Josh Duggar's Biggest Mistakes Solidified the Case Against Him, Big Updates

#CountingOn
court records highlight that Josh Duggar made a lot of mistakes. We talk about the biggest ones that occurred during the time he downloaded the worst of the worst online
Disclaimer:
Without a Crystal Ball is a commentary channel. The views expressed by Katie Joy are her opinions and should not be considered fact. Katie Joy discusses trending topics, current events, reality tv & More. This channel is for your entertainment. Please make sure you conduct your own research on any topics to verify any information.
Support the Channel By Becoming a Member:
/ @withoutacrystalball
Follow Katie Joy on Social Media:
Instagram: / withoutacrystalball
Twitter:
/ woacbofficial
/ katiejoyyt
Facebook:
/ withoutacrystalball
Without a Crystal Ball is a commentary channel. The views expressed by Katie Joy are her opinions and should not be considered fact.
All Clips Obtained through TLC KZbin & Used under Fair Use:
All clips obtained through TLC KZbin and used under Fair Use:
The Copyright Laws of the United States recognizes a “fair use” of copyrighted content. Section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Act states:
“NOTWITHSTANDING THE PROVISIONS OF SECTIONS 106 AND 106A, THE FAIR USE OF A COPYRIGHTED WORK, INCLUDING SUCH USE BY REPRODUCTION IN COPIES OR PHONORECORDS OR BY ANY OTHER MEANS SPECIFIED BY THAT SECTION, FOR PURPOSES SUCH AS CRITICISM, COMMENT, NEWS REPORTING, TEACHING (INCLUDING MULTIPLE COPIES FOR CLASSROOM USE), SCHOLARSHIP, OR RESEARCH, IS NOT AN INFRINGEMENT OF COPYRIGHT.”
THIS VIDEO AND OUR KZbin CHANNEL IN GENERAL MAY CONTAIN CERTAIN COPYRIGHTED WORKS THAT WERE NOT SPECIFICALLY AUTHORIZED TO BE USED BY THE COPYRIGHT HOLDER(S), BUT WHICH WE BELIEVE IN GOOD FAITH ARE PROTECTED BY FEDERAL LAW AND THE FAIR USE DOCTRINE FOR ONE OR MORE OF THE REASONS NOTED ABOVE.

[@tammykelsey7877]

How would they be able to tell if his kids weren’t victims if they didn’t let them get evaluated by forensic evaluations or CPS??? This is SO frustrating!!!

[@angiebauer7141]

No way should he (Josh Duggar) be able to see his children only being supervised by Anna! His children should have been removed for their safety and examined! This is so sick and so sad!

[@marycaramella1347]

I trully don't believe Anna would allow anything to happen to her kids. She appears to be a good Mama, and totally in the dark about Josh. Trully must be shocking...I don't think she's able to believe it, or accept that her beloved hubby did these things...or even understands what he's accused of. Sadly

[@bigmanabram8356]

IKR Anna needs to lose custody until a mental evaluation is done

[@eileenfleming9799]

And be questioned

[@alejandraalejandra4700]

@@marycaramella1347 she appeared to be so stupid from very beginning and NEVER changed for good...poor kids can't be supervised by brainwashed mother who acting voodoo visible

[@alejandraalejandra4700]

Coocoo

[@lmccauley7319]

That judge should never had let Josh out of jail, it's a disgrace, he is a danger to his children and everyone he is around.

[@pinkiesue849]

JB connections?

[@margaretkinnaman8585]

To be fair, that judge had just been appointed to the bench. What I want to know is who decided to give that particular judge Josh's case? Was there some inside finagling done to give an inexperienced judge a case like this?

[@debshaw680]

@@margaretkinnaman8585 really? Being your first case is no excuse. He’s got to be a lawyer of some sort and a human being. He was paid off.

[@margaretmacgillicuddy4944]

There were no valid reasons to keep him in jail. They have to offer bail. His release conditions are very normal for all those facing CP charges.

[@janeben-ami8754]

I agree!

[@70sladyalways25]

Shame on anyone who doesn’t pursue those children being evaluated!

[@kristivaught9541]

Exactly!!! They are doing the kids a disservice

[@kathrynhaigh1815]

The fact his wife is having to be readily available for his needs while heavily pregnant makes me feel sick while this investigation goes on. What is he making her do to pleasure himself all this time. He should NEVER have been released. Castrate him!!!!

