCapt]

I bought the 2021 CX-5 Touring SV package. This vehicle is SO much fun to drive along with great gas mileage.

[@lockinhinddanger934]

Ty very much for the comparison!

[@johnwhltson5319]

We bought a 2020 CX5 touring. We're very happy with it. Previous car was a 2014 Kia Soul+, which we took very good care of and the engine cracked with 53,000 miles on it.

[@maxbenson9982]

I stay far away from anything kia. One of the major problems across models is "catastrophic engine failure". I warned my mom not to buy a Sorento. Told her they're not made well. It died on her after 25k mi of ownership with 78k on the odometer. I loved that 'I told you'. Then she went out and bought another one with the same engine. Some people just don't learn

[@christophermunoz2568]

I don't get why people don't read reviews on cars before buying them. Kia souls like you said are bad and I would've just avoided it. 2015 consumer reviews had so many engine blown reviews.

[@johnwhltson5319]

@Christopher Munoz I thought people just didn't take care of their engines or beat the snot out of them. Foolish me.

[@mdchowdhury3874]

I was a big fan of Toyota. Recently i got a Forester 2017. Last week i was in Jasper, AB. The ride was amazing. I’ve drove so many cars but never felt that much comfort. Smooth steering, very impressive control over vehicle, rapid speed up and control again. Now i really love it and being honest, don’t wanna change this car anymore.

[@michaelbrennan7148]

Hi Scotty. I own a 2009 Subaru Forester. The car has been pretty reliable from day to day. It has a 2.5 SOHC NA engine. 4 sp AT. Vehicle consumes oil. I change oil/filter every 3k miles. Vehicle has really cool sunroof. We paid extra for navigation/DVD. Ehh maybe could have passed on that. Fluid changes ard pretty easy. Other engine repairs can be tricky. Patience and expensive tools. Storage and passenger room very good. 202k miles on the clock. . Hope is goes another 250k miles

[@ianipock4601]

As my first car I am getting my dads old 2004 Subaru Forester that we got used 5 years ago and it had a head gasket blow and a power steering pump die but since then it’s been an absolute dream for its performance

[@mvaldez5626]

Ive got a new CX30 and i absolutely love it. Coming from a sports car lover its all I want and need to take my wife and kid around its actually fun no CVT its great

[@rogersmoot6194]

You were smart not to buy one with the CVT----problems "down the road."

[@bruin4937]

Scotty, you've created such an outstanding channel, thank you! You provide your viewers with such a fantastic amount of important information to inform them of various cars' strengths and weaknesses and which cars to buy and avoid. Liked and subscribed!

[@juliayelle2942]

Yes All the Single Ladies need You Scotty. Take care and God Bless You and the amazing brain HE and your Dad gave you! Love u like a brother. Going to test drive the Mazda CX 5. I am needing more comfort and luxury. Drive my 'pickup' a 2000 FD Taurus SE wagon...68,800 mi. Been a great vehicle. Never need help with large cargo.

[@lambotama]

I bought a 2018 cx5 touring a couple months ago, installed the Mazda Android auto retrofit, and I love it

[@johnydeadboy]

As a 2013 cx5 owner with 130K miles and still running great always choosing mazda soon getting the 2023 meridian cx50, can't wait to hear your thoughts on that one.