Refusing Further Payment | The People's Court

The defendant hired the plaintiff to renovate his body garage. The defendant failed to pay for his services, so the plaintiff is suing. The defendant argues he paid the plaintiff, but he just kept asking for more.
Subscribe to our channel:
/ @peoplescourttv
Case #28376
#PeoplesCourt #RealityTV #Court

[@444clockit]

The daughter was laughing , she wasn’t phased she’s definitely heard him talk like that before lol & he definitely wasn’t embarrassed

[@elliebellie7816]

Fazed. Not phased.

[@444clockit]

@@elliebellie7816 get a life. Who comes to KZbin comments to play English teacher 🤣bye

[@SnazzyJazzy-iw9wj]

​@@444clockitPeople with a basic middle school education. If you don't want to be called out for sounding like an idiot, then don't sound like an idiot. Pretty simple. I thought that everybody had that kind of basic common sense. It's hilarious to see people with spell check and a basic education attempt to shame others for correcting them 😂 Just don't sound like an idiot, and you won't have to worry about it

[@444clockit]

@@SnazzyJazzy-iw9wj basic middle school education? I’m currently attending college youre a waste of space😂 I have an associates in psychology & working on my Bachelor’s. This is KZbin, it was a simple mistake go play in traffic thanks

[@444clockit]

@@SnazzyJazzy-iw9wj who really comes on KZbin to correct someone? 😂 it’s summer time, it’s the weekend you & the other person CLEARLY don’t have lives. I see spelling mistakes all the time & don’t say a word 😂😂 because it’s not that serious

[@MrAlienmagnet]

Sometimes Harvey seems to have watched a different case. This wasn't about a loan.

[@Daysgobye52]

Why would you bring your daughter in the courtroom? She's not part of this case.

[@user-jb1tw3qi6d]

But if it doesnt bother him or her why are YOU bothered

[@Daysgobye52]

@@user-jb1tw3qi6d Go pound sand.

[@PeopleRTheProblem]

So she can tell her friends she was on tv

[@bongoikno4994]

But she's part of his life smh at 13 she needs to be adult life so she can be learning you can't wait till people are adults to start teaching them reality smh

[@bjohnson1149]

So she can be on TV in her ripped up jeans and laugh at his deplorable bahavior.

[@shanimorrison8730]

Why did the plaintiff even take his daughter???? He does realise he's not teaching her right omg

[@user-jb1tw3qi6d]

List the things wrong with it

[@judyelmer2257]

@shanimorrison8730.keepp your NOSE out of other people's business

[@trekgirl65]

To show her how he is a filthy mouthed fool. Hope she did not follow in his footsteps in the foul language department in the adult world.

[@carriegarcia4173]

It's not like it was over 100 or 200 dollars it was 1800!! I would be using bad language with a mad asf attitude too..

[@jennylynx1869]

This! I worked for an amazing man that owned a property maintenance company and he paid a living wage and charged amazing prices and offered discounts. He cut the women’s shelter grass for free, but so many ppl ripped him off he had to close his business. I don’t think ppl understand how often this happens to contractors and it’s very frustrating. Once the work is done ppl will find ANY reason not to pay

[@thankthelord4536]

Why is the child even in the courtroom?

[@user-jb1tw3qi6d]

Because there is NOTHING WRONG WITH IT!!! Stop being over dramatic

[@josephmartinez4077]

@@user-jb1tw3qi6d right! And if I could be her age and on the show I would have loved it!

[@ChristineDuval-cy5ck]

You could tell she was excited to be there.

[@user-ms1pg2ok4i]

The young woman is allowed to be there. Okay thankthelord?t Maybe she isn't in your eyes but why not?

[@thankthelord4536]

@@user-ms1pg2ok4i young woman? Wow! She's barely out of puberty.

[@dahuffy]

Also nice to see that they dressed for court. 🤔

[@jennylynx1869]

Settle down it ain’t real court it’s a damn tv show y’all need to chill acting like you’re watching court tv

[@jvillebil13]

Kids pick up on their parents actions. My two children never heard me say profanity until one day they were in their teens and don't remember what they did but pissed me off and I looked at them and said, "I'm about ready to whip somebody's @$$" They were shocked and you could hear a pin drop. LOL I apologized and to this day as married adults in their 30's they've never heard me use cuss words again but they remember that day.