[@meeeka]

One good thing for Anna: no more pregnancies from her useless, child, pig husband the Leech in Chief. She's on the road to FREEDOM! (if she so chooses or is allowed...)

[@amiematthews6469]

Yes!!!

[@angelawade1445]

I do think if they volunteer to be castrated, maybe better treatment in prison, that would help us all.

[@skyewilson5650]

It’s insane to me how some men will go through so many steps just to hide things from their wives and family, instead of just getting help for the problem. Sad world.

[@Jusmeh]

Very observant and stated beautifully. in this dawn of "The Jealous".

[@marshakirby9978]

First of all , you have to realize you have a problem.

[@meganlopez560]

I feel so bad for the investigators who had to watch this. I bet they’ll never be the same.

[@danyellejones5871]

They say it's hard as working homicide. You can never unsee it.

[@Jusmeh]

most are used to the work, but it never gets easier. They also get training in how to not get too attached or involved. My Dad received some training at the FBI Academy. Well he spent 6 months up in Quantico learning even more. He was in the 111th Graduating class of the F. B. I..

[@Anna-lv2ow]

I have a lot of respect for the investigators that do that stuff. I would be a mess if I had to watch that.

[@margaretmacgillicuddy4944]

While the investigators are excellent at their jobs, it will eventually get to them. Especially if they have children. PTSD is real and catches up to everyone employed in C. Exploitation.

[@Jusmeh]

@@margaretmacgillicuddy4944 it never got to my Dad. I don't know how, maybe he didn't live long enough. He passed away 54.

[@GrandmatoRVSGCM]

This has made me just sick to my stomach. I can’t believe there are people out there that are so sick in the head. God help us!🙏🏼

[@beverlyghany7065]

People in prison hate people like Josh. He will get what's coming to him when he goes to prison.

[@snowwhite2709]

With the amount of connecting they could do between his phone and computer, I don't think there's anyway he can say it wasn't him. Hopefully Anna can understand the details when it comes out. He should not be near his kids, he is a disgusting man.

[@catherinefisher8534]

Imagine back to how you felt on September 11, 2001 - it was a shock and took months (years for some people) to start to try to comprehend what was done to our country. Anna is in this shocking situation, pregnant, and all she knows is if she divorces Josh, she'll be turning her back on God- that will NEVER HAPPEN.

[@thekowboymom2710]

I don't think Anna will ever believe it. She will have an excuse for what really happened because she does not want to believe it.

[@goomee5563]

@@catherinefisher8534 well said.

[@incaseofrapture6989]

@@catherinefisher8534 it didn’t take me that long to comprehend what had happened on 9/11. Sadly it ripped me apart but showed me what it was like to experience terrorism first hand. Let’s not compare Anna’s experience to 9/11. She knew who her husband was before he married her. Knew he molested 4 of his sisters, one of them as young as *5*, and family friend. She continued to ignore the red flags during their marriage when he admitted to cheating on her and being a member of Ashley Madison. Again, she chooses to hide her head in the sand after the CP investigation began. That’s where the sympathy ends. Yes she was raised in a cult, but that’s not an excuse, she still has a brain and common sense… you would think. If it looks like a duck, and walks like a duck… come on. She continued to stay with him and pop out his babies. I stopped feeling bad for her when she continued to support him during this investigation. A part of me thinks she knew Josh might be going away for a long time and did not want to burn the Duggar bridge because she lives in JB’s warehouse and he will no doubt need to support her and her 7 kids financially.

[@kimc555]

He couldn’t have incriminated himself worse, if he tried.

[@kimc555]

@@kathrynwitte3398 well that, yes. He was also incredibly arrogant. He never once thought law enforcement would catch; just that his wife may.

[@georgewilliams8136]

Hello Kimc555 how are you doing today?

[@georgewilliams8136]

@@kathrynwitte3398 Hello Kathryn how are you doing today?

[@bevolson7619]

Q

[@valeriemoran842]

In regard to parental rights and the "lack of evidence" which allows him to see his kids : There will continue to be a " lack of evidence" as long as the court tolerates the Duggars non cooperation with having the children evaluated by CPS. I am increasingly worried as his behavior appears to be compulsive and with all of the restrictions, his own kids are all he has access to. TERRIFYING.

