THE BATTLE OF ANGELS! SETH vs ASTORATH!?

[@Hnlamqe]

I can feel the stress levels from Dante rising.

[@randomcenturion7264]

Poor guy just wants to die already.

[@Dreadbringer]

Someone give him More blood wine & infusions.

[@zuluactual839]

AstarStress xD

[@brandonhughes4571]

Feel? Don't you mean hear it rising

[@D3sToD3s]

"My normal calm had been compromised"

[@tanksinatra3968]

I can hear Dante saying " I am too old for this "

[@wereshem-ankh9063]

Absolutely... Whippersnappers. Lol

[@amorphoussolid8512]

For sure! And a groan afterwards as he pulls himself up to deal with crap. Like running/defending half the damn galaxy!

[@RanRayu]

i love the contrast of astorath's sadness, kindness and patience when taking care of his brothers lost to the rage, and him not taking shit from seth and just looking down on him for thinking he can tell astorath what he can and cant do.

[@Dreadbringer]

Becouse he can and he did, only one of them was a master of His chapter, Astorath was way out of place even if i respect him for His duty.

[@RanRayu]

@@Dreadbringer ye, but astorath doesnt really work within the confines of chapter and rank, his task goes beyond such things, seth can not order astorath to stop killing blood angels who are lost, he can say he will do it himself, but if astorath doesnt agree with that seth cant do anything to stop him, other than attacking him. the only one astorath would listen to is dante if given an order, and that is because he is dante. i could be wrong, been awhile since i read anything warhammer, but astorath doesnt operate as normal marines do, he has his own unique task. so master of his chapter or not, seth cannot order astorath to do or stop doing anything.

[@Dreadbringer]

@@RanRayu of.course he can, couse they aré not blood Angels they aré flesh tearers, he might have His sacred duty but that doesnt allow him to brake chain of command, Is disrespectfull and out of líne, a High Chaplain doesnt have power over other chapters less so a máster of one, If Sanguinious himself came AND order him to or a council of chapter masters voted on It then It would be right, but thats Is not the case, they aré no longer a Legión, so Seth Is right.

[@Ryuzakku]

@@Dreadbringer Flesh Tearers are a Blood Angels successor, and therefoe Blood Angels. Astorath's duty is carried out for all chapters that suffer the Black Rage, and all chapters that suffer the Black Rage are Blood Angels.

[@RanRayu]

@@Dreadbringer no seth cannot order astorath to stop, astorath kinda stands above chapters, not in the sense that he can just order them around, but that he can do his job without anyone, other than dante, ordering him to stop. and if needed be allowed to remove anyone and anything that stands in his way in any manner he deems necessary. so if seth really prevents astorath from performing his duty, he could take seth out if he wanted to, not that i think he well go so far as to kill seth, unless seth is truly lost, but he might give him a new haircut with his axe.

[@adamgardner3768]

Seth, oh you actually Thought you could Challenge the High Chad of the Imperium.

[@chaptermasterd9362]

🤣🤣🤣

[@Martin_von_Koenigsberg]

Yes indeed

[@snakeyman5560]

Nassir Amit could do it.

[@Sicsempertyranus313]

Hey leviathan backed down from Seth.

[@Jelle1880]

I don't think he ever did, but he had to make his point. Also, he's probably 100% serious with his threat.

[@Overonator]

I see the Space Marines are at each other's throats. It's like they learned nothing from the Horus Heresy.

[@NinthRomance]

Ikr if they keep this up there might be another horus heresy x.x

[@justicar5]

@@NinthRomance well, they couldn't stay blind forever.

[@Motard.Actual]

They have learned. But the flesh Tearers will not have their loyalty question or there method. They will not be replaced by red ultramarines. They will not lose or leave behind who they are for a better look. They know who they are and they know what they are made for.

[@VallornDeathblade]

@I.B. Jr. "caring nothing about the sovereignty of other chapters" And tonight on Imperium Nihilus TV! It's the showdown you've all been waiting for! BADAB WAR TWO! SANGUINE BOOGALOO!

[@Dreadbringer]

@@Motard.Actual you undertand It, there Is a chain of command and Astorath as much as i respect him he was out of líne here.

[@AfroDee2iac]

This is actually the event that ultimately ends up sparing Seth's life later during his trial of the blood.

[@deviantspark2570]

Got a link my dude?

[@Dreadbringer]

@@deviantspark2570 its in Trial of Blood and the Flesh tearers omnibus i think or was It the blood Angels omnibus? The first one for certain.

[@deviantspark2570]

@@Dreadbringer Thanks for getting back to me, looks like I need to pick up another book.

[@Dreadbringer]

@@deviantspark2570 no worries battle brother i myself have several in waiting.