[@JamieM470]

Cussing is like yelling. If you yell all the time, people around you get used to the yelling and tune you out, so when you have a real reason to yell, no one takes you seriously. I know a woman like that, and her kids are so used to it that it doesn't affect them at all. They don't listen. If you cuss all the time, same thing. I'm the same as you. I don't like foul language so I don't do it casually like everyone seems to these days. The other day I got really upset and used a cuss word, and people around me were so shocked lol. Everyone wanted to know what happened and if they could help.

[@MediaBuster]

Plaintiff Andrew Tull died on August 9, 2020. His daughter (seen here) Ashley wrote: "When I was a little girl I used to paint his toenails while he was sleeping on the couch. I'm sure he didn't like it but he would always laugh and smile. That's the kind of person my Dad was. He would help you out when you're going through a difficult time, and he would make you laugh so hard that you would end up crying. I don't remember a single time when my dad wasn't at one of my sports games. It's not fair that he is gone so soon. He had great things ahead of him. I love and miss you. Rest in peace Daddy"

[@Candy-cc1bc]

That’s sad to hear. Her words were sweet. He was a good father to her. Thanks for sharing!

[@inukoko2012]

Aww this is sad. Atleast she had a good relationship with/ her dad and seems like he left a good impact in her life. ❤

[@natasharobinson2008]

😢😢😢 RIP 🙏🏾

[@MrCharlesEldredge]

Awww. That's so sad. What a sweet thing she wrote about her dad. I'm so sorry she lost him. It does sound like he was a good dad.

[@XanderBeckett1]

Ewww she touched his toes

[@theresarogerssimpson1280]

Yeah, ya can't pay 5 times then say I didn't know I was being charged by the Hour! That won't fly under Judge Milian's radar. 😊

[@rmwhite9425]

Plaintiff bought the daughter to show he has a responsibility to provide for her & this guy is stiffing him on money he earned. One thing he showed her is don’t let someone cheat you! Stand up for yourself. $1800 bucks is a lot of money.

[@stevelozano9523]

Do people know they're in court and are suppose to dress appropriately? 🤦‍♂️

[@rckkeller9437]

I agree.

[@TLibra]

You act like they’re in criminal court. Dressing a certain way will not make a difference here 🙄

[@rckkeller9437]

@@TLibra it’s a matter of respect for the court and our judicial system.

[@thankthelord4536]

T.v entertainment court.

[@figabriel4120]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@christopherbako]

What's the point of a kid being there?

[@user-jb1tw3qi6d]

Whats wrong with it?

[@PeopleRTheProblem]

So she can tell her friends she was on tv

[@MagnolyiaGrace]

So she can hear the judge rip into the father at the end. If the apple doesn't fall far from the tree, it was something she needed to hear.

[@juliecranford534]

Also, here’s a thought. He didn’t have a ring on. Maybe he’s a single father who decided this was a chance to take his teenage daughter on a free trip to watch the wheels of justice in action with the coolest judge ever. Maybe they spent a bit of his settlement on some fun activities together. As far as his texts-he was absolutely in the wrong. No excuses. However-he wasn’t defensive and admitted repeatedly how wrong he was. He took the correction from the judge like a real man. Who knows what impact that may have had on her. She was not shocked by anything she heard-she’s grown up with him. But maybe now she’ll start to see how inappropriate it is instead of giggling at it. This is all conjecture, but I do find it strange that most people in the comments are way more upset over the plaintiffs’ jeans than the defendant’s theft.

[@oldageisdumb]

It was right he got his money but plaintiff has some major issues

[@sylviasanchez585]

I am shocked that this adult child brought his 13 year old who is smiling throughout the session to witness her dad's best moment. He is teaching his daughter how to be an angry adult. You should be so proud dad. NOT!!! SHAME ON YOU. the defendant buried himself by continuing to pay him instead of firing him.

[@user-jb1tw3qi6d]

Give me the list 1-10 of bad things about bringing her in court. NAME THEM

[@judyelmer2257]

@sylviasanchez585.why is it any of your business why he has his daughter in court.

[@b8nnytez]

A contract is a contract. Just make sure the one you take it out with isn't an immature {blank}

[@Quartzquiz333]

As Judge Judy would say, the defendant ate the steak.

[@ChristineDuval-cy5ck]

In plaintiff defense, think about it, you get hired to do a job, you don't get paid, bad words are going to fly out. It's not the first time, won't be the last.