[@karencaddle7288]

Agree Valerie. Also on his peer to peer sharing, I pray to god he is not sharing videos of his children in sexual situations!

[@cgomez113]

And now, a few months in and there is potential for coaching.

[@karencaddle7288]

@@cgomez113 fortunately a professional looks for that and can usually spot it.

[@lristau117]

Thank you for having a long episode tonight. I am in hospital tonight and I need the distraction. It also gives me a little normalcy as I watch you after work during the week. Thank you.

[@ilanamillion8942]

Get well soon!

[@bearmarshmallowinc.1979]

Feel better sister ❤️

[@KaylaCorrine17]

I’m in the hospital too tonight!! Hope you’re doing well! Reach out if you want to talk ☺️

[@Lena-vl4iv]

@@KaylaCorrine17 I hope you get well soon ❤

[@michellegeorges8560]

Aw no! Hope it isn’t major and that you are good as new soon!

[@joycemitchell2092]

I like the court document chats. Helps to actually get the truth! Thank you!!

[@WithoutACrystalBall]

Of course!

[@gigi1603]

I’ve known the Duggar’s since 1987, when they lived next door to First Baptist Church of Springdale (now Cross Church where Jill and Derrick attend). Josh is my son’s age..he always was different than the other kids…

[@WithoutACrystalBall]

Feel free to reach out to me in DM if you care to share any details - email or on Instagram

[@noobie7719]

I’ll say!!

[@mariacortez9954]

In what way ; well he been a quiet personal way. ! Maybe he’s a little different I don’t think different just u may had seen he was More quiet 🤫?

[@ck121395]

There’s been lots of time for his kids to be coached not to tell the truth

[@vanessaverner8480]

I can’t find the video online now. He was at Michelle’s Dad’s birthday. Her family was looking at him with disgust. I thought it was because of the way he was talking about his grandfather. It was so impersonal sounding.

[@touchofclass3836]

Since when do the parents get to say to CPS if their children get questioned or not???? SERIOUSLY??????

[@lestranged]

especially when the parent is the suspect. wouldn't every guilty perp just say no to questioning? and that gets them off?

[@pinkiesue849]

Arkansas must have some strange laws.

[@margaretkinnaman8585]

I'm wondering about that as well, but then Jim Bob has very deep pockets and don't forget he was a state representative in the state house so he has favors he can call in. And I think he has done all he can to protect his brand so to speak.

[@debshaw680]

If you refuse, they can get a warrant. If they can’t get a warrant, they can’t question them. The court will appoint them a guardian ad litem who will argue for them in court of CPS persists. Been through this myself- tho in my case it was false malicious reporting. My neighbor who knew us well was a cop and advised me. Luckily, when CPS tried to bring the cops in, he was the one that came with. I let him in but wouldn’t let her. He’s the one who told me the law. She never came back because they couldn’t get a warrant based on anonymous calls- which we later found out were my friend’s CPS worker, for four of her kids adopted out of the foster system, whose bad actions against my friend got her fired and fined. She had to pay all of my legal fees. She lost her certifications when they discovered it was her harassing me. A children’s court judge got fired in all of this as well.

[@r.peebles3290]

@@pinkiesue849 Wrong!

[@jaymmxii7332]

How could the judge release him after all this graphic evidence? And how can he still be allowed to see his children!? 😤

[@tinam761]

To me, it is irresponsible to NOT evaluate Josh’s kids and to also allow contact. The children’s safety should come first. What was on his computer even involved a child losing their life in the CSA … seems pretty serious… I hope as things progress his children are evaluated.

[@carolinehughes3819]

I feel so bad for the children but also the officer’s especially the ones that have children. I don’t know how they do it (I’m glad they do but wish that they didn’t have to). Thank you Katie for keeping us informed and glad your wee boy is okay.

[@katie5096]

I’m listening to the part where you’re talking about DD… omg. If he only got 20 years in prison, it would be a slap on the wrist. That’s HORRIBLE. If our hearts are not completely shattered for his victims, we have absolutely no soul. Anyone who wants to protect Josh deserves to go right in there with him. 💔💔💔

[@LizONLY]

Congrats on your cardiologist appointment! I have a friend whose son has had to have surgeries and appointments since he was born! That takes a strong mama!