[@AfroDee2iac]

@@deviantspark2570 Apologies for the lack of response, I haven't been receiving notifications for some reason. But yes Chapter Master is correct. Without spoiling anything, this event helps Astorath realise that Seth is ultimately fighting for the preservation of The Blood tooth, nail, and claw. Which many others of The Blood don't recognize

[@KR15nAK]

like you said, if Astorath still hears the music, then he still serves a purpose, regardless of how Seth may feel about it. it would be interesting though, to see if this started a movement to each successor chapter creating their own dealer of the damned, taught exclusively by Astorath, to devote themselves so fully, they themselves begin to hear the music. Even better, out of the blue, Seth begins to hear the music

[@LordKingKamiGuru]

That would make Astorath less unique.

[@XRyanK]

@@LordKingKamiGuru Amen. Why water down something so cool.

[@kharis7602]

if seth could hear the music, that would be so badass

[@XRyanK]

@@kharis7602 He should just requestion an ipod from Mars.

[@77RJ777]

Even better Seth gets the black rage, gets put down like the mongrel dog he is and we don't have to hear about him anymore.

[@WingdingsChickenhead]

The person who left you the gift voucher... was me ALPHARIUS! I'm kidding, good on the guy though!

[@helicaldota]

was me, Cato Sicarius

[@bladespirit9000]

I liked seth, ever since the book where the flesh tearers are being judged by all the other chapter masters, and he threatens to kill them all, if they touch his chapter

[@snakeyman5560]

What book is that? I wanna read that now.

[@neilwilson4590]

Whats the book called? Would like to read that for my self

[@mouseketeery]

@@snakeyman5560 It's Trial By Blood - it's an anthology of Flesh Tearer short stories by Andy Smillie. I think the one Rho's talking about is there too, and the one that causes Seth to go to Astorath's Reclusiam in the first place.

[@mouseketeery]

@@neilwilson4590 It's Trial By Blood - it's an anthology of Flesh Tearer short stories by Andy Smillie. I think the one Rho's talking about is there too, and the one that causes Seth to go to Astorath's Reclusiam in the first place.

[@darthvaderginsburg4694]

@@neilwilson4590 It is in the Omnibus "Flesh Tearers". The name of the story is "Trial Of Gabriel Seth" in the Onnibus. It is in multiple Acts, I think? There is a stand alone book called "Trial By Blood" as a stand alone book as well. However, I swear I listened to this as an audio drama, but I cannot find it ATM.

[@imperialfist2304]

Sanguinala is closing upon us Wolf Lord! Know to share your praises on the fallen of the year, and the glorious Primarch Sanguinius.

[@archdornan3068]

Happy sanguinala

[@nicholascerillo4000]

Ironic how Gabriel Seth accuses Astorath of being a murderer when Gabe’s own chapter is guilty of butchering allied forces and civilians (at least more so than most Blood Angel chapters).

[@Dreadbringer]

Who woudnt defend His own men?

[@barlotardy]

Yeah, but they're SETH'S band of psychotic murderers.

[@Dreadbringer]

They might both be killers but only one of them was a master of His chapter, Astorath was way out of place here, they aré not a Legión anymore, there Is a chain of command for a reason.

[@matthewsmith1807]

@@Dreadbringer you keep banging on about a chain of command but Astorath and his ship aren't listed with the rest of the Blood Angels, move through the warp faster than any other imperial ship because of his duty/resolve/conviction; and he has music, not a map, to guide him through the warp on the dark side of the galaxy where the emperors light does not shine. Astorath is not taking orders but being guided by warp shenaningans. And we all know Sanguinius and the Emperor are still alive in the warp so I wouldn't put it past them helping out. Astorath is not a normal chaplain and shouldn't be judged by normal means i.e Seth being a chapter master. Seth is just butt hurt because the Flesh Tearers and Seth in paticular embrace the black rage more than most at the cost of innocent allies and civilians. Now I'm not saying you can't defend Seth or be his fanboy but the chain of command seems a moot point considering how Astorath goes about doing his thang. It's not like Guilliman is ordering him to do it.

[@Dreadbringer]

@@matthewsmith1807 im dont even like the guy nor the sons of Sanguinious, so dont come here poisoning the well, that just proves how butthurt you are by my statements, you claim Astorath Is special AND that he follows no one exept music AND that he shoudnt be judged by normal means, you come not only as biased but a cringe fanboy, i respect Astorath duty but going againts other chapters Sovereignty Is just stupid and defeats the purpose, you claim that couse he goes fast on the warp Sanguinious or the emperor aré in His side? Show me the book where the ángel told him to do whatever he likes, Come on what are you smoking? More like Khorne happy that so many sons of the ángel dies sharing blood amongst themselves they aré no longer a Legión and might doesnt makes right, im protecting Sovereignty of chapter masters doing what they feel like its the Best for their own men couse they were the Best amongst equals or they were choosen for It, if you dont respect your sucessors choice then you are just being a worst asshole, why not just censor the whole bunch then? Ridículous, a High Chaplain doesnt outrank a máster of the chapter, even one as mediátic as flesh tearers, men think about It. Who woudnt defend His own men? Only scum of the lowest cathegory.