[@perfectlyimperfect9129]

Bring it up at a funeral is wrong though

[@AbadScratchingHabit]

At a funeral? Yea okay …

[@oldageisdumb]

Sorry, being that petty and angry (calling wife ugly, going after someone at a funeral) is simply NEVER ok. If you justify it and make excuses for infantile, cruel behavior then you are saying it’s ok. Always behave in a way that you are proud of

[@IsomerMashups]

I wouldn't act like he did, but also... yeah. I don't really blame him. And it's not as if he said that in front of his daughter. He texted a bunch of nasty stuff directly to the other guy.

[@zyalynperez2333]

Yall get over it you owe me money and ignoring me I don't care if your mom died imma confront you. People don't work for free get over it.

[@Bebedollie]

Happy Saturday from New Zealand everyone. Have a blessed weekend 🙏 ❤

[@lbu9542]

Thank you, you, too!

[@Jimsalos]

Why does the guy interviewing the people keep calling it a loan?

[@barbarawallach1334]

Yes. Exactly what case was Harvey watching?

[@elskedijkstra1460]

His family and all who work with/for him should be ashamed. The hero is going to be the one to call it quits.

[@Ellie80681]

It wasn’t bad enough for them to cancel the filming…

[@user-ms1pg2ok4i]

Plaintiffs daughter in ripped jeans. Yup. Nope.

[@marskeins]

Defendant for sure owed. However I believe the plaintiff definitely got to harassing the defendant.

[@millissentflemmings2216]

It actually bugged me when JM was reading the nasty text messages and the daughter was smiling. 😮

[@WarGrowlmon18]

Like father like daughter 🤷‍♂️🤷‍♂️🤷‍♂️

[@millissentflemmings2216]

@@WarGrowlmon18 Yep, I agree! Children learn by observing their parents. Just made me a little sad.

[@Spankmepink]

Everyone in the courtroom was.

[@jennylynx1869]

Well the guy was a piece of shit, and his daughter ain’t 4

[@aerotaken5357]

The plaintiff is the reason you should never pay for handyman work hourly. Pay a flat rate for the job.

[@MrCharlesEldredge]

No. Hourly is better. If you don't like their work, they work too slowly, you don't invite them back.

[@elizabethgalligan1805]

I think the plaintiff and his daughter are disrespectful. Wearing ripped jeans to court is inappropriate! 😑

[@innocentBystander19]

Judge Judy has entered the chat.

[@blaq_betty]

Boo hoo 😭

[@chansophonlong]

I have seen the judge wear jeans under her rob,

[@wcm5636]

The father’s jeans are not ripped?

[@maryannegunter115]

Very inappropriate. Dad must be a Neanderthal, not to advise her to dress appropriately for court. Disgusting

[@jscott1363]

A verbal contact for this amount of work in 2024?! Then you will end up in court. A simple text about the work takes 10 seconds. And text costs during the work take seconds. Smh 😅

[@smileygates7315]

He's hot and hot headed!

[@Catloudan]

Plaintiff should be embarrassed . Allowing his daughter to wear ripped jeans to court and texting and speaking like that. Daughter clearly is amused and not surprised 🤦🏻‍♀️ great family.

[@TopherGrant]

Why? What does her outfit have to do with her integrity? Only poors buy expensive clothes to impress other poors. Some of us don't care to impress anyone else. Love yourself

[@dahuffy]

@@TopherGrant It's called respect for authority. And I know already you'll have a snarky comment, so don't bother. It's a generational thing.

[@TopherGrant]

@dahuffy generational thing? I'm Gen X. 47 years old from the deep south. I know ALL about manners and social graces. I choose to express myself through physical appearance as well that don't fit the status quo. I'll always say sir and ma'am. But I'm gonna dress how I like as long as it isn't indecent. I will take off my hat, though.

[@capri468]

You can tell his and his daughter are super close and that’s all that matters

[@annerose9219]

The plaintiff is a great example of a father.😢

[@stephaniehowe0973]

It is uncouth to mention it at the funeral but he was Ghosting 👻 him.

[@MrLeglamp]

Didn't the plaintiff's daughter have any going to court jeans?

[@LSweetie02]

Happy Friday PC family! 😎

[@keithkemp3008]

If you payed him he wouldn't be so mean and nasty !!!🤣🤣

[@MitchGrooms]

OMG, his "S"'s are killing my ears..

[@JeanneKropf]

Jeans? Someone needs to teach .

[@KingdomKeys53]

Why are so many people picking on the plaintiff and his daughter in the comments?

[@marleonetti7]

dont ever disrespect a funeral or else something really bad will come your way . this plaintiff died shortly after this case . i could tell u stories on this subject since i used to work for a funeral home and mortuary for seven years .