[@yvonnechristmas2616]

Your so sweet.

[@debshaw680]

It’s fantastic news! My son, a young adult, just went through colon cancer and now there’s something going on with his liver. Even when they’re adults, it’s terrifying.

[@LizONLY]

@@debshaw680 I know this doesn't compare, but, my son has asthma. He has had pneumonia 3 times (he has scars on his lungs from it, which,makes him more susceptible to any lung illness,) the flu countless times..basically any childhood illness they can get, he's had. Its a terrifying thing when your child (no matter what age) is sick and you can't help them. Im so sorry to hear that about your son. Im sure mine secretly hates me right now because we've had to keep him in a bubble for going on two years now, but, im hoping one day he understands.

[@debshaw680]

@@LizONLY I’m sure he will, especially now. I can appreciate the situation you’re in. I have lung scarring from undiagnosed pneumonia that went on for months. The family doctor kept saying it was nothing. It was pneumonia and a SEVERE cat allergy- we had several cats. I sort of aged out of the majority of my asthma as long as I stay away from cats and don’t breathe cold air.

[@notinadequate2119]

Imagine what he’s tricked his wife into thinking is normal bedroom behaviour. I hope he rots in prison forever.

[@margaretmacgillicuddy4944]

You make an excellent point. I am sure Anna’s mother did not tell her what a healthy marital relationship consists of other than pleasing Josh no mater what.

[@nelsonmorrison-aldrich8924]

I bet he's fun..

[@AJ-qi4yn]

And I think it's obvious he did somthing to his kids. I. All of the photos of Anna Josh and the kids..the oldest daughter is never anywhere near him I think her body language speaks loud and clear

[@zebeart8808]

Imagine what Josh has convinced Anna what is normal to treat children. Horrible.

[@elizabethgrogan8553]

I want to thank you for exposing the depravity of Josh Duggar. I don't think anyone could have imagined how awful it is. He's the most dangerous creature and not to be allowed around children. There is no cure for him. Just the knowledge that his father probably now knows all he's done is impossible to accept.

[@truffles2721]

Jim Bob see nothing wrong with abusing females.

[@brendadole9638]

Love you Katie. Thanks for your great content!!!

[@Pumababyandfriends]

I am just heartbroken over the evil that these people have inflicted on innocent children. Unbelievable….my heart goes out to these children harmed! In addition I am just a loss of words, how can the judge allow him to see his children with Anna/anyone present, if he is literally accused of watching the m of children???? How?

[@erileigh969]

It’s INSANE! 🤯

[@robinsloppy8140]

Just because Josh is guilty.. Doesn't make him a bad father.. Why harm these young children more, by taking that away from them?

[@jennyclark2950]

If he will s a his sister's , Why would a judge allow him around his own children ? Are we sure he hasn't s a 'd his own children ?? I wouldn't risk taking a chance !

[@pacificnw5394]

What really concerns me is what he would do next when it takes more and more for him to get his fix. From the sounds of this transcript, he is a very dangerous person and who knows what else he is capable of. It also sounds like the govt has a strong case. The fact that Josh and Jim Bob think he's going to beat the rap is quite arrogant. I will be praying for Anna and the kids to escape this.

[@sherryhoward7298]

Maam you are all over the place...geesh stay focused we are herevfoe Dugger info not lip gloss 🤣

[@Yvone0707]

Thanks Katie for sharing this information with us. It definitely debunks Josh and JB's claims it's not Josh. Congratulations on your son's good health report. Having watched the entire video, wow, the evidence is really damaging. Fear for the victims of this smut. Also fear for Josh's kids particularly if Anna doesn't wake up.

[@debbiescott6836]

The problem with Anna is, she was raised in this cult, her folks are deep in this crap! Back when this first came out about Josh, her family told her they would disown her! They have never supported her! There is no way she will leave Josh! And that’s so sad, they are so indoctrinated, there is no hope for them!! When you are in a cult who teaches when you go against, your parents, you might as well join a coven!! It’s OUTRAGEOUS!!

[@trenarichardson690]

In my opinion he should not ever get out of prison

[@byBeauxARTFULIVING]

EXACTLY, there is no cure for fidos

[@candeedeane2922]

I agree

[@pinkmissmuffett]

What a creep. If SA gets him off imagine what his poor wife suffers. I hope she blooms when he is sent to prison

[@valeriemoran842]

I have been concerned about that for quite some time. I have never forgotten the pictures of Anna shopping at a thrift store with the Duggar girls with a split lip and bruised face and eye.