[@xMorentz]

The music Astorath hears that draws him to the fallen - doesn’t distinguish between chapters. What would he do if he travelled across the galaxy to the sound of the music, only to find it’s a Flesh Tearer - and he’d what? Have to avoid killing him because of Seth’s threat?

[@servalkorion686]

seth can't best him so astrorah wouldn't care

[@ballerlarva4214]

I'm a huge Gabriel Seth fan but I think Astorath is correct here.

[@eichler721]

I would side with Astorath as Sanguinius himself during the Heresy laid his sons to rest. The High Chaplin is just continuing Sanguinius will and tradition. Seth is a badass and takes no shit from anyone.

[@sanguine2956]

Ya but that was the primarch himself, Astorath is different he is the chaplain of the blood Angel's not the flesh tearers

[@eichler721]

@@sanguine2956 it is the will of Sanguinius as otherwise he would not hear the song. Also this happened before the great rift but now the BloodAngels are in charge of the Imperium Nighalis. So ya they are in charge now.

[@miguelperez9906]

@@sanguine2956 this is the duty givens to a son of Sanguineous to give mercy to his brothers. The music itself is in my eyes more of warp entity Sanguineous (the thing in the warp that talks to Mephiston) so it’s basically a duty given by the primarch.

[@HammarPwnsYourFace]

What does mephiston have to say abt this? He survived the rage and came back...

[@eichler721]

@@HammarPwnsYourFace he also is one of a handful in the 10k years. Also Astorath only kills those who have lost complete control and are having a massacre of civilians and loyal Imperial servants.

[@mouseketeery]

The Flesh Tearers don't kill their surviving Death Company - they're retrieved, sent back to the ship they're kept on, their wounds are treated, and they're sent out again and again until killed in battle. We sort of get a follow-up to this story. Astorath speaks in Seth's favour in The Trial of Gabriel Seth (though he does call him a mongrel!) saying that the Chapters of the Blood need him and the Flesh Tearers. Also, I wish that Andy Smillie and Guy Haley would decide between them once and for all, how big Seth is. Smillie has him much smaller than Astorath and a head shorter than his new Primaris Captain (that he welcomed in his customary manner!), but Guy Haley calls him an 'immense' man and at least a head taller than other (First-Born) marines - in other words about the size of a Primaris, or as near as damn it.

[@barlotardy]

Yeah, I've noticed that too. Also, his mini is in dire need of updating; it's tiny.

[@Shandathe]

Something that should really be pointed out before siding with Astorath, the Flesh Tearers actually get along pretty well with their Death Company, possibly because the difference between the normal Flesh Tearer and one affected by the Black Rage isn't quite as large as it is for other Chapters. The Death Company has their own Strike Cruiser (Death's Cowl) and the Flesh Tearers don't cull survivors but the Chaplains round them up so they can be used again and again until they finally meet an end in battle. Or turn them into a Death Company Dreadnought if they're not QUITE dead. We've seen a Flesh Tearer Chaplain order Death Company around and get them to literally fall into line, reason with a Death Company dreadnought (sorta... ). So all that makes Astorath coming by and chopping them up a bit... annoying.

[@coalitionofrob436]

Astorath may have Seth, but Chaplain Apollus would destroy Astorath.

[@commissarlugh1040]

@@coalitionofrob436 apollus is 20 pounds of anger in a 10 pound bag.

[@chrisfrombeyond4240]

Seth needs to remember his place. Astorath needs to respect Seths wishes. They both need to take this before Dante, lest a small war break out.

[@3rdguru]

dont push seth hell ruin your day ask anyone in the inquisition that crossed his path ............oh wait

[@jim-ex3vh]

Got to love Seth!!!!! Standing up for his chapter! I honestly think Seth is in the right there, there his brothers under his command it’s up to him to deal with them

[@Dreadbringer]

Agreed.

[@NueThunderKing]

If your loyalty is more to the chapter than to the greater good of humankind, then you are in the wrong. Seth is on the brink of heresy and should not be tolerated.

[@Dreadbringer]

@@NueThunderKing what are you talking about? The greater good of humankind? Aré you a tau spy or just someone who believe he know better? Jajajajjajaa dont be ridículous the greater good has been one of the biggest couses of war ever, only the Emperor knows whats better.