[@Mewse1203]

You know he talks to his daughter just like that too

[@penelopelgoss2520]

As a once-upon a time small business owner, self run, I learned I had to keep records of everything from the first interaction to the final closure of the project. I could NOT count on the client to keep their own records so i took on that responsibility as well. It's a tough lesson to learn as we all want to be treated with respect and dignity. But if the sub flubbs their work or the owner short changes you, take them to court and present ALL of your records INCLUDING p[hotos~!~~

[@frankgiuliano380]

the old man is a cheep NYC..you no what.

[@aprila6628]

I wont RIP until you pay me 😂😂😂

[@Summerdechristopher]

Guys clam down you can dress regularly in civil court it makes a good good impression to dress nice in court but criminal court is way different this is civil someone shouldn’t come in with short shorts and breast out but what there wearing there’s nothing wrong plus it’s a 13 years old girl of course she’s going to laugh the father probably doesn’t have the best judgment but don’t have to say how there dressing and the little girl laughing

[@Bebedollie]

Clam down?

[@elvickRULES]

Look, I don’t expect a lot but ripped jeans? Come on. 🙄

[@TiffanySoCute]

Clint Eastwood. Plaintiff 😂

[@kierradrayton3599]

Just saw the plaintiffs obituary…sigh. Was only 51 when he passed, in spite of all this I really don’t think he was a bad father. Seeing that he had anger issues I imagine he probably had some heart or blood pressure problems.

[@ninosimone]

Once upon a time people use to have respect for the courtroom by dressing appropriately .

[@barbarawallach1334]

What case was Harvey listening to. Asking people it someone has to pay back a loan? What loan? It was a payment for work completed....

[@intheredcold9216]

$4000 dollars... for THAT and then another $1800? Should have fired him.

[@jscott1363]

Painting an entire building inside and out plus ac work is cheap at $5800 in 2024 😮

[@stephaniehowe0973]

You agreed to the contract verbal or written. Firing doesn't allow you to rip them off.

[@tamekadavis6641]

❤

[@nancy1045]

Dad is an horrible role model.

[@bjohnson1149]

How nice to see plaintiffs dress up for court 😁😁😁 Sad to see that young girl laughing about that horrible language. I do think the defendant owes the money but there's no excuse for the plaintiff's nasty mouth.

[@robertbrehm3986]

Why was Harvey talking about a loan? None of the litigants mentioned anything about a loan.

[@wrightwilliams105]

Plaintiff was nasty. It was very inconsiderate to mention it at the funeral. But yes, he was owed the money.

[@AC081361]

I do not get offended by swearing, I do however get offended by people who cheat people out of $$

[@carrievictor5810]

What are they wearing, how disrespectful

[@crystalshaw8744]

Why didn't the Defendant just answer the question she asked?

[@elainevankat5353]

The judge thinks the daughter has virgin ears…. Yet she reads all the nasty texts out loud! (so stupid)

[@jennylynx1869]

The people’s court comment section is always so over dramatic…

[@maxinef6654]

The plaintiff has some issues. He comes across as a jerk!

[@mariannemcgee6262]

Harvey just doesn’t add value, asking same questions repeatedly !!

[@theresarogerssimpson1280]

I love Harvey!

[@beholdkingjrahhh9014]

Dad is hott

[@JoLong-feist2]

😶

[@christopherbako]

Ridiculous decision.

[@b0094700]

Sounds like Biden

[@larrybrown3951]

I guess he can't afford to buy that girl some decent looking clothes. She has no self respect to walk into a courtroom dressed like that.

[@TopherGrant]

Hahaha what? Not everyone puts stock into clothes that other people like. That's what poor people do. Some of us dress how we want and am not out to impress strangers.

[@SnazzyJazzy-iw9wj]

Exactly. Some people just don't care if they look like bums that don't take care of themselves

[@jpsailorallaboardmatey461]

How the hell did she think just cause he paid a few times, that he still owed if the guy was asking too much and didn't finish the work? She seems wrong on this one

[@adrianknight1406]

Seems to me that there was a huge miscommunication problem between these two litigants for the construction job in question throughout! The incident and confrontation at the funeral talked about here was very sad and unfortunate. The text messages read aloud were bad as well.

[@RiahMunnblock]

First

[@LSweetie02]

Lol

[@Quartzquiz333]

Happy Friday!

[@inthemouthofmadness5910]

I understand the plaintiffs frustration and anger but there is a big difference between handling things like an adult and a child. There is no excuse for cursing at someone via text! Be the better person!!