[@riariaria]

@@valeriemoran842 Oh wow! That’s horrible! I missed that episode. What reasons did they give for her injuries?

[@riariaria]

I’ve also wondered what awful things she has to “joyfully” endure. 😭

[@maryanndasilva6415]

@@valeriemoran842 I hadn’t heard this before!!!

[@margaretkinnaman8585]

@@valeriemoran842 well the woman Danica that he hired says he is violent and physically abusive so I'm not surprised at all.

[@ladyv5655]

Thank you for the insight to this case. I hope JD spends the rest of his miserable life in prison. The details both sickened and enraged me. When he goes to prison, they had better put him in protective custody because he isn't going to have many friends there.

[@hoosiermom47]

Good God, what does anyone get out of watching a child get murdered!?? Josh Duggar is one seriously SICK individual, along with anyone else watching that content 😱😱

[@erileigh969]

It’s absolutely disgusting.

[@kataeva2220]

Omg I can’t . So evil sickening!!!!! Devils

[@kataeva2220]

T he poor babies and children

[@SHEISTHEKILLERQUEEN]

He’s a monster!

[@karenpennington5073]

Thank the Lord for your son’s health.

[@julieklie2344]

I can’t imagine how happy you are, after all you have been thru with your sweet baby, you needed and deserved good news! Congrats!

[@diannegustowski6998]

You do a fantastic job at getting and explaining this information. Please, keep doing the deep dives.

[@WithoutACrystalBall]

Ok!!!

[@georgewilliams8136]

Hello Dianne Gustowski how are you doing today?

[@ginnyg2003]

Glad to hear about your son! That's wonderful.

[@MsJMan84]

This man is so messed up in the head. He needs to be locked up.

[@kimc555]

Court minutes are also impartial. He person taking them does this, day in and day out. I saw the notification for this video today at work and finally getting to watch it.

[@emmajayne4894]

The Philippines DOES have the death penalty. Not just for murder but, espionage, drug trafficking, attempted murder and treason

[@jimfincher1324]

I was driving thru Springdale right after the Duggars were moving into their new house. I stopped at a service station for diesel and ask the cashier about them. Let me tell ya...the disgust on her face I'll never forget. I always wondered why....I definitely understand now!

[@barbarahedges1791]

Happy for you and your son that he is doing well. Praying for him to continue doing very well. I can't imagine the pain of going through that.

[@jenniebowman2885]

Katie, I totally know how you feel when it comes to cardiology. My newly two yea old has had open heart surgery as well. Awe, we can be heart moms together. Those appointments are rough each time. I’m glad your boy is doing so well. Much love from Utah.

[@WithoutACrystalBall]

💖💖I see you, mama

[@gracie910]

My son had a ablation for S V. T. 7 yrs later everything’s great

[@kikican158]

I'm a congenital heart patient, sending you mommas much love ❤️

[@rebeccam1713]

I see a cardiologist now due to high blood pressure linked to epilepsy (linked to an unexpected brain hemorrhage I had in 6th grade). By now after many years I seem to know doctors offices and medical centers like the back of my hand!

[@katiestmarie1306]

Heart mama here too! I know this comment is super late after posting. My heart dropped when she said open heart surgery. My little girl was born with hypoplastic left heart syndrome and passed away after her second OHS. So glad your little boy is doing well. Once a heart mama always one ❤

[@alisonwonderland5610]

Josh took pics of his office and let many people know he was there so he could convince Anna that he had to stay at work. But that's what is convicting him; his own desire to hide his behavior from Anna which led him to place himself at the computer during the downloads.

[@cher3093]

I like the longer streams, I love your deep dives especially into court evidence!

[@glorycloudwatch]

Wow, Katie. This was excellent. In the name of Jesus..lol....ANNA please, please listen to this. She really needs to hear this!

[@notyourmamaslunchbox]

Love these long streams. Love your channel KJ.

[@kaismith3545]

Great job on reporting on this Katie. I only watch your videos on this because it's clear you put alot of effort and time. Great information delivered in a entertaining way 👏

[@PrincesslilBB]

I like the deeper dives. But WOW, I don't think Jail time is enough really!!