[@NueThunderKing]

@@Dreadbringer the Emperor would chastise the whole Chapter if he heard of how Seth manages things. You asume the chapter is beyond reproach, and you would be wrong.

[@Dreadbringer]

@@NueThunderKing if the Emperor wanted he would do It, even Astorath was in Seth side during His trial with yes other chapter masters couse only they have the authority.

[@sleepysloth9765]

Neither are right or wrong. You can’t adhere to the old ways if they are flawed, yet you cannot step upon the old ways just because you’re new...it’s a double edged sword

[@HammarPwnsYourFace]

How is a second founded* chapter new?

[@carlhutto811]

Love ya man!! You make long drives so much better

[@theroadstopshere]

After learning about the amount of pain endured by Angels fallen to the Black Rage and hearing one plead with Astorath to end his suffering, I really can't side with Seth, regardless of how much I sympathize and respect him. Once the Rage has taken hold, it is only the rarest of Angels who come out alive, much less sane. Ending their suffering, and thus reducing the amount of pain and rage echoing into the Warp, is by far the better option. Imagine how much rage and pain has been denied to the Ruinous Powers by the mercy of Astorath, to say nothing of the souls redeemed. The High Chaplain has among the worst jobs imaginable for a Space Marine, but few can say they've done as much for the wellbeing of the Imperium and for the Sons of Sanguinius as him.

[@theroadstopshere]

@Pedro Kantor, the Crimson power Fister Oh absolutely get it, totally sympathetic to Chapter Master Gabriel. But with all due respect, Chapter Master Kantor (huge fan, btw), if my son was a danger to himself and others, and suffering so greatly he pleads for death, I'd be grateful in a sick, sad way to have someone come to end his suffering with compassion. Seth being Seth, though, he'd want to do it himself, which is totally fair. But even then, he doesn't hear the music or the call of the Rage in others so he can't head to them quickly the way the Chaplain can, and he has too many other duties to bear right now as Chapter Master. Astaroth, however cold he seems, seemingly serves as the hand of Sanguinius in the mortal realm, offering mercy to his sons suffering through his own last moments of pain and confusion by leading the High Chaplain to them. And as a Golden Hawk-boi fanboy, that's enough sign for me to trust Asty and his purpose almost unconditionally, even without considering the other stuff I mentioned before.

[@barlotardy]

To become one of the Emperor's angels of death is to willingly live a life of pain and struggle until that life ends. They know what they signed up for.

[@michasalamon8315]

I always like to imagine that Gabriel looks like Charles Dance (Tywin Lannister). I think this face matches him perfectly.

[@chrisfrombeyond4240]

Idk, I kinda imagine him looking, and sounding, like Jason Statham.

[@Dreadbringer]

Tywin Is too old and More cold and calculating in His wrath, More like a Dark Angel succesor chapter master, besides It fits More the Lion theme.

[@chrisfrombeyond4240]

Charles Dance would be a good Malcador.

[@Dreadbringer]

@@chrisfrombeyond4240 oh yeah. you might have nailed It. He sure has the potential and presence. I Guess Ian McKellen could do It too.

[@louismaurer5884]

Vinnie Jones lmfao

[@DoomSlayer-6660]

I would love to see Seth and Tyberos to have a conversation about whatever…..

[@jackwitzberger274]

Don’t cross Seth aka Amit reincarnated

[@RockaGrand]

Seems like the build up to answering the question: “What would a war between Blood Angels and an entire chapter of “Black Rage” induced units be like....” hypothetical at its best.

[@brandonhughes4571]

A absolute slaughter filled blood bath with both sides unleashing their death company's

[@dariuszmajecki]

Gabriel Seth is one of my top 3 favourite characters from 40k that is not from SW chapter (number 1 beingg Dante btw). He also shares same idea about Primaris as I do, and quite a lot of players :)

[@HammarPwnsYourFace]

Yes but do you know in the end he will probably end up giving it up just save his chapter. He will *become that which he despises....

[@tomisdead]

I cannot see it being Astoraths place, as you say they are not a Legion anymore, they are a separate entity, cousins at most. Seth has pulled the Flesh Tearers from the brink of annihilation, he has literally fought tooth and nail to drag the chapter back from the dark, he barely has any brothers left and now this high minded member of another chapter comes and kills one of the last brothers he has that his has tried so desperately to save? Seth is more than justified in his anger. Also we have seen Astoraths level patients when dealing with one of his own chapter, then talks to Seth like he's a dog? He clearly has no respect for what is at the least a superior officer of another chapter, and clearly sees them as the rest of the Imperium sees them. Unlike his very own chapter master Dante, who clearly sees something in Seth worth redeeming. Astorath need to look to his own house before waving his authority among his cousin chapters.

[@Dreadbringer]

I agree, astorath was getting out of líne, there Is a chain of command for a reason AND each máster of His chapter do as he sees Fit with His own men. Only the primarch and the emperor can tell otherwise

[@NueThunderKing]

Nope, sorry, chapter allegiance is not above the allegiance to the Imperium. And Seth it treading heresy grounds here, which may seem right but the angels carry chaos curses through their gene seed and this are not boons nor traditions to be kept. Even Sanguinius dealt death to all afflicted with the Red Thirst, what makes you think he wouldn’t do the same to those with Black Rage?

[@Dreadbringer]

@@NueThunderKing what are going about? What has chapter alledgiance has to do with murdering cousins who fall.far.from.your jurisdicción? Did the emperor or Sanguinious gave Astorath His duty?

[@joshuapolites374]

When you lead men into battle you feel responsible for them. After awhile they end up your family so you feel it is your duty to take care of them even if that means you must put them down yourself so I understand where Seth is coming from, but I would agree with Grim he was chosen for this position

[@mouseketeery]

The Flesh Tearers don't give the surviving Death Company the Emperor's Peace. They patch them up and put them back on the ship that they 'live' on. They are sent out in battle again and again until they're killed. They're on the edge - they need the honour of death in battle to save their souls.

[@Dreadbringer]

Astorath was chosen true but in their own chapter, doesnt give him the right to slay the little brothers of another chapter even if stricken with the same curse, its just wrong.

[@dndlover2690]

@@Dreadbringer HE IS REEDEMER FOR ALL THE CHAPTERS

[@Dreadbringer]

@@dndlover2690 appointed by...? Never heard the Emperor or Sanguinious gave him that task

[@joshuapolites374]

If he was not chosen then why does he hear the music. How is he right every single time. obviously somebody chose him for this job. Who they don't say but I'm guessing we all have a pretty good idea, and whether or not they are blood angels they are all still sons of the Angel.

[@TrevorJNagy]

I think this is perfectly fitting for the Seth and by proxy the Flesh Tearers. The Tearers have never cared about the Legion Wardens when they felt they were right, and now that the Wardens have become Chaplains, I can see that the thought hasn't changed. Besides, Seth isn't saying that they won't be killed, but that he should be the one to decide their fate. Unlike Astorath, a jumped up Blood Angel who, while he may be directed by Papa Angel, is not a member of that chapter. Seth calling him Cousin, I feel is the most telling of that. To Seth they aren't Brothers, family still, but Astorath is overstepping.

[@Dreadbringer]

Too true

[@HammarPwnsYourFace]

The moment he told Seth no...that’s where you fucked up

[@HammarPwnsYourFace]

To be honest mephiston would be the only one that will probably be able to talk seth down. I know him(seth)and Dante have a good relationship/understanding..... and at all but I don’t see Dante talk to him down not from this not at all. Only someone that has lived through it and understand it would *have any chance of getting seth to comply in the slightest

[@saltedllama2759]

During the days of the Crusade, whether in battle or in the sparring pits, even the World Eaters were described as being shocked by how much more violent and brutal the Blood Angels were than any other bloodline when pushed over the edge. Likewise Sanguinius knew he would have to cross that same line to defeat Horus and felt that line was a flaw and thus resisted.

[@Thozel]

In general i dont like loyal space marine stories but blood angels have won my heart. Devastation of Baal was pure awesomeness. Love to read more about them

[@rjlarose5271]

When it comes down to it both these men love thier brother's. So the anger they both display is understandable.

[@Motard.Actual]

Flesh Tearers best successor chapter period.

[@mr.b.9058]

Hear me out, they should use the damned to perfect the Rubicon Primaris operation. This could help ensure Dantes successful passage (not that he would need it) and could potentially save some battle brothers. What could go wrong?🤷🏼‍♂️🧛🏻‍♂️

[@Dreadbringer]

Mmm upgraded berserkers might be too dangerous or waste valuable resources though it Is kind of a good idea you know, maybe using voluntarios and sending then to Cawl.

[@mr.b.9058]

@@Dreadbringer What if the Rubicon can pull these guys from the darkness like the Lord of Death.

[@Coproquim]

It always makes me laugh that Seth is the shortest space marine 🤣

[@gaia9020]

Both have their points, you may like the one view more then the other, but in the end neither one is truly right or wrong, both have their believes

[@HammarPwnsYourFace]

Bloodsong or not. Mephiston needs to be the moderator. Especially when seth is involved

[@Deltarious]

I sort've just see Astorath as directly carrying out the duty and will of Sanguinius since he used to personally end the lives of his sons when there was no other choice, for me it's a pretty open and shut case, espetially seeing as Astorath literally hears all of them psychically, he is basically obligated to do it

[@J_Hyder]

Astorath should’ve humbled Seth a bit more IMO.