[@debbietrego1540]

I've said for a long time that Jim Bob has his own SA and that is why he is covering for Josh not only financially. The apple doesn't fall far from the tree. Especially first born!

[@bigmanabram8356]

Jim has secrets he is to weird

[@graememceachren1118]

Makes my Spidysense tingle!

[@reginawalther6178]

I can’t understand how anyone would like to follow that cult. Just put Josh in jail and leave him there.

[@georgewilliams8136]

Hello Regina Walther how are you doing today?

[@lindapittsonberger1874]

I have a love/hate relationship with the D’s but I just love all your tea.

[@wanda4573]

Glad for all your good news regarding the heart.

[@kimreed2489]

AWESOME reporting, Katie, as always!! I learned about your channel a couple weeks ago and am so impressed. Keep up the great work!! :)

[@JulieR73]

If only Judge Judy could preside over his case!

[@kristybolsover2652]

That would be epic

[@JulieR73]

@@kristybolsover2652 It would be! Hahaha! No doubt he’d see a lot of time in prison if it were up to her!

[@blessings3730]

I would love that. She would RIP him apart 🤣🤣

[@JulieR73]

@@blessings3730 yeah she would! What I’d give to see her do it!

[@ronadoyle3158]

Katie thank you as always for all the research you do!!!

[@anne-julieregnier4677]

And poor Anna, I believe that she'll understand the situation as herself not being "joyfully available" enough...

[@pacificnw5394]

I can't even imagine how many compromises he's probably pushed her into in their marital life. When I think about the level of manipulation that she's been exposed to it makes me angry. She deserves better and I hope she realizes this someday.

[@tracietoliver9592]

I’m afraid she will blame herself because their cult always says it’s the woman’s fault. Sad

[@piss-n-vinegar8457]

This was an AMAZING live! I’m a huge fan of longer lives, please keep em coming. I’m going to rewatch this JD live with my hubby later on tonight. Thanks Katie, well done !!! 👍🖐🏻👏🏻

[@LemonEyeDrops]

I really needed my woacb fix today thank you Katie!

[@carriecerino8243]

So happy that your son' s cardiologist appointment went so well! Loved today's vlod very informative !

[@cindybednar6997]

Thank-you for doing all this work.

[@wandamorris780]

Love the longer streams. I learned more from this video, thank you.

[@shurrieweatherman468]

That’s probably why he was sending emails and doing reviews while watching the bad stuff. So the covenant eye would see he is doing something at work and Anna would see he was actually at work and not get suspicious.

[@cjnoneya1020]

This and the comment about the photo to prove to anna he's in the office is seriously good

[@taliacatena4229]

Ya and he thought that evidence would absolve him but it incriminates him. How well versed can he be in the thorough workings of computers, he probably had no idea they could pinpoint it so accurately. Burn buddy

[@lestranged]

Exactly, if there was too long a gap with no activity on Covenant Eyes she might get suspicious, (like when your kids get too quiet) so he was doing some minimal trivial things on the 'clean' side of the partition at the same time. He was creating an alibi for himself which ironically will help to convict him! It places him at computer at the specific time.

[@margaretkinnaman8585]

Great points by all of you.

[@RunAMuckGirl2]

Thank you Katie. I DO love the deeper dives. Keeping it to under an hour is just right. If it's too long I just don't even start listening. lol I am interested in the Duggar stuff and the Sister Wives. I've become interested in the Britney Spears issue through your videos. Anything else you cover, I just haven't connected to yet. Meaning I don't have enough background in the story to know what you are talking about. If you've got a story line you enjoy covering and people just aren't watching it, it might help to do a recap for new watchers from time to time. So in the title something like, "New Member Recap and Update!" would get me to watch. ✨ 💖✨

[@bethfromchicago8719]

A fifteen minute recap with basic details would be great for people who don't have an hour to watch this video.

[@pfcheather]

I like the longer streams. It's great to listen to while I'm working

[@LucyPlop]

Same! It's like a relevant podcast. 😊

[@faegrrrl]

I cannot, can NOT believe this horrible criminal behavior is on the internet!! AND I can't believe that there are people who find these sick things attractive or intimate. I don't know how to put it. It's THAT evil!!