[@Dreadbringer]

Astorath shoudnt mess with other chapters, its uncalled for.

[@claydud271]

@@Dreadbringer you reckon a chaplain should be able to stomp a chapter master of one of the most beserk marine chapters.....

[@Dreadbringer]

@@claydud271 well depends, i dont really see any Chaplain taking out Moloc, Tyberus or Dante in 1v1, though Astorath do has His own honorguard of Erelim...

[@UmbraNupe]

@@Dreadbringer He is not a regular Chaplin. You can’t compare him to ones of others. His role goes beyond the Blood Angles

[@Dreadbringer]

@@UmbraNupe not in my opinión, messing with other chapters Sovereignty Is a Dick move AND just ignites civil wars or lack of support from succesor chapters, he should keep It strictly blood Angels bussiness. Besides who annointed as such? Dont recall the emperor nor Sanguinious giving him this role. He just hears music and feels entitled to mess with other chapters couse no one can messure up to His might. Very Bully.

[@robertemmitt4585]

merry Christmas all. well done rho

[@kingbaldwiniv5409]

I love the characters of the 9th legion! Seth and Astorath, awesome!

[@ziogualty]

Astorath can be calm and compassionate while he performs his duty, but no surprise he will be enraged if someone question or, even worse, wants to prevent him to fulfill it.

[@Shandathe]

Oh, Seth does quite a bit better than just questioning his duty to anger Astorath. Remember the man is utterly gifted at being a dick to get his point across. Here's the passage that makes Astorath lose his cool: --- Seth gestured around them. ‘For all of the theatre you use to hide your true nature, you are still a Blood Angel. And we are all lost, cousin. None amongst the bloodline are above the madness. Not even you.’ Astorath bared his fangs. ‘I have walked with the damned-’ ‘No!’ Seth roared, closing to within a blade’s thickness of Astorath. ‘You have not walked with them. You have stood above them, sneering down at them in arrogant indifference.’ Astorath’s composure slipped as a ripple of rage ran across his features. ‘I am untouched by the Blood’s madness.’ ‘You think so, Blood Angel?’ Seth grinned. ‘You think it is sane to kill those of your own blood?’

[@hotcauldron7918]

Meanwhile in heaven, Sanguinius facepalming so hard

[@jefferycrouch4396]

Dude I love your take and love of 40k stuff. I would love to hear you read from the Cacharadons novels or Brutal Kunnin. Think you'll love em

[@justinavery8664]

Yay angry Seth!!. Love the work and effort you put in Rho!!!👍

[@alithahnar7957]

Not a Legion? HERESY! Burn the Witch!

[@cn9707]

This is a fight Seth walked into knowing he couldn't win. He made the point to go in anyways.

[@Sgt.Nathaniel.Angelos]

Seth gets his ass kicked "and dont make me come back again" 😆

[@angelsofblood9879]

There are always should be a check and balance, regardless of one's duty. For Seth, they flesh tearers are his sons. He would gladly sacrifice himself to protect them; he went to Astoroth to prove that. Who watches the Watcher? Or who is able to verify or assist the high chaplain? It is a question, and a concern that is justified by the chapter master (and the one stubborn and courageous enough to stand up and say something).

[@michaellewis5200]

Just thinking about the two chapters coming to blows over this, makes me wonder if such a clash would gain the attention of the blood god. All that righteous rage and blood letting would surely attract something from the warp.

[@zackariaswade]

I think what Gabriel takes issue is that in all certain terms it is his chapter the one that he drug out of the blood soaked pit it was in and he who was also nearly assassinated by the inquisition is building up the Flesh Tearers. Chaplain Apollos is the his redeemer and leads the death company to the glorious ends that Seth would rather see than executions.

[@draculwalker1892]

Bad ass and great video as alwayz brother 🤘🏻love both of these guyz and can’t wait to see how this playz out ! Oh boy there will be Blood 🩸

[@Ally.Cat.252]

So was Seth going to fly his gunship home himself?? If he could why even have a servator pilot.

[@scottemerson1335]

You’d have to be a fool to think Seths threat is empty

[@spider00x]

Dude Gabriel Seth is the fucking man!

[@snethss]

Makes sense that someone would try to find another way

[@Dreadbringer]

It does if you are the máster of your chapter, those men aré under His wing.

[@rhysnavato3970]

How big is Astoraph !!?? It’s said in the devastation of Baal that Seth is bigger than everyone of the blood angels chapter

[@riktor3005]

Here is the real question, crossing the rubicon primaris is enough to restore the broken parts of a Astartes body? It also worked wonders with helping Mephiston contain his own mind/warp abilities. What if becoming a primaris could bring someone back from the black rage?

[@wmdragonj]

The follow up is at the end Flesh Tearers Omnibus. At the conclusion of Gabriel’s trail.

[@Brad-yq3zm]

Seth and Astoroth go at it, Khorne how ever sits back on his throne of skulls and tells Cabanda to break out the popcorn.

[@eddiegrathwohl624]

This needs to be a movie

[@reculture]

What would Sanguinius think of Gabriel's threat, not sure he would brush it off so lightly...

[@Shadowrecon122]

This sounds like it needs a poll!

[@elindvanelian]

What I know some successor chapters (at least Templars of Blood) have their way how to avoid Astaroth's help. But it means let kill in battle or kill everyone with very first symptoms of black rage and I am not sure this is something what Seth wish for.

[@ottomackensen]

Love Seth. Always standing up for himself and his chapter.

[@jimminey-fooking-cricket4903]

Did someone say Fallen? No I'll see myself out then.

[@Dreadbringer]

Where? Could you send me the location? I'll send some not interrogator chaplains.

[@julietran4473]

Astorath isn't one for backing down. He even called for Mephiston's death.

[@Gridia444]

HE DID WHAT?? That's it. He's not getting his Sanguinala present.

[@coalitionofrob436]

Most people do!

[@tripod222]

I'm not a BA fan, or a Flesh Tearer one, but wow, no matter what you think of Seth, that guy is the definition badassery.

[@edim108]

"Flesh Tearers vs Blood Angels" I can feel Sanguinous' pain at the thought of that. Seriously, last thing he'd want would be a war between his sons...

[@clarkneedsaweapon]

I move this gold man, always epic

[@azrael1045]

Gotta side with Seth here. As the Chapter Master of the Flesh Tearers it is his responsibility and duty to put down any of his brothers if they need putting down.

[@ryanshaw8375]

Is it possible to use these backgrounds with animations as Screensavers for my desktop? If so, how?

[@rantymcrant-pants9536]

find the picture, set it as screensaver. Google will help.

[@Slyslug]

download wallpaper engine on steam, just look up "wh40k" on the work shop and its done :')

[@Darkvoidninja]

All I wanted to hear “ one large fucking chain sword begins to scream” but oh well maybe next time.

[@yumanoid5753]

I wonder what happend to the tower of amareo (or so) where those unlucky are kept, who survive the blackrage? I know its lore from several editions past, but this little piece of information always intriegued me.

[@andyjones29]

I personally side with Seth as it's his chapter to lead and to deal with chapter issues as he see fit and as is the right of a chapter master which I'm pretty sure out ranks a high Chaplin (I could be wrong) but even so he isn't of the chapter. Also a threat from seth should never be took likely or called out as the history of the flesh tearers shows they stick by there words as shown in fear to tread where Amit call horus a traitor and even with the threat of death from the angel himself would not take those words bk. Amit was a beast and Seth is just as bad ass lol

[@Dreadbringer]

Agreed, there Is a chain of command for a reason AND each máster of the chapter do as he sees Fit with His own men.

[@kelman727]

In game terms Seth would butcher Astorath.

[@harleywalls6356]

you need to do sanguinius meets leman russ we really need that soo much

[@Judge_of_Anubis05]

Astroath hears the music playing for all the sons of Sanguinious. I never really liked Seth, especially now with his threat of full on conflict with the Blood Angels. I don't mind scepticism but Seth seems to take it too far.

[@mati12554]

I mean technically speaking Blood Angles became kind of a Legion after Girlyman had conversation with Dante after the events of Devastation of Ball.

[@Duppyman695]

Oh boy what a Fight! I Don't think Seth likes any body but can you blame him! Flesh Tearers don't back down!

[@saturn12002]

Wouldnt an attack upon a fellow chapter be an act of treason against the emperor? Astorath was right to question if Seth had gone mad. At the same tie considering Seth brought his chapter back from the brink of oblivion, and what a monumental effort that must have been, I cant quite blame Seth for making that threat. I fully believe he will carry through with it, if he feels he must. Though imagine what that could mean for the chapter, excommunication, no safe harbor in the imperirum...an inevitable fall to chaos with no options left.

[@imperialguardsmen7205]

I understand where Seth is coming from. when you fight beside someone for hundreds of years You form a bond with your brothers and to see them get killed off by your own kin after all the hardship and suffering you saw them go through just seems like a insult to their memory. Better to die by the enemy I say. Seth has seen way too many of his brothers die from astorath imagine seeing your closest friends get killed by the same person you would think to hate that person and that hate would certainly build up over time. This shows me how much Seth loves his brothers coz I can see how much he hates astorath.