[@dawnmurphy7488]

He's sick. Lock him up and throw away the key.

[@The_One_and_Only996]

Love the deeper dives!

[@adriennetochter6873]

I wonder if part of why he wasn’t kept from his kids us that there isn’t evidence found involving them wIth THIS case so far. While it seems plain to me that they are at risk from him, given that he already crossed the sibling taboo - he was not convicted of anything regarding his sisters. So that can’t be held against him in this case.

[@janetdunham8301]

this is one of your best lives, since I've been watching... Love this content. Continue the great work Katie

[@WithoutACrystalBall]

Thank you!

[@georgewilliams8136]

Hello Janet Dunham how are you doing today?

[@fulltimerver2355]

The Duggars and cult issues and your outfits and sharing about parenting challenges and your commentary on how you and others are treated and what you have learned about how to deal with it. Those are the subjects that bring me back. I am so impressed with your strength, courage, intelligence, and character.

[@suetupper9162]

Yes...love the deeper dives Katie

[@suemelone4641]

That’s the part that makes me want to scream… he should lose parental rights. The kids are victims

[@colleenthecatlady2344]

💕💕💕 Glad you have good news!!! GOD bless y'all 💕💕💕

[@Will0wFire]

I don't understand how Josh was let out to live with that third party family - and even less do I understand their motivation to harbour such a disgusting man in their home! Are they nuts!?

[@jessicaellen9398]

I'd like to know how he's finding out about this content. Surely there would be a paper trail or forums or text messages from other people who know about these

[@twwdc]

His arrest is part of a wider investigation on CA videos so I imagine some other people are facing court as well.

[@skyewilson5650]

Well a lot of people already know of the dark web and what it has on it, or an idea at least, but as far as downloading the browser and logging in and file sharing I don’t know. But I agree there’s got to be somewhere he’s found this first and how

[@margaretmacgillicuddy4944]

Those that get their jollies from cp find ways to get it and share it. Thankfully most state and federal law enforcement agencies are very proactive in investigating this crime. Further major investigations are shared around the world to find the worthless human beings making the content.

[@annettetuck9272]

You really should get a law degree! You are great at court case information and all the details.

[@pinkiesue849]

I was thinking she could be in child protection, Katie has a heart for it.

[@margaretkinnaman8585]

She would make a great child advocate in court.

[@tamaradrew3356]

I keep forgetting that this was a sting operation!

[@rebeccalunsford9372]

I don't think it would have matter if he didn't hid from Anna. She wouldn't have believed it so sad.

[@julieklie2344]

Thanks MODs ! Katie, the hardest working blogger ever. You are the best, and only one I trust on this subject! I’m sorta close enough to try to get in the courtroom when/if it goes to trial . I may need a motor home to camp out at the courthouse!

[@christinaking6530]

Glad to hear your son is healthy keep up the good work on your son bless your heart

[@markbarret6836]

Continued good health. We all listen in when we are cooking.

[@debshaw680]

Hahaha I absolutely do!

[@mjalonen7366]

Great work and thanks again

[@barbarahedges1791]

You're right when you say Josh is not an honest man. These types of people are dangerous in my opinion. What if he did something to a child and the child kept saying I'm going to tell my Momma. It is possible this type of person would actually kill to keep anyone quiet. How evil to get pleasure seeing anyone get hurt especially children. Sickening

[@bonniewashington541]

I think your reasoning is why the victims started getting younger in the cpsa videos Josh had.

[@kristenfarr1700]

I had no idea it was this dark. I’m left sick to my stomach. I’m just in shock that even existed. He’s a monster not a creep.

[@ladydirtold2371]

Question: how did josh find this particular content? Not something you just stumble onto. Were there searches? I wonder...

[@lauralawrence4435]

He used the stuff and when done, went back to what he was doing. Compulsive "behavior" going on.

[@riariaria]

Also cold, calculating, deceitful, callous and sadistic behavior.

[@margaretkinnaman8585]

It's a proven fact that this kind of perverted behavior escalates over time. The most dangerous type of pervert is the kind that does multiple deviant behaviors. Josh's abuse of his sisters, his use of Ashley Madison, his visiting strip clubs and the use of prostitutes, and finally his using CSAI all point to a unrepentant deviant psychopath.