[@Dreadbringer]

I agree cousin.

[@lay-hannowway8943]

Everything Seth appears in is just turned up 11 immediately, he's just to awesome and Astorath is well lucky to just get the warning, everybody else just gets dead.

[@Compa_Doom]

this is why seth is the best chapter master. He actually stands his ground and holds his belief regardless of the consequences.

[@giorgigogolashvili3097]

A real chip of the old block

[@Dreadbringer]

I agree there Is a chain of command they aré not a Legión anymore.

[@TheKlink]

Dante's all like "Maybe Seth will do me a favour and kill me..."

[@chickenistrexlastname1331]

Astorath is definitely a lowkey supernatural space marine. Even among the other space marines. Hahah

[@giwrgosroumeliwtis4938]

As always thank you for your videos and great job. I have one request could you tell me where i can find the wallpapers u have in your videos i would like to use them with wallpaper engine !! Thank u man

[@melvixen1943]

I think that might be a setup for seth to take a similiar role as Astorath the care for their brothers granting them that bloodsong ability.

[@fulgrimxo94]

After reading over my blood angels codex (9th ed.) I noticed something. There is a passage that states that only the testimony of Astorath during the flesh tearers trial on Baal saved the chapter from dissolution. The man is literally the only one responsible for the Flesh Tearers continued existence as a chapter and this is how they treat him? Seth is no angel of mine.

[@coalitionofrob436]

Astorath intervened because of this incident. Had it not occurred …….. who knows

[@vonkug]

It was Seth's statement. For his honor, he had to draw blood for blood. He knew he could not win, but he had to satisfy his honor if only in gesture. I don't doubt that Seth would back his word, but it wouldn't be war, at least not in theory. He knows the man who kills his brothers, and that, in his eyes, is the one that drew first blood.

[@louisdahlia]

You can not second guess the chosen of Sanguinious without getting at least one DTT😁

[@Darby-qu6hz]

This came on early in the morning.I wasn't awake and I thought it was christmas

[@matiasyannuzzi9655]

Seth: "If you keep murdering my men who fall to the Rage, I'll come back and I won't do so alone." Astorath: "Good, then I'll set up tables for you and the 20-odd marines that are left in your chapter."

[@barlotardy]

Joke's on Astorath! Seth ALREADY only had 20-odd marines left! :D

[@matiasyannuzzi9655]

@@barlotardy That's the point. It's Astorath throwing shade at Seth for being the leader of a nearly extinct chapter (I know, they received Primaris reinforcements and aren't so few in number, but that's despite Seth's efforts and not as a result of them).

[@Dreadbringer]

You say that like blood Angels werent almost exterminated against the Tyranids.

[@Ally.Cat.252]

Why is Astorath so much bigger/taller?

[@unknownps]

Seth is correct, the Legion is gone, command and thus responsibility of a chapter welfare is first and foremost the responsibility of the chapter master unless he asks, the chaplain has no place interfering

[@metalman0153]

I though that it was mentioned a couple of times how large Seth was compared to other Marines. Astorath is bigger?

[@barlotardy]

It seems to depend on who's writing him. Usually, Seth's depicted as a head taller than an average first born marine, which apparently makes Astorath about 72 feet tall.

[@metalman0153]

@@barlotardy Haha thank you for the reply. Astorath just steps on the damned to offer them redemption.

[@giorgiomangano5012]

Khorne is smiling in the background

[@andrew3203]

If this would come to a trial, (like a Senatoris Imperialis court) then Seth would win easily. His Chapter, his rules, his people. Then again, if it came to a trial, the Flesh Tearers would still die, even if not killed by Astorath. Thier deeds would be exposed, their Chapter declared Excomunicated and they would just burn.

[@eldetraquer]

Would ANY chapter try to chalenge Set when he made up his mind. The guy is unbreakable even the dark one try and fail

[@silversurfer8818]

What about Mephiston he defeated the pull of the black rage twice, how would an encounter with Astorath end?

[@GodlordBazi]

Astorath would kill Mephiston. The reason for this is mainly because Mephiston has shown enough willpower to retain at least a tiny bit of self control when the Black Rage kicks in. Mephiston would probably help Astorath there as much as possible. If that's not the case, I don't think Astorath would have the power to defeat a Black Rage driven Mephiston alone. During the last anger stroke Mephiston had, he was able to beg Dante to kill him as soon as he realised that he wasn't able to stop it this time. But good guy Dante just wrecked his hood and made a Primaris Marine out of him, while Astorath stood at his side the whole time with his axe ready for the worst case. Edit: I'm talking about the case of Mephiston succumbing to the Black Rage finally, of course. They are pretty cool with eachother and have met quiet often otherwise.