[@jodytempleton-jackson1377]

Thank you

[@darlenecorcoran2892]

oh yay! happy to hear your son got good results!! imagine josh going home that evening after downloading that depravity, and (barf) he's got daughters the same age?!?! (omfg)

[@brendameek3272]

And if convicted they say 20 years for one of the things? That SOB should get life in my eyes! Boy, does he EVER have some screws loose!

[@ameliafroehlich2577]

The sound you heard is my head exploding.

[@ChrisSmith-hp6rq]

Please. Deep dive into this case!

[@mgga1]

Holy wow…. I had no idea it was that horrific… you were not lying when you said worst of the worst… my brain didn’t even go that deep. Wow…. Well I didn’t want to know that much but I think I needed to. I think more need to know the worst of the worst…. You layed it out so I got the picture clearly now … His family needs to hear this

[@alaineedington9733]

I like the deeper dives, you cover so much info.

[@4125850]

Yes please to the deeper dives!

[@meganb735]

I’d love to see more coverage on welcome to plathville and escaping polygamy!

[@anne-julieregnier4677]

It's fascinating how a man who grew up "so far" from the real world being such a pro with the dark web. I just don't get it!

[@leandradozier968]

Well when you’re so repressed sexually, these things aren’t unusual. Why do you think pervs thrive in extreme religion practices?

[@sherrita80548]

@@leandradozier968 right he had a lot of time on his hands my nephew is 10 and he was able to bypass parental control and he ordered a crap ton of ebooks on Amazon and he was 6 then lol

[@sherrita80548]

I also think some other boy in the group probably told him how to do it

[@lestranged]

He's not that much of a pro, he left a big enough trail to get caught!

[@norajake3790]

@@leandradozier968 so true. So many factors here: blind respect for authority. Confusing faith and spirituality with justifying abuse/trauma. Repressing, controlling and warping sex while intensely focusing on reproduction. There’s denial of being an adult, having adult instincts, feelings, complexities, understanding mature topics; leads to denial of responsibility among other serious problems. Sheltering your child from a world they will inevitably need to learn how to navigate isn’t nice. Their rules look childish and ineffective for anyone vaguely familiar with the internet, they’re insulting their children’s intelligence, Josh knew that at least. What can you expect from a God that says not to eat from the Tree of Knowledge

[@RealPumpkinJay]

I’ve had a Linux partition before in the early 2000s. Well technically I had a Windows partition. I was running Linux most of the time and needed an old Windows operating system to play a PC game I adored. So what basically happens is that there are two different operating systems on the computer that operate completely independently from each other and they do not have any connection. When starting up, it is necessary to choose which side to boot.

[@kristiwoods4456]

I would speculate that he is taking pictures of the content that was being displayed on his computer. Sickening evil.

[@joyeb8413]

Love it! Your amazing, Thank you

[@lauralawrence4435]

He probably took the photos of his desk etc to prove his location to Anna.

[@cjnoneya1020]

This and the other comment about the psychology may be occurring really hit the target for me

[@valeriemoran842]

My thoughts as well

[@georgewilliams8136]

Hello Laura Lawrence how are you doing today?

[@dawnmerlino5491]

Katie thank you for breaking this all down as you did. It really explains exactly how they know it was Josh and not someone else. Smart as Josh believes he is he actually proved all he was doing at exactly the time he was doing it! Surely Anna has heard all of this while in court at least the fact that he covered up being at work while watching this horror. That alone should be enough for her to understand her husband is far from who she believes he is. She really must get herself and her children away from all this. It's all so awful. To know JOSH'S PARENTS know all this and still are remotely supportive of him...it's all so out of my ability to understand. Josh must go to prison for the maximum to protect everyone. He has definitely escalated his perversion through the years. Its scary to think what he may yet be capable of.

[@tammystpierre5921]

Hi Katie, I also enjoy when you do investigation work on other topics outside of reality tv. Whatever you do you are extremely through.

[@cjnoneya1020]

Yes!!!!

[@merallebach6079]

I love the Duggar lives! Please do more! Great video!

[@juliannesmommy6694]

I appreciate you sharing some of the info on the videos. I did NOT want to hear it. And it’s got me in tears. But; it gives a lot more dimension to the case. I had no idea stuff like that existed. And every person involved should suffer immensely (especially those paying for it)

[@JoyTb12345]

Yay, a LIVE!!